Arxiv:1108.3003V2 [Gr-Qc]

Home , Through the Wormhole

arXiv:1108.3003v2 [gr-qc] 14 Mar 2012 htcnan,i diinto addition version in simple contains, a that offers higher- theory as (DEGB) Einstein- well Gauss-Bonnet dilatonic as The fields terms. additional gravitational curvature of presence the by general- the a where term dimensions such curvature four for in framework theory gravitational the theory ized provided effective has string 8] partic- heterotic [7, In low-energy the wormholes. traversable ular, the for stable allow of to candidates existence suitable are consider the- gravity of Higher-curvature to ories gravity. led of is theories one generalized wormholes, traversable a obtain be nec- [6]. to matter wormholes of shown traversable type was support exotic to term, the essary reversed kinetic for a its candidate with of suitable field front scalar whose in a matter field, sign condi- of phantom energy A type these the tions. a of violates by throat tensor The open energy-momentum kept traversable. is be wormholes horizon, could no thus possess which and solutions wormhole [4]. of one class impenetrable, thus and proper, would traveler a a to of it approaching change mere the the of per- - horizon small turbations past against unstable the is (ii) geometry of [3], Schwarzschild speed through the pass at moving can particle light ra- a so even circumference maximum not zero a that to quickly to again contracts expands then “throat” and dius its - wormhole dynamic Schwarzschild the is (i) by findings: shattered following was the shortcuts the travel However, wormhole interstellar also Universe. of but own a dream our universes of that different regions two distant [2] two only showed not theory. Wheeler connect con- the can 1950s, was of the curiosity it mathematical In geometry, mere Schwarzschild [1] a of sidered 1935 feature in a discovered as was bridge”, “Einstein-Rosen nodrt icmetteueo xtcmte to matter exotic of use the circumvent to order In new a found [5] Thorne and Morris 1988 in However, Introduction.– ihrsett ailprubtosfrasbe fteewo 04.50.-h these 04.70.Bw, of 04.70.-s, subset numbers: PACS a for perturbations de re We radial Smarr to generalized matter. a respect satisfy exotic with wormholes of these that form show any and needing without dimensions, ecntuttaesbewrhlsi iaoi Einstein- dilatonic in wormholes traversable construct We R fEnti’ hoyi supplemented is theory Einstein’s of omoe nDltncEnti-as-ontTheory Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet Dilatonic in Wormholes ntttfu hsk nvri¨tOdnug -61 Old D-26111 Universität Oldenburg, für Physik, Institut hntefis omoe the wormhole, first the When iiino hoeia hsc,Dprmn fPhysics, of Department Physics, Theoretical of Division R udai curvature quadratic a , nvriyo onia oniaG-51,Greece GR-45110, Ioannina Ioannina, of University ukadKehu,JtaKunz Jutta Kleihaus, Burkhard Dtd ac 5 2012) 15, March (Dated: aait Kanti Panagiota S 8] [7, het- theory low-energy string the erotic by motivated [9–12] action fective uesrn hoydw ofu dimensions. four to down heterotic theory ten-dimensional superstring the the of of from compactification naturally existence the follows the that on intro- term solely are GB higher-curvature rely matter we of Instead, forms exotic phantom duced. No other theory. or DEGB fields the scalar of context the in tions the to contribution nontrivial equations. a field term, has four-dimensional latter GB the the that to field so exponentially scalar coupling a and dilaton) term, (the (GB) Gauss-Bonnet the term, n h iao eda nt radius finite a at field dilaton the and fsltos n fteeape rsne showed presented the examples for the the behavior classes besides of pathological other a One that, admits observed theory solutions. the also of solutions, el- was line hole it this black on But based solutions, ement. hole black static mits h eg lp aaee,and parameter, slope Regge the α o ftecraueivrat at behav- invariants curvature singular any the exhibit of not ior did solution the Since where opoe oio with horizon proper no h pctm ieeeeti h om[9] form write the may in we element Hence line equations. spacetime the field the of solutions 4 R ds = sapstv ueia offiin ie ntrsof terms in given coefficient numerical positive a is eew netgt h xsec fwrhl solu- wormhole of existence the investigate we Here n[]i a eosrtdta EBter ad- theory DEGB that demonstrated was it [9] In eew osdrol ttc spherically-symmetric static, only consider we Here µν EBtheory.– DEGB 2 16 R = 1 φ µν π as-ontter nfu spacetime four in theory Gauss-Bonnet − rmholes. ain edmntaelna stability linear demonstrate We lation. stedltnfil ihculn constant coupling with field dilaton the is Z e + Γ( emn hi oano existence, of domain their termine d R r 4 ) 2 x dt √ steG correction. GB the is nug Germany enburg, 2 − + g e Λ( R r g ecnie h olwn ef- following the consider We ) − tt dr en eua o all for regular being 2 1 2 ∂ + µ ∂ φ r g R 2 rr r GB 2 µ 0 dθ φ erccomponent metric twsconcluded was it , + = 2 sin + r αe R = µνρσ − r γφ 2 0 θdϕ R R u had but r GB 2 µνρσ ≥ 2 (2) r . γ , − 0 (1) , . 