NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

PATRICK J. HEATON

PRINCIPAL, CULTCULTURALURAL RESOURCES SERVICES

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Patrick(Patrick J. Heaton)Heaton)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Patrick J. Heaton, Heaton, Environmental Design Design & Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Principal, Cultural Resources ServicesServices..

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I have been employed with EDR since 2010.2010.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Anthropology from Hartwick College in

12 1994.1994. I also received a Master of Arts in AnthropologyAnthropology from New York

13 University in 1999.1999. I have more than 20 years of experience in managing

14 cultural resources compliance, environmental permitting, and historic

15 preservation projects. projects. I also have significant experience with

16 transportation, energy transmission, transmission, and utility -scale-scale renewable energy

17 projects in New York, New England, Ohio, and Maryland. My current

18 curriculum vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant

19 professional experience.

20

21

1 of 4

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Patrick(Patrick J. Heaton)Heaton)

1 Q. What are your current responsibilities at EDREDR??

2 A.A. In my current position,position, I am responsible for overseeing cultural resource

3 surveys, archaeological investigations, historic preservation planning

4 projects, and development of avoidance and/or mitigation strategies for

5 archaeological sites and historic properties.properties. IInn addition,addition, I managemanage and/orand/or

6 serveserve asas PrincipalPrincipal-in-in--ChargeCharge forfor eenvironmentalnvironmental permittingpermitting projects,projects,

7 includingincluding proposed solarsolar energyenergy projectsprojects inin NewNew York.York.

8 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

9 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

10 A. Yes.Yes. I provided testimony related to cultural resources surveys and visual

11 impact assessments for the Cassadaga Wind Project,Project, Galloo Island Wind

12 Project, Bluestone Wind Project, and the Baron Winds Project.

13 Q. Have you previously previously served as an expert witness before any other

14 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

15 offer testimony on in this prproceeding?oceeding?

16 A. Yes.Yes. I sponsored testimony regarding cultural resources investigations

17 conducted for the CentralCentral Hudson A and C Line Rebuild Project andand South

18 Fork Export Cable before the New York State Public Service

19 Commission.Commission. In addition,addition, I have provided testimony to the Public ServServiceice

20 Commission of Maryland related to a review of the environmental impacts

21 for the Great Bay Solar I Project. In addition, I have provided testimony

2 of 4

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Patrick(Patrick J. Heaton)Heaton)

1 before the Ohio Power Siting Board regarding the review of

2 environmental impacts impacts (including cultural resources resources and visual impacts)

3 for the Icebreaker Wind Project.

4 Q. What isis the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

5 A. To sponsor sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application Application for a

6 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connectconnectionion

7 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facilityfacility in

8 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County,County, New York.York.

9 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects aspects of the Application will you be

10 sponsoring?sponsoring?

11 A. I will be sponsoring the following following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 2, Overview and

12 Public Involvement; Exhibit 3, Location of Facilities; Facilities; Exhibit 9,

13 Alternatives;Alternatives; ExhibiExhibitt 10, Consistency with Energy Planning Objectives;

14 EExhibitxhibit 13, Real Property;Property; Exhibit 15, Public Health and Safety; Exhibit

15 17, AirAir Emissions; Exhibit 20, Cultural Resources; Exhibit 21, Geology,

16 SSeismologyeismology and Soils; Exhibit 28, Environmental Justice; Exhibit Exhibit 32,

17 State Laws and Regulations; and Exhibit 33, Other Applications and

18 Filings.

19 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared prepared by you, or under

20 your direction and/or supervision?

21 A. Yes.

3 of 4

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Patrick(Patrick J. Heaton)Heaton)

1 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

2 A. Yes.

4 of 4

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA Principal, Cultural Resources Services

