CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI
MINUTES OF 193rd MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE 28.05.2014 AT NEW DELHI
PRESENT
1. Dr. Rashidullah Khan, President I/c Chairman 2. Dr. Amitabh Kumar, Vice-President (Ayurved) Member 3. Dr. V. Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member 4. Dr. V.G. Udayakumar Member 5. Dr. Umesh Shukla Member 6. Dr. Srinivas K. Bannigol Member 7. Dr. Shuhabuddin Member Dr. Shamshad Bano Asstt. Registrar (Unani), CCIM
Special Invitee
1. Dr. Vanitha Muralikumar Member
Following members could not attend the meeting:-
1. Dr. Bhirgupati Pandey Member 2. Dr. Mohd. Shafique Member 3. Dr. B. Muthukumar Member
Agenda Item No. 1. Confirmation of minutes of the 192nd meeting of Executive Committee held on 25.04.2014 at New Delhi.
It was noted that 192nd meeting of Executive Committee & its adjourned meeting was held on 25.04.2014 & 16.05.2014 respectively at New Delhi. The minutes of the same were circulated to all the members of the Executive Committee on 20.05.2014 by email and by speed post vide letter No. 5-1/2014 (192nd EC) dated 21.05.2014 to suggest addition/deletion in respect of correctness of the minutes. However, the minutes, were also placed before the EC at the time of consideration of the same.
Executive Committee confirmed the same.
Agenda Item No. 2. Letter of GOI in respect of Legal Opinion from the Ministry of Law & Justice regarding representation of Deemed Universities in the Statutory Bodies and further notification by GOI in view of Legal Opinion- regarding.
It was noted that a legal opinion has been received from the GOI, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Deptt. of AYUSH regarding representation of Deemed Universities in the Statutory Bodies vide their letter No. A.11019/7/14-EC/CCIM (University Election) dated 01.05.2014. Contents of the letter are as under:-
193ec minutes 1
(a) “ The referring Department seeks to be advised on the issue as to whether all „Deemed Universities‟ are entitled to elect a member from their faculty to represent in CCIM under Section 3(1)(b) of IMCC Act.
(b) Similarly, Section 2(f) of UGC Act,1956 defines „University‟ as under: “ University means a University established or incorporated by or under a Central Act, a Provincial Act or a State Act, and includes any such institution as may, in consultation with the University concerned, be recognized by the Commission in accordance with the regulations made in this behalf under this Act.”
(c) As regards to „Deemed University‟, Section 3 of the UGC Act, 1956 read as under: “The Central Government may, on the advice of the Commission, declare by notification in the official Gazette, that any institution for higher education, other than a University, shall be deemed to be a university for the purposes of this Act, and on such a declaration being made, all the provision of this Act, and on such a declaration being made, all the provisions of this Act, shall apply to such institution as if it were a University within the meaning of clause(f) of section 2.”
(d) According to Section 2(k) of the IMCC Act, „University‟ for the purpose of IMCC Act is a University, which has been established by a law made by the competent legislature. Whereas Deemed Universities are the institutions which have been notified under Section 3 of the UGC Act as Deemed University, and there is no condition that those institutions should have been established by law. Since Deemed Universities are not the Universities established by any law, they cannot be recognized as University for the purpose of “University” under Section 2(k) of IMCC Act.
Hence, no further election shall be conducted from any Deemed University for Central Councils (Statutory Bodies) in the light of opinion rendered by Legal Affairs Department of Ministry of Law & Justice.”
Further, Govt. of India vide Notification No. S.O. 1087(E) dated 15.04.2014 has rescinded the following three Notifications by which Vd. Deodatta S.Bhadlikar (University representative of Padamshree Dr. D.Y. Patil Deemed University, Navi Mumbai), Dr. C. Nagarajan (University representative of Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham University, T.N.) and Dr. B. Sreenivasa Prasad (University representative of KLE University, Belgaum, Karnataka) had become the members of CCIM:- 1. S.O. 1757 (E), dated the 13th July, 2009 published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 3, Sub-section (ii), dated the 16th July, 2009. 2. S.O. 2816 (E), dated the 29th November, 2012 published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 3, Sub-section (ii), dated the 4th December, 2012; and 3. S.O. 188 (E), dated the 16th January, 2013 published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 3, Sub-section (ii), dated the 17th January, 2013.
193ec minutes 2
Since the rescinding of all the three Notifications have come into force at once i.e. with immediate effect from Notification No. 1087 published on 15.04.2014, therefore, all the above three members representing Deemed Universities, may no longer be treated as the members of CCIM.
Executive Committee noted and decided that a letter be written to all the concerned.
Agenda Item No. 3. Visitation of Rama Krishna Ayurvedic Medical College and Research Centre, Bangalore, Karnataka under Section 13C for the session 2014-2015 – regarding.
It was noted that Rama Krishna Ayurvedic Medical College and Research Centre, Bangalore, Karnataka was visited on 27-28.01.2014 by Dr. Jageshwar Prasad Chaurasia and Dr. Basavaraj S. Hiremath. After going through the report it has been observed that part I has not been submitted along with the visitation report.
Executive Committee noted that Part- I has already been received and assessed accordingly with approval of President I/c, CCIM as informed by the office.
Agenda Item No. 4. Regarding visitation to Dharma Ayurveda Medical College, Sriperumbudur (T.N.).
It was noted that an email letter was received dated 21.01.2014 by Dr. Goudar Amaregouda Mahantagouda, Dr. Rajashekhar Ganiger and Dr. Amit Kumar Sharma regarding Visitation of Dharma Ayurveda College, Sriperumbudur, Tamil Nadu for session 2014-15 under Section 13C in respect of denial of college authorities to get the visitation done. The matter alongwith letter of visitors was reported in 187th EC held on 17.02.2014 under Agenda Item No. 8. The decision of EC was as under: “Executive Committee agreed to consider the letter of visitors as report of the College”
Accordingly, the matter of Dharma Ayuvedic College was placed before Screening Committee held on 08.05.2014 and Screening Committee decided not to recommend to GOI for granting permission for the session 2014-15 as college has denied visitation.
Executive Committee agreed to the recommendation of Screening Committee and decided to send the recommendation to Govt. of India.
193ec minutes 3
Agenda Item No. 5. Regarding recommendation of Govt. Ayurved College Dhanwantri Nagar, Taluk Kanayannur, Tripunithura, Kerala under Section 13C.
It was noted that the Screening Committee had given the following recommendation in respect of Govt. Ayurvedic College, Tripunithura, Kerala for academic session 2014-15 :-
Recommended for UG 50 seats & PG in 06 subjects namely:-
1. Shalakya tantra (Shiro Nasa) -04 seats 2. Dravyaguna -04 seats 3. Swasthavritta -04 seats 4. Panchkarma -04 seats 5. Shalya tantra (Samanya) -05 seats 6. Rasashastra & Bhaisajyakalpna-04 seats However, due to typographical error the seats in respect of Rasahastra & Bhaisajyakalpna has been wrongly informed to the 192nd Executive Committee as 06 (instead of 04) seats. Hence, number of seats in the said subject be read as 04 seats.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Agenda Item No. 6. Regarding recommendation of S.R.M Govt. Ayurvedic College, Bansmandi, Bareilly, Uttar Pardesh and Govt. Ayurvedic College, Jalukbari, Gawahi under Section 13C.
It was noted that due to typographical error in the minutes of Screening Committee, visitation reports of S.R.M. Govt. Ayurvedic College, Bansmandi, Bareilly, U.P. and Government Ayurvedic College, Jalukbari, Guwahati under Section 13C, the number of seats recommended for UG was mentioned as 50 and 60 respectively instead of 40 and 50 seats as sanctioned by GOI.
Therefore, the seats as reported to 189th EC in respect of these two colleges be read as 40 seats (in case of S.R.M. Govt. Ayurvedic College, Bansmandi, Bareilly, U.P.) and 50 seats (in case of Government Ayurvedic College, Jalukbari, Guwahati) respectively.
Further, it was informed that the recommendations of these two colleges as per actual sanctioned seats by GOI have been sent with the approval of President I/c, CCIM.
Executive Committee noted the same.
193ec minutes 4
Agenda Item No. 7. Regarding recommendation received from Director, AYUSH, Bangalore to carry over system to BAMS Students.
It was noted that a letter No. AYUSH/61/DEV (2)/2013-14 dated 22.02.2014 from the Director of AYUSH, Bangalore, Karnataka regarding recommendation to carry over system to BAMS students and forwarding therewith a letter of Registrar, Rajiv Gandhi University Health Sciences, Karnataka, Bangalore dated 17.02.2014. As per the letter, the above said University conducted the Ist BAMS professional examination as per the new guidelines. As the percentage was very less, the students submitted a requisition to the Hon’ble vice-chancellor requesting for carryover to second BAMS. As per the new guidelines, it was not possible but keeping in view the above request of the students a joint meeting of CCIM members of Karnataka & Chairman, Board of Studies & members (UG-Ayu) was held on 27.12.2013. In the meeting the matter was discussed in detail and it was resolved unanimously to recommend to CCIM to revise the 2012 Regulation as follows:
1. The candidates of Ist BAMS are permitted to carryover all the failed subjects to 2nd BAMS & appear for 2nd BAMS examination concurrently along with the failed subjects of Ist BAMS. However these candidates have to pass all the failed subjects of Ist BAMS to become eligible to proceed to 3rd BAMS. 2. Similarly candidate of 2nd BAMS who have completely passed all the subjects of Ist BAMS but have failed in the 2nd BAMS are permitted to carryover all the failed subjects of 2nd BAMS to 3rd BAMS. However these candidates have to pass all the failed subjects of 2nd BAMS to become eligible to proceed to 4th BAMS. 3. The candidate of 3rd BAMS who have completely passed all the subjects of 2nd BAMS but have failed in the 3rd BAMS are permitted to carryover all the failed subjects of 3rd BAMS to final year. However these candidates have to pass all the failed subjects of 3rd BAMS to become eligible for appearing final year examination.
It was also unanimously resolved to recommend the extension of benefit of carryover system as per the present guidelines of revised BAMS regulation as notified in Govt. of India gazette dated 25th April 2012 to the previous batch of BAMS students admitted prior to 2012.
Hence, the applicant requested to look in the matter and do the needful.
Executive Committee decided to send a reply to University stating that the matter has been placed in EC & EC decided to refer the matter to Regulation Committee, till then University has to follow the concerned Regulations in toto.
193ec minutes 5
Agenda Item No. 8. Recognition of Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) Degree awarded by Bhagat Phool Singh Mahila Vishwavidyalya, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat, Haryana in the Second Schedule to the IMCC Act, 1970- reg.
It was noted that a letter V.12013/03/2012-EP(IM-2) dated 13.02.2014 has received from Govt. of India regarding recognition of Ayurvedacharya (BAMS) Degree awarded by Bhagat Phool Singh Mahila Vishwavidyalya, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat, Haryana in the Second Schedule to the IMCC Act, 1970 alongwith the name of the beneficiary colleges.
Accordingly, on the basis of following information furnished by University, the students passing out are of regular batch and they were admitted in the session 2007-08, 2008-09, 2009-10, 2010-11, 2011-12, 2012-13 and 2013-14. As per record available in the office of CCIM, the status of beneficiary college is as under:
S. Name of the College Year Permission of Govt. of India No. 1. Shri Maru Singh Memorial 2007-08 Permitted Institute of Ayurveda, Khanpur 2008-09 Permitted Kalan, Sonipat, Haryana. 2009-10 Permitted 2010-11 Permitted 2011-12 Not Permitted 2012-13 Not Permitted 2013-14 Permitted
As per information, the recommendation of Council to include the Ayurvedacharya Degree of the University has been sent to GOI vide letter No. 27-20/2012-Univ. dated 20.05.2014.
Executive Committee noted and approved the same.
Agenda Item No. 9. Consideration of policy regarding eligibility of teachers (reference: 184th to 187th EC) alongwith withdrawal of decision of Screening Committee regarding eligibility of teachers (reference: 189th EC) – regarding.
It was noted that as per order of President, I/c, CCIM, Point No. 3,12 & 15 (out of 28 points placed before EC) decisions of EC duly ratified by General Body (on 19.3.2014) may again be placed before EC with full facts for consideration.
193ec minutes 6
Point Reasons for ineligibility of teachers Policy for eligibility of teachers. No. 3. Appointed in Non-Allied subjects against Regulation 1.07.1989, Not Eligible 2.04.2011, 25.04.2012 & CCIM circular F-28-13/2004-Ay. Dated 9.10.2004.s 12. Teacher applied to the post before 1989 with UG qualification and After confirming the relevant appointed/reported to the post after 1989 by the competent documents may be consider authority / Govt. eligible. 15. Teacher appointed with UG qualification before 1989 continued Consider Eligible ( Gap period service with gap of years. will not be considered as teaching experience)
Accordingly, the facts in the matter (in chronological order) are placed below-
A. Consideration of Point No. 3, 12 & 15 (Out of 28 points placed before EC) regarding policy of eligibility of teachers (reference: 184th to 187th EC)
i) The policy for eligibility of teachers prepared by Screening Committee (consisting of Dr. Prasanna N Rao, Dr. V.G. Udaykumar, Dr. BP Pandey, Dr. Ragini Patil and Dr. Srinivas K. Bannigol) in its meeting held on 31.10.2013 & 01.11.2013 was placed before 184th EC held on 18.11.2013 under Addl. Agenda Item No.6. The EC decided as under:-
“(i) Executive Committee approved the policy except in respect of point No. 20 decision on which is as under:-
Sl. No. Reason for ineligibility of teachers Decision of EC 20. Teacher appointed as Demonstrator/clinical registrar/ Tutor/ Consider eligible if the teacher Junior Lecturer/ Technical assistant/Senior Resident/Service appointed as Demonstrator/ Tutor/ senior Resident/JRF/SRF/Ayurved Expert appointed by Junior Lecturer after 1989 with PG Universities / Govt. organizations after 1989 with PG qualification. qualification & teacher appointed or deputed to AYUSH chairs.
(ii) The reasons which are not covered in this policy but mentioned in criteria approved by EC in its meeting held on 26.06.2013 will be taken into consideration in clearing the pending of eligibility of teachers.
(iii) The relevant points of the policy be adopted in clearing eligibility issues of Unani/ Siddha teachers if there is any.
