Newsletter Autumn Winter 2016
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NEWSLETTER AUTUMN 2016 CASEWORK BUILDINGS AT RISK PUBLICATIONS EVENTS SAVE EUROPE’S HERITAGE Photographs of the Futurist Cinema, Liverpool, when it fi rst opened in 1912, and during demolition August 2016. Photo credit Cinema Theatre Association (before) and Jane MacNeil (after). SUPPORT SAVE Subscriptions: Legacies: SAVE is extremely grateful for the support we receive We invite you to leave a gift in your will to SAVE. By from our Friends and Saviours. They provide us with news including a legacy, large or small, you can help to ensure of buildings at risk from across the country, and help us that SAVE continues to work to protect Britain’s with our trickiest cases. endangered heritage, and make sure that your legacy lives on in the very fabric of British architecture. If you would like to support SAVE, and join a lively group of like-minded people then please consider Don’t forget to include our charity number when writing becoming a Friend for as little as £3 a month, or a your will. (269129). Saviour for £250 a year. The benefi ts of becoming a Friend include: Fighting Fund: · A complimentary publication when joining · SAVE’s biannual newsletters SAVE is only able to fi ght campaigns against demolition · Access to the online Register of over 1,500 Buildings at and harmful development by building a specialist team Risk for each project with fi nancial, planning, architectural · Discounts on publications and events and heritage expertise. The direct costs of bringing such · Press releases and campaign updates teams together, and for campaigning for threatened buildings, are covered by the Fighting Fund. Saviours receive all the above with the addition of a hand The Fund allows us to lobby government, work with printed tea-towel, designed by the artist Kitty Rice, and architects to design practical alternative schemes, and an exclusive annual event with the SAVE team. take direct legal action if necessary. In order that we can keep campaigning successfully we ask you to Please visit www.savebritainsheritage.org/support-us support the Fund. for more information. Donating to the Fighting Fund is a fantastic way to If you are already a Friend, but would like to become a contribute to SAVE’s core work. Saviour, please email Emily Lunn (emily.lunn@ savebritainsheritage.org) or call the offi ce (020 7253 3500), If you wish to make a donation to the Fighting Fund, and we will amend your records. please visit: www.savebritainsheritage.org/support-us/ fi ghting-fund This newsletter has been generously supported by Selectaglaze By Appointment to Her Majesty The Queen Founded in 1966 and Granted the Royal Warrant in 2004, Manufacturer and Supplier of Secondary Glazing Selectaglaze Ltd. St Albans Selectaglaze is the leading designer, manufacturer and installer of secondary glazing in the UK. ,0 ,+1&+2"!1+!%+!"!1,ъсۖ00&+ ""5-+6%ȄѸ1%" ,*-"/0,#01Ȅ4&1%'201#,2/*"*,$+&1/1 "3,)3"&100" ,+!/6$)7&+$0601"*01,*""11%"3/6&+$+""!0,#301/+$",# )&"+10ѷ 3"/1%"6"/0Ѹ")" 1$)7"%04,/("!,++,1)"-/,'" 10#/,*1%" ,,3"/2&)!&+$1,&+!0,/01)"Ѹ 1%"2-/"*",2/11,1%"+(,#+$)+!ѷ6&+01))&+$&100601"*0Ѹ&1%0&!"!1%"2&)!&+$0&+" ,*&+$ 4/*"/Ѹ.2&"1"/+!0#"/ѷ /"!,*&++1)64,/(&+$&+&01"!2&)!&+$0Ѹ4%"/"1%"-/&*/64&+!,40 ++,1" %+$"!Ѹ")" 1$)7" 1("0$/"1-/&!"&+"&+$-/1,#1%"1"*,#"5-"/10Ѹ4%,/&+$1%"2&)!&+$ (1,)&#"+!02&1)"#,/ ут01 "+12/601+!/!0,#20"ѷ%"*,01/" "+1-/,'" 1,#1%&016-"Ѹ&01%"& ,+& &$%1%,20"2&)!&+$&+&+$0 /,00ѷ+ ")&+!"/")& 1Ѹ&1&0+,401+!&+$-/,2!+!/"!6#,/20"0*,!"/+!6,Ȅ& "0ѷ "#2))602--,/11%"4,/(,#&+0#"$2/!&+$1%"/& %/ %&1" 12/)1-"01/6,#,2/ &1&"0+!1,4+0 /,001%"ѷ ,/#2/1%"/&+#,/*1&,+-)"0" ,+1 1ѹ"+.2&/&"0ҿ0")" 1$)7"ѷ ,ѷ2(Ѻстшушщфшушт,/3&0&1 444ѷ0")" 1$)7"ѷ ,ѷ2( SAVE NEWSLETTER | AUTUMN 2016 2 Welcome to the SAVE autumn newsletter of 2016 It has been been a fantastically packed year so far – kicking We continue to be involved with detailed negotiations off with victory in the Welsh Streets and securing a over the acquisition and restoration plans for Wentworth permanent reprieve from demolition for some 400 Woodhouse in Yorkshire, and we are pleased to report terraced houses. We are now following with interest new that the damaging plans for the re-development of refurbishment and adaptation proposals by PlaceFirst, a Winchester town centre have been kicked into the long Manchester based developer who is drawing up a long grass following decisive action from the Council, and a overdue regeneration proposal for the area. As we go to local campaign strongly supported by SAVE. print, a pilot project is about to begin. Mike Fox has been in Georgia giving advice to We have also been busy with major legal and high profi le campaigners concerned about demolition and major new challenges over the Futurist Cinema and Lime Street in development in the capital Tbilisi, and