Patrick Heaton is a Principal and the Director of Cultural Resources at EDR. He is a Registered Professional ArchaeologistArchaeologist (RPA) with more than 20 years of experience managing cultural resources (i.e., archaeological and historic sites) compliance, environmental permitting,permitting, and historic preservation projects, and meets the Qualifications for the Secretary of the Interior'sInterior’s Standards for Archaeology and Historic Preservation (per 36 CFR 61). His primary areas of technical expertise include archaeology, cultural reresourcessources management, visual impact assessment, and environmental permitting compliance and strategy, including State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) and Tribal consultation,consultation, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA).(SEQRA). As Director of Cultural Resources, Patrick oversees cultural resources surveys, archaeological investigations, historic preservation planning projects,projects, and develops avoidance and/or mitigation strategies for archaeological sites and historic properties.properties. Mr. Heaton has significant experience with transportation,transportation, energy transmission, and utility-scale-scale renewable energy (wind and solar) projects in New York, New England, Ohio, and Maryland. educationeducation employmentemployment history Master of Arts, Anthropology,Anthropobgy, New York University, 1999. Principal,Principal, Cultural Resources Services, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C., Bachebr of Arts, Anthropobgy, Hartwidc College, 1994. Bachelor of Arts, Anthropology, Hartwick College, 1994. Syracuse, NY, 2013-present.-present. registration / certifications Project Manager, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture,Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C., Syracuse, Registered Professional ArchaeobgistArchaeologist (RPA), 2000. NY, 2010-2013.2010-2013. Meets the Secretary of Interior'sInterior’s Standards for ArchaeobgyArchaeology andand Historic Associate, Principal Archaeologist, and Project Manager, John Milner Preservation (36 CFR Part 61). Associates, Inc., Croton-on-on-Hudson,-Hudson, NY, 2004-2010.2004-2010. professional affiliation.affiliations Project Archaeologist, John Milner Associates, Inc., CrotonCroton-on-on-Hudson,-Hudson, NY,NY, 2000-2004.2000-2004. Board of Directors,Directors, New York Archaeological CouncilCouncil,, 2018-present.-present. Graduate Teaching Assistant, Anthropology Department, New York Member,Member, Council for Northeast Historical Archaeology.Archaeology. University, New York, NY, 1997-2000.1997-2000. Member,Member, New York State Archaeological Association (NYSAA).(NYSAA). Research ConsultantConsultant,, Sass Conservation, Inc., Yonkers, NY,NY, 19981998-2000.-2000. Vice-President,-President, Board of Directors (2014-2016),(2014-2016), Preservation Association Field Archaeologist,Archaeologist, Various Firms, NY,NY, RI,RI, MA,MA, PA,PA, CTCT,, 19951995-1999.-1999. of Central New York (PACNY).

Village of Fayetteville Historic Preservation Commission (2010-2014).(2010-2014). Executive Board (2006-2007),(2006-2007), Professional Archaeologists of New York City (PANYC).(PANYC). proprojectject experience Mohawk Solar, Montgomery County, NY-NY- Principal-in-in-Charge-Charge and Project Manager for environmental permitting studies for a proposed 90 MW solar energy facility,facility, the firstfirst solar project to pursupursuee a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law. Services have included preparation of a Public Involvement Program Plan, Preliminary Scoping Statement, Article 10 Application, GIS data management and mapping, archaeological and historic resources surveys, wetland delineation,delineation, threatened and endangered species habitat assessment, avian surveys, agricultural land use analysis, socioeconomic analysis, visual impact assessment, visual mitigationmitigation planting plan, public outreach support, stakeholder engagement, and agency consultation.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.cort.www.edrdpc.com

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

Flint Mine Solar, Greene County, NY-NY- Principal-in-in-Charge-Charge and Project Manager for environmental permitting studies for proposed 100 MW solar energy facility pursuing a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law. Services have included preparation of an environmental permitting Critical Issues Analysis,Analysis, siting design support, assistance with Public Involvement Program Plan, preparation of a Preliminary Scoping Statement, Phase IAIA archaeological investigation, SHPO consultation, wetland delineationdelineation,, threatened/endangered species habitat assessment, pubpubliclic outreach, stakeholder engagement, and regulatory agency consultation. BluestoneBluestone Wind Farm, Broome County, NY-NY- Technical oversight for aarchaeologicalrchaeological survey,survey, historichistoric resourcesresources surveysurvey and effects analysisanalysis,, State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) consultation, and cultural resources mitigation in support of Article 10 Application to the New York State Board on Electrical Generating Siting and the Environment for a proposed 124124 MW wind energy facility. SouthSouth Fork Export Cable,Cable, On-shore-shore Transmission Line & Substation Facilities, Suffolk County, NYNY-- Principal-in-in-Charge-Charge and Project Manager for State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) consultation, Phase I archaeological survey,survey, historic-architectural-architectural resourceresourcess survey, and Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) as part of consultant team with AECOM and VHB in support of an New York State Public Service Law Article VII application for a 138kV underground transmission line and new substation associated with a proposed 90-MW-MW offshore wind energy project. South Fork Wind Farm, Outer Continental Shelf, Rhode Island-Massachusetts-Massachusetts Wind Energy Lease Area-Area- Provided technical oversight for historic resources visual effects analysis and terrestrial archaeological assessments in supportsupport of National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act by the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) review for a proposed 90-MW-MW offshore wind energy project. Coxsackie Correctional Facility, Greene County, NY-NY- Principal-in-in-Charge-Charge for a Phase I-Ill-III archaeological site investigation and data recovery, wetland delineations, wetland permitting, threatened and endangered species surveys, Incidental Take Permit, and preparation of a habitathabitat conservaconservationtion plan for a proposed 8--acreacre Training Facility. Directed archaeological field investigations, artifact analysis, and technical report for a Pre-Contact-Contact Native American archaeological site resulting in the recovery of approximately 7,000 artifacts. On behalfbehalf of the New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (DOCCS) and Office of General Services (OGS), coordinated agency and stakeholder consultation pursuant to Section 14.09 of the New York State Historic Preservation Act and SectionSection 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act with the New York State Historic Preservation Office, Department of Environmental Conservation, United States Army Corps of Engineers, Stockbridge-MunseeStockbridge-Munsee Band of Mohican Indians, and Delaware Nation. InterstateInterstate 81 (1-81)(I-81) Viaduct Project,Project, Archaeological Assessment, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Managed the Phase IAIA Archaeological Sensitivity Assessment and Phase IB shovel testing survey conducted to help support Section 106 of the National Historic PreservationPreservation Act consultation and National Environmental PolicyActPolicy Act (NEPA) review as part of a consultant team with Parsons and AKRF, Inc. on behalf of the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) for the replacement of approximately 5 miles of elevated highways (NYSDOT PIN 3501.60). Coordinated State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) consultation and assisted with public outreach events/meetings and preparation. Interstate 81 (1-81)(I-81) Viaduct Project,Project, Visual Impact Assessment, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Managed the Visual Impact Assessment in accordance with Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) standards conducted to help support NEPA review as part of a consultant team with Parsons, AKRF, Inc., and TVVMLATWMLA for the replacement of approximately 5 miles of elevated highways (NYSDOT PIN 3501.60). Block Island Wind Farm, Block Island, RI-RI- Assisted with management and preparation of VIA for the first offshore wind farm constructed in the United States. Block Island Wind Farm includes 5 wind turbines and is a 30 MW facility located 3 miles off Block Island in the AtlanticAtlantic Ocean. Project role included field photography, coordination of visual impact analyses, and technical report writing.writing. Village of Mohawk Water Wells, Herkimer County, NY-NY- Oversaw the archaeological monitoring of excavation/construction of water wells within a 1.2-acre-acre parcel being redeveloped with storm-resilient-resilient municipal and utility infrastructure. Monitoring conductedconducted as part of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act consultation for the New York GovernorsGovernor’s Office of Storm Recovery (GOSR) and Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). City of Oneida Storm Recovery Project, City of Oneida, Madison County,County, NY-NY- Oversaw the archaeological investigations, construction monitoringmonitoring,, SWPPP preparationpreparation,, and SWPPP inspections for demolition of 154 structures in the City of Oneida. Phase I archaeological survey/testing and construction monitoring during construction activities as part of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act compliance for the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA;(FEMA; HMGP Project #4031-0035).#4031-0035). Great Bay Solar I, Somerset County, MD-MD- Oversaw the environmental permitting studies in support of Maryland Public Service Commission review for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN), including preparation of an Environmental Review Document (ERD), wetland delineations, visualvisual

