Planning Committee AGENDA Friday 28 April 2017 10.00am Page 1. To receive apologies for absence and introductions 2. To receive declarations of interest 3. To receive and confirm the minutes of the previous 3 – 13 meeting held on 31 March 2017 (herewith) 4. Points of information arising from the minutes 5. To note whether any items have been proposed as matters of urgent business MATTERS FOR DECISION 6. Chairman’s Announcements and Introduction to Public Speaking Please note that public speaking is in operation in accordance with the Authority’s Code of Conduct for Planning Committee. Those who wish to speak are requested to come up to the public speaking desk at the beginning of the presentation of the relevant application 7. Request to defer applications included in this agenda and/or to vary the order of the Agenda To consider any requests from ward members, officers or applicants to defer an application included in this agenda, or to vary the order in which applications are considered to save unnecessary waiting by members of the public attending 8. To consider applications for planning permission including matters for consideration of enforcement of planning control: 14 – 24 • BA/2017/060/CU Eagle’s Nest, Ferry Road, Horning • BA/2016/0323/FUL Bureside, Water Works Lane, 25 – 44 Horning 1 Page 9 Enforcement Update 45 – 53 Report by Head of Planning (herewith) POLICY 10 Salhouse Neighbourhood Plan – Proceeding to 54 – 95 Referendum Report by Director of Planning and Resources (herewith) 11 Thorpe St Andrew Neighbourhood Plan – Designating 96 – 98 Thorpe St Andrews as a Neighbourhood Area Report by Planning Policy Officer (herewith) 12 Broads Local Plan – Recreation Impacts Study 99 – 104 Report by Planning Policy Officer (herewith) 13 Landscape Strategy and Landscape Consultation Guide: 105 – 116 Consultation Version Report by Planning Policy Officer (herewith) MATTERS FOR INFORMATION 14 Appeals to the Secretary of State Update 117 – 118 Report by Administrative Officer (herewith) 15 Decisions made by Officers under Delegated Powers 119 – 121 Report by Director of Planning and Resources (herewith) 16 Circular 28/83: Publication by Local Authorities of 122 – 125 Information About the Handling of Planning Applications Report by Head of Planning (herewith) 17 To note the date of the next meeting – Friday 26 May 2017 at 10.00am at Yare House, 62-64 Thorpe Road, Norwich 2 Broads Authority Planning Committee Minutes of the meeting held on 31 March 2017 Present: Sir Peter Dixon – in the Chair Mr M Barnard Mr H Thirtle Ms G Harris Mr V Thomson Mr P Rice In Attendance: Mrs S A Beckett – Administrative Officer (Governance) Mr B Hogg – Historic Environment Manager (Minute 10/8(2)) Ms A Long – Director of Planning and Resources Miss S Mullarney (Administrative Officer (Governance) Ms C Smith – Head of Planning Members of the Public in attendance who spoke: BA/2017/0059/CU Horizon Craft, Old Road, Acle Mr Ryan Mabbott The Applicant BA/2016/0323/FUL Bureside, water Works Lane, Horning Prof Erika Denton The Applicant 10/1 Apologies for Absence and Welcome The Chairman welcomed everyone to the meeting. Apologies were received from Prof J Burgess, Mr W Dickson and Mr J Timewell. He also welcomed Sarah Mullarney who had recently joined the Governance team and was attending as an observer. 10/2 Declarations of Interest Members indicated their declarations of interest in addition to those already registered, as set out in Appendix 1 to these minutes. 10/3 Chairman’s Announcements and Introduction to Public Speaking The Chairman reported on the following: (1) The Openness of Local Government Bodies Regulations 3 The Chairman gave notice that the Authority would be recording this meeting following the decision by the full Authority on 27 January to record all its public meetings on a trial basis and investigation of ways of making recordings available on the website were being made. The recording was a means of increasing transparency and openness as well as to help with the accuracy of the minutes. The copyright remained with the Authority and the minutes would be as a matter of record. (2) Introduction to Public Speaking The Chairman reminded everyone that the scheme for public speaking was in operation for consideration of planning applications, details of which were contained in the Code of Conduct for members and officers. (This did not apply to Enforcement Matters.) 10/4 Minutes: 3 March 2017 The minutes of the meeting held on 3 March 2017 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. 10/5 Points of Information Arising from the Minutes None to report 10/6 To note whether any items have been proposed as matters of urgent business No items had been proposed as matters of urgent business. 10/7 Requests to Defer Applications and /or Vary the Order of the Agenda No requests to defer or vary the order of the agenda had been received. 