Report to the Future Melbourne Planning Committee Agenda Item 6.5
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Page 1 of 45 Report to the Future Melbourne Planning Committee Agenda item 6.5 Ministerial Planning Referral: TPM-2014-8 2 September 2014 85 Spring Street, Melbourne Presenter: Karen Snyders, Planning Coordinator Purpose and background 1. The purpose of this report is to advise the Future Melbourne Committee of a Ministerial Planning Application (reference 2014/000435) at 85 Spring Street, Melbourne. The planning application was initially referred by the Department of Transport, Planning and Local Infrastructure (DTPLI) on 11 February 2014 and later amended on 5 March 2014. An amended application/response to the DTPLI further information request was received on 27 June 2014 and a further amended application/response to preliminary comments was received on 6 August 2014. 2. The applicant is Grocon Pty Ltd, the owner is Kador Group Holdings P/L and the architect is Denton Corker Marshall. 3. The site is ‘L’ shaped and has frontages to both Spring and Little Collins Streets. The application seeks approval for the development of a residential tower of 46 levels (303 apartments) with two basement levels. The tower includes nine levels of car parking and two retail tenancies at ground floor level (one to Spring Street and one to Little Collins Street). Access to the car park is from Coates Lane (existing) and access to the apartments is proposed from both Spring and Little Collins Streets. The building has an eight storey (31.58 metres) podium to Little Collins Street. To Spring Street the building extends beyond its title boundary, over the entry to Parliament Station. The overall building height is a maximum of approximately 169.58 metres to the top of an architectural feature to Spring Street. 4. The total gross floor area is 46,941 square metres. Key issues 5. Key considerations with respect to this proposal are design and built form, residential amenity, impact on development potential of adjoining properties and matters relating to vehicle access. 6. The application site is not subject to any height controls. The land to the south is occupied by low rise heritage buildings. The site also adjoins multi-storey buildings at 27 Little Collins Street (Sheraton Hotel) and apartments and 99 Spring Street (mixed use building which includes apartments). 7. The proposed building is in part built to the site boundaries but also incorporates some setbacks. The setbacks are however considered inadequate and result in a building which will overwhelm the pedestrian as well as adversely impact on the amenity of surrounding lanes. Inadequate (including zero) boundary setbacks will also adversely affect the amenity of existing adjoining and proposed apartments which would necessitate the use of partially obscure glazing, further reducing the amenity of proposed apartments. The proposed building height is considered excessive in relation to the low rise heritage buildings to the south, combined with inadequate setbacks from these buildings which fails to adequately respect their development potential. There are also concerns about the potential for conflict between entering and exiting vehicles as well as impact on loading and access associated with the adjoining building at 27 Little Collins Street. 8. The changes to the development required to render it consistent with requirements of the Melbourne Planning Scheme are considered so significant that they cannot be addressed by conditions. Recommendation from management 9. That the Future Melbourne Committee resolves that a letter be sent to the Department of Transport, Planning and Local Infrastructure advising that the Melbourne City Council objects to the application for the reasons set out in the attached delegate report. Attachments: 1. Supporting Attachment 2. Locality Plan 3. Selected proposed plans 4. Delegate Report Page 2 of 45 Attachment 1 Agenda item 6.5 Future Melbourne Committee 2 September 2014 Supporting Attachment Legal 1. The Minister for Planning is the responsible authority for determining the application. Finance 2. There are no direct financial issues arising from the recommendations contained in this report. Conflict of Interest 3. No member of Council staff, or other person engaged under a contract, involved in advising on or preparing this report has declared a direct or indirect interest in relation to the matter of the report. Stakeholder consultation 4. Council officers have not advertised the application or referred it to any referral authorities. This is the responsibility of the DTPLI acting on behalf of the Minister for Planning who is the responsible authority. Relation to Council policy 5. Relevant Council policies are discussed in the attached delegate report (refer Attachment 4). Environmental sustainability 6. An ESD report forms part of the application submission. It includes the statement that the residential component of the development has the potential to achieve a 5 star Green Star rating. This is consistent with Clause 22.19 of the Melbourne Planning Scheme. The report does not address the matters of the water efficiency of the retail premises. 