2 February 1911
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
3612 612[COUNCIL.] Questica p.Issed; the Councwil's, amend- PAlPER PRESENTED. ment not mader. By tile Colonrial Secretary; Report onl No. 76o.-Add new denuse, to stand ats investi ,uatiozis it the compositioa± of the Clauste 272. as fojllows :- If eit her III, se ga es caused by blasting in winies. Of Parliament, -within thirty days 'text after any ree-ulaiii. or by-laws hiave been so laid before it, resolvvs that such regulations (a by-laws ught to be annul- led, the same -hIal!, after the date oit suchl QITSTIltN -RAILWAY PROJECT. resolution, be of nto cffect, without Pre- judice to the validity oif anything Iuinv Rlo. V. HAMERSUEY asked the in the ivaurtiruc tinder- the some.. Colonial Secretary:. Is it the intention of The MINISTER FOR MINES: The (lie (ioverinnent to introduce a Bill for Council had inserted the provisioni taken the construction of' it line of railway from from the Commonwealth Acts. He did Perch to Waniwetoo at ant early dale? riot approve of it but it had been urged to have it l-assed because in a health Act, The COLONXIAL SECRETARY re- wirih was an Art of regulation, greater plied: The Railway Advisory Board has power should 1)0 given to deal with those been requested to make an inspection of regtulations than wouild be the case in re- tile Wnnneroit district, find snainnit at gard to other Acts of Parliament. He recommendation upon the ap~plication for moved- a la y four Ptlt. Ulk receipt of That [lie amaendmeni be made. the board's report the Government wvill Question passed: the Council's amend- determine whether the line is one which ment made. ran be includedl in thle Government pro- On motion by the MINILSTER FOR rrnueof public works to he submitted MfINES, No. 77 made. to Parrlianment next session. No. 7S (consequential on No. 52) p)0st- poned. Progress reported. Tin's"-art jrurure a! .- 5 a.m. (Thursdlay), NOTICE OF MOTION-MINING INDUSTRY. Notice of inoliu iii tie name ot -0 'IF. 0. lirimagv, li :prjoiutt 1 [loyal Conmrissioin lo inquire into cud rep~ort on the iirii indtoq rv, called on. 'IeowfilatiVe C(ltomicil lion. T. F. 0. BRIMIAOE (North- Thursday, 2nd Febrcary, 1911. East) : In consequence of the lateness of the seisiorr. and also the po-;sihifiiy of Worrirs presentetl . 36112 the session closing very shortly, it was (toetion t 1Railway projet. Warnueroc 361t2 Notice at motion, flinitig indlustry A.. 1)"12 hiq iriteirtion to a'ck leave lo withdraw thre Thiui, Public T~trnry, Dtnvcut, mad tl (alli-iy ..tWca;rn Ariir1i.,, Rect., 3n. ?'~i mnotion,. The House woul inot have sufl- Tranifer of Luint Ac.tkMt. eieitt linte to L',ttntiou Act Arnmdrent.'2a.. Cornrail give a mo1tion of this inn- Criminal Code Act .%tiaendmeur, 2a., Coot. :;! juortairre adcqrtiale ctinsidera tior. Thie Rtoads, Recoin. Loan. 91,10,00. 1R...tl matter xvA4 of t-onsilleiaie itttortance. ti',rmrsty, 21t.. ('out 3(Z t6 ivoriri thle House to t'"uHinwelutnry Allowanves, IR. .... 1 and Ire have liked EiectoraiArt Auienuinetit, Ae.,einhiy'siunmnd. have had mnore tine to iousider it. 'By meats .. ... ~ Alopropriuti -n, all Otanet, .7440 leave of tire Iloise. therefore, lie woruld Supply, 41)61 7110. Lill otres . 3t wittudiaw the inotioll. )Iottou riir.- r industry., to iqie . A4ljnurnncut, ut Lie tit boriHiurs Tire PRESIDENT: Really th(le motion ThIe l'ItESI l)N'I' took the C'hair at wanrot hefore the Housse; it had neveIL 2.l15 p.111_ arid read prayeiS. been. niore. [2 FEaRuAay, 1911]] 3613 BILL-PUBLIC LIBRARY, M-USEUM, Hon. R. D. McKENZIE : lie- AND ART GALLERY OF WEST- ports were presented to Parliament an- ERN AUSTRALIA. nuafly from the Library, and from the Recommittal. Museum and Art Galery; they were separate institutions, but the committees On motion by Hon. R. D. MCKENZIE were comprised of the same gentlemen in (Honorary Minister), Bill recommitted each case. The word "any" would apply for amendment. in the event of there being two commit- Clause 12-Quorum tees, and it could also stand if there Hon. R. 3. MCKENZIE moved- should be only one committee. That in line .1 the word "seven" be Hon. J. F. CULLEN- It was under- struck out and "six" inserted in lieu. stood from the Minister that there was In the original amendment it was pro- only one committee, therefore there was vided that five trustees should constitute .no reason why the word "the"' should a quorum; this was altered to seven; it not be inserted. was now found that six would be a better Amendment put and passed; the clause number than five in view of the difficulty as amended agreed to. in getting many of the professional gen- Bill again