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

Assessment,Assessment, Phase 1 archaeologicalarchaeological survey,survey, Phase II archaeologicalarchaeological sitesite investigation,investigation, hhistoricistoric rresourcesesources aassessment,ssessment, rare plant survey, wetland permitting, and local permitting for a proposed 100 MW solar energy project located on 800-acres.-acres. Solar Development Project (Private Client), Worcester County, MD-MD- Oversaw the environmental permitting studies in support of an application for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN) from the Maryland Public Service Commission, including preparation of an Environmental Review Document (ERD), wetland delineation and permitting, threatened/endangered species habitat assessment) and cultural (archaeological(archaeological and historic) resources studies forafor a proposed 100 MW solarsolar energy project located on 900-acres.-acres. Walton River GasGas Main HDD, Delaware County, NY-NY- Oversaw the Phase I archaeologicalarchaeological surveysurvey and Phase II aarchaeologicalrchaeological sitesite investigationsinvestigations for a proposed gasgas mainmain adjacent to the West Branch of the Delaware River. Beaver Road Industrial Park,Park, Monroe County, NY-NY- Oversaw the Phase 1B archaeological investigations for a 49-acre-acre parcel. Onondaga Creekwalk Phase II, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Managed the environmental permitting services and cultural rresourcesesources surveys as part of a consultant team with C&S Engineers for the a 2.2-mile-mile recreational trail along Onondaga Creek (NYSDOT PIN 355.14). Services provided as part of coordinated SEQRA/NEPA review included: preparation of a Section 106 Project SubmittalSubmittal Package; Phase 1 Archaeological and Historic Resources Surveys; rare, threatened, and endangered (RTE) species assessments; Section 4(f) Consultation correspondence; and, the environmentalenvironmental portions of a NYSDOT Design Approval Document. Term Contract forfor Bridge Rehabilitation,Rehabilitation, New York State Thruway Authority (NYSTA),(NYSTA), Western New York-York- Managed the environmental and cultural resources services to support environmental permitting as part of consultant team with Stantec for NYSTA bridge rehabilitatiorehabilitationn projects. Services include: preparation of Section 106 Project Submittal Packages; Phase 1A ArchaeologicalArchaeological Assessments and/or Phase 1 Archaeological Surveys; wetland reconnaissance and/or delineations; rare, threatened, and endangered (RTE) species assessments; Section 4(f) Consultation correspondence;correspondence; and, the environmental portions of Design Approval Documents.Documents. Onondaga Lake Parkway/NY Route 370, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Managed the environmental permitting studies as part of coordinated SEQRA/NEPA review as part of a consultant team with Lochner for the reconstruction and safety improvementsimprovements of 2--milemile parkway (NYSDOT PIN 3287.17). Services include wetland delineation and permitting, rare, threatened, and endangered (RTE) species assessments, groundwater modeling, historic landscape inventory, and visual impact assessment. Arkwright Summit WindWind Farm,Farm, Chautauqua County, NY-NY- Managed the environmental permitting for a proposed 36-turbine,-turbine, 78-megawatt-megawatt (MW) wind energy facility and associated 3-mile-mile generator leadlead line.line. Services include managing review under New York State Environmental Quality ReviewReview Act (SEQRA), including Lead Agency coordination, preparation of Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS), Final EnvironmentalEnvironmental Impact Statement (FEIS), Visual Impact Assessment, shadow flflickericker analysis, supplemental Phase 1B Archaeological Survey,Survey, Historic Resources Assessment, and preparation of Joint Application for Permit for wetland permitting for submission to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC).

