<<

Inventory of Historic Religious Properties in : An Assessment of Significant and At-Risk Houses of Worship

A Report Prepared for: The Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia 1616 Walnut Street, Suite 1620 Philadelphia, PA 19103

August 2011

By: Molly Lester M.S., Historic Preservation Candidate 2012 University of , School of Design TABLE OF CONTENTS

Project Overview………………………………………………………...... 2 Background Scope Administration

Methodology………………………………………………………...... 2

Sources………………………………………………………...... 4

Data Categories………………………………………………………...... 8

Inventory of Historic Religious Properties………………………………….12 Summary of Results At-Risk Indicators Indicators of Architectural Modifications or Integrity Indicators of Architectural Significance Status of Designation Preservation Planning Opportunities

Cover Photographs (Source: Philadelphia Architects and Buildings) Top: Germantown Mennonite Meetinghouse, Germantown Avenue Center: North Muchmore Presbyterian , North Broad Street Bottom: North Tenth Street Church, Girard Avenue PROJECT OVERVIEW

Background Founded as ’s “Holy Experiment,” Philadelphia has a centuries-long history of fostering and constructing prominent houses of worship throughout the . In recent decades, as congregations face declining membership and shifting neighborhood demographics, their historically- and architecturally-significant properties have often suffered from deferred maintenance, insensitive alterations, and partial or complete demolition.

Advocacy organizations such as Partners for Sacred Places and the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia have focused on this issue for years, highlighting the threats to Philadelphia’s neighborhoods and communities if these structures continue to be abandoned or lost. In order to fully understand and address this issue, the Preservation Alliance established this project to gather and develop data on the significance and status of the city’s religious properties.

Scope This phase of research focused on the identification of all of Philadelphia’s historic religious properties—a degree of comprehensiveness not captured in previous inventories or data sets. It emphasized historical and architectural information on properties, as well as external data sets such as real estate information and demolition permits that had never been linked with congregational inventories. The project therefore seeks to strengthen the data of concerned advocacy groups and address the issue of declining religious properties with research from two angles: the identification of architecturally and historically significant properties that are not listed on historic registers, and the use of external indicators to identify properties that are particularly at risk of deterioration and demolition.

The scope of this summer’s research precluded on-site documentation and fieldwork (beyond the author’s previous experience with several dozen of the city’s historic religious congregations). Information on building condition and integrity is therefore dependent on earlier site visits by Partners for Sacred Places and on (undated) exterior conditions assessments included in the data provided by the Department of Licenses and Inspections.

Administration This database and report were prepared over the course of the summer of 2011 for the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia, under the supervision of Executive Director John Andrew Gallery and Advocacy Director Benjamin Leech. Additional supervision and research support was provided by the staffs of the Philadelphia Historical Commission and Partners for Sacred Places.

METHODOLOGY

This inventory of historic religious properties was populated by data from several resources, agencies, and research collections, including: the Philadelphia Historical Commission; Partners for Sacred Places; the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia; the City of Philadelphia Office of Property Assessment (formerly the Bureau of Revision of Taxes); the City of Philadelphia Department of Licenses and Inspections; the Philadelphia City Planning Commission; the Philadelphia Architects and Buildings Project; the Historical Society of Pennsylvania; the Greater Philadelphia Geohistory Network; Google

Page | 2

Maps, Google Earth and Google Street View; the Philadelphia Historical and Museum Commission; the National Register for Historic Places; the Historic American Buildings Survey; the Philly Church Project; the University of Pennsylvania’s Historic Preservation Department; and others.

With the exception of Partners’ for Sacred Places’ existing inventory (see below), none of these data sets focused exclusively on historic religious properties. All of these resources, therefore, needed to be culled and cross-referenced to identify all of the buildings that meet the following parameters:  Located within the City of Philadelphia  Currently standing  Constructed before 19601  Constructed as a religious house of worship (this excludes rowhouses and other storefront congregations)2

1 Because historic preservation policies typically define “historic” in terms of 50 years or older, the year 1960 was used as a benchmark date for inclusion in the main inventory. In cases of buildings constructed in the 10 or so years after 1960, a separate list of modern religious properties that emerged during research is included. This list is incomplete, however, and should be consulted but not considered comprehensive.

2 In some cases, the original function of a building was unclear. This includes properties that may have originally served as parochial schools or other parish properties (rather than places of worship), as well as buildings that were constructed with no religious function at all (e.g. factories or commercial buildings). Again, a separate list of non-purpose-built properties (as well as those properties whose original purpose is undetermined) is included for reference, but does not capture all of the buildings currently occupied by congregations that were built to serve non-religious functions.

Page | 3

SOURCES

Pre-2007 Religious Properties Database (Philadelphia Historic Properties Corporation; Partners for Sacred Places) Partners for Sacred Places’ database—inherited and adapted from the former Philadelphia Historic Properties Corporation—included 622 entries for historic religious properties in Philadelphia and the surrounding counties. This inventory included architectural information for many (but not all) properties, including construction dates and original architects.

For the purposes of this new inventory, which focuses only on properties within the City and of Philadelphia, data had to be filtered based on zip code to identify only those properties that are located within the county lines. The existing PSP database also included several duplicate entries for properties, as well as out-of-date information on congregations and records for properties that have since been demolished.

Tax Parcel Listings and Data (City of Philadelphia Office of Property Assessment) Data from the City of Philadelphia’s Office of Property Assessment (formerly the Bureau of Property Taxes) offered information related to property ownership, real estate transfers, and limited information on building condition—all of which can help identify at-risk historic religious properties.

Although the OPA’s spreadsheet includes some information on building construction dates, this data is limited and, in many cases, unreliable. The data also codes its building use, including a category (“W” codes ) for religious functions, but it does not distinguish between purpose-built religious properties and rowhouse or storefront churches (or other buildings that have been adaptively reused as religious properties). Google Maps and Street View (see below) and other resources were therefore consulted for each of the 1,338 W-coded properties (that were not in the Partners for Sacred Places database) to cull the buildings that were both historic and purpose-built as religious properties.

Partial and Complete Demolition Permits (Since May 2006) (City of Philadelphia Department of Licenses and Inspections) The Philadelphia Department of Licenses and Inspections provided information on all demolition permits (for partial and complete demolition) that were filed since May 2006. It is worth noting that the filing (and approval) of a permit does not signify that the demolition was completed; the status of the buildings with “complete demolition” permits could not be confirmed, however.

Current Unsafe and Imminently Dangerous Citations (as of July 2011) (City of Philadelphia Department of Licenses and Inspections) As part of its inspection responsibilities, the Department of Licenses and Inspections issues citations for properties that are deemed “unsafe” or “imminently dangerous,” proving hazardous to the health or safety of the building occupants or the public. This inventory of historic religious properties denotes all of the properties that have unresolved citations, although the contributing factors for the citation were not defined by the Department’s data.

Page | 4

Philadelphia Register of Historic Places and other Historic Property Files (Philadelphia Historical Commission) The Historical Commission’s files and research library provided extensive historical information and— where applicable—building permit information on several of the database’s properties, particularly those already listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places.

Historic Maps (Fire Insurance and Land Use) (The Greater Philadelphia Geohistory Network) The Network’s website (www.philageohistory.org) includes several digitized historic fire insurance and land use maps dating from the mid-19th century.

Because many of these maps do not denote the footprint of a building—rather, just the presence of a building—it is not always possible to confirm the reconstruction or replacement of buildings. This resource nevertheless was often valuable when other resources conflicted over construction dates, or when the name and faith tradition of the original congregation was unknown. In some cases, these maps proved that a building originally served a non-religious function.

Philly History (City of Philadelphia Department of Records) The Department of Records has digitized its collection of historic photographs, which are available at www.phillyhistory.org. These photographs were frequently consulted to confirm that the original building is consistent with the building that stands on the site today.

Google Maps, Earth, and Street View (Google) The maps, aerial photography, and street-level photography of (respectively) Google Maps, Google Earth and Google Street View were constant resources in confirming that certain properties had been demolished, and in identifying properties that were not included in earlier inventories (e.g. PSP database). The Street View images are not time-stamped, but the Street View cars are currently operating and updating their images in Philadelphia.3

Historic Inventories (National Register of Historic Places; Philadelphia Register of Historic Places) For those properties that are listed as contributing structures in historic on the local or National Registers, the district nominations and inventories often included information on properties’ construction dates, materials, and/or architects.

3 The City of Philadelphia is well documented by Google Street View, including high-definition imaging in many areas of the city. 25 properties in outlying areas of the city were not visible in Google Street View, however, and their building footprints were not outlined on Google Maps. The presumption—based on their geographic location and cursory congregational research—is that these buildings were constructed after 1960 and/or are storefront churches or synagogues. These W-coded entries are, however, included for reference as a separate table in the database.

Page | 5

“Inventory of African-American Church Resources, 1787-1949, City of Philadelphia” (Emily T. Cooperman, Ph.D., ARCH Historic Preservation Consulting) In 2008, Emily Cooperman, Ph.D., compiled an inventory of historic African-American associated churches and sites in Philadelphia. This survey included extant properties as well as others that are no longer standing. Dr. Cooperman’s research on 85 historic African-American congregations helped to populate and corroborate the architectural information in those entries.

Pennsylvania Cultural Resources Geographic Information System (GIS) (Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission) PHMC’s historic resource surveys (on file at the Philadelphia Historical Commission) and its online database (https://www.dot7.state.pa.us/ce/project/gis.asp) include architectural information and data on historic register designations.

Philadelphia Architects and Buildings Database (Various Contributors) The Philadelphia Architects and Buildings database incorporates data from several of the sources that are listed here separately. Its depth of references and historic publication citations, however, helped to populate much of the architectural information in this database.

Congregation Websites (Various Contributors) A limited number of congregations (usually those in mainline denominations) include congregational or building histories on their websites. Where possible, these dates were corroborated using other sources.

“Historic Sacred Places of Philadelphia” (Roger Moss) Roger Moss’ book was a foundational text for the research of several of the city’s well-established, extant religious properties, including investigation of their original construction as well as subsequent alterations and additions.

Real Estate Listings (Various Websites) Without a singular, comprehensive listing of properties that are on the market, data on properties that are for sale or for lease relied on individual brokers’ websites and aggregate real estate listing websites (e.g. www.loopnet.com). Colliers International Senior Vice President Cathryn Coate also contributed listings from the subscription service CoStar database.

Historic American Buildings Survey ()

Page | 6

In the course of its decades-long documentation program, the Historic American Buildings Survey has documented 57 historic religious properties that still exist today. The depth of documentation ranges from site photographs to thorough architectural histories, and can serve as a baseline for further archival research and conditions or integrity analysis.

Philadelphia Church Project Developed by an architectural amateur and enthusiast, this website project has visited over 70 churches in the Philadelphia area (with an emphasis on Roman Catholic churches). This encyclopedia of historic religious properties offered information on congregational histories and, in some cases, architectural information.

Archival Research and Documentation (University of Pennsylvania Historic Preservation Department) Several departmental papers from the University of Pennsylvania’s graduate program in historic preservation have focused on religious properties in the City of Philadelphia. This archival research and documentation of sites such as Bryant Baptist Church (originally the First Reformed Presbyterian Church) and First Church of Christ, Scientist (originally Christ Church Chapel) supported the architectural research of this new inventory.

Other Websites “Manayunk/Roxborough Churches,” Ancestry.com, www.freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~dynamo53/Manayunk/ManayunkChurche s.html (Accessed August 18, 2011).

“The Architecture of George T. Pearson,” , www.brynmawr.edu/cities/archx/gtp/index.html (Accessed August 20, 2011).

Other Books Archdiocese of Philadelphia. Our Faith-Filled Heritage: the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, 1808—2008. Philadelphia: Editions du Signe, 2007.

Gallery, John Andrew. Sacred Sites of Philadelphia. Philadelphia: Paul Dry Books, 2007.

Preisler, Julian H. Historic Synagogues of Philadelphia and the . Charleston, SC: History Press, 2009.

White, William Prescott and William H. Scott. The Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia: A Camera and Pen Sketch of Each Presbyterian Church and Institution in the City. Philadelphia: Allen, Lane & Scott, 1895.

