West Hill and West End Neighborhood Plan

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

West Hill and West End Neighborhood Plan 2013 Development Without Displacement In Albany’s West Hill & West End Neighborhoods Lauren Ellmers Michael Jackson Desirae Mayo Debra Nelson Urban Community Development Instructor: Corianne Payton Scally, Ph.D. December 12, 2013 Development Without Displacement Abstract ABSTRACT In distressed urban neighborhood development planning, a community strives to transform undesirable space to create a desirable place. The West Hill/West End neighborhoods, like other distressed neighborhoods in the City of Albany, seek ways to promote investments and incentives to strengthen and stabilize their community. It is a challenge, however, for communities to increase the desirability of the neighborhood to encourage development in a way that minimizes the risk of displacement of residents and businesses. This paper explores ways to make the most of the natural and built resources to increase neighborhood desirability, retain and encourage affordable housing, attract desirable businesses, and apply zoning tools to enable these actions. Recommendations include ways to optimize existing urban green space as a resource in place making; support and retain affordable housing; retain and attract neighborhood businesses; and apply or adjust zoning laws and building regulations to transform spaces into desirable places by encouraging suitable development without displacing the current residents and businesses. i Development Without Displacement Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ i Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................ ii I. Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 1 II. Optimizing Green Spaces in Place Making............................................................................... 2 Urban Green Space for Health and Well-being .......................................................................... 2 West Hill/West End Neighborhood Green Spaces ...................................................................... 3 Community Place Making Principles, Recommendations and Resources .................................. 4 Consistency with Albany 2030 Comprehensive Plan ................................................................. 9 III. Keeping Affordable Housing Affordable .............................................................................. 10 Programs for Homeowners........................................................................................................ 10 Programs for Renters ................................................................................................................. 11 Programs for First Time Homebuyers ....................................................................................... 12 Students in Your Neighborhood ................................................................................................ 12 Community Land Trust ............................................................................................................. 13 Tax Incentives ........................................................................................................................... 13 Cooperative Housing ................................................................................................................. 14 Efficient Land Use .................................................................................................................... 14 IV. Developing Low Cost Business Space .................................................................................. 15 Supporting Entrepreneurs .......................................................................................................... 16 Identifying Potential Locations ................................................................................................. 17 Community Based Incubators ................................................................................................... 19 V. Using Zoning to Encourage Development without Displacement ........................................ 22 ii Development Without Displacement Table of Contents Inclusionary Zoning .................................................................................................................. 22 Maintaining Present Industries Within the Neighborhood ........................................................ 23 Maximizing Parcel and Building Size ....................................................................................... 24 The Costs of Housing Regulations ............................................................................................ 25 Learning from the Successes and Mistakes of Other Cities ...................................................... 26 VI. Conclusion ............................................................................................................................. 27 VII. References ............................................................................................................................ 