Agenda Item C.4.B, Supplemental
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Agenda Item C.4.b Supplemental Public Comment 2 April 2018 Full Electronic Version 111 SW Columbia Street, Suite 200 March 29, 2018 Portland, Oregon 97201 pewtrusts.org Mr. Phil Anderson, Chair Pacific Fishery Management Council 7700 NE Ambassador Place, Suite 101 Portland, OR 97220-1384 RE: Agenda Item C.4 Process for Review of Reference Points for Monitored Stocks Dear Chair Anderson and Council Members, The Pew Charitable Trusts is submitting public comment on behalf of 31,888 ocean advocates in support of ecosystem-based fisheries management for northern anchovy. The petition itself is included here, along with a compilation of the names, cities and states of individual signers that were submitted to the Council. Thank you for your time and consideration. We appreciate the opportunity to work with you to maintain sustainable fisheries and healthy ocean ecosystems. Bobby Hayden Senior Associate, U.S. Oceans, Pacific The Pew Charitable Trusts [email protected] 1 March 29, 2018 Mr. Phil Anderson, Chair Pacific Fishery Management Council 7700 NE Ambassador Place, Suite 101 Portland, OR 97220-1384 RE: Agenda Item C.4 Process for Review of Reference Points for Monitored Stocks Please protect anchovies and the marine wildlife that depend on them Dear Chair Anderson and Council Members: I am writing to ask the Pacific Fishery Management Council to adopt an ecosystem-based approach to managing northern anchovy. As you know, northern anchovies are among the most important forage fish in the Pacific Ocean, but existing management of the stock is based on decades-old information. True ecosystem-based management of this fishery requires that catch limits and other measures are based on the best available science, and are responsive and adaptive to changing environmental conditions. Northern anchovies are too important to other fisheries and the broader marine ecosystem to be managed passively. Only by ensuring that management of this essential forage fish is based on the best available science, and considers the broader marine ecosystem, can this Council can help maintain both a healthy ocean and productive and sustainable fisheries. For these reasons, I encourage you to act. Sincerely, We the undersigned 2 First Last City State First Last City State Allen A. San Francisco CA Jackson NeilAbarilles Mountlake TerraceWA Sylvia A. Lynch Daly City CA Laura Ackerman Spokane WA Richard A. Rogers Long Beach CA Catherine Adams Seattle WA Linn Aasly Belmont CA Jenny Adams Everett WA Andrew Abate Ventura CA Julia Adams Olympia WA Bob Abbott madera CA Susan Adams Roy WA Dominic Abbott Anaheim CA Kristen Adamson Seattle WA Rachel Abdel San Francisco CA Gaby Adamu Vancouver WA Reyhaneh Abdi APPLE VALLEY CA C T ADDERSON KENT WA Suzanne a'Becket Cupertino CA Bob Aegerter Bellingham WA Lourdes Abellera Los Angeles CA Carol Affleck Seattle WA lowell abellon Los Angeles CA Jayne Ahrens RENTON WA Mimi Abers Berkeley CA Sonja Aikens Walla Walla WA Mimi Abers Berkeley CA Michael Akstull VANCOUVER WA Larry Abgarian Encinitas CA Patricia alameda Port Townsend,WA Maryann Ablaza Milpitas CA Gary Albright Snohomish WA Michael