2 that the pathological behavior was due to the choice where M and D are identified with the mass and dila- of the coordinate system. ton charge of the wormhole, respectively. Unlike the Here we argue that this class of asymptotically flat case of the black hole solutions [9], the parameters M solutions is indeed regular and represents a class of and D characterizing the wormholes at radial infinity wormholes with r0 being the radius of the throat. In- are not related, in agreement with the classification of 2 2 2 deed, the coordinate transformation r = l +r0 leads this group of solutions as two-parameter solutions. to a metric without any pathology, Wormhole properties.– A general property of a wormhole is the existence of a throat, i. e., a sur- ds2 = e2ν(l)dt2+f(l)dl2+(l2+r2) dθ2 + sin2 θdϕ2 . face of minimal area (or radius for spherically sym- − 0 (3) metric spacetimes). Indeed, this property is implied In terms of the new coordinate, the expansion at the by the form of the line element (3) above, with f(0) 2ν(l) throat l = 0, yields f(l) = f0 + f1l + , e = and ν(0) finite. To cast this condition in a coordi- 2ν0 ··· e (1+ν1l)+ , φ(l)= φ0+φ1l+ , where fi, νi and nate independent way, we define the proper distance φ are constant··· coefficients. All curvature··· invariants, l ′ l ′ ′ i from the throat by ξ = √gll dl = f(l )dl . including the GB term, remain finite for l 0. 0 0 → Then the conditions for a minimalR radiusR drp = 0, The expansion coefficients f0, ν0 and φ0 are free pa- dξ l=0 2 rameters, as well as the radius of the throat r0 and the d r dξ2 > 0 follow from the substitution of the expan- value of α – the value of the constant γ is set to 1 in l=0 the calculations. The set of equations remains invari- sion at the throat. In order to examine the geometry of the space man- ant under the simultaneous changes φ φ + φ∗ and (r, l) (r, l)e−φ∗/2. The same holds for→ the changes ifold, we consider the isometric embedding of a plane → passing through the wormhole. Choosing the θ = π/2 α kα and φ φ + ln k. As a result, out of the 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 parameter→ set (α,→ r , φ ) only one is independent: we plane, we set f(l)dl +(l +r0)dϕ = dz +dη +η dϕ , 0 0 where z,η,ϕ are a set of cylindrical coordinates in thus fix the value of φ0, in order to have a zero value { } 3 of the dilaton field at infinity, and create a dimension- the three-dimensional Euclidean space R . Regarding less parameter α/r2 out of the remaining two. Also, z and η as functions of l, we find η(l) and z(l). We 0 note that the curvature radius of the curve η(l),z(l) since only the derivatives of the metric function ν ap- { } at l = 0 is given by R0 = r0f0. From this equation we pear in the equations of motion, we fix the value of ν0 to ensure asymptotic flatness at radial infinity. Note obtain an independent meaning for the parameter f0 that force-free wormhole solutions, i.e., with ν(l) 0, as the ratio of the curvature radius and the radius of cannot exist with a nonphantom scalar, as was shown≡ the throat, f0 = R0/r0. in [13]. Essential for the existence of the wormhole solution is the violation of the null energy condition Of particular interest is the constraint on the value T nµnν 0, for any null vector field nµ. For spher- of the first derivative of the dilaton field at the throat, µν ically symmetric≥ solutions, this condition can be ex- which originates from the diagonalization of the dila- pressed as G0 + Gl 0 and G0 + Gθ 0, where ton and Einstein equations in the limit l 0. In 0 l 0 θ the Einstein− equations≥ have been− employed.≥ The null terms of the expansions it translates into a constraint→ energy condition is violated in some region if one of on the value of the parameter φ , i.e. 1 these conditions does not hold. By using the expansion of the fields near the throat, we find that there 2 f0(f0 1) φ1 = − . (4) 2 −γφ0 α −γφ0 0 l 2 2αγ e f0 2(f0 1) r2 e G + G = < 0 , (5) h − − 0 i − 0 l l=0 −f r2 0 0 Since the left-hand-side of the above equation is provided e2ν(0) = 0, i.e. in the absence of a horizon. positive-definite, we must impose the constraint f 6 0 ≥ The wormhole solutions satisfy a Smarr-like mass 1. This constraint introduces a boundary in the phase formula space of the wormhole solutions. The expression in- κ D side the square brackets in the denominator remains M = 2Sth 2 φ0 2π − 2γ positive and has no roots if a/r0 < e /2 - this in- equality is automatically satisfied for the set of solu- 1 dφ − + √ ggll 1+2αγ2e γφR˜ d2x tions presented. 8πγ Z − dl For l we demand asymptotic flatness for the where κ denotes the surface gravity at the throat and two metric→ ∞ functions and a vanishing dilaton field. Then, the corresponding asymptotic expansion yields 1 √ −γφ ˜ 2 ν M + , f 1+ 2M + , φ D + Sth = h 1+2αe R d x . → − l ··· → l ··· → − l ··· 4 Z 3

