Rewriting Eden with the Book of Mormon: Joseph Smith and the Reception of Genesis 1-6 in Early America
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Utah State University DigitalCommons@USU All Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 12-2019 Rewriting Eden With the Book of Mormon: Joseph Smith and the Reception of Genesis 1-6 in Early America Colby Townsend Utah State University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/etd Part of the History Commons Recommended Citation Townsend, Colby, "Rewriting Eden With the Book of Mormon: Joseph Smith and the Reception of Genesis 1-6 in Early America" (2019). All Graduate Theses and Dissertations. 7681. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/etd/7681 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Rewriting Eden with the Book of Mormon: Joseph Smith and the Reception of Genesis 1–6 in Early America By Colby Townsend A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in History Approved: ____________________________ ___________________________ Philip L. Barlow, Ph.D. Kerit Holt, Ph.D. Major Professor Committee Member ____________________________ ___________________________ Norman L. Jones, Ph.D. Richard S. Inouye, Ph.D. Committee Member Vice Provost for Graduate Studies UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY Logan, Utah 2019 ii Copyright © Colby Townsend 2019 All Rights Reserved iii ABSTRACT Rewriting Eden with the Book of Mormon: Joseph Smith and the Reception of Genesis 1–6 in Early America by Colby Townsend, Master of Arts Utah State University, 2019 Major Professor: Dr. Philip Barlow Department: History Only a few months after the publication of the Book of Mormon Joseph Smith, Jr. edited the version of Eden found in the Book of Mormon into the text of the Bible itself. Where there was no story of Cain plotting with Satan prior to his revisionary work, after he was done working on the manuscripts of his “new translation,” the section on Cain killing Abel in Genesis was expanded to include a story about Cain plotting explicitly with Satan to become “Master Mahon,” master of the great secret that you can kill to get gain. The text of Genesis also leaves the effects of the expulsion from Eden, known more broadly as “the Fall,” unspoken, and it is unclear whether the Fall was supposed to be viewed as positive or negative. In the Book of Mormon it is argued that without the Fall Adam and Eve would not have had children and humanity in general would not be able to have joy. In Smith’s expanded text Adam and Eve both exclaim happiness with the results of the Fall because they can now have children and joy, something they would not have had if they had not eaten the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. (217 pages) iv PUBLIC ABSTRACT Rewriting Eden with the Book of Mormon: Joseph Smith and the Reception of Genesis 1–6 in Early America Colby Townsend The colonists living in the new United States after the American War for Independence were faced with the problem of forming new identities once they could no longer recognize themselves, collectively or individually, as subjects of Great Britain. After the French Revolution American politicians began to weed out the more radical political elements of the newly formed United States, particularly by painting one of the revolution’s biggest defenders, Thomas Paine, as unworthy of the attention he received during the American War for Independence, and fear ran throughout the states that an anarchic revolution like the French Revolution could bring the downfall of the nation. State, local, and regional organizations sprang up to fight Jacobinism, the legendary secret group of murderers and anarchists that fought against the French government. This distressing situation gave rise to new literature that sought to describe the “real” origins and background of Jacobinism in the War in Heaven and in Eden, and a new movement against Jacobinism was established. Fears about the organization of secret societies did not wane in the decades after the French Revolution, but worsened in the last half of the 1820s when a Freemason, William Morgan, disappeared under mysterious circumstances in connection to an exposé of Masonry he had written. Most Americans assumed that Freemasons had abducted and murdered Morgan in order to keep their oaths and rites secret. v One influential early American who was influenced by this socio-historical was Joseph Smith, Jr., the founding prophet of Mormonism. Smith interpreted the Eden narrative in light of the movement against secret societies, and literary motifs common to anti-Jacobin literature during the period provided language and interpretive strategies for understanding the Eden narrative that would influence how Smith produced his new scripture. Only a few months after the publication of the Book of Mormon Smith edited the version of Eden found there into the text of the Bible itself and made the