Frances Power Cobbe and the Anti-Vivisection Controversy in Victorian Britain, 1870-1904

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Frances Power Cobbe and the Anti-Vivisection Controversy in Victorian Britain, 1870-1904 University of Calgary PRISM: University of Calgary's Digital Repository Graduate Studies Legacy Theses 2000 "Those candid and ingenuous vivisectors": Frances Power Cobbe and the anti-vivisection controversy in Victorian Britain, 1870-1904 Montgomery, Brooke Montgomery, B. (2000). "Those candid and ingenuous vivisectors": Frances Power Cobbe and the anti-vivisection controversy in Victorian Britain, 1870-1904 (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Calgary, Calgary, AB. doi:10.11575/PRISM/13131 http://hdl.handle.net/1880/39765 master thesis University of Calgary graduate students retain copyright ownership and moral rights for their thesis. You may use this material in any way that is permitted by the Copyright Act or through licensing that has been assigned to the document. For uses that are not allowable under copyright legislation or licensing, you are required to seek permission. Downloaded from PRISM: https://prism.ucalgary.ca UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY "Those Candid and Ingenuous Vivisectors": Frances Power Cobbe and the tinti-Vivisection Controversy in Victorian Britain, 1 870-1 904. Brooke ~Montgomery A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY CALGARY, ALBERTA my2000 O Brooke Montgomery 2000 National Library Bibliothhue nationale 191 of Canada du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliographic Services services bibliographiques 395 Wellington Street 395, rue Wellington Ottawa ON K1A ON4 Ottawa ON K1AON4 Canada Canada Your hk Votre r~fcirmtd Our 1Ye Norre rdHnmae The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accorde me licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive pernettant a la National Library of Canada to Bibliotheque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distribute or sell reproduire, prster, distribuer ou copies of this thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette these sous paper or electronic formats. la forme de microfiche/film, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format electronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriete du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protege cette these. thesis nor substantial extracts f?om it Ni la these ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or otherwise de celle-ci ne doivent etre imprirnes reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. ABSTRACT This thesis examines the anti-vivisection controveny of late Victorian Britain, looking particularly at the involvement of Frances Power Cobbe, leader and morai centre of the movement It explores the way that the idea of progress informed arguments on both sides of the debate and turned emerging scientific discourse into contested ground on which two sides fought over which would be the one to define what progress meant for British society. Women were prominent on the anti-vivisection side while men dominated the growing scienufic profession and consequently the arguments of Cobbe and others that emerged out of the controversy were gendered and frequently made associations between the treatment of women and of animals. Many people were instrumental in helping me complete this thesis. First of all, I would like to thank my supervisor Dr. Douglas Peen without whose support and guidance this study could not have been completed. I would also like to thank memben of the History Department who provided input on this thesis, particularly the members of my committee, Dr. Elizabeth Jameson and Dr. Martln Staum. Thanks also to Dr. Gretchen MacMillan fiom the Political Science department who was the external examiner. In addition I must thank the Rstory Department for their generous financial support which allowed me to devote most of my time and energy to my studies. I would also like to extend my heartfelt gratitude to my fellow graduate students, Chns Mummery, Jeff Wigelsworth, James Ems, James Warren and Kristin Bumett, who provided fhendship, emotional support and humour throughout my two years of study. I would particularly like to thank Whitney Lackenbauer who offered invaluable insight and advice and who was always a good sparring partner during our fiequent debates. Thanks also to my co-workers in the University Archives who were always interested in my work, supportive and encouraging. I would like to offer a very special thanks to my dear friend Jennifer Arthur who was always there when I needed to talk or go shopping and who is truly a 'kindred spirit' Finally, thank you to my parents Bill and Sharonne Montgomery and my brother Craig for their love and support and for their unwavering faith in my abilities. I could not have done it without them. TABLE OF CONTENTS Approval Page. ................................................................................... ii .-. Abstract.......................................................................................... -111 Acknowledgements.............................................................................. iv Table of Contents................................................................................. v Introduction. ................ Chapter One: Context of Controversy: ...................................................... 17 Animal Welfare Sentiment and the Regulation of Vivisection. 