1 f(l)

0 φ(l) -1

-2 r0 R α 2 0 /r0=0.02, f0=1.1 α/r2=0.02, f =1.5 -3 0 0 α/r2=0.02, f =2.0 ν(l) 0 0 -4

0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 l

FIG. 1: The metric and dilaton functions for f0 = 1.1 (red FIG. 2: Isometric embedding for a wormhole solution for 2 or solid), 1.5 (green or dashed ), 2.0 (blue or dotted), and α/r0 = 0.02 and f0 = 1.1. 2 α/r0 = 0.02, versus l.

tion, the dilaton field and all curvature invariants at Here hµν is the induced metric on the throat, R˜ the the throat. The third boundary, indicated by dots, scalar curvature of h, and the integral is evaluated at is characterized by curvature singularities; it emerges 2 l = 0. Thus the known DEGB mass formula for black when branches of solutions with fixed α/r0 terminate holes [12] is augmented by a contribution which may at singular configurations with the derivatives of the be interpreted as a modified throat dilaton charge, functions developing a discontinuity at some point lcrit where the GB modification is of the same type as the outside the throat. GB modification of the area (or entropy, in case of Stability.– A crucial requirement for traversable black holes). wormhole solutions is their stability. We therefore as- Numerical results.– For the numerical calcula- sess the stability of the DEGB wormhole solutions tions we use the line element (3). At l = 0 regularity with respect to radial perturbations. We allow the requires relation (4) to hold with f(0) = f0 or φ(0) = φ0 in order to obtain a unique solution. Note that 1.8 f 1 for l is always satisfied. Thus the asymp- α 2 1.04 /r totic→ boundary→ ∞ conditions read ν 0 and φ 0. 0 → → 0.02 The field equations, reducing to a system of ODE’s, 1.6 1.02 0.05 were solved for 1.0001 f0 20.0 fixing γ = 1. 0.06 Wormhole solutions were≤ found≤ for every value of α/r2 1.0 0.08 0 -0.02 0.0 0.02 considered up to 0.13 - this translates into a lower 2 1.4 0.09 M

