Black Law Windfarm Which Comprises 54 Operational Turbines, Only Two of Which Are Located Within the North Lanarkshire Area
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AGENDA ITEM Ma. ..*.-'k...).. Application No: Proposed bevelopment: 11/00544/CNS Black Law Wind Farm Extension Phase 2 (Erection of 11 Turtdnes 80m to hub and 126.5m to blade tip) and assodated infrastructure. Site Address: Black Law W indfarm Allanton MEQPJ Date Registered: 12th May 201 1 Applicant: Agent: Scottish Power Renewables NIA Cathcart Business Park Spean Street Glasgow (344 4BE Appllcatlon Level: Contrary to Development Plan: Other Application Level No Ward: Repremntatlone: 01 2 Fortissat 334 letters of representation received. Charles Cefferty, Thomas Cochrane, James Robe ttson , Recommendation: Object for the Following Reaeone:- 1. The proposed development is contrary to policies DSP4, NEE 38, EDI 3A of the North Lanarkshire Local Plan, supplementary planning guidance SPG 12 "Assessing Wind Turbine Developments" and Scottish Planning Policy In that the submitted ES, Addendum and additional supporting information have not sufficiently addressed the potential cumulative noise impact of the proposed windfarm. In addition, given the proximity of the turbines to the settlements; adverse visual impact on selected recepton and furVler erosion of recreational space there are concerns that this extension (in addition to the already approved schemes) is such that the amenity enjoyed by local residents will be reduced to an unacceptable level. Margaret Mitcheli MSP, Neii Findlay MSP, Siobhan McMahon, Parneta Nash MP, 15 Outwith the piEtn 8FBa Prcrdumd bv Ptrnn In$ and DevalWm &fit N Emironmrntil Srrvi No rM LJnrkthlrr C Fleming How* 2 TwtRbad Cumb*;mituM **me nunbar'10m= 467 IJW I Black LwWindfarm, Allanton, ML2 9PJ A; Bckaround Patlers: Representation cetters Letter from MS Liza Dick, Hartfield Farm, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John Ward, 153 Mill Road , Allanton, ML7 5DD received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Lynne Walker, 21 Wilson Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter froin Mr Malcolm McMillan, 258 Allanton Road, Allanton , Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Sophia Gibson, 257 Allanton Road, Shotts, ML7 5AQ received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Robert McCafferty, 220 Allanton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Margaret McLean, 222 Alianton Road, Ailanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr David Muir, 58 Hartfield Terrace, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from MS Suzanne Graham, 48 Hartfield Terrace, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Brian Graham, 48 Hartfield Terrace, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Alice Muir, 58 Hartfield Terrace, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Christina Saunders, 17 Kingshill Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Jaqueline Anne Magee, 57 Wilson Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Oevid Stapleton, 16 Newarkgate, ML7 5FB, received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Daniel McArdle, 2 Newark Gate, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ann McArdle, 2 Newark Gate, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 t Letter from Mr John Elder, 50 Haitfield Terrace, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John felfer Pollock, 9 Darmeid Place, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201t Letter from Mr lain Young, 23 Darmeid Ptace, Alianton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 tettar from Ms Agnes Farnell, 21 Dameid Place, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Grace Paterson, 19 Darmeid Place, Allanton, Shotts recetved 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Anne O'Hare, 218 Allanton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Douglas Clad(, 9 Dura Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr James OHare, 218 Alianton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from M Clark, 9 Dura Road, Ailanton, ML7 5AB received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Graeme Bruce, 5 Hawthorn Place, ML7 !SA, received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Helen McClair, 67 Eastwood Drive, Newmains, ML2 9NW received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John Roberts, 8 Kirk Path, Allanton, ML7 5BB received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Anm Roberts, 8 Kirk Path, Allanton, ML7 5BB received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr George Dick, 40 Dura Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr MaimSaunders, 17 Kingshill Road, Atfanton, Shotts received 14th June 2011 Letter from Mr Johnathan Roberts, 8 Kirk Path, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Leanne Roberts, 5 Hawthorn Place, Allanton, Shotts received i4th June 2011 Letter from Mrs Lillian Begley, 25 Coltness Avenue, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 20f 1 Letter from Mr David Reid, 29 Redmire Crescent, Alfartton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Sheile