29 iii Development Without Displacement Introduction I. INTRODUCTION In distressed urban neighborhood development planning, a community strives to transform undesirable space to create a desirable place. It is a challenge, however, for communities to increase the desirability of the neighborhood to encourage development in a way that minimizes the risk of displacement of residents and businesses. Nearly 75 percent of the West Hill/West End neighborhoods in Albany, New York are residential1, with areas of public green space and pockets of light industry and businesses. Within the core neighborhood, the CORe report2 documented a high frequency of vacant properties in the West Hill neighborhood, with approximately 16 percent of the tax parcels having vacant buildings and 13 percent of the tax parcels having vacant lots; additionally, damage was reported on more than half of all occupied buildings in this neighborhood. Considering that the West End neighborhood appears to have similar characteristics to the West Hill neighborhood, this paper will address the overall West Hill/West End neighborhoods together. These distressed neighborhoods seek to encourage development to improve their communities. To turn the tide and encourage development in these neighborhoods, the neighborhoods seek efforts to revitalize vacant buildings and reuse vacant lots, and provide incentives for renewal of occupied buildings.3 However, such development should be done in a way to minimize displacement of current residents from direct takings of property or other negative consequences such as loss of affordable housing or loss of businesses (e.g., from “gentrification” or a shift in the urban community toward wealthier residents or businesses at the expense of its poorer residents). This paper explores ways to make the most of the natural and built resources to increase neighborhood desirability, retain and encourage affordable housing, attract desirable businesses, and apply zoning tools to enable these actions. Recommendations include ways to optimize existing urban green space as a resource in place making; support and retain affordable housing; retain and attract neighborhood businesses; and apply or adjust zoning laws and building regulations to transform spaces into desirable places by encouraging suitable development without displacement of the current residents and businesses. 1 Kurlychek, Megan, and Corianne P. Scally. 2013. A Pilot Assessment of Neighborhood Conditions in Albany’s South End and West Hill for the Governor’s CORe Initiative. 2 Kurlychek, Megan, and Corianne P. Scally. 2013. A Pilot Assessment of Neighborhood Conditions in Albany’s South End and West Hill for the Governor’s CORe Initiative. 3 Kurlychek, Megan, and Corianne P. Scally. 2013. A Pilot Assessment of Neighborhood Conditions in Albany’s South End and West Hill for the Governor’s CORe Initiative. 1 | P a g e Development Without Displacement Green Space II. MAKING THE MOST OF WHAT YOU HAVE - OPTIMIZING GREEN SPACES IN PLACE MAKING URBAN GREEN SPACE FOR HEALTH AND WELL-BEING The practice of developing or redeveloping parks and open spaces as catalysts for revitalizing neighborhoods and communities is spreading throughout the United States.4 The green spaces of the West Hill/West End neighborhoods in Albany, New York are a unique, enviable, and under- utilized resource that can be an asset to this community, providing a sense of place and pride. There is a considerable body of research that demonstrates the positive impact of green space to enhance a sense of wellbeing and mental health, and improve the ability to cope with life’s ups and downs.5 Studies show that the most highly valued open spaces are those which enhance urban life by providing a variety of opportunities and physical settings, encouraging socialization, and supporting cultural diversity.6 Recently published research in the United Kingdom suggests that people are happier when living in urban areas with greater amounts of green space.7 Open space and green spaces in a neighborhood are one of the significant issues in planning strategies in neighborhood rehabilitation. The urban, primarily residential neighborhoods of West Hill/West End are roughly 550 acres in size and are anchored by the 80-acre Tivoli
Recommended publications
  • 5 IMPLEMENTATION Implementation of the Hudson River Valley Greenway Trail Is an Ongoing Process
    5 IMPLEMENTATION Implementation of the Hudson River Valley Greenway Trail is an ongoing process. The existing hiking, biking and water trail routes can continue to be improved and promoted, while the multi-use path will require a significant level of new planning, design and capital investment. In the past 25 years, the Greenway has developed grass-roots and local government support for these efforts, providing an excellent foundation for the next generation of the trail system. The following actions are recommended for the ongoing success of the HRVG: 1. Continue promoting the Water Trail: this is the most direct connection to the river, and can be marketed without significant capital improvements to promote the whole Greenway. 2. Upgrade the existing Hiking Trails: The continuous hiking trail can be achieved with alignments closer to the river - and many of these key connections are already in progress. With the new TZ bridge path and the Walkway over the Hudson, a loop hiking trail can connect both sides of the river in the lower half of the valley. 3. Improve the on-road Bike Routes: the currently signed NYS Bike Route 9 is a challenging route and is limited to experienced cyclists. Improving signage, paved shoulders, bike lanes, bike parking and Amtrak access will all support increased use along the route. Both the PTNY and West Side routes are not currently designated, but they can be improved to create on-road routes on both sides of the river. 4. Develop the continuous Hudson River Valley Greenway Trail trunk line: the efforts of the past decades have led to significant new potential to create a continuous multi-use path the length of the Hudson River Valley from Manhattan to the Adirondacks.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Hudson River Access Plan Poughkeepsie to Rensselaer