Page | 7

DATA CATEGORIES

Data Heading Source Description Data Input Conventions Unsafe/Imminent Danger L & I Indicates citation issued by the Department of Licenses and ----- Inspection For Sale/Sold/ Real estate Properties on the market as of ----- Closed/Vacant broker websites August 2011 Broker Real estate Applies to properties on the ----- broker websites market as of August 2011 Covenant on file PSP; PHMC; Denotes protective easement PAGP (exterior façade) on file with ----- holding organization Current Congregation Various Congregation as of August “” or “” 2011 (not “St.” or “Ss.”) Faith Various Religious tradition of current “N/A” used for Tradition/Denomination congregation properties confirmed on the market or closed; “Adaptive Reuse” in cases of conversion to non- religious use Original Congregation Various Congregation at time of “Saint” or “Saints” construction (not “St.” or “Ss.”) Original Faith Various Religious tradition of original ----- Tradition/Denomination congregation Change in Faith N/A Denotes congregations that Changes in Tradition/Denomination? have changed faith traditions denomination name or denominations since their (e.g. “Methodist original construction Episcopal” to “Methodist”) not considered a change in building’s faith tradition Address Start OPA N/A ----- Address End OPA N/A ----- Direction OPA N/A Cardinal directions abbreviated Street Name OPA N/A ----- Street Suffix OPA N/A All suffixes spelled out Demolition Permits L & I Permits filed since May 2006 for partial or complete ----- demolition Full Address OPA N/A All street suffixes spelled out

Page | 8

AKA Address Various Mailing address and/or cross------street (where applicable) City N/A N/A ----- State N/A N/A ----- Zip Code N/A N/A ----- Tax Parcel OPA Unique identifier for each ----- property City Council Philadelphia City Council district ----- City Council Planning District Philadelphia City Planning District, as City Planning defined by the Philadelphia ----- Commission 2035 comprehensive plan Latitude BatchGeo.com Geocoded coordinate of ----- property Longitude BatchGeo.com Geocoded coordinate of ----- property Circa/Pre/Post Various Used when date is approximate ----- Original Building Various Year of completion of the Complete original building (currently ----- standing), before any additions or alterations Date Source Various Reference for date of “Maps” refers to construction PhilaGeoHistory maps, which can only confirm a date range (not a specific date of construction) Original Architect Various Architect of the original Initials only for middle building (currently standing), name, unless architect before any additions or went by middle name alterations (e.g. J. Franklin Stuckert); “&” indicates partners in firm; Semi-colon (;) indicates individual architects Architect Source Various Reference for architect ----- Single Building/Complex Various Denotes free-standing building (including additions) or building part of a larger ----- complex (e.g. with rectory, school, etc.) Add1 Various Description of first building ----- addition or alteration Add1Yr Various Year of completion for first ----- building addition or alteration Add1Arch Various Architect of the first building -----

Page | 9

addition or alteration Add2 Various Description of second building ----- addition or alteration Add2Yr Various Year of completion for second ----- building addition or alteration Add2Arch Various Architect of the second ----- building addition or alteration Add3 Various Description of third building ----- addition or alteration Add3Yr Various Year of completion for third ----- building addition or alteration Add3Arch Various Architect of the third building ----- addition or alteration Artisans Various Craftsmen and studios ----- associated with building ExtMat1 PHPC/PSP Primary exterior building ----- material ExtMat2 PHPC/PSP Secondary exterior building ----- material CityReg(Ind) PHC Denotes individual listing on the Philadelphia Register of ----- Historic Places CityReg(HD) PHC Denotes inclusion within the boundaries of a historic district on the Philadelphia Register of ----- Historic Places (does not necessarily signify that property is contributing) NatReg(Ind) NPS Denotes individual listing on the National Register of ----- Historic Places NatReg(HD) NPS Denotes inclusion within the boundaries of a historic district on the National Register of ----- Historic Places (does not necessarily signify that property is contributing) NHL NPS Denotes designation as a ----- National Historic Landmark PSP High Priority PSP Identified by Partners for Sacred Places as a high-priority ----- property to target for preservation HABS HABS Indicates whether property has been documented by the ----- Historic American Buildings Survey

Page | 10

Census of Stained Glass PAB Indicates whether property has been documented by the ----- Census of Stained Glass Cooperman Inventory PAGP Indicates whether property was included in Emily Cooperman’s ----- inventory of African-American sites Notes Various N/A ----- Owner1 OPA First listed owner of the ----- property Owner2 OPA Second listed owner of the ----- property Census OPA Census tract ----- Sale Date OPA Date property sold MM/DD/YYYY Bldg CD OPA [Building Code Table] See OPA ----- Zone OPA Legal use per licenses and ----- inspection Frt OPA 11 Pos. 2 Dec. Front dimension ----- of property Dpt OPA 11 Pos. 2 Dec. Depth of ----- property Tot Area OPA 11 Pos. 2 Dec. Total land area ----- of property Otr Bldg OPA Other buildings on site ----- Stories OPA 3 Pos. 1 Dec. number of stories ----- Gen Const OPA [Type construction table] See ----- OPA Dt Ext Cond OPA Date exterior inspected ----- Ext Cond OPA Exterior appearance -----

Page | 11

INVENTORY OF HISTORIC RELIGIOUS PROPERTIES

Summary of Results A total of 748 historic religious properties are included in this database, including 33 buildings that have been adapted to non-religious functions.

The inventory also captures the following subsets of properties: At-Risk Indicators I. 51 properties are closed, vacant, or for sale (including adaptively reused properties and properties whose status cannot be confirmed); II. 161 properties were sold within the last ten years; III. 10 properties have open “unsafe” citations from the Department of Licenses and Inspections, as of August 2011 (including 2 properties that are currently for sale); IV. 473 properties have been rated “4” or higher on the Office of Property Assessment’s evaluation of exterior conditions (with “8” as the most severe deterioration);4 V. 2 properties have filed for complete demolition permits.

Indicators of Architectural Modifications or Integrity VI. 33 properties have been adapted to non-religious uses; VII. 254 properties have changed religious denominations or faith traditions since their original construction (excluding the 33 properties that have been adaptively reused, the 51 properties that are currently closed or for sale, and the 86 properties whose original and/or current faith tradition could not be confirmed); VIII. 12 properties were constructed for Catholic congregations but are currently occupied by non-denominational or other Protestant congregations;5 IX. 5 properties have changed use from Christian faith traditions to non-Christian religious traditions, suggesting more substantial alterations and modifications. (This figure does not include cases of adaptive reuse).

Indicators of Architectural Significance X. 16 Properties are known to have been constructed before 1850, but are not listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places (individually or in historic districts). 6

Status of Designation XI. 132 properties are individually listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places; XII. 10 properties are listed on the Philadelphia Register within the geographic boundaries of a local historic district, but are not individually listed; XIII. 34 properties are listed individually on the National Register of Historic Places; XIV. 8 properties are designated National Historic Landmarks; XV. 6 properties are individually listed on the National Register of Historic Places, but are not individually listed on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places;

4 188 properties in the inventory have no exterior conditions rating in the OPA property index. 5 This subset does not include the 4 formerly Catholic properties that have been adaptively reused, or the 10 Catholic properties that are currently closed, vacant, or for sale. 6 Construction dates are not known and/or confirmed for 29 properties in the database. As those years are determined, this subset may change.

Page | 12

XVI. 10 properties have been deemed by the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission as eligible for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places, but are not yet listed; XVII. 78 properties are listed within the geographic boundaries of a National Register Historic District, but are not individually listed on the National Register.

Preservation Planning Opportunities XVIII. 206 properties are located within the first- and second-priority planning districts targeted by the Philadelphia 2035 Comprehensive Plan (e.g. Lower South; West Park; Central; University/Southwest; Lower Northeast).

Page | 13

INVENTORY OF HISTORIC RELIGIOUS PROPERTIES: AT-RISK INDICATORS

I. Properties that are closed, vacant, or for sale (including adaptively reused properties and properties whose status cannot be confirmed); II. Properties that were sold within the last ten years; III. Properties that have open “unsafe” citations from the Department of Licenses and Inspections, as of August 2011; IV. Properties that have been rated “4” or higher on the Office of Property Assessment’s evaluation of exterior conditions (with “8” as the most severe deterioration); V. Properties that have filed for complete demolition permits.

Page | 14

I. At-Risk Indicators: Properties Vacant, Closed or For Sale 1

CURRENT FAITH DEMOLITION YEAR ORIGINAL UNSAFE/ FOR SALE/SOLD/ ORIGINAL RELIGION/ CIRCA/ NATREG(IND BROKER CURRENT CONGREGATION TRADITION/ ORIGINAL CONGREGATION PERMITS (SINCE FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS ZIP CODE BUILDING ORIGINAL ARCHITECT CITYREG (IND) CITYREG (HD) NATREG (HD) IMM.DANG. CLOSED/VACANT DENOMINATION PRE/POST ) DENOMINATION 2006) COMPLETED

(FOR SALE WITH 1301-1307 S. 33RD STREET); OCCUPIED STILL BY FOR SALE WEICHERT N/A JAMES W. QUEEN MEMORIAL CHAPEL PRESBYTERIAN 1309-1319 S. 33RD STREET 19146 1925 NO NO NO NO HEADSTART?; FORMER JAMES W. QUEEN MEMORIAL CHAPEL CLOSED? 40TH STREET CHURCH OF GOD PENTECOSTAL MANTUA BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 651-659 N. 40TH STREET 19104 CIRCA 1888 ISAAC PURSELL NO NO NO NO SOLD COLLIERS ALL SAINTS’ EPISCOPAL CHURCH, CRESCENTVILLE N/A TRINITY PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH, CRESCENTVILLE EPISCOPAL 6301 CRESCENTVILLE ROAD 19120 1926 HORACE W. SELLERS NO NO NO NO MONASTERY AND MANAYUNK FOR SALE ADAPTIVE REUSE FOURTH REFORMED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 355 MARTIN STREET 19128 1900 NO NO NO NO APARTMENTS AVENUES CLOSED? CAMBODIAN STUDENTS COUNCIL? ADATH SHALOM? JUDAISM BETH SAMUEL SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM 2353-2355 S. MARSHALL STREET RITNER STREET? 19148 CIRCA 1927 MAX A. BERNHARDT NO NO NO NO CORPORATE REALTY FOR SALE PARTNERS & CO. (KEVIN ADAPTIVE REUSE SAINT PAUL'S BAPTIST CHURCH; CHRIST EVANGELICAL CHURCH (ORIGINAL) 948-952 N. 8TH STREET 19123 1875 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO SMITH) COMMERCIAL (ONLY ORIGINAL FAÇADE REMAINS) CLOSED? DEVEREUX MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST DEVEREAUX MEMORIAL METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 2527-2535 W. ALLEGHENY AVENUE 19132 1905 NO NO NO NO

CLOSED? DISSTON MEMORIAL PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) DISSTON MEMORIAL PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 4506 TYSON AVENUE 19135 1886 EDWIN F. DURANG? NO NO NO NO FOR SALE? FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF HOLMESBURG PRESBYTERIAN FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF HOLMESBURG PRESBYTERIAN 7811 FRANKFORD AVENUE 19136 1853 NO NO NO NO MICHAEL SALOVE FOR SALE FORMER 40TH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH N/A 40TH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST 125-129 S. 40TH STREET 19104 1872 SLOAN & HUTTON NO NO NO NO COMPANY DEM-COMPLETE FOR SALE KW COMMERCIAL FORMER CHRIST INDEPENDENT BAPTIST CHURCH N/A SAINT AMBROSE PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 114 W. ONTARIO STREET HOWARD STREET 19140 CIRCA 1904 DUHRING, OKIE & ZEIGLER NO NO NO NO WEST CORPORATE REALTY PHILADELPHIA FOR LEASE FORMER CHRIST MEMORIAL EPISCOPAL CHURCH N/A CHRIST MEMORIAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 4233 CHESTNUT STREET 19104 1886 ISAAC PURSELL NO NO NO PARTNERS & CO. STREETCAR SUBURB

CHURCH OF THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION OF THE BLESSED VIRGIN MARY PAUL MONAGHAN (EDWIN FORREST CLOSED FORMER CHURCH OF THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION N/A ROMAN CATHOLIC 1018-1020 N. FRONT STREET 108-110 W. ALLEN STREET 19123 1869 NO NO ELIGIBLE NO (B.V.M.) BALDWIN - 1910-11 - LOWER CHURCH)