π 0.10 bound on the radius of the throat r0 that can be arbi- 0.12

trarily large. In Fig. 1, we show the metric and dilaton A/16 1.2 0.128 functions for an indicative set of wormhole solutions. σ2=0 In Fig. 2, we present the isometric embedding of the 2 1 solution with α/r0 =0.02 and f0 =1.1. In Fig. 3 we exhibit the domain of existence of the wormhole solutions. Here we show the scaled area of 0.8 the throat A/16πM 2 versus the scaled dilaton charge -0.1 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 2 D/M D/M for several values of α/r0. We observe that the domain of existence is bounded by three curves indicated by dots, crosses and asterisks. The boundary FIG. 3: The scaled area of the throat versus the scaled 2 indicated by asterisks corresponds to the limit f0 =1 dilaton charge for several values of α/r0 . The domain of and coincides with the black hole curve since g (r ) existence is bounded by the black hole solutions (aster- − 00 0 tends to zero in this limit. The boundary indicated isks), the f0 → ∞ solutions (crosses), and curvature sin- by crosses corresponds to the limit f0 . In this gularity solutions (dots). The shaded areas indicate linear limit, the mass M and the dilaton charge→ ∞D assume stability (lilac or lower), instability (red or upper), unde- ﬁnite values. The same holds for the redshift func- cided yet (white) with respect to radial perturbations. 4

