8 Barne Barton
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PLYMOUTH SUSTAINABLE NEIGHBOURHOODS STUDY Criteria notes in red gives a summary of guidance only – refer to notes above for full guidance. KEY: How well does the neighbourhood achieve the objective? Good Makes a significant contribution Moderate Makes some direct or significant contribution Poor Does not contribute to the objective Neighbourhood Area: 8 Barne Barton Objective Achieves Comments Options for Consideration objective? 1. A community with thriving mixed use centres. A sustainable neighbourhood should have clear & identifiable local & neighbourhood centres, with access to jobs, education, healthcare, leisure, retail and public transport & open space. 1.1 Is there a range of community facilities, consistent with the neighbourhood The facilities of Barne Barton consist of three Consider ways of bringing in a further range of population? convenience stores, a second hand shop, essential amenities and facilities that can be Criteria: community centre and resource centre, used as meeting places for all ages. Facilities include shops, religious meeting places, community halls, scout takeaways, two primary schools and a police huts etc. office. The post office has closed and is now a Encourage developments that provide for a convenience store with sub post office. There are religious meeting place, a public house, health no district or city facilities in Barne Barton. There facilities, sports facilities, local employment are no shops in the central area no pub or café, no business premises, no church, no health facilities and restricted access to sports facilities. These facilities are too few for the population of 4,140. Some of the missing facilities are provided by the district centre of St Budeaux on the outskirts of Barne Barton, this supplies neighbourhood and district facilities such as banks, a library, pubs and churches. 1.2 Are community facilities grouped to create identifiable local & There are two identifiable local centres within Consider strengthening local centres by locating neighbourhood centres? Barne Barton: future facilities in the existing centres to • Miers Close: local centre, which consists reinforce their identity. of a convenience store, Tamar View Community Complex, a police office and a Miers Close: local centre consider adding more community resource centre. facilities to strengthen this and turn it into a small • Barne Road: local centre, which has a neighbourhood centre. convenience store, second hand shop and take away restaurant. Consider creating a sense of arrival for Barne Barton at the junction of Barne Road/Wolseley Road gateway to the settlement. 1.3 Are the current catchment populations sufficient to support the local & The current population of Barne Barton is 4,140, Look at ways of bringing more facilities into neighbourhood centres? which could support a small neighbourhood centre Barne Barton to provide the community with Criteria: or two local centres. The population is too great for more support. Local centres - pop.2,000 – 5,000 (av. 3,500) the amount of existing facilities in the Neighbourhood centres - pop. 5,000-9,000 (av. 7,000) neighbourhood. Based on 1692 households, residential density of 31dph and household size of 2.4, actual current catchment populations are approximately: Local centres: • Miers Close has a catchment area of 3ha giving a catchment population of 190. • Barne Road has a catchment area of 5ha giving a catchment population of 406. Neither of the local centres has a large enough population within the recommended walking catchment to sustain it. This is due to the topography of the area, reducing the size of the catchment areas. 1.4 Are people able to work locally? Explore potential of some local live work units as Criteria: 1,706 people (aged 16-74, including unemployed) part of any new developments. • Good – job ratio above 1.0 are economically active in Barne Barton. However, • Moderate – job ratio between 0.7 to 1.0 there are only 433 jobs available within the • Poor – job ratio below 0.7 neighbourhood. This gives a very poor job ratio score of 0.25, one of the lowest for Plymouth. This shows there are little available employment opportunities within the neighbourhood. There is a lack of employment opportunities within Barne Barton as there is little industry in the area and too little facilities to provide a significant amount of employment. The lack of education and training facilities in the area may also contribute to the lack of employment. Employment opportunities would consist of the MoD Naval Base, two primary schools (Bull Point Primary School and Barne Barton Primary School) and the local centres. 