FORMER COMMUNITY OF JOY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST/TABOR UNITED UNITED CHURCH OF CLOSED N/A TABOR UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST/TABOR REFORMED CHURCH DEM-INTERIOR NON- 5700 N. FAIRHILL STREET W. CHEW AVENUE 19120 1921 NO NO NO NO CHURCH OF CHRIST CHRIST (UCC) LOAD BEARING DEM-REMOVE A / SOLD COLLIERS FORMER CORPUS CHRISTI PARISH N/A CORPUS CHRISTI ROMAN CATHOLIC 2800 W. ALLEGHENY AVENUE 19132 1927 NO NO NO NO INSERT A TANK CLOSED FORMER EAST FALLS UNITED METHODIST CHURCH N/A EAST FALLS METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 3580 INDIAN QUEEN LANE 19129 CIRCA 1872 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO POWELTON US FOR SALE FORMER EMMANUEL LUTHERAN CHURCH N/A EMMANUEL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 3727 BARING STREET 19104 1872 NO NO NO VILLAGE SOLD COLLIERS? FORMER EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF THE GOOD SHEPHERD N/A EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF THE GOOD SHEPHERD EPISCOPAL 2121-2127 E. CUMBERLAND STREET 19125 1889 NO NO NO NO REFORMED/UNITED FOR SALE KW COMMERCIAL FORMER FAITH UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST N/A FAITH UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST? REFORMED CHURCH ON MAP CHURCH OF CHRIST 7253-7265 OGONTZ AVENUE 19138 1930 NO NO NO NO (UCC) VACANT? FORMER GOOD SHEPHERD CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A GOOD SHEPHERD CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 6535 CHESTER AVENUE 6667 CHESTER AVENUE 19142 1950 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO FOR SALE WEICHERT FORMER HOPE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH N/A HOPE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 1301-1307 S. 33RD STREET 19146 1887 CHARLES L. BOLTON NO NO NO NO CLOSED FORMER KING OF PEACE CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A KING OF PEACE CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 1301 S. 26TH STREET 2500 WHARTON STREET 19146 CIRCA 1926 NO NO NO NO FOR SALE FORMER KYNETT MEMORIAL METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH N/A KYNETT MEMORIAL METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST 1629-1635 W. CAYUGA STREET N. 17TH STREET 19140 CIRCA 1901 HALES & BALLINGER NO NO NO NO FORMER MARTHOMA CHURCH OF PHILADELPHIA/ORTHODOX METHODIST FOR SALE BY OWNER N/A ORTHODOX METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 2060 ORTHODOX STREET TORRESDALE STREET 19124 CIRCA 1916 NO NO NO NO EPISCOPAL CHURCH CORPORATE REALTY FOR SALE? PARTNERS & CO. (KEVIN FORMER MIKVEH ISRAEL SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM MIKVEH ISRAEL SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM 2331 N. BROAD STREET 19132 CIRCA 1908 PILCHER & TACHAU YES NO NO NO SMITH) FORMER MIZPAH SEVENTH DAY ADVENTIST CHURCH/FORMER FRANKFORD SOLD COLLIERS N/A FRANKFORD BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 4357 PAUL STREET UNITY STREET 19124 1897 CHARLES W. BOLTON NO NO NO NO BAPTIST CHURCH CLOSED FORMER MOST BLESSED SACRAMENT CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A MOST BLESSED SACRAMENT CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 5628 CHESTER AVENUE 19143 1924 CHARLES W. GILMORE NO NO NO NO REFORMED/UNITED FOR SALE COLLIERS FORMER OAK LANE UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST N/A REFORMED CHURCH OF OAK LANE CHURCH OF CHRIST 6547 N. 7TH STREET 19126 1905 VALENTINE LEE NO NO NO NO (UCC) FOR SALE COLLIERS FORMER OUR LADY OF ANGELS ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A OUR LADY OF ANGELS ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 4972 MASTER STREET 19131 1924 H. STACKHOUSE; JAMES DOYLES & SONS NO NO NO NO CLOSED FORMER OUR LADY OF CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A OUR LADY OF VICTORY CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 224-250 N. 54TH STREET 5412 VINE STREET 19139 1909 ROWLAND W. BOYLE NO NO NO NO VACANT? FORMER PENN ALEXANDER SCHOOL LIBRARY AND TECHNOLOGY CENTER SAINT ANDREW'S COLLEGIATE CHAPEL, PHILADELPHIA SCHOOL OF DIVINITY EPISCOPAL 4201 SPRUCE STREET 19104 1926 ZANTZINGER, BORIE & MEDARY NO NO NO NO DEM-REMOVE A / SOLD COLLIERS FORMER RESURRECTION EPISCOPAL CHURCH N/A RESURRECTION EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 3301 WELLINGTON STREET 19149 1928 NO NO NO NO INSERT A TANK CLOSED FORMER SAINT ALOYSIUS CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A SAINT ALOYSIUS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 2604-2608 TASKER STREET 19145 1924 CHARLES F. SCHAEF NO NO NO NO COLDWELL BANKER SAINT ANDREW'S BYZANTINE UKRAINIAN CATHOLIC CHURCH; JEWISH FOR SALE FORMER SAINT ANDREW'S BYZANTINE UKRAINIAN CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A JUDAISM 425-429 PINE STREET 19106 CIRCA 1850 UNKNOWN NO NO SOCIETY HILL COMMERCIAL NRT NATIONAL WORKER EDUCATIONAL CENTER (ORIGINAL) PRUDENTIAL FOX & GREATER SAINT MATTHEW BAPTIST CHURCH; SAINT ANTHONY OF PADUA FOR SALE FORMER SAINT ANTHONY OF PADUA CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A ROMAN CATHOLIC 2319-2327 FITZWATER STREET 19146 1892 FRANK WATSON NO NO NO NO ROACH CATHOLIC CHURCH (ORIGINAL) FOR SALE COLLIERS FORMER SAINT AUGUSTINE CHURCH OF THE COVENANT, EPISCOPAL N/A PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF THE COVENANT EPISCOPAL 2701-2709 W. GIRARD AVENUE 19130 1888 FRANK R. WATSON NO NO NO NO CLOSED FORMER SAINT BONIFACE CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A SAINT BONIFACE (BONIFASCIUS IN PAB?) CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 142-174 W. DIAMOND STREET 19122 1872 NO NO ELIGIBLE NO VACANT FORMER SAINT HENRY ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A SAINT HENRY ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 4400-4420 N. 5TH STREET 19140 1921 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO FORMER SAINT JAMES UNITED METHODIST CHURCH/SAINT ALBAN'S SAINT JAMES UNITED METHODIST CHURCH; SAINT ALBAN'S EPISCOPAL FOR SALE? METHODIST EPISCOPAL 111 E. TABOR ROAD 199 E. TABOR ROAD 19120 1915 GEORGE T. PEARSON NO NO NO NO EPISCOPAL CHURCH, OLNEY CHURCH, OLNEY FOR SALE COLLIERS FORMER SAINT PETER'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH, GERMANTOWN N/A SAINT PETER'S CHURCH EPISCOPAL 6008 WAYNE AVENUE 19144 1883 FURNESS & HEWITTT YES NO YES NO CLOSED FORMER SAINT PHILIP'S UNITED METHODIST CHURCH N/A SAINT PHILIP'S METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST 700-710 E. TIOGA STREET 19134 1910 BALLINGER & PERROT NO NO NO NO UNSAFE? FRANKFORD GROUP MINISTRY METHODIST CENTRAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST 1515 ORTHODOX STREET 4620 GRISCOM STREET 19124 CIRCA 1876 NO NO NO NO COLONIAL VACANT? GERMANTOWN MENNONITE MEETING HOUSE MENNONITE GERMANTOWN MENNONITE MEETING MENNONITE 6119-6131 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19144 1770 UNKNOWN YES NO YES GERMANTOW N COLONIAL GERMANTOWN SETTLEMENT CHARTER SCHOOL? (4807 AUCTIONED JUNE 16, FOR SALE?/SOLD? N/A SAINT MICHAEL OF THE SAINTS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 4811 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19144 1952 NO NO NO GERMANTOW 2011) N COLONIAL FOR SALE? GOODWILL BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST WAKEFIELD PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 4711 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19144 1888 GEORGE T. PEARSON NO NO NO GERMANTOW N FOR SALE KW COMMERCIAL IGLESIA PENTECOSTAL SUBE ACA N/A SAINT BARNABAS PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 2300-2304 N. 3RD STREET 19133 CIRCA 1875 NO NO NO NO CLOSED? NEW GREATER STRAIGHTWAY BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST CONGREGATION OHEL JACOB; CONGREGATION ADATH JESHURUN (HABS) JUDAISM 1705-1713 N. 7TH STREET 19122 1888 J. FRANKLIN STUCKERT YES NO NO NO

CLOSED? PATHWAY EVANGELISTIC CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL HERMON PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 4837 FRANKFORD AVENUE 19124 1868 NO NO NO NO FORMER RUFFIN NICHOLS MEMORIAL AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL FOR SALE N/A CHURCH OF THE NATIVITY 618 N. 11TH STREET 19123 1909 NO NO NO NO CHURCH/CHURCH OF THE NATIVITY

US FOR SALE COLLIERS SILOAM N/A CHURCH OF THE ASSUMPTION ROMAN CATHOLIC DEM-INTERIOR NON- 1123-1133 SPRING GARDEN STREET 19123 1849 PATRICK C. KEELY YES NO NO NO LOAD BEARING CLOSED? TABERNACLE MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST BEREAN; RHAWNHURST METHODIST METHODIST 1900-1908 RIPLEY STREET LORETTO AVENUE 19111 NO NO NO NO II. At-Risk Indicators: Properties Sold Within the Last 10 Years 1

