Engineering Ethics: Three Case Studies

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Engineering Ethics: Three Case Studies ENGINEERING ETHICS: THREE CASE STUDIES (Subtitle: EVERYTHING SHOULD BE AS SIMPLE AS POSSIBLE, BUT NOT SIMPLER) Victor Singer, P.E. (retired) Dan Schiffbauer, P.E. Toshiba OVERVIEW: • Canons or Codes of Ethics • Noteworthy Historical Background for Each Case In Point – The Tacoma Narrows First Suspension Bridge: failed 1940 – The Silver Bridge (US Hwy 35 Ohio River Crossing): failed 1967 – The Shuttle Challenger: failed 1986 • Questions To Ponder For Each Case In Point: – Are There Relevant Ethical Issues Or Just 20-20 Hindsight? – When, If At All, Did Which Ethical Issue Come Into Play? – If Errors Occurred, Were They Errors Of Judgment, Omission or Commission? – Or Murphy’s Law Events - - Accidents In An Imperfectly Understood World? – Who Should Have Done What, That He Didn't Do? CANONS OR CODES OF ETHICS • NSPE, ASCE, ASME, AAES: Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public . (Fundamental Canon) • AIChE: Members shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public . • IEEE: We, the members of the IEEE . , do hereby . agree to accept responsibility in making decisions consistent with the safety, health and welfare of the public . • AIAA: The AIAA member will have proper regard for the safety, health and welfare of the public in the performance of his professional duties. • AIA: Members should . thoughtfully consider the social and environmental impact of their professional activities. • ABA Model Code of Professional Responsibility: Canons: 1. A lawyer should assist in maintaining the integrity and competence of the legal profession. 2. A lawyer should assist the legal profession in its duty to make legal counsel available. 3. A lawyer should assist in preventing the unauthorized practice of law. 4. A lawyer should preserve the confidences and secrets of a client. 5. A lawyer should exercise independent professional judgment on behalf of a client. 6. A lawyer should represent a client competently. 7. A lawyer should represent a client zealously within the bounds of the law. 8. A lawyer should assist in improving the legal system. 9. A lawyer should avoid even the appearance of professional impropriety. CASE IN POINT: TACOMA NARROWS FIRST SUSPENSION BRIDGE • Highway 16 Puget Sound Crossing between Tacoma WA and Kitsap Peninsula opened to traffic 7/1/1940; collapsed 11/7/1940; 6-minute video of collapse at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-zczJXSxnw from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacoma_Narrows_Bridge_(1940) VON KARMAN VORTEX STREET (observed from space): • Wind blowing above the sea is disturbed by an island, creating a "vortex street." Clouds serve as markers, allowing us to see the vortices in the flow downstream of the island. Von Karman Vortex Street in the atmosphere: SeaWiFS image courtesy of Orbimage, Inc., SeaWiFS Project (Code 970.2) and Distributed Active Archive Center (Code 902) at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD TACOMA NARROWS BRIDGE: before, during and after failure • 3 hrs transverse flexural (up and down) vibration, amplitude 1.5 ft, 35 mph wind • Wind rose to 42 mph, a midspan hanger cable broke (slipped), and the torsional mode started. Frequency 0.2 Hz, 28 ft double amplitude • Frequency associated with von Karman vortices at 42 mph wind: ~ 1 Hz • Federal Works Agency's Failure Commission concluded: Vortex shedding unlikely important because of the frequency difference. • Violins teach that excitation with RANDOM frequency content produces responses at resonant frequencies AND AT HARMONICS unless the vibrating system provides substantial internal damping. • Currently popular attribution: AEROELASTIC FLUTTER: jargon for stimulation of multiple degrees of freedom CONCURRENTLY, A MURPHY’S LAW EVENT. SIMILAR PHENOMENA from: www.clarktesting.com Stockbridge Damper (SCE 1928) PROTECTION AGAINST MURPHY’S LAW