    2020 HUDSON RIVER ACCESS PLAN POUGHKEEPSIE TO RENSSELAER FINAL REPORT GEORGE STAFFORD MARCH 2020 Photo courtesy of Jeanne Casatelli ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Hundreds of individuals, elected officials, agencies and organizations have contributed to the development of this document through their words and actions. They include: • People passionate about improved access to the Hudson River who attended public meetings, provided more than 1,000 comments and 5,000 votes on places where they use or wish to use the river, and have been directly involved in keeping access points open by taking part in cleanups along the shorelines and other activities. • Elected federal, state and local officials from Poughkeepsie to Rensselaer who provided letters and resolutions contained in this report, participated in phone interviews, facilitated public meeting sites, and elevated the importance of saving and increasing access points through their support of local plans and reports issued in recent years. • Individuals and organizations who collaborated on the Hudson River Access Forum that issued “Between the Railroad and the River—Public Access Issues and Opportunities along the Tidal Hudson.” This 1989 publication remains extremely relevant. • Finally, we wish to thank Matthew Atkinson, who authored “On the Wrong Side of the Railroad Tracks: Public Access to the Hudson River” (1996) for the Pace Environmental Law Review. This work provides a phenomenal review of the public trust doctrine and the legal principles governing the railroads’ obligation to provide river access. Mr. Atkinson’s advice during the development of this document proved invaluable. CONTACT / PRIMARY AUTHORS CONTACT Jeffrey Anzevino, AICP Director of Land Use Advocacy Scenic Hudson, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • New York State Open Space Conservation Plan 2005
    Draft New York State Open Space Conservation Plan 2005 Draft New York State Open Space Conservation Plan & Generic Environmental Impact Statement November 2005 George E. Pataki, Governor Prepared by: The Department of Environmental Conservation Denise M. Sheehan, Acting Commissioner The Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Bernadette Castro, Commissioner The Department of State First Deputy Secretary of State Frank Milano DRAFT GENERIC ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT COVER SHEET Title. .New York State 2005 Draft Open Space Conservation Plan and Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement Responsible Agencies. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Project Location. Statewide Prepared By. Staff of the Responsible Agencies Contact Persons. DEC, Francis Sheehan, (518) 402-9405 OPRHP, Robert Reinhardt, (518)474-0415 Date of Completion . November 9, 2005 Comments Due. .. January 18, 2005 Address. .Open Space Conservation Plan 625 Broadway, 5th Floor Albany, NY 12233-4250 Fdsa NEW YORK STATE’S OPEN SPACE CONSERVATION PLAN 2005 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT INTRODUCTION ................................................ 1 Creating New York’s Open Space Conservation Plan ............... 2 Developing this Plan........................................ 5 CHAPTER I - FOUNDATIONS OF THE OPEN SPACE PLAN ............ 9 Guiding Principles for the Open Space Conservation Plan ........... 9 Definition of Open Space .................................... 9 Goals
    [Show full text]
  • Tivoli Lake Preserve: Community Engagement & Visioning Plan Final
    (Re) Imagining Tivoli Lake Preserve: Community Engagement & Visioning Plan Final Report Prepared for: The City of Albany Department of Development & Planning Prepared by: Tivoli Lake Preserve Community Engagement & Visioning Plan This document was prepared for the Hudson River Estuary Program, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, with support from the New York State Environmental Protection Fund, in cooperation with the New England Interstate Water Pollution Control Commission. The viewpoints expressed here do not represent those of NEIWPCC or NYSDEC, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or causes constitute endorsement or recommendation for use. Tivoli Lake Preserve Visioning Plan - Final Report Introduction In the Spring of 2014, the City of Albany began assessing opportunities to improve Tivoli Lake Preserve (Tivoli), a natural resource project that aligns with goals set in the City’s Albany 2030: Comprehensive Plan. Creating a Visioning Plan that would redevelop Tivoli and bring out its full potential required extensive community and stakeholder outreach and engagement in order to gather ideas, address concerns, form recommendations and prioritize future improvements. It was clear from the beginning that residents, the City, and other interested parties were passionate about the Preserve and strongly supported actions that would make it both a local and regional destination. Tivoli, located in the West Hill Neighborhood, is a unique property with immense potential. This project is about the future of the Preserve. It is about transforming the currently underutilized property in a methodical and implementable fashion. The intent is that the Preserve will be a source of pride for residents in the surrounding community, utilized by many from around the region and beyond, and one day talked about as an example of what can be done when a community comes together through hard work, common interests, and a desire to improve their neighborhood.