1800-1900 Chapter Two: The Life of Frances Power Cobbe: ........................................36 Philanthropy as Woman's Mission Chapter Three: Feminising the Anima! Body: ........................................... .1lO Women, Animals and Anti-Vivisection in the Writing of Frances Power Cobbe Conclusion.. ................................................................................... .I44 Bibliography.................................................................................... 147 INTRODUCTION Controversy over the practice of vivisection has plagued scientists fiom the nineteenth centuly until the present in both Britain and North America. It has become a particularly contentious issue in the last thirty years as animal rights proponents have united to promote the liberation of animals from laboratories. Contemporary debates about the practice of vivisection, however, are substantially different fiom nineteenth-century arguments. Today, philosophers such as Peter Singer, Tom Regan and Stephen Clarke, though arguing &om different philosophical perspectives, all agree that animals are intrinsically valuable and morally relevant beings who have the right to live free fiom human abuse and exploitation.' The =ti-vivisection movement of late Victorian Bntain, though in many ways a precursor to today because it engaged in questions of our moral obligation to animals, had a fbndamentally different philosophical starting point. In the past, debate centred primarily on the morality of causing pain to helpless animals, yet those involved in the movement never questioned the hierarchy of being that placed humans above animals. Singer, Regan and Clarke agree that the existence of a hierarchy of being -has been used, and continues to be used, as the justification for many forms of animal abuse, including the use of animals for vivisection. What the contemporary animal rights movement does have in common with the anti- vivisection movement of the nineteenth century is the substantial presence of women. I See Keith Tester, -4nimals and Sociey: The Hummip of Animal Rights (New York : Roudedge. t 99 1). 1- 16 for a ddiscussion of the basic arguments of Singer, Regan and Clake. See also, Peter Singer, .4nimal Liberation, (New Yok: Avon Books, 1 979,Tom Regan, The Case for.4nmalRighrs.h. (BakeIq: Universic of California Press, 1983). Tom Regan, The Sn~ggIefor Animal Righn, (Clarke Summit: International Society for Animal Rights, Inc., 1987), and Stephen Clarke, ThehfomlSrms of .4nimalr. (Oshrd: Clmdon Press, 1977). Currently, women compose seventy to eighty percent of animal rights adherents.' It cannot, however, be stated that anti-vivisection was a feminist cause, then or now. Although women who supported it in the nineteenth century often recognised that the oppression of both women and animals was interconnected and that many members of the movement were also feminists, the two causes never actually united and, in fact, sometimes saw their aims as antithetical. The distance between the two groups became more acute in the twentieth century as liberal feminists made a concerted effort to dissociate themselves from any identdication with animals or animal causes because they believed that much of the justification for women's alleged inferiority was based on their association with the "animal," represented by the body. Men, on the other hand, were traditionally linked to the mind or rationality. And as Lynda Birke puts it "to be closer to animals in our culture is to be denigrated."' Feminists, therefore, have asserted that women and men are both rational being distinct fiom animals. But the implication is that they are better than animals and indeed the identification of women as rational agents has deliberately rested on the premise that humans and animals are different and that 'humanness' is a superior quality. Some feminists and male supporters of feminism within the animal rights movement, however, are beginning to challenge the traditional human centred view and to see it as part of the dominant and patriarchal culture. They argue that liberal feminists are buylng into this culture when they privilege the mind over the body, the human over the animal, and reason over emotion.
Recommended publications
  • Levinas and the New Woman Writers: Narrating the Ethics of Alterity
    Georgia State University ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University English Dissertations Department of English 12-10-2018 Levinas and the New Woman Writers: Narrating the Ethics of Alterity Anita Turlington Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/english_diss Recommended Citation Turlington, Anita, "Levinas and the New Woman Writers: Narrating the Ethics of Alterity." Dissertation, Georgia State University, 2018. https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/english_diss/210 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of English at ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in English Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. LEVINAS AND THE NEW WOMAN WRITERS: NARRATING THE ETHICS OF ALTERITY by ANITA TURLINGTON Under the Direction of Leeanne Richardson, PhD ABSTRACT This study applies the ethical theories of Emmanuel Levinas to the novels and short stories of the major New Woman novelists of the fin de siècle in England. Chapter One introduces the study and its theoretical framework. Chapter Two discusses how New Woman writers confront their protagonists with ethical dilemmas framed as face-to-face encounters that can be read as the moment of ethics formation. They also gesture toward openness and indeterminacy through their use of carnivalesque characters. In Chapter Three, Levinas’s concepts of the said and the saying illuminate readings of polemical passages that interrogate the function of language to oppress or empower women. Chapter Four reads dreams, visions, allegories, and proems as mythic references to a golden age past that reframe the idea of feminine altruism.
