A Demo Search Engine for Products

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Demo Search Engine for Products A Demo Search Engine for Products Beibei Li Anindya Ghose Panagiotis G. Ipeirotis [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Department of Information, Operations, and Management Sciences Leonard N. Stern School of Business, New York University New York, New York 10012, USA ABSTRACT using customer review ratings. This approach has quite a few Most product search engines today build on models of rele- shortcomings. First, it ignores the multidimensional preferences vance devised for information retrieval. However, the decision of consumers. Second, it fails to leverage the information gener- mechanism that underlies the process of buying a product is ated by the online communities, going beyond simple numerical different than the process of locating relevant documents or ratings. Third, it hardly takes into account the heterogeneity objects. We propose a theory model for product search based on of consumers. These drawbacks highly necessitate a recommen- expected utility theory from economics. Specifically, we propose dation strategy for products that can better model consumers' a ranking technique in which we rank highest the products that underlying purchase behavior, to capture their multidimensional generate the highest surplus, after the purchase. We instantiate preferences and heterogeneous tastes. our research by building a demo search engine for hotels that Recommender systems [1] could fix some of these problems takes into account consumer heterogeneous preferences, and also but, to the best of our knowledge, existing techniques still have accounts for the varying hotel price. Moreover, we achieve this limitations: First, most recommendation mechanisms require without explicitly asking the preferences or purchasing histories consumers to log into the system. However, in reality many of individual consumers but by using aggregate demand data. consumers browse only anonymously. Due to the lack of any This new ranking system is able to recommend consumers prod- meaningful, personalized recommendations, consumers do not ucts with \best value for money" in a privacy-preserving manner. feel compelled to login before purchasing. Even when they login, The demo is accessible at http://nyuhotels.appspot.com/ before or after a purchase, consumers are reluctant to give out their individual demographic information due to many reasons (e.g., time constraints, privacy issues, or lack of incentives). Categories and Subject Descriptors Therefore, most context information is missing at the individual H.3.3 [Information Storage and Retrieval]: Information consumer level. Second, for goods with a low purchase frequency Search and Retrieval for an individual consumer, such as hotels, cars, or real estate, there are few repeated purchases we could leverage towards General Terms building a predictive model (i.e., models based on collaborative filtering). Third, and potentially more importantly, as privacy Algorithms, Economics, Experimentation, Measurement issues become increasingly noticeable today, marketers may not be able to observe the individual-level purchase history of each Keywords consumer (or consumer segment). Instead, the only information Consumer Surplus, Economics, Product Search, Ranking, Text available is at an aggregate level (e.g., market share or unit Mining, User-Generated Content, Utility Theory sold). As a consequence, many algorithms that rely on knowing individual-level behavior lack the ability of deriving consumer preferences from such aggregate data. 1. INTRODUCTION Alternative techniques try to identify the \Pareto optimal" It is now widely acknowledged that online search for products set of results [2]. Unfortunately, the feasibility of this approach is increasing in popularity, as more and more users search and diminishes as the number of product characteristics increases. purchase products from the Internet. Most search engines for With more than five or six characteristics, the probability of a products today are based on models of relevance from \clas- point being classified as \Pareto optimal" dramatically increases. sic" information retrieval theory [9] or use variants of faceted As a consequence, the set of Pareto optimal results soon includes search [11] to facilitate browsing. However, the decision mecha- every product. nism that underlies the process of buying a product is different In our work, we design a new ranking system for recommen- from the process of finding a relevant document or object. Cus- dation that leverages economic modeling. We aim at making tomers do not simply seek something relevant to their search, recommendations based on better perception of the underlying but also try to identify the \best" deal that satisfies their specific the \causality" of consumers' purchase decisions. Our algorithm criteria. Today's product search engines provide only rudimen- learns consumer preferences based on the largely anonymous, tary ranking facilities for search results, typically using a single publicly observed distributions of consumer demographics as ranking