21 November 2018 at 6.30Pm in Meeting Rooms 1 & 2 at the Richmond Town Hall
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Agenda Page 1 YARRA CITY COUNCIL Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda to be held on Wednesday 21 November 2018 at 6.30pm in Meeting Rooms 1 & 2 at the Richmond Town Hall Rostered Councillor membership Councillor Stephen Jolly Councillor Mike McEvoy Councillor Mi-Lin Chen Yi Mei (substitute for Cr James Searle) I. ATTENDANCE Vicky Grillakis (Co-ordinator Statutory Planning) Sarah Griffiths (Senior Co-ordinator Statutory Planning) Cindi Johnston (Governance Officer) II. DECLARATIONS OF PECUNIARY INTEREST AND CONFLICT OF INTEREST III. CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES IV. COMMITTEE BUSINESS REPORTS Printed on 100% recycled paper Yarra City Council – Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda – Wednesday 21 November 2018 Agenda Page 2 "Welcome to the City of Yarra. Yarra City Council acknowledges the Wurundjeri as the Traditional Owners of this country, pays tribute to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in Yarra and gives respect to the Elders past and present." Yarra City Council – Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda – Wednesday 21 November 2018 Agenda Page 3 Guidelines for public participation at Internal Development Approval Committee meetings POLiCY Council provides the opportunity for members of the public to address the Internal Development Approvals Committee. The following guidelines have been prepared to assist members of the public in presenting submissions at these meetings: • public submissions are limited to a maximum of five (5) minutes • where there is a common group of people wishing to make a submission on the same matter, it is recommended that a representative speaker be nominated to present the views of the group • all public comment must be made prior to commencement of any discussion by the committee • any person accepting the chairperson’s invitation to address the meeting shall confine himself or herself to the subject under consideration • people making submissions shall address the meeting as a whole and the meeting debate shall be conducted at the conclusion of submissions • the provisions of these guidelines shall be made known to all intending speakers and members of the public generally prior to the commencement of each committee meeting. For further information regarding these guidelines or presenting submissions at Committee meetings generally, please contact the Governance Branch on (03) 9205 5110. Governance Branch 2008 Yarra City Council – Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda – Wednesday 21 November 2018 Agenda Page 4 1. Committee business reports Item Page Rec. Page 1.1 PLN18/0172 - 622-642 Nicholson Street Fitzroy North - The 5 43 construction of a ten storey building plus three basement levels and a roof top terrace, the use of the land as an office, medical centre, supermarket and a bottle shop, the sale of liquor for consumption off the premises, a reduction in the car parking requirement and alterations to the access to a road in a Road Zone, Category 1 by removing and altering crossovers to Nicholson Street. 1.2 115 Easey Street, Collingwood - PLN17/0655 - Full demolition of 54 76 the existing dwelling and construction of three dwellings on a lot. 1.3 PLN17/0789 - 377 St Georges Road, Fitzroy North - Demolition of 81 123 the existing building for the construction of a mixed-use multi-storey building, and use of the land for dwellings, with a reduction in the car parking requirement. 1.4 5 Park Drive, Clifton Hill - PLN17/0648 - Amendment to a Section 131 144 173 Agreement 1.5 37 - 39 Stewart Street - PLN16/0365.02 - Section 72 Amendment 145 157 to extend the existing platform (with associated air conditioning units) on the western side of the existing building to a height of 8.3 metres. Yarra City Council – Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda – Wednesday 21 November 2018 Agenda Page 5 1.1 PLN18/0172 - 622-642 Nicholson Street Fitzroy North - The construction of a ten storey building plus three basement levels and a roof top terrace, the use of the land as an office, medical centre, supermarket and a bottle shop, the sale of liquor for consumption off the premises, a reduction in the car parking requirement and alterations to the access to a road in a Road Zone, Category 1 by removing and altering crossovers to Nicholson Street. Executive Summary Purpose 1. This report provides Council with an assessment of planning permit application PLN18/0172 which seeks approval for the construction of a ten storey building plus three basement levels and a roof top terrace, the use of the land as an office, medical centre, supermarket and a bottle shop, the sale of liquor for consumption off the premises, a reduction in the car parking requirement and alterations to access to a road in a Road Zone, Category 1 by removing and altering crossovers to Nicholson Street. 