    [Show full text]
  • Mohawk-Hudson Bike-Hike Trail - Albany to Cohoes Section AREA of MAP COVERAGE
    Mohawk-Hudson Bike-Hike Trail - Albany to Cohoes Section AREA OF MAP COVERAGE Saratoga Springs l i l a a r D n T R D a Y l R E a N M C R H n G ID E a U n 32 V D A I i H Schenectady L C Troy R R E a R INDUSTRY DR T l E n D O i T p W R a T N l R m D RD Albany N D p K E R A C R A I E a R R T V L N L L D S I R A D C m M h E T Y R R S W S N A a V I I N J F E N E O N C R O h T E R R N S M W N T E D D R C S T O A C A C O K V d E R A N J S S R T l D N A U N D O U E E S M B IS d U EM S U L l IN R N R I If it were not for a few vantage points along the trail overlooking O H OL S F R E A IG O H C L A V O E I I GH H B E L T EL P R G S R W R A the City of Cohoes, you would be unaware of traveling through D AD S E A E D a R ST Schaghticoke E R O D M IC I Lock 5 t HFI LLS H e EL HI the river city at the confluence of the Mohawk and Hudson Lock 4 r D ST O H f E ILL C o CR V E r ST A d A VE Rivers.
    [Show full text]
  • Windows on History
    EXPLORING THE HUDSON RIVER VALLEY NATIONAL HERITAGE AREA Windows on History A rail journey through the Hudson River Valley, between New York City and Albany, is more than a trip from point A to point B. It’s a voyage through a landscape rich in history and beauty. Just look out the window… Na lley tion Va al r H e e v r i i t R a g n e o A s r d e u a H Na lley tion Va al r H e e v r i i t R a g n e o A s r d e u a H W ELCOME TO THE HUDSON RIVER VALLEY! RAVELING THROUGH THIS HISTORIC REGION, you will discover the people, places, and events that formed our national identity, and led Congress to designate the Hudson River Valley as a National Heritage Area in 1996. The Hudson River has also been designated one of our country’s Great American Rivers. TAs you journey between New York’s Pennsylvania station and the Albany- Rensselaer station, this guide will interpret the sites and features that you see out your train window, including historic sites that span three centuries of our nation’s history. You will also learn about the communities and cultural resources that are located only a short journey from the various This project was made station stops. possible through a partnership between the We invite you to explore the four million acres Hudson River Valley that make up the Hudson Valley and discover its National Heritage Area rich scenic, historic, cultural, and recreational and I Love NY.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 27 , Number 1
    THE HUDSON RIVER VALLEY REVIEW A Journal of Regional Studies The Hudson River Valley Institute at Marist College is supported by a major grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities. Publisher Thomas S. Wermuth, Vice President for Academic Affairs, Marist College Editors Christopher Pryslopski, Program Director, Hudson River Valley Institute, Marist College Reed Sparling, Writer, Scenic Hudson Editorial Board Art Director Myra Young Armstead, Professor of History, Richard Deon Bard College Business Manager Col. Lance Betros, Professor and Head, Andrew Villani Department of History, U.S. Military Academy at West Point The Hudson River Valley Review (ISSN 1546-3486) is published twice Kim Bridgford, Professor of English, a year by the Hudson River Valley West Chester University Poetry Center Institute at Marist College. and Conference James M. Johnson, Executive Director Michael Groth, Professor of History, Wells College Susan Ingalls Lewis, Assistant Professor of History, Research Assistants State University of New York at New Paltz Alyssa Hewitt Sarah Olson, Superintendent, Roosevelt- Maxine Presto Vanderbilt National Historic Sites Amanda Schreiner Roger Panetta, Professor of History, Hudson River Valley Institute Fordham University Advisory Board H. Daniel Peck, Professor of English, Peter Bienstock, Acting Chair Vassar College Dr. Frank Bumpus Robyn L. Rosen, Associate Professor of History, Frank J. Doherty Marist College Shirley M. Handel David Schuyler, Professor of American Studies, Marjorie Hart Franklin & Marshall College
    [Show full text]
  • 2016 NYS Open Space Conservation Plan
