20120604-NEWS--29-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 5/31/2012 3:35 PM Page 1
$2.00/JUNE 4 - 10, 2012
ADVERTISEMENT
Proud to be the 2012 SBA Large Lender of the Year KeyBank is committed to lend $5 billion to small businesses by 2014.
All credit products are subject to credit approval. KeyBank SBA Preferred Lender. ©2012 KeyCorp. KeyBank is Member FDIC. ADL5088 22 7 NEWSPAPER 74470 83781 0 20120604-NEWS--30-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 5/31/2012 3:36 PM Page 1
An SBA loan could be the first chapter in your success story. Your business may be small, but your goals are big. An SBA loan from KeyBank can help you with financing for a new location, new equipment, more inventory, or maybe even an acquisition. KeyBank is an SBA Preferred Lender, and we’re committed to lending $5 billion to community businesses like yours by September 2014. That’s a lot of local success stories. Let’s start writing yours. KeyBank is proud to have been named the 2012 SBA Large Lender of the Year.
To connect with a Key SBA loan specialist in your area, stop by a local KeyBank branch or call 888-KEY2BIZ or visit key.com/sba.
Pictured: Costas Mavromichalis, owner, Constantino’s Market, and his daughter, Anna Mavromichalis, general manager. All credit products are subject to credit approval. Banking products and services are offered by KeyBank N.A. Member FDIC and Equal Housing Lender. 20120604-NEWS--1-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 10:45 AM Page 1
Vol. 33, No. 22 $2.00/JUNE 4 - 10, 2012
Eaton shift Law school away from admission trucks long in coming tighter at Acquisition continues CSU, CWRU manufacturer’s focus on electrical business Jobs scarce and apps down,
By MARK DODOSH schools recalculate class size [email protected] By MICHELLE PARK [email protected] The planned $11.8 billion megadeal that will combine Cleveland-based Two of Northeast Ohio’s three law schools Eaton Corp. with Cooper Industries MARC GOLUB are among a growing number of law institutions plc of Dublin, Ireland, will result in Josh Kabat and his fiancée, Kiaran Daley, own the new Cleveland Pickle sandwich shop in the City Club Building scaling back admissions as applications continue the formation of a company that is on Euclid Avenue in downtown Cleveland. to drop amid a persistently tough job market for referred to in regulatory documents attorneys. as “New Eaton.” In an effort to preserve the quality of the But, in reality, school’s incoming class, Cleveland-Marshall Eaton has been College of Law is cutting the target for its entering ANALYSIS creating a “New HEY, NEIGHBORS! class to 140 from its previous target of 200. Like- Eaton” for at least wise, Case Western Reserve a decade, with the pace of its trans- University School of Law formation into an electrical equip- Influx of restaurants promising sign for city’s residential hopes is reducing its admissions INSIDE: A look at ment and energy management giant target by about 10%, to past enrollment accelerating over the last four years. By JAY MILLER lunch counters and fast-food spots 190 from a previous range data from Cleve- Eaton began its life 101 years ago [email protected] by the mid-1990s after law firms and of 210 to 220. land-Marshall and as a maker of truck axles, but the businesses fled to the suburbs and Cleveland-Marshall’s the University of company has seen its truck and here’s no better way to chart the Tower City and Galleria malls applications are down Akron. Page 16 automotive segments steadily shrink the evolution of downtown opened their food courts. Later, fine nearly 30% this year com- in their relative contributions to Cleveland into a residential dining emerged, first in the Ware- pared to last year, when Eaton’s business as a whole. That’s neighborhood than to watch house District and then on East the school admitted 168 students in its fall class, because Eaton has focused in recent Tthe kind of restaurants that are Fourth Street, squeezing out even said its dean, Craig M. Boise. Both Mr. Boise times on acquiring companies related moving onto Euclid and Prospect more delis and diners. and Lawrence E. Mitchell, dean at Case Western to its electrical business segments, avenues and into the Warehouse But the tide is turning, or maybe Reserve’s law school, are revising their admis- which the company three years ago District. returning. With young people flocking sion targets downward in their first years at the divided for financial reporting pur- Downtown’s streets had lost nearly to renovated apartments in former helm. poses into “Electrical Americas” and all their family restaurants, storefront See NEIGHBORS Page 12 “Having been here a little less than a year, “Electrical Rest of World.” obviously the first thing you hate to do is say, The acquisition of Cooper Indus- ‘Look, my revenue’s down, and we need to … tries would put an exclamation point shrink revenue projections for the law school on Eaton’s transformation because MORE OPTIONS DOWNTOWN ... going forward,’” said Mr. Boise, who became of Cooper’s size and global reach as dean last July. “But this is something that’s not a supplier of electrical equipment ... AND COMING that includes such better-known brands SOON See ADMISSION Page 16 as Crouse-Hinds electrical enclosures and Halo lighting fixtures. In 2011, Eaton’s two electrical INSIDE segments combined to account for Want a tasty treat? You’re in $7.2 billion, or 45%, of Eaton’s overall BRGR 9, West Ninth St. El Güero, West Ninth St. sales and $883 million, or 39%, of its the right place operating profits. The planned addi- As summer fast approaches, tion of Cooper, which had sales last Northeast Ohio has been inun- year of $5.4 billion and net income of dated by stores serving $828 million, would cause Eaton’s frozen snacks. PAGE 10 electrical business to dwarf each of PLUS: its four other operating segments — ■ The Gotham King portfolio Hydraulics, Aerospace, Truck and of nine office buildings in the Automotive. Charka Indian Cuisine, West Ninth St. Nexus Café, Prospect Avenue Potbelly, Euclid Avenue city’s eastern suburbs has en- However, even before the surprise tered into foreclosure. PAGE 3 See EATON Page 26 INSIDE: Many restaurateurs already established in Northeast Ohio are looking to expand beyond the region. Page 14
SPECIAL SECTION INVE$TINGGUIDE2012 Investors grow more leery of potential effects of Entire contents © 2012 November’s presidential election ■ Page I-1 by Crain Communications Inc. PLUS: DEFERRED COMPENSATION ■ SUPERSTAR 10 ■ & MORE Vol. 33, No. 22 20120604-NEWS--2-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 5/31/2012 1:06 PM Page 1
Beachwood U Brook Park U Middleburg Heights U North Olmsted
©2012 Porsche Cars North America, Inc. Porsche recommends seat belt usage and observance of all traffic laws at all times. Vehicle shown includes optional equipment available at additional cost.
OUR COLLECTION JUST GOT BIGGER. AND FASTER.
Every carmaker has a vision of the future. Ours just happens to be in production. The 2012 Porsche 911 Carrera Cabriolet. Starting at $93,700. INTRODUCING THE ALL-NEW MASERATI OF CLEVELAND.