Cassadaga Wind Farm, ChautauquaChautauqua County, NY-NY- Directed the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey, Historic Resources Survey, State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) consultation, and Visual Impact Assessment in support of Article 10 Application to the New York State Board on Electrical Generating Siting and the EnvironmentEnvironment for a proposed 70 wind turbine, 126 MW wind energy facility. Baron Winds Project, Steuben County, NYNY-- Directed the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey, Historic Resources Survey, State Historic PreservationPreservation Office (SHPO) consultation in support of ArtideArticle 1100 Application to the New York State Board on Electrical Generating Siting and the Environment for a proposed (up to) 300 MW wind energy project with up to 80 wind turbines. North Carolina Wind Energy Lease Areas, NCNC-- Managed the visual assessment conducted as part of a National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Environmental Assessment for the North Carolina Wind EnergyArea.Energy Area. Commissioned by the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)(BOEM) and ICF, EDR'sEDR’s visual assessment included identification of visually sensitivesensitive sites (e.g., historic sites), field photography, and the production of daytime and nighttime photo simulations demonstrating the potential visibility and visual impact of offshore meteorological towers. This project also includedincluded the production of time-lapsetime-lapse videos showing the towers visual impact over an 18-hour-hour period. Emerging Technology & Entrepreneurship Complex (ETEC), University at Albany,Albany, Albany County, NY-NY- Oversaw the SEQRA review, including preparation of a Scoping Document, Supplement EnvironmentalEnvironmental Impact Statement (SEIS), Phase 1B Archaeological Survey, Visual Assessment, FEIS,

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 3 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

SEQRA Findings Statement, and coordination of traffic study (by sub-consultant)-consultant) on behalf of the State University Construction Fund (SUCF) for a 12-acre-acre site proposed for new academic building on the New York State Office of General Services (OGS) Harriman Campus. Amherst State ParkPark Pedestrian Improvements Project, Town of Amherst, Erie County, NY-NY- Directed the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey, SHPO consultation, and development of archaeological site avoidance measures for a proposed 1-mile-mile multi-use/pedestrianmulti-use/pedestrian trail. Seneca Bus Facility,Facility, Rochester Genesee Regional Transit Authority (RGRTA),(RGRTA), Village of Waterloo, Seneca County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and wetland reconnaissance as part of consultant team with AKRF, Inc. in support of NEPA review of 1-acre-acre transit facility.facility. West River Greenway Trail, Grand Island, NY-NY- Oversaw the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and visual renderings as part of consultant team with C&S Engineers, Inc. for a proposed 8-mile-mile multi-use/pedestrianmulti-use/pedestrian trail along the Niagara River. American Packaging Facility, Town of Chili, Monroe County, NYNY-- PreparedPrepared the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and SHPO consultation for a proposed 35-acre-acre commercial/light industrial facility.facility. Interstate 690 (I-690)(I-690) Teall Avenue & Beech Street Interchange,Interchange, CityCity of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Oversaw the Visual Assessment and Archaeological Resources Screening as part of National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA) review and Section 106 consultatioconsultationn as part of a consultant team with Parsons and AKRF, Inc. on behalf of the NYSDOT for a bridge replacement and intersection improvement of 0.5-mile-mile elevated highway. Canalways Trail,Trail, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Directed the Section 106 Project Submittal Package and Phase 1A Archaeological Assessment as ppartart of a consultant team with CHA for the design and construction of a 2.7-mile-mile recreational trail along the shorelineshoreline of Onondaga Lake (NYSDOT PIN 3950.49). Penn Forest Wind Farm,Farm, Carbon County, PA-PA- Supervised the preliminary visual assessment, visual fieldwork, viewshed analysis, visual simulations, and preparation of public outreach materials for proposed 40-turbine-turbine wind energyenergy facility.facility. Stiles Brook Wind Farm,Farm, Towns of Windham and Grafton, VT-VT- Oversaw the prelimpreliminaryinary visual assessment, visual fieldwork, viewshed analysis, visual simulations, and preparation of public outreach materials for proposed 3030-turbine-turbine wind energy facility. Substation Relocation,Relocation, Village of Mohawk, Herkimer County, NY-NY- Managed the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey conducted as part of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act consultation for a proposed 1.2-acre-acre substation relocation project. Project sponsored by New York GovernorsGovernor’s Office of Storm Recovery (GOSR) and Federal EmergencyEmergency Management Agency (FEMA). Highway Garage,Garage, Town of Nichols, Tioga County, NY-NY- Supervised the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey conducted as part of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act consultation for a 7.0-acre-acre site proposed for relocatirelocationon of a municipal highway garage.garage. Project sponsored by New York GovernorsGovernor’s Office of Storm Recovery (GOSR) and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Jericho Rise Wind Farm,Farm, Franklin County, NY-NY- Directed the Phase 1B archaeological survey,survey, historic resources survey and effects analysis, and SHPO consultation in support of SEQRA review and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers wetland permitting for a proposed 37 wind turbine, 7878 MW wind energy facility.facility. Liverpool Village Cemetery Restoration Plan,Plan, Village of Liverpool, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Oversaw the historic landscape preservation planning and restoration project, associated NYS Consolidated Funding Application (CFA), and public outreach for a 6-acre-acre cemetery listed on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP).(NRHP). Cumberland Bay State Park, Camping Area Comfort Station Replacements,Replacements, Clinton County, NYNY-- Oversaw the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey for proposed comfort station replacements in a state park on Lake Champlain.Champlain. Services provided as part of a consultant team with Beardsley Architects & Engineers, D.P.C. for a Term Services Agreement with the New York State OOfficeffice of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation (NYSOPRHP). Montezuma Heritage Park & Giardina Park,Park, Town of Montezuma, Cayuga County, NY-NY- Supervised the Phase 1A Archaeological Resources Surveys in support of historic preservation planning for a prproposedoposed 168-acre-acre heritage park that interprets archaeological remains of the Erie and Cayuga-Seneca-Seneca Canals and an addiadditionaltional 16--acreacre town parkpark.. Main Street Campus Improvements,Improvements, Rochester Genesee Regional Transit Authority (RGRTA),(RGRTA), City of Rochester, Monroe County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared a Phase 1B Archaeological Survey in support of NEPA review of this 3-acre-acre transit facility.facility.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 4 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