(iv) Executive Committee further agreed to consider the teachers eligible whose eligibility has been cleared on the basis of above policy.”
ii) The Executive Committee in 185th EC (held on 07.12.2013), confirmed the minutes of 184th EC except Addl. Agenda Item No.6 which was again adjourned for next date of EC. iii) The 185th Executive committee in its adjourned meeting held on 09.01.2014, decided to defer the matter i.e. Addl. Agenda Item No.6 to next (186th) meeting in view of order dated 04.01.2014 in HC of Uttarakhand at Nainital iv) Executive Committee at its meeting 186th (held on 04.02.2013), decided on the deferred agenda as under-
Addl. Agenda Item No.6 Policy prepared by screening committee for the eligibility of the teachers.
Executive Committee decided that all the issues will be categorized by the screening committee as per applicability under concerned regulations and those issues which are not covered under the concerned Regulations are
193ec minutes 7
deferred to regulation amendment committee. Thereafter, the recommendations will be placed before Executive Committee.
v) The Executive Committee while confirming the minutes of 186th Meeting in 187th Meeting (held on 17.02.2014) noticed that while confirming the minutes of 184th Meeting in 185th Meeting held on 17.12.2013 & its Adjourned Meeting held on 09.01.2014, the decision of Additional Agenda Item No. 6 of 184th Meeting was inadvertently noted as “EC confirmed the minutes of 184th EC except Additional Agenda Item No. 6 is again deferred for next Executive Committee” instead of except point No. 20 of Additional Agenda Item No.6 which is again deferred for next EC. Hence, EC decided in 187th Meeting that the said omission must be corrected. In view of the said observation of EC, the corrected minutes of th 184 meeting which are confirmed are as under:-
”Executive Committee confirmed the minutes of 184th EC except point No. 20 of Addl. Agenda Item No.6 which is again deferred for next EC.”
In accordance with the above corrections of Agenda Item No.1 of 185th Meeting, EC modified the decision on Additional Agenda Item No.6 of 186th Meeting as under:-
Previous decision of 186th Meeting Modified decision Executive Committee decided that all the issues will EC decided that all the issues will be be categorized by the screening committee as per categorized by the Screening Committee applicability under concerned regulations and those on the basis of decision of Additional issues which are not covered under the concerned Agenda Item No.6 of 184th Meeting Regulations are deferred to regulation amendment except point no. 20. Thereafter, the committee. Thereafter, the recommendations will be recommendation of screening committee placed before Executive Committee. will be placed before EC.
Thereafter, Executive Committee confirmed the minutes.
vi) The minutes of above EC have been ratified by the General Body in its meeting held on 19.03.2014. vii) Now, President I/c, CCIM directed to place the matter relating to the Point No. 3, 12 & 15 before EC for consideration.
B. Consideration of decision of Screening Committee regarding eligibility of teachers (reference: 189th EC).
It was noted that as per order of President, I/c, CCIM, decisions of 189th EC held on 19.03.2014 under Addl. Agenda Item No. 14 duly ratified by General Body (on 19.3.2014) is to be placed before EC for consideration.
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
SCREENED BY Dr. B.P.Pandey, Dr. V.G. Udaykumar, Dr. Ragini Patil on 18.02.2014 1. Dr. T.S.Gopalkrishna Reader Swasthvritta Considered eligible after deducting the period of long gap from 1992 to 2011, as teacher was in service under state Govt. 2. Dr. M. Sudheer Kumar Professor Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 2007 to 2009
193ec minutes 8
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
3. Dr. Kulamani Sarangi Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible after deducting the period of controversy (4years) as teacher was on suspension
4. Dr. Phaim Mohd. Shafi Lecturer Shalya Tantra Considered eligible Lecturer in shalya tantra Qureshi dept. from 01.01.2010 onwards after deducting the experience of 2 years 5. Dr. Anita Gunwantrao Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible after deducting the period of Holey one year experience 6. Dr.Murli Dhar Das Reader Shalya Tantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of controversary (4years) of teaching experience 7. Dr. Prabhugouda Patil Lecturer Sharir Kriya Considered eligible 8. Dr.Arun Kumar Sharma Professor Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of 2 years, as teacher is non PG joining before 1989 9. Dr. Asha Gupta Professor Ras Shastra Considered eligible 10. Dr. Kishore Daulatrao Reader Samhita Considered eligible Tarar 11. Dr . Rakesh Kumar Singh Reader Shalakya Considered eligible after deducting the period of Tantra one year experience 12. Dr. Seema Saxena Reader Kriya Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 13. Dr. Bhavana Vinod Shah Professor Kaumarbritya Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 14. Dr. Anitha Panda Reader Ras Shastra Considered eligible after deducting the previous experience from 20.10.2004 to 30.05.2007 of Santhigiri Ayurved College Pallakad Kerala 15. Dr. P.K. Beena Rose Professor Prasuti Tantra Considered eligible 16. Dr. Snehalata Jakkula Reader Kaumarbritya Considered eligible and teaching experience countable from 03.07.2006 onwards 17. Dr.Lilabati Mishra Reader Panchkarma Considered eligible after deducting the period of two year experience 18. Dr. Arun Kumar Singh Reader Kaumarbritya Considered eligible 19. Dr. Saily Sreedhary Lecturer Swasthavritta Considered eligible and teaching experience will Parameswaran be counted from the day of result of PG (2013) 20. Dr. Kalyani Pranita Reader Kyachitiksa Considered eligible Prakash 21. Dr. Prasant Anant Surup Reader Shalakya Considered eligible after deducting the period of Tantra two year experience 22. Dr. Manoj K.S. --- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 23. Dr. Kavita Vyas -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 24. Dr. Sharavati Goroba -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Kamble concerned college for clarification 25. Dr. Neeta Narendra Harale -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 26. Dr. Renuka Chegaraddi -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 27. Dr.Pravin Laxman Naik -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 28. Dr. Amit Prakash Nawkar -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 29. Dr. Sharmila Sen Das -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 30. Dr.Minakshi Gopalrao -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Borude concerned college for clarification 31. Dr. Sudhir Manohar -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Zuvekar concerned college for clarification
193ec minutes 9
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
SCREENED BY Dr. B.P.Pandey, Dr. Ragini Patil on 19.02.2014 32. Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 33. Dr. P.S. Vinohba Professor Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 34. Dr.Neeta Raj Holkar Reader Sharir Rachna Considered eligible after deducting the period of three year experience 35. Dr. Sheshadri B.V. Professor Panchkarma Considered eligible Venkatarao B.V. 36. Dr. Mahadev Laxman Professor Shalakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Bhosle three year experience 37. Dr. Yashpal Singh Lecturer Panchkarma Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 38. Dr. Basavraj Dundappa Professor Samhita Considered eligible Hundekar Siddhant 39. Dr. Sunil Bandopant Patil Professor Rasashastra Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 40. Dr. Kavita Gorla Lecturer Prasutu tantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Controversy and experience will be counted w.e.f. 01.01.2011 onwards 41. Dr. Venkatshiva Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Chadalawada two years experience 42. Dr Manish Lodha Reader Kriya Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 43. Dr. Chitralekha K.S. Reader Kayachikitsa Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience 44. Dr. Bhimrao Ganpat Patil Professor Prasuti tantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of one year experience 45. Dr. Sanjay Ramchandra Professor Kriya Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of Mali two years experience 46. Dr. Shambhunath Baijnath Professor Kaumarbhritya Considered eligible after deducting the period of Raj one year experience 47. Dr. Ujwala Kantilal Shah Professor Rognidan Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience 48. Dr. Cheriyachen P. Professor Panchakarma Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience 49. Dr. Krishnaji Vithoba Professor Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Phadtare three years experience 50. Dr. Ashok Virupaxappa Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Nandi one year experience 51. Dr. Shobha Shivram Reader Shalakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of Mhasawade two years experience 52. Dr. Kantha Reddy Toomu Professor Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience 53. Dr. T.C. Jayaraj Professor Rognidan Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience 54. Dr. Archana Jagadish -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Desai concerned college for clarification 55. Dr. Poormina V. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 56. Dr. Narashmulu M. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 57. Dr. Rajendra Ojha -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification and supportive documents as name of first college is not clearly mentioned in the teaching staff list
58. Dr. Stella Thekkekara Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the George concerned college for Submitting PG certificate
193ec minutes 10
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
59. Dr. Anil Singhai -- -- Ask to verify previous experience which was not mentioned in 2010, from teaching staff list of Rani Dhullayia Ayurved college. If the experience date match with previous data the teacher may be considered as Eligible Reader in Kayachikitsa 60. Dr. Govardhana Reddy -- -- Ask to verify previous record from the year Ravula 2002 to 2006 of the concerned college
SCREENED BY Dr. Ragini Patil , Dr.S.K. Bannigol, Dr.K.G.Vishwanathan on 20.02.2014 61. Dr. Pradhumnha Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible Madhukarrao Pasarkar 62. Dr. Laxmi Soujanya D. Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible after deducting the experience of Hingulambika Ayurvedic College, Gulberga, as reqested by teacher at the time of hearing 63. Dr. Reddy Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the V.L.Prasannakumar V. experience of Sri Sairam Ayurvedic College , Satyanarayana Chennai as per statement given by teacher at the time of hearing 64. Dr. Premananda Kar Lecturer Panchakarma Considered eligible 65. Dr. Mangesh Parkash Reader Sharir Rachna Considered eligible after deducting the Deshpandey experience of KMCT Ayurved College, Kozhikkode Kerala. 66. Dr. Santosh Kumar Mishra Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible 67. Dr. Milind Ganesh Mokashi Professor Samhita Considered eligible Siddhant 68. Dr. Niranjan Shukla Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible 69. Dr. Namrata Harichandan Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience of SVM Ayurved College ILKAL. 70. Dr. Vrushali Tole Reader Shalakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the period of two years experience 71. Dr. Vasant Patil Reader Panchakarma Considered eligible 72. Dr. Chandu Nair Professor Swasthavitta Considered eligible Govindapillai Sarawathy Amma 73. Dr Sudha Rani . R. Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible 74. Dr. Deepa Atul Lecturer Samhita Considered eligible Anserwadekar Siddhant 75. Dr. Prasanth S. Acharya Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience of Ramakrishna Ayurved College Banglore as he was working as honorary teacher and his teaching experience will be considered from 01.10.2006 onwards 76. Dr. Akthar Hussain -- Considered ineligible as non PG joining after 1989 77. Dr. Chaihtanya R. Menon -- -- Directed to write a letter to the teacher and concerned college for submission of PG degree and after submission of PG degree the teacher may be treated eligible teacher in concerned subject after the approval of President CCIM. 78. Dr. Krishna Kumar T.S. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 79. Dr. Shakuntala Mahapati -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 80. Dr. Indira Shivnand -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Hiremath concerned college for clarification 81. Dr. Satwashila Thorat -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 82. Dr. Seema Punjabrao -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Gangale concerned college for clarification
193ec minutes 11
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
83. Dr. Seema Singh -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 84. Dr. Rama Krishna T. -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 85. Dr. Jayalaxmi -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Shankargouda Menasagi concerned college for clarification 86. Dr.Ashwini Venkatesh -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Junjarwad concerned college for clarification 87. Dr Chandra Shekher -- -- Directed to take a legal opinion in the matter Pandey 88. Dr. Ashok Kumar Tripathi -- -- Directed to take a legal opinion in the matter SCREENED BY Dr K.G.Vishwanathan, Dr. S.K.Bannigol, Dr. Sarangpani on 21.02.2014 89. Dr. Dhanraj Bhagwan Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible Gayakwaid 90. Dr. Anita Santoshrao Reader Rasshastra Considered eligible Wanjari 91. Dr. Padmavati Venkatesh Reader Panchakarma Considered eligible Kulkarni 92. Dr. Dharmendra Kumar Professor Swasthavritta Considered eligible Mishra 93. Dr. Itnal Shobha Ramappa Lecturer Kayachikitsa Considered eligible 94. Dr. Awade Swateja Ajit Reader Prasuti Tantra Considered eligible 95. Dr. Prasanna K.G. Lecturer Kayachikitsa Considered eligible and teaching experience will be counted from 01.01.2012 onwards 96. Dr.Chandrashekhar Alladi Lecturer Samhita Considered eligible after deducting the previous Siddhant experience of six years and teaching experience will be counted from 01.06.2008 onwards 97. Dr. Anil Kallappa Bagalkoti Lecturer Swasthavritta Considered eligible and teaching experience will be counted from date of completion of PG 98. Dr. Subbaraju Nagaraju Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the previous M. Reddi experience from 06 01 1997 to 10.10.2000 and teaching experience will be counted from 16.10.2000 onwards 99. Dr. Satyendra Chaturvedi Reader Dravyaguna Considered eligible 100. Dr.Tanuja Pawar Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible and teaching experience will be counted from 10.02.2009 onwards 101. Dr. Hemant Laxman Reader Rachna Sharir Considered eligible Shinde 102. Dr. Pramod Anand Tiwari Reader Rachna Sharir Considered eligible 103. Dr.Shrikant Gaddi Halli Professor Samhita Considered eligible Shetty Siddhant 104. Dr. Virendra Singh Yadav Lecturer Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the previous experience from 01.10.1998 to 19.02.2007 and teaching experience will be counted from 05.05.2008 onwards 105. Dr. P Laxmaiah -- -- Ineligible due to overage 106. Dr. Satish Chandra -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Madanlal Jaiswal concerned college for clarification 107. Dr. Ujwal Krishna -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Deshpande concerned college for clarification 108. Dr. Rajeshwari -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Sangagouda Biradar concerned college for clarification 109. Dr. Rohini Revansidha -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Keskar concerned college for clarification and Directed to verify the records available with CCIM 110. Dr Atul Nirgude -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 111. Dr.P.Nageshwara Babu -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 112. Dr.Ishwarappa Prahillad -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Ugar concerned college for clarification
193ec minutes 12
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
113. Dr.Rajnesh Kumar Mishra -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 114. Dr. Tushar Jagannath Jogi -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 115. Dr. Subash Maruti Kolhe -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 116. Dr. Nisha K.V. -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 117. Dr. Devrajan -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Shankarnarayan after 01.07.1989 118. Dr. Pradeep Sreedharan As per the certificate with ref No B3/3040/2012 Dated 25.08.2012 issued by the Principal of Govt. Ayurvedic College, Tripunithura That Dr. Pradeep S is a final year PG in Panchakarma under M.G.University and will complete MD exam on 03.09.2012. Oral and practical exams of the same is scheduled on 04.09.2012 and 05.09.2012. Date of birth of the teacher is 29/05/1964 i.e. above 45. So screening committee ask to refer the matter to the Executive committee as teacher is PG. SCREENED BY Dr K.G.Vishwanathan, Dr. S.K.Bannigol, Dr. Sarangpani on 22.02.2014 119. Dr. Bhagirathi Sahoo Lecturer Kaumarbhritya Considered eligible after deducting the period of four years experience 120. Dr. Bhagavati Mohan Professor Prasutitantra Considered eligible after deducting the Mahantappa experience from 01.04.2000 to 31.02.2009. 121. Dr. Sunil Kumar Bansal Professor Kayachikitsa Considered eligible 122. Dr.Sunita Goyal Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 28.09.1998 to 14.06.2003. 123. Dr. Usha Ravindra Reader Agadtantra Considered eligible Deshmukh 124. Dr.Jonthan Rout Lecturer Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 01.05.2006 to 10.01.2012(period of suspension). 125. Dr. Bihu Ranjan Nanda Reader Shlakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 15.04.2006 to 14.02.2009(period of suspension). 126. Dr. Sapan Kumar Das Lecturer Shlakyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 15.04.2006 to 14.02.2009(period of suspension). 127. Dr. Satya Naryan Patnaik Professor Kayachikitsa Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 2006 to 2009(period of suspension). 128. Dr. Kailash Chandra Reader Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the Tripathi experience from 15.04.2006 to 14.02.2009(period of suspension). 129. Dr.Subhendu Kumar Reader Prasuti Tantra Considered eligible after deducting the Nanda experience from 15.04.2006 to 14.02.2009(period of suspension). 130. Dr. Jogesh Chandra Rath Professor Rachna Sharir Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 2006 to 2009(period of suspension). 131. Dr. Niranjan Prasad Lecturer Samhita Considered eligible after deducting the Tripathi Siddhant experience three years. 132. Dr. Mruthyunjaya Reader Shalyatantra Considered eligible after completion of PG, Nanjundaiah Hiremeth 2007(date of result) 133. Dr. Baban Singh Reader Swasthvritta Considered eligible after deducting the experience from 03.10.2003 to 21.12.2009. 134. Dr.Dilip Prabhakar Gadgil Professor Samhita Considered eligible after deducting the Siddhant experience of Tilak Maharashtra vidyapeeth Pune . 135. Dr. Madanlal Dewashwar Reader Kayachikitsa Considered eligible 136. Dr. Praveen Kumar Lecturer Panchakarma Considered eligible and teaching experience will Shayamsunder Madikonda be counted from 09.11.2011 onwards. 137. Dr. Amol Suresh Doshi Reader Prasuti tantra Considered eligible
193ec minutes 13
Sl. Name of Teacher Designation Department Remark of Screening Committee No.