Now you can experience Maserati for yourself, at Maserati of Cleveland, part of Collection Motorsports. Best of all, your Maserati comes with a level of service that has become the hallmark of Collection Auto Group.
Porsche of North Olmsted NOW LOCATED AT: A Part of Collection Auto Group 28400 Lorain Road, North Olmsted, Ohio 44070 28300 Lorain Road 440-716-2720 North Olmsted Open 24/7 at: www.clevelandporsche.com 440-716-2000 #1 PORSCHE DEALER IN OHIO www.maseraticleveland.com Cleveland Follow us on for additional specials and offers
Pure Driving Passion
Electric Luxury and Performance With Extended Range. Plug In Or Fill Up.†
“Martin. Aston Martin.”
An Aston Martin shakes up the status quo while stirring the soul of those who drive one. Why not make that someone you? Come to the new Aston Martin Cleveland, part of Collection Motorsports, and experience the exquisite craftsmanship and phenomenal performance that is Aston Martin.
2012 Fisker Karma Extended Range Electric Vehicle Starting at $95,900*
CLEVELAND
Aston Martin Cleveland 28300 Lorain Road North Olmsted FISKER OF CLEVELAND ______Located at 28300 Lorain Road t 440-716-2000 www.fiskerofcleveland.com 440.716.2000 astonmartinofcleveland.com * Base price. Not including destination charge. †Fisker Karma has a range of up to 50 miles with no gas and an extended range of 350 miles using a gasoline-driven generator. ©2012 Fisker Automotive, Inc. ^^^JVSSLJ[PVUH\[VNYV\WJVT 20120604-NEWS--3-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 2:59 PM Page 1
JUNE 4 -10, 2012 WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 3 Gotham King portfolio in foreclosure INSIGHT
asked for the appointment of a Former Duke Realty buildings suffering from lofty ’07 purchase price receiver and to transfer the case to Region has the county court’s commercial docket. By STAN BULLARD its seeds were sown in 2007 when into so-called “special servicing” a Under court rules, Judge Corrigan [email protected] Gotham Realty Holdings of New year ago in what Mr. King described cannot rule on the requests until this strengths York and local developer and broker as a strategic default to try to rene- week at the earliest. One of the region’s commercial Donald King bought the buildings gotiate the loan, which had been Court papers by Orix maintain real estate trophies, the Gotham from Duke Realty Corp. of Indi- sold to investors. However, Dallas- Gotham King has not made payments King portfolio of nine office buildings anapolis for $140 million. The price based Orix Capital Markets LLC filed of more than $800,000 monthly since in water in the eastern suburbs, is the subject is considered a record for a portfolio to foreclose on the properties May July 2011. The mortgage does not of a $135 million foreclosure action of office buildings in Northeast 23 in county court, and the case was mature until 2017. in Cuyahoga County Common Ohio’s suburbs, and was paid just assigned to Judge Peter Corrigan. Duke sold the nine buildings in its technology Pleas Court. before the ensuing recession gave Orix, which serves as special quest to exit Northeast Ohio for Real estate experts express no the office market a drubbing. servicer, and U.S. Bank, which acts surprise at the development, saying The Gotham King mortgage went as trustee for the bondholders, have See GOTHAM Page 8 NorTech may work to build industry cluster By CHUCK SODER [email protected]
NorTech thinks its latest idea could hold water. Northeast Ohio could create a lot of jobs if it can build on existing strengths related to water tech- nology, according to NorTech vice president Byron Clayton. The opportunity could be big enough to warrant more of Nor- Tech’s attention. The technology- focused economic development group, which already is working to accelerate the region’s advanced energy and flexible electronics sectors, might make water tech- nology its third focus area. That decision depends on the outcome of a study NorTech is in the process of finishing. Although the study isn’t done, information gathered so far suggests that Northeast Ohio has what it takes to be a player in the water tech- nology sector, said Dr. Clayton, who would lead NorTech’s effort to promote the sector’s growth. The findings also suggest that demand for water technologies is on the rise, he said. JASON MILLER Vox Mobile CEO Kris Snyder finds himself in a good spot these days. He’s leading a company that helps other businesses manage their The near-term opportunity in handheld mobile devices, and the more types of devices they buy, the more they want the help of businesses like his. water technology is driven by federal mandates: The U.S. Envi- ronmental Protection Agency is By CHUCK SODER requiring that sewer districts [email protected] across the nation reduce the VOX amount of sewage that flows into ox Mobile Inc. should thank waterways during heavy rains. Among them is the Northeast that guy who keeps asking Ohio Regional Sewer District, MANAGES his boss if he can get an which plans to spend $3 billion iPhone. over the next 25 years reducing storm water runoff that gets into VAll those businesses that are starting the sewer system and adding A MOBILE to let their employees use iPhones, infrastructure designed to prevent sewers from overflowing so often. Androids and other handheld mobile The bigger, longer-term oppor- devices for their work have helped Vox tunity involves cleaning up indus- WORLD Mobile more than triple the size of its trial wastewater, Dr. Clayton said. That’s a topic companies in North- staff in less than three years. east Ohio know a lot about, given The Independence-based company, the region’s industrial heritage Company triples in size and its well-publicized struggles which helps businesses manage their to keep the Cuyahoga River and as businesses look for help mobile devices, employs 110 today, up Lake Erie clean. See WATER Page 27 with smart phones, tablets See MOBILE Page 26
CORRECTION THE WEEK IN QUOTES The May 21 “Who’s Who” feature incorrectly stated Third Federal “We either needed to “Even if your mistakes “Everybody’s afraid “I’m bullish on energy. Savings & Loan’s deposits in the prepare to admit a lot are horrible, people that the wrong … Over the long term entry for chairman and CEO Marc A. Stefanski. of students who were want to try it. They president doing the I’m sure it’s a good Third Federal had $6.1 billion in wrong thing can put deposits in 2011 in the Cleveland area likely not going to be say, ‘I want to see investment.” and $8.8 billion companywide. successful ... or we what horrible tastes us back into a — Carina Diamond, managing director, SS&G Wealth Manage- had to get smaller.” like.’” recession.” ment, Solon. I-4 — Craig M. Boise, dean, Cleve- — Celeste Blau, co-owner of The — Kevin Myeroff, CEO of NCA land-Marshall College of Law. Sweet Spot in Lakewood. Page Financial Planners, Mayfield Page One 10 Heights. Page I-1 20120604-NEWS--4-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 10:37 AM Page 1
4 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM JUNE 4 - 10, 2012