School of Pharmacy,Pharmacy, Binghamton University,University, Village of Johnson City, Broome County, NY-NY- Supervised the SEQRA review (including preparation of a Full Environmental Assessment Form, or EAF) and Phase 1A Archaeological Assessment on behalf of the State University ConstructionConstruction Fund (SUCF) for a 5.5-acre-acre site proposed for new academicacademic building.building. Maxwell Field Streambank Stabilization Project,Project, City of Oneida, Madison County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey for this 0.3-acre-acre streambank stabilizationstabilization project.project. Chain Works District Redevelopment Project,Project, City of Ithaca, Tompkins County, NY-NY- Prepared a Phase 1A Archaeological Survey in support of SEQRA review of 95-acre-acre historic industrial site proposed for redevelopment. Central Hudson Gas & Electric W-H-H & G Transmission Lines,Lines, Ulster County & Dutchess County, NY-NY- Directed the SHPO consultation, archaeologicalarchaeological surveys,surveys, and visual impact studies in support of NYS Public Service Commission Part 102 Applications for the refurbishment of a 13-mile-mile transmissiontransmission-line-line and an 11--milemile transmissiontransmission line.line. Coye Hill Wind Farm,Farm, Tolland County, CT-CT- Supervised the NaturalNatural Resources Impact Evaluation Report and consultation with the Connecticut SHPO in support of Petition for a Declaratory Ruling from the Connecticut Siting Council for proposed 4-turbine,-turbine, 12 MW wind energy projectproject.. NFG Dunkirk Pipeline,Pipeline, Chautauqua County,County, NY-NY- Supervised the SHPO consultation and Phase 1A/1B Archaeological Surveys in support of NYS Public Service Commission Article VII Application for a proposed 9--milemile natural gas pipeline. Orleans County Transit Facility, Rochester Genesee Regional Transit Authority (RGRTA),(RGRTA), Orleans County, NYNY-- PreparedPrepared the Phase 1A Archaeological Survey in support of NEPA review of proposed 2-acre-acre bus storage/service facility.facility. Great Bay Wind Project,Project, Somerset County, MD-MD- Prepared the culturalcultural resources surveys,surveys, the consultation with the Maryland Historical Trust (MHT), and the Visual ImpactAssessmentImpact Assessment for a proposed 35--turbine,turbine, 100 MW wind energyenergy projectproject.. Services provided in support of Maryland Public Service Commission review for a CPCN and Section 106 conconsultationsultation as part of NEPA review by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in association with Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act take permit review. Onondaga Lake West Revitalization Area,Area, Village of Solvay, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Prepared the Phase 1 culturalcultural resources surveys of 400-acre-acre brownfield area and proproposedposed streetscape improvements.improvements. Van Dyke Road Substation,Substation, Albany County, NY-NY- DirectedDirected the Visual Impact Assessment and Phase 1 archaeological survey for a proposed 4.3-acre-acre substation site and 1.6-mile-mile underground transmissiontransmission duct bank.bank. Batavia Senior Housing Project,Project, Genesee County, NY-NY- Supervised the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and prepared Phase 2 Archaeological Site Investigation Work Plan for a 13.5--acreacre site proposed for development as a senior housinhousingg facility.facility. Copenhagen Wind Project,Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Prepared the Phase 1A/1B Archaeological Survey and Historic Resources Survey, New York SHPO consultation, Visual Impact Assessment, and preparepreparedd sections of Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) and FEIS as part of SEQRA review for proposed 47-turbine,-turbine, approximately 79 MW wind energy projectproject.. Black Oak Wind Farm,Farm, Tompkins County, NY-NY- Directed the Phase 1A Cultural Resources Survey, Historic Resources Visual Effects Analysis, and SHPO consultation in support of SEQRA review for a proposed 7-wind-wind turbine, 14-MW-MW wind energyenergy project.project. Downtown Syracuse Commercial Historic District,District, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Prepared the National RegisterRegister of Historic Places (NRHP) nomination and Multiple Property Documentation Form on behalf of the Downtown Committee of Syracuse, Inc. for a proposed 21-acre-acre historic district. The nomination was approved by the National Park Service and listed on the NRHPNRHP on May 7, 2013. Chittenango Landing Dry Dock Complex Cultural Landscape Report,Report, Town of Sullivan, Madison County, NY-NY- Prepared the Part 1 of a Cultural Landscape Report (CLR) on behalf of the Chittenango Landing Canal Boat Museum for a 6-acre-acre historic site/museum listed on the NRHP. The interpretive site includes a 19th19th-century-century dry dock complex and associated buildingsbuildings located on the Erie Canal. Aquidneck Island Reliability Project,Project, Newport, RI-RI- DirectedDirected visual fieldwork, visual simulations, and report preparation for a Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) for the proposed upgrade of approximately 4.4 miles of National Grid 69 kV transmissitransmissionon line to 115 kVkV..

