Durham Research Online
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Durham Research Online Deposited in DRO: 09 December 2008 Version of attached le: Published Version Peer-review status of attached le: Peer-reviewed Citation for published item: Gaydarska, B. (2007) 'Landscape, material culture and society in South East Bulgaria.', Oxford: Archaeopress. Further information on publisher's website: http://www.archaeopress.com/searchBar.asp?sql=%5BSeries+ID%5D+%3D+2+AND+%5BPublished+Date%5D+%3E+%2331+Mar+2007%23 Publisher's copyright statement: Additional information: In addition to the full-text of the report, DRO contains a zipped archive of ArcView 3.2 les. Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in DRO • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full DRO policy for further details. Durham University Library, Stockton Road, Durham DH1 3LY, United Kingdom Tel : +44 (0)191 334 3042 | Fax : +44 (0)191 334 2971 https://dro.dur.ac.uk Landscape, Material Culture and Society in South East Bulgaria Bisserka Ivanova Gaydarska Contents List Volume I Contents List i List of Tables xv List of Figures xvii Abstract xviii Acknowledgements xix Chapter One: Setting the scene 1.1 The study area 1 1.2 Aims and objectives 3 1.3 Methodological framework 4 1.4 Summary of thesis by chapters 5 Chapter Two: History of recent investigations 2.1 General stages in Bulgarian prehistoric research 7 2.2 General interpretative trends in Bulgarian prehistory 9 2.3 History of GIS research 15 Chapter Three: Theoretical and Methodological Background 3.1 Landscape archaeology 17 3.2 Society and Material culture 23 3.3 Microregional studies 32 3.4. GIS Methodology 42 Chapter Four: Palaeo-environmental reconstructions Introduction 43 4.1. Geological data 43 4.2. Geomorphological data and soils 48 4.3. Climate and Vegetation according to modern and palaeo-botanical data 69 i Chapter Five: The Sokolitsa Microregion 5.1 Tell Galabovo 71 5.2. Obrutchishte flat site 90 5.3 Atanasivanova mogila (barrow) site 92 5.4 Mednikarovo tell 94 5.5 Karaivanovi mogili barrow cemetery (KMBC) 98 5.6 Iskritsa flat site 100 5.7 Klisselika tell 104 5.8. Gudgova tell 107 5.9 Polski Gradets tell 113 5.10 Polski Gradets pit site 116 Chapter Six: The Ovcharitsa Microregion 6.1 Gonova mogila (barrow) 119 6.2 Ovcharitsa I flat site 120 6.3 The Ovcharitsa II site 122 6.4 Aldinova mogila 127 6.5 Ovchartsi barrow 129 6.6 Barrow four 131 6.7 Goliamata mogila (the big barrow) 133 6.8 Malkata mogila (the small barrow) 138 6.9 Goliama Detelina flat site 139 6.10 Tcherniova mogila 142 6.11 Manchova mogila 144 6.12 Taniokoleva mogila 147 6.13 Kurdova mogila 148 6.14. Mednikarovo-Iskritsa barrow cemetery (MIBC) 150 Chapter Seven: The Drama microregion 7.1 Gerena flat site 155 7.2 Merdzumekja tell 157 7.3. Kajrjaka flat site 163 ii Chapter Eight: Landscape, Material Culture and Society in the Sokolitsa, Ovcharitsa and Drama micro-regions – a comparison and synthesis 8.1 Material Culture and Society 167 8.2 Landscapes and settlement patterns 172 8.3 Long-term trends of prehistoric life in South East Bulgaria 177 Conclusion 181 Bibliography 183 Appendix A: Description of routes 197 Appendix B: Illustrations 211 AFig. 5.1.1 General plan of Galabovo tell and profiles in E4, D4 213 AFig. 5.1.2 Profiles in B4/C4 and profiles in O5/O6, O7, N5/N6 214 AFig. 5.1.3 Houses from LCA horizon I and II and a pit from LCA horizon III 215 AFig. 5.1.4 Pottery from LCA horizons I - III 216 AFig. 5.1.5 Houses from BA horizon X and key for Galabovo illustrations 217 AFig. 5.1.6 House in J3-5/K3-5/L3-5 from BA horizon XI and the pottery depot 218 AFig. 5.1.7 House in M4/5-L4/5 from BA horizon XII and pottery from the house 219 AFig. 5.1.8 Artefacts from house in M4/5-L4/5 from BA horizon XII 220 AFig. 5.1.9 House in J5/6-L5/6 from BA horizon XII and artefacts from the house 221 AFig. 5.1.10 Feature plans from BA horizon XIII; pottery from BA horizon XIII 222 AFig. 5.4.1 General plans and profiles from Mednikarovo tell 223 AFig. 5.4.2 Pottery from Mednikarovo tell 224 AFig. 5.4.3 Pottery from Mednikarovo tell 225 AFig. 5.6.1 General plan of Iskritsa flat site; pottery from Iskritsa dwelling site 226 AFig. 5.6.2 Profiles from Iskritsa dwelling site; plan of Iskritsa pit site 227 AFig. 5.6.3 Pottery and flints tools from Iskritsa pit site 228 AFig. 5.6.4 ECA pottery from Iskritsa dwelling site 229 AFig. 5.6.5 Pottery from Iskritsa dwelling site 230 AFig. 5.7.1 General plan of tell Klisselika; pottery from the tell 231 AFig. 5.7.2 Pottery from tell Klisselika 232 AFig. 5.7.3 Pottery from tell Klisselika 233 AFig. 5.8.1 General