CHRISTOPHER GUILDFORD Chairman

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

CHRISTOPHER GUILDFORD Chairman GS 1841 GENERAL SYNOD RELATIONS WITH THE UNITED REFORMED CHURCH A report by the Council for Christian Unity, to which is appended HEALING THE PAST – BUILDING THE FUTURE : REPORT OF A CHURCH OF ENGLAND – UNITED REFORMED CHURCH STUDY GROUP 1. The report is the fruit of three separate series of informal conversations between our two churches in the past two decades, but it deals with unfinished business that goes back to the English Civil War and the Restoration in the mid-seventeenth century. In the view of the Council for Christian Unity, the report and the actions that it proposes will contribute to the healing of the historic divisions between our two churches and will draw them closer together for the future. The United Reformed Church has welcomed the report and approved its recommendations. 2. The report summarises the history of the relations between the Church of England and the United Reformed Church and its historic predecessor churches and outlines areas of theological convergence, together with areas where differences remain. 3. The report concludes (paragraph 144) with the following recommendations, which have been endorsed by the CCU and the Faith and Order Commission: a) That representatives of the two churches should join together in an act of worship in 2012, that would mark both the 350 th anniversary of the Great Ejection of nonconforming ministers following the Act of Uniformity 1662 and the 40 th anniversary of the inauguration of the United Reformed Church. The service should contain an expression of penitence for our part in perpetuating the divisions of the past, a desire for the healing of memories and an act of commitment to work more closely together in the future. b) That in the new climate created by the joint act of reconciliation and commitment, further joint work should be undertaken on certain topics, mainly concerning ministry and authority in the church. 4. The report will be introduced by the Bishop of Guildford as Chairman of the Council for Christian Unity. The Synod will be invited to approve the two recommendations of the report outlined in 4 above. On behalf of the Council CHRISTOPHER GUILDFORD Chairman 1 HEALING THE PAST – BUILDING THE FUTURE The report of the Church of England – United Reformed Church Joint Study Group. Introduction by the co-convenors Jesus prayed ‘may they all be one, as you Father are in me and I am in you, may they also be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me. ’ John 17.21 NRSV The Church of England and United Reformed Church agreed to explore their shared ecumenical commitment through the study of the international Anglican Reformed document, God’s Reign and our Unity. A group of seven people, three Church of England, three United Reformed and one Methodist, met on seven occasions over the period 2007 – 2010. This study group built on the insights of various conversations, both multi-lateral and bi-lateral, over the last seventy years, including most recently, an Anglican/United Reformed Church dialogue and a trilateral informal conversation between the Church of England, the Methodist Church and the United Reformed Church. The shared commitment to unity was re-visited through looking at the Church of England’s Thirty- nine Articles and the United Reformed Church’s Basis of Union. Scripture, the tradition of the church and God’s mission imperative in a changing world are all drivers in the search for unity. Within each of our two churches, there is a varied understanding of the role that Scripture plays in the Christian life. However, there is common agreement about the centrality of scripture in shaping the Christian life. Our two churches have historically diverged from one another, as we have each sought to be shaped by the Holy Spirit, but discovered that our discernment of the Spirit was leading us in different directions. However, we each affirm the activity of the Spirit in the life of the church and share a common desire to be shaped by the mind of Christ. We also gathered aware of the influence that the discrepancy in size of membership between our two churches has to play. The context of the conversations undertaken by this study group has been one of challenge and change, in the church and in the world which the church seeks to witness to and to serve. Society has become more plural in terms of faith, whether in the major faith traditions, more contemporary outcrops of spirituality, or in the rise of atheism. Spirituality has become a watchword, but has not necessarily been interpreted within a Christian context. The post-Enlightenment rise of individualism has led to a point where each individual feels free to determine his or her own beliefs without need of a wider reference point. In the main, church-going has been declining, apart from areas blessed by immigration and the rise of Pentecostalism. Mainstream churches have been faced with ageing congregations and reducing resources. External pressures have turned churches inwards in terms of their priority being their own renewal. Internal divisions have led to questions about unity being more widely debated within, rather than between, churches. 