CURRENT FAITH YEAR ORIGINAL ORIGINAL RELIGION/ DEMOLITION CIRCA/ CITYREG CITYREG NATREG UNSAFE/IMM.DANG. FOR SALE/SOLD/CLOSED/VACANT BROKER COVENANT ON FILE CURRENT CONGREGATION TRADITION/DENOMINA ORIGINAL CONGREGATION FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS ZIP CODE BUILDING ORIGINAL ARCHITECT NATREG (HD) NHL HABS DENOMINATION PERMITS (SINCE 2006) PRE/POST (IND) (HD) (IND) TION COMPLETED SALE DATE DT EXT COND EXT COND UNITARIAN DEM-INTERIOR NON- NO UNITARIAN SOCIETY OF GERMANTOWN UNITARIAN CHURCH OF GERMANTOWN UNITARIAN 6509-6511 LINCOLN DRIVE 19119 1928 EDMUND B. GILCHRIST NO NO NO NO NO NO UNIVERSALIST (UUA) LOAD BEARING 1/4/2001 0 UNITED CHURCH OF UNITED CHURCH OF NO BETHEL UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST SALEM ZION UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST 6101 N. MASCHER STREET 19120 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHRIST (UCC) CHRIST (UCC) 1/13/2001 0 NO EL BUEN SAMARITANO TEMPLO PENTECOSTAL PENTECOSTAL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 501 W. SEDGLEY AVENUE 2344 N. 5TH STREET? 19140 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/30/2001 4/10/2006 4 NO COMMUNITY CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL ALLEGHENY AVENUE CHURCH BAPTIST 3167 FRANKFORD AVENUE ALLEGHENY AVENUE 19134 CIRCA 1899 STEARNS & CASTOR NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/19/2001 4/10/2006 4 NO OPEN HEART MINISTRIES NON-DENOMINATIONAL BETH HAMREDOSH/BETH JACOB SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM 6018-6022 LARCHWOOD AVENUE 19143 1932 I. LEVIN? NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/30/2001 5/16/2006 4 RITTENH NO DAYCARE? ADAPTIVE REUSE SAINT PHILIP'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 1923-1927 LOMBARD STREET 19146 CIRCA 1873 THOMAS EARLY YES OUSE NO NO NO NO 5/1/2001 FITLER 4/27/2011 4 WELSH PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH; FAIRMOUNT STATION SPRING NO UNITED FOR CHRIST MINISTRIES PENTECOSTAL POST OFFICE? (1895 ATLAS-SAME FOOTPRINT AS 1910 PRESBYTERIAN 626-630 N. 21ST STREET 19130 CIRCA 1920 NO NO NO NO NO 6/28/2001 GARDEN CHURCH) 7/23/2007 3 NO WOOLSTON CHILD AND FAMILY CENTER - CLOSED ADAPTIVE REUSE EAST BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 1236-1244 E. COLUMBIA AVENUE 19125 NO NO NO NO NO NO 7/9/2001 20060410 4 US NO WOODLAND BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST WOODLAND BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 2210 S. 65TH STREET 19142 PRE 1942 NO NO NO NO NO NO 7/30/2001 0 NO HOLY INNOCENTS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC HOLY INNOCENTS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 4213-4217 GLENDALESTREET 1337 E. HUNTING PARK AVENUE 19124 1958 NO NO NO NO NO NO 9/18/2001 4 NO FAITH INDEPENDENT BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 3215-3217 S. 22ND STREET 19145 PRE 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/5/2001 5/10/2007 4 NEW MOUNT ZION PENTECOSTAL CHURCH OF GOD CHURCH OF GOD IN NO 20TH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 1501-1509 N. 20TH STREET 19121 CIRCA 1899 THOMAS P. LONSDALE NO NO NO NO NO NO IN CHRIST CHRIST (COGIC) 12/19/2001 10/19/2010 4 NO SHERWOOD CHRISTIAN OUTREACH CENTER N/A 5543 WILLOWS AVENUE 19143 1925 NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/11/2002 0 UNITED CHURCH OF FRANKFORD CONGREGATIONAL UNITED CHURCH OF UNITED CHURCH OF NO GRACE TRINITY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST 5200-5248 OXFORD AVENUE 19124 1928 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHRIST (UCC) CHRIST CHRIST (UCC) 2/18/2002 4/17/2006 4 NO INDIA HARVEST CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL TACONY METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 4800 LONGSHORE AVENUE HEGERMAN ST 19135 PRE 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO 2/20/2002 5/4/2006 4 SAINT THOMAS UNITED METHODIST CHURCH, NO METHODIST SAINT THOMAS METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST 4701 TACKAWANNA STREET 19124 CIRCA 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO FRANKFORD 4/23/2002 4/17/2006 4 FOR SALE KW COMMERCIAL NO IGLESIA PENTECOSTAL SUBE ACA N/A SAINT BARNABAS PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 2300-2304 N. 3RD STREET 19133 CIRCA 1875 NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/12/2002 8/9/2006 4 PHILADELPHIA PRAYER, PRAISE AND WORSHIP NO PENTECOSTAL EZEKIEL BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 230 S. 51ST STREET 19139 1905 HENRY L. REINHOLD NO NO NO NO NO NO CENTER 6/28/2002 5/18/2006 4 SAINT STANISLAUS CATHOLIC CHURCH; FIRST NO SAINT PHILIP NERI WORSHIP SITE ROMAN CATHOLIC PRESBYTERIAN 234-244 FITZWATER STREET 19147 1857 SAMUEL SLOAN YES NO NO NO NO NO PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF SOUTHWARK (ORIGINAL) 8/25/2002 3 NO MOUNT PISGAH UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST MOUNT PISGAH METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST 238-244 E. CAMBRIA STREET 19134 NO NO NO NO NO NO 8/26/2002 4/10/2006 4 NO CHRISTIAN HERITAGE CATHOLIC CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 6431-6439 CALLOWHILL STREET 400 N. SIMPSON STREET 19151 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/1/2002 5/15/2006 4 NO KENSINGTON ASSEMBLY OF GOD ASSEMBLY OF GOD SAINT JOHN'S EVANGELICAL REFORMED CHURCH 3375 FRANKFORD AVENUE 19134 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/11/2002 0 PSP FIRST AFRICAN BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST FIRST AFRICAN BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 1600-1606 CHRISTIAN STREET 19146 1904 WATSON & HUCKEL NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/30/2002 4/6/2006 4 NO TABOR LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN TABOR EVANGELISTIC LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 4843 MASCHER STREET 4860 N. HOWARD STREET 19120 1909 CARL P. BERGER NO NO NO NO NO NO 2/26/2003 0 NO SPRUCE HILL CHRISTIAN ACADEMY/SCHOOL ADAPTIVE REUSE PILLAR OF FIRE SCHOOL; ORIGINAL USE? 4109-4111 BALTIMORE AVENUE 19104 NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/10/2003 0 SPRING NO FAMILY INSITUTE OF PHILADELPHIA ADAPTIVE REUSE BETHANY MISSION 1527 BRANDYWINE STREET 19130 CIRCA 1887 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO NO 3/11/2003 GARDEN 2/3/2005 0 NO CALVIN PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) CALVIN PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 5931-5943 MASTER STREET 1401 N. 60TH STREET 19151 CIRCA 1922 HEACOCK & HOKANSON NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/13/2003 5/16/2006 4 SOCIETY NO EPISCOPAL COMMUNITY SERVICES ADAPTIVE REUSE SAINT PAUL'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 221-231 S. 3RD STREET 19106 1761 YES NO RITTENHOUSE NO NO 4/16/2003 HILL 20101028 4 NO THIRD MORAVIAN CHURCH MORAVIAN THIRD MORAVIAN CHURCH MORAVIAN 3559-3561 KENSINGTON AVENUE 19134 1869 NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/13/2003 4/10/2006 4 NO CHRIST'S PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) ITALIAN PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 1010 S. 10TH STREET 1020 S. 10TH STREET 19147 CIRCA 1908 CHARLES L. HILLMAN NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/15/2003 10/21/2010 4 842 S. 57TH STREET (PARCEL NO ABIDING TRUTH MINISTRIES NON-DENOMINATIONAL NINTH PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 5701 WASHINGTON AVENUE 19143 1916 GEORGE D. SAVAGE NO NO NO NO NO NO EXPLORER); 846 S. 57TH STREET 6/24/2003 5/17/2006 4 NO CHESTNUT HILL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST CHESTNUT HILL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST 8810-8814 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19118 CIRCA 1885 NO NO NO CHESTNUT HILL NO NO 7/10/2003 0 1030 N. 48TH STREET; WYALUSING NO OUR MOTHER OF SORROWS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC OUR MOTHER OF SORROWS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 4800-4814 LANCASTER AVENUE 19131 1867 EDWIN F. DURANG; FRANK WATSON NO NO NO NO NO NO 8/3/2003 STREET 0 0 RITTENH NO LUTHERAN CHURCH OF THE HOLY COMMUNION LUTHERAN SAINT PAUL’S REFORMED EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 2108-2114 CHESTNUT STREET 101-121 S. VAN PELT STREET 19103 1880 ISAAC PURSELL NO OUSE NO NO NO NO FITLER 11/14/2003 1/6/2011 4 CHAPEL OF THE GESU (SAINT JOSEPH'S PREPARATORY NO ROMAN CATHOLIC CHAPEL OF THE GESU ROMAN CATHOLIC 1734-1754 W. THOMPSON STREET 19130 1888 EDWIN F. DURANG NO NO NO NO NO YES SCHOOL) 12/31/2003 4/6/2006 4 NO BROAD STREET MINISTRY PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) CHAMBERS-WYLIE MEMORIAL PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 321-327 S. BROAD STREET 19107 1901 RANKIN & KELLOGG YES NO NO BROAD STREET NO NO 1/6/2004 10/14/2010 4 NO OLD SHIP OF ZION BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST HOPE BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 2422-2424 W. YORK STREET 19132 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 2/1/2004 4/7/2006 3 NO GREATER SAINT LUKE'S DISCIPLE CHURCH PENTECOSTAL HIGHWAY MISSION TABERNACLE UNION? 1500-1506 RACE STREET 19121 1865 NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/16/2004 6/1/2007 4 NO CHESTNUT STREET BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST BEREAN BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 4017-4021 CHESTNUT STREET 19104 CIRCA 1895 FRANK R. WATSON NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/4/2004 4/17/2006 4 NO TRINITY CHELTEN UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST CHELTEN AVENUE UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST 2145-2155 E. CHELTEN AVENUE 19138 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/12/2004 5/8/2006 4 NO MOUNT ZION GREATER HIGHWAY CHURCH OF CHRIST PENTECOSTAL SAINT STEPHEN ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH - CLOSED 1993 ROMAN CATHOLIC 3801-3819 N. BROAD STREET 19140 1896 FRANK R. WATSON NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/26/2004 0 KENCREST CHILDHOOD CENTER: NO ADAPTIVE REUSE SAINT MARY OF CZESTOCHOWA ROMAN CATHOLIC 5900 ELMWOOD AVENUE 19143 NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/24/2004 CENTER 0 0 NO SPIRIT AND TRUTH WORSHIP CATHEDRAL NON-DENOMINATIONAL CONGREGATION BETH ISRAEL JUDAISM 3135-3149 W. MONTGOMERY AVENUE 1801 N. 32ND STREET 19121 1907 ANDREW J. SAUER YES NO NO NO NO NO 7/6/2004 11/9/2010 5 NO WORD ALIVE WORSHIP CENTER NON-DENOMINATIONAL 801-807 W. LUZERNE STREET 19140 1928 NO NO NO NO NO NO 7/6/2004 4/10/2006 4 NO CENTRE D'ADORATION CHRETIENNE HAITIAN CHRISTIAN HOPE LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 4530 BENNER STREET 19135 PRE 1942 NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/7/2004 4/17/2006 4 NO NEW INSPIRATIONAL BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST ALL SAINTS LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 1907-1909 W. CAYUGA STREET 19140 1906 CARL P. BERGER NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/8/2004 4/10/2006 3 REFORMED/UNITED FOR SALE COLLIERS NO FORMER OAK LANE UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST N/A REFORMED CHURCH OF OAK LANE CHURCH OF CHRIST 6547 N. 7TH STREET 19126 1905 VALENTINE LEE NO NO NO NO NO NO (UCC) 12/14/2004 0 NO NORTH PENN BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST NORTH PENN BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 2425 N. 27TH STREET 19132 CIRCA 1911 CHARLES M. WELLS NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/9/2005 4/7/2006 5 NO FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF OLNEY PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF OLNEY PRESBYTERIAN 239 W. TABOR ROAD 5435 N. 3RD STREET 19120 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/12/2005 0 NO OLNEY BAPTIST MISSION BAPTIST FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF OLNEY PRESBYTERIAN 5415 N. 3RD STREET 19120 1925 CHARLES ZIEGLER NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/12/2005 0 SPRING NO CONDOMINIUMS ADAPTIVE REUSE CHRIST EVANGELICAL REFORMED CHURCH 1520 GREEN STREET 19130 1860 STEPHEN D. BUTTON YES NO NO NO NO 2/23/2005 GARDEN 20101130 4 NO FREEDOM OF FAITH RUSSIAN LUTHERAN CHURCH? RUSSIAN LUTHERAN SAINT PHILIP'S LUTHERAN CHURCH OF THE DEAF LUTHERAN 11047 BUSTLETON AVENUE 19116 POST 1962 NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/25/2005 4 NO GREATER FAITH MISSIONARY BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST BELOVED SAINT JOHN BAPTIST CHURCH? BAPTIST 2601 W. LEHIGH AVENUE 19132 1921 NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/26/2005 4 NO EMMANUEL PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 1212-1220 MARLBOROUGH STREET 19125 CIRCA 1922 NO NO NO NO NO NO 7/24/2005 11/9/2005 4 MESSIAH GATEWAY CHURCH; SAINT ANDREW'S CHURCH NO NEW COMFORT BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST OF CHRIST; SAINT ANDREW'S REFORMED CHURCH 2200-2214 SNYDER AVENUE 19145 1921 CHARLES W. BOLTON & SON NO NO NO NO NO NO (ORIGINAL?) 9/7/2005 0 PARTIALLY OR COMPLETELY DEMOLISHED: NO SEPTEMBER 2011; FORMER MONASTERY OF SAINT N/A MONASTERY OF SAINT CLARE ROMAN CATHOLIC 2012-2030 W. GIRARD AVENUE 19130 1915 NO NO NO NO NO NO 9/14/2005 CLARE 20081007 7 SAINT JOHN'S AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL AFRICAN METHODIST NO 7039 GREENWAY AVENUE 19142 PRE 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH EPISCOPAL 10/18/2005 0 RITTENH CHURCH OF THE NEW SWEDENBORGIAN NO OFFICES ADAPTIVE REUSE SWEDENBORGIAN 2129 CHESTNUT STREET 19103 1883 THEOPHILUS P. CHANDLER, JR. YES OUSE NO NO NO NO 10/27/2005 CHURCH FITLER 0 0 NO WYOMING AVENUE BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST WYOMING AVENUE BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 123-125 E. WYOMING AVENUE 19120 1922 HEACOCK & HOKANSON NO NO NO NO NO NO 11/29/2005 0 COLDWELL SAINT ANDREW'S BYZANTINE UKRAINIAN CATHOLIC FORMER SAINT ANDREW'S BYZANTINE UKRAINIAN SOCIETY FOR SALE BANKER NO N/A CHURCH; JEWISH NATIONAL WORKER EDUCATIONAL JUDAISM 425-429 PINE STREET 19106 CIRCA 1850 UNKNOWN NO NO SOCIETY HILL NO NO 12/3/2005 CATHOLIC CHURCH HILL COMMERCIAL NRT CENTER (ORIGINAL) 11/24/2009 4 48TH STREET BAPTIST CHURCH; HOLY COMFORTER NO JEHOVAH JIREH MINSTRIES/BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST EPISCOPAL 4803-4809 HAVERFORD AVENUE 19139 1874 FURNESS & HEWITT NO NO NO NO NO NO PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH (ORIGINAL) 12/4/2005 5/15/2006 4 NO OLNEY BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST OLNEY BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 237 W. CHEW AVENUE 19120 1924 NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/12/2005 0 CLOSED NO FORMER SAINT ALOYSIUS CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A SAINT ALOYSIUS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 2604-2608 TASKER STREET 19145 1924 CHARLES F. SCHAEF NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/20/2005 4/17/2006 4 3001-11 C STREET; 413 E. INDIANA NO LIBERTY BAPTIST CHURCH OF KENSINGTON BAPTIST KENSINGTON CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH CONGREGATIONAL 3001 C STREET 19134 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO AVENUE 12/28/2005 4/10/2006 4 II. At-Risk Indicators: Properties Sold Within the Last 10 Years 2

