Subglacial Basins: Their Origin and Importance in Glacial Systems and Landscapes
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This is a repository copy of Subglacial basins: Their origin and importance in glacial systems and landscapes. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/100951/ Version: Accepted Version Article: Cook, S.J. and Swift, D.A. orcid.org/0000-0001-5320-5104 (2012) Subglacial basins: Their origin and importance in glacial systems and landscapes. Earth-Science Reviews, 115 (4). pp. 332-372. ISSN 0012-8252 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2012.09.009 Article available under the terms of the CC-BY-NC-ND licence (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) Reuse This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs (CC BY-NC-ND) licence. This licence only allows you to download this work and share it with others as long as you credit the authors, but you can’t change the article in any way or use it commercially. More information and the full terms of the licence here: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/ Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing [email protected] including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. [email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ This is an author-formatted version of manuscript http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2012.0 .00 . Please cite this work as Cook, S.J. and Swift, D.A. 2012. Subglacial basins: their origin and i portance in glacial syste s and landscapes. Earth Science Reviews, Volu e 115, Issue 4, Pages 332+3,2. Subglacial basins: their origin and importance in glacial systems and landscapes COOK, S.J.1,',( and S)IFT, ,.A.2,' 1 Centre for -laciology, Institute of -eography and Earth Sciences, Aberystwyth .niversity, Ceredigion, S/23 3D0, .1 2 Depart ent of -eography, .niversity of Sheffield, 2inter Street, Sheffield, S10 2TN, .1 ABSTRACT C.osed topographic basins are found beneath contemporar0 ice masses and 1ithin the footprint of former ice masses in a.. g.aciated regions. )e present the first integrated revie1 of subg.acia. basin occurrence and formation and the imp.ications of such basins for g.acio.ogica. processes and the evo.ution of .andscape. Our purpose is to motivate research in areas 1here understanding of basin origin and process significance is 1ea2. 3asins on the order of 10-102 m deep and 102-103 m .ong are produced b0 g.acia. erosion of subg.acia. roc2 and/or sediment and are 2no1n as 5overdeepenings6. Out.et and va..e0 g.aciers can 5overdeepen6 their beds far be.o1 sea .eve. or .oca. f.uviati.e base .eve.. 7arger basins, t0pica..0 in ice sheet contexts, ma0 have a pre-g.acia. 8usua..0 tectonic9 origin. Subg.acia. basins are important g.acio.ogica..0 because the0 re:uire ice, 1ater and sediment to ascend an adverse subg.acia. s.ope in order to exit the g.acia. s0stem, the efficienc0 of 1hich is dependent upon the gradient of the adverse s.ope and that of the ice surface. 3asins thus inf.uence subg.acia. drainage s0stem morpho.og0 and transmissivit0, the thic2ness and distribution of basa. ice and sediment .a0ers, and the mechanisms and d0namics of ice f.o1. Adverse gradients that exceed 11 times that of the ice surface ma0 even permit the formation of subg.acia. .a2es. )e specu.ate that, in comparison to ice masses 1ith fe1 or no subg.acia. basins, those 1ith numerous or ver0 .arge basins ma0 respond to c.imatic changes 1ith unexpected vigour. In addition, erosion rates and transport path1a0s of 1ater and sediment through the g.acia. s0stem, and the expression of these processes in the sediment and .andform record, ma0 be unexpected.0 comp.ex. Further, our revie1 sho1s that, in a 1arming c.imate, ice masses resting on adverse s.opes 1i.. be vu.nerab.e to rapid and potentia..0 catastrophic retreat; ne1 .a2es in subg.acia. basins exposed b0 mountain g.acier retreat 1i.. present ' The authors contributed e:ua..0 to this 1or2. Correspondence to ,. A. S1ift [email protected]; te.ephone +44 114 222 7 5 9 or S. J. Coo2 [email protected]; te.ephone +44 161 24712029. ( Present address: Schoo. of Science and the Environment, Aanchester Aetropo.itan Bniversit0, Chester Street, Aanchester, A1 5C,, BK. Page 1 of 76 an increasing haDard; and subg.acia. .a2es ma0 drain catastrophica..0. On even .onger time sca.es, 1e specu.ate that the g.acia. excavation and post-g.acia. fi..ing of basins in mountainous regions shou.d contribute important.0 to c.imate-re.ated changes in isostas0 and re.ief. A.though the contro.s on overdeepening