DOCSLIB.ORG

REPLY ALL Shouldn't ALL Policy Be Science-Based?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
REPLY ALL Shouldn't ALL Policy Be Science-Based? REPLY ALL SHOULdn’t ALL POLICY BE SCIENCE-BASED? JENNIFER WINTER and TREVOR TOMBE What Tom Mulcair — and the Conservatives — atives were short-sighted in “letting” miss when it comes to economic policy. Shell’s Voyageur project be cancelled. He states, “An $11-billion project to process raw bitumen was cancelled with Certains aspects clés échappent à Tom Mulcair — seemingly no concern for the loss of et aux conservateurs — en matière de politique tens of thousands of value-added jobs.” économique. But why should the government fund a project that a company has deemed un- profitable? If our sole focus is creating jobs, we can just start generating electri- city using bicycles, or start transporting crude oil using a bucket brigade instead of pipelines. Pushing for government sub- om Mulcair’s article “Building specific policy Mulcair supports in this sidies for “value-added” projects violates a Balanced, Sustainable Energy regard; he specifies only that the prin- the laws of economics (thus jeopardizing TFuture” in the May issue of ciple of “polluter pay” should reign. our prosperity), just as surely as denying Policy Options, where he identifies “sci- The evidence on how to achieve en- climate change is contrary to evidence ence-based” environmental policies vironmental objectives with the least from climate science. as key to NDP priorities is, overall, a economic cost is clear: put a price on To get to the heart of the matter, thoughtful piece. But he neglects the carbon. More specifically, governments what exactly is a “value-added” job? importance of science-based policies should favour carbon taxes or cap-and- Value-added is the difference between generally, and economic policy in trade systems. It is disappointing that total sales revenue and the total cost particular. Since science can speak to Mulcair also fails to acknowledge the of components, materials and services more than just environmental policy, strides already made in reducing green- purchased from other firms. It is an in- shouldn’t all policy be science-based? house gas emissions. He states: “Pro- dustry’s contribution to GDP. Jobs in ex- To be clear, this neglect is not specif- jects that fail to uphold basic principles tractive resource industries are value-add- ic to Thomas Mulcair and the NDP but is like polluter pay are being met with ed jobs. Let’s look at the evidence: Sta- found among all politicians, policy-mak- increasing hostility.” Referring to oil tistics Canada reports that in 2008 the ers and many members of the media sands projects in this way ignores the value-added per hour of work in mining who report on these issues. Speeches, fact that Alberta has a carbon tax on and oil and gas extraction equalled $305, official statements and news articles those large emitters and is considering while the corresponding value-added are rampant with buzzwords and mis- raising the price tag on carbon. per hour in manufacturing was barely conceptions about economic concepts When discussing energy issues, over $50 (CANSIM table 383-0022). It is and consensus policy prescriptions. But politicians seem unable to resist mak- hardly an evidence-based claim to say Mulcair’s article is an example of specific ing another dangerous claim: that that primary sector employment is not policy claims that are inconsistent with “value-added jobs” (read: oil upgraders, “value-added.” In fact, almost every job evidence-based economic policy. refineries or manufacturing) should be is a value-added job, and the free mar- The first issue he raises in the arti- given special consideration. Mulcair ket will eliminate those that are not (ex- cle is how we can best achieve environ- argues the export of raw resources is not cept when the government interferes). mental objectives. It is unclear what a path to prosperity, and the Conserv- n his article Mulcair also continues to Ipromote the Dutch disease view, stat- Jennifer Winter is a research associate at the School of Public Policy, University ing, “The Conservatives’ single-minded of Calgary. Her research focuses on the effects of government regulation on the focus on the export of raw resources...has development of natural resources. Trevor Tombe is an assistant professor in the contributed to an artificial rise in the value economics department, University of Calgary. He examines the intersection of of the Canadian dollar that is hollowing international trade and macroeconomics. out our other export industries.” There 52 OPTIONS POLITIQUES JUIN 2013 reply ALL is no clear evidence for this claim (as is drawal). Second, he