138. Dr. Kembhavi Akash Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible 139. Dr. Dayanand S Professor Shalyatantra Considered eligible after deducting the experience two years. 140. Dr. N.R.Shankarnarayana -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 141. Dr. Shankar Pandurang -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Chougule after 01.07.1989 142. Dr.Yellambhatla -- -- Considered ineligible due to due to overage Janardhana 143. Dr. Krupakar Reddy -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 144. Dr.Vilas Rajaram Mane -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 145. Dr. Dwarkanath Shripad -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Kodolikar after 01.07.1989 146. Dr. Ravindranath -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Basappashetty Gundal after 01.07.1989 147. Dr. Suresh Venkappa -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Amberkar after 01.07.1989 148. Dr.Maheshwar Siddayya -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Karpurmath after 01.07.1989 149. Dr.Girijashankar -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining Banshnarayan Singh after 01.07.1989 150. Dr.Prakash Pandurang -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the Gosavi concerned college for clarification 151. Dr. T. Venugopal -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 as experience shown from 01.01.1988 is found false after verification with concerned college. 152. Dr. Vivekanand Shridhar -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining More after 01.07.1989 153. Dr. Nisha P. -- -- Considered ineligible due to Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989 154. Dr. Mahajan Anita -- -- Asked to write a letter to the teacher and the concerned college for clarification 155. Dr. Krishan Kumar -- Sharma Directed to put up the matter before EC
Executive Committee decided to withdraw the circular part of point No. 3 i.e. CCIM circular F-28-13/2004-Ay. dated 09.10.2004 as well as to completely withdraw point 12 & 15. EC also decided to withdraw the decision of 189th EC in respect of Add. Agenda Item No.14 on eligibility of 155 teachers. EC further decided that a consolidated policy will be prepared for by the EC members in the matter of teacher’s eligibility.
Agenda Item No. 10. Matter for presentation to GOI as per BJP Manifesto, 2014- regarding.
It was noted that a letter No.Z.28015/74/2014-P&C (AYUSH) dated 19.5.2014 has been received from the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Deptt. of AYUSH regarding material for presentation enclosing therewith a copy of relevant page of the Manifesto of BJP. The relevant points of the manifesto are reproduced as under:-
193ec minutes 14
“1. Education and Training: Will review the role of various professional regulatory bodies in healthcare and consider setting up an overarching lean body for healthcare. High priority will be given to address the shortfall of health care professionals.
2. Modernize Government hospitals, upgrading infrastructure and latest technologies.
3. Reorganize Ministry of Health and Family Welfare in order to coverage various Departments dealing in healthcare, food and nutrition and pharmaceuticals for effective delivery of healthcare service.
4. Increase the number of medical and para-medical colleges to make India self sufficient in human resources and set up an AIIMS like institute in every State.”
The ministry has asked to furnish information/views of the Council in the matter.
Executive Committee decided to authorize the President I/c, CCIM to form a Committee in consulation with Vice- President (Ayurved & Siddha) to make a consolidated view of the Council to be sent to the Ministry in the matter.
Agenda Item No. 11. Reporting of decision of Govt. of India in respect of Ayurved Colleges permitted/not permitted by Govt. of India in compliance of court order.
It was noted that Government of India has conveyed the decision in respect of following colleges in compliance of court order.
Ayurveda
Sl. Name of College Session W.P. Recommendation Permitted/not GOI letter number No. number of CCIM permitted and date of Court Order 1. Late Kedari Redekar 2012-13 WPC No. Recommended To grant permission to R. 17011/154/2012- Ayurveda 9563 of for the year the college with 50 seats EP(IM-1) Mahavidyalaya, 2012 dated 2012- 13.” in BAMS course and 14 Dated 07.05.2014 Kohlapur, 09.12.2013 seats in 03 PG courses Maharashtra namely Rognidan-04 seats, Rasashastra – 05 seats, Shalya-05 seats for the academic session 2012-13 2. Shri Krishna Govt. 2011-12 WPC No. Recommended for To grant permission to R.17011/33/2011- Ayurvedic College & 20743 of the session 2011- the college for BAMS EP(IM-1) 2011 dated course with 50 UG seats Hospital, Umri Road, 12. Dated 12.05.2014 15.10.2012 the academic session Kurukshetra, Haryana 2011-12 Executive Committee noted the same.
193ec minutes 15
Agenda Item No. 12. Reporting of decision of Govt. of India in respect of Ayurved and Unani colleges for Letter of Intent by Govt. of India for the session 2014-15.
It was noted that Government of India has conveyed the decision in respect of following Ayurved and Unani colleges for letter of intent for the session 2014-15.
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM AYURVED 1. Padmashree Dr. D.Y. Recommended to To start new PG in 04 R. Patil College of increase Intake Capacity subjects:- (i) Kriya Sharir (ii) 14011/14/2013- Ayurveda And Research in PG Courses i) Ayurved Swasthvritta (iii) EP (IM-1) Centre, Pimpri, Pune, Samhita-4 to 6 seats, Rasashastra & bhaishajya R. Maharashtra. ii)Rachana Sharir-4 to 6 Kalpana (iv) Panchkarma 13011/14/2013- seats. with 6 seats each subject. EP(IM-1) Recommended to start And to increase admission DATED 12.05.2014 new PG in (i) Kriya capacity in 02 existing PG Sharir, (ii) Swasthavritta, courses:- (i) Ayurved (iii) Rasashastra, (iv) Samhita Siddhant (ii) Panchkarma with 6 seats Rachana Sharir 4 to 6 seats each in each subject 2. JSS Ayurveda Medical Recommended for To increase admission R. College, Mysore, increasing 50 to 100 UG capacity from 50 to 100 14011/35/2013- Karnataka. seats. seats in existing UG course. EP(IM-1) And to start new PG course R. in Swasthvritta with 03 13011/42/2013- Recommended for PG in seats. EP(IM-1) Swasthavritta- 03 seats Dated 12.05.2014 3. Shri Vijay Mahantesh Recommended for To start new PG courses in R. Ayurvedic Medical Starting new PG in (i) 02 subjects 14011/34/2013- College, Bagalkot, Ilkal, Prasuti Tantra and Stri (i) Prasuti Tantra and Stri EP(IM-1) Karnataka Roga- 5 seats, (ii) Roga (ii) Shalakya Tantra 05 Dated 12.05.2014 Shalakya Tantra- 5 seats. seats in each Subject 4. Latthe Education Recommended for To increase admission R. Society’s Acharya increasing 40 to 50 UG capacity from 40 to 50 13011/49/2013- Deshabhushan seats. seats in existing BAMS EP(IM-1) Ayurvedic Medical course. Dated 12.05.2014 College & Hospital, Bedkihal Shamanewadi, Belgaum, Karnataka .
5. Bheemchandra Recommended for 50 To start new BAMS course R.12011/26/2013- Education Trust, UG seats with 50 UG seats EP(IM-1) Hillside Ayurveda college, Bangalore, Dated 12.05.2014 Karnataka.
193ec minutes 16
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM 6. Shubhdeep Ayurveda Recommended for To start new PG course in R. Medical College & increasing 50 to 60 UG 02 subject 14011/31/2013- Hospital, Indore, MP seats. (i) Panchakarma & EP(IM-1) Recommended for new (ii) Rognidan – 5 seats in R. PG in Rognidana- 05 each subject. 13011/34/2013- seats. And to increase the EP(IM-1) Not recommended for admission capacity from 50 Dated 12.05.2014 PG in Panchakarma due to 60 seats in existing UG to deficiency in course additional faculty. 7. Narayan Prasad Recommended for 50 to To start new PG course in R. Awasthi, Govt. Ayurved 60 UG seats. 02 subjects 14011/28/2013- College, Raipur, C.G. Recommended for PG in (i) Dravyaguna & EP(IM-1) Dravyaguna- 06 seats and (ii) Rognidan & Vikriti R. Rognidana- 06 seats. Vigyan with 06 seats in 13011/33/2013- The shortcomings shall each subject. EP(IM-1) be compiled at the time And to increase the Dated 12.05.2014 of LOP visit. admission capacity from 55 to 60 seats in existing UG course 8. Pt. Khushilal sharma Recommended for To Start new PG course in R. Government(Autonom increasing 50 to 60 UG 04 subject 14011/26/2013- ous) Ayurveda College seats. (i) Dravyaguna – 05 seats, EP(IM-1) & Institute, Bhopal, (ii) Rasashastra – 05 seats, R. MP. Recommended for new (iii) Rognidan – 06 seats, 13011/30/2013- PG in Dravyaguna -5, (iv) Panchakarma – 05 EP(IM-1) Rasashastra -5, Rognidan seats. Dated 12.05.2014 -6, Panchkarma -5. And to increase the admission capacity from 50 to 60 seats in existing UG course 9. Govt. Ayurvedic Recommended for To start new PG course in R. College, Jalukbari, Starting new PG in (i) 04 subjects (i) Shalya 14011/02/2013- Guwahati Shalya tantra- 03 seats, Tantra – 03 seats, EP(IM-1) (ii) Prasuti & Stri Roga- 02 (ii) Rachana Sharir – 02 Dated 12.05.2014 instead of 04 seats, (iii) seats Rog nidan-3 seats (iv) (iii) Rognidan – 03 seats & Sharir Rachna- 2 seats. (iv) Prasuti Tantra – 04 seats. 10. University College of Recommended for new To start new PG course in R. Ayurved, Dr. S.R. PG in subjects 03 subjects (i) Kayachikitsa, 14011/12/2013- Rajasthan Ayurvedic Kayachikitsa, Shalya (ii) Dravyaguna and EP(IM-1) University, Jodhpur, tantra, Dravyaguna (iii) Shalya tantra 06 seats Dated 12.05.2014 Raj. Vigyan →6 seats each. in each subject.
193ec minutes 17
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM 11. Rani Dullaiya Smriti Recommended for To increase the admission R. Ayurved PG increasing 50 to 60 UG capacity from 50 to 60 13011/26/2013- Mahavidyalaya & seats. seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) Chikitshalaya, Bhopal, Dated 12.05.2014 MP. 12. J.S.Ayurved Recommended for To increase the admission R. Mahavidyalaya & PD increasing 50 to 60 UG capacity from 50 to 60 13011/38/2013- Patel Ayurved Hospital, seats. seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) Nadiad, Gujarat. Dated 12.05.2014 13. Government Recommended for To increase the admission R. Autonomous Increase intake from40 capacity from 40 to 60 13011/21/2013- Dhanwantri Ayurveda To 60 as the college is seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) College, Mangalnath meeting all requirements Dated 12.05.2014 Road, Ujjain, MP. for UG course and it is also noted that the minimum requirement for running PG course is not available 14. Government Ayurved Recommended for To increase the admission R. College, Nanded, MS . increasing 60 to 100 UG capacity from 60 to 100 13011/05/2013- seats. seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) Dated 12.05.2014 15 Govt. Ayurved Recommended for To increase the admission R. Mahavidyalaya, Raje increasing 50 to 100 UG capacity from 50 to 100 13011/03/2013- Raghuji Nagar, Umer seats. seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) Road, Nagpur, Dated 12.05.2014 Maharashtra. 16. Chaudhary Harchand Recommended for 50 To start new BAMS course R. Singh Atmaram UG seats with 60 seats 12011/25/2013- Education Trust, Quadra Institute of EP(IM-1) Ayurveda, Dated 12.05.2014 Roorkee,Hraidwar Road, U.K. 17. Mahatma Jyotiba Fule Recommended for 100 To start new BAMS course R. Vidyapeeth Samiti, UG seats with 100 seats 12011/22/2013- Mahatma Jyotiba Fule Ayurveda EP(IM-1) Mahavidyalaya, Jaipur, Dated 12.05.2014 Rajasthan. 18 Abhilashi Education Recommended for 60 UG To start new BAMS course R. Society, Abhilashi seats with 60 seats 12011/14/2013- Ayurvedic college and research institute, EP(IM-1) Chailchock, Tehsil- Dated 12.05.2014 Chachyot, Distt. Mandi(H.P.)