    Department of Parks, Recreation Department Agriculture Department of Environmental and Historic of State and Markets Transportation Conservation Preservation 2016 NEW YORK STATE OPEN SPACE CONSERVATION PLAN www.dec.ny.gov REGIONAL PRIORITY CONSERVATION PROJECTS Priority Projects Map 2016 NEW YORK STATE OPEN SPACE CONSERVATION PLAN 76 REGIONAL PRIORITY CONSERVATION PROJECTS Ecoregions Map The identification of seven (7) distinct ecological systems or “ecoregions” within New York State will assist DEC in achieving a more unified ecosystem-based approach to managing our state's natural resources. For more information on ecoregions, see the www.worldwildlife.org/science/ecoregions/item1847.html. ECOREGIONS NEW NEW YORK YORK STATE New York State Ecoregions Identified by The Nature Conservancy (TNC) 2016 NEW YORK STATE OPEN SPACE CONSERVATION PLAN 77 REGIONAL PRIORITY CONSERVATION PROJECTS REGIONAL PRIORITY CONSERVATION PROJECTS NEW33B YORK STATE'S REGIONAL OPEN SPACE ADVISORY COMMITTEES The following conservation projects have been identified through the nine Regional Advisory Committees (Committees) and public comments received through the Open Space Conservation Plan's (Plan) review process. It represents the unique and irreplaceable open space resources of New York that encompass exceptional ecological, wildlife, recreational, scenic, and historical values. The identification of these projects is a result of extensive analysis of our state's open space conservation needs by the Committees, in consultation with DEC and OPRHP staff. These projects are filtered through a wide spectrum of professional expertise found on each of the Committees through a consensus-based process. Each of DEC’s nine administrative regions is represented by a Committee consisting of members appointed by the DEC and OPRHP commissioners, and by each of the counties within each region.
    [Show full text]
  • Patroon Greenway Project
    Patroon Greenway Project A Community and Transportation Linkage Planning Project Task 1 Report: Existing Conditions, Opportunities and Constraints Prepared for: Capital Distric t Transportation Committee Albany, New York May, 2004 Jeff Olson, R.A. 10 Clark Street Saratoga Springs, NY 12866 USA 518.584.6634 [email protected] John B. Thomas 334 Poyneer Road Nassau, New York, USA 12123 [email protected] Patroon Greenway Project - Task 1 Report Patroon Greenway Project Task 1 Report: Existing Conditions, Opportunities and Constraints Table of Contents 1. Overview of the Study Area.................................................... 3 2. Map of Tax Parcel Ownership................................................. 4 3. Trail Alignment............................................................................ 6 4. Route Opportunities and Constraints..................................... 7 5. Current Land Uses .................................................................... 9 6. Land Ownership / Right of Way Issues ............................... 10 7. Alignment Analysis .................................................................. 11 8. Next Steps……………………………………………………15 9. Appendix: NYSDOT Concept Plan, Aerial Photos with Field Notes, Existing Conditions Photos, Patroon Creek Waterway Map………………………………………………….16 This project is funded through the Capital District Transportation Committee’s (CDTC) Community and Transportation Linkage Planning Program. Trailblazer / Taconic Green Team 2 Patroon Greenway Project - Task 1
    [Show full text]
  • Tivoli Trail/Parking/Fishing Pier
    THE TIVOLI PRESERVE: TRAIL AND PARK IMPROVEMENTS ALBANY, NEW YORK DECEMBER 5, 2016 CITY OF ALBANY NEW YORK REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS (RFP 2018-27) AUGUST 28, 2018 CITY OF ALBANY, NEW YORK REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR THE PROVISION OF DESIGN SERVICES FOR: TIVOLI PRESERVE TRAIL & PARK IMPROVEMENTS SECTION 1: PURPOSE 1.1 The City of Albany hereby requests proposals from qualified landscape architecture / urban design / engineering / trail design teams to provide design, specifications, bid materials, and construction administration services related to the design and construction of the Tivoli Preserve Loop Trail, parking lot enhancements, and fishing pier. This initiative is made possible through funds from the Environmental Protection Funds under the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) under Contract # DEC01-41GG-3350000. SECTION 2: PROJECT AREA AND PROJECT DESCRIPTION 2.1 PROJECT AREA: The Tivoli Lake Preserve (the “Preserve”) is an 80-acre park located between Livingston Avenue, Northern Boulevard, and Interstate 90 in the West Hill neighborhood of Albany. The surrounding area contains a mix of uses including light industrial, residential, and institutional. The Preserve borders an active CSX freight line, which runs through the northern section of the property. The preserve contains a dynamic landscape including Tivoli Lake, riparian wetlands, upland forests, meadows, and a wide variety of flora and fauna. The Patroon Creek, a local tributary to the Hudson River which runs along the Preserve’s northern border, is currently undergoing a daylighting improvement project which will help with downstream flooding issues, as well as improve water quality with downstream and potentially in Tivoli Lake.