seems to be wary On environmental policy, the Conserv- borne out by the studies from the Univer- of foreign investment, calling for “full atives’ approach is equally inconsistent sity of Calgary School of Public Policy by and public consultations” instead of with evidence. Their regulatory, com- Matt Krzepkowski and Jack Mintz, and by the Conservatives’ within-government mand-and-control approach is among Wardah Naim and Trevor Tombe). reviews. They are both wrong. Foreign the least efficient methods to achieve Consider, for example, the fact that investment in Canada should be un- environmental goals. The evidence in the Canadian manufacturing sector has hindered. Barriers to foreign direct in- this regard is nearly as strong as the case been declining at a similar rate to the US vestment will lower investment, lower for free trade: carbon taxes or a cap-and- manufacturing sector. Canada’s manu- capital accumulation, decrease wages trade system will achieve environmental facturers also purchase a huge amount and lower productivity. In short, inter- goals with the least economic damage. of intermediate inputs from abroad, and nationally mobile capital promotes pros- “Science-based” means looking at a rising dollar means cheaper access to perity, not the reverse. evidence and objectively evaluating that inputs, to the benefit of domestic manu- evidence free of normative value judg- facturing. Oil sands firms also purchase he failure to use a science-based ments. It means making claims about many inputs from manufacturers in cen- Tapproach to policy-making (in all the world only when evidence warrants. tral Canada. We do not wish to claim the areas) is a feature of politics, not par- We hope that politicians of all stripes case is closed one way or the other, but ties. The Conservatives’ recent feder- learn to accept evidence in all aspects of a science-based view of economic policy al budget contains a large number of policy-making. Canadians would surely means admitting when the evidence is import tax increases on thousands of see tremendous benefits. n unclear. We simply do not have enough items that will increase prices and lower evidence to definitively say whether oil Canada’s international trade flows. The exports harm Canadian manufacturing. magnitude is striking, with nearly $1.1 Policy Options welcomes responses from readers to There are also some minor slip-ups. billion in increased import tax revenue the ideas and policy proposals carried in our pages. First, Mulcair claims “Canada [is] the projected over the next five years. Evi- Send responses to [email protected]. only country in the world to withdraw dence from economic science couldn’t Options politiques invite ses lecteurs à réagir from the Kyoto Protocol.” In fact, Japan be clearer: free trade increases prosperity. aux idées et propositions avancées dans ses and Russia elected not to sign on to the There is almost no other issue where the pages en adressant leurs commentaires à Kyoto extension (essentially a with- consensus view of economists is clearer. [email protected]. ✁ POLICY OPTIONS SUBSCRIPTION ORDER FORM New Renewal (please include subscriber # _____ _______________________) SUBSCRIBE 1 year 2 years ON-LINE $49.98 (GST included) 87.46$ (GST included) www.irpp.org $54.73 (Quebec taxes incl.) 94.77$ (Quebec taxes incl.) $67.60 (US) 123.30$ (US) $87.60 (Other countries) 163.30$ (Other countries) PayaBLE IN CANADIAN FUNDS ONly Name ______ _____________________________________________________________________________________ Company ________________________________________________________________________________________ Addresse _________________________________________________________________________________________ City _________________________________________________ Province ___________________________________ Postal code _________________________________ Telephone __________________________________________ 1470 Peel Street Payment enclosed VISA MasterCard Amex Bureau 200 Card no __________________________________________________________ Montreal, Quebec Card expiry date __________________________________________________ Canada H3A 1T1 invoice me Signature _________________________________________________________ POLICY OPTIONS 53 JUNE 2013.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 1 Signature Page Past and Present Populism