biblical narrative conform to the version found in the Book of Mormon through his own revisions and additions. vi ACKNOWLEDGMENTS A scholar may often feel alone in their work as they pour over manuscripts in an archive or piles of books on a desk but it would be impossible to find one who is not in constant conversation with their contemporaries as well as the important work done by others who came before them. I am indebted in all of my work to both. First, I would like to thank my thesis committee, Doctors Philip Barlow, Norm Jones, and Keri Holt, each of whom has shaped my thinking and writing in unique and significant ways. To Dr. Barlow for helping me to say what I wanted to say in a generous way toward my subject and the sources. To Dr. Jones for introducing me to the thought and society of the transatlantic world of Early Modern Europe and always being ready to laugh, and to Dr. Holt for helping me to find the sources and archives that I needed at just the right moments and the kind of constructive criticism every young scholar needs. I owe each of you more than I could ever hope to repay. Much of the work in this thesis was presented in graduate seminars and academic conferences over the last two years. I appreciate the helpful comments from Elisabeth Cropper, Raelyn Embleton, Al Roberts, Vinna Chintaram, Landon Wilkey, Katie Houser, Kate Martin, Tayce Robinson, Ben Horrocks, Dr. Susan Grayzel, Dr. James Sanders, and Dr. Christopher Conte on parts of the introduction and chapters one and two. Chapter three benefited greatly from the insights and editor’s hand of Dr. Keri Holt, as well questions and comments from attendees at the 2018 annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature in Denver, Colorado. Chapter four benefitted, especially during the thesis defense, to the reactions of Drs. Barlow, Jones, and Holt. An early version of this chapter was presented at the annual Joseph Smith Papers Conference at the Church History Museum in Salt Lake City, Utah. I appreciate those in attendance who asked questions and provided feedback on all of my research. I also benefited from stimulating conversations with fellow graduate students vii Joanna Dobrowolska, David Tauber, Jason Fackrell, Kirtan Patel, and Dan Weller. Thank you all for a delightful first year at Utah State University. I also need to acknowledge a debt of gratitude to scholars who have always been open to discussing my work and early American religious history and have shaped my thinking. Robin Jensen, David Grua, Brian Hauglid, David Bokovoy, Ben Park, Bill Davis, Loyd Ericson, Christopher Blythe, and many others. Thank you for sharing your thoughts, time, and research with me. I am indebted to the staffs of several university libraries and archives. In particular, I enjoyed working closely with the staff of the Special Collections and Archives at the Merrill- Cazier Library at Utah State University as the graduate fellow for the 2018–2019 academic year. Being able to not only see but also engage in the inner workings of an archive has been a gift to an aspiring historian. Thank you Jennifer Duncan, Clint Pumphrey, Dan Davis, Bob Parson, Todd Welch, Rose Milovich, Devin Greener, Randy Williams, and many others for giving me a home away from home. I would also like to thank the archivists and staff at the American Antiquarian Society in Worcester, Massachusetts, particularly Ashley Cataldo and Kimberly Toney. The entire staff at the archive was a pleasure to work with. I have also spent many hours studying and writing at the J. Willard Marriott Library at the University of Utah and appreciate the professional and quiet work of the staff there. This thesis is dedicated to Kelsey and Jude, the two who have had to listen to me talk about the subject of this thesis the most, sometimes what probably felt like days on end. For this I will be forever grateful. Colby Townsend viii CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………………...iii PUBLIC ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS………………………………………………………………vii INTRODUCTION………………………………………………………………………1 CHAPTER I. The European Context: Creating Heretics and Establishing Biblical Criticism Introduction………………………………………………………………..14 Eden in Europe…………………………………………………………….18 Eden in the Hebrew Bible: The Evolution of Research on the Pentateuch…26 II. Enacting Eden: Biblical Reception and the Formation of Identity in Early America, 1730–1830………………………………………………………..40 The Reception of John Milton’s Paradise Lost in Early America……………..44 Eden in the Early American Republic………………………………………48 Beginnings: The Puritans and Early Colonists……………………………....55 The Two Great Awakenings………………………………………………..58 Conclusion…………………………………………………………………73 III. An Illiterate Farm Boy?: Joseph Smith’s Use of the Bible from 1828–1830…...75 The Bible, Literacy, and Early American Education………………………...80 Analysis…………………………………………………………………….85 Conclusion………………………………………………………………...129 IV.