EVENTS • In general, interpolate within rather than extrapolate beyond prior experience. • Extrapolate in small steps, only where risk and benefits are balanced. • Tacoma Narrows Bridge was a substantial extrapolation into the unknown. • Much lower flexural rigidity and torsional rigidity than prior art, to reduce cost. • Eminence of the designer - - Leon Moisseiff - - played role in suppressing criticism. • Exception - - David B. Steinman, also an eminent suspension bridge designer, criticized the design at a 1938 meeting of the ASCE Structural Division. • Othmar Ammann (Failure Commission member) wrote: – "The failure has given us invaluable information. [that] every new structure that projects into new fields of magnitude involves new problems . [for] which neither theory nor experience furnish an adequate guide. It is then that we must rely on judgment. If errors or failures occur, we must accept them as a price for progress." QUESTIONS TO PONDER – Are There Relevant Ethical Issues Or Just 20-20 Hindsight? – When, If At All, Did Which Ethical Issue Come Into Play? – If Errors Occurred, Were They Errors Of Judgment, Omission or Commission? – Or Murphy’s Law Events - - Accidents In An Imperfectly Understood World? – Who Should Have Done What, That He Didn't Do? SECOND CASE IN POINT: THE SILVER BRIDGE • US Highway 35 Ohio River Crossing, Point Pleasant WV to Kanauga Ohio. – completed 1928, collapsed 12/15/1967 center span 700 ft, side spans 380 ft each, deck width 28 ft from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver Bridge SILVER BRIDGE • 46 dead, 2 missing (never found) HERCILIO LUZ BRIDGE • Florianopolis, Brazil – (26 deg S latitude) center span 1113 ft. Opened 1926, closed 1982, re-opened (pedestrians) 1988, closed 1991 • Designers: David B. Steinman and Holton D. Robinson – Using eyebar chain as upper chord of stiffening truss reduced weight and cost. – American Bridge Company proposed using their "special" 1060 carbon steel eyebars heat-treated to over 2X strength of the 1020 ASTM A-7 in common use. – Steinman dissociated his firm from further connection with the project. SILVER BRIDGE: concept & proportions copied from Florianopolis • For main span 2/3 as long, chain tension force was about half as large, allowing chains with only two heat-treated 1060 steel eyebars rather than four as on Florianopolis. • If one outer eyebar breaks, pin cannot sustain unsymmetrical load; bridge comes down • Eyebars 12” x 2”, Eye dia 28 in. Pin dia 11 inches • Heat Treat: ST 875 degC, WQ, temper 625 degC 2 hrs. • Average eyebar properties: Ftu 120 ksi, Fty 81 ksi, El >20%, R/A >45%, CVN 2 to 3 ft lbs at 32 degF, KIc 46.4 ksi root inch • Other steel shapes and plate (1020 carbon steel, ASTM A7-24) Ftu 58.2 ksi, Fty 31.7 ksi, El 20.7%, R/A > 50%, CVN > 15 ft lb at 50 degF, KIc ~100 ksi root inch • Eyebar allowable stress 50 ksi (67% of min required elastic limit) Ignorance is Truly Bliss • Only one recovered eyebar had a broken head • Fracture Surface, lower side: corner crack 0.28 inch long (parallel to 2 inch thickness), and 0.12 inch deep radially. • Technology enabling quantifying the relationship between flaw size and failure load didn't yet exist in the 1920's when Silver Bridge was designed. • 1920’s era brittle fracture provisions for steels for buildings and bridges commonly reflected a 15 ft lb minimum CVN (Charpy Vee Notch Impact Test) • Eyebar steel, at 2X the strength, provided less than 20% as much fracture energy • Steinman’s view (evidently): Stronger eyebars either too much extrapolation from prior experience or too little fracture energy for Florianopolis, as far from equator as Miami and much warmer than Kanauga. SILVER BRIDGE: post-mortem • Found original stress analysis reasonably accurate • Evaluated actual loading at time of failure to estimate actual load on failed eyebar. • Conducted extensive material testing program, including modern fracture toughness tests and related crack growth rate quantifications, and scale