    Signature Page Past and Present Populism and Protest in the Labour Party and New Democratic Party: Comparisons and Contrasts By Sydney Ann Hull A Thesis Submitted to Department of Political Science Saint Mary’s University, Halifax NS In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Honours Political Science April 2017, Halifax, Nova Scotia Copyright Sydney Hull 2017 Approved: Dr. Alexandra Dobrowolsky. Professor, Department of Political Science Saint Mary’s University Date: 21 April 2017 1 Past and Present Populism and Protest in the Labour Party and New Democratic Party: Comparisons and Contrasts By Sydney Ann Hull A Thesis Submitted to Department of Political Science Saint Mary’s University, Halifax NS In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Honours Political Science April 2017, Halifax, Nova Scotia Copyright Sydney Hull 2017 Approved: Dr. Alexandra Dobrowolsky. Professor, Department of Political Science Saint Mary’s University Date: 21 April 2017 2 Past and Present Populism and Protest in the Labour Party and New Democratic Party: Comparisons and Contrasts By Sydney Ann Hull Abstract: Recent election campaigns in several prominent liberal democracies have seen the rise to prominence of both right and left-wing populist candidates. While significant media and scholarly attention has focused on the former, this thesis examines the less studied but equally prevalent resurgence of left-wing populism through a comparative analysis of two populist movements in Britain and Canada, Momentum and Leap, that
    [Show full text]
  • Hill Times, Health Policy Review, 17NOV2014
    TWENTY-FIFTH YEAR, NO. 1260 CANADA’S POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT NEWSWEEKLY MONDAY, NOVEMBER 17, 2014 $4.00 HEARD ON THE HILL BUZZ NEWS HARASSMENT Artist paints Queen, other prominent MPs like ‘kings, queens in their people, wants a national portrait gallery little domains,’ contribute to ‘culture of silence’: Clancy BY LAURA RYCKEWAERT “The combination of power and testosterone often leads, unfortu- n arm’s-length process needs nately, to poor judgment, especially Ato be established to deal in a system where there has been with allegations of misconduct no real process to date,” said Nancy or harassment—sexual and Peckford, executive director of otherwise—on Parliament Hill, Equal Voice Canada, a multi-par- say experts, as the culture on tisan organization focused on the Hill is more conducive to getting more women elected. inappropriate behaviour than the average workplace. Continued on page 14 NEWS HARASSMENT Campbell, Proctor call on two unnamed NDP harassment victims to speak up publicly BY ABBAS RANA Liberal Senator and a former A NDP MP say the two un- identifi ed NDP MPs who have You don’t say: Queen Elizabeth, oil on canvas, by artist Lorena Ziraldo. Ms. Ziraldo said she got fed up that Ottawa doesn’t have accused two now-suspended a national portrait gallery, so started her own, kind of, or at least until Nov. 22. Read HOH p. 2. Photograph courtesy of Lorena Ziraldo Liberal MPs of “serious person- al misconduct” should identify themselves publicly and share their experiences with Canadians, NEWS LEGISLATION arguing that it is not only a ques- tion of fairness, but would also be returns on Monday, as the race helpful to address the issue in a Feds to push ahead on begins to move bills through the transparent fashion.
    [Show full text]
  • Letter in Support of Yukon First Nations Against S-6 from NDP
    NIKI ASHTON MP - Churchill Thompson Office The Pas Office 83 Churchill Drive, Suite 307 P.O. Box 2820 – 1416 Gordon Avenue Thompson, Manitoba R8N 0L6 The Pas, Manitoba R9A 1M6 Phone: (204) 677-1333 Phone: (204) 627-8716 Fax: (204) 677-1339 Fax.: (204) 627-8717 Toll free: (866) 785-0522 Ottawa Office 263 Confederation Building House of Commons Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0A6 Phone: (613) 992-3018 Fax: (613) 996-5817 Website: nikiashton.ndp.ca Email: [email protected] To Whom It May Concern, The NDP has consistently stood with Yukon First Nations and Yukoners in opposition to S-6. As Aboriginal Affairs critic for the NDP, I have been proud to listen alongside our Leader, Tom Mulcair and our Northern Affairs critic, Dennis Bevington to Yukon First Nations and Yukoners. Together, we brought the messages from Yukon to Parliament. S-6 cannot be supported. We have been clear; First Nations deserve a federal government that will work, nation-to- nation, and respect the work of Yukon Environmental and Socio-economic Assessment Act. Ottawa should not be dictating to First Nations and Yukoners. As Official Opposition, we made every effort to make sure that Yukon voices were being heard loud and clear throughout the process. In Ottawa, our Leader Tom Mulcair hosted Yukon First Nations to hear concerns first hand. In Ottawa and Whitehorse, we met with Yukon First Nations, Yukon leaders, members of the legislature, members of community and environmental organizations, members of industry and Yukoners who were part of putting together YESAA. The messages we heard guided our opposition in Parliament.