PUBLISHER/EDITORIAL DIRECTOR: Brian D.Tucker ([email protected]) EDITOR: Mark Dodosh ([email protected]) MANAGING EDITOR: Scott Suttell ([email protected]) OPINION Switch it arketing counts for plenty when selling groups from outside Northeast Ohio on holding their meetings and conventions in Cleveland. And right now, the commu- Mnity isn’t doing itself any favors by giving its conven- tion center second-banana status in marketing the city’s new meeting complex as the Cleveland Med- ical Mart and Convention Center. At the very least, the names should be switched so that the convention center receives top billing over the medical mart. And serious consideration should FROM THE PUBLISHER be given to changing the “medical mart” part of the name so that it identifies more clearly just what will be going on inside the space that will serve as an A resource for human resource issues adjunct to the convention center portion of the complex that’s rising on Cleveland’s Mall. o, how many times over, say, the ago. It’s free and you can register for it on at all to the Millennials. We’ve wondered from the start why “convention last 12 months have you found our home page at www.crainscleveland To have the best work force, you just center” has come second in the name. Hotels, yourself in something like the .com. might need to manage differently. For restaurants and attractions such as the Rock and following conversation? But the events we’ve held on this topic example, is there technology you can SYOU: “We’ve been trying to fill a also have drawn an interesting mix of employ to bridge the generations? Are Roll Hall of Fame and Museum stand to benefit management job for months now, and we folks from all sorts of industries across you trying to identify values that are most from the dozens upon dozens of meetings the just can’t seem to find great candidates.” Northeast Ohio. Savvy business owners shared across all these generations so they convention hall could host each year as tens of THEM: “I know what you mean. We and HR leaders know that if it’s difficult can pull together? Do you understand thousands of visitors from outside the region spend had a director leave three months now to find good people, it’s what are truths and myths about each their money here. ago, and have tried everything BRIAN going to get far worse as the generation? Cleveland essentially has been out of the convention — recruiters, trade publication TUCKER Baby Boomers continue to On June 21, we will host a breakfast business for two decades, as the city’s old conven- ads, digital job services and the leave the work force. panel that will delve into those questions tion center was an antiquated, pillar-filled structure results are maddening.” We believe a key to keeping and more in an effort to help businesses that many meeting planners bypassed in favor of YOU: “Same with us. And it’s talented employees is learning enlarge their talent pool. And it’s a robust a good job, with a nice salary what makes them tick. And group, consisting of Robert Walker, modern options in other cities. Nearly a half-billion and benefits package.” believe me, it’s more than just a director of Kent State University’s School dollars in Cuyahoga County sales tax money is THEM: “Yeah, same here. With salary and benefits package and of Digital Sciences; Evan Ishida, senior going toward the new trade show complex that will this supposed bad economy interesting work. manager of performance and learning occupy the place where the former convention and high unemployment, how Think about it: For perhaps consulting at Eaton Corp.; and Alan center stood. To get the most bang for those bucks, can there not be more good the first time in American history, Loos, manager of information technology the name that goes on the complex and on promo- people out there?” workplaces are filled with people from at FedEx International. tional materials for it should scream that Cleveland Talent retention and acquisition is a three distinctly different generations, The event at the Ritz Carlton starts with is back in the convention game. problem for all businesses right now, each of which looks at job and career networking from 7 a.m. to 8 a.m., followed The current name doesn’t do that. Rather, it’s cre- and it’s likely to get worse long before it differently than the other. What jazzed by the panel discussion and Q&A. To the Boomers might have little value to register, call 216-771-5158 or visit www ating confusion in the minds of meeting planners gets better. It’s one reason we launched our weekly e-newsletter on staffing and Generation X, and what that crowd cares .crainscleveland.com/breakfast. See you beyond the region, according to Jim Bennett, the human resources issues a few months about in their work might have no meaning there. ■ former McKinsey & Co. consultant whom developer MMPI Inc. recently appointed to oversee the project it’s building. As representatives of MMPI and Positively Cleve- LETTERS land — the city’s convention and visitors bureau — go out to sell Cleveland as a meeting place, they “really find (the current name) unhelpful,” Mr. Up with second chances at employment Bennett told Crain’s editorial board last month. Also unhelpful is the medical mart name, given ■ I would like to thank Brad Friedlander from opportunities even long after their Jill Rizika the way that portion of the project is evolving. for the opinions expressed in his May 21 debt to society has been paid. Executive director The medical mart concept envisioned permanent Personal View, “Give criminals another According to a study released in 2010 Towards Employment showrooms leased by medical equipment vendors. employment shot,” and for his track by the Center for Economic and Policy However, the input Mr. Bennett is receiving in record of giving second chances to job Research, in 2008 the U.S. economy was Political centrists minimized applicants with criminal backgrounds. estimated to have lost $57 billion to $65 meetings with health care industry leaders is that At Towards Employment, we have billion in reduced output of goods and ■ My children will never fully appreciate the space should be more than static rooms. Among helped thousands of individuals with services from people with prison records the artistry behind pressing “play” and the possibilities: areas that offer views of the future barriers to employment find and keep due to their lack of employment. Towards “record” on a boombox at the precise of medicine, and others where early-stage biotech jobs. In 2004, we added specific services Employment has sought to ameliorate moment when the DJ stops speaking to companies — both local and from abroad — can for those with criminal backgrounds, this problem by helping ex-offenders tape a favorite song. They will never hear showcase their innovations. and since that time have placed more than prepare for and find employment while a busy signal when dialing their friends. Rather than be enslaved to a concept, the pro- 1,350 individuals with past convictions working with employers to meet their And, they will most likely shave 30 pounds from their backpack loads by ject’s backers should go with the industry flow and in full-time jobs. Mr. Friedlander’s expe- staffing needs. housing millions of pages of textbooks should transform that part of the complex into a rience that people with criminal records Through our combination of services are “often model employees” is shared and employer relationships, we are working on a 10-ounce tablet. “health innovation center” or something similar to by many of our employer partners. to make sure that individuals with crim- I’m OK with this. give it a dynamic flair. The focus should be on making Our participants have a breadth of inal backgrounds have the opportunity What concerns me, as Brian Tucker the investment a success, not on bemoaning the skills and experiences that could be an to take advantage of their second chance thoughtfully wrote about in his May 14 “failure” of the medical mart. asset to many businesses; however, and play a role in improving our local commentary, “Yet another defeat for many with past convictions are barred economy. See LETTERS Page 6 20120604-NEWS--5-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 10:38 AM Page 1
JUNE 4 - 10, 2012 WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 5
THE BIG ISSUE Has the environment downtown changed — for better or worse — since the casino opened in May?
