Cigar Insider Special Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
internet only CigarCLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE DECEMBER 23, 2014 n VOL.Insider 19, NO. 24 n FROM THE PUBLISHER OF CIGAR AFICIONADO MAGAZINE IN THIS ISSUE: CIGAR INSIDER’S TOP SCORES OF 2014 PREVIEWS FROM THE FEBRUARY 2015 Ashton Estate Sun Grown 22-Year Salute Dom. Rep. 94 CIGAR AFICIONADO MAGAZINE: A. Flores 1975 Serie Privada Capa Habano SP 52 Dom. Rep. 93 n Ashton Virgin Sun Grown Spellbound [page 2] Achilles Heroicos Nicaragua 93 n Partagás Lusitania [page 2] n Ashton Estate Sun Grown 24-Year Salute [page 2] Cohiba Siglo VI Cuba 93 n Hoyo de Monterrey Double Corona [page 2] Illusione Fume d’Amour Clementes Nicaragua 93 n Padrón Family Reserve 44 Years Maduro [page 3] n San Cristobal Revelation Triumph [page 3] Partagás Lusitania Gran Reserva Cuba 93 n La Antiguedad Robusto [page 3] San Cristobal de la Habana El Morro Cuba 93 n La Bohéme Poeta [page 3] Alec Bradley Mundial No. 5 Honduras 92 INDUSTRY ANALYSIS: Arturo Fuente Don Carlos No. 2 Dom. Rep. 92 n Average Score by Brand [page 4] Ashton Estate Sun Grown 24-Year Salute Dom. Rep. 92 n Average Score by Size and Country [page 5] n Humidor Selections—46 Cigars Rated 91+ Cohiba Siglo III Cuba 92 in 2014 [page 6] Cohiba Siglo IV Cuba 92 n Analysis by Country [page 7] n Cigars for a Budget—Our Best Buys [page 8] La Palina Classic Lancero Dom. Rep. 92 n Comprehensive Tasting Report for 2014: Montecristo Petit No. 2 Cuba 92 266 Cigar Ratings [page 10] Padrón Family Reserve 44 Years Maduro Nicaragua 92 CIGAR NEWS: Padrón Family Reserve 50 Years Maduro Nicaragua 92 n Major Changes to U.S.-Cuba Relations [page 8] Quai d’Orsay Belicoso Royale Exclusivo Francia Cuba 92 Rocky Patel Platinum Robusto Nicaragua 92 San Cristobal Revelation Legend Nicaragua 92 San Cristobal Revelation Triumph Nicaragua 92 ACTOR LIAM NEESON Source: Cigar Insider THE THINKING MAN’S WHERE THE TOP SCORERS ARE MADE MOVIE STAR has taken COUNTRY CIGARS RATED 90 POINTS OR HIGHER PERCENT on roles and personas that Cuba 29 18 62.1% range from the serious to the action hero. The February U.S.A. 21 11 52.4% issue of Cigar Aficionado tells Dom. Rep. 81 34 42.0% the story of Neeson’s career and his thoughts on act- HonDuRas 43 17 40.0% ing. Plus, see the Top 25 Cigars of 2014, including niCaRagua 92 36 39.1% the No. 1 Cigar of the Year. Source: Cigar Insider CIGAR INSIDER SPECIAL REPORT: 2014 YEAR IN REVIEW BY GREGORY MOTTOLA igar Insider’s annual year in review is a comprehensive cross section and examination of all the brands we rated through- Cout the year. Some come from companies that are familiar industry standards, while others are from producers who might not have the same production or distribution as some of the industry’s bigger cigar companies. [continued on page 5] TO SUBSCRIBE GO TO WWW.CIGARINSIDER.COM Cigar Insider CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TASTING REPORT: EXCLUSIVE FEBRUARY 2015 CIGAR AFICIONADO PREVIEWS 93 RING GAUGE: 54 ASHTON VIRGIN SUN GROWN LENGTH: 7 