    [Show full text]
  • The Comparative Politics of E-Cigarette Regulation in Australia, Canada and New Zealand by Alex C
    Formulating a Regulatory Stance: The Comparative Politics of E-Cigarette Regulation in Australia, Canada and New Zealand by Alex C. Liber A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Health Services Organizations and Policy) in The University of Michigan 2020 Doctoral Committee: Professor Scott Greer, Co-Chair Assistant Professor Holly Jarman, Co-Chair Professor Daniel Béland, McGill University Professor Paula Lantz Alex C. Liber [email protected] ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7863-3906 © Alex C. Liber 2020 Dedication For Lindsey and Sophia. I love you both to the ends of the earth and am eternally grateful for your tolerance of this project. ii Acknowledgments To my family – Lindsey, you made the greatest sacrifices that allowed this project to come to fruition. You moved away from your family to Michigan. You allowed me to conduct two months of fieldwork when you were pregnant with our daughter. You helped drafts come together and were a constant sounding board and confidant throughout the long process of writing. This would not have been possible without you. Sophia, Poe, and Jo served as motivation for this project and a distraction from it when each was necessary. Mom, Dad, Chad, Max, Julian, and Olivia, as well as Papa Ernie and Grandma Audrey all, helped build the road that I was able to safely walk down in the pursuit of this doctorate. You served as role models, supports, and friends that I could lean on as I grew into my career and adulthood. Lisa, Tony, and Jessica Suarez stepped up to aid Lindsey and me with childcare amid a move, a career transition, and a pandemic.
    [Show full text]
  • NDP Response Rural Ontario Priorities
    Rural Ontario Institute 1. Access to quality medical services nearby is a long-standing concern for rural and small town. Ontarians typically some distance from urban facilities and services. What is your party’s platform with respect to the accessibility of health care and quality medical services near to rural and small town residents? Is the current situation satisfactory? How would your party’s approach to a Health Accord and/or the Canadian Health Transfer improve things for rural Ontarians? NDP Response: After eight years in government, Stephen Harper’s Conservatives have failed to improve public health care. This is simply unacceptable. New Democrats have a practical plan to strengthen public health care, all Canadians deserve the best quality care, regardless of where they live. Tom Mulcair is committed to better home care, long-term care, palliative care and expanded public coverage for prescription drugs. We’ll put patients at the centre of primary care, and tackle the social determinants of health while recognizing the importance of mental health. These initiatives will benefit all Canadians—including rural and small town residents. 2. Rural and small town Ontario has an older demographic than urban places making services for an aging population, aging in place/home-care/seniors housing a priority for many. Does your party have a proposed policy agenda that it would implement relevant to a rural/small town context? NDP Response: Over the next 25 years, the number of seniors in Canada will double. We need to be ready. But instead of taking action, Stephen Harper’s Conservatives raised the age of eligibility for OAS and GIS from 65 to 67.
