Finance and Constitution Committee Cabinet Secretary for the The Scottish Parliament Constitution, Europe and External EDINBURGH Affairs and EH99 1SP Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster (by e-mail) Direct Tel: (0131) 348 5215
[email protected] 6 October 2020 Dear Cabinet Secretary and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, UK Internal Market Bill and Legislative Consent Memorandum 1. As lead Committee we are required under Rule 9B.3.5 of the Standing Orders to report on the UK Internal Market Bill LCM and this letter fulfils that requirement.1 A number of changes were voted on and these are set out in the meeting minute of 6 October 2020. 2. The Committee previously submitted a response to the consultation on the White Paper which preceded the Bill. The Committee has had limited time to scrutinise the Bill and the LCM due to the parliamentary timetable at Westminster. Given the significance and complexity of the proposals and the potential impact of the Bill on businesses and people across Scotland this is regrettable. 3. The Committee’s view is that Brexit will have a very significant impact on devolution and how it works. The UK Government’s ad hoc approach to addressing this without sufficient consultation with the devolved institutions and a wider public debate is unsustainable. There needs to be an inclusive and constructive conversation across all four nations of the UK which addresses the highly complex consequences of Brexit on the devolution settlement with the aim of delivering a consensual solution. 4. It is regrettable therefore that the UK Government has sought an accelerated legislative timetable for the highly complex and challenging Internal Market Bill without an opportunity for sufficient 1 Murdo Fraser MSP, Dean Lockhart MSP and Alexander Burnett MSP dissented from this letter.