Parliamentary Committee of Investigation Final Report to Investigate Militias Activity in the State of Rio De Janeiro
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE OF INVESTIGATION FINAL REPORT TO INVESTIGATE MILITIAS ACTIVITY IN THE STATE OF RIO DE JANEIRO. RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE OF INVESTIGATION (RESOLUTION No. 433/2008) PRESIDENT: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER MARCELO FREIXO VICE-PRESIDENT: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER CIDINHA CAMPOS RAPPORTEUR: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER GILBERTO PALMARES FULL MEMBERS: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER PAULO MELO STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER PEDRO PAULO STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER JOÃO PEDRO STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER ANDRÉ CORRÊA 2 RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY 1. BACKGROUND 2. ORGANIZATION AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE 2.1 - Organization 2.2 - Members 2.3 - Chair, Organization, Vice-President Election and Rapporteur Appointment 2.4 - Operation 3. DURATION 4. DOCUMENTS 4.1– Official Letters Issued 4.2.– Documents Received, attachments by subject and testimonies 4.2.a – Administrative documents 4.2.B – Work Methodology. Documents received and testimonies/meeting - by attachment 4.3 – Call Notices 4.4- Minutes 5. SUMMARY OF SESSIONS 6. PRAISES, CREDITS AND ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 7. RAPPORTEUR’S VOTE 3 RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY 1. BACKGROUND The institution of the Parliamentary Committee of Investigation was requested by the State Assembly Member MARCELO FREIXO in February 2007, due to the extremely serious situation of militias in the communities of the State of Rio de Janeiro, with strong evidence of participation of civil and military police officers, military firemen and Prison Guards. Such situation required the public administration to provide a prompt solution in 2008, when reporters of the “O DIA” newspaper were kidnapped and tortured in a Rio de Janeiro slum. 2. ORGANIZATION AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE 2.1 - Organization The Parliamentary Committee of Investigation was organized upon the Draft Resolution no. 626/2008, under the provisions of Art. 30 of the Internal Regulations of the Rio de Janeiro State Assembly, with first duration of ninety (90) days, extensible for more sixty (60) days, comprising nine (9) members. The Draft was approved and produced Resolution no. 433/2008 published in the Official Gazette of 11.06.2008. 2.2 - Members In accordance with Act “E”/GP/No. 018/2008, published in the Official Gazette of 13.06.08: The President of the Rio de Janeiro State Assembly, pursuant to the powers granted by articles 20, item III, paragraph “a” and 24, head provision of the Internal Regulations, RESOLVES: “To appoint as full members to the Parliamentary Committee of Investigation – “CPI”, organized under Resolution no. 433/2008, the State Assembly Members Mr. MARCELO FREIXO – PSOL - Author, Mr. PAULO MELO – PMDB, Mr. GILBERTO PALMARES – PT, Mr. PEDRO PAULO – PSDB, Mr. JOÃO PEDRO – DEM, Mr. ANDRÉ CORREA - PPS and Mr. PAULO RAMOS – PDT. Rio de Janeiro, June 12, 2008. 4 RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY State Assembly Member JORGE PICCIANI President.” NOTE: The Official Gazette of 24.09.08 published the Official Letter CTLS - AP No. 58/2008, of 12.09.08, by which the State Assembly Member PAULO RAMOS, a member to the CPI, notifies his withdrawal and appoints the State Assembly Member CIDINHA CAMPOS to replace him as full member. The order to the Official Letter is: “TO BE PRINTED” NEW MEMBERS AFTER ACT “E”/GP/No. 025/2008 - OFFICIAL GAZETTE OF 25.09.08 PRESIDENT: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER MARCELO FREIXO VICE-PRESIDENT: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER CIDINHA CAMPOS RAPPORTEUR: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER GILBERTO PALMARES MEMBERS: STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER PEDRO PAULO STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER JOÃO PEDRO STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER ANDRÉ CORREA STATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER PAULO MELO During the 19th Ordinary Meeting held on October 30, 2008, the State Assembly Member CIDINHA CAMPOS was appointed to take over as Vice-President with retroactive office since 25.09.08, and the proposal was unanimously approved upon voting 2.3 - Chair, Organization, Vice-President Election and Rapporteur Appointment 2.3.1 - Pursuant to the Regulations, the State Assembly Member MARCELO FREIXO took office as the President to the Committee 2.3.2 - On June 19, 2008, at 9:30 AM, in room number 311 of Palácio Tiradentes, the headquarters of the Legislative Branch in the State of Rio de Janeiro, a Committee Organization meeting was held, with the purpose of electing the Vice-President and the Rappourter. The election took place with the initial casting of votes, being the State Assembly Member PAULO RAMOS was elected as Vice-President, and the State Assembly Member GILBERTO PALMARES was elected as Rapporteur to the Committee. 