2 In this context, responding to Jesus’ prayer that his followers might be one, has become more of a challenge. However, the study group believes that it is an essential challenge for the churches to respond to and a key part of the churches witness to a fragmented world. The setting up of a Church of England/United Reformed study group, rather than formal conversations, has been a reflection of the diminution of the emphasis on unity across the churches. However, the life of a study group has meant that discussion could happen more freely and under less pressure, than in a formal conversation which needed to lead to a specific agreement. The study group would like to offer this ecumenical methodology as a way forward in building relationships and reflecting on difficult issues between churches. This process has allowed nettles to be grasped without the pressure of decisions needing to be made. It is our hope and our prayer that the Holy Spirit will continue to open up new possibilities of conversation with one another, conversations that lead us more closely to the mind of Christ and equip us better to engage in the wider mission conversations that lie before us in the world. We have been grateful to the work of the two co-secretaries in drafting an extensive and valuable report, outlining the conversations that have already taken place over the last century, the particular issues that arise today and the setting of these issues within the context of other international agreements, such as Reuilly and Leuenberg and through the work of the World Council of Churches. The Venerable Dr Joy Tetley, Church of England co-convenor The Reverend Elizabeth Welch, United Reformed Church co-convenor 3 The shape of the report The report is in three sections. Section 1 (pages 3-16) explains the background to the meetings of the study group in the history of the relationship between the Church of England, the United Reformed Church and the Christian traditions out of which it was formed. Section 2 (pages 17-32) describes the meetings of the study group and sets out the key areas of convergence and divergence between the Church of England and the United Reformed Church that emerged during these meetings. Section 3 (pages 32-33) contains the study group’s conclusions and recommendations. The key conclusions are that the two churches can and should take steps towards a closer relationship and the key recommendation is that there should be a joint service of recognition, penitence and mutual commitment at Westminster Abbey in 2012, the fortieth anniversary of the founding of the United Reformed Church and the three hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the Great Ejection of 1662, as a way of formally inaugurating this closer relationship. Section 1. The background to the study group 1. During the period of the Civil War and the Commonwealth a series of Acts of Parliament abolished episcopacy, the 1559 Book of Common Prayer, the Thirty Nine Articles and the traditional liturgical calendar from the life of the Church in England. Those who remained loyal to the Church of England as it had been before the Civil War looked for the day when all these changes could be reversed and those clergy who had lost their livings because of their loyalty to the bishops and the king could have their livings restored. 2. Their opportunity came with the failure of the Commonwealth and the restoration of the Monarchy in 1660 and their sense of bitterness over what had happened in the preceding years meant that they were not inclined to compromise with those who thought differently from them. The result was that when the Savoy Conference of 1661 failed to achieve agreement on the revision of the Book of Common Prayer between those representing the newly restored bishops and those representing a Presbyterian approach to church polity, those clergy who were unwilling to promise to use only the rites and ceremonies of the Prayer Book or to receive episcopal ordination were given a choice of either conforming or being deprived of their livings on St Bartholomew’s day, 24 August 1662. Many of those who felt they could not conform held to an understanding of the work of the Holy Spirit in worship which set them against a restriction to prescribed forms. Freedom of worship, an antipathy to prelacy and a rejection of Establishment were all theological issues involved in the early history of Dissent which continue to be alive today.
