Overview of Bohmian Mechanics Xavier Oriolsa and Jordi Mompartb∗ aDepartament d'Enginyeria Electr`onica, Universitat Aut`onomade Barcelona, 08193, Bellaterra, SPAIN bDepartament de F´ısica, Universitat Aut`onomade Barcelona, 08193 Bellaterra, SPAIN This chapter provides a fully comprehensive overview of the Bohmian formulation of quantum phenomena. It starts with a historical review of the difficulties found by Louis de Broglie, David Bohm and John Bell to convince the scientific community about the validity and utility of Bohmian mechanics. Then, a formal explanation of Bohmian mechanics for non-relativistic single-particle quantum systems is presented. The generalization to many-particle systems, where correlations play an important role, is also explained. After that, the measurement process in Bohmian mechanics is discussed. It is emphasized that Bohmian mechanics exactly reproduces the mean value and temporal and spatial correlations obtained from the standard, i.e., `orthodox', formulation. The ontological characteristics of the Bohmian theory provide a description of measurements in a natural way, without the need of introducing stochastic operators for the wavefunction collapse. Several solved problems are presented at the end of the chapter giving additional mathematical support to some particular issues. A detailed description of computational algorithms to obtain Bohmian trajectories from the numerical solution of the Schr¨odingeror the Hamilton{Jacobi equations are presented in an appendix. The motivation of this chapter is twofold. First, as a didactic introduction of the Bohmian formalism which is used in the subsequent chapters. Second, as a self-contained summary for any newcomer interested in using Bohmian mechanics in their daily research activity. arXiv:1206.1084v3 [quant-ph] 3 May 2019 ∗ E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] 2 This paper entitled “Overview of Bohmian Mechanics” includes the two prefaces, the introduction and the first chapter of the second edition of the book “Applied Bohmian Mechanics: From Nanoscale Systems to Cosmology”. The whole book, with nine additional chapters, has been published by Pan Stanford editorial and it can be ordered as indicated below. This paper has to be cited as: X. Oriols and J. Mompart “Overview of Bohmian Mechanics”; Chapter 1 of the book “Applied Bohmian Mechanics: From Nanoscale Systems to Cosmology”. Editorial Pan Stanford Publishing Pte. Ltd (Second edition, 2019). Print ISBN: 9789814800105 How to Order: You can place an order from any good bookstores or email us at [email protected] for more information. http://www.panstanford.com/ 3 CONTENTS I. Preface first edition 4 New cutting edge ideas come from outside of the main stream 4 II. Preface second edition: 6 Quantum engineering: a giant with feet of clay 6 III. Introduction 7 III.1. What is a quantum theory 8 III.2. How Bohmian mechanics helps 9 III.3. On the name Bohmian mechanics 10 III.4. On the book contents 11 IV. Historical Development of Bohmian Mechanics 13 IV.1. Particles and waves 13 IV.2. Origins of the quantum theory 14 IV.3. \Wave or particle?" vs. \wave and particle" 15 IV.4. Louis de Broglie and the fifth Solvay Conference 17 IV.5. Albert Einstein and locality 17 IV.6. David Bohm and why the \impossibility proofs" were wrong? 18 IV.7. John Bell and nonlocality 20 IV.8. Quantum hydrodynamics 21 IV.9. Is Bohmian mechanics a useful theory? 21 V. Bohmian Mechanics for a Single Particle 22 V.1. Preliminary discussions 22 V.2. Creating a wave equation for classical mechanics 22 V.2.1. Newton's second law 22 V.2.2. Hamilton's principle 23 V.2.3. Lagrange's equation 24 V.2.4. Equation for an (infinite) ensemble of trajectories 24 V.2.5. Classical Hamilton{Jacobi equation 26 V.2.6. Local continuity equation for an (infinite) ensemble of classical particles 26 V.2.7. Classical wave equation 26 V.3. Trajectories for quantum systems 27 V.3.1. Schr¨odingerequation 27 V.3.2. Local conservation law for an (infinite) ensemble of quantum trajectories 27 V.3.3. Velocity of Bohmian particles 28 V.3.4. Quantum Hamilton{Jacobi equation 28 V.3.5. A quantum Newton-like equation 29 V.4. Similarities and differences between classical and quantum mechanics 30 V.5. Feynman paths 32 V.6. Basic postulates for a single-particle 33 VI. Bohmian Mechanics for Many-Particle Systems 34 VI.1. Preliminary discussions: The many body problem 34 VI.2. Many-particle quantum trajectories 35 VI.2.1. Many-particle continuity equation 36 VI.2.2. Many-particle quantum Hamilton{Jacobi equation 36 VI.3. Factorizability, entanglement, and correlations 37 VI.4. Spin and identical particles 38 VI.4.1. Single-particle with s = 1/2 38 VI.4.2. Many-particle system with s = 1/2 particles 40 VI.5. Basic postulates for many-particle systems 41 VI.6. The conditional wave function: many-particle Bohmian trajectories without the many-particle wave function 42 VI.6.1. Single-particle pseudo-Schr¨odingerequation for many-particle systems 43 4 