View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE

provided by ChesterRep

Reflecting on the characteristics and values of a military nurse:

20 200 200 byWar Alan Finnegan Zone (FRCN 14), qualitative Hugh McKenna (FRCN 3) and Kathresearch McCourt (FRCN 8)

n 2013, I (AF) was appointed as the first role models, such as Mary Seacole and UK Ministry of Defence Professor of , and attempting to , with an implicit responsibility conduct an empirical study to determine to lead and support military nurses in their relevance in a modern setting. This Iundertaking high impact research. Early into in situ was novel, and this assignment, I deployed into Afghanistan I was indebted to other civilian authors, to complete a series of qualitative nursing including RCN Fellows Hugh McKenna research studies. This included an exploration and Kath McCourt, who provided their into the characteristics and values that military academic expertise and support to ensure nurses defined as being pre-requisite to that the research was built on strong successfully undertaking their role in a harsh methodological foundations. and demanding environment. As such, this article is drawn from the only In part, I was motivated through a qualitative nursing studies conducted in a reflection on principles such as compassion, War Zone and published in resilience and clinical competency that are Today. I have been the assistant editor of the attributed to significant military nursing journal since 2016.

Citation Finnegan A, Finnegan S, Characteristics and values of a British military McKenna HP et al (2016) Characteristics and values nurse. International implications of War Zone of a British military nurse. International implications qualitative research of War Zone qualitative research. Nurse Education Today. 36, 86-95. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2015.07.030 Abstract 200 20 Background Between 1 and 14, British military nurses served in Afghanistan caring for Contact details both service personnel and local nationals of all ages.20 This paper is from the only qualitative alan.finnegan@chester. nursing research conducted in situ in Afghanistan, in 13. ac.uk Aim To explore the characteristics and values that are intrinsic to military nurses in First published undertaking their operational role. January 2016 Design A constructivist grounded theory was used. UK Ministry of Defence Research Ethical This version Committee approval was obtained. September 2020 Conduct of work Semi-structured interviews with 18 British armed forces nurses. Results A theoretical model was developed that identified the intrinsic characteristics and values required to be a military nurse. The nursing care that was delivered was perceived as outstanding. Recommendations Originality, and linked to sustainable development goals in good health and wellbeing and informing quality education.

Author details Alan Finnegan FRCN, director of Nursing and Military Mental Health, University of Chester, Chester, England; Hugh McKenna FRCN, professor of nursing, University of Ulster, Coleraine, Northern Ireland; Kath McCourt FRCN, dean of health, Community and Education Studies, University of Northumbria, Newcastle upon Tyne, England

nursingstandard.com © RCN Publishing Company Limited 2020 / 81 supplement / feature