model testing program. • Final Highway Accident Report NTSB Report SS-H-2 (adopted 12-16-1970): – Fig 36: approximate positions of all vehicles on the bridge at time of failure. – Westbound lane 1/3 empty, eastbound lane more than half empty. – Page 98: "the probability of 100 percent of design stress is quite remote." – Failed eyebar head obviously loaded to actual capability when it failed. – The state-of-the-art circa 1920’s lacked recognition of potential premature - - flaw- induced - - failure in brittle materials at low temperatures. – Fracture cause: a flaw grew over 40 years to critical size by stress corrosion and corrosion fatigue. Which was dominant is unknown. – No indication main member deterioration by rusting to a point of inadequacy under intended or actual loading. QUESTIONS TO PONDER – Are There Relevant Ethical Issues Or Just 20-20 Hindsight? – When, If At All, Did Which Ethical Issue Come Into Play? – If Errors Occurred, Were They Errors Of Judgment, Omission or Commission? – Or Murphy’s Law Events - - Accidents In An Imperfectly Understood World? – Who Should Have Done What, That He Didn't Do? THIRD CASE IN POINT: SHUTTLE CHALLENGER What SHOULD happen: What DID happen: • SPACE SHUTTLE DISCOVERY • SPACE SHUTTLE CHALLENGER at STS-120 Launch at SPS-25 Launch Jan 28, 1986 BACKGROUND: Space Shuttle Program Overview • Vehicle Architecture: Shuttle's APOLLO flight vehicle "Stages In Parallel" architecture was a substantial departure from Apollo and Mercury "Stages In Series" architecture. • Re-Usable Orbiter objective made Crew Capsule Jettison feature of Apollo and Mercury programs more difficult than before. • NASA Decision: NO CREW CAPSULE ESCAPE SYSTEM FOR SHUTTLE BACKGROUND Space Shuttle Program Overview cont’d. • Funding Strategy: Seek Congressional approval by earmarking at least one component supplier contract for each US Senatorial and Rep District in the country. • Delaware got space suits, Wisconsin got SRM steel cases, Minnesota got phenolic resin impregnated carbon cloth, Virginia got rayon for white woven cloth (carbon cloth precursor), Nevada got ammonium perchlorate oxidizer for solid propellant, etc. • Congressional direction to NASA: YOU TELL US that revenue from commercial flights will cover the program development costs. – Interpretation: "You tell us" more important than whether or not it's true.
Recommended publications
  • I-35W Mississippi River Bridge Failure – Is It a Wake up Call?
    Point of View These columns of ICJ offer an opportunity to the engineering fraternity to express their views on the current practices in design, construction and management being followed in the industry. To share your opinion with our readers, you may send in your inputs in about 1500 words via e-mail to [email protected] I-35W Mississippi river bridge failure – Is it a wake up call? N. Subramanian Infrastructure plays a major role in the economy of 1907, the Tacoma Narrows in 1940 and the West Gate a country. Bridges are a major component of any in 1970. Whether this theory will hold well in the near infrastructure and the failure of a bridge will affect the future is debatable as many of the aging infrastructure economy of any country. The recent failure of the I-35W projects in several countries are under threat of failure Mississippi river bridge may be considered as a wake and some immediate measures are necessary to save up call to think about redundancy in structural design them from disasters. This paper discusses the recent of bridges, and evolution of bridge monitoring and failure of I-35 W Mississippi river bridge and gives some inspection systems. The details of the I-35W Mississippi details of other major bridge failures. river bridge, its failure and its impact on future bridge designs, monitoring and testing are discussed in this The I-35W Mississippi river bridge paper. These details may help in preventing such The I-35W Mississippi river bridge (officially designated disastrous failures in future.