criterion such as price, best selling, or more recently, well as the observed aggregate-level purchases (i.e., anonymous purchases and market shares in NYC and LA), not by learning Copyright is held by the International World Wide Web Conference Com- mittee (IW3C2). Distribution of these papers is limited to classroom use, from the identified behavior or demographics of each individ- and personal use by others. ual. We instantiate our research by building a demo search WWW 2011, March 28–April 1, 2011, Hyderabad, India. ACM 978-1-4503-0637-9/11/03. engine for hotels, using a unique data set containing transac- utility after purchasing a product. This idea naturally gener- tions from Nov. 2008 to Jan. 2009 for US hotels from a major ates a ranking order: The products that generate the highest travel web site. Our extensive user studies, using more than consumer surplus should be ranked on top. 15000 user judgments, demonstrate an overwhelming preference for the ranking generated by our techniques, compared to a 2.2 The BLP Model large number of existing strong baselines. The key for our model is to identify the different product The major contributions of our research are: (1) We present a characteristics and estimate the corresponding weights assigned causal model, based on economic theory, to capture the decision- by consumers towards the characteristics and the price of the making process of consumers, leading to a better understanding product. However, different consumers hold different evalu- of consumer preferences. The causal model relaxes the assump- ations towards the product characteristics and towards the tion of \consistent environment" across training and testing money. To capture the consumer heterogeneity, we use the data sets: we can now have changes in the environment and Random-Coefficient Logit Model [3] (also known as BLP). can predict what should happen under such changes. (2) We This model incorporates consumer heterogeneity by assuming infer personal preferences from aggregate data, in a privacy- that consumers have idiosyncratic tastes towards product char- preserving manner. (3) We propose a ranking method using acteristics. In other words, the coefficients β and α in equation the notion of surplus, which is derived from a \generative" user 1 and 2 are different for each consumer. Based on this, we behavior model. (4) We present an extensive experimental define the utility surplus for consumer i to buy product Xj as study: using six hotel markets, and 15000 user evaluations USi = U (X ) − [U (Ii) − U (Ii − p )] + "i (3) using blind tests, we demonstrate that the generated rankings j h j m m j j are significantly better than existing approaches. X ik k i i = β · xj + ξj − α pj + "j : k |{z} |{z} 2. THEORY MODEL | {z } Utility of money Stochastic error Utility of product i In this section, we first introduce the background of the ex- Here, I is the income of consumer i, pj is the price of product pected utility theory, characteristics-based theory, and economic Xj , Um is the utility of money (parameterized by user specific i surplus. Then we discuss how we leverage these concepts into weight scalar α ), and Uh is the utility of product purchased our setting and empirically estimate our model. (parameterized by user specific weight vector βi). Note that ξ is a product-specific disturbance scalar summarizing unob- 2.1 Background i served characteristics of product Xj , whereas "j is a stochastic Our model is derived from from expected utility and rational choice error term that is assumed to be i.i.d. across products choice theories. A fundamental notion in utility theory is that and consumers in the selection process. The parameters to be each consumer is endowed with an associated utility function estimated are αi and βi, which represent the weights that con- U, which is \a measure of the satisfaction from consumption of sumer i assigns towards \money" and towards different observed various goods and services." The rationality assumption defines product characteristics, respectively. that each person tries to maximize its own utility. The technical details for the model estimation are in [7]. To More formally, assume that the consumer has a choice across better understand our model, let's consider an example. products X1; ::: ;Xn, and each product Xj has a price pj . Buy- ing a product involves the exchange of money for a product. Example 1. Suppose that we have two cities, A and B and Therefore, to analyze the purchasing behavior we need to have two types of consumers: business trip travelers and family trip two components for the utility function: (1) Utility of Product: travelers. City A is a business destination (e.g., New York The utility that the consumer will get by buying the product City) with 80% of the travelers being business travelers and 20% Xj , and (2) Utility of Money: The utility that the consumer families. City B is mainly a family destination (e.g., Orlando) will lose by paying the price pj for product Xj . with 10% business travelers and 90% family travelers. In city A, On one hand, the decision to purchase product Xj generates a we have two hotels: Hilton (A1) and Doubletree (A2).