profile and house plans, Gudgova tell 234 AFig. 5.8.2 Plans and profile from Gudgova tell 235 AFig. 5.8.3 LCA and EBA vessels from Gudgova tell 236 AFig. 5.8.4 BA vessels and sherds from Gudgova tell 237 AFig. 5.8.5 Figurines and cult objects from Gudgova tell 238 AFig. 5.10.3 Pottery from Polski Gradets pit site and Polski Gradets tell 239 AFig. 6.1.1 Plan of Gonova mogila; grave 2, the obsidian blade from grave 1 240 AFig. 6.2.1 Pottery and artefacts from Ovcharitsa I flat site 241 AFig. 6.3.1 General location of Ovcharitsa II enclosure; pottery from the site 242 AFig. 6.3.2 Plan of the EBA enclosure and the LBA cemetery in Ovcharitsa II site 243 AFig. 6.3.3 Profiles of the ditch and the stone wall from Ovcharitsa II 244 AFig. 6.3.4 Profile and plan of the “chain dwellings” at Ovcharitsa II 245 iii AFig. 6.3.5 Pottery and artefacts from Ovcharitsa II enclosure 246 AFig. 6.3.6 Flint artefacts from Ovcharitsa II enclosure 247 AFig. 6.3.7 Various artefacts from Ovcharitsa II enclosure 248 AFig. 6.3.8 Pottery from Ovcharitsa II enclosure 249 AFig. 6.4.1 Plans of barrows 250 AFig. 6.6.1 Plan of Barrow Four, pottery from the features 251 AFig. 6.7.1 General plans and profiles of Goliamata Mogila 252 AFig. 6.7.2 Grave goods from Goliamata Mogila 253 AFig. 6.8.1 Plan, grave goods and grave 5 of Malkata mogila 254 AFig. 6.9.1 General plan of Goliama Detelina flat site, pottery from the site 255 AFig. 6.9.2 Various artefacts from Goliama Detelina flat site 256 AFig. 6.11.1 Plan and grave goods, Manchova mogila 257 AFig. 6.14.1 General plan of MIBC; MIBC1 grave 1 258 AFig. 6.14.2 Plans of MIBC 259 AFig. 6.14.3 Grave 2 from MIBC3, Grave 2 from MIBC1, silver beads from grave 1 from MIBC4 260 AFig. 6.14.4 MIBC2 graves 1-2; MIBC4 graves 1-2 261 AFig. 6.14.5 MIBC3 graves 1-2 and content of pit N2 262 Appendix C: Principal Component Analysis 263 ATable 4.3.1 Calibrated C14 dates, location and depth for pollen coring sites 265 ATable 4.3.2 Raw pollen data by (coded) coring site and assemblage 266 ATable 4.3.3 Mean and standard deviation of principal botanical species 267 ATable 4.3.4 Correlation Matrix 268 ATable 4.3.5 PCA extraction by main botanical species 269 ATable 4.3.6 Cumulative and total variance by components 269 ATable 4.3.7 Matrix of component scores 270 ATable 4.3.8 Rotated (Varimax) component matrix 270 ATable 4.3.9 Component transformation matrix 271 ATable 4.3.10 Evaluation of Willis’ main claims for Bulgarian vegetational history 271 AFig. 4.3.1 Eigenvalues by component 267 AFig. 4.3.2 Component Plot in Rotated 3-dimensional Space 273 AFig. 4.3.3 Component Plot in Rotated Space – Components 1 and 2 273 AFig. 4.3.4 Component Plot in Rotated Space – Components 3 and 4 274 AFig. 4.3.5 Component Plot in Rotated Space – Components 5 and 6 274 AFig. 4.3.6 Pollen assemblages by principal components 1 and 2 275 AFig. 4.3.7 Pollen assemblages by principal components 1 and 3 275 AFig. 4.3.8 Pollen assemblages by principal components 2 and 3 276 AFig. 4.3.9 Pollen assemblages by principal components 1 and 4 276 AFig. 4.3.10 Pollen assemblages by principal components 5 and 6 277 Appendix D: GIS Analysis279 Instructions for the use of the CD-ROM 279 iv List of Figures on CD-ROM Figure Name Figure Content File Name CDFig.1 Galabovo tell slope g4 CDFig.2 Galabovo tell aspect g2 CDFig.3 Galabovo tell visibility g3 CDFig.4 Galabovo tell elevation g1 CDFig.5 Galabovo tell visibility +8m g5 CDFig.6 Galabovo tell cost surface g6 CDFig.7 Galabovo tell logistical network g7 CDFig.8 Path Galabovo tell – Gudgova tell g8 CDFig.9 Path Galabovo tell – Atanasivanova mogila g9 CDFig.10 Path Galabovo tell – Iskritsa pit site g10 CDFig.11 Path Galabovo tell – Iskritsa dwelling site g11 CDFig.12 Path Galabovo tell – Klisselika tell g12 CDFig.13 Visibility from path Galabovo tell – Gudgova tell g13 CDFig.14 Path Galabovo tell – Mednikarovo tell g14 CDFig.15 Path Galabovo tell – Gonova mogila g15 CDFig.16 Visibility from path Galabovo tell – Gonova mogila g16 CDFig.17 Path Galabovo tell – MIBC1 g17 CDFig.18 Visibility from path Galabovo tell – Atanasivanova mogila g18 CDFig.19 Visibility from Path Galabovo tell – Iskritsa pit site g19 CDFig.20 Visibility from Path Galabovo tell – Iskritsa dwelling site g20 CDFig.21 Visibility from Path Galabovo tell – Klisselika tell g21 CDFig.22 Path Galabovo tell – Tcherniova mogila g22 CDFig.23 Visibility from Path Galabovo tell – Tcherniova mogila g23 CDFig.24 Path Galabovo tell – Kurdova mogila g24 CDFig.25 Visibility from Path Galabovo tell – Kurdova mogila g25 CDFig.26 Path Galabovo tell – Manchova mogila g26 CDFig.27 Visibility from Path Galabovo