reported with further amend- tlemen, who would be appointed as trum- ments, and the report adopted. tees, to attend meetings. Read a third time and passed. Hon. J. F. CULLEN: The "Minister should make the nunmber five; it was a mistake to make a quorum more than BILL,-TRANSFER OF LAND AkCT one-third, which would be ample security A]KENDMENT. that nothing foolish would be done. Bill read a third time, and passed. Hion. R. D. McKENZIE: The question was fully debated i~n another place, and it was felt that five would be too small a number. As a matter of fact, 10 was BILL- CONSTITUTION ACT AM]END- suggested first, hut a compromise -was .MENT. arrived at and seven was inserted. Second Reading. Amendment passsd; the clause as Debate resumed from the previous day. amended sgreet-W. Hon. Sir E. H. WITTENQOIM Clause 16-Personal property vested in (North) : The Bill before tbe House is trustees:- a most important measure and, I think, Hon. R. n. McKENZrE: - This deserves the fullest consideration. I am clause was amended by inserting after thbe Riot going to say the Bill is a new one, word "Act" in line 7 of Subelause 1 the because I understand it has had the eon- 'words ",except so far as any such goods sideration of hon. members before; in- and chattels are on loan to either com- deed, I am told it has been debated at mittee superseded by the trustees or as some length. I had not the opportunity the Governor may otherwise direct." of hearing those debates because I had There was a misapprehension that there not then the honour of being a member of were two committees, one to deal with the House. When first I saw this measuire the library and another for the museum. on the Notice Paper what most surprised As a matter of fact, one comnmittee con- me was the fact of the Government sub- trolled both institutions, therefore the mnilling a Bill of this description. One word "either" in the amendment might could have understood it had the Bill come lead to a lot of confusion. He moved an from the Opposition, hut it caused me sur- amendment- prise that it should have emanated from That the word "either" be struck out the Government. However, as it has been and "any" inserted in lieu. submitted for our consideration I anm sure Hon. J. F. CULiLEN: There was only the House will deal with it most carefully. -one committee, therefore why not substi- From what I can gather there has been tute the word "the"? outside the House no demand whatever 3614 3614COUNCIL.] for the measure, little or no request that poses all taxation and regulates all ex- there should be a reduction of the fran- penditure. Not one penny of expenditure chise; that is to say, little or no request can take place without its consent. And beyond that made by a certain section of the representatives in that House are sent the public and some portion of the Press. there by the votes of every adult person I have not heard of any public meet- throughout the State who chooses to re- ings called to discuss the matter, nor have gister. What I want to make clear is I heard of any great weight of popular that every adult person who chooses to voice brought forward in its favour. register has a vote to send a representa- Hon. J. W. Kirwan: Almost every mem- tive to the House which controls the whole ber of the Assembly is in favotur of it. of the expenditure, the imposition of taxa- tion, and practically everything that is Hon. Sir E. H. WITTENOOM: I am worth living for. No matter how poor only considering the voice of the people, that elector may be, no matter if he has and I am supported in my contention by not a single interest in Western Australia, the fact that at the recent elections two or if he does not own a single penny, he can three who stood out stoutly for the present vote to return a representative to impose condition were re-elected. Mainy of those taxation on the whole conmnunity. I who pledged themselves to vote for the thing this is as it should be. I think every reduction of the franchise did it volun- individual throughout the State should tarily, and I feel quite certain had they have a vote so that be can say under what not done it they would have been elected laws and conditions we ought to live. But, just the same. That is my impression. apart from those who, perhaps, have no Therefore it does mot seem to mue it is at interest in the State and very little means, all imperative on the House to make such and who perhaps do not care very much a very substantial change unless it has how things go, there is a large number of been shown to he the fullest desire of the people who have the spirit and instinct people.