193ec minutes 18
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM 19. Kalyan Society, Recommended for 50 To start new BAMS course R. Lal Bhadur Shastri UG seats with 50 seats 12011/05/2013- Mahila Ayurved college and Hospital, EP(IM-1) Yamunanagar,Haryana Dated 12.05.2014 20. Dhanvantari Ayurveda Recommended for To increase the admission R. College, Hospital & increasing 40 to 60 UG capacity from 40 to 60 13011/06/2013- Research Centre, seats. seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) Siddapur, Karnataka. Dated 12.05.2014 21. Vaidya Yagya Dutt Recommended for To start new PG course in R. Sharma Ayurved increasing 75 to 100 UG 06 subjects 14011/25/2013- Mahaviyalaya, Opp. seats. (i)Swasthavritta-05seats EP(IM-1) Dharpa Power House, (ii)Agad Tantra & R. G.T.Road, Khurja, U.P. Recommended for Vyavaharahayurved -05 13011/31/2013- Starting new PG in (i) seats (iii) Ayurved Samhita EP(IM-1) Swasthavritta-5, (ii) & Siddhanta-06 seats Dated 15.05.2014 Agadtantra-5, (iii) (iv) Dravyaguna – 05 seats Samhita-3, (iv) Siddhant- (v) Rasa Shastra & 3, Bhaishajya Kalpana- 05 (v) Dravyaguna-5, (vi) seats and (vi)Rachana Rasshastra & Bhaishjya Sharir – 05 seats kalpna-5, (vii) Rachna And to increase the Sharir-5. admission capacity from 75 to 100 seats in existing UG (BAMS) 22. R A Podar Ayurved Conditionally To increase the admission R. College, Worli, recommended for capacity from 60 to 100 13011/01/2013- Mumbai, Maharashtra increase intake of UG seats in existing UG course EP(IM-1) from 60 to 100 seats. Dated 15.05.2014 23. Shree Saptashrungi Recommended for To start new PG course in R. Ayurved increasing 50 to 60 UG 07 subjects 14011/21/2013- Mahavidyalaya & seats. (i) Samhita & EP(IM-1) Hospital Kamal Nagar, Recommended for start Siddhanta R. Hirawadi, Panchhwati, new PG 07 subjects: (ii) Kriya Sharir 13011/29/2013- Nasik, Maharashtra 1)Samhita&Siddhant (2) (iii) Dravyaguna EP(IM-1) Kriya Sharir, (iv) Rasa Shastra & Dated 15.05.2014 (3) Dravyaguna, Bhaishajya Kalpana (4)Rasashastra, (v) Kaumarbhritya (5)Kaumarbhritya, (vi) Agad Tantra (6)Agad tantra, (vii) Panchkarma with (7)Panchkarma with 6 06 seats in each seats each. Course And to increase the admission capacity from 50 to 60 seats in existing UG (BAMS)couse
193ec minutes 19
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM 24. Sri Sai Ayurvedic Recommended for To start new PG course in R. Medical College and increasing 75 to 100 UG 05 subjects 14011/22/2013- Hospital, Sarsol, G.T. seats. (i) ShalakyaTantra- EP(IM-1) Road, Aligarh, Uttar 03seats R. Pradesh Recommended for (ii) Rasa Shastra & 13011/35/2013- Increase (PG) course (i) Bhaishajya EP(IM-1) Prasuti Tantra – 04-06 Kalpana-06 seats Dated 15.05.2014 seats & (ii) Shalya Tantra (iii) Agad Tantra-06 seats – 04-06 seats. (iv) Rachana Sharir-06
seats Recommended for PG in (v) Maulik Siddhant- Shalakya tantra- 03 seats 06 seats and Rasashashtra- 06 And to increase the seats, Agadatantra-06 admission capacity from seats, Sharir Rachana-06 75 to 100 seats in existing seats and Maulik UG (BAMS)course Siddhant-06 seats. And in existing 02 PG
courses (i)Prasuti & Strirog (ii) Shalya Tantra from 04 to 06 seats in each course. 25. Prabuddh Shikshan Recommended for 50 To start new BAMS course R.12011/09/2013- Sanathan, UG seats with 50 seats EP(IM-1) Prabuddh Ayurvedic Medical College, Dated- 15.05.2014 Hospital & Research Centre, Lucknow, U.P. 26. Santushti Human Recommended for 100 To start new BAMS course R.12011/15/2013- Development UG seats with 100 seats EP(IM-1) Educational and Welfare Society, Dated- 15.05.2014 Santushti College of Medical & Higher Studies, Santusti Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital, Mirzapur, U.P. 27. Anandi Shikshan Recommended for 60 To start new BAMS course R.12011/20/2013- Prasarak Mandal’s UG seats with 60 seats EP(IM-1) Ayurved Medical College, Hospital & Dated- 16.05.2014 Research Institute, Ajanta Road, Sgvan, Buldana Maharashtra 28. Bal Bhagwan Shikshan Recommended for To Increase admission R.13011/43/2013- Prasarak Mandal’s increasing 50 to 60 UG capacity from 50 to 60 EP(IM-1) Dhanwantri Ayurved seats. seats in existing UG(BAMS) Dated- 16.05.2014 Medical College, course Degloor Road, Udgir, Distt. Latur
193ec minutes 20
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM Maharashtra 29. Shree Dhaneshwari Recommended for 50 To start new BAMS course R.12011/16/2013- Manav Vikas Mandal, UG seats conditionally with 50 seats EP(IM-1) Sou Shantadevi Dated- 16.05.2014 Vedprakash Patil Ayurved College & Research Institute, Mahrashtra
30. Yashwant Ayurvedic Recommended for To Increase in the R.13011/25/2013- College PG Training increasing 80 to 100 UG admission capacity from 80 EP(IM-1) Research Centre, seats. to 100 seats in existing Dated- 19.05.2014 Kodoli, Kolhapur, MS. UG(BAMS) course
31. Jagdamba Education Recommended for 50 To start new BAMS course R.12011/29/2013- Society, Matoshri UG seats with 50 seats EP(IM-1) Asarabai Darade Dated- 19.05.2014 Ayurvedic college, Babhulgaon, Tal. Yeola, Distt. Nashik, Maharashtra 32. Sunil Ramsingh To Increase in the To Increase in the R.13011/20/2013- Chunawale Ayurved admission capacity from admission capacity from 40 EP(IM-1) Mahavidyalaya, 40 to 60 seats in existing to 60 seats in existing Dated- 19.05.2014 Buldana, Maharashtra. UG(BAMS) course UG(BAMS) course
33. Aquarius Public To Increase in the To Increase in the R.13011/32/2013- Education Society, admission capacity from admission capacity from 50 EP(IM-1) Mahadeorao Shivankar 50 to 60 seats in existing to 60 seats in existing Dated- 19.05.2014 Ayurved Medical UG(BAMS) course UG(BAMS) course College & Research Institute, Gondia, Maharashtra 34. Smt. K.C. Ajmera To Increase in the To Increase in the R.13011/37/2013- Ayurved College, admission capacity from admission capacity from 40 EP(IM-1) Dhule, Maharashtra 40 to 60 seats in existing to 60 seats in existing Dated- 19.05.2014 UG(BAMS) course UG(BAMS) course 35. Sangam Sevabhavi Recommended for To Increase in the R.13011/44/2013- Trust's Ayurved increasing 50 to 60 UG admission capacity from 50 EP(IM-1) Mahavidyalaya, seats. to 60 seats in existing Dated- 20.05.2014 Sangamner, UG(BAMS) course Ahmednagar, Maharashtra
193ec minutes 21
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM 36. Dayabhai Maoji Recommended for PG in To start new PG course in 14011/03/2013- Majithiya Ayruveda Rognidana- 03 seats. Rognidan avum Vikriti EP(IM-1) Mahavidyalaya, Vigyan with 03 seats Dated- 20.05.2014 Yavatmal, Maharashtra
37. Manjara Ayurved Recommended for new To start new PG course in 14011/18/2013- Medical College & PG in Rachna Sharir -4 with 03 seats EP(IM-1) Hospital, Latur, Seats Dated- 20.05.2014 Maharashtra 38. Chhatrapati Shahu Conditionally To start new PG course in R.14011/24/2013- Maharaj Shikshan recommended for Panchakarma with 06 seats EP(IM-1) Sanstha Ayurved increase intake of PG in And to increase the R. Mahavidyalya, Paithan Kayachikitsa from 04 to admission capacity in 13011/52/2013- Road, Kanchanwadi, 06 seats. existing PG course namely EP(IM-1)
Aurangabad, Conditionally Kayachikitsa from 04 to 06 Dated- 20.05.2014 Maharashtra recommended for seats Starting new PG in Panchkarma with 6 seats. 39. Krishna Education Not Recommended Not to grant Letter of R.12011/18/2013- Society, Kusumtai Intent/Permission to EP(IM-1) Rajarambapu Patil establish a Kusumtai Dated- 20.05.2014 Ayurvedic Medical Rajarambapu Patil College, Hospital and Ayurvedic Medical College, Research Institute, Hospital and Research Chiplun, Dist-Ratnagiri, Institute. Maharashtra 40. Dr. G.D. Pol Recommended for To increase the admission R.13011/45/2013- increasing 80 to 100 UG Foundation’s Y.M.T. seats. capacity from 80 to 100 EP(IM-I) & R. Ayurvedic Medical seats in existing UG (BAMS) 14011/42/2013- College & Hospital, Recommended for Starting and to start new Post EP(IM-I) new PG in (1) Stri Rog & Kharghar, Maharashtra Prasuti tantra-4, (2) Graduate Course of Study Dated- 21.05.2014 Panchkarma-4 seats in 02 Subjects namely (i) Prasutitantra and (ii) Panchakarma with 4 seats in each course.
UNANI 40. National Institute of Not Recommended for To Start new PG course in R. Unani Medicine, deptt. of IBT and also not 02 subjects 14012/01/2013- Kottigepalya, recommended for Deptt. (i)Jarahat - 05 seats EP(IM-1) Bangalore, Karnataka of Jarahat. (ii)Ilaj Bit Tadbeer – 05 Dated 12.05.2014 seats
193ec minutes 22
S Name of College Recommendation sent Letter Of Intent by GOI Letter No. & Date No. by CCIM 41. Luqman Unani Medical Recommended on To increase the admission R. College & Hospital, condition to fulfill the capacity from 40 to 60 13012/05/2013- Bijapur, Karnataka shortcomings till the LOP. seats in existing UG (BUMS) EP(IM-1) course. Dated 12.05.2014
Executive Committee noted the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.1. Regarding Audit Report on the accounts of Central Council of Indian Medicine for the year 2011-12 to 2012-13 received from the Principal Accounts Office, M/o Health & Family Welfare, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi.
It was noted that a letter No.IA(HQ)/MHFW/ CCIM(172)/2011-12/1009 dated 12.3.2014 was received from Sr. Accounts Officer (IAHQ), Govt. of India, Principal Accounts Office, M/o Health & Family Welfare, Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi regarding Audit Report on the accounts of CCIM for the year 2011-12 to 2012-13 in which it is stated that Parawise reply on the objections raised by Internal Audit may be furnished to the undersigned within a month from the receipt of Audit Report.
After getting replies from all the concerned sections, a comparative statement of Audit observation and Reply on the Internal Audit for the year 2011-12 to 2012-13 has been prepared which is placed for approval.
Further, it was noted that as regards to Para No.2 of Audit Report for the year 2011- 12 to 2012-13 regarding excess expenditure of telephone at the residence of entitled officers, a reminder in continuation of letter No.10-13/2012-Internal Audit dated 28.8.2012 may again be sent to the Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family, Department of AYUSH, EP(IM-2) with the request to convey the sanction as required under Section 12(d) of IMCC Act, 1970” for actual payment of telephone bills (at residence) of entitled officers.
Executive Committee noted and approved the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.2. Regarding Advance initiation of the process of filling up of the posts of Director/Head of Autonomous Bodies under the D/o AYUSH, at least one year prior to the occurrence of the vacancy.
It was noted that an O.M. No.V.26011/1/2014-NI(RAV) dated 13.2.2014 has been received from the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Department of AYUSH,
193ec minutes 23
(NI Desk), New Delhi in which it has been conveyed that the Hon’ble HFM has directed that in future, the process of filling up of the posts of Director/Head of Autonomous Bodies under the D/o AYUSH, may as a matter of principle, be initiated at least one year prior to the occurrence of the vacancy and requested for the compliance of direction of the HFM.
In this connection, it was noted that the direction of the Hon’ble HFM may be followed in the CCIM also.
Executive Committee agreed to the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.3. Visitation Report of Ayurveda Colleges under Section 13C for the session 2014-15- reg.
It was noted that some annexure of Part I of Visitation Report for the session 2014- 15 under section 13C are not signed by the Visitors/Principals of the following colleges:-
1. Vishnu Ayurveda College, P.O Government Press, Shoranur-679122 Dist. Palakkad Kerala 2. Karnataka Ayurveda Medical College & Hospital K.E.C.T Tower, Ashok Nagar, Mangalore D.K.,Karnataka 3. SCSES’S Rural Institute of Ayurved, Research Centre & Hospital,At Vidyagiri, Mayani, Tal. Khatav, Dist. Satara-415102, Maharashtra 4. KMCT Ayurveda Medical College, Manassery, P.O, Taluk & District Kozhikkode-673602 Kerala 5. J.S. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, College Road, Nadiad-387001 Dist.-Kaira-Nadiad, Gujarat 6. Govt. Akhandanand Ayurved College & Hospital, Lal Darvaja, Bhadra, Ahmedabad-380001, Gujarat.
Executive Committee decided to get revisitation done of those colleges where visitors’ signature as well as Principal’s signature are not found. If the signature of only visitors are not found then explanation will be called from the visitors. This decision be applicable to all such cases.
