DOCSLIB.ORG

Thesis-Template-4Rd Version

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Calhoun, Institutional Archive of the Naval Postgraduate School Calhoun: The NPS Institutional Archive Theses and Dissertations Thesis Collection 2001-12 The Karabagh conflict and its effects on Turkey's role in the Caucasus Akdeniz, Bulent. Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School http://hdl.handle.net/10945/1418 NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL Monterey, California THESIS THE KARABAGH CONFLICT AND ITS EFFECTS ON TURKEY’S ROLE IN THE CAUCASUS by Bulent Akdeniz December 2001 Thesis Advisor: Mikhail Tsypkin Second Reader: Glenn E. Robinson Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE Form Approved OMB No. 0704-0188 Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instruction, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302, and to the Office of Management and Budget, Paperwork Reduction Project (0704-0188) Washington DC 20503. 1. AGENCY USE ONLY (Leave blank) 2. REPORT DATE 3. REPORT TYPE AND DATES COVERED December 2001 Master’s Thesis 4. TITLE AND SUBTIT LE: The Karabagh Conflict And Its Effects On Turkey’s 5. FUNDING NUMBERS Role In The Caucasus 6. AUTHOR(S) Bulent Akdeniz 7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 8. PERFORMING Naval Postgraduate School ORGANIZATION REPORT Monterey, CA 93943-5000 NUMBER 9. SPONSORING /MONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 10. SPONSORING/MONITORING N/A AGENCY REPORT NUMBER 11. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES The views expressed in this thesis are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Department of Defense or the U.S. Government. 12a. DISTRIBUTION / AVAILABILITY STATEMENT 12b. DISTRIBUTION CODE Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited 13. ABSTRACT (maximum 200 words) This thesis examines the Karabagh conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia and its implications on the Caucasus regional security in general and Turkey’s role in particular. It investigates the causes of the conflict from a theoretical, historical and practical view and evaluates the role of the various international actors in the conflict. This thesis also traces the role of oil and oil politics in resolving the conflict and contrarily examines how the conflict affects the development of the oil in the Caucasus region. This study concludes that the Karabagh conflict and the ensuing events eroded the Turkish role in the Caucasus and created a situation prone to instability and renewed violence. This study provides specific recommendations for Turkish foreign policy makers to enhance the stability in the region without sacrificing Turkish interests. Recommendations include increased relations and engagement with Iran and Russia and the further containment of Armenia until a dramatic change in its attitude is observed. 14. SUBJECT TERMS Karabagh, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Caspian Oil, Turkish Foreign Policy, and 15. NUMBER OF Caucasus PAGES 133 16. PRICE CODE 17. SECURITY 18. SECURITY 19. SECURITY 20. LIMITATION CLASSIFICATION OF CLASSIFICATION OF THIS CLASSIFICATION OF OF ABSTRACT REPORT PAGE ABSTRACT Unclassified Unclassified Unclassified UL NSN 7540-01-280-5500 Standard Form 298 (Rev. 2-89) Prescribed by ANSI Std. 239-18 i THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK ii THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK iv ABSTRACT This thesis examines the Karabagh conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia and its implications on the Caucasus regional security in general and Turkey’s role in particular. It investigates the causes of the conflict from a theoretical, historical and practical view and evaluates the role of the various international actors in the conflict. This thesis also traces the role of oil and oil politics in resolving the conflict and contrarily examines how the conflict affects the development of the oil in the Caucasus region. This study concludes that the Karabagh conflict and the ensuing events eroded the Turkish role in the Caucasus and created a situation prone to instability and renewed violence. This study provides specific recommendations for Turkish foreign policy makers to enhance the stability in the region without sacrificing Turkish interests. Recommendations include increased relations and engagement with Iran and Russia and the further containment of Armenia until a dramatic change in its attitude is observed. v THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK vi TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................1 II. THEORY AND THE ROOTS OF THE CONFLICT ..............................................7 III. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF THE KARABAGH CONFLICT...............21 A. THE EARLY PERIOD IN AZERBAIJANI-ARMENIAN RELATIONS (1905-1987) .............................................................................22 B. RESURGENCE IN THE KARABAGH CONFLICT (1987-1991)............26 C. ESCALATION AND WAR (1991-1994)......................................................33 D. MEDIATION PROCESS IN THE CONFLICT (1994-) ............................43 IV. ARMENIA..................................................................................................................51 A. ARMENIAN- RUSSIAN RELATIONS.......................................................53 B. ARMENIAN-IRANIAN RELATIONS........................................................56 C. ARMENIAN-TURKISH RELATIONS.......................................................59 D. ARMENIAN-U.S RELATIONS ...................................................................66 E. CONCLUSION...............................................................................................66 V. AZERBAIJAN...........................................................................................................69 A. AZERBAIJANI-RUSSIAN RELATIONS...................................................71 B. AZERBAIJANI-IRANIAN RELATIONS...................................................76 C. AZERBAIJANI-TURKISH RELATIONS..................................................78 D. AZERBAIJANI-U.S RELATIONS..............................................................83 E. CONCLUSIONS.............................................................................................86 V. OIL AND PIPELINE ISSUES ..................................................................................89 A. RUSSIA’S ROLE IN THE CASPIAN REGION ........................................91 B. LEGAL STATUS OF THE CASPIAN SEA................................................93 C. IRAN’S ROLE IN THE CASPIAN REGION.............................................95 D. TURKISH/U.S POSITION IN THE REGION ...........................................96 E. OIL RESERVES AND AGREEMENTS IN THE CASPIAN REGION ..97 F. BAKU-CEYHAN ROUTE AND TURKISH VIEWS ................................99 G. TURKISH STRAITS AND RELATED ECOLOGICAL AND SAFETY CONCERNS ................................................................................101 H. ARMENIAN VIEWS ON CASPIAN OIL AND ITS EFFECTS ON THE KARABAGH CONFLICT ................................................................106 I. CONCLUSIONS...........................................................................................109 VI. CONCUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................113 A. EFFECTS OF KARABAGH CONFLICT ON TURKEY’S ROLE IN THE REGION ..............................................................................................113 B. FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS AND ANAYSIS.........................................118 C. RECOMMENDATIONS.............................................................................121 vii BIBLIOGRAPHY................................................................................................................127 INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST.......................................................................................133 viii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Occupied Azerbaijani Territories.....................................................................42 Figure 2. Republic of Armenia ........................................................................................52 Figure 3. Republic of Azerbaijan....................................................................................70 Figure 4. Pipeline Routes ................................................................................................91 Figure 5. Caspian Sea......................................................................................................94 Figure 6. The Bosphorus ...............................................................................................104 Figure 7. Proposed Pipelines Detours Circumventing the Bosphorus ..........................105 ix THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK x ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS While writing this thesis, I received invaluable encouragement from my advisor, Professor Mikhail Tsypkin. I would like to thank my advisor, Professor Mikhail Tsypkin and my second reader, Professor Glenn E. Robinson for their guidance during my thesis. I would like to
Recommended publications
  • A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today