    [Show full text]
  • Download The
    GENIUS, WOMANHOOD AND THE STATISTICAL IMAGINARY: 1890s HEREDITY THEORY IN THE BRITISH SOCIAL NOVEL by ZOE GRAY BEAVIS B.A. Hons., La Trobe University, 2006 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE AND POSTDOCTORAL STUDIES (English) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) October 2014 © Zoe Gray Beavis, 2014 Abstract The central argument of this thesis is that several tropes or motifs exist in social novels of the 1890s which connect them with each other in a genre, and which indicate a significant literary preoccupation with contemporary heredity theory. These tropes include sibling and twin comparison stories, the woman musician’s conflict between professionalism and domesticity, and speculation about biparental inheritance. The particulars of heredity theory with which these novels engage are consistent with the writings of Francis Galton, specifically on hereditary genius and regression theory, sibling and twin biometry, and theoretical population studies. Concurrent with the curiosity of novelists about science, was the anxiety of scientists about discursive linguistic sharing. In the thesis, I illuminate moments when science writers (Galton, August Weismann, William Bates, and Karl Pearson) acknowledged the literary process and the reading audience. I have structured the thesis around the chronological appearance of heredity themes in 1890s social novels, because I am arguing for the existence of a broader cultural curiosity about heredity themes, irrespective of authors’ primary engagement with scientific texts. Finally, I introduce the statistical imaginary as a framework for understanding human difference through populations and time, as evidenced by the construction of theoretical population samples – communities, crowds, and peer groups – in 1890s social fictions.
    [Show full text]
  • The Sexual Politics of Meat by Carol J. Adams
    THE SEXUAL POLITICS OF MEAT A FEMINISTVEGETARIAN CRITICAL THEORY Praise for The Sexual Politics of Meat and Carol J. Adams “A clearheaded scholar joins the ideas of two movements—vegetari- anism and feminism—and turns them into a single coherent and moral theory. Her argument is rational and persuasive. New ground—whole acres of it—is broken by Adams.” —Colman McCarthy, Washington Post Book World “Th e Sexual Politics of Meat examines the historical, gender, race, and class implications of meat culture, and makes the links between the prac tice of butchering/eating animals and the maintenance of male domi nance. Read this powerful new book and you may well become a vegetarian.” —Ms. “Adams’s work will almost surely become a ‘bible’ for feminist and pro gressive animal rights activists. Depiction of animal exploita- tion as one manifestation of a brutal patriarchal culture has been explored in two [of her] books, Th e Sexual Politics of Meat and Neither Man nor Beast: Feminism and the Defense of Animals. Adams argues that factory farming is part of a whole culture of oppression and insti- tutionalized violence. Th e treatment of animals as objects is parallel to and associated with patriarchal society’s objectifi cation of women, blacks, and other minorities in order to routinely exploit them. Adams excels in constructing unexpected juxtapositions by using the language of one kind of relationship to illuminate another. Employing poetic rather than rhetorical techniques, Adams makes powerful connec- tions that encourage readers to draw their own conclusions.” —Choice “A dynamic contribution toward creating a feminist/animal rights theory.” —Animals’ Agenda “A cohesive, passionate case linking meat-eating to the oppression of animals and women .
    [Show full text]
  • Higher Laws" "Higher
    tcny n<,rt IIInl J J A BENEFACTOR OF HIS RACE: THOREAU'S "HIGHER LAWS" AND THE HEROICS OF VEGETARIANISM ROBERT EPSTEIN grasped and lived by is the law which says: "Follow your own gen­ Berkeley, California ius"--be what you are, whether you are by your own nature hunter, or Was Thoreau a vegetarian or not? There wood chopper, or scholar. When you are several answers to this question. have become perfect you will be perfect; but only if you have If dietary practice is to be the sole learned to be, all along, what at criterion for judging, then Thoreau cannot be each manent you were. (pp 84-5) considered a vegetarian, since, by his own account, he ate fish and meat (though the Echoing Thoreau, the eminent psycholo­ latter rarely). gist, Carl G. Jung once wrote: Yet, despite this fact, Thoreau espoused I had to obey an inner law which a vegetarian ethic. So, his practice does was :irr\posed on me and left me no not suffice as a criterion for judging the freedanfreedom of choice. Of course I did extent of his vegetarianism. Consequently, not always obey it. How can anyone he has been criticized numerous times, e.g. live without inconsistency? (1965, by Wagenknecht, 1981, Garber, 1977, Jones, p. 356) 1954, for being inconsistent. How consistent was he in adhering to the vegetarian ideal? What we need to do in Thoreau scholarship-­ The question is not easy to answer. We must particularly regarding his dietary views--is ask: consistent from whose point of view? put aside our judgments of inconsistency The notion of consistency cannot always and (which frequently represent a defense against easily be objectively detennined,determined, because the areas of conflict in us) and attempt to un­ critic's own biases distort that which is derstand Thoreau franfrom within his own frame of ref~ence.[l] being viewed, in this case Thoreau's vegetar­ The question with which we ianism.