Henderson, 3 Hartwood Gardens, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from D McLean, 10 Kingshill Road, ML7 5AL, received 14th June 207 1 Letter from Ms Anne Brown, 213 Alianton Road, Allanton , Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Afex H Brown, 213 Allanton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John McLean, 222 Alianton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Alexander Brown, 213 Allanton Road, Allanton, ML7 5AQ received 14th June 201 I Letter from hts Emma Murphy, 266 Allanton Road, Allanton, Shatts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Mark Murphy, 266 Allanton Road, Allanton, ML? 5AQ received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Marion Stewart, 2 Redmire Crescent, Atlanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Mary Nelson, 9 Springhead Road, Allanton, Shotts received l4tb June 201 1 Letter from Ms Yvonne Crumley, 2 Hartfield Crescent, Atranton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mrs Hslen Duncan, 202 Allanton Road, Allanton, Shoffs received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Abigail Nicol, 208 Allanton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 20-l1 Letter from Ms. A Forrest, 29 Springhead Road, Alianton, Shotts received 14th June 201 I Letter from W Herkes, 18 Kingshill Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John McAteer, 17 Hawisworth Crescent, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Mary Bryce, 31 Springhead Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms E Appleton, 1 Hartwood Garddens, Hartwood, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Archibald McAlpine, 49 Mut-ray Crescent, Mewmains, Wishaw received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Robert Thomson, 279 Ailanton Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Scatt McAlpine, 49 Murray Crescent, Newmains, Wishaw received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms With McAlpine, 49 Murray Crescent, Newmains, Wishaw received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John Smith, 14 Cathburn Road, Morningside, Newmains received 14th June 201 I Letter from Mr Davld Robertson, 4 Redpath Drive, Stenhousernuir, received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr James Weir, 19 Springhead Road, Allanton, ML5 7AW received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Kelly Thomson, 8 Park Road, Dykehead, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr lan MacKenzie, 5 Auchhetburn Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter fmm Mrs Anne MacKenzie, 5 Auchterbum Road, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr John Williamson, 4 Newark Gardens, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 1 Letter from E Williamson, 4 Newark Gate, Allanton, Mt7 5FB received 14th June 201 t Letter from Ms Elaine Smith, 32 Coltness Road, Shotts, ML7 5L6 received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Joe Smith, 32 Coltness Avenue, Shotts, ML7 5FB received 14th June 201 1 Letter from The Scottish Government, 4th Floor ,5Atlantic Quay, 150 Broomielaw received 12th July 201 1 Letter from Ms Cafoline Stapleton, 16 Newark Gate, Allanton, Shotts received 14th June 201 I Letter from Mr Calum Strachan, 50 Hart Street, Unwood, PA3 3EB received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Graham Allan, 22 KirktonfieldCr, Nellston, G78 3PX received 14th June 201 1 Letter from K Gonnan, 31 Balfour Terrace, East Kilbride, G75 OJU received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Simon Stewart, 26 Stuart Street, Forres, LV36 1HR received 14th June 201 1 Letter fmm Mr Mathew Ken, 72 Avonbank Crescent, ML3 7PD, received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Alan Bar, 14 Dungavel Gardens, Hamilton, MU?PE received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Pete Mutray, 159114 Slateford Road, Edinburgh, EH14 1PB received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Alan Macbain, 33 Maple Avenue, Newton Meams, G77 55Q received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Angela Canale, 29 Irvine Crescent, Coatbridge, ML5 3QF received 14th June 201 1 Letter from P Buchanan, 73 PyothaIl Road, Broxburn, EH52 6HW received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Ms Susan Farrefl, Flat 21 , 32 Midlock Street, Glasgow received 14th June 201 I Letter from Calais Brown, 57 Aller Place, Livingstone, EH54 6RF received 14th June 20t 1 Letter from A Mitchell, Flat lilt4 Reid Avenue, Linwood received 14th June 201 I Letter from Mr James Branscombe, Flat 211,32 Midlock Street, lbrox received 14th June 201 1 Letter from SP McLeod, 2B Brisbane Street, Livingstone, received 14th June 201 1 Letter from W Jenkins, 3A Manse Grove, EH47 8EN, received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Kari Sorensen, 8/3 Uppergrove Place, Edinburgh, EH3 &AY received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Glyn Martin, 3 Manse Grove, Stoneyburn, EH47 8EW received 14th June 201 1 Letter from A Buchman, 73 Pyothaij Road, Broxburn, West Lothian received 14th June 201 1 Letter from Mr Brian Woodbum, 8A Pilrig