700 W. St. Clair Ave., Suite 310, Cleveland, OH 44113-1230 Phone: (216) 522-1383 Fax: (216) 694-4264 www.crainscleveland.com
Publisher/editorial director: Brian D. Tucker ([email protected]) Editor: Mark Dodosh ([email protected]) Managing editor: Scott Suttell ([email protected]) TASHA MCCRORY CHRISTOPHER WOODWORTH MICHAEL J. TURNER EMILY BOYLAN Sections editor: Amy Ann Stoessel ([email protected]) Cleveland Cleveland Cleveland (and an Americab Cleveland Assistant editor: I think it’s changed for the better. The I think since the casino opened, the driver for 23 years) I’ve noticed a difference just as far as Joel Hammond ([email protected]) police are patrolling a lot more, the downtown atmosphere has improved, I really think it’s changed for the better, police and security, specifically around Sports Senior reporter: atmosphere is a lot better and the especially with people taking the oppor- not only because it’s better for my the casino. ... It’s definitely a lot more Stan Bullard ([email protected]) hotels are filled. They’re booked for, tunity to attend events downtown and business, it’s better for the city. It busy. But I think that it’s been a posi- Real estate and construction like, months in advance. then also going to the casino. ... But makes the city look more vibrant at tive change as far as businesses Reporters: the big question is, is this short term? night, makes it look alive. booming everywhere down Euclid. Jay Miller ([email protected]) Government Chuck Soder ([email protected]) Technology Dan Shingler ([email protected]) Energy, steel and automotive Tim Magaw ([email protected]) Health care and education Michelle Park ([email protected]) Finance Ginger Christ ([email protected]) Manufacturing, marketing and retailing Research editor: a portfolio company of a portfolio company of Deborah W. Hillyer ([email protected]) Cartoonist/illustrator: Rich Williams Industrial Sands has acquired Marketing director: has been acquired by Lori Grim ([email protected]) has been acquired by has been acquired by an affiliate of Marketing/Events manager: Christian Hendricks ([email protected]) Marketing/Events coordinator: Jessica Snyder ([email protected]) Advertising sales manager: Nicole Mastrangelo ([email protected]) Senior account executive: Sell-Side Advisor Sell-Side Advisor Sell-Side Advisor Buy-Side Advisor Adam Mandell ([email protected]) Account executives: Dawn Donegan ([email protected]) Andy Hollander ([email protected]) Lindsey Nordloh ([email protected]) Office coordinator: Toni Coleman ([email protected]) Digital strategy and development has received funding from has sold manager: Stephen Herron ([email protected]) HMR Acquisition Company, Inc. Web/Print production director: has been acquired by Craig L. Mackey ([email protected]) Production assistant/video editor: has completed a Steven Bennett ([email protected]) control recapitalization $75 Million to Graphic designer: Private Equity Lauren M. Rafferty ([email protected]) Placement Billing: Susan Jaranowski, 313-446-6024 ([email protected]) Sell-Side Advisor Financial Advisor Sell-Side Advisor Sell-Side Advisor Credit: Todd Masura, 313-446-6097 ([email protected]) Audience development manager: Erin Miller ([email protected]) Crain Communications Inc. Keith E. Crain: Chairman Delivering results Rance Crain: President Merrilee Crain: Secretary We know that successful, long-term business relationships depend upon delivering Mary Kay Crain: Treasurer results for our clients. William A. Morrow: At KeyBanc Capital Markets,® more than 500 professionals leverage extensive industry Executive vice president/operations Brian D. Tucker: Vice president knowledge, equity and debt capital markets expertise, and a leading merger and Robert C. Adams: acquisition advisory practice to deliver strategic solutions that help our clients Group vice president capitalize on opportunities. technology, circulation, manufacturing Paul Dalpiaz: Chief Information Officer Dave Kamis: Vice president/production & manufacturing
G.D. Crain Jr. Founder (1885-1973) Mrs. G.D. Crain Jr. Chairman (1911-1996)
Subscriptions: In Ohio: 1 year - $64, 2 year - $110. Outside Ohio: 1 year - $110, 2 year - $195. Single copy, $2.00. Allow 4 weeks for change of address. For subscription information and delivery concerns send correspondence to Audience Development Department, To learn more visit key.com/m&a. Crain’s Cleveland Business, 1155 Gratiot Avenue, Detroit, Michigan, 48207-2912, or email to custom- [email protected], or call 877-812-1588 Offices in Atlanta, Boston, Charlotte, Chicago, Cleveland, Dallas, (in the U.S. and Canada) or (313) 446-0450 (all other locations), or fax 313-446-6777. Houston, Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco and Seattle Reprints: Call 1-800-290-5460 Ext. 125 Audit Bureau of Circulation KeyBanc Capital Markets is a trade name under which corporate and investment banking products and services of KeyCorp and its subsidiaries, KeyBanc Capital Markets Inc., Member NYSE/ FINRA/SIPC, and KeyBank National Association (“KeyBank N.A.”), are marketed. Securities products and services are offered by KeyBanc Capital Markets Inc. and its licensed securities representatives, who may also be employees of KeyBank N.A. Banking products and services are offered by KeyBank N.A. Key.com is a federally registered service mark of KeyCorp. ©2012 KeyCorp ADL4982 20120604-NEWS--6-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 2:48 PM Page 1
6 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM JUNE 4 - 10, 2012 Film credit extension awaits Kasich By JAY MILLER “We have a lot of people who want the available credit will help build [email protected] to come to here,” Mr. Schwartz said businesses that cater to the film and during an interview May 24 in his video industry and will convince The expected extension of the state Caxton Building office overlooking people who aspire to careers in front film tax credit that wooed produc- Progressive Field. “But people are of or behind the cameras to stay here. tion of this summer’s blockbuster waiting; they’re going to go where Mr. Schwarz added that the movie, “The Avengers,” to Cleveland they can get a tax credit.” “Avengers” experience will be a valu- should help boost the region’s embry- The legislation passed the Ohio able tool he can use to sell the region. onic film industry. House May 24 and awaits the gover- “It was amazing to watch how the As he waited in late May for the nor’s signature. A spokeswoman for city came together to make this hap- Legislature to move House Bill 508 Gov. Kasich said last Thursday, May pen,” he said. “There is no other city in — one of three pieces of legislation 31, that the bill reached the governor the United States that would have that make up Gov. John Kasich’s the previous day and is under review done what we did. It showed we are mid-term budget update — Ivan by his policy staff. He has 10 working capable of a ‘can-do’ approach.” Schwarz, executive director of the days to sign the bill. In advance of the new legislation, Greater Cleveland Film Commis- HB 508 increases the amount of the film commission contracted with sion, was planning a trip later this tax credit available to film makers to Cleveland State University for a month to Los Angeles to see which $20 million a year from $10 million study of the industry’s impact in the movie productions he can bring to for the next two years. Mr. Schwarz state. That study looked at 16 movie Northeast Ohio in the next two years. said the extension and doubling of projects filmed in the Cleveland area over the last three years and found that for every dollar in tax credit awarded, the film companies returned $1.20 into the state’s economy and provided a total of $35.5 million in labor income. ■ LETTERS continued from PAGE 4 political reason,” is that with every election cycle more and more centrist leaders are falling prey to the extremist fringes of their respective parties. My former boss, U.S. Sen. Richard Lugar of Indiana, was the most recent political victim. In a statement following his primary defeat, Sen. Lugar clearly and elo- quently reminded the country that “bipartisanship is not the opposite of principle.” Is anyone listening? I’m willing to put my nostalgia for the NFL before free agency and riding bicycles sans helmet to rest. However, I don’t believe that we are progressing as a society when we encourage our children to design only in black or white rather than appreciating the many shades of grey that exist between their beliefs and the beliefs of others. This is not a problem unique to politics, though it may be best observed in that arena. Rather, this culture of ideological inflexibility is prevalent in every industry. We have all witnessed the damage that “group-think” can inflict on an organization. Yet how many of our organizations overtly or tacitly promulgate this type of activity? Our leaders, both public and private, need to teach our children how to develop their own ideas and opinions. They need to show them that the world is far more complex and nuanced than that which exists only in their minds or in their parents’ home. They need to demonstrate that it’s OK to seek out new things. It’s right to ask good questions. And, ideas conflicting with their own are neither “better” nor “worse” categorically. They are simply “different” and valu- able data points of reference for forming new thoughts. True leadership is teaching younger generations how to listen to and study differing ideologies to develop their own ability to think critically. The purpose is not to draw a box around their own beliefs, but to help affirm or adapt them appropriately. I hope that the pendulum will swing and centrism will once again be en vogue. I hope that society will, at some point soon, embrace the value of reaching across the aisle in pursuit of the greater good. We’ve resurrected other ideas from earlier generations. Wouldn’t this be one worthy of borrowing?