Abler Santa Cruz CA Monika Alcorn Vancouver WA Michael Abler Santa Cruz CA Gabrielle Alderette Bremertonn WA June Abner San Diego CA Janet Alderton Deer Harbor WA Kevin Abrahamian Glendale CA Sandi Aldrich Duvall WA sally abrams San Francisco CA Shawn Alexander Olga WA Jesse Abrams Irvine CA Elizabeth Alexander Richland WA Jesse Abrams IRVINE CA Karen Alger Tacoma WA Sarah Abrell Carlsbad CA Karen Alger Tacoma WA Sarah Abrell Carlsbad CA na all bow WA Tammy Abreu-Butron Gilroy CA chris allan Arlington WA Carroll Abshier Lakewood CA Teresa Allen Deming WA Daena Acevedo La Puente CA Patrick Allen Poulsbo WA Beverly Ackerman-Bodmer Santa Rosa CA Renee Allen Vancouver WA Sue Acob Tulare CA Linda Allen Seattle WA Marion Acoff San Dimas CA Shawn Allen Seattle WA Mary Acorme Novato CA Robert Allmen Yakima WA anna acosta South Gate CA S. Almskaar Everson WA Carolyn Acosta Ontario CA S. P. Almskaar Everson WA Mike Acosta RIVERSIDE CA KIM Altenburg MONROE WA Susan Acosta Inglewood CA Lisa Alvarez Seattle WA Nancy ActonCaldwell Big Bear City CA Dr. R. WesleyAman Auburn WA Hayleey Acuna El Centro CA Christy Anderlik liberty lake WA Ricardo Acuna Los Angeles CA Becky Anderson Bellingham WA Jamie Adair Oceansie CA Glen Anderson Lacey WA Margaret Adam Corona CA Daniel Anderson Vancouver WA David Adams Penn Valley CA Patricia E Anderson Cathlamet WA L. Adams Escondido CA Lynnette Anderson Issaquah WA Linda Adams San Rafael CA Patricia Anderson CATHLAMET WA Paula Adams Pasadena CA Rosanne Anderson Cheney WA Marge Adams San Jose CA Susan Anderson Vancouver WA Mary Adams Adams Folsom CA Kevin Anderson OMAK WA Michelle Adams Saratoga CA Lisa Angle Gig Harbor WA 3 First Last City State First Last City State Dawne Adams San Marcos CA Diane Anicker Vancouver WA Cathy Adams orangevale CA Nicole Annecston Shoreline WA Janaye Adams EL MONTE CA Steve Ardire Shelton WA Kim Adams San jose CA Deanna Armstrong Seattle WA EVA ADAMYAN Los Angeles CA Angela Armstrong Bremerton WA Elizabeth Adan Carmichael CA Dessi Armstrong Vancouver WA deborah adatto Rancho CucamongaCA David Arntson Bothell WA Allison Addicott Berkeley CA Valarie Arras Seattle WA Dalia Adeina Canyon CountryCA Ardith Arrington SEATTLE WA Dalia Adeina SANTA CLARITACA Keri Arthur Spokane valleyWA Jessica Adejobi Oakland CA M. Arveson Lae Tapps WA Pure Adelard Los angeles CA Lindzie Ashby Seattle WA Julie Adelson Santa monica CA Dana Ashton Bainbridge IslandWA Karen Adhikari Oakland CA Linda Ashworth Kenn. WA Julia Adkins Napa CA Sigrid Asmus Seattle WA Julia Adkins Napa CA Mike Aspros Vancouver WA Crystal Adkins Glendora CA Robert Astyk Bellingham WA Jill Adler Manteca CA Gail Atkins Raymond WA Mary Adler Forestville CA Bailey Atkinson Seattle WA Linda Adney Hayward CA Tonjia Atomic Tacoma WA Willy Aenlle Altadena CA Natascha Atsatt Everett WA Willy Aenlle Altadena CA April Atwood Seattle WA Susan Affonso Bonsall CA Rachel Auestad Redmond WA Sarah Agate Redwood city CA Bonny Jean Austin Auburn WA Richard Agee San Diego CA Leslie Austin Johnson Vancouver WA Will Agee El Cajon CA Linda Avinger Bellingham WA Kate Ague Menlo Park CA Joann Ayala Seattle WA Rose Aguilar San Francisco CA Matt B Bellingham WA Jackie Aguilar Elk Grove CA Michele