Recommended publications
  • The Creeds, Confessions and Liturgical Forms of the Reformed
    THE CREEDS, CONFESSIONS AND LITURGICAL FORMS OF THE REFORMED CHURCHES OF NEW ZEALAND THE CREEDS, CONFESSIONS AND LITURGICAL FORMS OF THE REFORMED CHURCHES OF NEW ZEALAND Published in 2015 by the Forms and Confessions Committee in conjunction with the National Publications Committee of the Reformed Churches of New Zealand. This book is not copyrighted. Any part of it is freely available for use by anyone interested. Scripture taken from the Holy Bible, New International Version. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984 International Bible Society. Used by permission of Zondervan Bible Publishers. ISBN 978-0-473-28109-0 Contents Ecumenical Creeds The Apostles’ Creed ................................................................................................................ 8 The Nicene Creed.................................................................................................................... 9 The Athanasian Creed ........................................................................................................... 10 Confessions The Heidelberg Catechism .................................................................................................... 13 The Belgic Confession .......................................................................................................... 57 The Canons of Dort ............................................................................................................... 75 The Westminster Confession of Faith ..................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Conciliation Agreement in Full, with the Agreement of Both Parties
    STATEMENT A statement from the Diocese of Guildford EMBARGOED UNTIL WEDNESDAY 23 OCTOBER 2013, 6.01AM The Diocese of Guildford can confirm that a formal complaint by the Board of Deputies against the Revd Dr Stephen Sizer has been resolved through conciliation under the Clergy Discipline Measure. The process was led by two expert conciliators, senior figures from the Jewish and Anglican Christian communities, respectively Sir Gavin Lightman, a retired High Court Judge, and The Very Revd Dr Christopher Lewis, Dean of Christ Church Cathedral, Oxford. The process also included a face-to-face meeting between both parties The Bishop of Guildford, The Rt Revd Christopher Hill welcomed the outcome, saying: “I am deeply grateful for the painstaking work of Sir Gavin and Dr Lewis in bringing the parties together to achieve this positive outcome. I am equally thankful to Jonathan Arkush and Stephen Sizer for cooperating in agreement towards resolution of their differences. Both sides have agreed on the importance of engaging in free political debate without using insulting or offensive language. Dr Sizer will be taking more care in future when linking to external websites. “I am pleased to note that both parties have agreed to endeavour to resolve any future disputes promptly, informally and by personal contact’. “I welcome the sprit of this agreement as positive step towards Jewish-Christian understanding. I am also pleased to take this opportunity once again to emphasise how important it is for the Church to stand firm against all forms of prejudice and the evils of racial hatred.” ENDS Notes for editors The text of the Conciliators’ report to the Bishop is attached and may be published from 9am on Wednesday, 23 October.
    [Show full text]
  • Guildford Cathedral – Accounts, 2011
    GUILDFORD CATHEDRAL Annual Report and Consolidated Financial Statements For the year ended 31st December 2011 GUILDFORD CATHEDRAL Annual Report for the year ended 31st December 2011 Index Annual Report Page Mission Statement & Statement of Direction & Intent 2-3 Structure & Management 3-5 Annual Report of the Chapter 6-9 Financial Review of Cathedral Activities 9-11 Appendices 1 Management Organisation 2 The Cathedral Chapter 3 Chapter Members’ Portfolios 4 The Cathedral Council 5 The College of Canons 6 The Honorary Assistants 7 The Cathedral Finance Committee 8 The Cathedral Community Committee 9 The Fabric Advisory Committee 10 The Guildford Cathedral Shops Board 11 The Cathedral Lay Staff 12 The Senior Volunteers 13 The Cathedral Officers & Advisers Audited Accounts for the year ended 31st December 2011 Report of the Independent Auditors 18 Consolidated Statement of Financial Activities 19 Consolidated Balance Sheet 20 Chapter Statement of Financial Activities 21 Chapter Balance Sheet 22 Accounting and other policies 23-25 Notes to the Financial Statements 26-38 1 GUILDFORD CATHEDRAL Annual Report for the year ended 31st December 2011 Administrative Office Cathedral Office Stag Hill Guildford GU2 7UP Tel: 01483 547860 Fax: 01483 303350 General Email: [email protected] Web site: www.guildford-cathedral.org Constitution and Statutes Guildford Cathedral is governed under the Cathedrals Measure 1999 and by a Constitution and Statutes which came into effect on 24th November 2002, and as amended on 19th October 2011. Under these regulations, it is the duty of the Chapter to direct and oversee the administration of the affairs of the Cathedral and to order the worship and promote the mission of the Cathedral.
    [Show full text]
  • Women Bishops in the Church of England
    Women bishops in the Church of England Standard Note: SN/PC/03897 Last updated: 1 February 2010 Author: Lucinda Maer Section Parliament and Constitution Centre At present, women are prevented from becoming bishops under the 1993 Church of England Measure that permitted women to be ordained as priests. Although women can become priests, parishes can pass resolutions against the ministry of female priests in their parish. On 11 July 2005, the Church of England General Synod gave approval for setting in train “the process for removing the legal obstacles to the ordination of women to the episcopate”. In July 2006 the Synod agreed in principle to the consecration of women to the episcopate. The Women Bishops Legislative Drafting Group published its first report in April 2008. They set out a number of options for introducing women bishops, including providing a separate structure, or a code of practice, for those who would feel unable to accept a female bishop in their diocese. The House of Bishops proposed a motion for the Synod which would have allowed special arrangements to continue to be made for those who, as a matter of theological conviction, would be unable to receive the ministry of women as bishops or priests. The bishops favoured a ‘code of practice’ rather than a structural solution (one which would involve setting up new dioceses) to achieve this. On 7 July 2008, the Synod reaffirmed their majority support for the consecration of women to the episcopate. They decided that special arrangements should be made available to those whose theological convictions meant they were unable to receive the ministry of women priests or bishops, and there should be a ‘statutory national code of practice’ to which all concerned would have to have regard.
