• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Observing Light-by-Light Scattering in Vacuum with an Asymmetric Photon Collider Maitreyi Sangal,1 Christoph H. Keitel,1 and Matteo Tamburini1, ∗ 1Max-Planck-Institut f¨urKernphysik, Saupfercheckweg 1, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany (Dated: January 8, 2021) Elastic scattering of two real photons is the most elusive of the fundamentally new processes predicted by quantum electrodynamics. This explains why, although first predicted more than eighty years ago, it has so far remained undetected. Here we show that in present day facilities elastic scattering of two real photons can become detectable far off axis in an asymmetric photon- photon collider setup. This may be obtained within one day operation time by colliding one millijoule XUV pulses with the broadband gamma-ray radiation generated in nonlinear Compton scattering of ultrarelativistic electron beams with terawatt-class optical laser pulses operating at 10 Hz repetition rate. In addition to the investigation of elastic photon-photon scattering, this technique allows to unveil or constrain new physics that could arise from the coupling of photons to yet undetected particles, therefore opening new avenues for searches of physics beyond the standard model. In classical electrodynamics, light beams in vacuum served directly. To date, X-ray beam experiments could pass through each other unaffected [1]. However, in only place an upper bound on the photon-photon scat- the realm of QED photons in vacuum can scatter elasti- tering cross section [41]. cally via virtual electron-positron pairs [2]. This qualita- There exist two main challenges to detect elastic scat- tively new process has profound implications in cosmol- tering of real photons: (i) the smallness of the photon- ogy, where it results in a modified photon spectrum [3,4], photon scattering cross section; (ii) the fact that photons as well as in astrophysics, where photon-photon scatter- are identical particles such that, e.g., the backscattering ing can occur in the strongly polarized vacuum present of two photons colliding head-on is indistinguishable from in the magnetosphere of pulsars and magnetars [5{8]. the case of no scattering. For two colliding photon beams Notably, photon-photon scattering also plays a critical with finite angular spread, this implies that all the events role in searches of physics beyond the standard model. where both photons are scattered inside the opening an- In fact, due to its tiny cross section, precision measure- gle of the photon beams are undetectable. ments of any possible deviation of this process from QED Here we show that both the above challenges can be predictions could be evidence of new physics that could overcome in an asymmetric photon-photon collider setup arise from the coupling of photons to unknown weakly where a highly-collimated broadband gamma-ray beam interacting light particles such as axion-like particles, collides with an XUV pulse (see Fig.1). In fact, a sub- minicharged particles, magnetic monopoles or hidden stantial number of scattering events can be triggered by gauge bosons [9{15] (see also the recent reviews [16, 17]). requiring both that photon collisions occur at center of p Despite the very weak coupling, these exotic hypotheti- momentum (CM) energies "CM = "γ "!(1 − cos #)=2 2 cal particles could play a key role in the evolution of the approaching mec , where the elastic photon-photon scat- Universe, and may lead to observable astrophysical and tering cross section σ is maximal [2], and that at least one cosmological effects such as matter-antimatter asymme- of the colliding beams has a large photon density. Here try [18] or the recent evidence of birefringence in cosmic "γ ("!) is the gamma (XUV) photon energy, # the an- microwave background radiation [19, 20]. gle between the gamma and XUV photon, me the elec- Following the seminal calculations of photon-photon tron mass and c the speed of light in vacuum. In the scattering by Euler [21] and the full QED results by considered asymmetric setup, the high energy of gamma arXiv:2101.02671v1 [hep-ph] 7 Jan 2021 2 Karplus and Neuman [2, 22{24], proposals to detect photons allows to attain "CM . mec , while XUV beams elastic photon-photon scattering of synchrotron radia- provide a relatively large photon number density. More- tion [25] or of free electron laser (FEL) radiation [26, 27] over, although for kinematic reasons scattered photons were suggested. More recently, the advent of high-power are prevalently directed along the initial direction of the laser systems has led to ingenious proposals to detect gamma photon (see below), the high-collimation of the the finite photon-photon coupling induced by the pres- gamma beam implies that one or even both the scattered ence of virtual particles in the collision of intense laser