    [Show full text]
  • CDTC Executive Director Michael Franchini Announces Retirement!
    Volume 13, Issue 4 June 2021 INNewsletter MOTION of the Capital District Transportation Committee (CDTC) Metropolitan Planning Organization for New York’s Capital Region INSIDE THIS ISSUE: CDTC Executive Director Michael Franchini Announces Retirement! CDTC Executive Director 1 Executive Director of the Capital District Transportation Committee, Michael Announces Retirement! Franchini announced he will retire in July. Franchini, who has led CDTC for the past Village of Scotia 9 years, began with the organization in 1997 when he was appointed Albany Coun- Downtown Connections 2 ty Deputy Commissioner of Public Works by County Executive Michael G. Breslin, Study Kicks Off and began representing Albany County at the Capital District Transportation Com- CDTC Launches First mittee. Annual “Ditch the Car” 3 Challenge “It has been a pleasure to lead CDTC over the past 9 years.” said Michael Franchi- The Patroon Creek ni, CDTC Executive Director. “The choice to retire was not an easy decision, but Greenway: A Vision I felt the time was right. I would like to thank all the CDTC members for their co- for Connecting Albany’s 4 operation, participation, and their willingness to reach a regional consensus. I’m Waterfront to the Pine looking forward to spending more time with my wife and our kids and grandkids.” Bush Preserve Born and raised in the City of Albany, Michael attended Vincentian Institute. After Congratulations Michael! high school he received an appointment to the United States Coast Guard Academy From Our CDTC 5 Members! in New London, Connecticut, and graduated in 1977 with a Bachelor of Sciences in Oceanography. (Continuted on Page 4) Quotable Quote “Physically robust infrastructure is not enough if it fails to foster a healthy community; ultimately, all infrastructure is social.” -Pete Buttigieg U.S Secretary of Transportation Image: Michael enjoying one of his last days in the office.
    [Show full text]
  • Review of Plans for the City of Albany
    REVIEW OF PLANS FOR THE CITY OF ALBANY Compiled in 2012 for Partners for Albany Stories (PASt), by Aine Leader-Nagy, researching consultant, for the development of an Interpretive Plan for Albany. Funding provided by the Hudson River Valley Greenway Communities Grant program Contents Albany 2030 Comprehensive Plan..........................................................................................2-39 Albany Sustainable Design Assistance Team (SDAT), A Sustainable Capital for the 21st Century (2007) ........................................................40-52 Capitalize Albany: Economic Development Strategy for New York’s Capital City (1996) .......................................................................................53-66 Management Plan for the Albany Urban Cultural Park (1987)..........................................67-118 Arbor Hill Neighborhood Plan (July, 2003)..........................................................................119-141 Capital South Plan: SEGway to the Future (2007) .............................................................142-147 Erie Canalway National Heritage Corridor Preservation and Management Plan (October 2006)...........................................................................148-187 Heritage Areas of New York State (February 2010)............................................................188-192 Hudson River Valley National Heritage Area Management Plan (2002)..........................193-205 New York State Convention Center: Key Information (2012)..........................................206-209
    [Show full text]