Kosovo-Kosova
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by NORA - Norwegian Open Research Archives KOSOVO-KOSOVA A discourse analysis of the Albanian political thought during the period 1990- 1999 ALTIN FUGA UNIVERSITY OF OSLO 2.5.2007 2 CONTENTS KOSOVO-KOSOVA..................................................................................................................................... 1 CONTENTS................................................................................................................................................... 2 1. INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................... 4 1.1 REFLECTING ON THE OTHER MA ESSAYS .......................................................................................... 4 1.2 THE OBJECT OF THE ESSAY ................................................................................................................ 5 1.3 DO WE NEED ANOTHER ESSAY ABOUT KOSOVO/YUGOSLAVIA? ........................................................ 6 1.4 THE STRUCTURE OF THE ESSAY ......................................................................................................... 7 2. METHODOLOGY.............................................................................................................................. 8 2.1 METHODOLOGY: A GENERAL VIEW ................................................................................................... 8 2.2 DISCOURSE- A DEFINITION .............................................................................................................. 10 2.3 THE ROLE OF THE SUBJECT .............................................................................................................. 14 2.4 DISCOURSE, POWER AND KNOWLEDGE ............................................................................................ 15 2.5 DISCOURSE ANALYSIS AS A METHODOLOGICAL TOOL...................................................................... 18 2.6 METATHEORETICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF DISCOURSE ANALYSIS ................................................... 20 2.7 CRITERIA FOR EVALUATION ............................................................................................................ 21 3. METHOD........................................................................................................................................... 24 3.1 METHOD- THE CASE STUDY RESEARCH DESIGN ............................................................................... 24 3.2 THE CASE- THE UNIT OF ANALYSIS .................................................................................................. 25 3.3 THE SUBJECTS ................................................................................................................................. 26 3.4 COLLECTING DISCURSIVE DATA/MATERIALS ................................................................................... 27 4. THE ALBANIAN CONTEXT.......................................................................................................... 29 4.1 THE PREDECESSORS OF THE ALBANIAN NATIONAL MOVEMENT....................................................... 29 4.2 THE EVENTS THAT PRECEDED THE ALBANIAN NATIONAL MOVEMENT............................................. 32 4.3 A NEW LEADERSHIP TAKES OVER .................................................................................................... 33 4.4 THE FORMATION OF THE ALBANIAN NATIONAL MOVEMENT............................................................ 34 5. “NO ‘SPECIAL STATUS’, NO THIRD REPUBLIC, BUT ONLY INDEPENDENCE!” ......... 37 5.1 RUGOVA AND HIS SELF-IMAGE ........................................................................................................ 37 5.2 THE ALBANIANS- REPRESSED, DISCRIMINATED AND THREATENED BY MILOŠEVIĆ AND SERBIA...... 38 5.3 ETHNIC CONFLICT AS ELITE MANIPULATION .................................................................................... 39 5.4 DEMOCRACY AND SELF-DETERMINATION........................................................................................ 41 5.5 THE DISCOURSE OF SELF-DETERMINATION ...................................................................................... 42 3 5.6 THE STRATEGY TO ACHIEVE THE POLITICAL GOAL .......................................................................... 44 5.7 THE ALBANIANS UNDER THE SERB OCCUPATION ............................................................................ 47 5.8 THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO............................................................................................................. 48 5.9 THE STRATEGY TO ACHIEVE THE POLITICAL GOALS ........................................................................ 51 5.10 THE DAYTON PEACE ACCORD AND THE LDK DILEMMA............................................................ 55 5.11 SUMMARY.................................................................................................................................. 57 6. THE DEMOCRATIC OPTION ...................................................................................................... 61 6.1 THE DEMOCRATS AND THEIR SELF-IMAGE ....................................................................................... 61 6.2 THE CRISIS OF REAL SOCIALISM AND ELITE MANIPULATION ............................................................ 62 6.3 DEMOCRACY AND SELF-DETERMINATION ....................................................................................... 64 6.4 THE GOAL: THE DEMOCRATISATION OF YUGOSLAVIA ..................................................................... 66 6.5 THE STRATEGY OF THE DEMOCRATIC FRACTION ............................................................................. 67 6.6 THE CONFLICT AFTER THE DISSOLUTION OF YUGOSLAVIA .............................................................. 70 6.7 THE GOAL OF THE ALBANIAN MOVEMENT....................................................................................... 71 6.8 THE DAYTON PEACE TALKS AND THE RADICALISATION OF THE ALBANIAN MOVEMENT.................. 75 6.9 SUMMARY....................................................................................................................................... 78 7. REXHEP QOSJA, HIS POLITICAL IDEAS ................................................................................ 81 7.1 QOSJA AND HIS SELF-IMAGE............................................................................................................ 81 7.2 THE VICTIMISATION OF THE ALBANIANS BY SERBIA ....................................................................... 82 7.3 ETHNIC CONFLICT AS ELITE MANIPULATION.................................................................................... 83 7.4 SOCIAL PROGRESS, SELF-DETERMINATION AND DEMOCRACY ......................................................... 85 7.5 THE REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO VS. THE ALBANIAN UNIFICATION.......................................................... 86 7.6 THE STRATEGY OF THE ALBANIAN MOVEMENT............................................................................... 87 7.7 THE YUGOSLAV DISSOLUTION: OCCUPATION VS. LIBERATION ........................................................ 89 7.8 THE ALBANIAN UNIFICATION.......................................................................................................... 90 7.9 THE STRATEGY OF THE ALBANIAN MOVEMENT............................................................................... 92 7.10 THE POST-DAYTON STRATEGY................................................................................................... 94 7.11 SUMMARY.................................................................................................................................. 97 8. THE POWER/KNOWLEDGE EFFECTS ................................................................................... 100 9. LITERATURE ................................................................................................................................ 105 10. DISCOURSE MATERIALS .......................................................................................................... 111 11. ENDNOTES..................................................................................................................................... 122 4 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Reflecting on the other MA essays Ethnicity and ethnic conflicts became a major topic of scientific debate after the events in Yugoslavia etc. The ethnic tide peaked in 2000, at least here, at the Institute of political science, University of Oslo. The majority of the essays on Yugoslavia consist of rational choice/game theory inspired investigations1. The authors justify the use of this approach with the complicated nature of the conflicts and the need to sim- plify their studies. Second, they defend the use of formal, consistent, and precise models with the necessity for rigorous reasoning and the aspiration to generalise the conclusions. The students repeat a line borrowed from Hovi & Rasch (1996: 3) “Sim- ple models shall lead the way to more complicated explanatory and predictive mod- els”. These essays can be criticised in a number of points. Empirically, the students use no primary Albanian and Serbian sources. To quote Foucault (2001: 276), “About them it could be said, rather, that they are eaters of history as others have prepared it. They consume it pre-processed”. Even secondary sources, mainly foreign journalists, had few contacts between ‘the natives’,