Recommended publications
  • Sagaponack Common School District Board of Trustees Meeting PRESENT: Cathy Hatgistavrou, President Brian Villante, Vice Presi
    Sagaponack Common School District October 18, 2018 Board of Trustees Meeting PRESENT: Cathy Hatgistavrou, President Brian Villante, Vice President Lauren Thayer, Member ALSO PRESENT: Alan Van Cott, Superintendent Eileen Tuohy, District Treasurer Jeanette Krempler, District Clerk The meeting was called to order by Cathy Hatgistavrou at 7:05 p.m. Brian Villante seconded the motion. The Pledge of Call to Order Allegiance was conducted. A motion was made by Brian Villante to approve the Approval of Meeting Minutes September 20, 2018 meeting minutes with amendments. Lauren Thayer seconded the motion. Passed 3-0. A motion was made by Brian Villante to approve the September Treasurer's Report. Lauren Thayer seconded the Approval of the September motion. Passed 3-0. Treasurer's Report Checking account total: $127,516.38 Money Market account total: $1,611,820.93 A motion was made by Lauren Thayer to approve the Approval of Budget Transfers October 2018 budget transfers in the amount of $5,917.00. Brian Villante seconded the motion. Passed 3-0. A motion was made by Cathy Hatgistavrou to approve Check Approval of Check Warrant #08- Warrant #08-201819 in the amount of $38,305.61. Brian 201819 Villante seconded the motion. Passed 3-0. A motion was made by Cathy Hatgistavrou to approve Check Warrant #09-201819 in the amount of $74,638.57. Brian Approval of Check Warrant #09- 201819 Villante seconded the motion. Passed 3-0. A motion was made by Brian Villante to set the tax rate for Approval Tax Rate the 2018-2019 school year at .2229/$1,000.00 of assessed value.
    [Show full text]
  • ED041428.Pdf
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 041 428 EC 006 107 TITLE Exceptional Children Media Reviews Reprint. INSTITUTION Council for Exceptional Children, Arlington, Va. PUB DATE 68 NOTE 59p. JOURNAL CIT Reprinted from Exceptional Children, September 1968 - April 1970 EDRS PRICE EDRS Price MF-$0.50 HC Not Available from EDRS. DESCRIPTORS Annotated Bibliographies, Audiovisual Aids, Bibliographies, Educational Methods, *Exceptional Child Education, Films, *Handicapped Children, Instructional Materials, *Instructional Media, *Literature Reviews ABSTRACT Forty-nine books, films, and tapes are reviewed in various areas of special education. Authors' comments on the reviews are frequently included. (JD) .-es. Exceptional Children 2Media Reviews Reprint September 1968-Apri11970 Reprinted from EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN September 1968- April 1970 Media Reviews VOLUME 35 September 1968 The Modification of Stuttering. Eugene J. Brut- to the two process theory. Chapter IV, "A ten and Donald J. Shoemaker. Englewood Cliffs, Theory for the Modification of Stuttering," New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1967. 148 pp. $5.50. deals with extinction of classically conditioned responses and of instrumental responses. Chap- This book is intended to acquaint both the ter V, "Clinical Procedures for the Modifica- college student and the professional speech pathologist with the learning theories around tion of Stuttering," is 49 pages long or about which current thinking about stuttering has one-third of the book. One of the first pro- been structured, with the data important to cedures described is the obtaining of critical the fundamental predictions of these the- factors; which evoke negative emotion in the ories, and with a two-process theory of learn- patient. The techniques of therapy are in terms ing that seems promising for both the the- oretical integration of the data on stuttering of inhibition of negative emotional responses, and the therapeutic modification of it.