Addl. Agenda Item No.4. Recommendation of Screening Committee in respect of Rishikul Govt. P.N. Ayurvedic College and Hospital Haridwar Uttrakhand after reassessment- regarding.
It was noted that Rishikul Govt. P.N. Ayurvedic College and Hospital, Haridwar (Uttrakhand) was visited on 12-13.02.2014 by Prof. G.S.Tomar, Dr. Ram Mohan and
193ec minutes 24
Dr Rajkumar Yadav to assess the available facilities of teaching and practical training for conducting UG/PG & PG course under section 13C.
The visitation report along with all the relevant documents and assessment done by office was considered and examined by Scrutiny Committee held on 12.03.2014 to 14.03.2014 and EC decided to recommend for UG 60 seats and PG in 07 subjects namely Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -07 seats, Dravyaguna-04seats, Shalya tantra-05seats, Shalakya Tantra-04 seats, Prasuti Tantra-04 seats, Kayachikitsa-04 seats, Panchakarma – 04 seats (instead of 05) due deficit in faculty to Govt. of India for granting permission for the session 2014-15.
Further, it was noted that at the time of reassessment of said college, the members of screening committee noticed that there is shortage of additional teaching faculty in Department of Prasuti tantra. Therefore the committee decided not to recommend for PG course in Prasuti tantra due to unavailability of additional teaching faculty.
Executive Committee agreed to the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.5. Clarification received from visitor in respect of Visitation Report of Swami Kalyandev Government Ayurved College Rampur, Muzaffarnagar, Uttar Pradesh under Section 13C for the session 2014-15. It was noted that Swami Kalyandev Government Ayurved College, Rampur, Muzaffarnagar, (Uttar Pradesh) was visited on 24-25.01.2014 for the session 2014- 15 under section 13C & while examining the report only Part I was found with the report. Further, in this regard as per decision of 190th EC (on 04.04.2014), the clarification has been asked from the visitor. In response to the same, one visitor named Dr. V.K.Pandey has sent the copy of Part II of the visitation report of the said college.
However, with the approval of President I/c, CCIM the report has been considered and assessed accordingly.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.6. Recommendation of Screening Committee in respect of ISM Colleges visited under Section13C.
It was noted that meetings of Screening Committee of Ayurved and Unani were held on 26-27.05.2014 and for Siddha on 28.05.2014 and recommendations were placed before the E.C. at the time of consideration of the same.
193ec minutes 25
AYURVED
Minutes of Screening Committee Meeting held on 15.05.2014 in respect of Ayurved Colleges visited under Section 13C for the session 2014-15.
The Screening Committee meeting constituted by Dr. Amitabh Kumar (V.P. Ayurved), Dr. Bhrigupati Pandey, Dr. V.G. Udaya Kumar, Dr. Srinivas K. Bannigol and Dr. Umesh Shukla, EC Members, CCIM held on 15.05.2014 to scrutinize the Visitation Report along with all the relevant documents and assessment done by office of following Ayurved Colleges under Section 13C. After careful examination of all the documents and facts, the Screening Committee decided as under:-
S. No. Name of College Remark of Screening Commitee 1. Manjara Ayurved Medical College & Recommended for UG 60 seats Hospital, Behind Bus Stand, Ghandhi Maidan, Tq. Latrur- 413512, Maharashtra 2. Smt. Kamaladevi Gauridutt Mittal Not recommended for UG & PG Puanrvasu Ayurved Mahavidyalaya due to following reasons:- Vd. Ramgopal Sharma Chowk, Netaji 1. Hospital is not functional Subhash Road, Charni Road (West), 2. Bed Occupancy is 48.68% Dist. Mumbai -400002 against the requirement of Maharashtra 50% for PG institute. 3. Other shortcomings mentioned by the visitors. 3. T.M.A.E Society’s Ayurvedic Medical Recommended for UG 50 seats College, and PG in Shalya Tantra Sankalapura, Tanda, Ballary Road, (Samanya)- 03 seats with Hospet-583201 remedial shortcomings. Karnataka 4. Sangam Sevabhavi Trust’s Ayurved Recommended for UG 50 seats Mahavidyalaya and PG in 04 subjects namely Tal. Sangamner – 422605, 1. Prasuti Tantra-05 seats Dist. Ahmednagar 2. Kayachikitsa-03 seats Maharashtra (instead of 05seats due to deficit of 01 higher faculty) 3. Shalakya Tantra- (Shiro- Nasa-Kalan Avum Kantha Roga)-5 seats 4. Shalya Tantra- 05 seats 5. Bagamar Seva Samiti’s Bhagwan Recommended for UG 50 seats Mahaveer Jain and PG in 04 subjects namely Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital 1. Rasashastra-05 seats Gajendergad-582114 2. Kayachikitsa-05 seats Tq:Ron , Dist. Gadag 3. Shalya Tantra-05 seats Karnataka 4. Panchkarma-02 seats (Instead of 05-seats)
193ec minutes 26
6. Major S.D. Singh Ayurvedic Medical Recommended for UG 50 seats College & Hospital Bewar Road, Fatehgarh, Dist. Farrukhabad-209625 Uttar Pradesh
7. Sushrutha Ayurvedic Medical College Recommended for UG 50 seats & Hospital #23, Papaiah Garden, Diagonal Road C.K. Achukattu, B.S.K., IIIrd Stage Bangalore – 560085 Karnataka 8. Ahalia Ayurveda Medical College Recommended for UG 50 seats Kozhipara, Palakkad Dist. 678557 Kerala 9. Jammu Institute of Ayurved & Recommended for UG 90 seats Research and PG in 03 subjects namely Muthi, Nardhani Raipur 1. Kriya Sharir-05 seats Ban Talab Road 2. Kayachikitsa-05 seats Jammu Tawi 181123 3. Shalya Tantra-05 seats
10. Smt. K.C. Ajmera Ayurved College, Recommended for UG 40 seats Dayasagar Educational Campus, Agra Road, Deopur, Dist. & Tal Dhule – 424002, Maharashtra
11. Shri Jagadguru Gurusiddeshwar Co- Recommended for UG 50 seats Operative Hospital Society’s Ayurvedic and PG in 10 subjects namely Medical College, 1. Dravyagune-05 seats Ghataprabha-591310 2. Rasahastra & Tal-Gokak, Dist. Belgaum Bhaisajyakalpna-05seats Karnataka 3. Rognidan-05 seats 4. Swasthavritta-05seats 5. Kayachikitsa-05 seats 6. Prasuti Tantra-05seats 7. Shalya Tantra-05seats 8. Shalakya Tantra-05 seats 9. Panchkarma-05seats 10.Kaumarbhritya-05seats 12. Mannam Ayurveda Co-Operative Recommended for UG 50 seats Medical College, MSM P.O. Pandalam-689501, Dist. Pathanamthitta Kerala
193ec minutes 27
13. Ayujyoti Ayurvedic College & Hospital Recommended for UG 50 seats Jodhpuria,Sirsa-1250766 Haryana 14. Punjab Ayurved Medical College & Not recommended due to Hospital, following reasons:- 43 MMK, Morzanda Khari, 1. The higher faculties are 11 Sri Ganganagar-335037 in 10 departments gainst Rajasthan the requirement of 12 in 11 departments. 15. Shree Chhatrapati Shivaji Education Recommended for UG 40 seats Society’s Dhanwantari Ayurvedic Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre, Industrial Area, Shiv- Shankar Nagar, Jatrat Road, Nipani-591237, Tal: Chikodi, Dist Belgaum, Bangalore, Karnataka 16. Shri K.R. Pandav Ayurved College & Recommended for UG 50 seats Hospital, Bahadura, Near Dighori Naka, Umred Road, Dist. Nagpur Maharashtra
17. Jupiter Ayurved Medical College & Recommended for UG 40 seats Hospital, Shankarpur, Post- Khapri, Tehsil & District Nagpur – 15 Maharashtra
18. Ashwini Educational Association’s Recommended for UG 50 seats Ayurved Medical College & PG Centre, and PG in 02 subjects namely #405/1, Opp. Bathi Lake, “ 1. Kayachikitsa-05 seats Ashwini Nagar”, P.B. Road, Dist. 2. Shalya Tantra- 05 seats Davangare Karnataka 19. Hon. Shri Annasaheb Dange Ayurved Recommended for UG 50 seats Medical College and Post Graduate and PG in 09 subjects namely Training Research Centre, 1. Sharir Rachna- 02 seats A/p Ashta, Tal. Walwa, 2. Sharir Kriya- 05 seats Dist. Sangli- 416301 3. Rasahastra & Maharashtra Bhaisajyakalpna-05seats 4. Shalya tantra- 05 seats 5. Shalakya Tantra – 06 seats 6. Kayachikitsa- 06 seats 7. Rognidan- 06 seats 8. Prasuti Tantra & Stri roga-
193ec minutes 28
05 seats (instead of 06- seats) 9. Samhita Siddhanta- 06 seats 20. Aligarh Unani/Ayurvedic Recommended for UG 50 seats Medical College, ACN Hospital, Opp. F.M. Tower, Anoopshahr Road, Aligarh – 202002 Uttar Pradesh 21. Bhanwar Lal Nahata Samriti Sansthan, Recommended for UG 50 seats Mandsaur Institute of Ayurved with remedial shortcomings. education & Research, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh 22. JD Ayurvedic Medical College & Recommended for UG 50 seats Hospital Bhankari, G.T. Road , Aligarh-202001 Uttar Pradesh 23. Sri Sri Nrusinghnath Ayurved College Recommended for UG 30 seats & Research Institute, with remedial shortcomings. P.O Paikmal, Dist. Bargarh-768039 Orissa 24. Loknete Rajarambapu Patil Ayurvedic Recommended for UG 50 seats Medical College, Hospital, Post and PG in 10 subjects namely Graduate Institute & Research Centre 1. Swasthavritta- 06 seats Urun-Islampur, Sangli Road, 2. Rasahastra & Tal. Walwa, Bhaisajyakalpna-06seats Dist. Sangali-415409 3. Agad Tantra- 06 seats Maharashtra 4. Rognidan-06 seats 5. Shalya Tantra- 05 seats 6. Kaumarbhritya-06 seats 7. Kayachikitsa-05 seats 8. Panchkarma- 06 seats 9. Prasuti Tantra & Stri roga- 05 seats 10.Shalakya (Shiro Nasa- Karna Avum Kanta Roga- 06 seats) 25. Atreya Ayurvedic Medical College, Recommended for UG 50 seats Hospital & Research Centre Post Kodigehalli, Doddaballapura Bangalore-561203 Karnataka
Minutes of Screening Committee Meeting held on 26-27.05.2014 in respect of Ayurved Colleges visited under 13C
193ec minutes 29
The Screening Committee constituted by Dr. Amitabh Kumar (V.P. Ayurved), Dr. V.G. Udaya Kumar, Dr. Srinivas K. Bannigol and Dr. Umesh Shukla, EC Members, CCIM held on 26-27.05.2014 to scrutinize the Visitation Report along with all the relevant documents and assessment done by office of following Ayurved Colleges under Section 13C. After careful examination of all the documents and facts, the Screening Committee decided as under:-
S.No. Name of College Remark of Screening Committee 1. Veenavadini Ayurved Recommended for UG 50 seats College & Hospital, Akbarpur, Phase-II, Behind Kanhakunj, Kolar Road, Bhopal Madhya Pradesh
2. Chhatisgarh Ayurved Recommended for UG 60 seats (instead Medical College of 75 due to deficit teaching staff) G.E. Road, Village Manki, Dist.-Rajnandgaon 491441 Chhatisgarh 3. Sri Dharmasthala Recommended for UG 75 seats and PG Manjunatheshwara College 13 subjects namely of Ayurveda & Hospital, 1. Samhita Siddhanta- 06 seats Laxminarayan Nagar, P.O. 2. Rachna Sharir- 06 seats Kuthpady 3. Dravyaguna- 06 seats Taluk and District Udupi- 4. Rasahastra & Bhaisajyakalpna- 574118 06seats Karnataka 5. Rognidan-05 seats 6. Prasuti tantra & Striroga- 06 setas 7. Kayachikitsa- 06 seats 8. Shalya tantra- 06seats 9. Panchkarma- 06 seats 10.Manasroga- 05 seats 11.Swasthavritta- 04 seats 12.Agad tantra- 05 seats 13.Kaumarbhritya- 04 seats
4. BSSS’S Ramrao Patil Recommended for UG 40 seats Ayurved Mahavidyalaya & Rugnalaya Bus Stand Road, Tq. Purna, Dist. Parbhani Maharashtra
193ec minutes 30
5. Ayurved Seva Sangh’s Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG Ayurved Mahavidyalaya in 03 subject namely Ganeshwadi Panchavati 1. Kayachikitsa- 05 seats Tal. & Dist. Nashik- 2. Shalya tantra- 04 seats 422003 3. Panchkarma- 01 seat Maharashtra
6. Uttaranchal Ayurvedic Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG College in 02 subjects namely Ayurved Estate, 1. Maulik Siddhanta- 05 seats 17, Old Mussoorie Road, 2. Swasthavritta- 05 seats Rajpur Dehradun – 248009 3. Agad tantra- 05 seats Uttarakhand and conditionally recommended for OG Dravyaguna- 05 seats as the college is not fulfilling the number of species in herbal garden. 7. Vaidyaratnam Ayurveda Recommended fro UG 50 seats and PG College, in Kaychikitsa-04 seats with remedial Ollur, Thaikkattussery shortcomings Thrissur-680322 Kerala 8. Vaidyaratnam P.S. Varier Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG Ayurveda College, in 05 subjects namely Kottakkal, P.O Edarikode- 1. Manasroga-06 seats 676501, 2. Agad tantra- 04 seats Taluk-Tirur, 3. Panchkarma- 04 seats Dist. Malappuram 4. Dravyaguna- 04 seats Kerala 5. Swasthavritta- 04 seats
9. Shri Narsingh K.Dube Recommended for UG 50 seats Charitable Trust’s Nalasopara Ayurved Medical College & Hospital (Swargiya Shri Suresh Nursingh Dube Ayurved College) Medical College Road, Serve No-59 (Old) 112 New, Achole, Nallasopara (E) Tal . Vasai, Dist. Thane- 401209, Maharashtra 10. Dr. BRKR Govt Ayurvedic Not recommended due to deficient in College higher faculty distribution. The Colleges Opp. E.S.I Hospital is having 14 higher faculty in 10 Erragadda Hyderabad- department only. 500038 Andhra Pradesh
193ec minutes 31
