Arxiv:1610.10013V2 [Cond-Mat.Soft] 30 Jan 2017 to Understand Some of the Issues, It Is Relevant to Be X
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Experimental soft-matter science Sidney R. Nagel The James Franck and Enrico Fermi Institutes and the Department of Physics The University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637 (Dated: January 31, 2017) Soft materials consist of basic units that are significantly larger than an atom but much smaller than the overall dimensions of the sample. The label \soft condensed matter" emphasizes that the large basic building blocks of these materials produce low elastic moduli that govern a material's ability to withstand deformations. Aside from softness, there are many other properties that are also caused by the large size of the constituent building blocks. Soft matter is dissipative, disordered, far-from-equilibrium, non-linear, thermal and entropic, slow, observable, gravity-affected, patterned, non-local, interfa- cially elastic, memory-forming and active. This is only a partial list of how matter created from large component particles is distinct from \hard matter" composed of constituents at an atomic scale. Issues inherent in soft matter raise problems that are broadly important in diverse areas of science and require multiple modes of attack. For example, far-from-equilibrium be- havior is confronted in biology, chemistry, geophysics, astrophysics and nuclear physics. Similarly, issues dealing with disorder appear broadly throughout many branches of inquiry wherever rugged landscapes are invoked. This article reviews the discussions that occurred during a workshop held on January 30-31, 2016 in which opportunities in soft-matter experiment were surveyed. Soft matter has had an exciting history of discovery and continues to be a fertile ground for future research. PACS numbers: 47.57.-s, 47.54.-r, 82.35.-x, 05.70.Ln, 46.65.+g, 83., 47. CONTENTS Acknowledgments 24 I. Introduction: 1 A. Participants in the workshop held in Arlington VA on A. Characteristics of soft condensed matter 1 January 30-31, 2016 on which this report is based 24 B. Soft-matter systems and the disciplines that study 1. Scientific Advisory Committee 24 them 5 2. Attendees 24 II. Colloids 6 References 24 III. Granular Materials, (non-Colloidal) Suspensions, Emulsions and Foams 7 I. INTRODUCTION: IV. Glasses and Jamming 9 A. Characteristics of soft condensed matter V. Packing 11 The label \soft condensed matter" does not do justice VI. Liquid Crystals 12 to the broad scope of this branch of research. \Softness" VII. Polymers and Rheology 13 emphasizes the low elastic moduli that govern a mate- rial's ability to withstand deformations. However, that VIII. Fluids 14 is only one attribute and many other properties go hand- IX. Mechanical Meta-materials 15 in-hand with the malleability of a material. arXiv:1610.10013v2 [cond-mat.soft] 30 Jan 2017 To understand some of the issues, it is relevant to be X. Active and Adaptive Matter 17 reminded of the common cause of the emergence of low XI. Self Assembly 18 elastic moduli in these soft materials. In colloids, poly- mers, foams, granular matter, emulsions and other soft XII. Patterns and Structure Formation 18 matter, the atoms are organized on a mesoscopic scale XIII. Simulations and Big Data 20 into entities that are much larger than an atom but still much smaller than the overall size of the material. These XIV. Instrumentation 21 large entities interact with one another to produce the elastic response of the material. However, because the XV. Outreach 22 individual constituents are large, the moduli must neces- XVI. Concluding Remarks 23 sarily be small. This is essentially a dimensional-analysis letters to nature Experiments that cleanly reveal the nature of interactions that this street is shed starting from the free end rather than from the between a deformable body and a ¯ow are dif®cult to perform, top, where the ¯ow ®rst encounters the ®lament. Despite the with complications including the control of three-dimensional ¯ow oscillations of the street, the ®lament remains a static, seemingly effects and the challenge of ¯ow visualization. Soap ®lm is a rigid body. Indeed, transient small disturbances (such as a small convenient experimental system that resembles two-dimensional displacement at the free end, or a thin vortex wake produced by a hydrodynamics in many respects3±7. In this experiment, we take cylinder placed upstream) do not destroy the stability of this state. advantage of the relative simplicity of this system, and use the However, if the external perturbation is suf®ciently large, the ¯owing soap ®lm as a laminar two-dimensional ¯ow tunnel. The ®lament jumps to a stable ¯apping state (Fig. 2b), whose persistence experimental set-up is shown in Fig. 1. The horizontal span of the is quite robust to perturbation. Unlike a simple pendulum, the tunnel is 8.5 cm, the typical ®lm thickness 3±4 mm, and ¯ow