    [Show full text]
  • Levy-Canadian Elections-ENG.INDD
    Holding Pattern The 2019 Canadian Election By Andrea Levy In the parlance of the horse-race terminology favoured by election commentators, the 2019 Cana- dian Elections were a squeaker, or too close to call up until the last minute. Yet given the living fossil of Anglo-American representative democracy that is Canada’s winner-take-all electoral system, the outcome of the 2019 election held few real surprises. There was little doubt that it would be either the incumbent Liberal Party or the opposition Conservative Party which would walk away from elec- tion night victorious, if chastened, perhaps, by minority status. The French have a word for it: alter- nance, two parties governing by turns in a protracted holding pattern. And the periodic alternation of the Liberals and the Conservatives, both parties of capital whose concrete policies have diverged chiefly in the details, has characterized Canadian politics virtually since Confederation. The perpetuation of this holding pattern can only exacerbate the country’s many afflictions and con- tradictions: from spiralling inequality of income and wealth to an economy embedded in extractiv- ism; from the ongoing dispossession of Indigenous peoples to the catastrophe of climate change, with recent research revealing that Canada is warming twice as fast as the rest of the world. With a turnout just shy of 65 percent, the 21st century pattern of voter disaffection held steady. When a third of the electorate stays home, even a majority government cannot claim a strong popular mandate. In this election, Justin Trudeau’s Liberal Party was re-elected with thirteen seats short of a majority, and roughly a third of the ballots cast by those who were motivated enough to go to the polls (a share of the popular vote that was actually a notch lower than that of the rival Conserva- tives).
    [Show full text]
  • New NDP Vs. Classic NDP: Is a Synthesis Possible, and Does It Matter? Tom Langford
    Labour / Le Travail ISSUE 85 (2020) ISSN: 1911-4842 REVIEW ESSAY / NOTE CRITIQUE New NDP vs. Classic NDP: Is a Synthesis Possible, and Does It Matter? Tom Langford David McGrane, The New NDP: Moderation, Modernization, and Political Marketing (Vancouver: UBC Press, 2019) Roberta Lexier, Stephanie Bangarth & Jon Weier, eds., Party of Conscience: The CCF, the NDP, and Social Democracy in Canada (Toronto: Between the Lines, 2018) Did you know that after Jack Layton took over as its leader in 2003, the federal New Democratic Party became as committed to the generation and dissemination of opposition research, or “oppo research,” as its major rivals in the federal party system? Indeed, the ndp takes the prize for being “the first federal party to set up stand alone websites specifically to attack opponents, now a common practice.”1 The ndp’s continuing embrace of “oppo research” as a means of challenging the credibility of its political rivals was on display during the final days of the 2019 federal election campaign. Facing a strong challenge from Green Party candidates in ridings in the southern part of Vancouver Island, the ndp circulated a flyer that attacked the Green Party for purportedly sharing “many Conservative values,” including being willing to “cut services [that] families need” and to fall short of “always defend[ing] the right to access a safe abortion.” Needless to say, the ndp’s claims were based on a very slanted interpretation of the evidence pulled together by its researchers 1. David McGrane, The New ndp: Moderation, Modernization, and Political Marketing (Vancouver: ubc Press, 2019), 98.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Years in the Making
    ANATOMY OF THE ORANGE CRUSH: TEN YEARS IN THE MAKING Brad Lavigne It has been called an overnight success a decade in the making. The historical political realignment of federal politics by Jack Layton and the New Democratic Party was in fact an ambitious and methodical strategy to modernize Canada’s social democratic party into a viable contender for government. Brad Lavigne, the 2011 campaign manager, NDP senior strategist and longtime Jack Layton adviser, provides an insider’s account of the anatomy of the Orange Crush. Un succès instantané, certes, mais précédé d’une décennie de préparation. C’est ainsi qu’on a qualifié l’exploit de Jack Layton et du NPD, qui ont opéré un réalignement historique de la vie politique canadienne grâce à leur stratégie de modernisation ambitieuse et méthodique en vue de faire du parti social-démocrate un aspirant crédible à la direction du pays. Directeur de la campagne 2011, stratège en chef du NPD et longtemps conseiller de Jack Layton, Brad Lavigne décortique les tenants et aboutissants de la « vague orange ». t only took a few minutes. I stepped out of the makeshift It was an outcome that very few outside Jack Layton’s cir- war room in our election-night operations at the cle believed was possible and one that even fewer predicted. I Intercontinental Hotel in downtown Toronto to make a few short calls to congratulate newly elected New Democratic o how did it happen? Was it an accident? Was Jack Party (NDP) Members of Parliament from Atlantic Canada. S Layton — and the 2011 NDP campaign — simply the By the time I returned from the adjoining room, the benefactor of lacklustre performances from the Liberals and team had taped a bunch of flip-chart paper to the walls with the Bloc Québécois? Or was it something more? the names of dozens and dozens of Quebec ridings scribbled To understand how the “Orange Crush” on May 2, on them.