    [Show full text]
  • Mona Caird's the Daughters of Danaus (1894) As A
    UNIVERSITE D’ ANTANANARIVO ECOLE NORMALE SUPERIEURE DEPARTEMENT DE FORMATION INITIALE LITTERAIRE CENTRE D’ETUDE ET DE RECHERCHE EN LANGUE ET LETTRE ANGLAISES MEMOIRE DE CERTIFICAT D’ APTITUDE PEDAGOGIQUE DE L’ ECOLE NORMALE (C.A.P.E.N ) MONA CAIRD’S THE DAUGHTERS OF DANAUS (1894) AS A REFLECTION OF THE EARLY ASPECTS OF FEMINISM IN BRITAIN PRESENTED BY : RAHARIJHON Mbolasoa Nadine DISSERTATION ADVISOR Mrs RABENORO Mireille Date de soutenance : 22 Décembre 2006 ACADEMIC YEAR : 2005-2006 When you accuse me of not being * When you accuse me of not being Like a woman I wonder what like is And how one becomes it I think woman is what Women are And as I am one So must that be included In what woman is So, there fore, I am like by Pat Van Twest. ___________________________________________________________________________ * HEALY, Maura, Women , England, 1984, Longman p. 28 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We address our deep gratitude to : - Mrs RABENORO Mireille, our dissertation advisor, for her precious contribution to the elaboration of this dissertation - Mrs RAZAIARIVELO A. for her advice which were so useful for the achievement of this work. - Mr RAZAFINDRATSIMA E. for he is the one who inspired us the very topic of this dissertation. - Mr Manoro Regis, our teacher and the head of English Department at E.N.S. for his kindness, his patience, and above all his helpful advice. - All our teachers at the English Department of E.N.S. for their support and follow-up while through on the five years’ training. - Our dearest parents and our sister for the kind support they brought to us during all this time.
    [Show full text]
  • Animal Rites and Justice
    BEI'WEEN THE SPFX::IES 190 Although the service had supporters both Morning, a magazine for Presbyterian minis­ within and without the religious canmunity, a ters, a Presbyterian pastor accused the ser­ few ministers of the Christian faith, in vice of "humanism," stating that, "We are of particular two publicly and one through my the refonned. faith, the church refonned. al­ acquaintance, said they would not attend such ways reforming. I hardly believe that funer­ a service as ani.rna/ls do not have souls, and als like the one for Wind-of-Fire are steps therefore, it was inappropriate to hold a in this refonnation process." Another pas­ service which implied that anima/ls would tor, responding in the September, 1985, is­ participate in a resurrection, afterlife, or sued of the same magazine, countered this by in particular heaven. saying, "the pastor reports, and seemingly has problems with, the minister saying that Anna Kingsford, a nineteenth century God I S Love extends to all of creation and feminist/mystic and anima/l rights activist, offering prayers for animals that are victims pointed out that all forms of life are re­ of human injustice. I am disturbed by what garded as having souls within the Judea/ this seems to say both about the role of a Christian tradition. In Genesis, the word in pastor towards a grieving person and about Hebrew which applies to all living things is the relationship of humans to animals."[3] "Nephesh," meaning soul. As Kingsford points out, in '!he Perfect~, a series of her Q1e humorous response to the service lectures published in London in 1882, "had appeared in a column called "Insect Rights," the Bible been accurately translated, the by John C.