photons are deflected to angles larger than the beam beams [28{32], in cavities [33, 34], with Bragg inter- opening angle, therefore providing an observable of the ference [35], and with measurements of vacuum bire- scattering event. frengence and dichroism induced by ultraintense laser Moreover, photon-photon scattering could also be me- fields [36{38]. However, despite the recent observation diated by axion-like particles, which would result in a of scattering of virtual photons in ultraperipheral Pb nu- systematic excess of the number of scattering events com- clei collision in the Large Hadron Collider [39, 40], the pared to QED predictions. Finally, the broadband nature interaction of real photons in vacuum has never been ob- of the gamma-ray beam allows photon-photon collisions 2 s FIG. 1. Schematic setup. A collimated ultrarelativistic electron beam propagating along x collides with an intense linearly polarized optical laser pulse therefore generating a collimated gamma-ray beam. The laser pulse polarization axis and propa- gation direction are in the xy plane. The electron beam and possible positrons generated in the collision with the laser pulse are deflected by a magnetic field along z. The gamma-ray beam passes through a collimator, which selects photons with small angle with respect to the xy plane. The collimated gamma-ray beam collides with an XUV pulse propagating in the xz plane. Elastic photon-photon scattering events can result in large angle s := arctan (ps;z=ps;x) photon deflection. 2 mediated by such hypothetical particles to be probed For "CM > mec the process of two photon conversion across a wide range of sub-MeV CM energies. This ap- into an electron-positron pair becomes possible [2]. Al- proach for searching signals of new physics in the low- though two photon conversion into an electron-positron energy frontier [42] is independent and complementary pair is another important QED process that has not yet to those with matter [43{48] and with high-power opti- been observed directly [52, 53], its cross section is ∼ α−2 cal lasers [11{15]. larger than elastic photon-photon scattering [2], where The elastic photon-photon scattering cross section σ α ≈ 1=137 is the fine structure constant (see [54] for 2 2 reaches its maximum at "CM just above mec [σ(mec ) ≈ multiphoton electron-positron pair creation). Thus, the 1:3 × 10−34 m2], drops by three orders of magnitude al- detection of the much rarer elastic photon-photon pro- 2 2 −37 2 2 ready at "CM = 0:5 mec [σ(0:5 mec ) ≈ 2:2 × 10 m ], cess is facilitated in the region "CM < mec , where two − + and by further four orders of magnitude at "CM = photon e e pair conversion cannot occur. In fact, the 2 2 −41 2 − + 0:1 mec [σ(0:1 mec ) ≈ 1:3 × 10 m , see Fig.2]. created e e pair can yield a relatively large background Due to its strong energy dependence σ ≈ 1:29 × of photons via Compton backscattering, therefore hiding −35 2 6 2 2 10 ("CM=mec ) m for "CM . 0:3 mec (see Fig.2)], signs of elastic photon-photon scattering. In addition, for optical photon beams such as those delivered by the almost complete suppression of background noise associ- most powerful lasers worldwide [49], σ falls to the tiny ated with Compton scattering of gamma rays with stray value σ(1:55 eV) ≈ 10−68 m2. The smallness of the cross particles requires to operate in extreme high vacuum con- −11 section implies that a large number of photons are re- ditions (. 10 Pa) similar to those of accelerators and quired to trigger elastic photon-photon scattering. In storage ring facilities [55, 56]. Background noise can be fact, the total number of scattering events occurring measured by comparing the results obtained by running in the head-on collision of two identical photon beams the experiment with and without the XUV pulse. 2 with focal area S and with Nγ photons is Nγ σ("CM)=S. Thus, for 1.55 eV photon energy and S ≈ 10−10 m, one We start considering the simpler case of head-on col- 29 needs Nγ ≈ 10 in order to trigger a single scatter- lision of two photons with the same energy, i.e., in the ing event. This huge number of photons corresponds to CM frame. Figure2 plots the normalized differential 2:5×1010 J energy per beam, well above the energy deliv- elastic photon-photon scattering cross section σ−1dσ=dΩ ered by the world's highest energy facilities such as Laser for different values of "CM. While the full expression of M´egajoule [50] and the National Ignition Facility [51]. dσ=dΩ is considerably complex [2, 23, 24], Fig.2 shows 2 −10 By contrast, for 0:5 mec photons and S ≈ 10 m, one that the angular distribution of scattered photons weakly 13 needs Nγ ≈ 2:1 × 10 for triggering a single scatter- depends on "CM, such that its much simpler low energy 2 ing event, which corresponds to an energy of 0.87 J per approximation "CM mec can be used to infer the beam.

Load more

  7

Copy Link