Community, Conflict, and Queer Potential at the Lesbian Herstory Archives
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Syracuse University SURFACE Dissertations - ALL SURFACE December 2017 The Ageing of the Archives: Community, Conflict, and Queer Potential at the Lesbian Herstory Archives Rebekah Orr Syracuse University Follow this and additional works at: https://surface.syr.edu/etd Part of the Social and Behavioral Sciences Commons Recommended Citation Orr, Rebekah, "The Ageing of the Archives: Community, Conflict, and Queer otentialP at the Lesbian Herstory Archives" (2017). Dissertations - ALL. 803. https://surface.syr.edu/etd/803 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the SURFACE at SURFACE. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations - ALL by an authorized administrator of SURFACE. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ABSTRACT The Lesbian Herstory Archives is the oldest and largest lesbian archives in the world. This dissertation project examines the role of this community archive in building, defining, redefining, and sustaining community over time. More specifically, this dissertation seeks to explore the relationship between queer archives and community through the following research questions: 1. How does the act of archiving produce community? 2. How does a community archive and project of collective memory, rooted in a specific identity, respond to a radically shifting socio-political climate? 3. In what ways does the deployment of community produce boundaries of inclusion and exclusion? Drawing from interviews, participant observation, and archival research, this study explores how the changing Archives community mirrors the shifting socio-political climate of the United States. Special attention is paid to how the rhetoric of community is deployed by the Lesbian Herstory Archives in order to secure needed resources. Research findings suggest that the power of this rhetoric might be diminished over time as lesbian identity has become less salient and increasingly critiqued. Relatedly, this study reveals how, despite the best intentions of the organization’s founders, the rhetoric of community adopted by the Lesbian Herstory Archives has often relied on a falsely homogenizing understanding of community that is based on a universal lesbian identity construction, leading to exclusions based on race, class, and gender identity. Despite this fact, it is argued that this notion of community, while ambiguous and ripe for criticism, can be a powerful tool to mobilize individuals and groups. The Ageing of the Archives: Community, Conflict, and Queer Potential at the Lesbian Herstory Archives by Rebekah Orr B.S., SUNY College at Brockport, 2008 M.A., Syracuse University, 2010 Dissertation Submitted in partial FulFillment oF the requirements For the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology Syracuse University December 2017 © Copyright by Rebekah Orr 2017 All Rights Reserved Acknowledgements I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my advisor, Dr. Jackie Orr, a constant source of inspiration for me as we labored and loved this project into being. To my committee members, Dr. Robin Riley, Dr. Margaret Himley, Dr. Roger Hallas, and Dr. Gretchen Purser, your incredible intellect, insight, and support have been such a gift to me- thank you. To RR- thank you for making sure I saw this thing through to the end. There are no words… To my sister from across the world, Dr. Gohar Siddiqui, thank you for the countless read-throughs, and for your unconditional love and support. You mean the world to me. To my wife, Dr. Jenn Billinson, my ride or die, my one true pairing, you are magic. It’s been a pleasure growing up and becoming a Dr. with you. Finally, to my research participants- thank you for sharing your lives and your stories with me. Your generosity of time and your commitment to preserving the lesbian past is truly awe-inspiring. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS…………………………………………………………………………………………………...iv TABLE OF CONTENTS…………………………………………………………………………………………………….v Chapter One: Theoretical and Substantive Significance……………………………………………………1 Chapter Two: An Ethnography of the Archive………………………………………………………………...42 Chapter Three: The Ageing Archive……………………………………………………………………………….60 Chapter Four: Contested Communities…………………………………………………………………………..95 Chapter Five: At Home With the Archives?..............................................................................................142 Chapter Six: Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………………………174 BIBLIOGRAPHY……………………………………………………………………….……………………………….