John Znidarsic University Heights 20120604-NEWS--7-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 2:46 PM Page 1
JUNE 4 - 10, 2012 WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 7
WHO TO UH’s Ahuja center ahead of operating estimate WATCH IN The idea behind Ahuja, Mr. Zenty warranted a situation — and Ahuja HEALTH CARE Chagrin Highlands location offers broader said, was to ease the commute for is a strong example of this — where patients in the eastern suburbs who they’re starting to snatch up the We’re looking to profile some of footprint, draws ‘very favorable’ payer mix frequented the system’s modestly northern tier of that Akron market,” the region’s health care up-and- sized hospitals in Bedford and Rich- Mr. Ryan said. comers in “Who to Watch: Health By TIMOTHY MAGAW about 44% of its patients carrying mond Heights but found it difficult Care,” a special section slated for [email protected] commercial insurance, another 44% to travel to Case Medical Center for Proceeding with caution publication July 16. enrolled in Medicare and the rest more acute care. Also, Ahuja has When Ahuja opened in March If you think you know who will be Despite a tepid economy and paying out of pocket or with Medic- helped draw new patients into the 2011, it employed about 400 people, among those leading the Northeast the region’s population stagnation, aid. system from the south. but that number has grown to about Ohio health care scene of the University Hospitals’ roughly 1-year- To keep Ahuja’s engine humming, “It’s given us that broader foot- 700. Also, the adjacent medical future, drop an email to sections old, $298 million Ahuja Medical Ms. Juris has been tasked with print because we also now have a pavilion that was relatively empty editor Amy Ann Stoessel, astoessel Center in Beachwood is on solid cementing the medical center’s rep- large number of patients coming during the opening since has filled. @crain.com, or call 216-771-5155. financial footing and is shoring up utation as the community hospital from Medina and Akron,” Mr. Zenty Long-term plans at Ahuja call for Please send your suggestions by the health system’s presence in of choice in the area it serves. Part said. “A number of physicians we have two more patient towers on the Monday, June 18. Cleveland’s eastern suburbs. of that job includes expanding pro- in those communities are referring medical center’s 53-acre campus. There are no hard and fast Ahuja achieved a positive operating gramming, such as wellness semi- to Ahuja because it’s an exquisite But given mounting concerns requirements for possible inclusion margin in the first quarter of 2012 — nars and health screenings. facility. facing the health care field, espe- in this section other than that the more than a year earlier than antic- “We have to come to life in the “Ahuja has allowed us to continue cially at the federal level, Mr. Zenty candidate needs to exhibit the kind ipated — and is helping fuel Univer- community,” she said. “We’re brand our strategy where our goal is to wouldn’t speculate when construc- of potential that makes him or her sity Hospitals’ market growth. The new. People need to know we’re here.” bring world-class health care closest tion would start, or whether it may someone to watch in the health health system saw a 9% hike in to where people live,” he said. happen at all. care field. inpatient discharges in the first Zenty: It’s paying off Bill Ryan, president of the Center “We’re doing well and still have Also, mark your calendars and quarter of 2012 over the like period Ahuja is the first new hospital for Health Affairs, an advocacy group some capacity,” he said. “We want keep thinking about the region’s last year, while the entire market built in Cuyahoga County in three representing area hospitals, said a to make sure to be judicious.” future leaders, as this is the third stomached a slight decrease. decades and is the crown jewel of component of University Hospitals’ Mr. Zenty said UH is paying par- of these sections in 2012: “Who to In the 10 months Ahuja was open University Hospitals’ sprawling $1.2 strategy with Ahuja and its other ticular attention to potential ramifi- Watch: Law” will publish Nov. last year, patient volume totaled billion construction initiative, Vision Vision 2010 investments was to cations of the coming presidential 26. 11,700 at the 144-bed hospital that sits 2010, which launched in 2006. The solidify its rank as the second- election and the impending U.S. off Interstate 271 at Chagrin High- initiative also includes the $260 largest health system in the region, Supreme Court ruling on the consti- lands. That number, which includes million Seidman Cancer Center near behind the Cleveland Clinic. tutionality of President Barack stable outlook on its $831 million in surgeries and inpatient stays, is the system’s flagship hospital, Case Also, Mr. Ryan said University Obama’s expansive health care over- outstanding debt. Moody’s also rec- expected to climb to 20,600 for all of Medical Center in Cleveland, and Hospitals’ investments could help haul. ognized the success of University 2012 if the current momentum keeps new community health centers in stave off pressure from Summa “There is a lot of uncertainty in Hospitals’ expansion strategy, noting up, said Susan Juris, who signed on as Concord Township, Medina and Health System’s march north from the health care world,” Mr. Zenty that “the benefits of which are apparent Ahuja’s president last December. Twinsburg. Akron into the Medina market, where said. “We have no plans for any in growing market share and rev- “We’re off to a roaring start for University Hospitals CEO Tom Summa opened a health center in expansion right now.” enue which we expect to continue.” 2012,” Ms. Juris said. Zenty said in an interview that by all fall 2010 and an emergency depart- That wait-and-see attitude was “This is a multifactor strategy Ms. Juris said the medical center’s accounts the system’s investments ment in late 2011. recognized by Moody’s Investors we’ve put together,” Mr. Zenty said. balance sheet has been buoyed by — the largest in its more than 150- “It’s solidified (University Hospi- Service, which in April affirmed “Our plan is working exactly as we a “very favorable” payer mix, with year history — are paying off. tals’) market share, and it may have the health system’s A2 rating and had designed it.” ■ 20120604-NEWS--8-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 6/1/2012 3:57 PM Page 1