    [Show full text]
  • Conflicting Narratives in the 2015 Canadian Federal Election And
    It’s the Way you Tell It: Conflicting Narratives in the 2015 Canadian Federal Election and 2016 US Presidential Election by Sandford Borins, 1 Professor of Public Management, University of Toronto A paper to be Presented at The Canadian Political Science Association Annual Conference May 30, 2017 © Sandford Borins 2017 Preliminary Draft: Not for Citation 1 Funding from the University of Toronto and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada; the research assistance of Simran Manghirmalani, Adam McGrath, and Karen Hu; and the comments of Beth Herst and Peter Sage are gratefully acknowledged. Previous versions of this paper were presented at the University of Regina, University of Ottawa, and Blurring Genres Research Network (London, UK). 1 Abstract This article develops a narrative-based model for political communication in election campaigns. Political parties develop a heroic fable about the relationship between their leader and the electorate and an ironic fable about the relationship between the leader(s) of their opponent(s) and the electorate. This model was applied to English-language political advertisements posted online by the three major parties in the 2015 Canadian federal election and advertisements by the two major party candidates in the 2016 US presidential election. The narrative characteristics of the ads (fable employed, narrating voice, background music, visual tonality) demonstrated significant differences among the five parties’ narrative strategies. YouTube viewcounts were used to determine the effectiveness of individual ads as well as the overall campaigns. The article demonstrates how narrative analysis enhances our understanding of the essential role of the party leader in election campaigns.
    [Show full text]
  • Master of Arts in History, Queen's University. Super
    Dr. Christos Aivalis SSHRC Postdoctoral Fellow Department of History University of Toronto Education: 613-929-4550 [email protected] 2010-2015: Ph.D. in History at Queen’s University 2009-2010: Master of Arts in History, Queen’s University. Supervisor: Ian McKay. 2005-2009: Bachelor of Arts (hons.) in History and Political Science, University of New Brunswick. Dissertation: “Pierre Trudeau, Organized Labour, and the Canadian Social Democratic Left, 1945-2000.” Supervisor: Ian McKay. Committee members: Timothy Smith, Jeffery Brison, Pradeep Kumar, and Gregory Kealey. Post-Graduate Scholarships and Awards: 2017- 2019: SSHRC Post-Doctoral Fellowship Award (held at the University of Toronto, Department of History. Supervisor: Dr. Sean Mils 2016-17: Nominee—Eugene Forsey Prize in Canadian Labour and Working-Class History— Best Graduate Thesis 2016: Queen’s University Department of History’s most Outstanding Doctoral Dissertation Prize 2016: Queen’s University Award for Scholarly Research and Creative Work and Professional Development 2016: Departmental Nominee—John Bullen Prize for Canadian Historical Association’s best Doctoral Dissertation 2015: Nominee—Canadian Committee for Labour History Article Prize. 2015: Nominee—New Voices in Labour Studies—Best Paper Prize. 2015: Nominee—Jean-Marie-Fecteau Prize for Canadian Historical Association’s Best Graduate Student Article. 2013-2015: Queen’s University Graduate Scholarship. 2013-2014: Finalist—Queen’s University History Department Teaching Award. 2010-2013: SSHRC Joseph-Armand Bombardier CGS Doctoral Scholarship. 2010: Queen’s University Tri-Council Award. 2010: Ontario Graduate Scholarship (declined). 2009: SSHRC Master's Scholarship. 2009: Queen’s University Tri-Council Award. Teaching and Research Experience: Fall 2018-Winter 2019: Adjunct Professor for History 102: History of Canada, Royal Military College of Canada.