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 5 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

Mary Cariola Children'sChildren’s Center,Center, Town of Henrietta, Monroe County, NY-NY- Supervised a Phase 1 Archaeological Survey conducted as part of SEQRA review for a proposed residential facility for ddisabledisabled children located on 1.3-acres.-acres. CentralCentral Hudson Gas & Electric A & C Transmission Lines,Lines, Dutchess County, NY-NY- DirectedDirected SHPO consultation, Phase 1 Archaeological Survey,Survey, and Visual Impact Assessment in support of ArtideArticle VII application for the rebuild of 11 milmileses of 115 kV transmission lines. Indian Point Energy Center (IPEC),(IPEC), Westchester County, NY-NY- On behalf of Scenic Hudson, Inc., and Riverkeeper, coordinated preparation of visual simulations and Visual Impact Assessment for a proposed dosedclosed-cycle-cycle cooling (CCC) systemsystem at a nuclear energy facility. Scioto Ridge Wind Farm,Farm, Hardin & Logan Counties, OH-OH- Prepared Cultural Resources Survey Work Plans in support of Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB) Certificate Application for proposed wind energy project with up to 176 wind turbines and a generating capacity of up to 300 MW. School of Medical & Biological Sciences,Sciences, University at Buffalo, City of Buffalo, Erie County,County, NY-NY- Supervised the SEQRA process on behalf of the State University Construction Fund, including preparation of DEIS and support studies (Visual Assessment, Archaeological SensitivitySensitivity Assessment, andand Historic Resources Impact Assessment), conducted SEQRA public hearing, preparation of FEIS, and SEQRA Findings Statement for a proposed ~600,000—600,000 gross square foot medical/educational facility located on the UniversityUniversity at Buffalo'sBuffalo’s Downtown Campus. Wild Meadows Wind Project,Project, Grafton & Merrimack Counties, NH-NH- DirectedDirected visual fieldwork/photography and presented visual resources analyses and simulations at public open houses conducted in support of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) consultationconsultation for a proposed 37- turbine,turbine, 74 MW wind energy projeproject.ct. Loveless Farms,Farms, Town of Skaneateles in Onondaga County, NY-NY- DirectedDirected the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and Visual Impact Assessment in support of SEQRA review for a proposed 1818-lot-lot subdivision located on 47-acres.-acres. White Pine Commerce Park,Park, Town of Clay,Clay, Onondaga County, NY-Supervised- Supervised the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and SHPO consultation for Onondaga County Industrial Development Authority (OCIDA) in support of SEQRA review for a 300-acre-acre parcel and 4-mile-mile sewer line. Empire Brewing Company FamisteadFarmstead Brewery,Brewery, Town of Cazenovia, Madison County, NY-NY- Oversaw the visual assessment, viewshed analyses, visual simulations, and analysis of visual effects on NRHP-listedNRHP-listed properties as part of SEQRA review for a proposed craft brewery. Wilcox Estates,Estates, Town of BartonBarton in Tioga County, NY-NY- Oversaw the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey as part of SEQRA review for a proposed 32-lot-lot subdivision located on 20-acres.-acres. Barcelona Water Improvement District,District, Town of Westfield in Chautauqua County, NY-NY- Prepared the Phase 1 ArchaeologicalArchaeological Survey as part of Section 106 of the NHPA review for a 4-mile-mile long public water system located in the hamlet of Barcelona. Village of Danforth Historic Resources Survey,Survey, Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Developed the public outreach strategy, historic resource inventory forms, and visual field guide to enable community volunteers to conduct a Neighborhood Historic Resource Survey and NRHP eligibilityeligibility evaluation of over 300 buildings for the City of Syracuse Bureau of Planning and Sustainability. Student Life Center,Center, SUNY Cortland,Cortland, City of Cortland, Cortland County, NY-NY- Supervised the SEQRA process on behalf of the State University Construction Fund, including preparation of DEIS, support studies (including, Visual ImpactImpact Assessment, Phase 1A Cultural Resources Survey, and Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment), FEIS and SEQRA Findings Statement for proposed recreationalrecreational athletic facility. Newfield Covered Bridge,Bridge, Town of Newfield, Tompkins County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared the Phase 1A Cultural Resources Survey for a NRHP-listedNRHP-listed historic bridge rehabilitation (NYSDOT PIN 37550). Owasco River Greenway Trail,Trail, City of Auburn & Town of Fleming, Cayuga County, NY-NY- DirectedDirected the Phase 1A Cultural Resources Survey for a proposed 8.4-mile-mile-multi-multi-modal-modal recreationalrecreational trail (NYSDOT Project 375557). Niagara Falls Underground Railroad Heritage Area Management Plan,Plan, Niagara County, NY-NY- Prepared a Heritage Area Management Plan (HAMP) authorized under Section 35.05 of the New York State Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation Law to identify and encourage heritage tourism opportunities related to the Underground Railroad in the Niagara Falls vicinity.vicinity. ASLA Award for Historic Preservation. Seneca Park Zoo Parking Lot Expansion,Expansion, City of RochesterRochester & Town of Irondequoit, Monroe County, NYNY-- Managed a Phase 1 Archaeological Survey in support of SEQRA review on behalf of Monroe County Parks Department for a 1.5-acre-acre parcel.parcel.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 6 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