o Open access quickly repatriated to their home countries. This is an open access TheIntroduction foundations and of modern background medicine and The local population’s progress, rehabilitation, article distributed under nursing are directly correlated in caring for community care and future treatments were the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution- armed forces personnel in times of conflict through a local healthcare facility outside of Non Commercial 4.0 and war (Gabriel and Metz 1992, Medicine the military’s scope of influence. International (CC BY-NC and The Military 2020). This extends to the By 2013, military medical and mental health 4.0) licence (see https:// formation of the (Royal) College of Nursing research were dominated by positivist theories creativecommons.org/ licenses/by-nc/4.0/), (RCN) in 1916 (Finnegan and Nolan 2012). and quantitative research, and no qualitative which permits others to It was during the Crimean war (1853-1856) nursing research had been undertaken in copy and redistribute in that field hospitals were first established. During the Afghan/Iraq war zones. In 2013, I (AF) any medium or format, remix, transform and this war death was common due to yellow fever, deployed to Afghanistan to collect data for four build on this work non- dysentery, cholera and tuberculosis (Gill and Gill studies. In addition to this study (Finnegan et al commercially, provided 2005). It was here, while attending wounded 2016a), data were collected on educational and appropriate credit is servicemen and delivering care in hostile clinical preparation (Finnegan et al 2016b), given and any changes made indicated territories and under dangerous conditions, the psychological implications (Finnegan et al that Florence Nightingale began to formulate 2016c), and the role of the mental health team her concepts about nursing (Nightingale 1859). (Finnegan et al 2014b, 2014c). Approval for These advancements resonant today with the study was granted by the UK Ministry of the spotlight on infection control, hospital Defence Research Ethical Committee. epidemiology, and hospice care. It was fitting Interviews were conducted with 18 military that the network of ‘field’ hospitals quickly set nurses based at Camp Bastion Hospital, up during the COVID-19 pandemic were given Afghanistan during June and July 2013. The the name Nightingale. intent was to accurately reflect the respondent’s In World War I, military nurses demonstrated interpretation of a wide range of emotions, extreme flexibility and resilience at clinical, behaviour, thoughts and beliefs. This led to physical, psychological and environmental an emerging theoretical model categorised as: levels, including caring for local nationals and personal values, military skills, scope of practice enemy troops (Gerolympos 1995). Nurses were and clinical leadership. These groupings were at risk (Harper and Brothers 1918, Hay 1953), responsive to the common dynamic healthcare and their patients were positively influenced factors faced by any nurse in relation to by the calm way the nurses went about their manpower, experience, motivation, satisfaction, duties, while the nurses were inspired by the and the type of casualty with associated ethical performance, fortitude and cheerfulness of issues. I had the support of civilian academics their patients (Hay 1953). Evidence can be who had military experience and they helped found in the diaries of nursing leaders such scrutinise the data to ascertain comparators as Maud McCarthy who, as in chief and differences. It is important to recognise that to the British Expedition Force, had sailed model was an emerging prototype, and needed on the first ship to France in 1914 and then testing and further research on its functionality maintained her position throughout the entire and to consider wider transferability. campaign until 1918. However, few research studies have assessed the effectiveness of the military nurses’ operational role, and a RespondentsInfluence and were impact volunteers who had made a comprehensive literature search identified no lifestyle choice to deploy in support of fighting published empirical study that explored the troops. The participants believed that the core characteristics and values required by nursing care delivered in the conflict area was military nurses in the operational arena. of a very high standard for all patients. They In this century, an International Security reported a sense of self-worth and pride aligned Assistance Force compromising of British, to strong team integration as being significant American and other allied troops was deployed positive factors in underpinning the excellent to Afghanistan (2001-2014) in support of a care. Prior experience of this environment NATO mission and to care for all patients, helped and made the nurses less likely to be including local nationals of all ages and captured negatively psychologically affected by either the persons (CPers) (Simpson et al 2014). The major clinical presentation of casualties, high activity hub for medical activity was Camp Bastion levels or the austere environment (Finnegan et al Hospital, which contained multi-national 2016c). Senior staff identified the importance British, American and Danish clinical staff of advocacy, being tenacious and backing their under British command. Coalition patients were judgement to deliver compassionate care. Role