CURRENT FAITH YEAR ORIGINAL ORIGINAL RELIGION/ DEMOLITION CIRCA/ CITYREG CITYREG NATREG UNSAFE/IMM.DANG. FOR SALE/SOLD/CLOSED/VACANT BROKER COVENANT ON FILE CURRENT CONGREGATION TRADITION/DENOMINA ORIGINAL CONGREGATION FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS ZIP CODE BUILDING ORIGINAL ARCHITECT NATREG (HD) NHL HABS DENOMINATION PERMITS (SINCE 2006) PRE/POST (IND) (HD) (IND) TION COMPLETED SALE DATE DT EXT COND EXT COND NO MARANATHA BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST SAINT BARTHOLOMEW'S PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 4525 COMLY STREET DITMAN STREET 19135 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO 2/10/2006 4/17/2006 4 CLOSED NO FORMER KING OF PEACE CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A KING OF PEACE CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 1301 S. 26TH STREET 2500 WHARTON STREET 19146 CIRCA 1926 NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/13/2006 4/17/2006 4 NO HOLY CROSS LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN KREUZ LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 815 W. LEHIGH AVENUE 19133 1899 EMIL H.C. HARTMANN NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/26/2006 4/10/2006 4 NO HARVEST TIME CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP NON-DENOMINATIONAL 4001-4015 N. 9TH STREET 19140 PRE 1942 NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/24/2006 0 AFRICAN METHODIST AFRICAN METHODIST NO ZION AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH ZION AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 1600-1606 S. 21ST STREET 19145 1928 GEORGE E. SAVAGE NO NO NO NO NO NO EPISCOPAL EPISCOPAL 6/5/2006 3/19/2001 4 NO BRYANT BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST FIRST REFORMED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH (COOPERMAN?) PRESBYTERIAN 1144 S. 19TH STREET 19146 CIRCA 1875 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/16/2006 3/19/2001 4 NO OASIS CITY CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL LINDLEY UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST 5248 N. 5TH STREET 19120 1923 NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/22/2006 0 GREEN STREET MONTHLY MEETING OF THE RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF NO GREEN STREET MONTHLY MEETING 45 W. SCHOOL HOUSE LANE 19144 1876 YES NO NO NO NO NO RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF FRIENDS FRIENDS (QUAKER) FRIENDS (QUAKER) 6/29/2006 0 INELIGIBL PSP FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF PASCHALL BAPTIST SAINT CLEMENT'S ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 7100-7120 WOODLAND AVENUE 2220 S. 71ST STREET 19142 1927 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO NO E 7/12/2006 0 NO LIFEWAY BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST OLD LOWER DUBLIN BAPTIST CHURCH (PAB) BAPTIST 9554 BUSTLETON AVENUE 19115 YES NO NO NO NO NO 7/27/2006 4/17/2006 4 NO MOUNT SINAI TABERNACLE BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST NORTHWEST BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 2737 W. LEHIGH AVENUE 19132 1917 J. FLETCHER STREET; STACKHOUSE NO NO NO NO NO NO 7/31/2006 5/22/2007 4 NO REFUGE TEMPLE HOUSE OF PRAYER PENTECOSTAL SAINT MARTIN CHURCH EPISCOPAL 1000 OAK LANE AVENUE 19126 1891 PURSELL & FRY NO NO NO NO NO NO 8/30/2006 0 NO IGLESIA APOSTOLICA LUZ Y VERDAD, INC. APOSTOLIC OUR SAVIOUR LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 3156-3164 D STREET 450 E. ALLEGHENY AVENUE 19134 1924 ROWLAND W. BOYLE; PAUL J.HENON JR NO NO NO NO NO NO 9/27/2006 4/26/2006 4 RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF NO CHESTNUT HILL FRIENDS MEETING HOUSE CHESTNUT HILL FRIENDS MEETING HOUSE 100 E. MERMAID LANE 19118 1931 HEACOCK & HOKANSON NO NO NO NO NO YES FRIENDS (QUAKER) FRIENDS (QUAKER) 10/18/2006 0 NO GRACE CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP NON-DENOMINATIONAL OUR LADY OF LORETO CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 6208-6210 GRAYS AVENUE 19142 1938 PETRILLO & NEELY, ARCHITECTS YES NO NO NO NO NO 10/25/2006 0 NO WISSINOMING BIBLE FELLOWSHIP NON-DENOMINATIONAL MENNONITE BRETHREN IN CHRIST MENNONITE 4414-4416 VAN KIRK STREET 19135 1922 NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/29/2006 4/17/2006 4 FRIENDS CENTER / CENTRAL PHILADELPHIA MONTHLY RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF DEM-INTERIOR NON- PSP RACE STREET FRIENDS MEETING 1600-1610 S. 18TH STREET 1515 CHERRY STREET 19102 1856 GEORGE CHANDLEE; NATHAN SMEDLEY; WILLIAM EYRE YES NO YES NO YES YES MEETING FRIENDS (QUAKER) FRIENDS (QUAKER) LOAD BEARING 10/31/2006 12/21/2010 3 NO PHILADELPHIA PRAISE CENTER MENNONITE BRETHREN CHURCH? AMERICAN BRETHREN 1701-1705 MCKEAN STREET 19145 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 11/10/2006 5/31/2005 4 CLOSED? NO PATHWAY EVANGELISTIC CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL HERMON PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 4837 FRANKFORD AVENUE 19124 1868 NO NO NO NO NO NO 11/22/2006 4/17/2006 4 WEST CORPORATE PHILADELPHIA FOR LEASE REALTY PARTNERS NO FORMER CHRIST MEMORIAL EPISCOPAL CHURCH N/A CHRIST MEMORIAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 4233 CHESTNUT STREET 19104 1886 ISAAC PURSELL NO NO NO NO NO STREETCAR & CO. SUBURB 2/6/2007 0 DEM-REMOVE A / SOLD COLLIERS NO FORMER CORPUS CHRISTI PARISH N/A CORPUS CHRISTI CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 2800 W. ALLEGHENY AVENUE 19132 1927 NO NO NO NO NO NO INSERT A TANK 2/12/2007 0 FOR SALE KW COMMERCIAL NO FORMER CHRIST INDEPENDENT BAPTIST CHURCH N/A SAINT AMBROSE PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 114 W. ONTARIO STREET HOWARD STREET 19140 CIRCA 1904 DUHRING, OKIE & ZEIGLER NO NO NO NO NO NO 2/14/2007 4/10/2006 4 CLOSED NO FORMER OUR LADY OF VICTORY CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A OUR LADY OF VICTORY CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 224-250 N. 54TH STREET 5412 VINE STREET 19139 1909 ROWLAND W. BOYLE NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/29/2007 5/18/2006 4 POWELTON US FOR SALE NO FORMER EMMANUEL LUTHERAN CHURCH N/A EMMANUEL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 3727 BARING STREET 19104 1872 NO NO NO NO NO VILLAGE 4/23/2007 5/12/2006 4 CLOSED? NO CAMBODIAN STUDENTS COUNCIL? ADATH SHALOM? JUDAISM BETH SAMUEL SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM 2353-2355 S. MARSHALL STREET RITNER STREET? 19148 CIRCA 1927 MAX A. BERNHARDT NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/3/2007 5 NO PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF THE REDEEMER PRESBYTERIAN 738 E. PENN STREET 19144 PRE 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/25/2007 0 MICHAEL SALOVE FORMER 40TH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL FOR SALE NO N/A 40TH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST 125-129 S. 40TH STREET 19104 1872 SLOAN & HUTTON NO NO NO NO NO NO COMPANY CHURCH DEM-COMPLETE 7/24/2007 0 SCHAEFFER-ASHMEAD CHAPEL, LUTHERAN COLONIAL NO LUTHERAN LUTHERAN THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY CHURCH LUTHERAN 7241 GERMANTOWN AVENUE ESTIMATED ADDRESS/TAX PARCEL # 19119 CIRCA 1902 THOMAS F. MILLER NO NO NO NO NO 7/26/2007 THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY OF PHILADELPHIA GERMANTOWN 0 CORPORATE REALTY PARTNERS SAINT PAUL'S BAPTIST CHURCH; CHRIST EVANGELICAL FOR SALE NO ADAPTIVE REUSE 948-952 N. 8TH STREET 19123 1875 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO NO NO 8/24/2007 & CO. (KEVIN CHURCH (ORIGINAL) SMITH) COMMERCIAL (ONLY ORIGINAL FAÇADE REMAINS) 20070424 4 NO CHRIST BIBLE FELLOWSHIP OF PHILADELPHIA NON-DENOMINATIONAL CALVARY CHURCH 1921-1925 E. VENANGO STREET 19134 PRE 1942 NO NO NO NO NO NO 9/20/2007 4/10/2006 4 NO GOD'S CHURCH BY THE FAITH OF PHILADELPHIA NON-DENOMINATIONAL SAINT ALBAN'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 200 W. TABOR ROAD N. 2ND STREET 19120 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 9/21/2007 0 CLOSED NO FORMER SAINT BONIFACE CATHOLIC CHURCH N/A SAINT BONIFACE (BONIFASCIUS IN PAB?) CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 142-174 W. DIAMOND STREET 19122 1872 NO NO ELIGIBLE NO NO NO 10/16/2007 0 NO REHOBOTH UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST PAUL STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 4217-4227 PAUL STREET 19124 1832 NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/17/2007 4/17/2006 4 NO GOLDEN GATE BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST ZION GERMAN PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 1238 N. 28TH STREET 133 S. 24TH STREET 19121 1890 WILLIAM H. DECKER NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/31/2007 NO 59TH STREET BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST BEREAN BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 315 S. 59TH STREET 19143 CIRCA 1913 GEORGE E. SAVAGE NO NO NO NO NO NO 11/1/2007 4 NO SAINT PAUL CATHOLIC CHURCH-WORSHIP SITE ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT MARY MAGDALEN DE PAZZI ROMAN CATHOLIC 710-720 MONTROSE STREET 19147 1891 YES NO NO NO NO NO 11/28/2007 4 NO BERACHAH BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST SOMERVILLE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 1970 CHELTEN AVENUE 6327 LIMEKILN PIKE 19138 CIRCA 1909 WILSON, HARRIS & RICHARDS NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/19/2007 4/10/2006 4 NO AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR SENIORS ADAPTIVE REUSE SAINT GEORGE EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 518-538 S. 61ST STREET 19143 1871 NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/16/2008 20060518 4 UNITED CHURCH OF NO SAINT STEPHEN'S UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST SAINT STEPHEN'S EVANGELICAL REFORMED CHURCH REFORMED 4201 PRINCETON AVENUE ERDRICK STREET 19135 PRE 1962 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHRIST (UCC) 4/1/2008 4/17/2006 4 NO SAINT TIMOTHY CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT TIMOTHY CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 3001 LEVICK STREET 19149 1949 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/10/2008 5/4/2006 3 NO NATIONAL OF SAINT RITA OF CASCIA ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT RITA OF CASCIA CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 1156-1162 S. BROAD STREET 19146 1915 GEORGE I. LOVATT; BALLINGER & PERROT NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/18/2008 4 NO NORTHEAST COMMUNITY CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PCA 3300 TYSON AVENUE 19149 PRE 1942 NO NO NO NO NO NO 5/5/2008 4/17/2006 3 PLEASANTVIEW BAPTIST CHURCH; FIRST NO HOLY TEMPLE OF DELIVERANCE CHURCH PENTECOSTAL CONGREGATIONAL 124-128 W. SEYMOUR STREET 19144 CIRCA 1889 J. FRANKLIN STUCKERT NO NO NO NO NO NO CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH (ORIGINAL) 5/20/2008 4/11/2006 3 NO SAINT LEO CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT LEO THE GREAT CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 6658 KEYSTONE STREET 19135 1894 FRANK R. WATSON NO NO NO NO NO YES 5/28/2008 NO ALL SAINTS CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC ALL SAINTS ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 2651 BUCKIUS STREET 19137 1895 EDWIN F. DURANG NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/3/2008 TABERNACLE MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CLOSED? NO METHODIST BEREAN; RHAWNHURST METHODIST METHODIST 1900-1908 RIPLEY STREET LORETTO AVENUE 19111 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH 6/9/2008 4 NO UNITED CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST APOSTOLIC WOODLAND AVENUE UNITED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 6601 WOODLAND AVENUE 19142 1909 NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/16/2008 0 SPRUCE STREET (FIRST) BAPTIST CHURCH OF SOCIETY PSP; PHMC JUDAISM BAPTIST 418 SPRUCE STREET 19106 1829 THOMAS U. WALTER YES NO SOCIETY HILL NO NO PHILADELPHIA HILL 7/8/2008 11/18/2010 0 NO HOLY GHOST BYZANTINE CATHOLIC CHURCH BYZANTINE CATHOLIC HOLY GHOST BYZANTINE CATHOLIC CHURCH BYZANTINE CATHOLIC 2300 S. 24TH STREET 19145 1912 NO NO NO NO NO NO 8/14/2008 0 SOLD COLLIERS NO ALL SAINTS’ EPISCOPAL CHURCH, CRESCENTVILLE N/A TRINITY PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH, CRESCENTVILLE EPISCOPAL 6301 CRESCENTVILLE ROAD 19120 1926 HORACE W. SELLERS NO NO NO NO NO NO 8/21/2008 5/31/2001 4 NEW CREATION LUTHERAN CHURCH/IGLESIA NO LUTHERAN BETHEL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 162-166 W. TIOGA STREET 19140 NO NO NO NO NO NO LUTERANA NUEVA CREACIÓN 10/15/2008 0 CLOSED NO FORMER EAST FALLS UNITED METHODIST CHURCH N/A EAST FALLS METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 3580 INDIAN QUEEN LANE 19129 CIRCA 1872 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/29/2008 0 PILGRIM CONGREGATIONAL UNITED CHURCH OF UNITED CHURCH OF NO EBENEZER CHURCH 1403-1409 MARLBOROUGH STREET 19125 1841 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHRIST CHRIST (UCC) 11/17/2008 4/10/2006 4 FORMER COMMUNITY OF JOY UNITED CHURCH OF TABOR UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST/TABOR REFORMED UNITED CHURCH OF DEM-INTERIOR NON- CLOSED NO N/A 5700 N. FAIRHILL STREET W. CHEW AVENUE 19120 1921 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHRIST/TABOR UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST CHURCH CHRIST (UCC) LOAD BEARING 12/23/2008 0 FORMER EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF THE GOOD SOLD COLLIERS? NO N/A EPISCOPAL CHURCH OF THE GOOD SHEPHERD EPISCOPAL 2121-2127 E. CUMBERLAND STREET 19125 1889 NO NO NO NO NO NO SHEPHERD 12/23/2008 3/7/2005 4 WEST PHILADELPHIA NO RENEWAL PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PCA LUTHERAN CHURCH OF THE INCARNATION? LUTHERAN 4633 CEDAR AVENUE 19143 1905 CHARLES OELSCHLAGER NO NO NO NO NO DEM-INTERIOR NON- STREETCAR LOAD BEARING SUBURB 1/7/2009 0 DEM-INTERIOR NON- US FOR SALE COLLIERS NO SILOAM N/A CHURCH OF THE ASSUMPTION ROMAN CATHOLIC 1123-1133 SPRING GARDEN STREET 19123 1849 PATRICK C. KEELY YES NO NO NO NO NO LOAD BEARING 3/10/2009 11/30/2010 5 HOPE OUTREACH MINISTRIES UNITED CHURCH OF UNITED CHURCH OF NO 417-429 E. INDIANA AVENUE 401 E. INDIANA AVENUE 19134 PRE 1942 CHARLES J. BROOKE NO NO NO NO NO NO CHRIST CHRIST (UCC) 3/20/2009 4/10/2006 4 NO MOUNT ZION FIRE BAPTIZED HOLINESS CHURCH PENTECOSTAL FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF MANAYUNK PRESBYTERIAN 100 DUPONT STREET 19127 1833 NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/5/2009 4 NO METHODIST EPISCOPAL 4739 SILVERWOOD STREET GATES STREET 19128 1910 GEORGE E. SAVAGE NO NO NO NO NO NO 4/14/2009 5 PSP SAINT JOHN THE EVANGELIST CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT JOHN THE EVANGELIST ROMAN CATHOLIC 21 S. 13TH STREET 19107 1831 WILLIAM RODRIGUE YES NO NO NO NO NO 4/21/2009 10/14/2010 4 GRACE LUTHERAN CHURCH?; MANTUA PRESBYTERIAN US NO KINGDOM WORSHIP CENTER CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL PRESBYTERIAN 3500 SPRING GARDEN STREET 19104 1911 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH (OLDEST)? 4/24/2009 5/17/2006 4 INELIGIBL NO ANDORRA BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST MANATAWNA BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 8711 RIDGE AVENUE 19128 1913 BENJAMIN D. PRICE NO NO NO NO NO E 6/4/2009 0 PSP; PHMC CHRIST CHURCH IN PHILADELPHIA EPISCOPAL CHRIST CHURCH IN PHILADELPHIA EPISCOPAL 20 N. AMERICAN STREET 22-34 N. 2ND STREET 19106 1727 UNKNOWN; DR. JOHN KEARSLEY (HEAD OF BUILDING COMMITTEE) YES OLD CITY YES OLD CITY YES YES 6/6/2009 5 II. At-Risk Indicators: Properties Sold Within the Last 10 Years 3

