Asian and African Studies, Volume 20, Number 1, 2011 POLEMICS IN THE AGE OF RELIGIOUS PERSECUTIONS: MAIMONIDES’ ATTITUDE TOWARDS ISLAM* Daniel BOUŠEK Institute of Near Eastern and African Studies Charles University in Prague, Faculty of Arts, Celetná 20, 116 42 Praha 1, Czech Republic
[email protected] The present paper inquires into Maimonides’ attitude to Islam. His halakhic stance towards Islam has been molded in the period of large-scale religious persecutions in Maghreb and Yemen whose repercussions has found the way to his writings dealing with Islam. Both persecutions affected not only local Jewish communities but also Maimonides personally when he had to convert to Islam. The paper analyzes his refutation of the main arguments of Muslim polemics with Judaism: Biblical testimonies to Muhammad; falsification of the Scripture; the abrogation of the Mosaic Law. In his polemical discourse with Islam Maimonides has not introduced much new and in fact reiterates polemical arguments of the older Jewish authorities. Key words: Maimonides, conversion, Islam, polemics, persecution, falsification of scriptures The Jews, during the 12th century, lived through at least two major religious persecutions which took place at either end of the Islamic world, one in the Maghreb and Andalusia and the second in Yemen. It ought to be said at the outset that both were conducted by extremist Muslim movements. While Maimonides (Moshe ben Maimon, 1138 – 1204), the most influential medieval Jewish halakhist and religious philosopher, experienced the first personally, the second also touched him indirectly. Nevertheless, to both he responded in writing with an effort to comfort and guide victims of these persecutions who were confronted with the acute choice either to accept Islam in order to save their lives, or to sanctify God’s name with martyrs’ deaths.