2. As detailed in the assessment section, this report recommends approval of the proposed development subject to conditions, including a reduction in the overall height of the building to eight storeys through the deletion of two levels. Key Planning Considerations 3. Key planning considerations include the following: (a) Land use (Clauses 11.01, 11.02, 11.03, 17.01, 17.02, 21.04 and 32.04 of the Yarra Planning Scheme). (b) Built form (Clauses 15.01, 21.05, 22.05, 22.07 and 22.10 of the Yarra Planning Scheme). (c) Off-site amenity impacts (Clauses 15.01, 22.05 and 22.10 of the Yarra Planning Scheme). (d) Internal amenity (Clauses 22.05 and 22.17 of the Yarra Planning Scheme). (e) Car and bicycle parking (Clauses 18.01, 18.02, 21.06, 52.06 and 52.34 of the Yarra Planning Scheme). (f) Licensed premises (Clauses 22.09 and 52.27). (g) Access to a Road Zone (Clause 52.29). Key Issues 4. The key issues for Council in considering the proposal relate to the following: (a) Strategic justification. (b) Land Use. (c) Built form and design. (d) Equitable development. (e) Off-site amenity impacts. (f) Internal amenity. (g) Sustainable design. (h) Potentially contaminated land. (i) Car and bicycle parking. Yarra City Council – Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda – Wednesday 21 November 2018 Agenda Page 6 (j) Traffic and access. (k) Objector concerns. Submissions Received 5. A total of 240 objections were received to the application, these can be summarised as follows: (a) Design and built form (including out of character, excessive height, bulk and scale and inappropriate materials and finishes). (b) Overdevelopment of the site. (c) Off-site amenity impacts (including overlooking, overshadowing, loss of daylight, glare from the proposed glazing, loss of views, wind impacts). (d) Increase in noise (traffic, people, outdoor areas/terraces, mechanical plant equipment, etc.). (e) Poor internal amenity. (f) Car parking, traffic and access including impractical turn table, lack of car parking on site, increased traffic, waste management issues. (g) Other (including setting a precedence, no community benefit, reduction in property values, impacts during construction). Conclusion 6. Based on the following report, the proposal is considered to comply with the relevant planning policy in the Scheme and should be supported subject to the following key recommendations: (a) A reduction in the overall height of the building from 10 to eight stories through the deletion of two levels. (b) The eastern facade of the building with a reflectivity of no less than 0.5 or 50 per cent. (c) Restriction to the size of vehicles accessing the loading bay of the building to 12.5 metres in length or less (equating to medium rigid trucks or smaller). (d) Restriction to the number of loading vehicle events for trucks occurring each day, to no more than four. CONTACT OFFICER: Nikolas Muhllechner TITLE: Principal Planner TEL: 9205 5456 Yarra City Council – Internal Development Approvals Committee Agenda – Wednesday 21 November 2018 Agenda Page 7 1.1 PLN18/0172 - 622-642 Nicholson Street Fitzroy North - The construction of a ten storey building plus three basement levels and a roof top terrace, the use of the land as an office, medical centre, supermarket and a bottle shop, the sale of liquor for consumption off the premises, a reduction in the car parking requirement and alterations to the access to a road in a Road Zone, Category 1 by removing and altering crossovers to Nicholson Street. Trim Record Number: D18/177514 Responsible Officer: Senior Co-ordinator Statutory Planning Proposal: The construction of a ten storey building plus three basement levels and a roof top terrace, the use of the land as an office, medical centre, supermarket and a bottle shop, the sale of liquor for consumption off the premises, a reduction in the car parking requirement and alterations to the access to a road in a Road Zone, Category 1 by removing and altering crossovers to Nicholson Street. Existing use: Function centre operating in a four storey building. Applicant: Ratio Consultants Zoning / Overlays: Mixed Use Zone Environmental Audit Overlay Date of Application: 16 March 2018 Application Number: PLN18/0172 Planning History 1. Planning permit 2363 was issued by the City of Fitzroy on 3 November 1983 and allowed the construction a building on site and the use of the premises for the purpose of a showroom, warehouse and reception room with ancillary car park. 2. Planning permit 782 was issued by the City of Fitzroy on 14 December 1989 and allowed the display of two illuminated non-advertising signs. 3. Planning permit 955 was issued by the City of Fitzroy on 1 October 1990 and allowed the use of the ground floor of the building for the purpose of a restaurant. 4. Planning permit 956 was issued by the City of Fitzroy on 1 October 1990 and allowed the use the ground floor of the building for the purpose of a reception room. 5. Planning permit 2615 was issued by the City of Fitzroy on 18 January1994 and allowed the subdivision of the site into two (2) lots.