Crown City Wind Project,Project, Cortland County, NY-NY- Managed the Cultural ResourcesResources Survey, Visual Impact Assessment, and prepared DEIS sections as part of SEQRA review for proposed 44-turbine,-turbine, approximately 71 MW wind energy project. Buckeye II Wind Project,Project, Champaign County, OHOH-- DirectedDirected the Visual Impact Assessment for a proposed 56-turbine,-turbine, 140 MW wind energy project in support of an Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).(OPSB). Monticello Hills Wind Project,Project, Otsego County, NY-NY- Supervised the SEQRA process and preparation of permitting support studies (including Full Environmental Assessment Form, Visual Impact Assessment, wetland delineation, shadow-flicker-flicker analysis, Phase 1A Cultural Resources Survey, Historic Resources Survey, and Phase 1B ArchaeologicalArchaeological Survey) for a proposed six-turbine,-turbine, 18 MW wind energy project. South Mountain Wind Project,Project, Delaware County, NY-NY- Managed the preparation of environmental permitting studies in support of SEQRA review (including wetland delineation, threatenedthreatened and endangered species habitat assessment, and timber rattlesnake survey) for a proposed community-scale-scale wind energy project. Smokey Avenue Wind Project,Project, Otsego County, NY-NY- Supervised the preparation of environmental permitting studies in support of SEQRASEQRA review (including Shadow Flicker Analysis, ballooning fieldwork and visibility study, and Phase 1A Cultural Resources Survey) for proposed commcommunityunity-scale-scale wind energy project. Roaring Brook Wind Power Project,Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Directed the supplemental/addendumsupplemental/addendum Phase 1B Archaeological Survey in association with project layout revisions for a proposed 79MW wind energy project.project. Sackets Harbor Battlefield National Historic Landmark (NHL) Nomination,Nomination, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Prepared sections of NHL nomination and Battlefield Preservation Plan for the 260-acre-acre War of 1812 battlefield in Sackets Harbor,Harbor, under a grant from the American Battlefield Protection Program of the National Park Service. Warren Hull Family Home & Famistead,Farmstead, Erie County, NY-NY- Coordinated prepreparationparation of graphic displays for cultural landscape historic overview and treatment plan to support restoration of the landscape at a ca. 1825 landmark house museum. Long Island - New York City Offshore Wind Project,Project, Queens, Nassau, & Suffolk Counties, NYNY-- Supervised the preparation of visual simulations, web- based presentationpresentation,, and associated visualization services for a proposed 350 MW offshore wind energy project located in the Atlantic Ocean approximately 13-miles-miles off the coast. Allegany Wind Power Project,Project, Cattaraugus County, NY-NY- Prepared the supplemental/addendum Phase 1B Archaeological Survey in association with review of construction plans by New York SHPO for a proposed 29-turbine,-turbine, 72.5 MW wind energy project. Horse Creek Wind Farm,Farm, Jefferson County,County, NY-NY- Directed the Visual Impact Assessment, including viewshed analysis, field work, photographic simulations, and VIA report for a proposed 50-turbine,-turbine, 100 MW wind energy project.

