arXiv:0704.1422v1 [hep-ph] 11 Apr 2007 f L e f 2 v t 6 5 4 3 2 1 F P F C M B [A t d t u a v t r v v r c i h o e e e o o A L D L D D D h v e n o o o 0 e m a . . . c e a c . . ] r r h c a e r
a l l l 0 b . abor abor
h c l o y i i i i u u u V P M e C a i m n F w a v m i 8 o o par par par par g n C n g B - s m m m y t i i o . r w a l t u h h b c a o e b n c
c
a a l o a e r a e e e i d l r i e e l e a i r i i T C ( T T c r n t i o ur t c o n g . t m ne ( ( i r c r o l s a w 3 e a
i t t t t h at at hi
s o o 2 l 1 bus h h h g i o w u F e o t i i t r i i ni s l y ) t l e
d h v f ) ) i e e e y m m m m bi y m o y p u n i w , o s i l w 3 a or or 6 A k e e e w ,
t y u o r ni , e s p e f p , p o h A t o n e e t r e e ve e e a t i e
s n u h s e l e x i a 1 h n r t a f f 1 o i nt i nt nt nt a l v t ghi t A h 1 x s i d c t e e c , p p a i y h r e e h F 8 h t r nov t t m e , e s t h N N n o e i
e e r h g h w e r
i 0 T o o o o e . n o n e e . m a r d n S t o e r r
e e e A p a
y ’ k az az g i e n n t n 2 a i w 3 t e P n c L g 0 u c i M . m h di di di di o w e c t G l T , K s u
n .
a a u y A i 0 a i i 1
o a c d m V c
i i m n n p e t e 6 u u i n e r , r l c
s 0 h e onal onal r e h g u t r F f l
n g a a f r c r F F F F Sc 0
m t h o t e a y x i n e r n l ne a f e e e e h n n r r n t m I s 0 g as a . M o n p i a
o n i i i nt n e x i l a b m opa o l d
c u o
n r m z . n i s s s m s e i S a m va a l n 3 n t t
e m r i
gol p o e i e i i i i a r e C . r . e s ur : N a s e d e d r s t i S c c c i i I d g a g i b n g nz g e
n e u i g t s l C m
C e 1 A a r i n y h a a a e O e . r s d e d y o s di de t i ol B c h d t a
r , ve a n . v a h va a o A e a e l gy e I f y i e
t e f v w o 1 d i n N e e i r g l r n e a
e n d
m d o n o
o o , A 3 R y l l L r f a A a r F g
a e l t F o f r i nna e t ,
f uc 1 a d c v I I a b a i c C do s a o e U v G t e . m m . f n a , p r a N N l . d e a c e i e l f R l b n of s -
r e
I G s
e t as s t r r . r u S n u t d a r o
e a r o s t l e i l o e o o F F u
y i a F
A n x o o r a e od i e n V f i an C t r . 4 r i c n c o b m p t f a t o T r
n e i n p s c C a ar N N y e , i y t s f h e he a s p o - b t e . o g
i c o t a e 6 at M i u e r
l a b x o i a gnol axi e p e s , , i n o i n n t i d i r a u l 0 r s S a c t Sas e
n v t i a l r d r
y o , ol e h R n r p , e U U a o i y e h 0 @ e y e l , e u . t e g l L r
f a u e o , r n t
o n r n I
( ng n c t n o a ar h i n e e T i b ( t ni ni m a i t m N u N s n c d a k c I s a n
r t r r l e ppol 2 C d n s P e t i C l n N i e e l a i e i i o e l h m o o ,
G e i 1 F c e m o
n v v 3 s d o 1 r e f l t i n c c or n e v E o n , e d a r r h n a i l t F r , o e e d r L S a a o y N t z e i G
nt
a p s a s u l de i R e . oj i n e s c s r r ( s s l d , e - l c t m N d f i G m C e
l T s o l e o f s s B a i N di . i s c h u a f r a e r I b i a and
o t e
q a e n r i i f r . ) 2 M l n e a r . o C o .