10/8 Applications for Planning Permission The Committee considered the following applications submitted under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, as well as matters of enforcement (also having regard to Human Rights), and reached decisions as set out below. Acting under its delegated powers the Committee authorised the immediate implementation of the decisions. The following minutes relate to further matters of information, or detailed matters of policy not already covered in the officers’ report, and which were given additional attention. (1) BA/2017/0059/CU Horizon Craft, Old Road, Acle Upton with Fishley Part change of use of boat shed and workshops to a bar and restaurant (Class A3). Installation of 8 shore power posts and extension of gravel walkway. Applicant: Mr Ryan Mabbott 4 The Chairman stated that comments had been received from the local Ward member this morning. In accordance with the Authority’s procedures, this was after the cut off point for receipt of information and would not normally be taken into account. However, given that this was the Ward Member therefore on this occasion, with Committee approval, an exception was being made. A copy of Mr O’Neill’s email was circulated to the Committee. The Head of Planning provided a detailed presentation of the application including two elements – the first involving a part change of use of a boat shed and workshops at Horizon Craft to a bar and restaurant; the second element of the application included an extension of 140 metres of a gravel walkway and the installation of 8 shore power posts and electric hook up for moored boats. The applicant leased the site from Richardsons with the aim of the providing diversification of the existing business, improve viability and extend the season. Members attention was drawn to the location of the site by the Acle Bridge where there was development at all four corners with a cluster of tourist and marine related businesses and with access off the main distributor A1064 road, a major factor in consideration of the application particularly with regard to the comments from the Highways Authority. The Head of Planning stated that being a main distributor road, the national speed limit was 60 mph with an advisory, not mandatory, speed limit of 30mph on the bridge, which it was noted was a blind summit. It was widely recognised that this limit was poorly observed. She provided the visibility measurements at different locations and the visibility requirements for differing speed limits and pointed out that the main problems occurred when traffic needed to turn right. Since the writing of the report, additional consultations had been received from: • Upton Parish Council – no objection • Acle Parish Council stating that they supported the principle of the application but raised an objection due to the traffic concerns on lack of highways visibility and considered that a traffic survey and impact assessment should be done, and a speed reduction imposed. • Frank O’Neill Local District Member – Fully Supported the application. Recognised the highway concerns and advocated that the Highways Authority convert the advisory 30mph speed limit to mandatory as well as impose this from Acle Bridge to the roundabout at the junction of the A47. • Lana Hempsall – District Member for the adjacent ward, Acle. Raised concerns about the access and recommended a site visit and that Highways be pressed to undertake a traffic survey and assessment, that improvements be made and the Authority to make this a strategic priority. She also supported the principle of the application. • Further correspondence from the Highways Authority which was covered within the presentation. 5 In providing the assessment, the Head of Planning concluded that the proposals were in accordance with the NPPF, compliant with Broads Authority policies and met the Acle Neighbourhood Pan aspirations, would not have an impact on the landscape or amenity, would increase employment and improve and contribute to the tourism facilities and network generally in the Broads. The main concern, related to the objections from the Highways and the question as to whether the difficulties could be mitigated or the speed limit reduced, both of which the Highways Authority had concluded could not be justified, details being set out at section 5 of the report and in their additional letter. It was stated that Highways could not make speed limit changes to make an unacceptable (in highway terms) development acceptable. They had also stated that the additional costs involved in mitigation including enforcement could not be justified. They also stated that a traffic impact assessment was not warranted. The Head of Planning commented that the concerns of the Highways Authority had been carefully examined and the risks involved. However, it was concluded that taking into account all material considerations, there was a long established existing use of the site, there were already permitted development rights which could generate considerably more traffic than at present or an intensification of use, without further reference to the Planning Authority.