1/2" SPELLBOUND DOM. REP. FILLER: Dom. Rep. This box-pressed double corona is covered in a dark, oily wrapper. Each toasty puff carries BINDER: Dom. Rep. notes of chocolate and earth balanced by minerals and a touch of peppermint. WRAPPER: Ecuador Price: $14.50 Body: Medium to Full 93 RING GAUGE: 49 PARTAGÁS LUSITANIA CUBA LENGTH: 7 5/8" A dark wrapper and flat head make this a very attractive double corona. Notes of semisweet FILLER: Cuba chocolate harmonize with bitter orange peel, leather and freshly cut pine. BINDER: Cuba Box Date: April 2013 WRAPPER: Cuba Price: £25.00 (U.K.) Body: Medium 92 RING GAUGE: 48 ASHTON ESTATE SUN GROWN LENGTH: 6 5/8" 24-YEAR SALUTE DOM. REP. FILLER: Dom. Rep. A long perfecto with symmetrical construction and a full draw that imparts bright and zesty BINDER: Dom. Rep. smoke full of dried orange peel, red pepper flakes and underlying woodiness. WRAPPER: Dom. Rep. Price: $21.00 Body: Medium 92 RING GAUGE: 49 HOYO DE MONTERREY DOUBLE CORONA CUBA LENGTH: 7 5/8" Dressed in a medium-claro wrapper, this double corona is finished with a flat head and FILLER: Cuba three-seam cap. It’s woody and grassy at first, but takes on rich chocolate notes, BINDER: Cuba hints of vanilla bean and touches of citrus. WRAPPER: Cuba Box Date: July 2013 Price: £24.94 (U.K.) Body: Medium to Full 95-100: Classic n 90-94: Outstanding n 80-89: Very good to excellent n 70-79: Average to good commercial quality Below 70: Don’t waste your money n N/A: Not Available Note: Prices are manufacturers’ suggested retail, before taxes. 2 TO SUBSCRIBE GO TO WWW.CIGARINSIDER.COM December 23, 2014 Cigar Insider CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TASTING REPORT: EXCLUSIVE FEBRUARY 2015 CIGAR AFICIONADO PREVIEWS 92 RING GAUGE: 52 PADRÓN FAMILY RESERVE LENGTH: 6" 44 YEARS MADURO NICARAGUA FILLER: Nicaragua A box-pressed torpedo with a dark wrapper and opulent draw. It’s rich and sweet with BINDER: Nicaragua coffee bean and toast complemented by notes of chocolate and graham cracker. WRAPPER: Nicaragua Price: $31.30 Body: Medium to Full 92 RING GAUGE: 50 SAN CRISTOBAL REVELATION TRIUMPH NICARAGUA LENGTH: 7" Tall and box pressed with a three-seam cap. The draw is substantial, leaving tangy FILLER: Nicaragua impressions of orange peel and horseradish balanced by sweet leather and earth. BINDER: Nicaragua Price: $8.50 Body: Medium to Full WRAPPER: Ecuador 91 RING GAUGE: 52 LA ANTIGUEDAD ROBUSTO NICARAGUA LENGTH: 5 1/4" This box-pressed cigar is a strong and hearty smoke full of baker’s chocolate, FILLER: Nicaragua roasted coffee beans and earth, but balanced by floral sweetness. BINDER: Nicaragua Price: $7.40 Body: Medium to Full WRAPPER: Ecuador 91 RING GAUGE: 54 LA BOHÉME POETA DOM. REP. LENGTH: 5 3/4" Wrapped in an oily cover leaf, this cigar draws perfectly, delivering earthy, FILLER: Dom. Rep. tea-like intonations that intensify to show leather, minerals and a red wine note. BINDER: Dom. Rep. Price: $12.24 Body: Medium to Full WRAPPER: Ecuador 95-100: Classic n 90-94: Outstanding n 80-89: Very good to excellent n 70-79: Average to good commercial quality Below 70: Don’t waste your money n N/A: Not Available Note: Prices are manufacturers’ suggested retail, before taxes. 