a e b q , n a u y t t d o r
l r , t t
s F A w K 3 t i M à à o A u r ’ u c n u 1 d A c t i 4
t m r i O , M t o b v y e B o d I , i h d i r a d n s o h c )
0 a t
( i O f or i i e a R N
bs i di di n
D e
t e o i n i r e A 0 l a a t o a d a U I n e n f t G t ont s k r A a l h l U
s D d
i s o n F N U c a p y f t o a c o C o i l m M t f c
e os e t F ni a P r d t o M . l G r r t S w U w r u p . n A t o N i L
E F i L p i l w i r
i h f a i C n s o - n θ e p e o : ad a l m e e f l c e L i e A v R T
i e , N . t c r e O i n t G i l d 1 t f N V r r 9 n r 5 n l
h o n t a l a e i A f 3 p a u 6 N r t
A ano, i r h
m , o , , d L a b gon b e a e ov , . r n G s r . ni
2 b a l a R b 0
o
D r n
l / e t o t s r l s A U g y a p r 0 e i i D om a y L G 0 g s e S
n i s i s a u i b a 2
C r 0 c t c o a, s , 3 r r 5 H U a 40, t s o t e o r ni , b
t n s o . k i a c b o f - 7 f ,
f y u
n a 0 w oc l
t r o T o e o
e i u o u C 4 g
u n ) l
a o n v c d a n ’ L P v gi v u a G r u c l O F I n n t
P / r h t ,
0 h
n S i
e
l
5 t m e t o i t u t a ≈ c p . i s a m i 2 a C t I i 0 i
r m d e a A a i t . c
h h o u c r i s a 1 3 a o i - l s 0 a ( bi 0 y d s
b h de n e 2 s c s s e , n n B r 00044 C , a . s A s s d 5 M e
P e e agi o 2 e d r t o e 0
i c k s d n s o , i t n e p a e r w t m a e l
e Q
c i o a
) t r s y C e f
k à e r a t n r r o k a m C ar
1 e ne ( i l , o e
i l s i d e e f 3 r c m R p n , n t C t r or v ) l c a . , i c a r r
i q s
h di . e l s
n
a d d ,
N e f l e z t o m t N e . p a
i t u p a a l t A o i t o I u e n
a b n I ol i n h t a t d R g i o r c n
C i t r
G r q r a i o s c t t e c I P G o t r a t e o u D h f
. d s 3 al o o e u i P i 1 I ubbi n e i o
v w S r t L c a , s C
m av r d o 2 n , f a o i
0 a
a ol i a
i G l ) S s v
a o y N a v i d b p v s a n , 8, t
N n c 4 p b l A r a
m n l
. h n l i e ( o e i l
i , o f e l G k ugl d l I r
o y r l d N
e a, d o r e apol b
u v i e o - n . t a e m
a a l a I e m a S u n L u o w
A n 20123 t t o a O v p s n c - e t a h c [A s
t m a p i t s i t l l e B e s 35131 a v . 5 i r
i t a l i o v e u 3 u am l . t n o
u a n m i r o e w d v
] l y
i , i
2 n n A m d f or 4 y S b g f P f r m
e a n k l b e i e
o 0 a e o f a , u e e , m a o w u ) , t r e
- e A r n
t l
a d i
t t , e , n i a y B r a c e I
m s k h c u i t
r o . v t a
l L P i d t t h x a t “ h r e r h
o .
t r i l r h as t 1 a t p al
3 l
s d c e i e A a e h a w o m . d ,
a
a c i e s , s a r c l S e
l l a l t r G r s o e o o e p C r n b y l o s a h
p e y g L t h o
G
- p a a s n g f E h m b e i u
i a N l i T 6
i e o m r r i A n t
l a s e h r i s y l n gl l , n h o
6 . c . a n r a P a e d d i t G x a
s
n r m c i n e h . t m s m i . g , 2
C c , i s A - i b n i r x e M S e
i , C b T c a T ”
a I n e c
l a
m f c n t s f 2 e l
t s h - . f s a h a o P o g c a t o
B a t e
o a
27100 G e s s h g s e e c h r n k r p l C v l c u e
P m e l nnoc e e e
t o e . e l c e c g l o u a b a i t i n .
e p , i o
a i s r v u r
a o r t s i s r t u ga s a r b i
w e n l o m z h l i r s y h s f n
i o s b y b t S d r z a i i f t u u ol l
a i . o i n e t b t b i a
e s e e r z ow n n o b h v g l a
s n i i i g l r l i c s i l s n n n g ol d a n e e e c e e e . t s s c t t , , hi t
r
h a
i i
3 6 3 6 3 , , , , ,
2
Table of contents.