B.E. GH WA Brenda Aguilar Wildomar CA Karen HedwigBackman Federal Way WA Karalinda Aguilar Folsom CA Margaret Badger Walla Walla WA Rainah Aguilera Santa Rosa CA Stephen Bailey Deming WA Katrina Aguilera San jose CA Kristina Bailey Rainier WA Gloria Aguirre Castaic CA Dori Bailey Port TownsendWA elsa aguirre Altadena CA Thomas Bain Seattle WA Colleen Aguirre Castaic CA Dave Baine Federal Way WA Margarita Aguirre Daly City CA Amy Bakalarski Spokane WA Gen Agustsson redondo beach CA Norman Baker Sequim WA Amy Agzarian Culver City CA Lauren Baker Richland WA Natalie Aharonian North HollywoodCA Darlene Baker Sammamish WA Natalie Aharonian North HollywoodCA Deborah Baker Moses Lake WA Lars Ahlberg Indio CA sam baker Seattle WA Janet Ahlstrom Volcano CA Rebekah Baldwin Puyallup WA Mahbub Ahmed Canoga park CA Maria Balicka Kenmore WA Jane Ahrens Berkeley CA Maria Balicka Kenmore WA Jane Ahrens Berkeley CA John Ballard Woodinville WA Isabel Ahuatl Indio CA Marci Ballou Olympia WA Edwin Aiken Sunnyvale CA Raymond Ballweg Bellingham WA 4 First Last City State First Last City State Bruce Aird Lake Forest CA CHERI BALTAZAR lake tapps WA lilith akasha los angeles CA Brian Baltin Seattle WA Kathi Aker Tujunga CA Robert Bamford Seattle WA Kathi Aker Tujunga CA Gay Bammert Seattle WA Ellen Akre San Rafael CA Rob Banga Seattle WA Sophie Aktimur Dublin CA Wesley Banks Vancouver WA Stephen Alamango topanga CA Lynne Bannerman Seattle WA Robert Alaniz Pasadena CA Nick Barcott Lynnwood WA Debbie Alavezos Ukiah CA Nick Barcott Lynnwood WA Lori Albee Salinas CA Charles Barker Auburn WA Cheryl Albert Freedom CA Margery Barlow Packwood WA Shan Albert Studio City CA Terry Barnard North Bend WA Gloria Albert Santa Monica CA Noel Barnes Renton WA Keil Albert Mountain ViewCA lois barnett port townsendWA Gise Albertine Arcata CA Joseph Barreca Kettle Falls WA Aubre Albin REDLANDS CA rick barrett seattle WA Paul Albright Ojai CA fiona barrett Lynnwood WA Alma Marie Alcala Manteca CA Mary Barrett Tenino WA Susan Alcott Jardine Sherman Oaks, CA Nadine Barrick Tumwater WA Jackie Aldana Walnut Creek CA Debbie Barrientes Covington WA Rory Alden Berkeley CA Jane Barron Dayton WA Garrett Alden Chico CA Jane Barron Dayton WA Gary Alderette Santa Rosa CA Kalanit Barson Langley WA Lauren Alegre Berkeley CA Quinn Bartlett Seattle WA ale aleman santa barbara CA Vivian Bartlett Bellingham WA Farah Aleman Chula Vista CA James Bates Seattle WA francelle aleman haywar CA Chris battis Bellingham WA Charles Alexander Rialto CA Sarah Bauman Bellingham WA john alexander chico CA Sarah Bauman Bellingham WA Jim Alexander Palmdale CA Sarah Bauman Bellingham WA Caroline Alexander Santa Cruz CA John Bayer Washougal WA Bernard Alexander Valley Village CA Tracy Baze SPOKANE WA David Alexander Modesto CA Basia Bazylewicz Redmond WA Heather Alexander Murrieta CA Heather Beaird Chehalis WA Kristy Alexis MENIFEE CA Carolyn Beall Puyallup WA Elaine Alfaro FELTON CA Susan Bechtholt Port Orchard WA Marleny Alfaro El Cerrito CA Kathryn Beck Bellingham WA Gail Alford Santa Rosa CA Karin Begg Snohomish WA Zaki Alherz Fremont CA Alii Bek SOUTH BEND WA julie Alicea Denair CA Bryan Bell Port Angeles WA Janis Alldis Scotts Valley CA Michelle