82 / © RCN Publishing Company Limited 2020 nursingstandard.com modelling and getting to know their staff were Popular descriptions of nurses ‘battling’ the important in building a rapport to understand virus and ‘being on the front line’ are used to other peoples’ views and aspirations. As with describe healthcare delivery. other parts of the nursing workforce, it was The findings from our study identified important to be conscious of some of the that certain themes and categories could be multifactorial stressors, although it was also polarised, depending on the circumstances. noted in Afghanistan that many nurses thrived. Nurses focused on their scope of practice, Nurses talked of quality care, helping civilian colleagues were intrigued by the each other, communicating with each other, leadership skills, while patients and public reminding each other of what is expected, and focused on personal attributes. However, recognising the qualities that nurses brought the power of nursing as a profession is built to the multi-professional team. An emphasis on the amalgamation of these elements to was placed on patient needs, which were provide the unique characteristic and value determined through robust communication of the profession. The research provided built on a trusting relationship. These included military nurses with a framework for a lessons learned from caring for CPers, where realistic personal development plan to build the nurses consciously detached themselves on their strengths and identify limitations. from any legal processes and treated the Also, it supplied selection panels with an casualty as a vulnerable patient. Respondents additional tool to help the recruitment process reported that military nurses must have the and presented a prompt to focus on all the correct clinical competencies, with skill sets components of being a military nurse, and not aligned to working within one’s scope of just one area, for example, physical fitness. practice. A particular concern was caring for Given the increasing global migration children, with anxiety induced from both a lack of nurses, it was hoped this paper could of clinical experience (Finnegan et al 2016c) encourage similar occupational models. Due and previous negative experiences. Participants to the sample, the findings were UK-focused, found these situations extremely stressful. but these nurses were deployed with equal The impact of the study at the time was to numbers of colleagues from the United States inform pre-deployment training and advocate and evidence suggests that lessons learned from the role of practice educators in the operational War Zone nursing have international military environment. Due to the unique nature of this and civilian implications [Q1 is there a separate research, the study built on homebased military ref for this?]. However, as an emerging model, qualitative defence research (Finnegan et al readers were advised to treat the findings with 2014a) and I published the challenges, theory some caution. The American Academy of and methods used to inform future studies Nursing’s Military and Veteran Family’s expert (Finnegan 2014a, 2014b). panel are working with the RCN’s defence forum and nursing academics to further develop nursing research. In 2020, this will COVID-19Current and presented future nurses relevance with a multitude be showcased in international events [Q2 still of challenges, and one means of assessing correct?], with 14-16 of the conference papers what is required in the present is to look scheduled to be published in a high standard to the past. Defence nurses face challenges peer review journal in April 2021. not generally encountered at an equivalent As the only international armed forces level within civilian practice, and this study nursing-led qualitative research study demonstrated the essence of compassion undertaken during the Afghanistan and and empathy associated with an altruistic Iraq conflicts, this article was an important motivation to relieve suffering in the harshest historical resource. Significant medical of condition. The attributes historically aligned advancements have been achieved by to great military nurses of previous generations translating clinical lessons learned on the were empirically demonstrated as intact in battlefield into civilian healthcare. The serious the current workforce, which is particularly poly-trauma injuries of the Afghan conflict poignant in the International Year of the Nurse featured orthopaedic problems, including and Midwife. amputations and associated injuries such as The characteristics identified in our study burns (Jansen et al 2012) and traumatic brain have been demonstrated in nurses during injuries (Taylor et al 2012, Trauma Brain the COVID-19 pandemic, and there is clear Foundation 2016). Yet the exemplary Bastion synergy with global workforce demands. Hospital healthcare provision (Care Quality nursingstandard.com © RCN Publishing Company Limited 2020 / 83 supplement / feature