    [Show full text]
  • Student Life | December 7, 2007
    STAFF EDITORIAL | PROFESSOR SMITH’S LAST LECTURE TODAY | SEE FORUM, PAGE 4 TUDENT IFE THE SINDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER OF WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY L IN ST. LOUIS SINCE 1878 VOLUME 129, NO. 41 FRIDAY, DECEMBER 7, 2007 WWW.STUDLIFE.COM Fewer appeals leave SU with Administration discusses money to burn tuition at annual forum part of the money set aside for BY TEDDY WHITE BY PERRY STEIN CONTRIBUTING REPORTER appeals because there has been such low demand. CONTRIBUTING REPORTER Student Union (SU) is encour- “The treasurers wanted to After meeting with students aging student groups on campus see the funding percentage [for at the annual Tuition Forum on to appeal for more funding after category I groups] higher,” said Tuesday to explain, and receive spending from the appeals fund Marius Johnson, SU treasurer. feedback on, the breakdown of lagged considerably in compari- “Because they could safely do it, tuition, the Washington Univer- son to previous years. they moved $15,000 so the fund- sity administration will meet As of Thursday afternoon, ing percentage would be higher.” with the Board of Trustees to- there was about $115,000 avail- The student activities fee, night to set the offi cial tuition able in the appeals fund for which is set at one percent of the for the 2008-09 academic year. Washington University student annual tuition paid by each stu- The Executive Board will of- organizations. dent, determines the SU budget; fi cially announce the tuition This amount is signifi cantly because tuition rates are rising price to the student body on greater than it has been in past faster than infl ation, the budget January 7, 2008.
    [Show full text]
  • Jeeps, Communists, and Quonset Huts: World War II Surplus Disposal in the Territory of Hawai‘I Gwen Sinclair
    Jeeps, Communists, and Quonset Huts: World War II Surplus Disposal in the Territory of Hawai‘i gwen sinclair In the waning days of World War II, the Honolulu Advertiser pub- lished a prescient article by a reporter named Gerry Burtnett about military surplus disposal: The disposal of surplus property in Hawaii is going to be one of the big- gest stories of the last days of the war and the postwar period. It may be a rather unpleasant story, from present indications.1 Disposal of war surplus in Hawai‘i was a big story, judging from the hundreds of newspaper articles about it published between 1945 and 1950. As soldiers, sailors, and marines returned home and life in the Territory began to be shaped by peacetime concerns, surplus disposal became an important industry in the Territory of Hawai‘i and in the nation as a whole. The disposal of surplus property captured the attention not only of the surplus-consuming public, but also of Congressional investigating committees. This paper will examine the effects of surplus disposal, why surplus held people’s attention for so long, and the major events and key people involved with surplus dis- posal in the Territory of Hawai‘i. Gwen Sinclair is a librarian and Head of the Government Documents & Maps Department at the University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa Library. Her publications and research interests range from government secrecy to presidential executive orders and proclamations relating to federal property in Hawai‘i. The Hawaiian Journal of History, vol. 50 (2016) 121 122 the hawaiian journal of history Long before the end of World War II, officials in Washington, D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • «The Security Economy
    The Security Economy « Recent years have seen security take a prominent place on the political and corporate agenda. Organised crime, terrorism, disruption of global supply chains, The Security computer viruses – all have played a role in raising people’s awareness of the risks they face in today’s world. Economy The result has been the emergence of a USD 100 billion market for security goods and services fed by growing demand from governments, businesses and private households. With globalisation and technological progress continuing at a rapid pace, the security economy is expected to expand further in the years ahead. New identification and surveillance technologies such as biometrics and radio frequency ID are coming on stream, and satellite-based monitoring is set to play an ever greater role. How large are the potential economic costs of major disruptions to transport systems and information networks? What is the overall cost of tighter security? Are there trade-offs between higher levels of security and economic efficiency? What are the future implications for society of the growth of surveillance in terms of its impact on privacy and other democratic liberties? This report tackles those and many other questions critical to the security economy of the 21st century. The Security Economy OECD's books, periodicals and statistical databases are now available via www.SourceOECD.org, our online library. This book is available to subscribers to the following SourceOECD themes: Science and Information Technology General Economics and Future
    [Show full text]