1 Page 3 of 45 Attachment 2 Agenda item 6.5 Locality Plan Future Melbourne Committee 2 September 2014 TPM 2014-8, 85 SPRING STREET, MELBOURNE Page 4 of 45 o <c o CO • 18 LITTLE COLLINS STREET THE HOTEL WINDSOR CANOPY OVER ENTRY APARTMENT : RETAIL SHOPFRONT ADDRESS ACTIVATION LITTLE COLLINS STREET EXISTING CAFE CANOPY OVER GLAZED FRONT TO CAR LIFTS COATES LANE <n WIDENED TO ALLOW O TWO WAY TRAFFIC a. in LOADING DOCK HEIGHT 5m CLEAR CANOPY ABOVE STATION ENTRY FOR RAIN PROTECTION EXISTING STAIRS TO PARLIAMENT STATION LIFT ACCESS TO BASEMENT BICYCLE BUILDING OVER + MOTORCYCLE PARKING < PROPOSED FOOTPATH EXTENSION BLUESTONE PAVING EXISTING PAVING ALIGNMENT NEW GLAZED BALUSTRADE CARPARK ENTRY 1BEO 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SKJOI REV 15 DENTON 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES / 1:300@A3 CORKER GROCON GROUND FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR STACKERS RETAIL GYM I POOL PLANT AMENITIES » 5_ 6 9M MARSHALL Page 5 of 45 \SKJ2)/ © © © © © © © © 3450 6375 6950 9550 7920 8185 7470 001 2 BEDROOM- INT 96 m2 EXT2mJ 27 LITTLE COLLINS STREET PODIUM CANOPY FACADE LEGEND 25% VISION FRITTED GLASS SPANDREL GLASS •= PRECAST PANEL FACADE 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SKJ03 REV 10 DENTON 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES / 1:250@A3 CORKER GROCON LEVEL 01 t R3 FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR••••• STACKERS RETAIL •GYM/POOL PLANT AMENITIES 0 %l 5_ MARSHALL Page 6 of 45 © © © © © © © © 3450 6375 6950 9550 7920 8185 7470 003 2 BEDROOM-n INT94m! EXT3m! 99 SPRING STREET 27 LITTLE COLLINS STREET 001 3 BEDROOM INT 149 mJ EXT31mJ 002 2 BEDROOM INT 105 nf EXT32mJ FACADE LEGEND 25% VISION FRITTED GLASS SPANDREL GLASS = PRECAST PANEL FACADE 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SK_105 REV 12 DENTON 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES / 1:250@A3 rT\ CORKER GROCON LEVEL 02 • R5 FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR STACKERS RETAIL GYM/POOL PLANT AMENITIES 0 25 5 L5M KJJ MARSHALL Page 7 of 45 0 0 © © © © © 3450 6375 6950 9550 7920 8185 7470 -7e- -?<- ALUMINIUM FRAME + INFILL CLADDING TO ROOF 99 SPRINGS 27 LITTLE COLLINS STREET NON ACCESIBLE ROOF © 80 -3 BEDROOM 79 -2 BEDROOM 85 82 1 BEDROOM 2 BEDROOM INT60nf INT 78 m! FACADE LEGEND 25% VISION FRITTED GLASS 12 COLLINS STREET 8 COLLINS STREET 4 COLLINS STREET 2 COLLINS STREET SPANDREL GLASS ' PRECAST PANEL FACADE 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SK 109 REV 17 DENTON 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES/ 1:250@A3 CORKER GROCON LEVEL 06-25 FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR STACKERS RETAIL GYM/POOL PLANT AMENITIES 0 25 1 0 MARSHALL Page 8 of 45 27 LITTLE COLLINS STREET FACADE LEGEND 25% VISION FRITTED GLASS SPANDREL GLASS == PRECAST PANEL FACADE 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SK_265 REV 4 DENTON LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES / 1:250® A3 CORKER GROCON LEVEL 26 FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR STACKERS RETAIL GYM/POOL PLANT AMENITIES o »_ (D MARSHALL Page 9 of 45 © © © 0 0 6375 0 6950 9550 7920 8185 '470 © 206 3 BEDROOM INT 161 m2 EXT 11m2 210 •2 BEDROOM INT 115 m2 EXT 11m2 FACADE LEGEND 25% VISION FRITTED GLASS SPANDREL GLASS <= PRECAST PANEL FACADE 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SK_210 REV 5 DENTON 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES/ 1:250 @ A3 CORKER GROCON LEVEL 31 FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR STACKERS RETAIL PLANT AMENITIES o 25 _L5M MARSHALL Page 10 of 45 © ® © © © © © © 3450 6375 6950 9550 7920 8185 7470 1©tT 004 005 -3 BEDROOM 2 BEDROOM- INT 133 m2 INT 129m2 EXT 7 m2 EXT 7 m2 ©v 8 EXT13mJ a © >- CD X m X o 0^. i 001 —y( . i 3 BEDROOM 8 X X INT 131 m2 EXT 11m2 ©^^ EXT23mJ 002 --© 3 BEDROOM INT 155 m2 003 EXT 11m2 2 BEDROOM INT 101 m2 EXT 5 m2 4 4© FACADE LEGEND EXT 7 m2 25% VISION FRITTED GLASS SPANDREL GLASS i i PRECAST PANEL FACADE 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED 85 SPRING STREET PLANNING APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SK 270 REV 2 DENTON LEGEND 25/07/2014 MELBOURNE SERVICES / 1:250@A3 CORKER GROCON LEVEL 36 FLOOR PLAN CIRCULATION CORE CAR STACKERS RETAIL PLANT AMENITIES 0 25 5 75M \ 1 J MARSHALL Page 11 of 45 0 0 © © © © © © 3450 6375 6950 9550 7920 8185 470 -><- © 4® 1 BED 2 BED 3 BED 4 BED APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT APARTMENT BALCONY 7459 SK_273 REV1