EAST SUFFOLK COUNCIL and SUFFOLK COUNTY COUNCIL JOINT LOCAL IMPACT REPORT East Anglia One North & East Anglia Two OFFSHORE WINDFARMS
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EAST SUFFOLK COUNCIL AND SUFFOLK COUNTY COUNCIL JOINT LOCAL IMPACT REPORT East Anglia One North & East Anglia Two OFFSHORE WINDFARMS Planning Inspectorate’s References: EA1N – EN010077 & EA2 – EN010078 November 2020 ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects Contents Page Appendices 3 Acronyms 4-5 1. Terms of Reference 6-8 2. Description of the Area 9-11 3. Statutory Development Plan 12-13 4. Other Relevant Local Policy 14-15 5. Assessment of Impacts and Adequacy of Response 16 6. The Principle of the Development 17-29 7. Air Quality – Emissions and Dust 30-41 8. External Lighting 42-43 9. Ecology and Ornithology 44-51 10. Coastal Change 52-56 11. Flood Risk 57-66 12. Built Heritage 67-73 13. Archaeology 74-80 14. Design and Masterplan 81-86 15. Landscape and Visual Effects 87-95 16. Seascape and Visual Effects 96-99 17. Land Use 100-102 18. Public Rights of Way 103-106 19. Noise and Vibration 107-114 20. Socio-Economic 115-120 21. Traffic and Transport 121-149 22. Minerals & Waste 150-152 23. Water Quality and Resources 153-154 24. Summary 155-156 2 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects Appendices Appendix 1: Rapid Historic Landscape Assessment Appendix 2: Archaeology Appendix 3: Annotated Visualisations of Trees and Vegetation Appendix 4: Analysis of Background Noise Survey Data 3 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects Acronyms AIS – Air Insulated Substation AONB – Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty AQMA – Air Quality Management Plan BEIS – Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy CCS – Construction Consolidation Site CIA – Cumulative Impact Assessment CoCP – Code of Construction Practice CRoW Act – Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000 DCLG – Department of Communities and Local Government DCO – Development Consent Order DMRB – Design Manual for Roads and Bridges EA – Environment Agency EA1 – East Anglia One Offshore Windfarm EA1N – East Anglia One North Offshore Windfarm EA2 – East Anglia Two Offshore Windfarm EA3 – East Anglia Three Offshore Windfarm EA4 – East Anglia Four Offshore Windfarm EIA – Environmental Impact Assessment EMP – Ecological Management Plan ES – Environmental Statement ESC – East Suffolk Council ETG – Expert Topic Group FRA – Flood Risk Assessment GIS – Gas Insulated Substation HDD – Horizontal Directional Drilling HER – Historic Environment Record HGV – Heavy Goods Vehicles HRA – Habitat Regulations Assessment HVDC – High Voltage Direct Current IAQM – Institute of Air Quality Management LCMS – Landfall Construction Method Statement LCT – Landscape Character Type LIR – Local Impact Report LLFA – Lead Local Flood Authority LPA – Local Planning Authority LMP – Landscape Mitigation Plan LVIA – Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment MU – Management Units MoU – Memorandum of Understanding 4 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects NG-ESO – National Grid Electricity Systems Operator NGET – National Grid Electricity Transmission NGV – National Grid Ventures NOA – Network Options Assessment NPPF – National Planning Policy Framework NRMM – Non-Road Mobile Machinery OCTMP – Outline Construction Traffic Management Plan OLEMS – Outline Landscape and Ecological Management Strategy OLMP – Outline Landscape Mitigation Plan OPCAEP – Outline Pre-Commencement Archaeology Execution Plan OTNR – Offshore Transmission Network Review OTP – Outline Travel Plan OWSI – Outline Written Scheme of Investigation PEIR – Preliminary Environmental Information Report PINS – Planning Inspectorate PRoW – Public Right of Way SCC – Suffolk County Council SFRMS – Suffolk Flood Risk Management Strategy SLVIA – Seascape, Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment SMP – Shoreline Management Plan SoCG – Statement of Common Ground SPA – Special Protection Area SPR – ScottishPower Renewables SSSI – Site of Special Scientific Interest SuDS – Sustainable Drainage System SWMP – Surface Water Management Plan TP – Travel Plan WSI – Written Scheme of Investigation WW2 – World War 2 5 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects 1. Terms of Reference Introduction 1.1. This report comprises the Joint Local Impact Report (LIR) of East Suffolk Council (ESC) and Suffolk County Council (SCC), referred to as “the Councils”. On the 1 April 2019 East Suffolk Council was created by parliamentary order, covering the former districts of Suffolk Coastal District Council and Waveney District Council. 1.2. Each of the main topics are ascribed to a Lead Authority for example SCC is the Lead Authority for Traffic and Transport. 