    [Show full text]
  • So Now I²ll Count from Ìve to One and Bring You out of This
    Media. Memory. Meme. Colin Bennett. Prime Time. ! !" #" $" #" %" &" '" ( =5#'5/# ">00# .56')# !"#$%#&'#$#($)*+(# ,+-+(+#.(&,&,#/&)*# )*+#$0&+',1#"#/&00# 8(5%# 2+#)$03&'4#)5#)*+%# )5'&4*)#$256)#%7# 86)6(+#$'9#/*$)# ?-+#)5# )*+7#/&00#5(#/&00# '5)#95#)5#%+1: 5'+# ;$-&9#<$.52, $'9# 2(&'4# 756# 56)#58# )*&,1 ")*("+,-(#."+/ 0!!#"1++-2 !"#$$%&'()*+ Vol. 24 No. 1 Issue # 154 !"#"$%&'()*+(,-./01** UFO Volume 24 • Number 1 columnists 6 Publisher’s Note: William J. Birnes 7 Saucers, Slips & Cigarettes: Dierdre O’Lavery 8 Rocket Scientist: Stanton T. Friedman 10 Outside the Box: Mike Good 12 Opinionated Oregonian: George W. Earley 14 Alien in the Attic: Farah Yurdözü 16 Coast to Coast AM: George Noory 17 An Alien View: Alfred Lehmberg 18 The Randle Report: Kevin D. Randle 20 21st Century News: Dr. Bob & Zohara Hieronimus 22 Truthseeking: Dennis Balthaser 24 Inner Space: Sri Ram Kaa and Kira Raa 26 View From A Brit: Nick Redfern 27 Bryant’s UFO View: Larry W. Bryant 28 The Orange Orb: Regan Lee 29 Beyond the Dial: Lesley Gunter 30 Mirror Images: Micah A. Hanks bits & bobs 32 Arlan’s Arcanae: Arlan Andrews, Sr. Say hello to Dierdre! She is a 74 Rick’s UFO Picks: Rick Troppman new columnist, she is on page 7, and she is sassy. To Alfred Lehmberg: A belated thank you for the great cover artwork of Richard toon Dolan in Issue #153. Thanks also must go to our 63 Bradley Peterson very very very patient readers. This issue has been a long time coming. Next one should be just a bit more prompt. UFO Issue 154 features 34 Aliens vs.
    [Show full text]
  • Directions & Travel Guide
    Accommodations Rio Grande Directory Travel Guide Rio Grande/Gallipolis • Athletic Director: Jeff Lanham Office: 740-245-7485 Cell: 740-441-5742 • Best Western e-mail: [email protected] 918 Second Ave. Gallipolis, OH 45631 ............... 740-446-3373 • Athletic Department Secretary: Wendy Hammons Office: 740-245-7293 Directions to Rio Grande • Hampton Inn Fax: 740-245-7555 444 State Route 7 N From Lexington, KY: (181 miles) Take I-64 Gallipolis, OH 45631 ............... 740-446-8000 • Sports Information Director: Randy Payton East toward Ashland. Exit off 64 East at the Office: 740-245-7213 Cell: 740-339-3632 Barboursville exit (EXIT 18) to Route 60/ • Quality Inn e-mail: [email protected] Route 2 North to Point Pleasant. Take US-35 577 State Route 7 N toward Chillicothe (cross bridge into Ohio). Gallipolis, OH 45631 ............... 740-446-0090 • Baseball Head Coach: Brad Warnimont Take the OH-325 exit toward Vinton/Rio Office: 740-245-7486 Cell: 740-208-7425 Grande and turn left. • Regency Inn e-mail: [email protected] 151 Upper River Road From Cincinnati: (131.66 miles) Take OH-32 Gallipolis, OH 45631 ................740-446-0241 • Men’s Basketball Head Coach: Ken French East toward Batavia. Merge of US 35 E. Take Office: 740-245-7294 Cell: 740-645-3035 the OH-325 Exit toward Vinton/Rio Grande • Riverside Motel e-mail: [email protected] and turn right. 1066 First Avenue Gallipolis, OH 45631 ...............740-446 -2702 • Women’s Basketball Head Coach: David Smalley From Columbus: (94.64 miles) Take I-270 Office: 740-245-7491 Cell: 740-709-4971 East (EXIT 101) toward Wheeling.