11. Govt. Ayurvedic Medical Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG College in 06 subject namely Dhanwantri Road, 1. Dravyaguna-07 seats Bangalore-560009 2. Rasashastra-06 seats Karnataka 3. Rognidan-03 seats (instead of 06 seats) 4. Panchkarma- 07 seats 5. Shalya tantra-07 seats 6. Shalakya tantra- 07seats
12. S.S.V.Samiti’s Shri SBS Recommended for UG 30 seats Ayurvedic Medical College Mundargi-582118, Dist. Gadag Karnataka 13. Babe Ke Ayurvedic Medical Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG College & Hospital in 04 subjects namely Village & P.O Daudhar, 1. Samhita Siddhanta-06 seats Tehsil & Dist. 2. Rachna Sharir-06 seats Moga- 142053 3. Dravyaguna-06 seats Punjab 4. Kaumarbhritya-01 seat
14. Ashvin Rural Ayurved Recommended for UG 40 seats and PG College Manchi Hill, Ashvi in 03 subjects namely B.K. 1. Rasahastra & Bhaisajyakalpna- Ashvi BK, Tal . Sangamner, 06seats Dist. Ahmednagar-413714 2. Shalya tantra- 06 seats Maharashtra 3. Kayachikitsa-06 seats
15. Shaheed Kartar Singh Recommended for UG 60 seats Sarabha Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital VPO Sarabha, Dist. Ludhiana-141105 Punjab
16. Government Ayurved Not recommended due to deficit in College higher faculty distribution and bed Near Gurudwara Moti occupancy. Bagh, Patiala-147001
193ec minutes 32
17. Rama Krishna Ayurvedic Recommended for UG 40 seats Medical College and Research Centre, #54/2, Ramagondanahalli, Yelahanka, Bangalore-560064 Karnataka. 18. Saint Sahara Ayurvedic Not recommended due to deficit in Medical College & Hospital, higher faculty distribution. The college Kot Shamir, Bathinda- is having 13 higher faculty in 10 151001 department. Punjab
19. Ashwini Ayurvedic Medical Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG College & Research Centre, in 04 subjects namely Ring Road, Maralur 1. Dravyaguna-04 seats Taluk & District Tumkur- 2. Kayachikitsa-04 seats 572105 3. Panchkarma- 04 seats Karnataka 4. Shalakya tantra-04 seats 20. Sri Sri College of Ayurvedic Recommended fro UG 50 seats with Sciences & Research, remedial shortcomings. 21st KM Kanakapura Road, Post Udayapura Bangalore-560062 Karnataka 21. Yerala Medical Trust Recommended fro UG 80 seats and PG Ayurvedic Medical College in 11 subjects namely & Hospital 1. Samhita Siddhanta-04 seats Institutional Area, Sector 2. Rachna Sharir-04 seats No.4, 3. Kriya Sharir- 04 seats Kharghar, 4. Dravyaguna-04 seats Navi Mumbai– 410 210 5. Rasahastra & Bhaisajyakalpna- Maharashtra 08seats 6. Kayachikitsa-04 seats 7. Rognidan- 04 seats 8. Agad tantra- 04 seats 9. Shalya tantra(Samanya)-04 seats 10.Shalya tantra(Ksharsutra Avum Anushastra)- 04 seats 11. Shalakya tanra- 04 seats 22. Desh Bhagat Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG Ayurvedic College & in 02 subjects namely Hospital 1. Kayachikitsa-05 seats Post Box No.5, Amloh 2. Rasashastra-05 seats Dist. Fatehgarh Sahib- 147203 Punjab
193ec minutes 33
23. Shree Chhatrapati Shivaji Recommended for UG 100 seats and PG Education Society’s in 09 subjects namely Dhanwantari Ayurvedic 1. Samhita Siddhanta- 06 seats Medical College, Hospital & 2. Rachna Sharir-06 seats Research Centre, 3. Dravyagune-06 seats Industrial Area, Shiv- 4. Rognidan-06 seats Shankar Nagar, Jatrat 5. Agad tantra-06 seats Road, Nipani-591237, Tal: 6. Kayachiklitsa-04 seats Chikodi, Dist Belgaum, 7. Shalya tantra-06 seats Bangalore, 8. Prasuti tantra-06 seats Karnataka 9. Kaumarbhritya-06 seats 24. Shri Veerpulikeshi Rural Recommended for UG 40 Seats with Vidyavardhak remedial shortcomings. Samasth’s Rural Ayurvedic Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre Opposite J.M.F.Court, Ramadurg Road, P.O & Tq. Badami-587201, Dist. Bagalkot Karnatka 25. Alva’s Ayurveda Medical Recommended for UG 100 seats and PG College in 10 subjects namely Moodbidri, Mangalore 1. Samhita Siddhanta- 05 seats Dist. Dakshin Kannada- 2. Rachna Sharir-05 seats 574227 3. Dravyaguna-05 seats Karnataka 4. Rasashastra & Bhaisajya Kalpana-10 seats 5. Agad tantra-05 seats 6. Prasuti tantra & Striroga-05 seats 7. Kaumarbhritya-05 seats 8. Shalya tantra – 05 seats 9. Kayachikitsa- 05 seats 10.Panchkarma- 05 seats 26. Rajiv Gandhi Govt. Post- Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG Graduate, Ayurvedic in 11 subjects namely College, 1. Kayachikitsa- 06 seats Paprola, Tehsil-Baijnath, 2. Shalya tantra – 04 seats Dist. Kangra-176115 3. Shalakya tantra- 04 seats Himachal Pradesh 4. Samhita Siddhantra- 04 seats 5. Rasashastra-02 seats (instead of 03 seats) 6. Dravyaguna- 02 seats (instead of 03 seats) 7. Rognidan- 02 seats (instead of 03 seats) 8. Prasuti Tantra- 03 seats 9. Balaroga-03 seats
193ec minutes 34
10.Panchkarma- 02 seats (instead of 03 seats ) 11.Swasthavritta- 03 seats
27. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya & Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG Hospital Heggeri in 05 subject namely Extension 1. Samhita Siddhanta-05 seats Old Hubli-508824 2. Kayachikitsa- 05 seats Karnataka 3. Rasashastra- 05 seats 4. Shalya tantra- 02 seats 5. Panchkarma-05 seats 28. Sri Sai Ayurvedic Medical Recommended for UG 75 seats and PG College & Hospital in 02 subject namely Opp. Phal Mandi, 1. Shalya tantra- 04 seats Sarsol, G.T. Road 2. Prasuti tantra- 04 seats Aligarh – 202001 Uttar Pradesh
29. Chaudhary Devilal College Recommended for UG 50 seats of Ayurveda, Bhagwangarh, Buria Road, Tehsil Jagadhri, Distt. Yamuna Nagar, Haryana
30. Swami Kalyandev Not recommended due to following Government Ayurved reasons College 1. Department of Rasashastra, Rampur, Shalya tantra and Panchkarma Muzaffarnagar are vacant Uttar Pradesh 2. There are 25 teachers against the requirement of 27 teachers. 3. Total higher faculties are 09 in 06 department against the requirement of 12 in 11 departments 31. Sri Dharmathala Recommended for UG 75 seats and PG Manjunatheshwara College in 15 subjects namely of Ayurveda and Hospital 1. Samhita Siddhanta- 12 seats Thanniruhalla, B M 2. Rachna Sharir-06 seats Road, 3. Kriya Sharir- 06 seats Taluka & Dist. Hassan- 4. Dravyaguna-06 seats 573201 5. Rasashastra & Bhaisajya Karnataka Kalpana-06 seats 6. Rogindan-06 seats 7. Swasthavritta- 06seats 8. Agad tantra-06 seats 9. Manasroga-06 seats
193ec minutes 35
10.Kaumarbhritya-06 seats 11.Kayachikitsa- 06 seats 12.Panchkarma- 06 seats 13.Prasuti tantra & Striroga-06 seats 14.Shalya tantra – 05 seats 15.Shalakya tantra-04 seats 32. Bharteeya Sanskrit Recommended for UG 40 seats Prabodhini, Gomantak Ayurveda Mahavidyalaya & Research Centre, Kamakshi Arogyadham Vajem, Shiroda Tq. Ponda, Dist. North Goa-403103
33. Shri Basaveshwar Vidya Recommended for UG 50 seats Vardhak Sangha Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Distt. Bagalkot-58710,1 Bijapur Karnataka 34. Siddhakala Ayurved Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG Mahavidyalaya in 06 subjects namely Pimparne Road, 1. Samhita Siddhanta-05 seats Sangamner Kd, (instead of 06) Tal. Sangamner, Dist. 2. Kayachikitsa-02 seats Ahmednagar-422605 3. Prasuti tantra- 02 seats Maharashtra 4. Shalya tantra-02 seats 5. Rogindan-04 seats (instead of 06) Not recommended for PG in Kaumarbhritya – due to deficit in higher faculty 35. Kalmathada Pujya Sri Recommended fro UG 40 seats Virupaksha Shivacharya Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital Manvi-584123, Dist. Raichur Karnataka 36. Shri Jagadguru Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG Gavisiddheshwar Ayurvedic in 09 subjects namely Medical College, Post 1. Dravyaguna-05 seats Graduate Studies & 2. Panchkarma- 05 seats Research Center, 3. Swasthavritta- 05seats Koppal – 583231 4. Rasashastra -05 seats
193ec minutes 36
Karnataka 5. Sharir Kriya-04 seats 6. Shalakya tantra – 04 seats 7. Kaumarbhritya-04 seats 8. Prasuti tantra & Striroga-04 seats 9. Shalya tantra-05 seats 37. K.V.G Ayurved Medical Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG College & Hospital in 06 subjects namely Ambatedka Sullia, Dist. 1. Dravyaguna-06 seats Dakshin 2. Panchkarma- 06 seats Kannada -574327 3. Shalya tantra – 06 seats Karnataka 4. Agad tantra-05 seats 5. Kayachikitsa- 05 seats 6. Rasashastra & Bhaisajya Kalpana- 06 seats 38. Pt. Shiv Shaktilal Sharma Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG Ayurvedic College & in 03 subject namely Hospital 1. Panchkarma- 06 seats Banjali, Sailana Road, 2. Samhita Siddhanta-06 seats Dist. Ratlam-457001 3. Kayachikitsa- 05 seats Madhya Pradesh
39. Guru Nanak Ayurvedic Recommended for UG 60 seats Medical College & Hospital Near Ajit Cinema, Barkandi Road, Taluka: Muktsar-152026 Punjab
40. Guru Nanak Ayurvedic Not recommended as less higher faculty Medical College & in 04 departments. Research Institute, Malerkotla Road, Gopalpur, Near Dehlon, Dist. Ludhiana-141118 Punjab
41. Swami Raghavendracharya Recommended for UG 40 seats with Tridand Ayurved remedial shortcomings. Mahavidyalaya and Chikitsalaya, Karjara Station, PO Manjhouli Via Wazirganj, Gaya- 823001 Bihar
193ec minutes 37
42. SMVVS, Smt. Rajeshwari Not recommended due to deficit of Karpurmath Memorial Higher faculty available in 10 Ayurved Medical College & departments requirement in minimum Research Centre, 100ft. 11 departments. Ring Road, Behind KC Nagar, Bijapur -03 Karnataka 43. Indira Gandhi Memorial Not recommended due to following Ayurvedic Medical College reasons & Hospital, 1. 02 departments are vacant i.e. At-Pokhariput, Dravyaguna and Swasthavritta, P.O.-Khandagiri, 2. No higher faculty in Samhita Dist-Khurda, Siddhanta, Rachna Sharir, Prasuti Bhubaneshwer-751030 tantra, Kaumarbhritya, Orissa Kayachikitsa and Shalakya tantra. 44. Kisan Dnyanoday Mandal Recommended for UG 50 seats with Gudhe’s Ayurved College & remedial shortcomings. Hospital Near Aurangabad Bye Pass,Dhule Raod , Chalisgaon, Dist. Jalgaon-424101 Maharashtra
45. Vaidya Yagya Dutt Sharma Recommended for UG 75 seats and PG Ayurved Mahavidyalaya in 08 subjects namely Opposite Dharpa Power 1. Kriya Sharir-05 seats House, 2. Chaya Avam Vikran- 05 seats Dist. Bulandshahar, 3. Prasuti tantra- 04 seats G.T.Road, 4. Kayachikitsa-05 seats Khurza- 203131 5. Shalya tantra – 05 seats Uttar Pradesh 6. Sangyaharan-05seats 7. Panchkarma-05 seats 8. Kaumarbhritya-05 seats
46. Dr. B.N.M Rural Ayurvedic Not recommended due to less higher Medical College & faculty for UG and PG and many other Hospital shortcomings Smt. Sushiladevi, Nagur Colony College Road, Tq. & Dist. Bijapur-586101 Karnataka
193ec minutes 38
UNANI
Recommendation of Screening Committee held on 27th May, 2014 at New Delhi
It was noted that the meeting of Screening Committee (Unani) under the convenership of Dr. Rashidullah Khan, Vice-President-Unani & President I/c, CCIM was held on 27.05.2014 to scrutinize the visitation reports of Unani Colleges under 13C :-
Present :- 1. Dr. Rashidullah Khan (Vice-President-Unani) , Convener 2. Dr. Shuhabuddin, Member, EC Absent:- 1. Dr. Mohd. Shafique, Member, EC 1. Dr. Shagufta Aleem (Member , CCIM)
On the basis of assessment report prepared by office, the Screening Committee after going through the content of the visitation reports (Part –I & Part –II including all relevant documents & Annexure submitted by the visitors and college) of following Unani Colleges as well as in view of notified Minimum Standard & Requirements of Unani College and attached Hospital Regulations, 2013 made the following recommendations:-
S. V.R. Name of the College Recommendations No. No. 1. 04 Zulfequar Haider Unani Medical Not Recommended College, Siwan (Bihar) 2. 05 Salfia Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 50 seats Darbhanga (Bihar) 3. 06 Nizamia Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 40 seats Gaya (Bihar) 4. 07 Mohsin-e-Millat Unani Medical Not Recommended College, Raipur (CG) 5. 10 IAMS, Srinagar (J&K) Not Recommended
6. 11 Kashmir Unani Medical College, Not Recommended Srinagar (J&K) 7. 15 HMS Unani Medical College, Not Recommended Tumkur (Karnataka) 8. 17 Saifia Unani Medical College, Recommended Burhanpur (MP) 9. 18 Al-Farooque Unani Medical Recommended for UG – 50 seats College, Indore (MP)
193ec minutes 39