    [Show full text]
  • WEEK 2 the Apostle's Creed
    WEEK 2 The Apostle’s Creed: Embracing Creedal Faith in the Midst of Pluralism The Catechetical lectures are given to those who are to be enlightened in baptism or confirmation and also to believers who are already baptized for edification. 1. What is a Creed? A creed is a statement of faith or belief from the Latin word ​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​ credo, meaning “I believe.” Latin root= ‘to place one’s heart in’; ‘to trust with the ​ heart.’ 2. Why does the Church use Creeds? a. Distinction. The first object of the earliest Christian creeds was to ​ distinguish the Church from the world, from Jews and heathen, afterwards orthodoxy from heresy, and finally denomination from denomination.5 b. Catechism. To instruct converts and baptized disciples as well. ​ c. Safeguard. The Church’s creeds correct ancient and modern heresies, ​ declaring and safeguarding God’s truth in Holy Scripture about Himself, ourselves, and the whole creation (1 Ths 2; 2 Tim 2; Jude 3). The faith is something to be jealously guarded, something that people might fall away to their spiritual peril.6 3. The Importance of Creeds. a. Creeds are necessary for at least 5 reasons: i. Creeds are summaries of what the apostles taught and what the ​ ​ Bible teaches. The Creeds, therefore, are both biblical and ​ ​ apostolic. ​ ii. Creeds proclaim the essentials of the faith. ​ ​ 1. The Vincentian Canon (AD445), written by St Vincent of ​ ​ ​ ​ ​ Lérins, lays out the test of catholicity: that “which has been ​ believed everywhere, at all times, and by all.” iii. Because Christians hold the essentials of the faith in the Creeds in common, Creeds also create Christian unity.
    [Show full text]
  • Invigorating Our Confessions of Faith (Creeds) with the Assistance of Romans JUSTIN J
    Word & World Volume 39, Number 3 Summer 2019 Invigorating Our Confessions of Faith (Creeds) with the Assistance of Romans JUSTIN J. LIND-AYRES Dusting Off the Church’s Treasures Recently I was worshiping with area pastors and deacons at a conference event. The host church had in its pew-rack hymnals that were over forty years old. Yet, they were still being employed by the congregation in its weekly worship. Despite the publication of newer denominational hymnals over the span of four decades, this congregation continued its allegiance to the “green book” with its tattered edges and fraying spine. My hunch is it has as much to do with the congregation’s fru- gality as it does to its faithfulness to the liturgical practices codified in the 1970s. When the time came in our conference worship to sing a hymn, we were instructed to turn to the hymnals in our pews. Before I could grab the book in front of me, my dear friend and pastor colleague reached for it. With a smirk on her face, she delicately opened its pages, took a slight intake of breath, and pre- tended to blow the dust out from the pages of the hymnal. I’m not sure if it was the Almost from the beginning, Christians have publicly and corporately con- fessed their faith in common statements, the most universally accepted being the three ecumenical creeds. But perhaps new contexts in our contemporary world call for the addition of new statements of faith alongside the classic ones. 246 Invigorating Our Confessions of Faith (Creeds) with the Assistance of Romans morning light playing tricks on my eyes or my own imagination sparked by her joke, but I thought I saw a cloud of dust waft up from that green book.