…183 VITA…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..186 v 1 CHAPTER ONE: AN INVITATION In the early morning hours of Monday, November 21, 2011, Linda “Sparky” Mortimer died alone in her bed. Without warning, this beautiful person, so full of life, was gone. Sparky, owner of a local restaurant and community space, Sparkytown, was the backbone of the Syracuse LGBTQ community. She gathered, fed, and united so many different people under one roof. She supported local queer artists and musicians, and she intentionally created a safe space for LGBTQ folks to just be. As long as Sparky was alive, you would always have a place to go, you would get a great big Sparky hug when you got there, and you would leave full of delicious, healthy, comfort food. I was cloistered away in my apartment writing my first comprehensive exam when I received the call that Sparky had passed away. My books and notes on queer archives, ghostly hauntings, and sociological traces surrounded me. I was writing about my own experiences of working with university and community members to create a local LGBTQ archives- a project that Sparky had inspired and supported wholeheartedly. I dropped everything in the midst of a timed written examination to attend a candlelight vigil in Sparky’s honor that night. The following is a short excerpt from my theory exam, written when I returned from the vigil: “I have often reflected upon what constitutes an archive, and I have argued passionately for the inclusion of the invisible, the inaudible, the forgotten, and the ephemeral. Less than 24 hours ago, this became deeply personal for me. My conviction shifted from something I knew, something I had intellectualized, to something that I felt to my core- a different kind of knowing….Throughout the day I wrote and cried, cried and wrote, and I felt. I felt Sparky. Her deep, loud laugh, her great big bear hugs and flirtatious pats on the ass. I felt her campy renditions of old womyn’s music. 2 Here come the lesbians! Here come the leaping lesbians! We’re going to please you, tease you Hypnotize you, try to squeeze you We’re going to get you if we can Here come the lesbians! I felt the warmth she radiated as she greeted each and every person that stepped into her restaurant. I felt her pleasure in feeding us all- body and soul. Sparky had shared hundreds of stories with me; I can tell you what year she came out, how many times she’s been to Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival, and the names of some of her favorite nuns who taught her how to peel potatoes as a child. But I never got around to “taking” Sparky’s oral history- I never properly interviewed her. Though she had shown me countless photographs documenting her amazing life and activism, I never collected them in an acid-free box and had her sign a release form. I can’t tell you exactly how many people gathered in front of Sparkytown on Monday night to honor her memory, but I can tell you what the glow of so many candles looks like. I can try to put into words what it felt like to be surrounded by so many others who loved her as much as I did. For those who would advocate for a traditional archive, Linda “Sparky” Mortimer is gone, without a trace. But for those who would advocate an expanded archive, an archive of feeling, an archive of hauntings, an archive of the ephemeral, the work of archiving a spark has only just begun.” The partially burned candle from that vigil, and the program from Sparky’s official memorial service sit on my bookshelf next to a cough drop Sparky gave my wife just days before her passing. These traces share shelf space with Avery Gordon’s Ghostly Matters, Ann Cvetkovich’s An Archive of Feeling, and Jacques Derrida’s Archive Fever. Together, they form the foundation for this dissertation project, and a sort of archive of their very own. In the early months of developing my dissertation research project, I was drawn to the queer archive as a site for knowledge production and dissemination. My emphasis was not on the communities producing and produced by the archives at this time. However, as I worked with Syracuse community members and university faculty to develop a local LGBTQ archives, I could see community itself playing a larger and more central role in the work we were doing. I was introduced, often by Sparky Mortimer, to older gays and 3 lesbians living in the Syracuse area, and I became fascinated by the dynamics of intergenerational exchange taking place. Over time, my interest was drawn away from the archival materials and process, and towards the social subtleties and undercurrents surrounding the project. This local scholarship and activism helped to shape my dissertation project as it exists today. Dissertation Overview This dissertation project seeks to honor lesbian elders and the incredible communities they have built from the ground up, while simultaneously imagining queer potentials for a younger generation that seeks to forge their own paths and claim their own identities. It examines the role