    A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today

    Volume: 8 Issue: 2 Year: 2011 A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today Ercan Karakoç Abstract After initiation of the glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructuring) policies in the USSR by Mikhail Gorbachev, the Soviet Union started to crumble, and old, forgotten, suppressed problems especially regarding territorial claims between Azerbaijanis and Armenians reemerged. Although Mountainous (Nagorno) Karabakh is officially part of Azerbaijan Republic, after fierce and bloody clashes between Armenians and Azerbaijanis, the entire Nagorno Karabakh region and seven additional surrounding districts of Lachin, Kelbajar, Agdam, Jabrail, Fizuli, Khubadly and Zengilan, it means over 20 per cent of Azerbaijan, were occupied by Armenians, and because of serious war situations, many Azerbaijanis living in these areas had to migrate from their homeland to Azerbaijan and they have been living under miserable conditions since the early 1990s. Keywords: Karabakh, Caucasia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Ottoman Empire, Safavid Empire, Russia and Soviet Union Assistant Professor of Modern Turkish History, Yıldız Technical University, [email protected] 1003 Karakoç, E. (2011). A Brief Overview on Karabakh History from Past to Today. International Journal of Human Sciences [Online]. 8:2. Available: http://www.insanbilimleri.com/en Geçmişten günümüze Karabağ tarihi üzerine bir değerlendirme Ercan Karakoç Özet Mihail Gorbaçov tarafından başlatılan glasnost (açıklık) ve perestroyka (yeniden inşa) politikalarından sonra Sovyetler Birliği parçalanma sürecine girdi ve birlik coğrafyasındaki unutulmuş ve bastırılmış olan eski problemler, özellikle Azerbaycan Türkleri ve Ermeniler arasındaki sınır sorunları yeniden gün yüzüne çıktı. Bu bağlamda, hukuken Azerbaycan devletinin bir parçası olan Dağlık Karabağ bölgesi ve çevresindeki Laçin, Kelbecer, Cebrail, Agdam, Fizuli, Zengilan ve Kubatlı gibi yedi semt, yani yaklaşık olarak Azerbaycan‟ın yüzde yirmiye yakın toprağı, her iki toplum arasındaki şiddetli ve kanlı çarpışmalardan sonra Ermeniler tarafından işgal edildi.
  • Asala & ARF 'Veterans' in Armenia and the Nagorno-Karabakh Region

    Asala & ARF 'Veterans' in Armenia and the Nagorno-Karabakh Region

    Karabakh Christopher GUNN Coastal Carolina University ASALA & ARF ‘VETERANS’ IN ARMENIA AND THE NAGORNO-KARABAKH REGION OF AZERBAIJAN Conclusion. See the beginning in IRS- Heritage, 3 (35) 2018 Emblem of ASALA y 1990, Armenia or Nagorno-Karabakh were, arguably, the only two places in the world that Bformer ASALA terrorists could safely go, and not fear pursuit, in one form or another, and it seems that most of them did, indeed, eventually end up in Armenia (36). Not all of the ASALA veterans took up arms, how- ever. Some like, Alex Yenikomshian, former director of the Monte Melkonian Fund and the current Sardarapat Movement leader, who was permanently blinded in October 1980 when a bomb he was preparing explod- ed prematurely in his hotel room, were not capable of actually participating in the fighting (37). Others, like Varoujan Garabedian, the terrorist behind the attack on the Orly Airport in Paris in 1983, who emigrated to Armenia when he was pardoned by the French govern- ment in April 2001 and released from prison, arrived too late (38). Based on the documents and material avail- able today in English, there were at least eight ASALA 48 www.irs-az.com 4(36), AUTUMN 2018 Poster of the Armenian Legion in the troops of fascist Germany and photograph of Garegin Nzhdeh – terrorist and founder of Tseghakronism veterans who can be identified who were actively en- tia group of approximately 50 men, and played a major gaged in the conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh (39), but role in the assault and occupation of the Kelbajar region undoubtedly there were more.
  • The U.S. South Caucasus Strategy and Azerbaijan