    [Show full text]
  • Empowering Popularity: the Fuel Behind a Witch-Hunt
    EMPOWERING POPULARITY: THE FUEL BEHIND A WITCH-HUNT ________________________________ A Thesis Presented to The Honors Tutorial College Ohio University ________________________________ In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for Graduation From the Honors Tutorial College With the degree of Bachelor of Arts in History ________________________________ Written by Grace Konyar April 2017 Table of Contents List of Figures ……………………………………………………………………….2 Introduction………………………………………………………………………….3 Chapter One………………………………………………………………………..10 Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story: The Development of Witchcraft as a Gendered Crime Chapter Two………………………………………………………………………………...31 The World Turned Upside Down: The Fragility of the Suffolk and Essex Witch-Hunts Chapter Three ……………………………………………………………………………...52 That Would Be Enough: The Tipping Point of Spectral Evidence Chapter Four………………………………………………………………………74 Satisfied: The Balance of Ethics and Fame Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………….93 Bibliography………………………………………………………………………………..97 1 List of Figures Image 1: Frontispiece, Matthew Hopkins, The Discovery of Witches, London, 1647…...........................................................................................................................40 Image 2: Indictment document 614 of the Essex Summer Sessions for Maria Sterling. Courtesy of The National Archives- Kew, ASSI 35/86/1/72. Photograph by the author………………………………………………………………………………....41 Image 3: Frontispiece, A True Relation of the Araignment of eighteen Witches, London, 1945……………………………………...……….…………………………48
    [Show full text]
  • Come, Holy Ghost
    Come, Holy Ghost John Cosin and 17th Century Anglicanism Notes from sabbatical study leave, Summer 2016 Donald Allister Come, Holy Ghost Sabbatical study Copyright © Donald Allister 2017 2 Come, Holy Ghost Sabbatical study Contents Come, Holy Ghost 4 Personal Interest 5 The Legacy of the 16th Century 8 Arminianism and the Durham House Group 10 The Origins of the Civil War 13 Cosin’s Collection of Private Devotions 14 Controversy, Cambridge, Catastrophe 16 Exile, Roman Catholicism, and the Huguenots 18 Breda, Savoy, the Book of Common Prayer, and the Act of Uniformity 22 Cosin’s Other Distinctive Views 25 Reflections 26 Collects written by Cosin and included in the 1662 Prayer Book 29 Cosin’s Last Testament 30 Some key dates 33 Bibliography 35 3 Come, Holy Ghost Sabbatical study Come, Holy Ghost, our souls inspire, and lighten with celestial fire. Thou the anointing Spirit art, who dost thy sevenfold gifts impart. Thy blessed unction from above is comfort, life, and fire of love. Enable with perpetual light the dullness of our blinded sight. Anoint and cheer our soiled face with the abundance of thy grace. Keep far from foes, give peace at home: where thou art guide, no ill can come. Teach us to know the Father, Son, and thee, of both, to be but One, that through the ages all along, this may be our endless song: Praise to thy eternal merit, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Amen.1 Original Latin ascribed to Rabanus Maurus (died AD 856), traditionally sung at Pentecost, Confirmations, and Ordinations: Veni, creator Spiritus, / mentes tuorum visita, / imple superna gratia, / quae tu creasti, pectora.
    [Show full text]
  • INFORMATION for Applicants
    INFORMATION for applicants GUILDFORD CATHEDRAL • INFORMATION FOR APPLICANTS • PAGE 1 OPEN a warm-hearted community, open to God, open to all TELL the Good News of Jesus to the world through our worship and outreach DEVELOP the use of our estate in a way that honours God’s concern for his Creation ENABLE the Bishop’s ministry and nurturing of young and old in their faith SERVE the schools, parishes and chaplaincies of our Diocese and to serve our County and locality GUILDFORD CATHEDRAL • INFORMATION FOR APPLICANTS • PAGE 2 HEAD OF DEVELOPMENT Guildford Cathedral and its context THE DIOCESE OF GUILDFORD The Diocese came into being in 1927, carved out of the historic diocese of Winchester, and covers almost the whole of Surrey and a significant area of North-East Hampshire. It also includes one parish in a London borough and one in rural West Sussex. In the northeast, it is largely suburban, but moving south and west, there are a number of distinct towns and numerous villages. This part of the diocese has a rural feel, but good road and rail links to London and elsewhere mean that there is much commuting within these areas. The population is just over a million, rising in line with the national rate. Notwithstanding the rural areas, the average population density is above average, both regionally and nationally. The area is rightly perceived as affluent, but there are other perspectives. There are surprisingly high levels of domestic and sexual abuse. The population is quite mobile, but the cost of housing is very high and there are issues of homelessness in the towns.