Appendix III - P Tai Po District Summaries of Written Representations

Item DCCAs No. of Representations EAC’s views no. concerned representations

1 P05 – 1 The representation The representation is not accepted proposes transferring because: Riviera Lodge from P17 to (i) the reasons given by the P17 – P05 because: proposer are not valid; Hong Lok (a) Riviera Lodge is in (ii) it will unnecessarily alter the Yuen close proximity to Fu boundaries concerned, which are Heng Estate in P05; unchanged under the EAC’s and proposal; and (b) the polling station of (iii) the location of the polling P17 at Tai Po Tau is station is not a consideration. quite far away from Nonetheless, the REO will bear Riviera Lodge. this in mind when identifying polling stations for P17.

2 P07 – 1 This representation The supporting view is noted. Fu Ming supports the naming of Sun P07 as Fu Ming Sun.

3 P10 – 3 All three representations The representations are accepted Tai Po object to transferring Kam because: Kau Shan from P13 to P10 and (i) the reasons given are considered propose to include it, valid; and P12 – together with Kam Shek (ii) the resultant population will San Fu New Village and Shek still be within the permissible Kwu Lung in P13, into limits: P13 – P12 instead; and transfer Lam Dynasty View, Grand P10: 14,236 (-17.20%) Tsuen Dynasty View and To P12: 14,948 (-13.06%) Valley Yuen Tung from P12 to P13: 15,890 (-7.58%) P10 because: (a) the group of Kam Shan, Kam Shek New Village and Shek Kwu Lung is more associated with Pan Chung in P12 in terms of their locations and community identity; and (b) the population deficit of P10 (12,235, -28.84%) will be Item DCCAs No. of Representations EAC’s views no. concerned representations

reduced by including the adjoining Dynasty View, Grand Dynasty View and To Yuen Tung in P10.

Tai Po District Oral Representations Received at the Public Forum on 24 January 2003

Item DCCAs No. of Representations EAC’s views no. concerned representations

4 P10 – 1 Same as item 3. See item 3. Tai Po Kau

P12 – San Fu

P13 – Lam Tsuen Valley