    The U.S. South Caucasus Strategy and Azerbaijan

    THE U.S. SOUTH CAUCASUS STRATEGY AND AZERBAIJAN This article analyzes the evolution of U.S. foreign policy in the South Cauca- sus through three concepts, “soft power”, “hard power” and “smart power” which have been developed under the administrations of Bill Clinton, George W. Bush and Barack Obama respectively. The authors also aim to identify how the US strategy towards this region has been perceived in Azerbaijan, which, due to its geographical position, energy resources and geopolitical environment, is one of the “geopolitical pivots of Eurasia”. Inessa Baban & Zaur Shiriyev* * Inessa Baban is a Ph.D candidate in geopolitics at Paris-Sorbonne University of France. She is a former visiting scholar at Center for Strategic Studies under the President of Azerbaijan. Zaur Shiriyev is a foreign policy analyst at the same think tank. The views expressed in this article are entirely personal. 93 VOLUME 9 NUMBER 2 INESSA BABAN & ZAUR SHIRIYEV he U.S. strategy towards the South Caucasus has become one of the most controversial issues of American foreign policy under the Obama administration. Most American experts argue that because of the current priorities of the U.S. government, the South Caucasus region does not get the attention that it merits. Even if they admit that none of U.S.’ interests in the Caucasus “fall under the vital category”1 there is a realization that Washington must reconsider its policy towards this region which matters geopolitically, economically and strategically. The South Caucasus, also referred as Transcaucasia, is located between the Black Sea and the Caspian Sea, neighboring Central Asia to the east, the Middle East to the south, and Eastern Europe to the west, hence connecting Europe to Asia.
  • The Effects of Nationalism on Territorial Integrity Among Armenians and Serbs Nina Patelic

    The Effects of Nationalism on Territorial Integrity Among Armenians and Serbs Nina Patelic

    Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2008 The Effects of Nationalism on Territorial Integrity Among Armenians and Serbs Nina Patelic Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES THE EFFECTS OF NATIONALISM ON TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY AMONG ARMENIANS AND SERBS By Nina Patelic A Thesis submitted to the Department of International Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Degree Awarded: Spring Semester, 2008 The members of the Committee approve the thesis of Nina Pantelic, defended on September 28th, 2007. ------------------------------- Jonathan Grant Professor Directing Thesis ------------------------------- Peter Garretson Committee Member ------------------------------- Mark Souva Committee Member The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii ACKOWLEDGEMENTS This paper could not have been written without the academic insight of my thesis committee members, as well as Dr. Kotchikian. I would also like to thank my parents Dr. Svetlana Adamovic and Dr. Predrag Pantelic, my grandfather Dr. Ljubisa Adamovic, my sister Ana Pantelic, and my best friend, Jason Wiggins, who have all supported me over the years. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………..v INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………….1 1. NATIONALISM, AND HOW IT DEVELOPED IN SERBIA AND ARMENIA...6 2. THE CONFLICT OVER KOSOVO AND METOHIJA…………………………...27 3. THE CONFLICT OVER NAGORNO KARABAKH……………………………..56 CONCLUSION………………………………………………………………...……….89 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY…………………………………………………………93 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH………………………………………………………….101 iv ABSTRACT Nationalism has been a driving force in both nation building and in spurring high levels of violence. As nations have become the norm in modern day society, nationalism has become detrimental to international law, which protects the powers of sovereignty.
  • Ronald Grigor Suny Oberlin College Conference On

    Ronald Grigor Suny Oberlin College Conference On

    NUMBER 93 NATIONALISM A.TIJD SOCIAL CLASS IN THE RUSSIA.\! REVOLUTION: THE CASES OF BAKU AND TIFLIS Ronald Grigor Suny Oberlin College Conference on "NATIONALISM AND SOCIAL CHANGE IN TRA.l\l'SCAUCASIA" Co-sponsored by Kennan Institute for Advanced Russian Studies, The Wilson Center and American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies April 24-25, 1980 NATIONALISM AND SOCIAL CLASS IN THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION: THE CASES OF BAKU AND TIFLIS Historians have either neglected unintentionally or skirted deliberately a most perplexing anomaly of the revolutionary e~ents in Russia in 1917-1918. While most would accept at this point the presence, if not decisiveness, of class antagonisms and conflicts in the central Russian cities -- with an in­ creasingly militant working class standing opposed to the propertied elements of Russian society -- when studying the national borderlands they generally dismiss the importance of class struggles and insist more often than not on the overwhelming significance of ethnic conflicts between different national­ ities, particularly those between the formerly-dominant Russians and the newly­ emerging minorities native to the periphery. While emphasizing the importance of nationalism and focusing almost exclusively on the political struggles be­ tween ethnic parties, the principal western writings on the national border­ lands have largely ignored investigation into the social structure of the minority communities. The contrast between the image of the revolution in Russia proper and in the borderlands has been drawn much too starkly to be convincing and clearly demands further investigation of the social basis of nationality conflicts and nationalism to see if class as well as ethnic fac­ tors played a part in the intensification of hostilities evident in 1917-1918.
  • Armenian Genocide Against the Azerbaijani People