10. 20 Hakim Abdul Hameed Unani Not Recommended Medical College, Dewas (MP) 11. 21 MIJ Tibbia College, Mumbai Not Recommended (MS) 12. 22 Mohammadia Tibbia College, Recommended for UG – 60 Seats Malegaon (MS) and PG in Amraze Niswan wa Qabalat – 02 seats However, not recommended for PG in Deptt. of Ilmul Advia. 13. 25 Iqra Unani Medical College, Recommended UG – 50 seats Jalgaon (MS) 14. 26 Rajputana Unani Medical Not Recommended College, Jaipur (Raj.) 15. 28 Govt. Unani Medical College, Not Recommended Chennai (TN) 16. 29 State Takmil ut-tib Unani Not Recommended Medical College, Lucknow (UP) 17. 30 State Unani Medical College, Not Recommended Allahabad (UP) 18. 31 Jamia Tibbia Deoband Unani Recommended for UG – 50 Medical College, Saharanpur (UP) Seats and PG – 04 Seats in Moalajat 19. 32 Ibne Sina Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 50 Azamgarh (UP) Seats 20. 33 Deoband Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 40 Saharanpur (UP) Seats and PG in Munafeul Aza – 02 Seats, Niswan wa Qabalat – 02 Seats and Jarahat – 02 Seats. However not recommended for PG in Moalajat 21. 34 Allama Iqbal Unani Medical Recommended for UG – 40 College, Muzaffarnagar (UP) Seats 22. 35 Aligarh Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 40 ACN, Aligarh (UP) Seats 23. 36 SGM Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 40 Ghazipur (UP) Seats 24. 38 Abdul Ali Tibbia College, Not Recommended Lucknow (UP) 25. 40 Calcutta Unani Medical College, Recommended for UG – 40 Kolkata (WB) Seats
26. 41 Yunus Fazlani Unani Medical Recommended for UG – 50 College, Auranagabad (UP) Seats
193ec minutes 40
27. 42 Hakim Rais Unani Medical Recommended for UG – 50 College, Sambhal, Moradabad Seats (UP)
SIDDHA
Recommendation for the Siddha Colleges for session 2014-15 under Section 13C of the screening committee held on 03-04.04.2014 and finalized on 28.05.2014 are as below:-
Sl.No. Name of the college Observation of the screening committee 1. Govt. Siddha Medical College, Recommended for UG 100 Seats Palayamkottai, TN and PG 37 Seats (6 Subjects) 1. Maruthuvam - 6 Seats; 2. Gunapadam - 8 Seats; 3.Sirappumaruthuvam- 6 Seats; 4. Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam-6 Seats 5. Noi Naadal and Noi Mudhal Naadal- 5 Seats; 6. Nanju Noolum Maruthuva Neethi Noolum-6 Seats. 2. Govt. Siddha Medical College, Chennai, TN Recommended for UG 50 Seats and PG 28 Seats (5 Subjects) 1. Maruthuvam - 9 Seats; 2. Gunapadam - 6 Seats; 3. Sirappumaruthuvam – 5 Seats; 4. Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam- 4 Seats; 5. Noi Naadal and Noi Mudhal Naadal - 4 Seats. 3. Akila Thiruvithamcore Siddha Vaidya Recommended for 40 UG Seats. Sangam Siddha Maruthuva Kallory & Hospital, Munchirai, KANYAKUMARI. TN 4. Velumailu Siddha Medical College, Recommended for UG 40 Seats Sriperumbudur, TN 5. Sri Sairam Siddha Medical College and Recommended for UG 50 Seats Research Centre, Chennai. 6. Santhigiri Siddha Medical College, Recommended for UG 50 Seats Thiruvanathapuram. Kerala
193ec minutes 41
7. National Institute of Siddha, Tambaram Recommended for PG 46 seats CHENNAI 106. TN (6 Specialities) 1.Maruthuvam-8 Seats 2.Gunapadam-8 Seats 3.Sirappu Maruthuvam -8 Seats 4.Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -8 Seats 5.Noi Nadal-7 Seats 6.Nanjunoolum Maruthuva Neethinoolum-7 Seats 8. Recommended for UG 30 seats RVS Siddha Medical College, Coimbatore. 9. Recommended for UG 50 seats. Sivaraj Siddha Medical College, Salem.
s
Executive Committee approved the same and decided to send the recommendations to Govt. of India except for the college at Sr. No. 4 i.e. Velumailu Siddha Medical College, T.N. for which EC decided that recommendation will be sent after verification of land details.
Addl. Agenda Item No. 7. Regarding recommendation of Sindagi Shanta Veereshwar Ayurvedic Medical College, Haweri (Karnataka) under Section 13C.
It was noted that due to oversight, the Screening Committee while scruitnizing the Visitation Report of Sindagi Shanta Veereshwar Ayurvedic Medical College, Haweri (Karnataka) under Section 13C has recommend for UG 50 seats instead of 40 seats as sanctioned by Govt. of India. Therefore, the seats as reported to 192nd EC in respect of said college be read as 40 seats.
Further, it is informed that the recommendations of said college as per actual sanctioned seats by GOI have been sent with the approval of President I/c, CCIM.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.8. Expenditure for the month of April, 2014- regarding.
It was noted that the Central Council has made the following expenditure in the month of April, 2014:-
S.NO. NAME OF HEAD AMOUNT 1. Pay of Secy./Estab. 793884 2. Dearness Allowance 885634 3. HRA 240690 4. TPA with D.A. 170820
193ec minutes 42
5. W.A. 600 6. NPS Tier-I 38286 7. Pension 521907 8. L.T.C 25700 9. Consolidated Salary 405725 10. Medical Reimb. 1409 11. OTA/ Compensation Allowance 1100 12. Tuition Fee 141566 13. Telephone 6902 14. Printing 1720 15. Newspapers & Periodicals Books 869 16. I.T 2618 17. Misc. Exps. 37207 18. T.D.S. 45116 19. T.A. President 23448 20. T.A. Estab. 62058 21. T.A. Executive Committee 1134884 22. T.A. Sub-Committee 36509 23. T.A. Member of Council 361371 24. Conveyance 900 25. T.A. Visitation (Ayu.) 1354254 26. T.A. Visitation (Unani) 308846 27. T.A. Visitation (Siddha) 41207 28. T.A. Bridge Course 70250 29. Seminar 16602 30. Honorarium 45750 31. DPC/Selection Comm. 28727 TOTAL 68,06,559
Executive Committee noted the same. It was also decided that air journey below 500 Km is not allowed for all CCIM members (except entitled member/expert, etc) as per rules.
Addl. Agenda Item No.9. Representation received regarding application of aggregate passing (40:50 rule) for Post graduate students (MD, MS Ayurved) appearing for examination.
It was noted that a letter has been received from Dr. Shailesh. S. Nikam, General Secretary, N.I.M.A regarding aggregate passing (40:50 rule) for Post graduate students (MD, MS Ayurved) appearing for examination referring the Dental Council of India Norm as under DCI revised MDS course regulation, 2007. As per the
193ec minutes 43 applicant, the students undergoing the Postgraduate (MD, MS Ayurveda) course have the passing criteria of obtaining 50% marks in respective subjects at present. In the modified structure, a candidate appearing for the exam would need to obtain aggregate 50% marks in his exams including Theory (I+II+II+IV) & Practicals individually. The minimum passing criteria for each paper in theory would be 40% only. This revision has been brought into force by many Councils, Universities & will save the suffering of candidates disqualifying by minimal difference in the exam.
Further, it was noted that a similar matter {Representation received from students of MUHS, Nashik regarding assessment of final year exam of MD/MS (Ayurved) course} was discussed in 190th EC meeting held on 04.04.2014 and the decision of the Executive Committee is as under:
“Executive Committee decided that in the final year examination of PG the candidate is required to obtained minimum 50% marks in aggregate in theory instead of 50% marks in individual papers.”
Executive Committee decided to forward the matter to Regulation Committee.
Addl. Agenda Item No.10. Visitation report of Ganga Education Society’s Ayurvedic Medical College, Kolhapur, Maharashtra under Section 13 C of the IMCC Act, 1970.
It was noted that Ganga Education Society’s Ayurvedic Medical College, Kolhapur, Maharashtra was visited by Dr. Satya Dev Khichariya and Dr. Sudarshan Behera on 27th & 28th January, 2014. After going through the visitation report, it had been found that only Part-II was submitted by the visitors. Therefore, as per decision of the EC clarification had been asked from the visitors. It is further submitted that in response to the same, the clarification received from one visitor named Dr. Satya Dev Khichariya is as under: “at the time of the visitation of Ganga Education Society’s Ayurvedic Medical College, Kolhapur, Maharashtra dated 27th & 28th January, 2014, after reaching there we found the institute and their Associated Hospital was locked since last few months as quarry collected from their neighbor residents by us. The profarma Part-I has been provided by the college only. Due to the locked institute we couldn’t found that Proforma Part-I.”
Executive Committee noted the same.
193ec minutes 44
Addl. Agenda Item No.11. Declaration of property details of the employees and members of CCIM.
It was noted that as per the direction of the President I/c, CCIM, the property details of the employees of CCIM and members of CCIM is required to be declared to the Council.
Executive Committee approved the same for office employees only.
Addl. Agenda Item No.12. Newspaper Report regarding arrest of Dr. Surendra Patel, Member, CCIM.
It was noted that as per reports published in various English & Hindi newspapers, among other persons, Dr. Surendra Patel, member of CCIM has also been reported to have been arrested by the State Police of Madhya Pradesh in mal-practice in the examination for the appointments in State Government.
In this connections, it was noted that Dr. Surendra Patel is an elected member of the CCIM under Section 3(1)(a) of the IMCC Act, 1970 from the State of Madhya Pradesh since 13th September, 2011.
Executive Committee decided that as the matter is of serious nature, hence the member in question will not be assigned any work of the Central Council of Indian Medicine till the final outcome of the investigation.
Further, a letter is to be sent to concerned Police Station, M.P. to obtain relevant documents and statement of the said member.
It was also decided that the recommendations in respect of colleges which have been visited by the said member will not be sent to Govt. of India unless the Visitation Reports are again verified by the Council. If any recommendations of such colleges have been sent to Govt. of India, they will be recalled and will be sent again after verification of the report.
Addl. Agenda Item No.13. Ratification of the decision of President I/C, CCIM in respect of payment to Senior Advocate and Additional Advocates appearing on behalf of CCIM before Supreme Court of India and various High Courts.
It was noted that given below are the details of payments done by CCIM to Senior/Additional Advocates with the sanction of President I/C, CCIM for pursuing the cases before the Supreme Court of India and various High Courts:-
193ec minutes 45
S.No. Particulars Amount paid/to be paid (Rs.) 1. SLP No. 5230/2014, CCIM V/s Dr. Ved Prakash 3,30,000/- Tyagi, Supreme Court of India – 27.02.2014- Paras Kuhad 2. W.P. No. 1754/2014, Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors. V/s UOI & Ors, Nainital High Court – 04.03.2014- Tasneem Ahmadi 36,300/- 3. W.P. No. 575(MS) of 2014 and SPA No. 70 of 2014 Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi V/s UOI & Ors. Nainital High Court – 19.03.2014 & 20.03.2014- Tasneem Ahmadi 72,600/- 4. SLP No. 5230/2014 Central Council of Indian Medicine V/s Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors, Supreme Court – 10.03.2014- 36,300/- Tasneem Ahmadi
5. W.P. No. 1754/2013 Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors V/s UOI & Ors. Nainital High Court – 17.02.2014 Tasneem Ahmadi 96,800/- 6. SLP No. 5230/2014 CCIM V/s Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors. Tasneem Ahmadi 72,600/- 7. CCIM V/s Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors (SPL. No. 15/2014)Nainital High Court at Uttrakhand – 6,000/- 03.02.2014 & 10.02.2014. Legal Axis
8. Dr. M. Trinadha Rao V/s Executive Officer & Ors. (WPC 253/2014) Hyderabad High Court – 04.02.2014 - Legal Axis 6,000/-
9. Sri Satya Sai Murlidhar Ayurvedic College & Hospital Vs. UOI & Ors. (W.P.C. No. 26013/2013) 6,000/- Punjab & Haryana High court- Legal Axis
10. Om Prakash Purushootam V/s UOI (W.P.C. No. 5082/2013) Bombay High Court at Nagpur- Legal Axis 14,750/- 11. Santosh Vs. State of Maharashtra (W.P.C. No. 6495/2013)
Bombay High Court at Nagpur- 06.02.2014, 20.02.2014 & 18,000/- 07.03.2014- Legal Axis 12. Dr. Arun Kumar Dwivedi Vs. State of U.P. (W.P.C. No. 63313/2013) Bombay High Court at Nagpur- Legal Axis 21,350/- 13. Riyazuddin Vs. State of NCT of Delhi (CRLA 577/2013) 12,000/- Delhi High Court, New Delhi 14. Satish Chander Tiwari vs. UOI (W.P.C. No. 64291/2013) Allahabad High Court Legal Axis 6,000/- 15. Anu S. Prasad & Ors. Vs. Central Council of Indian Medicine & Ors (SLP No. 39221/2013) Supreme Court of India 16,750/- 16. Ashok Kumar Vs. UOI & Ors. District Court Pujnjab Legal Axis 6,000/-
17. CCIM vs. Ved Prakash Tyagi (SLP No. 5230/2014) Supreme Court of India Legal Axis 27,000/-
193ec minutes 46
18. Legal Opinion with regards to the election of members- Legal Axis 2,000/-
19. Complaint against official of Dharma college of Ayurveda- Legal Axis 2,000/-
TOTAL 7,88,450/-
Executive Committee noted and approved/ratified the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.14. Filing of S.L.P. No. 14024/2014 titled as CCIM V/s T. Retnapandian & ors. before Supreme Court of India, at New Delhi.