CURRENT FAITH YEAR ORIGINAL ORIGINAL RELIGION/ DEMOLITION CIRCA/ CITYREG CITYREG NATREG UNSAFE/IMM.DANG. FOR SALE/SOLD/CLOSED/VACANT BROKER COVENANT ON FILE CURRENT CONGREGATION TRADITION/DENOMINA ORIGINAL CONGREGATION FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS ZIP CODE BUILDING ORIGINAL ARCHITECT NATREG (HD) NHL HABS DENOMINATION PERMITS (SINCE 2006) PRE/POST (IND) (HD) (IND) TION COMPLETED SALE DATE DT EXT COND EXT COND (STILL STANDING?) WORD OF FAITH CHRISTIAN TALMADGE MEMORIAL CHURCH (TALMAGE REFORMED NO NON-DENOMINATIONAL 403 RECTOR STREET PECHIN STREET 19128 1891 GEORGE T. PEARSON NO NO NO NO NO NO 6/26/2009 CENTER CHURCH?) COLONIAL NO GERMANTOWN CHURCH OF THE BRETHREN AMERICAN BRETHREN GERMANTOWN CHURCH OF THE BRETHREN AMERICAN BRETHREN 6613 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19119 CIRCA 1770 UNKNOWN YES NO NO NO NO GERMANTOWN 6/29/2009 4/6/2006 4 NO EBENEZER BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST BRETHREN CHURCH AMERICAN BRETHREN 2259-2265 N. 10TH STREET 19133 1904 ISAAC PURSELL NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/3/2009 4 NO IMMANUEL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN IMMANUEL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 5649 CHRISTIAN STREET 19143 1928 WALTER H. THOMAS (MARTIN & KIRKPATRICK) NO NO NO NO NO NO 10/26/2009 5/15/2006 4 CORPORATE REALTY PARTNERS FOR SALE? NO FORMER MIKVEH ISRAEL SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM MIKVEH ISRAEL SYNAGOGUE JUDAISM 2331 N. BROAD STREET 19132 CIRCA 1908 PILCHER & TACHAU YES NO NO NO NO NO & CO. (KEVIN SMITH) 12/16/2009 4 DEM-REMOVE A / SOLD COLLIERS NO FORMER RESURRECTION EPISCOPAL CHURCH N/A RESURRECTION EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 3301 WELLINGTON STREET 19149 1928 NO NO NO NO NO NO INSERT A TANK 1/7/2010 4 FORMER MIZPAH SEVENTH DAY ADVENTIST SOLD COLLIERS NO N/A FRANKFORD BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST 4357 PAUL STREET UNITY STREET 19124 1897 CHARLES W. BOLTON NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH/FORMER FRANKFORD BAPTIST CHURCH 1/15/2010 4/17/2006 4 NO SAINT JOAN OF ARC CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT JOAN OF ARC CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 3558 FRANKFORD AVENUE 2025 E. ATLANTIC STREET 19134 1922 NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/15/2010 4 NO KEEP THE FAITH MINISTRY APOSTOLIC SALEM EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 1923 HARRISON STREET 19124 PRE 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/21/2010 6/20/2007 4 PSP ARCH STREET UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST ARCH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 1344-1348 ARCH STREET 55 N. BROAD STREET 19107 1870 YES NO ELIGIBLE BROAD STREET YES YES 1/22/2010 1/4/2011 4 SAINT PETER CLAVER CATHOLIC CHURCH (CLOSED 1985); NO SAINT PETER CLAVER EVANGELIZATION CENTER ROMAN CATHOLIC PRESBYTERIAN 1200-1210 LOMBARD STREET 19147 1842 THOMAS U. WALTER YES NO NO NO NO NO FOURTH PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH (ORIGINAL) 1/27/2010 11/18/2010 4 NO BRIDESBURG UNITED METHODIST CHURCH METHODIST BRIDESBURG METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH METHODIST EPISCOPAL 2719 KIRKBRIDE STREET 19137 1913 BALLINGER & PERROT NO NO NO NO NO NO 2/9/2010 4/10/2006 4 RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF NO ARCH STREET MONTHLY MEETING ARCH STREET MONTHLY MEETING 312-338 ARCH STREET 320 ARCH STREET 19106 1804 OWEN BIDDLE (MASTER BUILDER) YES OLD CITY YES OLD CITY NO YES FRIENDS (QUAKER) FRIENDS (QUAKER) 2/26/2010 1/4/2011 4 NO SAINT DONATO'S CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC SAINT DONATO'S CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 401-409 N. 65TH STREET 19151 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/22/2010 5/18/2006 4 EMMANUEL FULL TEMPLE CHURCH OF GOD CHURCH OF GOD IN NO GRAND ARMY OF THE REPUBLIC HALL (PHILAPLACE) 980-984 N. MARSHALL STREET 19123 1866 NO NO NO NO NO NO IN CHRIST CHRIST (COGIC) 4/22/2010 4 NO APARTMENTS ADAPTIVE REUSE SAINT AGATHA'S ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 3801-3807 SPRING GARDEN ST 19104 1878 EDWIN F. DURANG NO NO NO NO NO YES 5/5/2010 20060426 4 RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF NO FRANKFORD FRIENDS MONTHLY MEETINGHOUSE TACONICK MEETING; OXFORD MEETING 1500 ORTHODOX STREET 19124 1832 UNKNOWN YES NO ELIGIBLE NO NO YES FRIENDS (QUAKER) FRIENDS (QUAKER) 5/21/2010 4/18/2006 4 MARS HILL BAPTIST CHURCH; STEVENS MEMORIAL NO MARS HILL BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST EPISCOPAL 900-916 W. LEHIGH AVENUE 2650 N. 9TH STREET 19133 1889 FRANK R. WATSON YES NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH; SAINT SIMEON CHURCH (ORIGINAL) 6/22/2010 4/10/2006 4 NO IMMACULATE CONCEPTION CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC IMMACULATE CONCEPTION CATHOLIC CHURCH ROMAN CATHOLIC 5728 ARDLEIGH STREET 1020 E. PRICE STREET 19138 1930 NO NO NO NO NO NO 7/12/2010 0 RUSSELL TABERNACLE CHRISTIAN METHODIST CHRISTIAN METHODIST NO SAINT JOHANNESKIRCHE (GERMAN REFORMED) GERMAN REFORMED 516 WHARTON STREET 19147 1873 NO NO NO NO NO NO EPISCOPAL CHURCH EPISCOPAL 7/12/2010 12/2/2010 5 NO NEW THANKFUL BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST GETHSEMANE BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST DEM-COMPLETE 1801 CECIL B. MOORE AVENUE 19121 PRE 1875 NO NO NO NO NO NO 9/15/2010 10/12/2010 8 PHAT QUANG BUDDHIST TEMPLE/BUDDHIST NO VIETNAMESE BUDDHIST EMANUEL GERMAN EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 1001-1007 S. 4TH STREET 19147 1869 COLLINS & AUTENREITH YES NO NO NO NO NO MEDITATION SOCIETY 9/29/2010 10/28/2010 5 SAINT MARK'S GERMAN EVANGELICAL AND REFORMED NO SEVEN MILE ROAD CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL 521 WELSH ROAD 19115 NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH OF PHILADELPHIA 10/11/2010 4/18/2006 4 BETHLEHEM PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH? (PHMC: 2100 N NO BEREAN PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) BROAD ST, SUGGESTING THAT THIS IS A DIFFERENT PRESBYTERIAN 2101-2107 N. BROAD STREET 19122 1888 THEOPHILUS P. CHANDLER, JR. NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH) 11/16/2010 0 WE ARE MORE THAN CONQUERORS DELIVERANCE NO NON-DENOMINATIONAL WEST PHILADELPHIA JEWISH COMMUNITY CENTER JUDAISM 11-19 COBBS CREEK PKY 11-19 S. 63RD STREET 19139 1928 NO NO NO NO NO NO MINISTRIES 11/30/2010 0 FOR SALE? NO FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF HOLMESBURG PRESBYTERIAN FIRST PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF HOLMESBURG PRESBYTERIAN 7811 FRANKFORD AVENUE 19136 1853 NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/1/2010 4/17/2006 4 NO OFFICES ADAPTIVE REUSE GRACE EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH LUTHERAN 492-498 ROXBOROUGH AVENUE RIDGE AVENUE 19128 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/13/2010 0 0 NO HOLY TRINITY BETHLEHEM PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN - PC(USA) HOLY TRINITY PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 1100 W. ROCKLAND STREET 19141 CIRCA 1925 NO NO NO NO NO NO 12/30/2010 4/11/2006 4 NO CONGREGATION MIKVEH ISRAEL JUDAISM CONGREGATION MIKVEH ISRAEL JUDAISM 121 N. INDEPENDENCE MALL EAST 19106 CIRCA 1976 HARBESON, HOUGH, LIVINGSTON & LARSON (H2L2 ARCHITECTS) NO NO NO OLD CITY NO NO 1/26/2011 4 DEM-INTERIOR NON- SPRING NO CALVARY BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST PALATINATE REFORMED CHURCH 655-659 N. 16TH STREET 19130 PRE 1859 YES NO SPRING GARDEN NO NO LOAD BEARING GARDEN 2/10/2011 4/7/2006 4 FOR SALE NO ADAPTIVE REUSE FOURTH REFORMED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH PRESBYTERIAN 355 MARTIN STREET MONASTERY AND MANAYUNK AVENUES 19128 1900 NO NO NO NO NO NO 3/3/2011 APARTMENTS 0 0 HOLY ROSARY ITALIAN CATHOLIC CHURCH; JANES NO TRUE UNITED CHURCH APOSTOLIC METHODIST 528 E. HAINES STREET 19144 CIRCA 1898 RANKIN & KELLOGG NO NO NO NO NO NO METHODIST CHURCH (ORIGINAL) 3/31/2011 4/7/2006 4 INDEPENDENCE RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF RELIGIOUS SOCIETY OF 500 ARCH STREET; INDEPENDENCE NATIONAL NO FREE QUAKER MEETINGHOUSE ARCH STREET FREE QUAKER MEETINGHOUSE 501-535 MARKET STREET 19106 1785 SAMUEL WETHERILL YES NO YES NO YES 8/26/1999 0 0 FRIENDS (QUAKER) FRIENDS (QUAKER) MALL E HISTORICAL PARK III. At-Risk Indicators: Properties With Open "Unsafe" Citations, August 2011 1