    [Show full text]
  • Visit Ohio's Historic Bridges
    SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION Visit Ohio’s Historic Bridges Historic and unique bridges have a way of sticking in our collective memories. Many of us remember the bridge we crossed walking to school, a landmark on the way to visit relatives, the gateway out of town or a welcoming indication that you are back in familiar territory. The Ohio Department of Transportation, in collaboration with the Ohio Historic Bridge Association, Ohio History Connection’s State Historic Preservation Office, TourismOhio and historicbridges.org, has assembled a list of stunning bridges across the state that are well worth a journey. Ohio has over 500 National Register-listed and historic bridges, including over 150 wooden covered bridges. The following map features iron, steel and concrete struc- tures, and even a stone bridge built when canals were still helping to grow Ohio’s economy. Some were built for transporting grain to market. Other bridges were specifically designed to blend into the scenic landscape of a state or municipal park. Many of these featured bridges are Ohio Historic Bridge Award recipients. The annual award is given to bridge owners and engineers that rehabilitate, preserve or reuse historic structures. The awards are sponsored by the Federal Highway Administration, ODOT and Ohio History Connection’s State Historic Preservation Office. Anthony Wayne Bridge - Toledo, OH Ohio Department of Transportation SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION 2 17 18 SOUTHEAST REGION in eastern Ohio, Columbiana County has Metropark’s Huntington Reservation on the community. A project that will rehabilitate several rehabilitated 1880’s through truss shore of Lake Erie along US 6/Park Drive.
    [Show full text]
  • INSPIRE Newsletter Fall 2020
    Missouri University of Science and Technology Scholars' Mine INSPIRE Newsletters INSPIRE - University Transportation Center Fall 2020 INSPIRE Newsletter Fall 2020 Missouri University of Science and Technology. INSPIRE - University Transportation Center Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsmine.mst.edu/inspire-newsletters Part of the Structural Engineering Commons Recommended Citation Missouri University of Science and Technology. INSPIRE - University Transportation Center, "INSPIRE Newsletter Fall 2020" (2020). INSPIRE Newsletters. 8. https://scholarsmine.mst.edu/inspire-newsletters/8 This Newsletter is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars' Mine. It has been accepted for inclusion in INSPIRE Newsletters by an authorized administrator of Scholars' Mine. This work is protected by U. S. Copyright Law. Unauthorized use including reproduction for redistribution requires the permission of the copyright holder. For more information, please contact [email protected]. TIER 1 UNIVERSITY TRANSPORTATION CENTER (UTC) Sponsored by the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Research and Technology in the U.S. Department of Transportation INSPECTING AND PRESERVING INFRASTRUCTURE THROUGH ROBOTIC EXPLORATION VOL. 4 | ISSUE 2 | (FALL) INSPIRE-UTC Biannual Publication Director’s Message Greetings colleagues and friends! Since our last newsletter, the INSPIRE UTC has held In this issue: a virtual annual meeting with its members and a graduate student poster competition. The center continues to host webinars on a quarterly basis, engaging attendees world- Director's Message wide on infrastructure and transportation related topics. Kummer Institute Donors In the largest single gift in the history of Missouri higher edu- cation, St. Louis businessman Fred Kummer and his wife June News have donated $300 million to a foundation that will support Forensic Bridge Research Missouri S&T.