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Introduction Other Voices: Dissenting Women Mary Franklin (d. 1711) was the wife of the Reverend Robert Franklin (1630–1703), one of some two thousand Nonconformist ministers who were “ejected” from their pulpits and their livings on Black Bartholomew’s Day,1 August 24, 1662, following the Restoration of Charles II (1630–1685). In May 1660, Charles returned from exile in Europe, beginning the Restoration of the monarchy. He was crowned on April 23, 1661. Though for many English subjects the Restoration was a joyous occasion, for the Dissenters,2 and especially for ministers and their relations, these became times that tried their souls. Mary Franklin wrote a narrative of her experi- ence of these times, taking up, late in life, one of her husband’s incomplete sermon notebooks, turning it upside down, and using its blank pages for her purposes.3 She wrote about her life as a minister’s wife and her family’s suffering under a govern- ment that exacted religious conformity to the Church of England as a measure of loyalty to the crown. She also recorded the triumph of God’s providences through it all. She did not seek publication of her brief, detailed, and moving testimony but rather seems to have kept the notebook within her family until her death, after 1. The name Black Bartholomew’s Day harkens back to a day of infamy for the Protestant godly, St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre, August 24, 1572, when tens of thousands of French Huguenots (Calvinists) were slaughtered by the Catholic King Charles IX. See N.
    [Show full text]
  • A Way Forward After the Consecration of Women Bishops
    313 A Way Forward after the Consecration of Women as Bishops in the Church of England Gerald Bray Editorial note The folloWing paper Was submitted bY the author to the Bishop of Guildford for consideration bY his commission, Which has been charged With finding a WaY forWard after the consecration of Women bishops. The paper assumes that such consecrations Will proceed as enVisaged bY general SYnod in JulY, 2005, and is concerned onlY With establishing principles for adequate proVision afterWards for those Who Will not be able to accept such a moVe. It is particularlY important that this matter should be seen to concern EVangelicals as much as anY other grouping Within the church, and it is With that in mind that the paper is being printed in Churchman so that the issues inVolVed maY receiVe a full airing Within the EVangelical constituencY. It goes Without saYing that the VieWs eXpressed are those of the author and do not necessarilY reflect the official stance of Church SocietY or of the Editorial board of Churchman . NoW that the general SYnod of the Church of England has cleared the WaY for legislation to be prepared making it possible for Women to be consecrated as bishops, the question arises of What proVision(s) should be made for those Who cannot accept this moVe. People on both sides of the debate recogniZe that there are ‘tWo integrities’ on this matter, i.e. VieWs Which are incompatible With each other, but Which do not touch fundamental Christian truths as to make anY form of communion betWeen them impossible.
    [Show full text]
  • Desatando La Verdad De Dios, Un Versículo a La Vez
    Gracia a Vosotros :: desatando la verdad de Dios, un versículo a la vez The Danger of Calling the Church to Repent Code: B181008 Have you ever heard of a church that repented? Not individuals, but an entire church that collectively recognized its congregational transgressions and openly, genuinely repented, with biblical sorrow and brokenness. Sadly, you probably have not. For that matter, have you ever heard of a pastor who called his church to repent and threatened his congregation with divine judgment if they failed to do so? It’s not likely. Pastors today seem to have a hard enough time calling individuals to repent, let alone calling the whole church to account for their corporate sins. In fact, if a pastor were so bold as to lead his own church to repent, he might not be the pastor for much longer. At minimum, he would face resistance and scorn from within the congregation. That inevitable backlash is likely strong enough to generate a kind of preemptive fear, keeping most church leaders from ever considering a call for corporate repentance. On the other hand, if a pastor or church leader has the temerity to call for another church—rather than his own—to repent, he will almost certainly be accused of being critical, divisive, and overstepping his authority. He’ll face a chorus of voices telling him to mind his own business. Vilifying him, therefore, clears a path for the confronted church to sidestep his admonition altogether. The fact is, churches rarely repent. Churches that start down a path of worldliness, disobedience, and apostasy typically move even further from orthodoxy over time.
    [Show full text]