speeds undulation is well ®tted by a travelling harmonic wave with a 200±300 cm s-1 (see Methods). The experiment is performed 80 cm spatially varying envelope: below the ¯ow entrance, at the midline. The ®laments are 0.15 mm y x; tf xsin 2pvt 2px=l in diameter and 2±6 cm long. Their linear density is about 2:0 3 10 2 4 g cm 2 1. The rigidity of the ®lament is estimated to be Here, y x; t is the horizontal displacement of the ®lament from the the order of 0.1 erg cm, tested in a steady soap ®lm where the centre-line, measured at a vertical distance x from the ®xed point for de¯ection is measured under a known force. The ¯uid wets the time t. f(x) is a spatial envelope function (increasing monotonically ®lament, with surface tension forces constraining the ®lament to lie from the ®xed point), v is the ¯apping frequency and l the always in the plane of the ®lm. The length of the ®lament can be wavelength. When the ®lament length is about 3 cm long and changed incrementally through the holder at the upstream end, ¯ow speed 280 cm s-1 (the corresponding Reynolds number is of which abuts the ®lm perpendicularly. the order of 104), we observed a typical ¯apping frequency of about At a ®xed ¯ow rate, there exists a critical ®lament length Lc, below 50 Hz and an amplitude (the total excursion of the free end) of which the ®lament is stretched straight and aligned with the ¯ow. about 1.5 cm. A thin vortex street is still evident, but is strongly Regardless of the magnitude of an externally imposed disturbance, modi®ed by the large-scale ¯apping motion. The successive small after a few oscillations, the ®lament quickly returns to this rest state. eddies produced by a single stroke are now of a single sign, unlike If, however, the length of the ®lament exceeds Lc, the system the alternating signs in the stretched-straight case. This local vortex becomes bi-stable, and two different stable dynamical states are observed. One remains the stretched-straight state, as when L , Lc. 2 Figure 2a shows such a state (exposure time 0.5 ms). Using a monochromatic light source, the photograph shows instantaneous interference patternsargument that reveal (Frenkel, small 2002). thickness The variations. bulk and A shear moduli narrow von KaÂrmaÂofn vortex a material `street' have8,9 (that the is, units a train [energy]/[volume]. of vortices of While alternating signs) canthe be interaction seen trailing energy behind between the ®lament. two constituent We note particles is perhaps not exceedingly different from that between individual atoms, the volume of each particle is large. Thus the moduli are orders of magnitude smaller than they would be for an atomicH or molecular crystal. Thus materials made up of such large basic units must have specialS attributes. However, even a cursory exam- ination suggests that there are many other properties, aside from low elastic moduli, that are also caused by the large size of the component building blocks and that would make such materials distinctive. DissipativeTT matter: Because the individual building blocks are large, they each have many low-energy degrees of freedom (e.g., vibrations) that can be easily activated when two particles collide or scrape past one another. This generatesF strong dissipation during flow or defor- mation, either due to frictional interactions or to the in- elasticityNN of collisions. Kinetic energy, for example due to sound vibrations, is rapidly absorbed into the internal degrees of freedom of the constituents. Thus granular or colloidal materials are highly damped systems. Disordered matter: Because the individual particles TT are large, it is prohibitively unlikely that any two of them will have precisely the same number of atoms in the same arrangement. Thus there is disorder in the size and shape of the constituents. (One counter-example is Figure 2 The two stableFIG. states 1 The of the oscillatory ®lament. When flapping the ®lament state length of a is filament greater than in a flowing matter made from viruses,L where the DNA regulatesthe critical the value, it cantwo-dimensional stay in either a stretched-straight soap film. state Flow or an structures, oscillatory state. modulated The by structure precisely.) Even this small amount of¯ow disorder is visualized usingthe interference moving filament, patterns under are a advectedsodium lamp. downstream.a, The ®lament is The flow is Figure 1 Experimental set-up.can Ahave vertical dramatic soap ®lm is fed effects. from the top For (H) with example, a solution ofin astretched granular straight invisualized the ¯ow. Von KausingÂrmaÂn typeinterference vortices are shed imaging. from its free From end. b (Zhang, The et al., 1.5% Dawn, a commercialmaterial brand of dishwashing consisting liquid of soap, hard in distilled grains, water. forces The willoscillatory predomi- ¯apping2000). state. Flow structures, modulated by the ®lament, are advected pressure head is ®xed usingnantly an over¯ow propagate mechanism.