CURRENT FAITH YEAR ORIGINAL FOR SALE/SOLD/ ORIGINAL RELIGION/ CIRCA/ UNSAFE/IMM.DANG. BROKER CURRENT CONGREGATION TRADITION/ ORIGINAL CONGREGATION DEMOLITION PERMITS (SINCE 2006) FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS BUILDING ORIGINAL ARCHITECT CITYREG(IND) CITYREG(HD) NATREG(IND) NATREG(HD) NHL PSP HIGH PRIORITY HABS CLOSED/VACANT DENOMINATION PRE/POST DENOMINATION COMPLETED OWNER1 OWNER2 CENSUS DT EXT COND EXT COND CATHEDRAL BASILICA OF SAINTS PETER CATHEDRAL BASILICA OF SAINTS PETER AND US ROMAN CATHOLIC ROMAN CATHOLIC 209-225 N. 18TH STREET 1864 NAPOLEON LEBRUN; JOHN NOTMAN (FAÇADE) YES NO YES NO NO YES NO AND PAUL PAUL CARDINAL JOHN J KROL 3 5/24/2007 3 18TH STREET METHODIST EPISCOPAL US FRIENDSHIP BAPTIST CHURCH BAPTIST METHODIST EPISCOPAL 1730 WHARTON STREET S. 18TH STREET 1888 J. FRANKLIN STUCKERT YES NO INELIGIBLE NO NO NO NO CHURCH FRIENDSHIP BAPTIST CHURCH OF PHILA 30 4/17/2006 4 US HOLY FLOCK OF CHRIST CHURCH NON-DENOMINATIONAL 1329 COTTMAN AVENUE PRE 1962 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH OF GESU 338 4/17/2006 4 SAINT PETER'S CHURCH OF CHRIST CHURCH OF CHRIST, CHURCH OF ATONEMENT; SAINT PAUL'S US EPISCOPAL 4700 KINGSESSING AVENUE 1200 S. 47TH STREET 1900 FURNESS, EVANS & CO. NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DISCIPLES OF CHRIST DISCIPLES OF CHRIST CHURCH (ORIGINAL) ST PETER

