Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux's Fontaine Des Quatre-Parties
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
!: 9 090/'1*0,'' 6$.+55'&505*' #%6-590(5*'0--')'0( 354#/&%+'/%'4 0( .'3+%#//+7'34+59 +/#35+#-6-(+--.'/50( 5*''26+3'.'/54(035*'')3''0( #45'30( 354 / 35+45039 *#+3 6-+'5'--08*'55 '--0- 88 ** "+/)*'/'/)**''//'/)) ** '#/0(5*'0--')'0( 354#/&%+'/%'4 April 30, 2020 #5' .'3+%#//+7'34+59 #4*+/)50/ © COPYRIGHT by Hoyon Mephokee 2020 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED AT THE CENTER OF THE GLOBE: JEAN-BAPTISTE CARPEAUX’S FONTAINE DES QUATRE-PARTIES-DU-MONDE, 1867-74 BY Hoyon Mephokee ABSTRACT ComMissioned in 1867 and installed in 1874, Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux’s (1827-1875) Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste (The Four Parts of the World Supporting the Celestial Sphere), also referred to as the Fontaine des Quatre-Parties-du-Monde (Fountain of the Four Parts of the World), is a public sculpture that adorns a fountain at the LuxeMbourg Gardens in Paris. The Monument sits on the axis between the LuxeMbourg Palace and the Paris Observatory and depicts four nude feMale figures who support a celestial sphere, and who represent the four continents—Europe, AMerica, Africa, and Asia—through their distinct physiognomic features. This thesis interrogates the work’s racial iconography and spatial relationship to sites that eMbodied French political and scientific authority during the Second French EMpire. Reading the Monument’s iconography in relation to its placeMent in the charged space of HaussMannized Paris, I suggest that Napoléon III intended Carpeaux’s work to affirm his right to govern and his need to unite a divided French nation. The Fontaine eMbodied the contradictions of Napoléon III’s political Messaging, as his regiMe outwardly chaMpioned progressive ideals, while it built and sustained itself on iMperial and racial conservatisM and French racial and political superiority. ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I aM deeply appreciative of the AU Art History faculty for extending to Me the opportunity to be a part of this incredibly challenging and rewarding prograM. I aM grateful to Dr. Juliet Bellow for always being available and willing to guide Me and My projects. Her Mentorship has been indispensable, from our first conversation about graduate school in the sumMer of 2018 to the completion of this thesis. I would like to thank Dr. Ying-Chen Peng, whose insights shaped the direction of a significant portion of this project. I would also like to acknowledge Dr. Nancy Rose Marshall for instilling in Me a love of nineteenth-century European art during My undergraduate years at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, and for encouraging Me to pursue this graduate degree. The priMary research that went into this thesis was Made possible by the late Dr. Carol Bird Ravenal, whose award allowed Me to travel to France in the sumMer of 2019; Jaylynn Saure, the administrative coordinator and unsung hero of our departMent; Cécile Gérard at the Archives Municipales de Valenciennes, who sent Me scans of archival documents; and Nadège Horner at the Musée d’Orsay, who generously provided me with her own archival transcriptions. I aM thankful to My peers in the cohort for welcoming Me into the prograM and for their eMotional and intellectual support. I aM, likewise, thankful to My college roomMates and My friends from home, who were willing to listen to Me talk about My project ad nauseaM, and whose Messages and calls kept me siMultaneously grounded and afloat. Finally, I aM indebted to My faMily. My parents, Chanin Mephokee and Yi Yangshin, are My acadeMic role Models. I credit this degree and thesis to their unconditional love, patience, and support, as well as to what I can only describe as the herculean efforts they took to raise me. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT.................................................................................................................................... ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS............................................................................................................. iii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS........................................................................................................... v INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER 1 THE FRENCH EMPIRE UNDER NAPOLÉON III................................... 9 CHAPTER 2 MAPPING THE FONTAINE.................................................................... 20 CHAPTER 3 THE FONTAINE’S RACIAL ICONOGRAPHY...................................... 34 CONCLUSION: A MONUMENT FOR THE FRENCH COLONIAL EMPIRE.............. 54 ILLUSTRATIONS........................................................................................................................ 59 BIBLIOGRAPHY......................................................................................................................... 62 iv LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Figure 1: Jean-Baptiste Carpeaux, Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste (The Four Parts of the World Supporting the Celestial Sphere), 1867-74. Bronze............................... 59 Figure 2: EMManuel FreMiet, Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste, 1867-74. Bronze........................................................................................................................................... 59 Figure 3: Carpeaux, Europe, from Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste, 1867- 74. Bronze..................................................................................................................................... 59 Figure 4: Carpeaux, America, from Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste, 1867- 74. Bronze..................................................................................................................................... 59 Figure 5: Carpeaux, Africa, from Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste, 1867- 74. Bronze..................................................................................................................................... 59 Figure 6: Carpeaux, Asia, from Les Quatre parties du monde soutenant la sphère céleste, 1867- 74. Bronze..................................................................................................................................... 59 Figure 7: Carpeaux, L’Empereur reçoit Abd el-Kader au palais de Saint-Cloud (The Emperor Receiving Abd el-Kader at the Palace of Saint Cloud), 1853. Marble........................................... 59 Figure 8: Carpeaux, Le Prince Impérial et son chien Néro (The Imperial Prince and his dog Nero), 1865. Marble................................................................................................................................. 59 Figure 9: Carpeaux, Ugolin et ses fils (Ugolino and His Sons), 1865-67. Marble......................... 59 Figure 10: Israël Silvestre, Perspective Above Versailles, c. 1690. Drawing................................ 59 Figure 11: Pierre Le Pature, General Map of the Palace of Versailles, 1717. Engraving............. 59 Figure 12: Hildegard of Bingen, The Universal Man, from Liber Divinorum Operum, 1165. Painting......................................................................................................................................... 59 Figure 13: Thomas of CantiMpré, from De natura rerum, 1295. Manuscript................................ 59 Figure 14: Leonardo da Vinci, Vitruvian Man, ca. 1492. Drawing, ink, and wash on paper......... 60 Figure 15: Antoine-Jean Gros, Bonaparte visitant les pestiférés de Jaffa (Bonaparte Visits the Plague Stricken in Jaffa), 1804. Oil on canvas.............................................................................. 60 Figure 16: Jean-Baptiste Tuby, Charles Le Brun, Bassin d’Apollon (The Fountain of Apollo), 1668- 71. Bronze..................................................................................................................................... 60 v Figure 17: AbrahaM Ortelius, Theatrum Orbis Terrarum: Title-page with Four Figures which Embody the Four Known Continents, 1606. Illustration................................................................ 60 Figure 18: Francesco Bertos, Allegorical Groups Representing the Four Continents: Europe, 1710-25. Bronze............................................................................................................................ 60 Figure 19: Bertos, Allegorical Groups Representing the Four Continents: America, 1710-25. Bronze........................................................................................................................................... 60 Figure 20: Bertos, Allegorical Groups Representing the Four Continents: Africa, 1710-25. Bronze........................................................................................................................................... 60 Figure 21: Bertos, Allegorical Groups Representing the Four Continents: Asia, 1710-25. Bronze. ....................................................................................................................................................... 60 Figure 22: AiMé-Jules Dalou, Caryatids: The Four Continents, 1867. Patinated plaster.............. 60 Figure 23: Charles Cordier, La Capresse des Colonies (The Capresse of the Colonies), 1861. Algerian onyx-Marble, bronze and gilt bronze, enaMel, aMethyst; white Marble socle............................................................................................................................................... 60 Figure 24: François-August Biard, Proclamation