8 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM JUNE 4 - 10, 2012 Developers fear Clean Ohio changes Congratulations “We would have never started the the flexibility to redevelop contam- DAMON A. FRANGOS If altered, brownfield project without brownfield money inated properties without end users USA Parking Systems, Inc is happy to for it,” Mr. Geis said. He also noted in place will hurt Ohio, he added. program would require that some tenants in the structure, welcome Damon as their in house counsel for which is designed to keep in Cleve- The case of 27 Colman The Frangos Group & USA Parking Systems, Inc. greater impact sooner land spinoff companies from Uni- Consider a project Mr. Davis versity Circle institutions, did not undertook in Cleveland’s Little Italy Best wishes as you begin your new career! By STAN BULLARD exist in 2008 when his team began neighborhood in which a Hemi- [email protected] undertaking the cleanup of the site. sphere affiliate removed 29 under- Congratulations Damon! Mr. Geis’ firm now is undertaking ground fuel storage tanks and Real estate developers and cities its fourth Midtown project. replaced 12 feet of topsoil so the with little virgin land available for “These sites were left for dead 20 land could be redeveloped as com- development are fretting that their years ago,” Mr. Geis said. “As devel- mercial or residential property. efforts to put environmentally tainted opers, we satisfied the (environ- The project got a $900,000 grant properties known as brownfields to mental) requirements to make them from the Clean Ohio Fund and site good use will receive a big blow if the productive. I did not make them work began in 2002. By the time state changes the criteria for how it dirty. I only made them better.” builder Andrew Brickman took over the site in 2008 and transformed it goes about doling out money to aid Why the change? with property cleanups. to sleek, modernist condo suites in Under the state’s Clean Ohio pro- For now, the state’s brownfield a project known as 27 Colman, the gram, developers and cities often could grant program remains in limbo. residential market had gone secure brownfield cleanup money The Kasich administration said through both boom and bust. even if they didn’t have tenants in earlier this year that it will accept no Today, all 27 condos on the site www.thefrangosgroup.com tow to occupy contaminated proper- new applications for brownfield have been sold for prices ranging ties they wanted to remediate. How- remediation under the Clean Ohio from $300,000 to $600,000 apiece. ever, Kasich administration officials Fund because state liquor profits “That points out the dramatic are indicating the state in the future that financed the program have impact of this program,” Mr. Davis will put an emphasis on issuing been shifted to JobsOhio, a private said. “The site had not been devel- cleanup money to projects that are entity Gov. John Kasich has entrusted oped because of the storage tanks. likely to produce jobs sooner than later. with shepherding economic devel- Without Clean Ohio, it would still Fred Geis, a member of the Geis opment efforts statewide. house storage tanks.” Cos. development firm in Streets- Laura Jones, spokeswoman for Maintaining the availability of boro who makes urban real estate JobsOhio, said the brownfield policy brownfield grants is a top issue with projects his personal mission, calls for JobsOhio is still under develop- NAIOP Northern Ohio, a trade the potential move a “crippling ment but is likely to include pro- group representing industrial and decision” that would harm urban grams offering grants — which office property owners, said Scott redevelopment, particularly by job- cities, developers and private prop- McCready, its president. NAIOP creating small businesses. erty owners prize — and revolving argues that grants rather than loans “We have been in development loans. Criteria for issuing loans and give private interests more incen- since 1967 but did our first brown- grants are not set, but Ms. Jones said tive to tackle blighted sites; it also field project three years ago,” Mr. the key change will be to require says the grant program has proven Geis said. “If it took us that long as a brownfield money to go where it it can attract private investment. developer to take on the liability, the can produce jobs the quickest. Brad Beckert, the city of Akron’s challenge and the learning curve to The change is a response to limited economic development engineering do a brownfield, how long do you state resources, Ms. Jones said. manager, said his city also is against think it will take a corporate middle Todd Davis, a nationally known changing the brownfield program. manager or a small business to do it?” brownfield legal expert and CEO of He worries about what it would In 2011, the Geis and Coyne families Hemisphere Development LLC of mean for small businesses that did the unheard of by putting Mid- Bedford, which redevelops tainted want to do modest expansions, town Technology Park, a suburban- properties, said it may seem sensible such as a company that wants to style office-warehouse building, to increase job requirements as a expand on a former dry cleaning smack in the middle of the city at condition of receiving a brownfield operation’s site next door. 7000 Euclid Ave. in Cleveland’s Mid- grant or loan. Nonetheless, Mr. Mr. Beckert also is concerned town neighborhood. The technology Davis said he believes the change is about the state doing away with park, regarded as a poster child for “going to stop brownfield develop- brownfield grants. He said Akron urban redevelopment, received a ment in its tracks in Ohio.” has found no takers for its brown- $750,000 Clean Ohio grant as part of People willing to spend money field redevelopment loan program, its financing. on real estate developments with a financed by a $1 million federal The project had no tenants at the brownfield component will gravi- grant. He expects the state would outset. The 128,000-square-foot tate to states with more generous find a similar lack of enthusiasm for a building is now 90% occupied. programs, Mr. Davis said. Losing brownfield loan program. ■