    [Show full text]
  • Framework for Improving Resilience of Bridge Design
    U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration Framework for Improving Resilience of Bridge Design Publication No. FHWA-IF-11-016 January 2011 Notice This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Transportation in the interest of information exchange. The U.S. Government assumes no liability for use of the information contained in this document. This report does not constitute a standard, specification, or regulation. Quality Assurance Statement The Federal Highway Administration provides high-quality information to serve Government, industry, and the public in a manner that promotes public understanding. Standards and policies are used to ensure and maximize the quality, objectivity, utility, and integrity of its information. FHWA periodically reviews quality issues and adjusts its programs and processes to ensure continuous quality improvement. Framework for Improving Resilience of Bridge Design Report No. FHWA-IF-11-016 January 2011 Technical Report Documentation Page 1. Report No. 2. Government Accession No. 3. Recipient’s Catalog No. FHWA-IF-11-016 4. Title and Subtitle 5. Report Date Framework for Improving Resilience of Bridge Design January 2011 6. Performing Organization Code 7. Author(s) 8. Performing Organization Report No. Brandon W. Chavel and John M. Yadlosky 9. Performing Organization Name and Address 10. Work Unit No. HDR Engineering, Inc. 11 Stanwix Street, Suite 800 11. Contract or Grant No. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15222 12. Sponsoring Agency Name and Address 13. Type of Report and Period Covered Office of Bridge Technology Technical Report Federal Highway Administration September 2007 – January 2011 1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE Washington, D.C. 20590 14.
    [Show full text]
  • 민⋅관 거버넌스를 통한 교량안전관리 개선에 관한 연구 a Study on the Improvement Program of Bridge Safety Management Through Public-Private Governance
    J. Korean Soc. Hazard Mitig. ISSN 1738-2424(Print) Vol. 18, No. 1 (Jan. 2018), pp.145~156 ISSN 2287-6723(Online) https://doi.org/10.9798/KOSHAM.2018.18.1.145 www.kosham.or.kr 등재 민⋅관 거버넌스를 통한 교량안전관리 개선에 관한 연구 A Study on the Improvement Program of Bridge Safety Management Through Public-Private Governance 김성제*·윤명오** Kim, Seong Jeh*, and Yoon, Myong O** Abstract Unsafe accidents occurred such as the collapse of Seongsoo Bridge in October 1994 and the collapse of Sampoong Department Store in June 1995, in the wake of the dynamic urban infrastructure & economic growth policy in the 1960s and thereafter. Following the collapse of the Seongsu Bridge, enacting in accordance with established regulations of ≷Misfortune and the safety supervision basic law≸ & ≷Special Act on Safety Management of Building Structures≸, regular safety inspection and diagnosis of routine was enforced. However, the bridge safety accident has remained constant since then, and the bridge safety management system is still insufficient compared to the developed nations. Based on advanced cases of bridge accidents in the developed countries (United States and Japan), this research suggest the best practices of the maintenance system, and development measures are provided to improve the safety management of bridges through governance. These are as follows. Innovation of bridge management policies through Bridge Management System (BMS), strengthen management of bridge safety inspection by expanding national participation, Organization and operation of bridge safety maintenance budget, concentration management of deteriorated bridge and long span bridge etc. In future the establishment of bridges life-cycle management system (LCM) to a preventive maintenance system by means of record management comparing with life-cycle costs (LCC) should be implemented to the comprehensive overall maintenance system of mid to long-term budget formulation and execution by applying professional and active citizen participation procedures.