back home in Liverpool, and a Victorian street and surrounding London we have hosted two book launches – the new buildings in Grimsby Docks – supported and advised by 2016–7 Buildings at Risk Catalogue Great Expectations, and our superb legal team. Both cases have garnered the lavishly illustrated Big Saves. Our fi rst Saviour event considerable public support, and helped focus national led by Dan Cruickshank in March was a great success, and and international attention on unnecessary and harmful we are planning next year’s over the coming weeks. Watch heritage destruction – see the casework section for more this space. details. We always want to hear from you about new cases, so All eyes are on the Museum of London as its re-location keep them coming in. We are also continuing to push our plans to Smithfi eld General Market gather pace, and we Friend and Saviour schemes, and telling more people will be watching closely as the newly appointed about what we do. Please help us spread the word! architects’ designs emerge. The east front of Wentworth Woodhouse, where negotiations over the acquisition of the house continue. Country Life 3 SAVE NEWSLETTER | AUTUMN 2016 CASEWORK LIME STREET, LIVERPOOL The developer’s proposal, with the existing buildings demolished The view down Lime Street towards St George’s Hall and the World Heritage Site We had been fi ercely opposing plans to demolish an entire row of historic buildings – including the 1912 façade of the After a year long fi ercely fought battle, the Court of Futurist Cinema. The buildings lie between two listed Appeal rejected our case against the demolition and Victorian pubs and together frame the view of the grand redevelopment of the former Futurist Cinema and over portico of one of Britain’s fi nest neo-classical buildings, ten historic buildings on Lime Street. Immediately after St George’s Hall, from the buff er zone of the World the judgment, demolition work began on the Futurist Heritage Site. façade. In the annals of architectural history, we regard In our view, the major demolition and large scale this demolition as an arch piece of civic vandalism. repetitive replacement façade, overlaid with a ghost image We would like to thank all our supporters for donating to of the lost Futurist is inappropriate and harmful. The bulk our funds. We could not have taken the action we did of the new 11-storey block immediately behind will be without your support. Your contributions of more than highly intrusive. £7,000 made a substantial diff erence to our overall costs We argued throughout that the façade of the Futurist and we are extremely grateful. could be saved and demolition was not necessary. In May, Despite the very recent decision by UNESCO to keep we paid for our own structural report to investigate the Liverpool on the global heritage ‘at risk list’, and the possibility of retaining the façade, carried out by leading threat that the city could lose its World Heritage status conservation engineer Edward Morton. It showed how due to harmful new development, the Court of Appeal the façade needed only a minimal amount of stabilisation rejected our appeal in a judgment issued on 2 August. to make it safe without requiring expensive road closures. The Council ignored this advice and shut Lime Street to traffi c for several weeks in June – claiming the façade was in danger of imminent of collapse. SAVE’s alternative proposal showing the Lime Street terrace, with the buildings restored and reused in between the two listed pubs SAVE NEWSLETTER | AUTUMN 2016 4 In the end, and after three High Court hearings to stop The demolition of Lime Street and the Futurist has been demolition, far from being in a poor structural condition, extensively covered in the local press, on BBC Radio an independent expert engineer’s report, jointly funded Merseyside, Bay TV, City Radio, the Liverpool Echo and by SAVE and the Council, found the façade of the former Liverpool Confi dential, and our campaign has been picked cinema to be structurally stable and the road was up in The Guardian, Private Eye and the architectural press reopened immediately. There is no reason why the façade – Building Design and Architects Journal and Planning of this grand building could not have been incorporated Magazine. into the new development. As part of our campaign, we also drew up an alternative vision for the site, with the help of conservation architect Eva Palacios, showing how the buildings could be refurbished and adapted to provide a hotel, student accommodation and shops – as proposed by the developers wishing to clear the site. Our campaign to save Lime Street was supported by the Merseyside Civic Society, the Cinema Theatres Association and The Victorian Society and a public petition to save the Futurist was signed by more than 4,000 people.