District Plan Change 32
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Abbott Allan Submitter Number: 349 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind power is a good idea in appropriate places. City hills are inappropriate. Makara is an important recreation area. Solar and other renewable options should be investigated. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Aberhart Rachel Submitter Number: 275 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind power is a good idea in appropriate places. City hills are inappropriate. Makara is an important recreation area. Solar and other renewable options should be investigated. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Adrian Natalie Submitter Number: 435 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Not appropriate on Wellington's rural hills and coast. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Agnew William Submitter Number: 311 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: It is not acceptable that these rules should override all other rules in the District Plan. Do not cover the rural hills of Wellington in wind turbines. Wind turbines are inappropriate on Quartz/ Makara hills. These rules are not satisfactory. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Page 1 Airways Corporation of Submitter Number: 209 New Zealand Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: amend Specific Provisions: Rule 26.3.1 Submission: Plan change 32 is supported in so far that it responds to the need for greater energy efficiency and the need to promote the generation of energy from renewable sources. Concerns do however exist over the proposed impact that any proposed wind energy development could have on the existing Hawkins Hill radar station or any future radar/ navigational aid sites. The potential problems radar may suffer are 1) structures may pose an obstruction to the radar signal path along aircraft routes 2)The rotating blades of the turbines could be picked up by primary radar and seen as false targets. The above need to be considered on a case by case basis as distance from radar elevation with respect to radar and orientation of turbines may each have an impact. Decision Requested: Amend to include a new subject matter: "The effects of any proposal on the operation of the Airways Hawkins Hill radar station and any other relevant navigational sites and facilities and the safe and efficient operation of the air transport network be fully assessed and avoided , remedied or mitigated". Allen Lyn Submitter Number: 227 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind turbines will spoil the rural area of Wellington. Makara is a special area. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Allen Anthony Submitter Number: 592 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Windmills should not be in Makara, Makara is a special area. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Andrews G Submitter Number: 360 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind power is a good idea in appropriate places. City hills are inappropriate. Makara is an important recreation area. Solar and other renewable options should be investigated. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Page 2 Angus Felicity Submitter Number: 299 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind power is a good idea in appropriate places. City hills are inappropriate. Makara is an important recreation area. Solar and other renewable options should be investigated. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Anslow Malcolm Submitter Number: 235 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: I oppose the Renewable Energy Rules, Chapter 26. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Anslow Tania Submitter Number: 237 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: I oppose the Renewable Energy Rules, Chapter 26. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Armstrong Victor Submitter Number: 449 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind turbines over the City's rural hills will not be in the best interest of the City. Hundreds of massive turbines will be needed to generate any significant power. Put turbines in other areas of Wellington region e.g. Wairarapa where there are no people or important rural/ coastal recreation area. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Arnold Brian Submitter Number: 422 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Do not put wind turbines on hills of Wellington they are noisy and visually intrusive. There could be health problems. Decision Requested: Withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Page 3 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Do not put wind turbines on hills of Wellington they are noisy and visually intrusive. There could be health problems. Decision Requested: Withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Askin Elizabeth Submitter Number: 604 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: We should learn from overseas mistakes, and not do this in the wrong places. There are other choices solar is good. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Atkins D M Submitter Number: 431 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind power is a good idea in appropriate places. City hills are inappropriate. Makara is an important recreation area. Solar and other renewable options should be investigated. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Baguley Christopher Submitter Number: 136 Gordon Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Quartz hill is not an appropriate site for wind turbines. Wind turbines may be sited in many locations away from people. Solar power has been poorly considered in New Zealand, yet is able to produce vast amounts of energy. Evidence from overseas has shown the huge negative impact resulting from the thoughtless positioning of wind turbines. Placing wind turbines in Makara will be irreplaceable. Noise pollution is becoming one of the biggest forms of pollution. My partner is deaf and susceptible to low frequency noise. We chose a quiet suburb to reduce discomfort from low frequency noises. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Page 4 Bailey Spencer Submitter Number: 444 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Makara has a unspoiled and natural character and is steeped in history especially Quartz Hill. It is not an appropriate site for a wind farm as noise and visual pollution will result. Property values and saleability will be eroded. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Baird Barbara Submitter Number: 346 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: Wind power is a good idea in appropriate places. City hills are inappropriate. Makara is an important recreation area. Solar and other renewable options should be investigated. Decision Requested: Decline and withdraw Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules. Baker Suzanne Submitter Number: 251 Submission Number: 1 Plan Section Name: Chapter 26 Renewable Energy Rules Support/Oppose: oppose Specific Provisions: Chapter 26 - General Submissions Submission: These rules should not override the Rural or Open Space B rules. The renewable energy rules should not allow any