    [Show full text]
  • Compensating Victims of Bridge Collapses Outside Minnesota
    Compensating Victims of Bridge Collapses Outside Minnesota Peter S. Wattson Senate Counsel State of Minnesota November 9, 2007 2 Contents Introduction ................................................................ ii 1. Tacoma Narrows Bridge - Washington - November 7, 1940 ....................1 2. Silver Bridge - West Virginia - December 15, 1967 ...........................2 3. Mianus River Bridge - Connecticut - June 28, 1983 ...........................3 4. Schoharie Creek Bridge - New York - April 5, 1987 ..........................4 5. Hatchie River Bridge - Tennessee - April 1, 1989 .............................6 6. San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge and Cypress Structure - California - October 17, 1989 ...............................................................7 7. Little Red River Pedestrian Bridge - Arkansas - October 29, 1989 ..............9 8. I-40 Bridge Near Webbers Falls - Oklahoma - May 26, 2002 ..................10 Conclusion .................................................................11 Bridge Collapse Web Sites ....................................................12 i Introduction This paper describes how other states have compensated victims of bridge collapses that occurred before the Interstate 35W Bridge over the Mississippi River in Minneapolis collapsed on August 1, 2007. It includes bridges that collapsed in California, Connecticut, New York, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Washington, and West Virginia, from 1940 to 2002. The collapses and the state response to them are described in chronological order. They offer an
    [Show full text]
  • Jeffery Harvey: Bridge Collapse Reminds Us to Have Emergency Plans
    Jeffery Harvey: Bridge collapse reminds us to have emergency plans... http://www.herald-dispatch.com/opinion/jeffery-harvey-bridge-col... http://www.herald-dispatch.com/opinion/jeffery-harvey-bridge-collapse-reminds-us-to-have-emergency- plans/article_6d68e5f3-5d46-5f9d-95bf-0db189d13558.html Jeffery Harvey: Bridge collapse reminds us to have emergency plans 11 hrs ago Bo Wriston Buy Now This December, West Virginians and Ohioans are reminded of one disaster that no one could have predicted. This month marks the 50th anniversary of the Silver Bridge Collapse, which sparked mass public attention and major concerns for bridge safety across the country. More than that, it took many American lives in the blink of an eye, and those that were spared and witnessed the event will forever be haunted by what they experienced that day. On that Dec. 15 in 1967, around 5 p.m., the Silver Bridge was full of rush-hour traffic that flowed between Point Pleasant, West Virginia, and Gallipolis, Ohio. Many were probably expecting to drive across that bridge like they had done so many times before, perhaps with work still on their minds or pondering what to fix for dinner that night. Yet, something happened that no one expected. The 1 of 3 12/15/17, 1:44 PM Jeffery Harvey: Bridge collapse reminds us to have emergency plans... http://www.herald-dispatch.com/opinion/jeffery-harvey-bridge-col... bridge's infrastructure gave out; the innovative eyebar-link suspension of the time had failed. In less than a minute, witnesses said the bridge crumbled and sank into the Ohio River, taking 37 vehicles and the lives of 46 people with it.
    [Show full text]
  • The Persistence of Failure Historic Bridge Collapses
    The Persistence of Failure Historic Bridge Collapses Henry Petroski Distinguished Professor Emeritus of Civil Engineering Duke University • • • Historic Failures of Iron and Steel Bridges • What are the Landmark Cases? • Do They Reveal a Pattern? • Can It Predict Future Collapses? Landmark Bridge Failures (some still being revisited) North British Railway, Edinburgh-to-Dund ee, ca. late 1870 Chester and Holyhead Railway, Ca. 1845 Dee Bridge Collapse 1847 Collapsed Dee Bridge Trussed Girder Revisiting the Dee Bridge Failure Peter Lewis, Open University, ca. 2004 Tay Bridge Collapse 1879 Tay Bridge, 1879 Tay Bridge, 1879 Dec. 28, 1879 Note smokestacks still