2.4 - Operation After organizing and providing the general standards to its operation, the Committee held one (01) Organization Meeting, twenty (20) Ordinary Meetings, three (03) Extraordinary Meetings and one (01) Closure Meeting. 5 RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY 3. DURATION The Committee started operations on June 19, 2008 and ended its first ninety (90)-day ruling period on September 15, in the same year, and, after an extension of sixty (60) days, its activities were concluded on November 14, 2008. According to the Internal Regulations of the Rio de Janeiro State Assembly, the Committee is entitled to another fifteen days to submit the Report to the Provisional Committees Division, which shall have five days to send it to the General Office of the Governing Board. 4. DOCUMENTS 4.1– Official Letters Issued No DATE ADDRESSEE/NAME COMPANY/ SUBJECT POSITION 001 19.06.08 1st Secretary ALERJ Secretary Appointment 002 19.06.08 Editor O DIA Material about militias requested 003 19.06.08 Editor O GLOBO Material about militias requested 004 19.06.08 Editor JB Material about militias requested 005 19.06.08 Editor EXTRA Material about militias requested 006 19.06.08 Mr. Celso Athaide CUFA Material about militias requested 007 19.06.08 Mr. Rossino Castro FAFERJ Material about militias Diniz requested 008 19.06.08 Dr. José Mariano SSP/Head of Civil Material about militias Beltrame Police Dept. and requested Military Police Cmd. 009 19.06.08 Dr. Cesar Rubens M. SEAP Attendance of Messrs. Ocian de Carvalho and Antonio Salustiano requested 010 19.06.08 State Ass. Jorge President of ALERJ Com. Operation in the holyday Picciani season 011 19.06.08 Editor O DIA Documents request - classified 012 19.06.08 Editor O GLOBO Documents request - classified 013 19.06.08 Editor JB Documents request - classified 6 RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY 001 19.06.08 Editor EXTRA Documents request - classified 015 19.06.08 Dr. José Mariano SSP’s Head of Civil Documents request - classified Beltrame Police Dept. and Military Police Cmd. 016 19.06.08 State Ass. Jorge Picciani President of ALERJ Private room requested 017 20.06.07 Dr. Cesar Rubens M. de SEAP Material about militias Carvalho requested 018 20.06.08 Dr. Cesar Rubens M. de SEAP Documents request - classified Carvalho 019 20.06.08 Dr. Sergio Luiz Côrtes da SESDEC/CB Material about militias Silveira MERJ (Fire requested Dept) Cmd. 020 20.06.08 Chief of Police Valdinho Federal Police Material about militias Jacinto Caetano Commissioner in Rio requested de Janeiro 021 20.06.08 Gen. Mario Madureira Head of the Eastern Documents request – classified. Military Command General Staff 022 20.06.08 Dr. Cesar Maia Mayor of the City of Material about militias Rio de Janeiro requested 023 23.06.08 Dr. Sergio Luiz Côrtes da SESDEC/CB Documents request - classified Silveira MERJ Fire Dept. Cmd. 024 26.06.08 State Ass. Jorge Picciani President of ALERJ Computers request 025 26.06.08 Chief of Police Sergio DPC’s Full Officer Police officers attendance Simões Caldas requested 026 26.06.08 Chief of Police Marcus 35th Police Station Call Antonio N. Pereira 027 26.06.08 State Ass. Graça Matos 1st Secretary Amends O. L. 001/08 028 26.06.08 Drs. Ignácio Cano and UERJ (State University Studies on militias of their João Trajano Santo Sé of Rio de Janeiro) authorship requested 029 26.06.08 Dr. Marfan M. Vieira MPERJ Documents request 030 26.06.08 Dr. Marfan M. Vieira MPERJ Documents request 031 27.06.08 Dr. Jailson S. e Silva Observatório das Studies about militias requested Favelas 032 27.06.08 Drs. Julita Lemgruber and CESEC Studies about militias requested Silvia Ramos 033 27.06.08 Dr. José Cláudio S.Alves UFRRJ Studies about militias requested 034 27.06.08 Dr. Luiz Eduardo Soares UERJ Studies about militias requested 035 30.06.08 Dr. Marcelo Burgos PUC/RJ Studies about militias requested 036 30.06.08 Dr. Michel Misse UFRJ/IFCS Studies about militias requested 037 30.06.08 Dr. Roberto Kant de Lima UFF Studies about militias requested 038 30.06.08 Drs. Gláucio Soares and IUPERJ Studies about militias requested Luiz Antonio Machado 039 30.06.08 Dr. Alba Zaluar UERJ Studies about militias requested 040 30.06.08 Dr. Jacqueline Muniz IBCCRIM Studies about militias requested 7 RIO DE JANEIRO STATE ASSEMBLY 041 30.06.08 Dr. Geraldo Tadeu IBPS Studies about militias Monteiro requested requested 042 30.06.08 Dr. Manuel Thedim IETS Studies about militias requested requested 043 30.06.08 Dr. José Mariano State Department of Assignment of Workers Beltrame Security 044 02.07.08 Dr. Tarso Genro Minister of Justice Assignment of Worker 045 02.07.08 Col. Gilson Pitta Lopes Mil. Police Cmd. O. L. 008 and 015 restated (*) 046 03.07.08 State Ass. Jorge Pres. of ALERJ Computer supplies requested Picciani 047 03.07.08 State Ass. Jorge Pres. of ALERJ Printer and fax requested Picciani 048 08.07.08 Col. Gilson Pitta Military Police Cmd. Worker Assignment requested 049 10.07.08 c/o Vanessa A.Cortes VIVA RIO Studies about militias requested requested 050 10.07.08 c/o Mrs. Rafael Dias JUSTIÇA GLOBAL Studies about militias requested requested 051 10.07.08 Chief of Police Marcus 35th Police Station Call to Clerk Antonio N.