  • Three Notes on the Longevity of the Revived Bretton Woods System
    MICHAEL DOOLEY University of California, Santa Cruz PETER GARBER Deutsche Bank Is It 1958 or 1968? Three Notes on the Longevity of the Revived Bretton Woods System ITISNOW widely accepted that the broad outlines of the current interna- tional monetary system are as we described them almost two years ago and labeled “the Revived Bretton Woods system.” This system’s main features are —the emergence of a macroeconomically important group of economies that manage their currencies vis-à-vis the dollar to support export-driven growth —the United States as center and reserve currency country, providing financial intermediation services for foreign, and particularly Asian, sav- ing through its national balance sheet, and willing to accept large current account imbalances —a group of poorer economies implementing export-led development policies and exporting large amounts of capital to richer economies, mostly the United States —unusually low and even falling short- and long-term real interest rates as a result of this glut of mobile global savings, and —a group of industrial and emerging economies with floating exchange rates, whose currencies are under incessant pressure to appreciate. Not agreed and under vigorous discussion is how long this system can last. Will it be a meteoric flash with a spectacular end soon to come? Or We are grateful to Daniel Riera-Crichton for his able and diligent research assistance in producing the empirical results of this paper. 147 148 Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1:2005 will it last for the reasonably
    [Show full text]
  • 00001. Rugby Pass Live 1 00002. Rugby Pass Live 2 00003
    00001. RUGBY PASS LIVE 1 00002. RUGBY PASS LIVE 2 00003. RUGBY PASS LIVE 3 00004. RUGBY PASS LIVE 4 00005. RUGBY PASS LIVE 5 00006. RUGBY PASS LIVE 6 00007. RUGBY PASS LIVE 7 00008. RUGBY PASS LIVE 8 00009. RUGBY PASS LIVE 9 00010. RUGBY PASS LIVE 10 00011. NFL GAMEPASS 1 00012. NFL GAMEPASS 2 00013. NFL GAMEPASS 3 00014. NFL GAMEPASS 4 00015. NFL GAMEPASS 5 00016. NFL GAMEPASS 6 00017. NFL GAMEPASS 7 00018. NFL GAMEPASS 8 00019. NFL GAMEPASS 9 00020. NFL GAMEPASS 10 00021. NFL GAMEPASS 11 00022. NFL GAMEPASS 12 00023. NFL GAMEPASS 13 00024. NFL GAMEPASS 14 00025. NFL GAMEPASS 15 00026. NFL GAMEPASS 16 00027. 24 KITCHEN (PT) 00028. AFRO MUSIC (PT) 00029. AMC HD (PT) 00030. AXN HD (PT) 00031. AXN WHITE HD (PT) 00032. BBC ENTERTAINMENT (PT) 00033. BBC WORLD NEWS (PT) 00034. BLOOMBERG (PT) 00035. BTV 1 FHD (PT) 00036. BTV 1 HD (PT) 00037. CACA E PESCA (PT) 00038. CBS REALITY (PT) 00039. CINEMUNDO (PT) 00040. CM TV FHD (PT) 00041. DISCOVERY CHANNEL (PT) 00042. DISNEY JUNIOR (PT) 00043. E! ENTERTAINMENT(PT) 00044. EURONEWS (PT) 00045. EUROSPORT 1 (PT) 00046. EUROSPORT 2 (PT) 00047. FOX (PT) 00048. FOX COMEDY (PT) 00049. FOX CRIME (PT) 00050. FOX MOVIES (PT) 00051. GLOBO PORTUGAL (PT) 00052. GLOBO PREMIUM (PT) 00053. HISTORIA (PT) 00054. HOLLYWOOD (PT) 00055. MCM POP (PT) 00056. NATGEO WILD (PT) 00057. NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC HD (PT) 00058. NICKJR (PT) 00059. ODISSEIA (PT) 00060. PFC (PT) 00061. PORTO CANAL (PT) 00062. PT-TPAINTERNACIONAL (PT) 00063. RECORD NEWS (PT) 00064.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Resources Flexibilities and Authorities in the Federal Government
    Human Resources Flexibilities and Authorities in the Federal Government August 2013 Human Resources Flexibilities and Authorities in the Federal Government U.S. Office of Personnel Management 1900 E. St., NW Washington DC Website: http://www.opm.gov Human Resources Flexibilities and Authorities in the Federal Government 2 This page intentionally left blank. U.S. Office of Personnel Management Human Resources Flexibilities and Authorities in the Federal Government 3 Preface This handbook summarizes the major human resources (HR) flexibilities and authorities in the Federal Government and is intended as a reference material for managers, supervisors, and employees on personnel matters dealing with recruiting, retaining, and motivating the Federal workforce. These HR tools and requirements, which should be used in a strategic manner, are a critical component in ensuring that the Federal Government maintains a world-class workforce to serve the American people. Handbook Organization The Human Resources Flexibilities and Authorities Handbook is divided into three parts. Part I describes how the Governmentwide HR practices convey the message that the Federal Government is a "single employer" with common policies. Part II is designed for the non-executive workforce (e.g., General Schedule, Federal Wage System). It will help to: Learn what is available to assist in developing integrated and merit-based systems that make sense for the organization Foster greater balance of employees' work and nonwork time for greater productivity and higher morale Inject new skills and competencies into the workforce Develop compensation, performance and reward systems that send clear messages high performance is valued and rewarded Tackle workforce challenges in general Part III is devoted to the flexibilities and authorities designed specifically for the Senior Executive Service.