    Armenian Genocide Against the Azerbaijani People

    Educational Research International Vol.7(4) November 2018 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ARMENIAN GENOCIDE AGAINST THE AZERBAIJANI PEOPLE Habil Hamidov Institute of Philosophy, and Law, Academy of Sciences of Azerbaijan, Baku, AZERBAIJAN. [email protected] ABSTRACT In the article, the author notes that Armenian Genocide of Azerbaijanis was committed in Baku, Shamakhi ,Guba districts, as well as Garabagh, Zangazur, Nakchivan, Lankaran and other regions of Azerbaijan with special brutality. In these areas peaceful population was slaughtered, villages were burnt, national and cultural monuments were totally destroyed. Keywords: Armenian Genocide against the Azerbaijani People, Republic, policy, separatism, terrorism INTRODUCTION When researching the global problems of mankind, it is important that the historical events are conveyed with truthful foundation. At initial glance, trustworthy coverage of facts is the prerogative of historical science, yet it is not always the case. Sometimes the facts reach the public mind in distorted forms. In such cases public foundation becomes precarious, cultural strata are erased, and the future generations cannot learn a lesson from the past. Without knowledge of the past, they cannot rely on successful future, their lives flee
  • Nonproliferation Approaches in the Caucasus

    Nonproliferation Approaches in the Caucasus

    Report: Nonproliferation Approaches in the Caucasus NONPROLIFERATION APPROACHES IN THE CAUCASUS by Tamara C. Robinson Tamara C. Robinson is a Senior Researcher at the Center for Nonproliferation Studies at the Monterey Institute of International Studies. ecent reports of the vast oil deposits in the Caspian Caucasian nuclear-weapon-free zone. It also evaluates Sea region have focused international attention U.S. policy responses to existing regional proliferation Ron the importance of stability in the Caucasus. threats. While the desire to stem proliferation may exist Yet the nuclear materials and expertise in these often in all three republics, economic conditions and problems overlooked newly independent states (Georgia, Arme- with domestic policy implementation, as a result of weak nia, and Azerbaijan) also pose a problem of international statehood, may override this desire if the West does not concern on three levels. At the ground level, maintain- offer additional assistance to support and strengthen non- ing control over these materials and watching over sci- proliferation efforts. entific expertise are imperative, yet measures are lacking as in most regions of the former Soviet Union, including MATERIALS AND THEIR PROTECTION, Russia herself. At the domestic policy level, the politi- CONTROL, AND ACCOUNTING cal and economic instability of these states in transition hampers the strengthening of key institutions for the pre- In order to understand proliferation problems on the vention of proliferation and provides an environment ground level, it is imperative to take stock of the nuclear conducive to black market activities. At the regional materials and control over them in each of the Cauca- level, the Caucasus represent both a geostrategically vi- sian republics and to assume that material protection, tal conduit and buffer between Russia and the Middle control, and accounting (MPC & A) will help guard East and from the Caspian Sea to the West.
  • Hamlet Isaxanli in Search of “Khazar”

    Hamlet Isaxanli in Search of “Khazar”