0 However, there is also a region in parameter space, α/r2 -0.001 0 where no negative mode exists, i.e. a region where the 0.020 -0.002 0.050 DEGB wormhole solutions are linearly stable with re- -0.003 0.060 spect to radial perturbations. The different solutions -0.004 0.080 are also marked in the domain of existence (Fig. 3). 0.090 2 -0.005 σ Junction conditions.– When we extend the -0.006 wormhole solutions to the second asymptotically flat -0.007 part of the manifold (l ) in a symmetric way, → −∞ -0.008 jumps appear in the derivatives of the metric and dila- -0.009 ton functions at l = 0. These can be attributed to -0.01 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 5.5 the presence of matter at the throat of the wormhole. −φ0 3 f0 Introducing the action (λ1 + λ02αe R¯) h¯ d x, ¯ − ¯ where hab is the inducedR metric on the throatp and R the corresponding Ricci scalar, the junction conditions 2 FIG. 4: The eigenvalue σ versus f0 for several values of take the form 2 α/r0 . −φ0 −φ0 ′ 4αe 8αe φ0 ρ λ0 2 λ1 = 2 , (8) − r0 − r0 √f0 metric and dilaton functions to depend on both l and ′ 2ν0 t, and we decompose them into an unperturbed part p + λ1 = , (9) and the perturbations:ν ˜(l,t) = ν(l) + λδν(l)eiσt, √f0 −φ0 −φ0 f˜(l,t)= f(l)+ λδf(l)eiσt, φ˜(l,t)= φ(l)+ λδφ(l)eiσt, 4αe ρdil ′ 8αe ′ 1 λ0 2 + = φ0 + 2 ν0 .(10) where λ is considered as small. Substituting the above r0 2 r0 √f0 in the (time-dependent) Einstein and dilaton equations and linearizing in λ, we obtain a system of linear We have also assumed that the matter at the throat ODEs for the functions δν(l), δf(l) and δφ(l). takes the form of a perfect fluid and a dilaton charge Rearranging appropriately the system of ODEs, we density ρdil. A simple numerical analysis shows that derive a decoupled second-order equation for δφ, the junction conditions can be easily satisfied for nor- ′′ ′ mal matter with positive energy density and pressure, (δφ) + q (δφ) + (q + q σ2) δφ =0 , (6) 1 0 σ for appropriately chosen constants λ1 and λ0. The presence of ρdil ensures that the stability considera- where q1, q0 and qσ depend on the unperturbed so- tions are not affected by the matter on the throat. lution. All coefficients take up constant values as Conclusions.– l and, in order to ensure normalizability, δφ Traversable wormholes do not exist in general relativity, unless some exotic matter is→ demanded ∞ to vanish in that limit. However, while q is bounded at l = 0, q and q diverge as 1/l. To is introduced. However, if string theory corrections σ 1 0 are taken into account the situation changes dramat- avoid this singularity, we consider the transformation δφ = F (l)ψ(l), where F (l) satisfies F ′/F = q (l)/2. ically. Here we investigated wormhole solutions in 1 DEGB theory without introducing exotic matter. We This yields − determined the domain of existence and showed lin- ′′ 2 ear stability with respect to radial perturbations for ψ + Q0ψ + σ qσψ = 0 (7) a subset of solutions. Since the radius of the throat ′ 2 is bounded from below only, the wormholes can be where Q0 = q1/2 q1 /4+ q0 is bounded at l = 0. Then, for regular,− normalizable− solutions, ψ has to arbitrarily large. Astrophysical consequences will be vanish both asymptotically and at l = 0 . addressed in a forthcoming paper as well as the exis- We solved the ODEs together with the normaliza- tence of stationary rotating wormhole solutions in the 2 DEGB theory. tion constraint for several values of α/r0 and f0. A solution exists only for certain values of the eigenvalue Acknowledgements.– We gratefully acknowledge σ2. In Fig. 4, we exhibit the negative modes of fam- discussions with Eugen Radu. B.K. acknowledges sup- ilies of wormhole solutions, which are thus unstable. port by the DFG.

[1] A. Einstein and N. Rosen, Phys. Rev. 48 (1935) 73. [2] J.A. Wheeler, Geometrodynamics (Academic, New 5

York, 1962). [7] D. J. Gross, J. H. Sloan, Nucl. Phys. B291 (1987) [3] M. D. Kruskal, Phys. Rev. 119, 1743 (1960); 41. R. W. Fuller and J. A. Wheeler, Phys. Rev. 128, 919 [8] R. R. Metsaev, A. A. Tseytlin, Nucl. Phys. B293 (1962). (1987) 385. [4] I. H. Redmount, Prog. Theor. Phys. 73 (1985) 1401; [9] P. Kanti, N. E. Mavromatos, J. Rizos, K. Tamvakis D. M. Eardley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 33 (1974) 442; and E. Winstanley, Phys. Rev. D 54 (1996) 5049; R. M. Wald and S. Ramaswamy, Phys. Rev. D21 Phys. Rev. D 57 (1998) 6255. (1980) 2736. [10] S. Mignemi and N. R. Stewart, Phys. Rev. D 47 [5] M. S. Morris and K. S. Thorne, Am. J. Phys. 56, 395 (1993) 5259. (1988). [11] C. M. Chen, D. V. Gal’tsov, N. Ohta, D. G. Orlov, [6] H. G. Ellis, J. Math. Phys. 14, 104 (1973); Phys. Rev. D81 (2010) 024002. K. A. Bronnikov, Acta Phys. Polon. B 4, 251 [12] B. Kleihaus, J. Kunz, E. Radu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, (1973); T. Kodama, Phys. Rev. D 18, 3529 (1978); 151104 (2011). C. Armendariz-Picon, Phys. Rev. D 65, 104010 [13] K. A. Bronnikov, E. Elizalde, Phys. Rev. D81 (2010) (2002). 044032.