1.— General considerations...... 3 1.1. Physics introduction...... 3
1.2. Comparing present and future detectors toward"13 ...... 3
2.— The next LNGS neutrino detector...... 5 2.1. General considerations...... 5 2.2. A modular approach of the LAr-TPC de! tector...... 6 2.3. Double phase LAr-TPC signal collection? ...... 6 2.4. A simplified structure for the modular detectors...... 8 2.5. The new experimental area...... 11 2.6. Initial filling procedures for the chamber...... 13 2.7. LAr purification...... 13 2.8. Photo-multipliers for light collection...... 14 2.9. Electronic readout and trigger...... 14 2.10. R&D developments...... 15
3.— The new low energy, off-axis neutrino beam (LNGS-B)...... 17 3.1. The present high energy CNGS beam configuration...... 18 3.2. A new, low energy focussing layout...... 18 3.3. Comparing the CNGS and NOvA neutrino beams...... 19 3.4. Detection efficiency for νe CC events and NC background rejection...... 21 3.5. Comparisons with NOvA...... 23
3.6. Evaluation of the beam associated " e background...... 24 3.7. Comparing the ultimate sensitivities to and 2 ...... 24 "CP sin (2"13)
4.— Tentative layout of LNGS!- B...... 26 5.— Conclusions...... !...... !...... 28
6.— References ...... 30
7.— Appendix. General comments on the use of Perlite...... 32
3
1.— General considerations. 1.1. Physics introduction. The understanding of neutrino has recently advanced remarkably with the observation that they have masses and that oscillate between each other. Oscillations arise in analogy to the CKM matrix for hadrons since the neutrino species " e," µ ,"# do not have specific masses, but are a combination of the mass eigenstates 1, 2, 3. Two of these oscillations, namely "12 related to and related to have been experimentally observed by " e # (" µ ,"$ ) "23 µ SK1. A third oscillation type characterized by " , occurring around "m2 has not been ! 13 23 observed. The observation of a non-zero value of will open the way to the ordering of the "13 ! neutrino masses and a determination of the CP violation phase " in neutrino oscillations. CP ! ! violation in the lepton sector will be! necessary in order t!o understand why matter is dominating over anti-matter in the Unive!r se. The very small but finite values of the neutrino masses require the existence of right-handed neutrino! s pecies and more generally neutrinos appear to be related to physics at an extremely high energy scale, beyond studies with accelerator beams. It is also possible that in addition to the indicated three types of neutrino species, other species could exist, oscillated by the " e," µ ,"# . There is unconfirmed evidence for the existence of this type of “sterile” neutrinos from the LNSD experiment [1] at Los Alamos National Laboratory. A search for evidence for sterile neutrinos is being pursued by MiniBooNE [2] at FNAL and ICARUS-600T [3] at LNGS. !
1.2. Comparing present and future detectors toward"13 . First generation long baseline neutrino experiments are currently operational at K2K [4] over a baseline of 295 km, at FNAL and at CNGS with baselines of about 730 km. These developments should be further exploited! in Japan and presumably also in the USA and Europe with some second generation experiments of much higher sensitivity, to become operational around 2010-2015. This requires major improvements both in the beam and in the detector mass and performance. The present detectors at FNAL (MINOS) [5] and CNGS2 (ICARUS) [3] are respectively a Iron-Scintillator sandwich of 2.5 cm iron and 4.1 cm wide scintillator strips with 5.4 kt total, 3.2 kt fiducial (MINOS, two modules) and a liquid Argon detector of a slightly lower mass of about 600 t of sensitive volume (ICARUS). It is important to underline that in practice these two detectors have roughly comparable discovery potential in many channels because of the much higher resolution capabilities of LAr-TPC when compared with Fe-scintillation sandwich. The main beam requirement is the average target power of the incoming proton beam (POT) that are
1 The experiment OPERA-CNGS1 is intended to observe explicitly the appearance (M. Guler et al., [OPERA Coll.], CERN/SPSC 2000-028, SPSC/P318, LNGS P25/2000).