    [Show full text]
  • Affidavit to File for Tax Deed Surplus Funds
    Finance and Administrative Services Department RECORDS, TAXES, AND TREASURY DIVISION -- Tax Deed Section 115 S. Andrews Avenue, Room A-100 • Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 • [email protected] <<print_date>> (TD #<<deed_app_number>>) <<deed_sale_date>> SURPLUS NOTICE <<title_search_entity_name>> <<title_search_entity_address>> NOTICE OF SURPLUS FUNDS FROM TAX DEED SALE: (For Tax Deed Applications Filed After 9/30/18) TAX DEED: <<deed_app_number>> SALE DATE: <<deed_sale_date>> PROPERTY I.D: <<account_number>> LEGAL DESCRIPTION: <<title_search_full_legal>> PLEASE NOTE: If you no longer have interest in the property described above please disregard this letter. Pursuant to Chapter 197, F.S., the above-referenced property was sold at public sale on <<deed_sale_date>>, and an estimated gross Surplus of $<<deed_sale_overbid_amount>> (subject to change) will be held by this office for 120 days beginning on the date of this notice to benefit the persons having an interest in this property as described in section 197.502(4), Florida Statutes, as their interest may appear (except for those persons described in section 197.502(4)(h), Florida Statutes). To the extent possible, these funds will be used to satisfy in full each claimant with a senior mortgage or lien in the property before distribution of any funds to any junior mortgage or lien claimant or to the former property owner. To be considered for funds when they are distributed, you must file a notarized statement of claim with this office within 120 days of this notice. If you are a lien holder, your claim must include the particulars of your lien and the amount currently due. Any lien holder claim that is not filed within the 120-day deadline is barred.
    [Show full text]
  • The Atlas Is Coming!
    TH~VOCET The Newsletter of the Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society November - Decem ber 2007 The Atlas is Coming! The Atlas is Coming! By Bob Power, SCVAS Executive Director this atlas from 1987 to 1993 (listed along with other con­ The Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society is the very tributor in Appendix l of the proud publisher of the Breeding Bird Atlas of Santa Clara Christmas Bird Atlas). The skilled and careful County, California. I could be een a bia ed regarding thi work of all of these observer is Count Coming book, but honestly, this is a neutral stateme nt: This will be reflected in the breadth and ac- your favorite bird book, with a wealth of natural hi tory - sign up now! curacy of thi atla . Following ahd data on our local breeding birds. The Atlas is best de- the atlas period, cribed by these word from the introduction: see Page 8 Michael M . Rog­ "The Breeding Bird Atla of Santa Clara er established County, California, which report the results and maintained the post-atlas database , of fieldwork in Santa Clara County from I 987 based on the contributions of many indi­ to 1993, was undertaken to determine the cur­ viduals (al o listed in Appendix I). The rent tatus of all pecies of birds known to be post-atlas data ignificantly augmented the breeding in the county. These data have been atlas data, particularly for bird breeding augmented with additional field ob ervations in the Santa Clara Valley." - Bill Bousman reported from 1994 to 2005. A breeding bird The Atlas is superbly written and beautifully atla eeks to determine the bird that breed illu trated.