UNSAFE/ FOR SALE/SOLD/ COVENANT DEMOLITION PERMITS YEAR ORIGINAL CITYREG CITYREG NATREG BROKER CURRENT CONGREGATION ORIGINAL CONGREGATION FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS ZIP CODE CIRCA/PRE/POST ORIGINAL ARCHITECT NATREG(HD) NHL PSP HIGH PRIORITY HABS IMM.DANG. CLOSED/VACANT ON FILE (SINCE 2006) BUILDING COMPLETED (IND) (HD) (IND) OWNER1 OWNER2 DT EXT COND EXT COND GEORGE W. TYRON? JOHN TACONY BAPTIST NO TACONY BAPTIST CHURCH TACONY BAPTIST CHURCH 6930 HEGERMAN STREET 4715 DISSTON STREET 19135 1885 NO NO NO NO NO NO YES ENOCHS? CHURCH 5/4/2006 4 NO SECOND MENNONITE CHURCH 2962-2964 N. FRANKLIN STREET 19133 PRE 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO THE SECOND MENNONITE CHURCH OF PHILA 4/10/2006 4 BURHOLME BAPTIST NO BURHOLME BAPTIST CHURCH BURHOLME BAPTIST CHURCH 935 COTTMAN AVENUE 19111 1927 HEACOCK & HOKANSON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH 4/17/2006 4 BETH GERMAN NO BETHANY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST BETHANY UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST 6537 RISING SUN AVENUE 19111 1951 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO EVANGELICAL REFORM CHURCH 4/17/2006 4 NO SAINT NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC CHURCH 1712-1724 S. 9TH STREET 710 WATKINS STREET 19148 1916 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO BROS OF ST NICHOLAS OF THE ORDER 10/21/2010 4 COLONIAL FIRST ME CHURCH OF PSP FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF GERMANTOWN FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF GERMANTOWN 6001-6025 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19144 1898 RANKIN & KELLOGG YES NO NO NO YES NO GERMANTOWN GTN 10/21/2010 4 NO CHURCH OF THE LORD JESUS CHRIST OF THE APOSTOLIC FAITH SAINT CATHERINE OF SIENNA CATHOLIC CHURCH 440 W. PENN STREET 19144 CIRCA 1915 C. CUMMISKEY NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CONGREGATION MISSION OF ST PAUL 4/11/2006 4 NO GOOD SHEPHERD UNITED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH J. ADDISON HENRY MEMORIAL PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 6441-6449 LANSDOWNE AVENUE 19151 CIRCA 1911 CHARLES W. BOLTON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO J ADDISON HENRY MEM PRESBY CHURCH 5/16/2006 4 BISHOP FOSS M E NO NEW WAY MISSIONARY BAPTIST CHURCH HARRY HOSIER MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH 4845-4855 N. 13TH STREET 19141 1916 CONRAD NEFF NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH OF LOGAN 4/12/2006 4 NO SIMPSON-FLETCHER UNITED METHODIST CHURCH FLETCHER UNITED METHODIST CHURCH? 6037 JEFFERSON STREET 19151 CIRCA 1912 BALLINGER & PERROT NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MARY A SIMPSON M E CHURCH 5/16/2006 4 H. STACKHOUSE; JAMES DOYLES & FOR SALE COLLIERS NO FORMER OUR LADY OF ANGELS ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH OUR LADY OF ANGELS ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH 4972 MASTER STREET 19131 1924 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO SONS DENNIS DOUGHERTY 5/16/2006 4 REV DENNIS J VACANT NO FORMER SAINT HENRY ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT HENRY ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH 4400-4420 N. 5TH STREET 19140 1921 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DOUGHERTY IN TRUST 4/11/2006 4 NO HOLY ANGELS (KOREAN) CATHOLIC CHURCH HOLY ANGELS CATHOLIC CHURCH 1321 70TH AVENUE 7000 OLD YORK ROAD? 19126 1905 HOWARD HAGER NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DENNIS J DOUGHERTY 4/12/2006 4 NO MATER DOLOROSA PARISH MATER DOLOROSA CHURCH 4253 PAUL STREET 1676 RUAN STREET 19124 CIRCA 1914 HARRY/HENRY HAMMER NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DENNIS J DOUGHERTY IN TRUST 4/17/2006 4 NO OUR LADY HELP OF CHRISTIANS CATHOLIC CHURCH OUR LADY HELP OF CHRISTIANS CATHOLIC CHURCH 2424 E. ALLEGHENY AVENUE 19134 1898 ALBERT W. LEH NO NO NO NO NO NO NO ARCHDIOCESE OF PHILA 4/24/2006 4 EDWIN F. DURANG; GEORGE I. NO OUR LADY OF HOPE CATHOLIC CHURCH-LOGAN HOLY CHILD CATHOLIC CHURCH 5220-5222 N. BROAD STREET W. DUNCANNON AVENUE 19141 1928 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO LOVATT DENNIS J DOUGHERTY 4/10/2006 4 OVERBROOK REV DENNIS J NO OUR LADY OF LOURDES CATHOLIC CHURCH OUR LADY OF LOURDES CATHOLIC CHURCH 6301 WOODBINE AVENUE 6315 LANCASTER AVENUE 19151 1895 NO NO NO NO NO NO FARMS DOUGHERTY 5/17/2006 4 MOST REV D J NO OUR LADY OF MOUNT CARMEL CATHOLIC CHURCH OUR LADY OF MOUNT CARMEL CATHOLIC CHURCH 2301-2341 S. 3RD STREET 19148 1922 THOMAS P. LONSDALE NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DOUGHERTY 10/28/2010 4 NO OUR LADY OF THE BLESSED SACRAMENT OUR LADY OF THE ROSARY CATHOLIC CHURCH 339 N. 63RD STREET 19139 1887 WATSON, EDKINS & THOMPSON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MOST REV DENNIS J DOUGHERTY IN TR 4/18/2006 4 NO SACRED HEART OF JESUS CATHOLIC CHURCH SACRED HEART OF JESUS CATHOLIC CHURCH 1406-1418 S. 3RD STREET REED STREET 19147 1876 EDWIN F. DURANG NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DENNIS J DOUGHERTY ARCHBISHOP OF PHILA 10/28/2010 4 NO SAINT CASIMIR CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT CASIMIR CATHOLIC CHURCH 324 WHARTON STREET 19147 1930 HOFFMAN & HENON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO ARCHDIOCESE OF PHILA 6/30/2009 4 REV DENNIS J NO SAINT CHARLES BORROMEO CHURCH SAINT CHARLES BORROMEO CHURCH 900 S. 20TH STREET 19146 1876 EDWIN F. DURANG NO NO NO NO NO NO YES DOUGHERTY 10/5/2010 4 DOUGHERTY ARCH NO SAINT GABRIEL CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT GABRIEL CATHOLIC CHURCH 1432-1448 S. 29TH STREET 2922-2928 DICKINSON STREET 19146 CIRCA 1902 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO THE MOST REV DENNIS J BISHOP 4/17/2006 4 NO SAINT IGNATIUS OF LOYOLA CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT IGNATIUS OF LOYOLA CATHOLIC CHURCH 632-644 N. 43RD STREET 19104 CIRCA 1905 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CARDINAL DENNIS J DOUGHERTY 5/18/2006 4 NO SAINT JOSAPHAT'S ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH FOURTH PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 124 COTTON STREET 19127 PRE 1895 G. CLEVELAND FREEMAN? NO NO NO NO NO NO NO PHILA ARCHDIOCESE 4 RITTENH NO SAINT PATRICK’S CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT PATRICK'S CHURCH 250 S. 20TH STREET 2001-2017 RITTENHOUSE STREET 19103 1911 LA FARGE & MORRIS NO OUSE NO RITTENHOUSE NO YES NO REV DENNIS J FITLER DOUGHERTY IN TRUST 10/5/2010 4 REV DENNIS J NO SAINT PAUL’S CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT PAUL'S CATHOLIC CHURCH 923 CHRISTIAN STREET 19147 1865 JOHN MCARTHUR, JR. YES NO NO NO NO NO NO DOUGHERTY IN TRUST ST PAULS 4/28/2006 4 NO SAINT VERONICA CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT VERONICA CATHOLIC CHURCH 3501-3525 N. 6TH STREET 533 W. TIOGA STREET 19140 1909 EDWIN F. DURANG & SON YES NO NO NO NO NO NO ARCHDIOCESE OF PHILA 4 NO UNION BAPTIST CHURCH UNION BAPTIST CHURCH 1910 FITZWATER STREET 19146 1913 CHARLES W. BOLTON & SON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO UNION BAPTIST CHURCH 4/6/2006 4 NO JANES MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH JANES METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 47-51 E. HAINES STREET 19144 1928 CHARLES PARKER NO NO NO NO NO NO NO JAMES ME CHURCH INC 4/7/2006 4 1801 MEADOW STREET; 4647 SECOND BAPTIST NO SECOND BAPTIST CHURCH OF FRANKFORD SECOND BAPTIST CHURCH OF FRANKFORD 1800-1814 WILMOT STREET 19124 CIRCA 1910 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MULBERRY STREET CHURCH OF FRANKFORD 4/18/2006 4 NO SAINT ADALBERT CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT ADALBERT CATHOLIC CHURCH 2639 E. ALLEGHENY AVENUE E. THOMPSON STREET 19134 1908 LOUIS GIELE NO NO NO NO NO NO NO ARCHDIOCESE OF PHILA 4/24/2006 4 BETHESDA METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH/OLIVET METHODIST NO BETHESDA UNITED METHODIST CHURCH 2820-2824 E. VENANGO STREET 19134 1865 NO NO ELIGIBLE NO NO NO NO CHURCH ? (PHMC) BETHES METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 4 REV DENNIS J NO SAINT BARBARA’S CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT BARBARA'S ROMAN CATHOLIC CHAPEL 5343 LEBANON AVENUE 19131 1929 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DOUGHERTY 5/16/2006 4 NO FOX CHASE UNITED METHODIST CHURCH FOX CHASE METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 7945 FILLMORE STREET 201 LONEY STREET 19111 1958 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO FOX CHASE M E CHURCH 4/17/2006 4 HENRY D. DAGIT & SONS; GEORGE NO SAINT EDMOND CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT EDMOND CATHOLIC CHURCH 2100 S. 21ST STREET 19145 1912 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO IGNATIUS LOVATT, SR. ARCHDIOCESE OF PHILA ST EDMONDS CHURCH 3/19/2001 4 SOCIETY SHAPIRO NO VILNA SHUL SYNAGOGUE ROWHOUSE 509 PINE STREET 19106 1921 UNKNOWN YES NO SOCIETY HILL NO NO NO HILL SONS OF ABRAHAM ABIE CONGREGATION 11/18/2010 4 RECTOR CHURCH PSP SAINT PETER'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH SAINT PETER'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH 313 PINE STREET 19106 1761 ROBERT SMITH (MASTER BUILDER) YES NO YES SOCIETY HILL YES YES YES WARDENS 11/18/2010 4 NO FIRST CHRISTIAN ASSEMBLY CHIESA CHRISTIANA HALIANA? 1900 S. 11TH STREET 19148 CIRCA 1890 THOMAS P. LONSDALE NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NICOLA FLANNINA SAVERIO AMICONE 10/21/2010 4 NO HICKMAN TEMPLE AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH SAINT PAUL'S PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 5001 BALTIMORE AVENUE 19143 1905 PURSELL & FRY NO NO NO NO NO NO NO PHILA ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF THE 5/12/2006 4 NO FRANKFORD MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH FRANKFORD MEMORIAL METHODIST CHURCH 1300 DYRE STREET 19124 1912 HORACE W. CASTOR NO NO NO NO NO NO NO FKD MEMORIAL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH 4/17/2006 4 NO CRESCENTVILLE UNITED METHODIST CHURCH EVANGELICAL CHURCH OF CRESCENTVILLE 400 SENTNER STREET 19120 PRE 1942 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO TRUSTEES OF CRESCENTVILLE 4/17/2006 4 NO SAINT PAUL'S BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST REFORMED CHURCH 628-634 N. 10TH STREET 1000 WALLACE STREET 19123 1888 GEORGE HEWITT NO NO NO NO NO YES NO ST PAULS BAPT.CHURCH 4/5/2006 5 NO MOUNT CARMEL BAPTIST CHURCH MOUNT CARMEL BAPTIST CHURCH 5728-5748 RACE STREET 19139 CIRCA 1915 HENRY DEHOFF NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MT CARMEL BAP CHURCH 5/16/2006 4 REC ST RICHARDS NO SAINT RICHARD OF CHICHESTER CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT RICHARD OF CHICHESTER CATHOLIC CHURCH 1800 POLLOCK STREET 3010 S. 18TH STREET 19145 1951 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH 4/17/2006 4 REV DENNIS J VACANT? NO FORMER GOOD SHEPHERD CATHOLIC CHURCH GOOD SHEPHERD CATHOLIC CHURCH 6535 CHESTER AVENUE 6667 CHESTER AVENUE 19142 1950 PETER F. GETZ NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DOUGHERTY 4/19/2006 4 SAINT JOHN THE EVANGELIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH/EMANUEL RECTORS CHURCH NO SAINT JOHN THE EVANGELIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 1332 S. 3RD STREET 19147 CIRCA 1860 YES NO NO NO NO NO NO EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH WARDENS VESTRYMEN OF 10/28/2010 4 WEST PHILADELPHIA PSP SAINT FRANCIS DE SALES CHURCH SAINT FRANCIS DE SALES 4615-4625 SPRINGFIELD AVENUE 19143 1911 HENRY D. DAGIT NO NO NO NO YES YES STREETCAR SUBURB DOUGHERTY DENNIS J 2/7/2001 4 JOHN E. CARVER (AFTER PSP CHURCH OF SAINT JAMES THE LESS CHURCH OF SAINT JAMES THE LESS 3201-3229 W. CLEARFIELD STREET 19132 1850 DRAWINGS BY GEORGE GORDON YES NO YES NO YES YES YES PLACE) CHURCH OF SAINT JAMES THE LESS 11/9/2010 4 NO OAK LANE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OAK LANE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 6635 N. 11TH STREET 1040 OAK LANE AVENUE 19126 1902 CHARLES W. BOLTON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO OAK LANE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 8/15/2000 4 NO CHRIST ASCENSION LUTHERAN CHURCH CHRIST EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH 8300 GERMANTOWN AVENUE 19118 1871 CHARLES M. BURNS YES NO NO CHESTNUT HILL NO NO NO THE EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHRIST 4/7/2006 4 NO CHURCH OF THE LIVING GOD WEST MEMORIAL UNITED PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 737-741 N. 43RD STREET 19104 1921 G. HODGENS NO NO NO NO NO NO NO HOUSE OF GOD WHICH IS CHURCH OF TH 5/18/2006 4 OUR LADY OF MOUNT CARMEL CHAPEL (CARMELITE OUR LADY OF MOUNT CARMEL CHAPEL (CARMELITE NO 6500-6590 OLD YORK ROAD 1400 W. 66TH AVENUE 19126 1915 MAGINNIS & WALSH NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MONASTERY) MONASTERY) CARMELITE CONVENT OF PHILA 4/11/2006 4 1ST SCHWNKFLDR NO FIRST CHURCH WORSHIP CENTER FIRST SCHWENKFELDER CHURCH 2913-2921 W. CUMBERLAND STREET N. 30TH STREET 19132 1888 NO NO NO NO NO YES NO CHURCH OF PHILA 4 NO GRACE UNITED METHODIST CHURCH GRACE METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 7101-7119 N. 20TH STREET 19138 1954 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO GRACE METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 4/7/2006 4 NO KILLINGSWORTH TEMPLE 5042-5050 BROWN STREET N. 51ST STREET 19139 CIRCA 1890 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO KODESH CHURCH OF IMMANUEL A CORP 5/15/2006 4 NO MOUNT OLIVET TABERNACLE BAPTIST CHURCH MOUNT OLIVET TABERNACLE BAPTIST CHURCH? 647-659 N. 42ND STREET 19104 1928 UNKNOWN NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MOUNT OLIVET TAB BAPTIST CHURCH 5/18/2006 4 ST PETERS EVANG NO SAINT PETER'S EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH SAINT PETER'S EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH 7401-7407 BRIAR ROAD 2167 74TH AVENUE 19138 1940 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CHURCH 11/9/2010 4 WALTER MANDER ETAL ST MATTHEW NO SAINT MATTHEW’S AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH SAINT MATTHEW'S AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH 215-223 N. 57TH STREET 19139 1940 CHARLES W. BOLTON & SON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO TRS AFRICAN- 4/18/2006 4 IV. At-Risk Indicators: Properties With Exterior Conditions Ratings of "4" or Higher 2

UNSAFE/ FOR SALE/SOLD/ COVENANT DEMOLITION PERMITS YEAR ORIGINAL CITYREG CITYREG NATREG BROKER CURRENT CONGREGATION ORIGINAL CONGREGATION FULL ADDRESS AKA ADDRESS ZIP CODE CIRCA/PRE/POST ORIGINAL ARCHITECT NATREG(HD) NHL PSP HIGH PRIORITY HABS IMM.DANG. CLOSED/VACANT ON FILE (SINCE 2006) BUILDING COMPLETED (IND) (HD) (IND) OWNER1 OWNER2 DT EXT COND EXT COND NO ENON TABERNACLE BAPTIST CHURCH (WEST) ENON TABERNACLE BAPTIST CHURCH 230-234 W. COULTER STREET 19144 1914 CHARLES H. WILSON NO NO NO NO NO NO NO TRUSTEES ENON BAPTIST CHURCH 4/10/2006 4 NO MOUNT CARMEL UNITED METHODIST CHURCH FERN ROCK METHODIST CHURCH 5901-5907 N. PARK AVENUE 19141 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO MT CARMEL METH EPIS CHURCH 4 UNKNOWN (ROBERT SMITH- NO HISTORIC/OLD SAINT GEORGE’S UNITED METHODIST CHURCH SAINT GEORGE'S CHURCH 229-237 N. 4TH STREET 19106 1769 YES OLD CITY YES NO NO YES YES UNCONFIRMED) ST GEORGE METHODIST CHURCH 11/2/2010 4 NO NATIONAL TEMPLE BAPTIST CHURCH UNIVERSALIST CHURCH OF THE RESTORATION 1618 W. MASTER STREET 19121 1860 HAZLEHURST & HUCKEL NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NATIONAL TEMPLE BAPTIST CHURCH 4/6/2006 4 10TH MEMORIAL BAPT NO TENTH MEMORIAL BAPTIST CHURCH SPRING GARDEN BAPTIST CHURCH 1900-1906 W. MASTER STREET 19121 1865 NO NO NO NO NO NO NO CH TRUSTEES 4/6/2006 4 NO SAINT DOMINIC CATHOLIC CHURCH SAINT DOMINIC CATHOLIC CHURCH 8500 FRANKFORD AVENUE 19136 1897 THE REV. JOHN D. BERRILL NO NO NO NO NO NO NO ST DOMINIC