1.5 Are education facilities in close proximity to local & neighbourhood centres? There are two primary schools within the There are plans to close these primary schools Criteria: neighbourhood (Bull Point Primary School and and open one new school closer to the local ‘Education facilities’ include crèche, primary schools (junior and infants), Barne Barton Primary School). These schools are centre. secondary schools and tertiary education centres. not located close to the local centres, although there is a pre-school held at the community Look at ways to create good links between the resource centre in the Miers Close local centre. Miers Close local centre and the new primary There is no secondary school or a tertiary school e.g. improved footways, pedestrian education centre within the neighbourhood (as the crossings, public realm etc. population is not big enough to sustain a secondary school). Barne Barton is in the catchment area for Tamarside Community College (in the adjoining neighbourhood of St Budeaux) providing Barne Barton residents with further education. 1.6 Are there places for formal sports, play & informal recreation? There are 2 areas with neighbourhood importance More public provision is required for sports and Criteria: for ‘informal recreation’ (spaces 001 and 002). recreation Open space categories 1 (informal recreation) & 2 (sport and formal There are 3 areas with importance for ‘sport and recreation) and play areas: formal recreation’ (spaces 040 and 141 have city • Good – more than one area of both category 1 & 2, of District or above importance & spaces 038 and 039 have importance, and areas for play. neighbourhood importance). However the majority • Moderate = at least one area of both category 1 & 2, of Neighbourhood of open spaces are owned by the MoD with no or above importance, and at least one play area. open access to the public. Also space 039 is a • Poor = less than one area of both categories 1 & 2. fenced off school playing field and therefore has limited public access. Space 003 has both informal and formal/sports recreation and contains a children’s playground. There is currently no indoor sports facility in Barne Barton that is open to the public. The MoD formerly offered services to naval personnel, and the MoD still retains a large stake in the area with its ownership of sports facilities, clubs and open space. This has resulted in inadequate open space and recreational facilities for many of the local residents. There is a lack of level land upon which people can play ball games. 1.7 Are there places to meet and socialise for all ages & interest groups? There is a lack of meeting places with no pub, There is likely to be a need for additional play Criteria: church, square or religious meeting halls. facilities, facilities for teenagers and young Community centres, shopping centres, pubs, squares and public parks Residents would have to travel into St Budeaux to people, (such as a skate park or basketball within the neighbourhood. find meeting areas in the district centre. The only court) and places to socialise for adults. meeting areas in Barne Barton are the community Consultation with the local population will centre and public parks. The community centre highlight specific community needs. provides a youth club, dance club, bingo etc Look at opportunities to create public spaces throughout the week and acts as a bar on Friday with seating etc for meeting and socialising, and Saturday night. There are also two basketball particularly at local and neighbourhood centres. courts and a skate park, which would serve as a social area for the older children in Barne Barton. Greater community use should be encouraged at the new school. 2. A balanced community A sustainable neighbourhood means a balanced community set within a safe and healthy environment. It should comprise a well- integrated mix of decent homes of different types and tenures to support a range of household sizes, ages and incomes. 2.1 Does existing housing stock provide a range of different tenures and types, No –There are disproportionately high levels of Look at ways to improve the balance of with a good mix of social and private housing? social rented accommodation and little private public/private housing within the neighbourhood. Criteria: housing. 1. Balance of public/ private housing stock Development opportunities within the 2. Mix of different types 1. A very high proportion of the population live in neighbourhood should provide a mix of social housing, 17.8% rent from the Council residential types, in particular detached houses. • Good – Good balance & mix. (compared to the national average of 13.2%) and • Moderate – Average balance & mix. 35.1% rent from Housing Association or New housing developments should be medium • Poor – Poor balance & mix. Registered Social Landlord (compared to 6.0% density to increase the population size although nationally). The proportion of owner occupied some detached housing should be incorporated properties is only 36.9%, which is around half of to increase the diversity of the housing stock. the national average of 68.9%. In the past ten years, the MoD has gradually Consider on-going maintenance to improve the disposed of the majority of its properties in Barne condition of public housing, including external Barton, selling these initially to Plymouth City spaces.