Commission 2012, Stockinger 2012) played a civilian nursing on a truly international scale. part in saving lives where previously patients The study demonstrates that despite the ethical would have died (Hodgetts 2012). These and geographical challenges, that quality experiences informed the development of the information can be collected in the harshest National Institute for Health Research/Ministry of terrains. The originality of the study is of Defence-funded Surgical Reconstruction embedded in the United Nations’ sustainable and Microbiology Research Centre (2015) and development goals of producing evidence to the Scar Free Foundation (2020). In mental inform good health and well-being and shaping health, clinical and nursing initiatives such quality education. as assertive outreach, community-based care, By collecting empirical data to inform crisis intervention (Artiss 1997) and group educational programmes, clinical practice and psychotherapy (Harrison and Clarke 1992 [Q3 policy, nursing researchers can help prepare the The reference Harrison and Clarke 1992 is not future generation of nurses. Placing nurses first, provided in the reference list. Please check.]) with a model that focuses on the requirements have their origins in the world wars. The of a good nurse, has the potential to lead to lessons learned from the battlefield, can have better patient care, and improve the quality of significant positive influences on military and their workforce experiences.

References

American Nurses Association (2015) Code of Ethics for Nurses Finnegan AP, Finnegan S, Bates D et al (2016a) Preparing Larson J, Brady M, Engelmann L et al (2013) The with Interpretive Statements (View Only for Members and British military nurses to deliver nursing care on deployment. formation of professional identity in nursing. Non-Members). www.nursingworld.org/practice-policy/ An Afghanistan study. Nurse Education Today. 35, 1, 104-112. Nursing Education Perspectives. 34, 2, 138-138. nursing-excellence/ethics/code-of-ethics-for-nurses/coe- doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2014.07.008 doi: 10.5480/1536-5026-34.2.138 [Q7] view-only/ (Last accessed: 4 September 2020.) [Qs4-11 For the following 8 queries please provide citations in Finnegan AP, McKenna H, Lauder W (2016b) The challenges Martin R, Barresi J (2003) Introduction: personal the text or delete from the reference list as appropriate] and psychological impact of delivering nursing care identity and what matters in survival: an historical within a war zone. Nursing Outlook. 64, 450-458. overview. In Martin R, Barresi J (Eds) Personal Identity. Artiss KL (1997) Combat psychiatry: from history doi: 10.1016/j.outlook.2016.05.005 Blackwell, Oxford. [Q8] to theory. . 162, 9, 605–659. doi: 10.1093/milmed/162.9.605. Finnegan AP, Finnegan SE, McKenna et al (2016c) Medicine and The Military (2020) Military Medical Characteristics and values of a British military nurse. Advancements. https://www.medicineandthemilitary.com/ Trauma Brain Foundation (2016) Guidelines for the international implications of war zone qualitative officer-and-medical-training/military-medical-advancements Management of Severe Traumatic Brain Injury. www. research. Nurse Education Today. 36, 86–95 (Last accessed: 4 September 2020.) braintrauma.org/uploads/13/06/Guidelines_for_ doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2015.07.030 Management_of_Severe_TBI_4th_Edition.pdf Nightingale F (1859) : What It Is and What It (Last accessed: 4 September 2020.) Gabriel RA, Metz S (1992) A History of Military Medicine: Is Not. Dover, Downers Grove IL. From Renaissance Through Modern Times. vol 2. Care Quality Commission (2012) Defence Medical Services: Greenwood, Westport CT. Nursing Midwifery Council (2015) The Code: Professional A Review of Compliance with the Essential Standards of Standards of Practice and Behaviour for Nurses and Quality and Safety. Care Quality Commission, London. Gerolympos AK (1995) The Redesign of Thessaloniki after the Midwives. NMC, London. [Q9] Fire of 1917. University Studio Press, Thessaloniki. Finnegan AP (2014a) Fieldwork and practical implications Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia (2019) Code for conducting qualitative research in the defence Gill C, Gill G (2005) Nightingale in Scutari: her legacy of professional conduct for nurses in Australia. NMB medical services. Journal of the Royal Army Medical re-examined. Clinical Infection Disorders. 40, 12, 1799-1805. Australia, Melbourne. [Q10] doi: 10.1086/430380 Corps.160, 2, 141-145. doi: 10.1136/jramc-2013-00022 Royal College of Nursing (2003) Defining Nursing. RCN Finnegan AP (2014b) Conducting qualitative research in Harper and Brothers (1918) The War on Hospital Ships: Publication, London. [Q11] With Narratives of Eye-Witnesses and British and German the British Armed Forces: theoretical, analytical and ethical Scar Free Foundation (2020) Making a World Implications. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps. Diplomatic Correspondence. Second revised edition. Harper and Brothers, London. Without Scars a Reality. www.scarfree.org.uk 160, 2, 135-140. doi: 10.1136/jramc-2013-000223 (Last accessed: 4 September 2020.) Finnegan AP, Nolan P (2012) Influences of British army nurses Harrison M (2010) The Medical War: British Military Medicine in the First World War. Oxford University Press, Oxford. [Q5] Simpson R, Wilson D, Tuck J (2014) Medical management of on mental . British Journal of Mental Health captured persons. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps. Nursing, 1, 4, 214-219. doi: 10.12968/bjmh.2012.1.4.214 Hay I (1953) One hundred years of army nursing. Wyman and 160, 1, 4-8. doi: 10.1136/jramc-2013-000064 Sons, London. Finnegan AP, Finnegan S, Thomas M, et al (2014a) The Stockinger ZT (2012) The combat trauma care system. Navy presentation of depression in the British Army. Nurse Hodgetts T (2012) A Revolutionary Approach to Improving Medicine. 10, 4, 40-43. Education Today. 34, 1, 83-91. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2013.02.020 Combat Casualty Care. PhD Thesis. City of London University, London. Surgical Reconstruction and Microbiology Research Centre Finnegan AP, Finnegan SE, Thomas M (2014b) Factors (2015) Translating Research into Improving Trauma Care affecting the mental health support to British armed forces International Council of Nurses (2020) Definition of Through Military. NHS and Scientific Partnership. NHS personnel on deployment in Afghanistan. Part one. Journal Nursing. www.icn.ch/nursing-policy/nursing-definitions Choices, London. of . 28, 5, 30-32. (Last accessed: 4 September 2020.) [Q6] Taylor BC, Hagel EM, Carlson KF et al (2012) Prevalence Finnegan AP, Finnegan SE, Thomas M (2014c). Factors Jansen JO, Thomas GOR, Adams SA et al (2012) Early and costs of co-occurring traumatic brain injury with and affecting the mental health support to British armed forces management of proximal traumatic lower extremity without psychiatric disturbance and pain among Afghanistan personnel on deployment in Afghanistan. Part two. Journal of amputation and pelvic injury caused by improvised and Iraq War Veteran V.A. users. Medical Care. 50, 4, 342-6. Community Nursing. 28, 6, 53-58. explosive devices (IEDs). Injury. 43, 7, 976-979. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0b013e318245a558 doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2011.08.027

84 / © RCN Publishing Company Limited 2020 nursingstandard.com