It was noted that Madras High Court, Madurai Bench has passed the orders dated 26/3/14, 03/4/14, 7/4/14, 16/4/14 in WP No.4713/2014 titled as T. Retnapandian V/s UOI & ors. whereby the said court has stayed the declaration of result of election to the post of President, CCIM held on 20/3/14. Aggrieved from the above said orders, CCIM filed the SLP before the Supreme Court seeking quashing of the said orders of Madras High Court, Madurai Bench. The SLP was listed on 22.05.2014 and the Court issued notice (Dasti) to the respondents. The next date of hearing is 02.06.2014.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.15. Filing of S.L.P. titled as CCIM V/s Ved Prakash Tyagi & Ors. before Supreme Court of India, at New Delhi.
It was noted that an order dt.13/5/14 has been passed by Nainitaal High Court, Division Bench in Special Appeal No.70/14 filed by Ved Prakash Tyagi assailing the order dt.10/3/14 of Single Judge, Nainitaal High Court in WP No.1754/13. Vide order dated 13/5/14, the DB has remanded the WP No.1754/13 to the single Judge, Nainitaal High Court for disposal. The CCIM was not heard by DB before passing the order dt.13/5/14. Aggrieved by the order dated 13/5/14 of Division Bench of Nainital High Court, CCIM filed the SLP challenging the order dt.13/5/14.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.16. Regarding final syllabus of 3rd and 4th professional year for BAMS.
It was noted that a meeting to finalize the syllabus of the 3rd and 4th professional year for BAMS was conducted in the office of CCIM, New Delhi on 12-13.05.2014.
The final syllabus submitted by concerned subject experts in the meeting was considered by the Committee.
193ec minutes 47
Executive Committee noted and approved the same and also decided to send to all the concerned as well as to upload on CCIM website. It was also decided that the entire syllabus may now be got printed in binding/ in the shape of book.
Addl. Agenda Item No.17. Reporting on the decision of Govt. of India in respect of Bundelkhand Government Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital, Gwalior Road, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh in compliance to Court Order.
It was noted that Govt. of India has forwarded the decision of following college in compliance to the Court Order dated 13.03.2014 of Hon’ble Court of Allahabad under Civil Misc. W.P. No. 48027/2013 & 31178/2013 as under
S. Name of the College Decision of Govt. Of India for the no. session 2012-13 1. Bundelkhand Government Permitted vide letter No. R- Ayurvedic Medical College & 17011/195/2012-EP(IM-1) Hospital, Gwalior Road, Jhansi, dated: 30.04.2014 Uttar Pradesh
Executive Committee noted the same.
Addl. Agenda Item No.18. Authorization for issuing Enrolment Certificates/Direct Registration Certificates, getting published the Central Registers and Various Regulations in the Gazette of India.
It was noted that the EC in its meeting held on 22.10.2013 decided to withdraw its decision of revocation of suspension of Dr. P.R. Sharma, Registrar-cum-Secretary (taken on 23.08.2013 in 181st meeting of EC) with immediate effect pending enquiry proceedings. Accordingly, Dr. P.R. Sharma, Registrar-cum-Secretary was suspended w.e.f. 22.10.2013 (A.N.).
In this connection, Dr. P. R. Sharma, approached to the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench at New Delhi and got his suspension stayed vide order passed in O.A. No.3904/2013 filed by Dr. P. R. Sharma V/s UOI & Ors. Accordingly, Dr. P. R. Sharma, Registrar-cum-Secretary was allowed to attend the office vide Office Order No. 30-5/2013-CC (42) dated 04.11.2013 alongwith the said order dated 01.11.2013. He joined his duty w.e.f. 08.11.2013.
193ec minutes 48
In this connection, it is further submitted that Dr. P. R. Sharma was allowed to join the office in view of order of CAT but no work was allotted to him. Since, Dr. P. R. Sharma being the Registrar-cum-Secretary of this Council was the DDO but no work was allotted to him due to which the obligatory work and duties envisaged in him could not has been discharged and all financial matters were stagnated and even normal routine work was hampering. It was, therefore, decided that in the present circumstance, it would be appropriate, if a senior officer of the Council is authorized to discharge the powers and duties of the Registrar-cum-Secretary/DDO. Executive committee after detailed discussion and taking the present situation decided that Dr. Shamshad Bano, Assistant Registrar (Unani) may be authorized to discharge the duties of the DDO till further orders.
Accordingly, an Office Order was issued for Dr. Shamshad Bano, Asstt. Registrar (Unani) to discharge the duties of Registrar-cum-Secretary/DDO etc. and since then all Bank Accounts of the Council are being operated with the signature of Dr. Shamshad Bano, Asstt. Registrar (Unani) in the capacity of Registrar-cum- Secretary/DDO which is the vested power in Registrar-cum-Secretary.
In this connection, it is further submitted that as per Section 23(1) of the IMCC Act, 1970, the Central Council shall cause to be maintained the Central Register of Indian Medicine containing the names of all persons who possess any of the recognised medical qualifications. As per section 23(2) of the said Act, it is the duty of the Registrar of the Council to keep and maintain the Central Register of Indian Medicine in accordance with the provisions of the said Act and orders made by the Central Council from time to time and publish the same in the Gazette of India in the manner as may be prescribed. Also, as per provision made under Section 25 of the said Act, it is for the Registrar to grant registration on the application made by any person and enter his name in the Central Register of Indian Medicine in the prescribed manner.
The Central Register is prepared and got published in the Gazette of India in the manner already prescribed by the Central Council and Enrolment Certificate/Direct Registration Certificate is accordingly issued to all the concerned. To execute these functions, the name of Asstt. Registrar (Unani) is being used as Registrar-cum- Secretary and she has been putting her signature on it.
But it has now been pointed out that in the present situation, when Dr. P. R. Sharma is in office, how statutory functions like operating Bank Accounts in the capacity of DDO would be discharged by some other officer and Gazette Notifications including various Regulations/Enrolment Certificates/Direct Registration Certificates/I.Cards etc. will be issued whereas such powers are vested in Registrar-cum-Secretary.
Since, the above work of publishing the Central Register of Indian Medicine including regulations, issuing the Enrolment Certificate/Direct Registration Certificate have to be performed in the prescribed manner by the Central Council, but the Central Council has not allotted any work to the existing Registrar as per its own decision due to finding him to have been indulged in some illegalities, it would, therefore, be in order and in public interest that the works of mandatory nature may not suffer
193ec minutes 49 further and Dr. Shamshad Bano, Asstt. Registrar (Unani) who has already been authorized to perform as DDO, and who is already discharging the functions as mentioned above, may further be authorized to get the Central Register of Indian Medicine published in the Gazette of India and to issue the Enrolment Certificate/Direct Registration Certificates/I.Cards etc. in the capacity of Asstt. Registrar (Unani) itself henceforth and such works done/being done may be treated for and on behalf of the CCIM with full competency as that of Registrar, CCIM.
Executive Committee decided that only Registrar be printed and the officer/person who is discharging the duties of Registrar at that particular time will sign over the Enrolment Certificate/Direct Registration Certificate/ I-Cards /the Gazette Notifications.
Addl. Agenda Item No.19. Regarding extreme corruption by AYUSH Deptt. Councils.
It was noted that a letter has been received from Govt. of India, Deptt. of AYUSH vide no. Z.28015/02/2014-EP(IM-2) dated 23.04.2014, forwarding a copy of letter dated 10.01.2014 from PMO enclosing therewith a representation dated 03.01.2014 of Dr. Satpathi on the subject cited above to examine the matter.
The contents of the representation of Dr. Satpathi are as under
“I am well wisher of congress. AYUSH Dept. Council‟s namely is Central Council Homeopathy, New Delhi & Central Council of Indian Medicine, New Delhi defaming current Govt. by illegal activities in name of ruling party. They are conduction inspection in short duration (like 10 month-1years) as against rule of one inspection every 3 years for established colleges. During inspection, inspectors and Council office bearer are demanding very very high sums in Lakhs as gifts to make the correct report or else they are ready to create pseudo negative report and defame college also. If college managements revolt they threaten them in name of Central ruling congress party & show fear to withdrawn permission. Under these conditions, when 2014 election are proposed this activities puts a very bad impression of congress in college owners/staff/students & relatives too as each time there is inspections all of them are over burdened with hectic work & leaves stand cancelled. So they all speak ill about ruling party. Atleast till elections, councils & AYUSH Dept. should be strictly warned to stop illegal activities & corruption. In Central Council of Homeopathy, New Delhi there is monopoly of President Dr Ramjee Singh and his favorites Vice President Dr. Arun Bhasme is still continuing is post after 4 years of completing his turn but no one can dare to give any different opinion.
Expecting the appropriate response.”
Executive Committee took the matter seriously and decided to take stern action, if anything brought to the notice of the Council.
193ec minutes 50
Addl. Agenda Item No.20. Recommendation of the Screening Committee in respect of of Maharashtra Arogya Mandal’s Sumati Bhai Shah Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Malwadi, Hadapsar , Tal:Haveli, Distt. Pune, Maharashtra and Bharti Vidyapeeth’s University, College of Ayurved, Satara Road, Tal. Haveli, Pune, Maharashtra under Section 13C for the session 2014-15.
It was noted that due to oversight in the sanctioned seats of Maharashtra Arogya Mandal’s Sumati Bhai Shah Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Malwadi, Hadapsar , Tal:Haveli, Distt. Pune, Maharashtra and Bharti Vidyapeeth’s University, College of Ayurved, Satara Road, Tal. Haveli, Pune, Maharashtra, seats of PG Diploma course has not been mentioned in the assessment as sanctioned by GOI. Therefore, in the recommendation of Screening Committee as well as in decision of 192nd E.C. meeting held on 16.05.2014 , the recommendation for PG Diploma course has been left. Further, it was noted that with the approval of President I/c, the reports of these colleges are again refer to Screening Committee consisting of Dr. Amitabh Kumar, Dr. Uday Kumar, Dr. Srinivas Bannigol and Dr. Umesh Shukla dated 27.05.2014 for their recommendation. After reconsidering the reports the recommendation of Screening Committee is as under:
S.No Name of College Recommendation of screening committee 1. Maharashtra Arogya Mandal’s Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in 10 subjects namely, Sumati Bhai shah Ayurved 1.Samhita Siddhanta-06 Mahavidyalaya Malwadi, Hadapsar 2. Rachna Sharir-06 ,Tal:Haveli, Distt. Pune, Maharashtra 3. Kriya Sharir-06 4. Dravyaguna-06 5.Rasashastra and Bhaisajya Kalpana-06 6.Rognidan-06 7. Prasuti Tantra-06 8.Agad Tantra-06 9.Kayachikitsa-06 10.Shalya Tantra-06 Recommended for PG Diploma course in 1.Ayurvedic Pharmaceutics-Rasashastra & Bhaisajya Kalpna-05 2. Prasuti Tantra &Stri Rog-05 2. Bharti Vidyapeeth’s University, Recommended for UG 100 seats and PG in 14 subjects namely, College of Ayurved, Satara Road, 1.Samhita Siddhant-04 Tal. Haveli, Pune, Maharashtra 2.Rachna Sharir -04 3.Dravyaguna-04 4.Kriya sharir-04 5.Rasashastra and Bhaisajya Kalpna-04 6.Rognidan-03 7. Swasthvritta-05 8.Agad Tantra-04 9.Prasuti tantra and Stri Rog-05 10.Kaumarbhritya-04 11.Kayachikitsa-05
193ec minutes 51
12.Shalya Tantra-04 13.Shalakya Tantra-04 14.Panchkarma-03 Recommended for PG Diploma course in 1. Panchkarma-02 2. Ayurveda Sangyaharan-02 3. Ayurvedic Cosmetology and Skin-02 4. Prasuti Tantra & Stri Rog-02 5. Balrog-02 6. Netra rog-02
Executive Committee noted the same and ratified.
Addl. Agenda Item No.21. Recommendation of the Screening Committee in respect of Ayurved Colleges after review regarding.
It was noted that decision of the Screening Committee I respect of the following colleges has been placed below 192nd EC Committee held on 16.05.2014 and EC decided to review the decision regarding recommendation of Screening Committee.
Further, it was noted that in compliance of decision of EC, the Visitation Report of these colleges has been placed before Screening Committee on 28.05.2014 for review of decision. The decisions of Screening Committee are as under:-
Sl.No. Name of College Remark of Screening Committee 1. Dr. Vandanatai Jagannathrao Dhone Gramin Ayurved Recommended for UG 50 seats. Mahavidyalaya Taluka Patur – 444501, Dist. Akola Maharashtra 2. Vidarbha Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Dhawantari Recommended for UG 50 seats and PG in 3 subjects namely Nagar, Chhatri Talao Road, Taluka & District 1. Kayachikitsa 2 seats Amrawati 444606 Maharashtra 2. Shalya Samanya 3 seats 3. Shalakya 2 seats Not recommended for Swasthavritta due to deficit lower and higher faculty. 3. Shubhdeep Ayurved Medical College Gram- Not recommended for UG and PG due to following reasons. Datoda, Khandwa Road Teh. Mhow, Near Chokhi 1. The available higher faculties are only in 10 departments against Dhani Dist.- Indore-452020 the requirement in 11 departments. Madhya Pradesh 2. Since the college is the not fulfilling the UG requirements, the PG seats can not be recommended.
4. Muniyal Institute of Ayurveda Medical Sciences Not recommended due to following reasons No.34/C, Shivalli Insdustrial Area 1. The higher faculties are only in 07 departments against the Taluk & Distt. Udupi, Manipal requirement in 11 departments. Karnataka 5. Bapuji Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital, Not recommended due to following reasons Sowlanga Road, Opp. A.G. College, 1. The higher faculties are only in 10 departments against the Channamumbapura, Shimoga, Karnataka requirement in 11 departments.
Executive Committee ratified the same.
193ec minutes 52
Addl. Agenda Item No.22. Discussion on the functioning of CCIM officers regarding.
With the permission of the Chair, a discussion was held with regard to the functioning of CCIM officers and it was noted that although Dr. Shamshad Bano, Asstt. Registrar (Unani) who is presently looking after and discharging the duties of the Registrar-cum-Secretary is performing promptly but there is a lot to improve her functionality and working behaviour.
The EC noted it and directed the Asstt. Registrar (Unani) to be cautious and responsive in future.
The meeting concluded with a vote of thanks to the Chair.
193ec minutes 53