and their inf.uence on other g.acia. and .andscape processes remain uncertain, 1e h0pothesise that overdeepened g.acia. s0stems ref.ect an e:ui.ibrium ice-bed geometr0 that maximises the efficienc0 of ice discharge. Improved understanding of overdeepening processes, especia..0 overdeepened-bed h0dro.og0, is therefore necessar0 to understand fu..0 the d0namic behaviour of va..e0 and out.et g.aciers, and thus the fate of Earth6s .argest ice masses. Keywords: g.acier d0namics; g.acier h0dro.og0; overdeepening; sediment transfer; g.acia. geomorpho.og0; .ands0stems; .andscape evo.ution; haDards; c.imate sensitivit0 1. I TRODUCTIO Subg.acia. basins 8i.e. c.osed topographic depressions in the beds of present and former ice masses9 are a ubi:uitous feature of g.aciated environments. In this paper, 1e demonstrate that man0 subg.acia. basins are produced b0 g.acia. erosion. This t0pe of basin is 2no1n common.0 as an 5overdeepening6. Eo1ever, man0 basins are .i2e.0 to be non-g.acia. in origin, and ma0 have undergone on.0 .imited modification b0 g.acia. processes. Our intention is to high.ight the process significance of subg.acia. basins in genera.; hence, 1e do not restrict our attention to those basins of exc.usive.0 g.acia. origin. Neverthe.ess, the appetite of ice masses to 5bite deep.0 into sound roc26 87inton, 1 639 means 1e focus primari.0 on the origin and process significance of g.acia. basins, and consider the process significance of presumed non-g.acia. basins on.0 1hen it is pertinent. This paper is primari.0 a revie1 that aims to motivate research 1here understanding of the origin and process significance of overdeepening is 1ea2. Neverthe.ess, 1herever possib.e, 1e have attempted to dra1 out and present ne1 ideas and h0potheses in order to i..ustrate the diverse and potentia..0 important imp.ications of overdeepening for g.acia. s0stems and geomorphic processes. The first three sections revie1 the context, occurrence, and origin of subg.acia. basins, focussing on the distribution and formation of g.acia. overdeepenings. )e then revie1 pub.ished 1or2 pertinent to the g.acio.ogica. importance of subg.acia. basins in t1o parts: first.0, the importance for g.acier h0dro.og0 and seasona. d0namics, ice f.o1 and the stabi.it0 of ice masses, and re.ated phenomena; and second.0, the importance for g.acia. geomorphic processes and .ong-term .andscape and ice sheet evo.ution. This revie1 and ana.0sis of pub.ished .iterature does not intend to be exhaustive; rather, 1e see2 to identif0 and support essentia. concepts. For brevit0, 1e do not inc.ude governing e:uations that can be found in cited .iterature. The sixth section is a discussion that dra1s on the evidence provided b0 pub.ished 1or2 to high.ight areas of uncertaint0 and future research :uestions. It is recommended that readers 1ho are fami.iar 1ith the concept of overdeepening and have an expert understanding of g.acier erosiona., h0dro.ogica. and ice d0namic processes s2ip to this section. The fina. section conc.udes the revie1 and discussion. 2. GLACIOLOGICAL CO TE(T A D DEFI ITIO S C.acia. erosion during the Guaternar0 period has contributed enormous.0 to the scu.pting of .arge regions of the g.obe, carving spectacu.ar a.pine .andscapes, scouring vast areas of continenta. crust, and generating prodigious :uantities of sediment for transport and deposition b0 g.acia., aeo.ian and f.uvia. processes. The evo.ution and g.acio.ogica. significance of man0 .arge-sca.e g.acia. erosiona. forms common to such regions, inc.uding B-shaped fjords and va..e0s, expanses of aeria. scouring, and cir:ues and arHtes, is no1 1e.. understood. In former.0 g.aciated regions, the distribution and morphometr0 of these .andforms has been exp.oited 1ide.0 for the purposes of pa.aeog.acio.ogica. Page 2 of 76 Figure 1. Schematic diagrams i..ustrating the t0pica. g.acia. and post-g.acia. context of over-deepened basins under temperate va..e0 g.aciation. and process reconstruction 8C.asser and 3ennett, 20049. Advances in remote sensing, numerica. mode..ing and geochrono.og0 continue to enab.e investigation of .andscape evo.ution at ever greater spatia. and tempora. sca.es, providing ne1 insight into the g.acio.ogica. significance of .andscapes and their component forms, even beneath contemporar0 ice sheets 83ingham et a.., 20109. C.acia. erosion is c.ose.0 .in2ed to spatia. patterns of ice f.o1 and sediment transport and deposition 8e.g. A..e0 et a.., 1 79, and, over mi..ion-0ear timesca.es, g.acia. .andscape evo.ution ref.ects and inf.uences the d0namics of tectonics and c.imate 8e.g.