standing in Dundee. In 2002 Peter Lewis digitized 1880 photos Replacement Tay Bridge (left), 1887 Bridge Proposed to Cross the Firth of Forth (Design Abandoned after Tay Bridge Collapse) Forth Railway Bridge Human Model, late 1880s Forth Rail Bridge, 1890 Quebec Bridge Collapse 1907 Quebec Bridge, 1907 (Second) Quebec Bridge, 1917 Tacoma Narrows Bridge Collapse 1940 Tacoma Narrows Bridge, 1940 Tacoma Narrows Bridge, 1940 Silver Bridge Collapse 1967 Silver Bridge, 1928 Silver Bridge Collapse December 15, 1967 Milford Haven Bridge Collapse 1970 Milford Haven Bridge June 1970 Cleddau (Milford Haven) Bridge,1975 Westgate Bridge October 1970 367-foot span being lifted onto piers Landmark Bridge Failures Is there a pattern? • 1847 - Dee Bridge, trussed girder • 1879 - Tay Bridge, through truss • 1907 - Quebec Bridge, cantilever • 1940 - Tacoma Narrows Bridge, suspension • 1967 - Silver
    [Show full text]
  • Copy of Huntington History Index 6-7-10.Xlsx
    HD = Herald Dispatch HH = Huntington Herald HA = Huntington Advertiser WCN = Wayne County News DND = Daily News Digest INDEX TO MISCELLANEOUS ARTICLES FOUND IN LOCAL NEWSPAPERS SUBJECT CAPTION DATE REEL ACCIDENTS - BIG SANDY BRIDGE COLLAPSE SIX PERISH AS BIG SANDY BRIDGE FALLS : BIG SANDY RIVER BRIDGE AT KENOVA AFTER FLOOD WATERS CARRY SPAN AWAY p. 1 December 22, 1926 HA ACCIDENTS - BIG SANDY BRIDGE COLLAPSE HIGH WATER STOPS HUNT FOR 5 BODIES LOST IN BIG SANDY p. 1 December 23, 1926 HA ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE DUPLICATES WRECK OF 20 YEARS AGO January 2, 1913 ENGINE CRASHING THROUGH BRIDGE CARRIES SEVEN MEN TO DEATH; TO BEGIN SEARCH FOR BODIES: THINK HIGH WATER WEAKENED ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE January 2, 1913 HD PIERS CAUSING BREAK p. 1 & 3 ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE NEW YEARS DAY OF 1913 BRING TRAGEDY TO HUNTINGTON January 2, 1913 DIVERS ARRIVE TO SEARCH RIVER FOR VICTIMS OF WRECK: STEEL GIRDERS JAMMED TOGETHER, HINDER WORK OF RECOVERING ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE January 3, 1913 HD BODIES p.1 & 2 THREE DIVERS TO HELP IN SEARCH OF GUYAN RIVER: WORK OF RECOVERING BODIES IS HAMPERED BY MUDDY WATER [C&O FREIGHT ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE January 4, 1913 HD TRAIN NO. 99] p.1 ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE FIRST PICTURES OF WRECKED BRIDGE THROUGH WHICH SEVEN WENT TO DEATH p.6 (pic) January 5, 1913 HD ACCIDENTS - CHESAPEAKE & OHIO BRIDGE COLLAPSE HELD BY DEBRIS SEVEN BODIES ARE IN GUYAN RIVER...DIVERS FAIL TO FIND MEN WHO WERE
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of U.S. Bridge Failures (1980-2012)
    ISSN 1520-295X A Study of U.S. Bridge Failures (1980-2012) by George C. Lee, Satish B. Mohan, Chao Huang, and Bastam N. Fard Technical Report MCEER-13-0008 June 15, 2013 This research was conducted at the University at Buff alo, State University of New York and was supported by the Federal Highway Administration under Contract Number DTFH61-08-C-00012. NOTICE This report was prepared by the University at Buff alo, State University of New York, as a result of research sponsored by MCEER through a contract from the Federal Highway Administration. Neither MCEER, associates of MCEER, its sponsors, the University at Buff alo, State University of New York, nor any person acting on their behalf: a. makes any warranty, express or implied, with respect to the use of any information, apparatus, method, or process disclosed in this report or that such use may not infringe upon privately owned rights; or b. assumes any liabilities of whatsoever kind with respect to the use of, or the damage resulting from the use of, any information, apparatus, method, or process disclosed in this report. Any opinions, fi ndings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily refl ect the views of MCEER or the Federal Highway Adminstration. A Study of U.S. Bridge Failures (1980-2012) by George C. Lee,1 Satish B. Mohan,2 Chao Huang3 and Bastam N. Fard4 Publication Date: June 15, 2013 Submittal Date: April 15, 2013 Technical Report MCEER-13-0008 FHWA Contract Number DTFH61-08-C-00012 1 Samuel P.
    [Show full text]