    [Show full text]
  • October 2019 Election Resources Go Ecumenical Matt Gardner Staff Writer Anglicans Casting a Ballot in Canada’S Federal Election on Oct
    ANGLICAN JOURNAL Since 1875 anglicanjournal.com @anglicanjournal vol. 145 no. 8 october 2019 Election resources go ecumenical Matt Gardner STAFF WRITER Anglicans casting a ballot in Canada’s federal election on Oct. 21 will find a range of ecumenical resources to help them learn more about the issues and converse with candidates. A letter released in September, signed by leaders of the Anglican Church of Canada and Evangelical Lutheran Church in Canada (ELCIC), encourages PHOTO: NIYAZZ/ participation in the election and directs SHUTTERSTOCK Anglicans and Lutherans to resources from the Canadian Council of Churches (CCC) and Citizens for Public Justice (CPJ) to help decide their vote. The use of resources from ecumenical See GUIDES, p. 15 PHOTO: JANET BEST Le Chœur gai de Montréal (Montreal Gay Men’s Chorus) sings at the annual pride mass at Christ Church Cathedral, diocese of Montreal. A new hymnal expands musical selections for LGBTQ+ Anglicans. ‘The Jesus movement’: Queer hymn collection offers ‘much-needed’ People or institution? resource for LGBTQ+ Anglicans and allies An interview with Episcopal Church Presiding Bishop Michael Curry Matt Gardner from the Hymn Society, an ecumenical STAFF WRITER non-profit association that seeks to Joelle Kidd STAFF WRITER Music played a healing role for many promote congregational singing, Songs for the Holy Other includes almost 50 Anglicans after an amendment to Bishop Michael Curry is the 27th and “queer hymns” by and for individuals the marriage canon that would have current presiding bishop of the U.S.- who identify with the LGBTQ+ recognized same-sex marriage failed to based Episcopal Church.
    [Show full text]
  • Mutual Accommodation As a Defining Feature of Canada's Success
    Understanding the Canadian Difference Mutual accommodation as a defining feature of Canada’s success A collection of essays by William A. Macdonald Copyright © 2016 by William A. Macdonald All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced by any means without prior permission of the author. For more information or additional copies of this publication, please contact: W. A. Macdonald Associates Inc. 205 – 63 St. Clair Avenue West Toronto, Ontario M5V 2Y9 T 416-865-7091 F 416-865-7934 E [email protected] www.wamacdonald.com The essays in this booklet originally appeared in The Globe and Mail. Canadian Difference is a bilingual online community dedicated to insightful national conversation about what makes Canada work; and to exploring the role mutual accommodation has played or could play on specific issues of importance to the country. To learn more, visit canadiandifference.ca Contents FOREWORD David Walmsley 4 EDITOR’S NOTE Rosemary Shipton 5 PREFACE William A. Macdonald 7 THE CANADIAN DIFFERENCE WEBSITE William R. K. Innes 8 THE ESSAYS The magic of the Canadian ideal 9 To be a global role model, Canada must realize what sets it apart 11 How Canada’s eight leaders of special vision guided the way 13 Overcoming Islamophobia: Fear is never the best basis for action 15 Justin Trudeau’s sunny ways — and a storm on the horizon 17 Truth and reconciliation: Will this time be any different? 19 To transform Canada’s economy, Trudeau needs to be a “bold builder” 22 To revive Canada’s economy, reward those who pitch in 24 Canada could play a major role in strengthening U.S.-China relations 26 In dealing with Uncle Sam, Canada must be patient and firm 28 An urgent call for national (economic) unity in Canada 30 Important Brexit lessons for an anxious, fraying world 32 AFTERWORD Paul Volcker 34 CLOSING THOUGHTS William A.
    [Show full text]