1.3. This LIR has been prepared in accordance with s60(3) of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) and having regard to the guidance in the Planning Inspectorate’s Advice Note One: Local Impact Reports and the DCLG Guidance for the examination of applications for development consent. 1.4. East Anglia One North Ltd and East Anglia Two Ltd, which are subsidiaries of ScottishPower Renewables (SPR) have submitted two applications for Development Consent Orders (DCO) for two offshore wind farms; East Anglia One North (EA1N) and East Anglia Two (EA2). This LIR relates to both DCO applications and the comments provided within the LIR address the local impacts of both projects unless explicitly stated otherwise. Scope 1.5. The LIR only relates to onshore impacts of the proposed schemes as they affect the administrative areas of ESC and SCC. This includes the potential impacts of the proposed offshore infrastructure upon areas within the Councils jurisdiction above the mean low water mark including visual and landscape impacts. 1.6. The report specifically describes the impact of Works (described in the Development Consent Orders (DCO); namely: • 800mw wind farm minimum 36km from shore (Lowestoft) – EA1N; • 900mw wind farm minimum 33km from shore (Southwold) – EA2 • Up to two export cables laid underground landing at Thorpeness and connecting to up to two transition bays for each project; • Up to six electrical cables laid underground between the landfall and the substation location north of Friston with associated cable jointing bays for each project; 6 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects • EA1N substation, EA2 substation, National Grid substation and associated grid connection works immediately north of Friston, • Temporary construction consolidation sites for each project and; • Other onshore construction activities and temporary works associated with the above works. 1.7. This LIR does not describe the schemes any further, relying on the Applicants’ descriptions as set out in the DCO application documents. 1.8. Only a brief description of the development area is provided to highlight specific features within the onshore Order Limits. The Applicants’ Environmental Statements (ES) otherwise provide acceptable descriptions. 1.9. The Councils have experience of the DCO process and post consent phases of other windfarm projects. East Anglia One (EA1) windfarm was consented in 2014 and is due to be completed in 2021 and the East Anglia Three (EA3) windfarm was consented in 2017 but has not yet commenced. 1.10. There is no relevant planning history to be described, the Order Limits largely encompass greenfield land other than where they encompass watercourses, woodlands or the public highway. 1.11. The Councils have taken into consideration the responses the Applicants have provided in relation to their Relevant Representation in the drafting of the LIR (Document reference ExA.RR3.D0.V1 - ESC RR-02 and SCC RR-07). 1.12. The Councils continue to engage with the Applicants through the Statement of Common Ground (SoCG) process, with a view to narrowing the issues in dispute. Purpose and structure of the LIR 1.13. S60 (3) of the 2008 Planning Act defines Local Impact Reports as: “a report in writing giving details of the likely impact of the proposed development on the authority’s area.” 1.14. This LIR provides details of the likely impact of the two schemes under topic-based headings reflecting the likely nature of the impacts. The key issues for the Councils and the local community under each topic are identified, followed by commentary on the extent to which the Applicants address these issues by reference to the 7 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects application documentation, including the DCO articles, requirements and obligations, as relevant. 8 | Page ESC and SCC Joint LIR for EA1N and EA2 Projects 2. Description of the Area 2.1. The onshore cable corridor for both schemes passes through approximately 9km of countryside on its route from the landfall at Thorpeness to the substations site at Friston/Knodishall. The entire onshore Order Limits are within ESC’s administrative boundaries. 2.2. The cables come ashore within the Suffolk Coast and Heaths Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) and Heritage Coast at Thorpeness. The cliffs in the area of the landfall comprise weakly cemented Pleistocene rocks and sediments with the coastline suffering from episodic coastal erosion. The landscape is typical of the Coastal Dunes and Shingle Ridge landscape character type (LCT) as defined by the Suffolk County Landscape Character Assessment. To the north of the settlement of Thorpeness, the section of the coastline is relatively undeveloped and uncluttered with the Suffolk Coast Path following the coast northwards. 2.3. In addition to being within the defined Heritage Coast and AONB, the landfall area also lies partly within the Leiston-Aldeburgh Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI). 2.4. Once under the unconsolidated cliffs, the cables run under