    [Show full text]
  • Towards a Theory Model for Product Search∗
    WWW 2011 – Session: E-commerce March 28–April 1, 2011, Hyderabad, India Towards a Theory Model for Product Search∗ Beibei Li Anindya Ghose Panagiotis G. Ipeirotis [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Department of Information, Operations, and Management Sciences Leonard N. Stern School of Business, New York University New York, New York 10012, USA ABSTRACT aproductis different from the process of finding a relevant With the growing pervasiveness of the Internet, online search document or object. Customers do not simply seek to find for products and services is constantly increasing. Most product something relevant to their search, but also try to identify the search engines are based on adaptations of theoretical models “best” deal that satisfies their specific desired criteria. Of course, devised for information retrieval. However, the decision mecha- it is difficult to quantify the notion of “best” product without nism that underlies the process of buying a product is different trying to understand what the users are optimizing. than the process of locating relevant documents or objects. Today’s product search engines provide only rudimentary We propose a theory model for product search based on ranking facilities for search results, typically using a single rank- expected utility theory from economics. Specifically, we propose ing criterion such as name, price, best selling (volume of sales), a ranking technique in which we rank highest the products that or more recently, using customer review ratings. This approach generate the highest surplus, after the purchase. In a sense, the has quite a few shortcomings. First, it ignores the multidimen- top ranked products are the “best value for money”foraspecific sional preferences of consumers.
    [Show full text]
  • Gr.Een Light
    GR.EEN LIGHT BULLETIN OF THE POIXT ASSOCIATION OF NEWPORT, RHODE ISLAND SUMMER 2011 The Point Association The Point Association is a group TheGREEN LIGHT of neighbors working together to LVNo.2 SUMMER 2011 improve the quality of life in our neighborhood by getting to know each other; preserving our historic heritage; maintaining the Point's CONTENTS residential character; beautifying our President's letter 3 parks, streets, and piers; and promot- ing public policies that strengthen all Kudos and Clamshells 4 of Newport's neighborhoods. Project Mural on the Point 5 Newport Pastor, Charles TimothyBrooks (1813-1883) 6 Cover: Have You Checked Your Flood Photo courtesy of Herb Armstrong Insurance Premiums Lately?? 7 A Letter to the Editor 8 Battery Park: the Last Footnote 9 Rules for the Use of our Driftways 10 AIRPA Hearing on Surplus Navy Lands: Newport Naval Hospital 13 fa un/the/ our. or Washington Street Extension (WSE) Appeal 18 ti the/ reu^e- of Ncwy Icwuifr, pEMA STAFF &Mcty'pi/ng', cwid/the/ Uu^erPcwTomus-cd/project. In/thfafa- Editor Alice Clemente MA£/\ve report on/$o-me/of£he/ faxue&that Advertising Miles Chandler may hcwe/the tyreate&t iAri£)(&ct on/ our Business Tom Goldrick Circulation Marcia Mallory Layout Donna Maytum fer C EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE OFFICERS President, Jeff Marshall 401-935-4226 /. fefer First VP, Beth Cullen 401-848-2945 Second VP, Peter Tea 401-847-5467 'Recording Secretary, Tom Kennedy 401-849-8893 Tje/Jutit down/fhe/ road/ c(/*plec&to- cwa/- Corresponding Sec'j, Shelley Kraman 401-849-0787 otKerpcu^rcjf-tcnoKu We/waA^tt'crfh^nh Treasurer, Tom Goldrick 401-849-9425 ly&&vjefp avid/ pete*- for the/ ma^ny yea^y ve^re^u^ered/to-tKe/ tttBe/ cwid/tcrtfoe/ cowa/- tKe^a/weil/Mv Meetings are generally scheduled for the first Monday chapter of their Ih/efr.
    [Show full text]