Gotham: Firm pushes for new terms EXCEPTIONAL LOUDONVILE FACILITY AVAILABLE FOR LEASE continued from PAGE 3 out of the region or sought less the compression of rents during the more lucrative markets. Duke sold expensive offices. Statistics from downturn. three office buildings in North Olm- online realty data provider CoStar Mr. King said the portfolio is sted last year but continues to own tell the tale: Vacancy in the Gotham making some payments on the 11 office buildings in Cleveland’s King portfolio is now 12% compared mortgage from cash flow, though not south suburbs that it has been unable to a mind-bogglingly low 2% at the the required monthly payment. to peddle. time of the purchase. For the first time, Mr. King The Gotham King portfolio includes Steve Egar, owner of the Egar revealed last week that he sold his newer office buildings, such as Metro- Associates brokerage in Beachwood, ownership stake in the portfolio politan Plaza and One Harvard said if Orix succeeds in wresting con- prior to the commercial downturn, Crossing in Highland Hills, as well as trol of the properties from Gotham although he declined to say specifi- others dating to the 1980s, such King in the court action, the next cally when he did so. He continues as Corporate Circle I, II and III in choice it faces would be a hard one: to manage the portfolio. Pepper Pike. hold the buildings or sell them. Mr. Charles Ishay, a Gotham principal Alec Pacella, a senior vice presi- Egar estimates that if the buildings named personally in the lawsuit, 0(5,//$7&2857/28'219,//(2+ 0,&+$(/-2&&+,21(52 PLFKDHORFFKLRQHUR#RPFOHFRP dent of the NAI Daus brokerage in were sold at today’s rates, they declined comment on the foreclo- 7RWDO6)$YDLODEOH 'LUHFW ZZZRVWHQGRUIPRUULVFRP Beachwood, called the Gotham King would go for half the prior price. sure action, though he said he later ¶&OHDU+HLJKW purchase “far and away the most In an interview last Thursday, May may discuss the litigation. Gotham 'RFNV expensive suburban office sale on a 31, Mr. King said Gotham King is Realty Holdings has a substantial 'ULYH,QV per-square-foot basis.” Comparable continuing to negotiate for new loan portfolio of holdings ranging from 3DUWQHULQJZLWK 2ZQHU2FFXSLHG3URSHUW\ +DO0D[ÀHOG&&,06,25 sales at the time were about 20% terms despite the foreclosure filing. New York to Chicago, according to KDOPD[¿HOG#KDOPD[¿HOGFRP less, he said. Mr. King maintains the portfolio’s its website. :HW6SULQNOHU 3KRQH +HDY\3RZHU ZZZKDOPD[¿HOGFRP Then the worst recession in vacancy was higher at its purchase Three calls to Orix were not than CoStar suggests, putting it returned by Crain’s deadline last Fri- 'LYLVLEOHWR6) decades wreaked unexpected havoc on the office market, driving up instead in the 7% range, but he day. Orix’s Cleveland attorney, Michael vacancies as tenants failed, pulled agrees the price was too high given Shuster, declined comment. ■ 20120604-NEWS--9-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 5/31/2012 1:49 PM Page 1
JUNE 4 - 10, 2012 WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS 9 In survey, Indians gauge appetite for new premium seats
park, what mix of premium seats Proposal would resemble club area, but would it have? How many suites?,” Mr. Shapiro said in April. playing field would be visible from lounge In addition to its club seat research, the Indians already have repurposed By JOEL HAMMOND that the survey questions are part of a number of the stadium’s suites: In [email protected] the Indians’ usual communications 2008, the team combined four suites with key stakeholders. into the Champions Suite, which can The Cleveland Indians are gauging The Indians conducted similar be rented on a per-game basis customers’ opinions of a new pre- research last October about club-level and holds up to 60 fans. One suite mium lounge at Progressive Field seating at Progressive Field. Before between first base and home plate that would continue the team’s this season began, the team lowered now is known as the “Fan Cave,” repurposing of the stadium’s suites. club seat prices — to a range of $55 complete with a billiards table and According to a stadium map to $65 from a range of $80 to $100 — flat-screen televisions. Another is included in a survey sent to premium and made aesthetic improvements home to the Indians Social Suite, ticket buyers, the lounge would to the club seats. where influential social media users encompass about eight suites either Various options for the premium gather for games. on the first-base side of home plate, lounge are listed in the survey, and In May, the Indians unveiled their adjacent to the stadium’s press box, respondents are asked whether they Kids Clubhouse, a new children’s or further down the left-field line, would renew in their current seats play area in right field that provides adjacent to the current Champions or opt for the premium lounge children a place to roam while par- Suite. It would seat 80 to 100 and, scenario presented in the survey. ents can see the action on the field.
unlike the team’s club level, would Pricing options vary from $100 for a PHOTO COURTESY OF THE CLEVELAND INDIANS The team converted a number of include views of the field from dining premium all-inclusive buffet with A youngster enjoys the grand opening of the Cleveland Indians’ new “Kids Club- suites to form the 10,000-square-foot areas, according to the survey. alcohol included to $125 for pay-as- house” at Progressive Field in May. The Indians repurposed about a half-dozen area. The club level, located in the you-go food with no alcohol included suites to for the play area for kids, an ongoing effort to turn unused areas of the Progressive Field, which opened second deck along the first-base line, to $150 for the same premium all- ballpark into profit. in 1994, was built with 121 suites, at also features a climate-controlled inclusive buffet and alcohol. one point the second-most in the lounge and all-inclusive food, but The survey also asks whether In April, the Indians hired former Shapiro said Mr. Robbins would be majors behind the Texas Rangers’ its lounge is set back from the field. customers would be more likely to Cleveland Browns ticket sales man- charged not only with increasing Ballpark at Arlington. In 2010, the The Indians note in the survey commit to multiple years of premium ager Ryan Robbins, who then was sales now, but also mapping out Indians began offering a free suite that the premium lounge concepts lounge seats if price certainty was with the Oakland Raiders, as their strategies for the future of the pre- rental — valued between $2,000 to are “hypothetical; the Indians have included in their purchase. new director of premium seating. At mium areas. $6,500 — for new and renewing season not committed to providing any of the time, Indians president Mark “If we were going to build a ball- ticket holders. ■ the concepts” contained in the A work in progress survey. Curtis Danburg, the team’s The Indians continue to investi- senior director of communications, gate ways to make little-used parts said last week the lounge concept is of Progressive Field — often the most “in its infancy and the team is expensive territory at the ballpark simply testing the waters,” adding — more profitable or fan friendly.