3 TO SUBSCRIBE GO TO WWW.CIGARINSIDER.COM December 23, 2014 Cigar Insider CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE AVERAGE SCORE BY BRAND Brand Rating Brand Rating Montecristo, Cuba (1 Cigar) 92.0 Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur, Honduras (2) 89.0 Quai d’Orsay, Cuba (1) 92.0 Kismet (5) 89.0 601 La Bomba Warhead II (1) 91.0 La Bohéme (4) 89.0 H. Upmann, Cuba (1) 91.0 Matilde Renacer (4) 89.0 L’Atelier Selection Spéciale (1) 91.0 My Father Connecticut (4) 89.0 Punch Rare Corojo, Honduras (1) 91.0 Rogue (5) 89.0 Ashton Estate Sun Grown (5) 90.6 The Edge Habano (2) 89.0 Cohiba, Cuba (7) 90.6 Viaje Skull And Bones (1) 89.0 Padrón Family Reserve (5) 90.6 7-20-4 Hustler (4) 88.8 Aging Room Small Batch M356 (2) 90.5 Alec Bradley Coyol (6) 88.8 Bolivar, Cuba (2) 90.5 Ashton Virgin Sun Grown (4) 88.8 La Flor de Cano, Cuba (2) 90.5 Padilla Connecticut (4) 88.8 Partagás, Cuba (4) 90.5 Señorial by José Blanco (5) 88.8 Illusione Fume d’Amour (4) 90.3 Tatuaje Cabinet (6) 88.8 A. Flores 1975 Serie Privada Capa Habano (3) 90.0 Hammer + Sickle Hermitage No. 1 (3) 88.7 Casa Fernandez Miami Aganorsa Leaf Maduro (1) 90.0 Las Calaveras Edición Limitada 2014 (3) 88.7 Davidoff Nicaragua (1) 90.0 Rocky Patel Decade Cameroon (3) 88.7 E.P. Carrillo La Historia (3) 90.0 Eiroa (4) 88.5 Herrera Esteli (1) 90.0 La Flor Dominicana 1994 (4) 88.5 Joya de Nicaragua (1) 90.0 Vault by Toraño D-042 (4) 88.5 La Flor Dominicana (1) 90.0 Vegueros, Cuba (2) 88.5 La Palina Classic (3) 90.0 Jericho Hill (4) 88.3 Tatuaje Black (1) 90.0 Juan Lopez, Nicaragua (3) 88.3 Arturo Fuente Don Carlos (7) 89.8 RyJ by Romeo y Julieta, Honduras (3) 88.3 Achilles (3) 89.7 Quesada 40th Anniversary (5) 88.2 Curivari Café Noir Reserva Limitada (3) 89.7 Camacho Ecuador (5) 88.0 Juan Lopez, Cuba (3) 89.7 Cohiba Nicaragua (4) 88.0 San Cristobal Revelation, Nicaragua (6) 89.7 L’Atelier (1) 88.0 The Banker by H. Upmann, Dom. Rep. (3) 89.7 La Antiguedad (5) 88.0 Alec Bradley Mundial (5) 89.6 Joya Red (4) 87.8 Casa Magna D. Magnus II (2) 89.5 Nat Sherman 1930 (6) 87.8 Norteño (6) 89.5 Trill (5) 87.6 La Palina Collection Mr. Sam (3) 89.3 Tatuaje Tattoo (4) 87.5 Montecristo Espada, Nicaragua (3) 89.3 Davidoff (1) 87.0 Rocky Patel Platinum (3) 89.3 Vegas Robaina, Cuba (1) 87.0 San Cristobal de la Habana, Cuba (3) 89.3 Viaje Exclusivo Leaded (1) 87.0 Don Pepin Garcia Original (10) 89.1 Villiger Talanga (5) 87.0 Ezra Zion Tantrum (1) 89.0 Inch by E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2014 (3) 86.7 Fonseca, Cuba (1) 89.0 Avo (1) 86.0 Hoja de Flores Auténtico Maduro (3) 89.0 Davidoff Maduro (3) 86.0 Hoyo de Monterrey, Cuba (1) 89.0 Room 101 Master Collection (5) 85.8 Source: Cigar Insider 4 TO SUBSCRIBE GO TO WWW.CIGARINSIDER.COM December 23, 2014 Cigar Insider CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE AVERAGE SCORE BY SIZE Clementes (Cigar Aficionado’s No.