    [Show full text]
  • Aproximações Preliminares Ao Debate Entre Frances Power
    História, Ciências, Saúde - Manguinhos ISSN: 0104-5970 [email protected] Fundação Oswaldo Cruz Brasil de Lima Carvalho, André Luis; Waizbort, Ricardo A dor além dos confins do homem: aproximações preliminares ao debate entre Frances Power Cobbe e os darwinistas a respeito da vivissecção na Inglaterra vitoriana (1863- 1904) História, Ciências, Saúde - Manguinhos, vol. 17, núm. 3, 2010, pp. 577-605 Fundação Oswaldo Cruz Rio de Janeiro, Brasil Available in: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=386138050002 How to cite Complete issue Scientific Information System More information about this article Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America, the Caribbean, Spain and Portugal Journal's homepage in redalyc.org Non-profit academic project, developed under the open access initiative Pain beyond the confines of man Pain beyond the confines of man: a preliminary CARVALHO, André Luis de Lima; WAIZBORT, Ricardo. Pain beyond the introduction to the confines of man: a preliminary introduction to the debate between debate between Frances Frances Power Cobbe and the Darwinists with respect to vivisection Power Cobbe and the in Victorian England (1863-1904). História, Ciências, Saúde – Manguinhos, Darwinists with respect to Rio de Janeiro, v.17, n.3, July-Sept. 2010. Available at: http:// vivisection in Victorian www.scielo.br. England Abstract (1863-1904) This article introduces a person who is little known and studied in the Brazilian and South-American academic communities. Frances Power Cobbe was a British woman in the Victorial period engaged in various social causes, among them the abolition of vivisection. In her later years, Cobbe criticized any use of live animals in laboratory experiments, with or without the use of anesthetics.
    [Show full text]
  • Equality, Priority and Nonhuman Animals*
    Equality, Priority and Catia Faria Nonhuman Animals* Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Department of Law [email protected] http://upf.academia.edu/catiafaria Igualdad, prioridad y animales no humanos ABSTRACT: This paper assesses the implications of egali- RESUMEN: Este artículo analiza las implicaciones del iguali- tarianism and prioritarianism for the consideration of tarismo y del prioritarismo en lo que refiere a la conside- nonhuman animals. These implications have been often ración de los animales no humanos. Estas implicaciones overlooked. The paper argues that neither egalitarianism han sido comúnmente pasadas por alto. Este artículo de- nor prioritarianism can consistently deprive nonhuman fenderá que ni el igualitarismo ni el prioritarismo pueden animals of moral consideration. If you really are an egali- privar de forma consistente de consideración moral a los tarian (or a prioritarian) you are necessarily committed animales no humanos. Si realmente alguien es igualitaris- both to the rejection of speciesism and to assigning prior- ta (o prioritarista) ha de tener necesariamente una posi- ity to the interests of nonhuman animals, since they are ción de rechazo del especismo, y estar a favor de asignar the worst-off. From this, important practical consequen- prioridad a los intereses de los animales no humanos, ces follow for the improvement of the current situation of dado que estos son los que están peor. De aquí se siguen nonhuman animals. importantes consecuencias prácticas para la mejora de la situación actual de los animales no humanos. KEYWORDS: egalitarianism, prioritarianism, nonhuman ani- PALABRAS-CLAVE: igualitarismo, prioritarismo, animales no hu- mals, speciesism, equality manos, especismo, igualdad 1. Introduction It is commonly assumed that human beings should be given preferential moral consideration, if not absolute priority, over the members of other species.
    [Show full text]
  • 'An Incredibly Vile Sport': Campaigns Against Otter Hunting in Britain
    Rural History (2016) 27, 1, 000-000. © Cambridge University Press 2016 ‘An incredibly vile sport’: Campaigns against Otter Hunting in Britain, 1900-39 DANIEL ALLEN, CHARLES WATKINS AND DAVID MATLESS School of Physical and Geographical Sciences, University of Keele, ST5 5BG, UK [email protected] School of Geography, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham, NG7 2RD, UK [email protected] [email protected] Abstract: Otter hunting was a minor field sport in Britain but in the early years of the twentieth century a lively campaign to ban it was orchestrated by several individuals and anti-hunting societies. The sport became increasingly popular in the late nineteenth century and the Edwardian period. This paper examines the arguments and methods used in different anti-otter hunting campaigns 1900-1939 by organisations such as the Humanitarian League, the League for the Prohibition of Cruel Sports and the National Association for the Abolition of Cruel Sports. Introduction In 2010 a painting ‘normally considered too upsetting for modern tastes’ which ‘while impressive’ was also ‘undeniably "gruesome"’ was displayed at an exhibition of British sporting art at the Bowes Museum, Barnard Castle. The Guardian reported that the grisly content of the painting was ‘the reason why it was taken off permanent display by its owners’ the Laing Gallery in Newcastle.1 The painting, Sir Edwin Landseer’s The Otter Speared, Portrait of the Earl of Aberdeen's Otterhounds, or the Otter Hunt had been associated with controversy since it was first exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1844 Daniel Allen, Charles Watkins and David Matless 2 (Figure 1).