Clinic spinoff installs rare, powerful imaging machine 3-D microscope used by Renovo Neural in demand
By CHUCK SODER the Ohio Third Frontier economic [email protected] development program, Renovo was formed to commercialize technology Diego Bohórquez, a post-doctoral developed by Drs. Bruce Trapp and fellow at Duke University, is looking Wendy Macklin at the Cleveland for “a needle in a haystack on the Clinic. moon.” They developed cell-based formulas Renovo Neural Inc. has a powerful designed to identify multiple sclerosis new tool that could help him find drugs and test their effectiveness, it. The Cleveland Clinic spinoff, and they figured out how to create founded in 2008 to develop and test multiple sclerosis-like brain damage multiple sclerosis drugs, has begun in animals, Dr. Medicetty said, noting leasing an extremely rare 3-D elec- that the company tests drugs on tron microscope that is proving animals at the Clinic. Renovo also popular with researchers who study aims to develop ways to test treat- other medical conditions and bodily ments for stroke, Parkinson’s disease functions. and other conditions, he said. Without it, Dr. Bohórquez would Drug development still is in the have a much harder time finding the company’s long-term plans but has elusive neural synapses that allow taken a back seat to generating the intestines to sense food and reg- revenue from the company’s drug ulate appetite. testing services, which are used by “With this technology, we are pharmaceutical companies, and tissue able to reconstruct a whole network imaging services made possible by of neurons,” Dr. Bohórquez said. the Sigma VP-3View, Dr. Medicetty The 3-D electron microscope — said. Renovo Neural, which employs the third Sigma VP-3View system to nine people full time and two part be installed in the United States — time, aims to turn a profit this year, can cut a block of tissue into dozens he said. However, he would not pro- of layers and provide detailed images vide sales figures. of each one, said Renovo Neural Renovo Neural is the first company CEO Satish Medicetty. By contrast, to use the Sigma VP-3View system to a traditional electron microscope provide a service, said Joel Mancuso, can scan only one slice at a time. applications manager for Gatan Inc. “Time and cost wise, this tech- of Pleasanton, Calif., which devel- nology makes a huge difference,” he oped the system with Carl Zeiss said. Microscopy LLC of Thorn-wood, N.Y. There is a four-week wait to use Mr. Mancuso said he knows of no the 3-D electron microscope, which similar electron microscope. would have cost about $700,000 to “Renovo is really in position to buy, Dr. Medicetty said. make it the norm,” Mr. Mancuso With the help of $3 million from said. ■ 20120604-NEWS--10-NAT-CCI-CL_-- 5/31/2012 2:32 PM Page 1
10 CRAIN’S CLEVELAND BUSINESS WWW.CRAINSCLEVELAND.COM JUNE 4 - 10, 2012 In time for summer, Cleveland’s menu for frozen treats expands
twice before you decide to come into As popularity grows, so does number of stores our neighborhood,’” Mr. Stark said. Stark Enterprises’ experience in By GINGER CHRIST of the last seven years and should negotiating leases, identifying real [email protected] rise for the foreseeable future, estate and drafting building plans according to IBISWorld Inc., a Cali- enables it to open stores faster than Frozen yogurt is hot. fornia-based market research firm. mom-and-pop shops, Mr. Stark said. Just ask the Bechke family, owners Frozen yogurt retail store revenue While the company’s plans are to of the Lemonberry frozen yogurt rose 2.8% in 2011 to $723.1 million, expand in northern Ohio and nearby chain. They plan to add a fourth according to IBISWorld, which fore- markets such as Pittsburgh and Erie, store to the shops they operate in casts a 2.9% gain in 2012. Pa., Mr. Stark isn’t dismissing the Brecksville, Medina and Strongsville. Bob Stark, president and CEO of idea of acquiring franchise rights for MCKINLEY WILEY Husband-and-wife team John Stark Enterprises Inc., a Cleveland- other states. The Lemonberry yogurt chain — with co-owner Joy Bechke (center) and daugh- and Joy Bechke, who run their based real estate development “It certainly piques our interest in ters Lindy Bechke (left) and Kari Bechke-Algaier pictured here — plan to add yogurt shops with the help of their company, sees a relatively limitless thinking about how we could do this soon a fourth store to their roster. two daughters, in 2010 debuted one market for frozen yogurt. in other markets,” Mr. Stark said. of the first self-serve yogurt shops in Mr. Stark initially approached Menchie’s main man and plans to have doubled that which to create a sundae. the area with the Strongsville store. Menchie’s as a potential tenant for number by the end of this year, said Lemonberry, for one, offers cus- In the two years since, the local Mr. Stark’s company, Yogurt Treats the developer’s Ohio retail properties. Kelly Wherley, Lam Ho operations tomers more than 60 toppings — frozen yogurt scene has exploded, LLC, is the northern Ohio franchisee However, the more Mr. Stark learned manager. fruits, cereals, nuts and chocolates with stores popping up throughout for Menchie’s Frozen Yogurt. It about the frozen yogurt chain, the “Although we receive many — and rotates 50 flavors among its Northeast Ohio. opened its first store last summer more taken he became with the inquiries from (retail) centers around three stores. “I think it’s getting saturated to a on Chagrin Boulevard in Woodmere, concept. the country, we have to be selective “It’s an experience to do it your- certain point,” John Bechke said, and since has added another 10 Neighbors, and rivals of where we choose to go,” Ms. self,” John Bechke said. “You can though he maintains there remains Menchie’s to the area. Wherley said. “We want to grow, but make it as healthy as you want or as “room for growth from competition.” It is on course to open another six Yogurt Vi, a fro-yo chain owned by it has to be controlled.” large as you want.” Frozen yogurt, known to aficiona- by July and 14 by the end of the Maumee-based Lam Ho Enterprises Ms. Wherley said she doesn’t Customers pay by the ounce at dos as fro-yo, has risen in popularity year. Mr. Stark wants Menchie’s to Inc., opened its first store more than think the Northeast Ohio market is self-serve shops, with total costs nationwide. become the McDonald’s of the local a year ago on the campus of the Uni- oversaturated with fro-yo shops. typically $4 to $7. Revenues from fro-yo stores fro-yo market. versity of Cincinnati. The company “We believe that the market still has increased in the aggregate in each “We say to the competition, ‘Think had four stores by the end of 2011 opportunities, and because of how So, how does horrible taste? we operate our business, we know The growing presence of these that there is always room for the frozen yogurt shops doesn’t go next Yogurt Vi,” said Ms. Wherley, unnoticed by other sellers of frozen whose company opened a store last treats. Celeste Blau opened The Sweet month in the Greens of Strongsville Spot on Detroit Avenue in Lakewood shopping center, less than a quar- last July with four family members. ter-mile from the Bechke family’s She opted to open a gelato store in Oglebay Means Business! Lemonberry store. part due to the number of ice cream Yogurt Vi stores all feature bright shops in the area. Gelato is similar to colors and wireless Internet; some ice cream but has less butterfat. have either flat-screen TVs showing “I think of our competition as not music videos or surround sound just gelato companies,” Ms. Blau said. music systems. “I definitely think that if there Ms. Wherley said despite requests weren’t as many frozen yogurt shops to franchise the chain, Yogurt Vi out there, we would do better.” stores remain corporate-owned. But Ms. Blau isn’t complaining. However, the company might con- The gelato shop has had a successful More than a hundred years ago, Earl W. Oglebay established a tradition of generous sider franchising in the future. first year, increasing business as hospitality at his summer estate. Today, Oglebay Resort continues that tradition with “This has allowed us to control months pass and the company’s our name, our reputation and our reputation spreads. extraordinary facilities and amenities, in a picturesque natural setting, ensuring your next brand,” said Ms. Wherley, whose The gelato store changes its flavors meeting will be both memorable and successful. company also has stores in Legacy based on the seasons and coming Village in Lyndhurst and Great events. For example, the store, which Northern Mall in North Olmsted, and only uses fresh, local ingredients, soon will launch stores at Belden will start serving raspberry gelato Village Mall in Canton and at Kent once the fruit comes into season at State University. Rosby Berry Farm in Brooklyn Heights. Ms. Blau said customers enjoy Nuts to you testing the shop’s flavor experi- Mr. Stark has a simple explanation ments, even ones that flop. Take the for the popularity of the frozen treat. new black sesame flavor, which Ms. “It’s a health food. It tastes great,” Blau admits is “horrible.” he said. “Even if your mistakes are horri- A number of frozen yogurt shops ble, people want to try it. They say, also are self-serve, offering customers ‘I want to see what horrible tastes • 271-room Wilson Lodge Check our dozens of flavors and toppings with like,’” she said. ■ • Premium cottages &