Forestry Royalties in Tanga Region: Paper Versus Reality Daniel Kobb
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TECHNICAL PAPER 48 Forestry Royalties in Tanga Region: Paper versus Reality Daniel Kobb 1998 East Usambara Catchment Forest Project TECHNICAL PAPER 48 FOREST ROYALTIES IN TANGA REGION: PAPER VERSUS REALITY Daniel Kobb Prepared for East Usambara Catchment Forest Project, Buffer Zone Conservation & Development Program, And Tanga Coastal Zone Project Ministry of Natural Resources and Tourism, Department of International Development Co- Tanzania operation, Finland Forestry and Beekeeping Division Finnish Forest and Park Service Tanga 1998 ii PREAMBLE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS In a spirit of co-operation this paper was financed by the Tanga Coastal Zone Conservation and Development Project, the Natural Resources and Buffer Zone Project and the East Usambara Catchment Forest Project. In this sense, it represents a rare effort on the part of donors to economise on scarce research or consultancy funds. The extra work of co-ordination fell largely (but not exclusively) on the East Usambara Catchment Forest Project (primarily Mr. Nashanda and Mr Johansson). Fieldwork demanded a level and complexity of logistics rarely encountered in consultancy reports. Police and traffic co-operation was granted. Much of this work was ably handled by Mr Mburi, who accompanied me for most of the field work and travel. Research assistance was provided by Davis Joseph, Burhan Majaliwa, Amri Joho, Kyalamaka Gwambibi, Sikuthani Muya, Celina Mhina, Christina Mzoo, Barnabas Mbwana, Francis Kiondo and Clarence Mangowi. Police officials who pitched in (under difficult sleepless conditions) included Officers Sembwana, Saumi, Christian, Mziray, Ferdnand, and Meck. Foresters sharing this burden were Mbwelewa Kimweri, Zuberi Gumbo, Azza Chomora, M.C. Luwoga, Frank Mahere, Benard, Emmanuel Msofi, Peter Ndege, John Paulo and Edgar Msikari. Mr. Mrema, of the Mangrove project, and his workers provided assistance on patrol. Hospitality was extended by the Amboni Company, and in particular Bruce and Jane Fox of Mkwaja. iii ABBREVIATIONS, TECHNICAL TERMS & SWAHILI WORDS ERV, Exchequer Receipt Voucher, a Central Government Receipt FBD, Forest and Beekeeping Division (in Ministry of Natural Resources and Tourism) FL, Felling License, permission to cut a tree once royalties (fees) have been paid. FRMP, Forest Resource Management Project, a World Bank financed project operating primarily in Tabora and Mwanza. KWh, Kilowatt Hours, a unit of electricity use m3, Cubic Metres RNRO, Regional Natural Resource Officer. TRC, Tanzania Railway Corporation “Tabora” Report, series of reports by Bert Koppers on royalty collection problems in Tabora. Tanesco, Tanzania Electricity Supply Company Exchange Rate: $ US 1 = 660 Tsh (Tanzanian Shillings) iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Preamble and Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................iii Table of Contents............................................................................................................................. v List of Tables and Figures..............................................................................................................vii Chapter One: Introduction ............................................................................................................. 18 1.1 The General Approach: Commercialism.............................................................................. 20 1.2 Methodology........................................................................................................................ 20 1.2.1 How was the Estimate or Target Derived? ................................................................... 20 1.3 Other Studies Silviculture and Tabora and a Pre-view of results ........................................ 22 1.4 Layout of this report............................................................................................................. 23 Chapter Two: Current Revenue Collected, the Data...................................................................... 24 2.1 Quarterly Data and the Case for District Collection ............................................................ 24 2.2 Felling License Data: (Primary Documents)........................................................................ 26 2.2.1 Daily Averages.............................................................................................................. 27 2.2.2 Seasonality and Trends ................................................................................................. 27 2.3 ERVs: Charcoal and Fuelwood (Primary Data Set)............................................................. 27 Seasonality of ERVs .............................................................................................................. 28 2.4 Summary .............................................................................................................................. 28 Chapter Three: Charcoal and Fuelwood ........................................................................................ 30 3.1 The Transport of Charcoal: Road Monitoring ..................................................................... 30 3.1.1 Commercial Traffic....................................................................................................... 30 3.1.2 Drivers’ Charcoal and Fuelwood .................................................................................. 32 3.1.3 Buses............................................................................................................................. 32 3.1.4 Bicycles......................................................................................................................... 33 3.1.2 Summary of Charcoal and Fuelwood traffic................................................................. 33 3.2 A map of Charcoal Sales...................................................................................................... 35 3.4 The Case of Mkarambati......................................................................................................37 3.5 Charcoal at Horohoro........................................................................................................... 38 3.6 Dar ....................................................................................................................................... 38 3.7 ERV Data: the Possible Effect of Observation .................................................................... 39 3.8 Charcoal Prices: Scarcity and Taxation ............................................................................... 39 Chapter Four: Timber .................................................................................................................... 42 4.1 The Transport of Timber: Road Monitoring ........................................................................ 42 4.2 Observing Three Random Saw-millers................................................................................ 43 4.3 Carpenters and Timber Dealers: “District Demand”............................................................ 43 4.3.1 High-Medium-Low Estimates....................................................................................... 45 4.4 Data from a Day in the Forests ............................................................................................ 45 4.5 The Kenyan Border.............................................................................................................. 45 4.5.1 An Alternative Recommendation for Horohoro; Marketing and Publicity................... 46 Chapter Five: Mangroves............................................................................................................... 47 5.1 Kipubmwi, Mkwaja: South of the Pangani......................................................................... 47 5.2 Moa and the Northern Coast ................................................................................................ 47 5.3 Disruption of Markets.......................................................................................................... 47 5.4 Revenue Estimates ............................................................................................................... 47 Chapter Six: Summary and Recommendations.............................................................................. 48 6.1 Summary: Low, Medium and High Estimates Revisited..................................................... 48 6.2 Data collection ..................................................................................................................... 48 6.3 Financial Administration...................................................................................................... 49 6.4 Checking Checkpoints and Revenue Collectors: an internal audit method ......................... 50 6.5 Sources to be exploited: some targets are derived ............................................................... 51 v 6.5.1 Charcoal and Fuelwood at Kabuku............................................................................... 51 6.5.2 Mizani and Amboni Checkpoints ................................................................................ 52 6.5.3 Saw-millers and large timber dealers............................................................................ 53 6.5.4 Dealing with the Army.................................................................................................. 53 6.5.5 Smuggling in Kenya. ...................................................................................................