    [Show full text]
  • The White Slave Trade and the Yellow Peril: Anti-Chinese Rhetoric and Women's Moral Authority a Thesis Submitted to the Depart
    The White Slave Trade and the Yellow Peril: Anti-Chinese Rhetoric and Women’s Moral Authority A thesis submitted to the Department of History, Miami University, in partial fulfillment of the Requirements for Honors in History by Hannah E. Zmuda May 2021 Oxford, Ohio Abstract Despite the mid-to-late nineteenth and early twentieth century’s cultural preoccupation with white women’s sexual vulnerability, another phenomenon managed to take hold of public consciousness: “yellow slavery.” Yellow slavery was the variation of white slavery (known today as sex trafficking) that described the practice when Asian women were the victims. This thesis attempts to determine several of the reasons why Chinese women were included as victims in an otherwise exclusively white victim pool. One of the central reasons was the actual existence of the practice, which this thesis attempts to verify through the critical examination of found contracts and testimony of Chinese women. However, beyond just the existence of the practice of yellow slavery, many individuals used the sexual exploitation of Chinese women for their own cultural, religious, and political ends. Anti-Chinese agitators leveraged the image of the Chinese slave girl to frame anti-Chinese efforts as anti-slavery efforts, as well as to depict Chinese immigrants as incapable of assimilating into American culture and adhering to American ideals of freedom. Additionally, white missionaries created mission homes to shelter and protect the Chinese women and girls escaping white slavery. However, within these homes, the missionaries were then able to push their perceived cultural and religious superiority by pushing the home’s inmates into their ideals of Protestant, middle-class, white womanhood.
    [Show full text]
  • Doctor of Philosophy
    RICE UNIVERSITY By Drew Robert Winter A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE Doctor of Philosophy APPROVED, THESIS COMMITTEE Cymene Howe (Apr 15, 2020) Cymene Howe James Faubion James Faubion (Apr 15, 2020) James Faubion Cary Wolfe Cary Wolfe (Apr 16, 2020) Cary Wolfe HOUSTON, TEXAS April 2020 i Abstract Hyperanimals: framing livestock and climate change in Danish Imaginaries By Drew Robert Winter The IPCC and UN FAO have both suggested a global reduction in meat consumption to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. But how do nations and citizens resolve tensions between ecological stewardship and meat consumption? What is implied in eating meat and raising livestock in a country where the historical imaginary yokes national values to the pig-producing countryside? To answer these questions, this dissertation examines how climate change is affecting meat consumption and production logics in Denmark. Though the country has a reputation for progressive environmental policy, its formerly large agricultural sector continues to exert disproportionate political influence, and many citizens consider pork its most "traditional" food. In 2016, a publicly-funded advisory council issued a report suggesting that parliament pass a beef tax to reduce consumption and reflect its environmental impact. The report was the most controversial the council had ever issued, with members receiving angry phone calls and politicians arguing the council should be disbanded. The proposal put national tensions between sustainability
    [Show full text]
  • Speciesism and Language: a Sociolinguistic Approach to the Presence of Speciesism in Current
    FACULTAD DE FILOLOGÍA UNIVERSIDAD DE SALAMANCA FACULTAD DE FILOLOGÍA GRADO EN ESTUDIOS INGLESES Trabajo de Fin de Grado Speciesism and Language: A sociolinguistic approach to the presence of speciesism in current British speech Salamanca, 2017 Abstract [EN] This paper is an attempt to study the presence of speciesism in the British culture by analyzing its language. Being this form of discrimination still highly prevalent worldwide, the aim of the essay is to analyze to what extent the English language used in Britain is influenced by it. For this purpose, two popular forms of the language have been analyzed: insults and proverbs. The research has been based on the answers of a survey addressed to young British English speakers and the results obtained from oral entries of the British National Corpus. The results of the study have shown a high influence of speciesism in the language and how normalized it is, proving that this form of discrimination is still highly accepted in the British society and therefore present in its language. Keywords: Speciesism, language, discrimination based on species, insults, proverbs. Abstract [ES] El propósito de este trabajo es el de estudiar la presencia del especismo en la cultura británica analizando su lenguaje. Debido al hecho de que esta forma de discriminación está todavía muy extendida alrededor de todo el mundo, este estudio pretende analizar hasta qué punto ha influenciado al inglés hablado en Reino Unido. Para esto hemos analizado dos formas populares del lenguaje: los insultos y los refranes. El estudio se ha basado en las respuestas de una encuesta completada por jóvenes Británicos y en los resultados obtenidos del análisis en entradas orales del British National Corpus.
    [Show full text]