Permit Appeal Number P15781 Hotel Windsor
Permit Appeal Number P15781 Hotel Windsor (H0764) 103-137 Spring Street and 1-17 Bourke Street, Melbourne Heritage Council Permits Committee Hearing – Friday, 27 August 2010 and Friday, 10 September 2010 Members – Ms Marita Foley (Chair), Mr Robert Sands, Ms Helen Martin Decision of the Heritage Council After considering the appeal in relation to conditions 1(a) and 1(b) of permit P14689 and conducting a hearing, the Heritage Council determines, pursuant to Section 76(4)(c) of the Heritage Act 1995, to vary the conditions to read as follows: Condition 1(a) – Reduce the height of the Corner Building to RL55.76, being the parapet height of the existing Annexe building where it abuts the northern tower of the Hotel Windsor. Condition 1(b) – Reduce the height of the rooftop additions (known as the ‘Stick’) to 5.65 metres above the height of the Corner Building, or other level as approved by the Executive Director in writing. Ms Marita Foley Mr Robert Sands Ms Helen Martin (Chair) Decision Date – 8 November 2010 1 APPEARANCES Executive Director, Heritage Victoria Mr Christopher Townshend SC, instructed by Department of Planning and Community Development Legal, appeared for the Executive Director. Mr Townshend called Mr Jim Gard’ner, Executive Director of Heritage Victoria, and Mr Matt Ainsaar, Town Planner and Land Economist from Urban Enterprise, to give expert evidence. Appellant Mr Stuart Morris QC, instructed by Norton Rose, appeared for the Halim Group (operator and occupier of the Hotel Windsor) and Hotel Windsor Holdings Pty Ltd (registered proprietor of the Hotel Windsor). Mr Morris called the following people to give expert evidence: Mr Ian White, Architect, of Denton Corker Marshall Pty Ltd Mr Peter Lovell, Heritage Consultant, of Lovell Chen Architects and Heritage Consultants Mr Glenn Coupar, Development Manager of the Halim Group Mr David Perry, Chief Executive Officer and General Manager, of the Hotel Windsor City of Melbourne Mr Matthew Townsend, Barrister, appeared for the City of Melbourne.
[Show full text]