Increasing Access to Family Justice Through Comprehensive Entry Points and Inclusivity
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Increasing Access to Family Justice Through Comprehensive Entry Points and Inclusivity FINAL REPORT February 2013 INCREASING ACCESS TO FAMILY JUSTICE THROUGH COMPREHENSIVE ENTRY POINTS AND INCLUSIVITY FINAL REPORT February 2013 Available online at www.lco-cdo.org Disponible en français ISBN: 978-1-926661-58-2 This publication may be cited as follows: Law Commission of Ontario, Increasing Access to Family Justice through Comprehensive Entry Points and Inclusivity (Toronto: February 2013) ABOUT THE LAW COMMISSION OF ONTARIO The Law Commission of Ontario (LCO) was created by an Agreement among the Law Foundation of Ontario, the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General, Osgoode Hall Law School and the Law Society of Upper Canada, all of whom provide funding for the LCO, and the Law Deans of Ontario’s law schools. York University also provides funding and in-kind support. It is situated in the Ignat Kaneff Building, the home of Osgoode Hall Law School at York University. The mandate of the LCO is to recommend law reform measures to enhance the legal system’s relevance, effectiveness and accessibility; improve the administration of justice through the clarification and simplification of the law; consider the use of technology to enhance access to justice; stimulate critical legal debate; and support scholarly research. The LCO is independent of government and selects projects that are of interest to and reflective of the diverse communities in Ontario. It has committed to engage in multidisciplinary research and analysis and make holistic recommendations as well as to collaborate with other bodies and consult with affected groups and the public more generally. LAW COMMISSION OF ONTARIO FINAL REPORTS Vulnerable Workers and Precarious Work (December 2012) A Framework for the Law as It Affects Persons with Disabilities (September 2012) Curriculum Modules in Ontario Law Schools: A Framework for Teaching about Violence Against Women (August 2012) A Framework for the Law as It Affects Older Adults (April 2012) Modernization of the Provincial Offences Act (August 2011) Joint and Several Liability Under the Ontario Business Corporations Act (February 2011) Division of Pensions Upon Marriage Breakdown (December 2008) Fees for Cashing Government Cheques (November 2008) DISCLAIMER The opinions or points of view expressed in our research, findings and recommendations do not necessarily represent the views of our funders, the Law Foundation of Ontario, the Ministry of the Attorney General, Osgoode Hall Law School, and the Law Society of Upper Canada or of our supporters, the Law Deans of Ontario. Law Commission of Ontario Tel: (416) 650-8406 2032 Ignat Kaneff Building, TTY: 1 (877) 650-8082 Osgoode Hall Law School, York University Fax: (416) 650-8418 4700 Keele Street General E-mail: [email protected] Toronto, Ontario, Canada www.lco-cdo.org M3J 1P3 ii Law Commission of Ontario Foreword Despite many reforms in the family legal system in Ontario, the most recent studies show that those trying to access the system still find it costly and confusing to navigate. The Final Report of the Family Justice Working Group of the Action Committee on Access to Justice in Civil and Family Matters (April 2013) and Dr. Julie Macfarlane’s Final Report in The National Self-Represented Litigants Project: Identifying and Meeting the Needs of Self-Represented Litigants (May 2013), both released after the Law Commission of Ontario’s Board of Governors approved this Final Report in our family law project, but before its release, continue to call for change. Our Report focuses on the early stages of people’s interaction with the system, when they are making the decision about whether to invoke the legal system, and integrates into consideration of the effectiveness of the system not only the factor of affordability, but also characteristics such as literacy, whether people live in rural and remote areas, culture, language, gender, disability, Aboriginality and others. Many of the reforms that have been instituted have been linked to the courts. On the basis of in-house research, commissioned research papers and consultations with both users of and workers in the system, we have concluded that at the earliest stages, for various reasons, family disputants need effective access to resources that do not necessarily draw them into the court system but, rather, allow access to the courts when needed. Furthermore, some reforms, intended to increase access to justice by ostensibly reducing cost, may be less valuable to those whose circumstances are related to low income than to those who are more likely to be able to afford assistance. Our central recommendation, multidisciplinary