VI.6.2. Example: Application in factorizable many-particle systems 45 VI.6.3. Example: Application in interacting many-particle systems without exchange interaction 45 VI.6.4. Example: Application in interacting many-particle systems with exchange interaction 47 VII. Bohmian Explanation of the Measurement Process 49 VII.1. The measurement problem 49 VII.1.1. The orthodox measurement process 51 VII.1.2. The Bohmian measurement process 52 VII.2. Theory of the Bohmian measurement process 53 VII.2.1. Example: Bohmian measurement of the momentum 56 VII.2.2. Example: Sequential Bohmian measurement of the transmitted and reflected particles 56 VII.3. The evaluation of a mean value in terms of Hermitian operators 60 VII.3.1. Why Hermitian operators in Bohmian mechanics? 60 VII.3.2. Mean value from the list of outcomes and their probabilities 60 VII.3.3. Mean value from the wave function and the operators 61 VII.3.4. Mean value from Bohmian mechanics in the position representation 61 VII.3.5. Mean value from Bohmian trajectories 61 VII.3.6. On the meaning of local Bohmian operators AB(x) 63 VIII. Concluding Remarks 63 Acknowledgments 64 IX. Problems and solutions 64 X. Appendix: Numerical Algorithms for the Computation of Bohmian Mechanics 72 X.1. Analytical computation of Bohmian trajectories 73 X.1.1. Time-dependent Schr¨odinger equation for a 1D space (TDSE1D-BT) with an explicit method 74 X.1.2. Time-independent Schr¨odingerequation for a 1D space (TISE1D) with an implicit (matrix inversion) method 75 X.1.3. Time-independent Schr¨odingerequation for a 1D space (TISE1D) with an explicit method 77 X.2. Synthetic computation of Bohmian trajectories 79 X.2.1. Time-dependent quantum Hamilton{Jacobi equations (TDQHJE1D) with an implicit (Newton-like fixed Eulerian mesh) method 80 X.2.2. Time-dependent quantum Hamilton{Jacobi equations (TDQHJE1D) with an explicit (Lagrangian mesh) method 81 X.3. More elaborated algorithms 83 References 83 I. PREFACE FIRST EDITION New cutting edge ideas come from outside of the main stream Most of our collective activities are regulated by other people who decide whether they are well done or not. One has to learn some arbitrary symbols to write understandable messages, or to read those from others. Human rules over collective activities govern the evolution of our culture. On the contrary, natural systems, from atoms to galaxies, evolve independently of the human rules. Men cannot modify physical laws. We can only try to understand them. Nature itself judges, through experiments, whether a plausible explanation for some natural phenomena is correct or not. Nevertheless, in forefront research where the unknowns start to become understandable, the new knowledge is still unstable, somehow immature. It is supported by few experimental evidences or the evidences are still subjected to different interpretations. Certainly, novel research grows up closely tied to the economical, sociological or historical circumstances of the involved researchers. A period of time is needed in order to distil new knowledge, separating pure scientific arguments from cultural influences. The past and the present status of Bohmian mechanics cannot be understood without these cultural considerations. The Bohmian formalism was proposed by Louis de Broglie even before the standard, that is Copenhagen, explanation of quantum phenomena was established. Bohmian mechanics provides an explanation of quantum phenomena in terms 5 of particles guided by waves. One object cannot be a wave and a particle simultaneously, but two can. Specially, if one of the objects is a wave and the other is a particle. Unfortunately, Louis de Broglie, himself, abandoned these ideas. Later, in the fifties, David Bohm clarified the meaning and applications of this original explanation of quantum phenomena. Bohmian mechanics agrees with all non-relativistic quantum experiments done up to now. However, it remains almost ignored by most of the scientific community. In our opinion, there are no scientific arguments to support its marginal status, but only cultural reasons. One of the motivations for writing this book is helping in the maturing process that Bohmian mechanics still needs. Certainly, the distilling process of Bohmian mechanics is being quite slow. Anyone interested enough to walk this causal road of quantum mechanics can be easily confused by many misleading signposts that have been raised in the scientific literature, not only by its detractors, but unfortunately very often also by some of its advocates. Following opinions from other reputed physicists (we are easily persuaded by those scientists with authority) is far from being a proper scientific strategy. In any case, since the mathematical structure of Bohmian mechanics is quite simple, it can be easily learned by anyone with only a basic knowledge of classical and quantum mechanics who makes the necessary effort to build his own scientific opinion based on logical deductions, free from cultural influences.