    Hamlet Isaxanli In Search of “Khazar” 2 In Search of "Khazar" The realities of events associated with the establishment and development of Khazar University have left indelible traces in my memory. I intend to pass these events to you in their entirety and in all sincerity. I hope I can relive together with you, readers, those days spent in ‘search of "Khazar". In Search of "Khazar" 3 CHAPTER 1 BETWEEN HEAVEN AND EARTH For a number of years I was familiarizing myself with different universities all over the world, whilst gathering my thoughts on science and education in my own country, Azerbaijan. These ideas and comparisons were taking a distinctive shape in my imagination - the shape of a university. Novel ideas and thoughts seemingly appear unexpectedly, but in reality they are a result of long and intensive subconscious efforts. The information that we absorb, accept and keep in our minds is explored and analyzed in invisible and imperceptible ways. Accor- ding to some hypotheses, this way is simply called a harmonization, putting thoughts into a correct and beautiful order. In this process, suddenly everything falls into place and an idea appears as a patch of light. The first place where I studied after Azerbaijan was Moscow State University. I spent long years there first studying and then researching mathematics. The university’s extremely high scientific potential and pleasant and creative atmosphere seemed to be a new world to me. Later I traveled more and came across more varied systems at universities in Canada and in Europe. I didn’t content myself solely with giving lectures, presenting papers at different conferences, workshops, and conducting new research.
  • I Am Delighted to Welcome You to the Pages of Azerbaijan in the World, the New Biweekly of the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy

    I Am Delighted to Welcome You to the Pages of Azerbaijan in the World, the New Biweekly of the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy

    AZERBAIJAN IN THE WORLD ADA Biweekly Newsletter Vol. 1, No. 1 February 1, 2008 [email protected] In this issue: -- Greetings from the Foreign Minister -- Greetings from the Rector -- Paul Goble, “Azerbaijan on the Cusp” -- Sevinge Yusifzade, “A Not So Distant Model” -- Murad Ismayilov, “Azerbaijani National Identity and Baku’s Foreign Policy” -- A Chronology of Azerbaijan’s Foreign Policy -- Note to Readers Greetings from H.E. Elmar Mammadyarov Minister of Foreign Affairs Republic of Azerbaijan I am delighted to welcome you to the pages of Azerbaijan in the World, the new biweekly of the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Given its booming economy, increasing presence in international affairs and growing prestige, Azerbaijan today deserves your attention, and I am confident that this new electronic publication will serve as a useful guide to its foreign policy. Situated in one of the most geopolitically sensitive regions in the world, my country affects and is affected by various regional trends, energy issues, and security threats, and in order to understand where Baku is heading, you will want to keep track of developments in all these areas. And Azerbaijan in the World will thus feature articles on those issues as well. Because Ambassador Pashayev, the rector of the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy, and Paul Goble, ADA’s director of research and publications, stand behind this project, I have every confidence in its success. I plan to be an attentive reader as well as a frequent contributor and very much hope you will be both as well. Greetings from Ambassador Hafiz Pashayev Rector Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy As the rector of the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy, I want to echo the words of Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov about our new biweekly, “Azerbaijan in the World” and take this opportunity to tell you something about our institution, its activities, and its goals.
  • Combatting and Preventing Corruption in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia How Anti-Corruption Measures Can Promote Democracy and the Rule of Law

    Combatting and Preventing Corruption in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia How Anti-Corruption Measures Can Promote Democracy and the Rule of Law

    Combatting and preventing corruption in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia How anti-corruption measures can promote democracy and the rule of law Combatting and preventing corruption in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia How anti-corruption measures can promote democracy and the rule of law Silvia Stöber Combatting and preventing corruption in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia 4 Contents Contents 1. Instead of a preface: Why (read) this study? 9 2. Introduction 11 2.1 Methodology 11 2.2 Corruption 11 2.2.1 Consequences of corruption 12 2.2.2 Forms of corruption 13 2.3 Combatting corruption 13 2.4 References 14 3. Executive Summaries 15 3.1 Armenia – A promising change of power 15 3.2 Azerbaijan – Retaining power and preventing petty corruption 16 3.3 Georgia – An anti-corruption role model with dents 18 4. Armenia 22 4.1 Introduction to the current situation 22 4.2 Historical background 24 4.2.1 Consolidation of the oligarchic system 25 4.2.2 Lack of trust in the government 25 4.3 The Pashinyan government’s anti-corruption measures 27 4.3.1 Background conditions 27 4.3.2 Measures to combat grand corruption 28 4.3.3 Judiciary 30 4.3.4 Monopoly structures in the economy 31 4.4 Petty corruption 33 4.4.1 Higher education 33 4.4.2 Health-care sector 34 4.4.3 Law enforcement 35 4.5 International implications 36 4.5.1 Organized crime and money laundering 36 4.5.2 Migration and asylum 36 4.6 References 37 5 Combatting and preventing corruption in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia 5.
  • SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR

    SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR

    SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR Aslan Ismayilov SUMGAYIT - BEGINNING OF THE COLLAPSE OF THE USSR 1 Aslan Ismayilov ЧАШЫОЬЛУ 2011 Aslan Ismayilov Sumgayit – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR Baku Aslan Ismayilov Sumgayit – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR Baku Translated by Vagif Ismayil and Vusal Kazimli 2 SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR SUMGAYIT PROCEEDINGS 3 Aslan Ismayilov 4 SUMGAYIT – Beginning of the Collapse of the USSR HOW I WAS APPOINTED AS THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR IN THE CASE AND OBTAINED INSIGHT OF IT Dear readers! Before I start telling you about Sumgayit events, which I firmly believe are of vital importance for Azerbaijan, and in the trial of which I represented the government, about peripeteia of this trial and other happenings which became echoes and continuation of the tragedy in Sumgayit, and finally about inferences I made about all the abovementioned as early as in 1989, I would like to give you some brief background about myself, in order to demonstrate you that I was not involved in the process occasionally and that my conclusions and position regarding the case are well grounded. Thus, after graduating from the Law Faculty of of the Kuban State University of Russia with honours, I was appointed to the Neftekumsk district court of the Stavropol region as an interne. After the lapse of some time I became the assistant for Mr Krasnoperov, the chairman of the court, who used to be the chairman of the Altay region court and was known as a good professional. The existing legislation at that time allowed two people’s assessors to participate in the court trials in the capacity of judges alongside with the actual judge.
  • ASN World Convention

    ASN World Convention

    ASN W2-4orld MAY Convention 2019 Convention Panels Session I Session VII THURSDAY 9:40 - 11:40 AM FRIDAY 3:00 - 5:00 PM Session II Session VIII THURSDAY 12:00 - 2:00 PM FRIDAY 5:20 - 7:20 PM Session III Session IX THURSDAY 3:40 - 5:40 PM SATURDAY 10 AM - 12 PM Session IV Session X THURSDAY 6 - 8 PM SATURDAY 1:40 - 3:40 PM Session V Session XI FRIDAY 9 - 11 AM SATURDAY 4:10 - 6:10 PM Session VI FRIDAY 11:20 AM - 1:20 PM BACK TO SUMMARY PANEL BK11 Imagining the Balkans in a Post-Western Global Order (ROUNDTABLE) THURSDAY MAY 2 // Session I // 9:40 - 11:40 AM // Room 1201 CHAIR Francine Friedman (Ball State U, US) [email protected] PARTICIPANTS Stefano Bianchini (U of Bologna, Italy) [email protected] A New Eastern Question? Disruptive Memories, Problematic Dialogue and the EU Decline R. Craig Nation (Dickinson College, US) [email protected] The Past as Prologue? Great Power Engagement in Balkan Europe Julie Mostov (NYU, US) [email protected] Fading Dreams of Democracy in the Shadow of Authoritarian Closure David Kanin (Johns Hopkins U, US) [email protected] Adjusting the Security Cap: Regional Dynamics in the Context of Western Entropy BACK TO SUMMARY PANEL CE7 Antisemitism and the Holocaust THURSDAY MAY 2 // Session I // 9:40 - 11:40 AM // Room 1202 CHAIR Mila Dragojevic (U of the South, US) [email protected] PAPERS Daina Eglitis (George Washington U, US) [email protected] Displacement and Danger: Women in the Nazi Ghettos of Eastern Europe Catherine Portuges (UMass Amherst, US) [email protected] 1945: A Hungarian