multifunction centres (that is, comprehensive delivery services), acknowledges the relationship between, and confluence of, legal and non-legal problems facing families, the importance of knowing how diversity can affect the value of various reforms and the benefit of the assistance of “trusted intermediaries” in helping those who, for whatever reason, are unable to access the system themselves. The Board of Governors, comprised of appointees of the founding partners, the judiciary and members at large, approved this Final Report in February 2013. The Board’s approval reflects its members’ collective responsibility to manage and conduct the affairs of the Law Commission of Ontario, and should not be considered an endorsement by individual members of the Board or by the organizations to which they belong. Bruce P. Elman, Chair, Board of Governors Patricia Hughes, Executive Director February 2013 iii The following individuals contributed to this project: LCO Staff Patricia Hughes, Project Head (October 2012-February 2013) Ida Bianchi, Project Head (March-September 2012) Stefan Kok, Project Head (January-December 2011) Kirsten Manley-Casimir, Interim Project Head (October-December 2010) Julie Lassonde, Project Head (until October 2010) Lauren Bates, Staff Lawyer (April-September 2008) Sue Gratton, Research Lawyer Margaret Hageman, Community Outreach Coordinator (August 2009-August 2010) Student Researchers Christine Barratt (JD Student, University of Maryland, School of Law) Andrea Dias (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Joshua Goldberg (JD Student. University of Ottawa, Faculty of Common Law) Zohra Hasham (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Ada Ho (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Stephen Hsia (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Howard Kislowicz (S.J.D. Student, University of Toronto, Faculty of Law) Amanda Letourneau (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Andrea McGarry (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Sahra Panjwani (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Jerri Phillips (JD Student, Queen’s University, Faculty of Law) Debjani Poddar (JD Student, University of Ottawa, Faculty of Common Law) Julia Rendell (LL.M. Student, University of Toronto, Faculty of Law) Nazila Rostami (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Tiffany Silas (JD Student, University of Maryland, School of Law) Renata Vienneau (JD Student, Osgoode Hall Law School, York University) Cody Yorke (JD Student, Queen’s University, Faculty of Law) Members of the Project Advisory Group Suzanne Cadieux, Ontario Works, City of Greater Sudbury Patti Cross, Ontario Court of Justice Tracy Gagnon, Ontario Native Women’s Association Tam Goossen, Urban Alliance on Race Relations Louise Guertin, Clinique Juridique Grand Nord Justice John Harper, Superior Court of Ontario (from January 2011) Justice Mary Jane Hatton, Superior Court of Ontario (until January 2011) Professor Ben Hovius, University of Western Ontario Susan Irwin, Rural Legal Services, Sharbot Lake Sergeant Lorna Kozmik, Toronto Police Service Paul Lantz, Keewaytinok Native Legal Services Marianne Park, Consultant Anne Marie Predko, Ministry of the Attorney General Justice Robert Spence, Ontario Court of Justice Members of the Board of Governors during this Project Bruce P. Elman, Member-at-large (from May 2012); Chair of the Board of Governors (from September 2012) iv Law Commission of Ontario Larry Banack, Member-at-large (from August 2012); Chair of the Board of Governors (July 2009-August 2012) Mark L. Berlin, Member-at-large (from January 2012) Gwen Boniface, Law Foundation of Ontario (from September 2011) Christopher D. Bredt, Law Society of Upper Canada (from March 2008) Nathalie Des Rosiers, Member-at-large (from November 2009) Adam Dodek, Ontario Law Schools (from July 2011) William Flanagan, Ontario Law Deans (January 2009-October 2009) Stephan Goudge, Judiciary (from September 2009) Neena Gupta, Member-at-large (July 2007-January 2012) Marie Henein, Member-at-large (July 2007-May 2009) Ian Holloway, Ontario Law Schools (November 2009-May 2011) Frank Iacobucci, Law Foundation of Ontario (January 2007-June 2011) Russell Juriansz, Judiciary (July 2008-September 2009) Mark Leach, Ministry of the Attorney General (June 2012-November 2012) Jinyan Li, Osgoode Hall Law School (July 2009-May 2010) Patrick Monahan, Osgoode Hall Law School, Chair of the Board of Governors (January 2007-June 2009); Ministry of the Attorney General (from November 2012) María Páez Victor, Member-at-large (from January 2012) Andrew Pinto, Member-at-large (from July 2012) Murray Segal, Ministry of the Attorney General (January 2007-May 2012) Lorne Sossin, Osgoode Hall Law School (from June 2010) Patricia Hughes, ex officio, Executive Director of the