Tioga Downs Wastewater Improvement Project,Project, Tioga County, NY-NY- Supervised the Phase 1 Archaeological Survey and Phase 2 Archaeological Site Investigation of a pre-contact-contact Native American archaeological site for a wastewater treatment facilityfacility and 0.5-mile-mile water line. Collegetown Terrace,Terrace, Tompkins County, NY-NY- Managed the SEQRA review and prepared FEIS on behalf of the City of Ithaca Planning & Development Board for a 16-acre,-acre, 1,260-unit-unit student housing project. Big Savage 138 kV Generator Lead,Lead, Allegany County, MD-MD- Managed the Visual Impact Assessment and Cultural Resources Assessment for Maryland Public Service Commission CPCN review of a proposed 7-mile-mile transmission line. Marble River Wind Project,Project, Clinton County, NY-NY- Supervised the cultural resources and visual impacts analysesanalyses for SEQRA permitting review of a revised layout for a 74-wind-wind turbine, 222 MW wind energy project. Amherst State Park Veterans Memorial,Memorial, Erie County, NY-NY- Managed the Phase 1B Archaeological Survey for a proposed veterans’veterans' memorial and 1,500- foot footpathfootpath in Amherst State Park. Timber Road II Wind Project,Project, Paulding County, OH-OH- Directed the Visual Impact Assessment for a 109-turbine,-turbine, 150 MW wind energy project in support of an Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need submittedsubmitted to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).(OPSB).

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 7 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Patrick J. Heaton,Heaton, RPA I Principal, Cultural Resources Services

Hardscrabble Wind Power Project,Project, Herkimer County, NY-NY- Directed the supplemental Phase 1B Archaeological Survey, construction monitoring, and compliance with U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/SHPO Memorandum of AgreementAgreement for a 37-turbine,-turbine, 74 MW wind energy projectproject.. Benson Mines Meteorological Tower,Tower, St. Lawrence County, NY-NY- Directed the visual assessment, ballooning fieldwork, and visual simulations in accordance with the Adirondack Park Agency (APA) Visual Analysis Methodology for a proposed 160-foot-foot meteorological tower.tower. Deerfield Wind Power Project,Project, Bennington County, VT-VT- Prepared sections of Supplemental DEIS for a 15-turbine,-turbine, 30 MW wind energy project located in the Green Mountain National Forest, as part of NEPANEPA review on behalf of the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) National Forest Service. 115 kV Line, Lighthouse Hill to Coffeen Street,Street, National Grid,Grid, Oswego & Jefferson Counties, NY-NY- Prepared visual impact assessment portion of Part 102 Report for a 40-mile-mile 115 kV transmission line maintenance and refurbishment project. Eastover Road Substation & Tap Line,Line, National Grid, Town of Schagticoke, Rensselaer County, NY-NY- Ballooning/visual impactimpact assessment fieldwork for a proposed 6.4-acre-acre 230/115 kV substation and 0.75-mile-mile 155 kV tap line. Master Agreement for Class III Cultural Resources Services,Services, Wyoming Department of Transportation, (2018-2020)-(2018-2020)- Oversaw the Master Agreement, numerous ClassClass III inventories statewide in support of transportation infrastructure projects. To date, projects have been completed in BigBig Horn, Converse, Fremont, Hot Springs, Park, and Washakie Counties under this master agreement. Bates Creek Cultural Resources InventoryInventory Project, Albany, Carbon, Converse, & Natrona Counties, WY (2017)-(2017)- Supervised the Class III Inventory in support of Section 106 compliance for proposed range improvements for the Bureau of Land Management, Casper Field Office. Collegetown Terrace SEQRA, City of Ithaca, NY-NY- Oversaw the SEQRA review and prepared FEIS on behalf of the City of Ithaca Planning & Development Board forafor a 16-acre,-acre, 1,260-unit-unit student housing project. publications/presentationspublications/presentation;

Presenter. It'sIt’s a Brave New World: Online Consultation with the New York State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). 2015 New York State Wetlands Forum Conference, Syracuse, NY. April 2015. Poster Presentation. The Effect of Larger Rotor Diameters and Taller Hub Heights on Shadow Flicker Impacts.Impacts. 2013 American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) Wind Conference, Chicago,Chicago, IL. May 2013. Presenter. Cultural Heritage Planning: History as a Marketable Asset.Asset. Annual Conference of the New York Upstate Chapter of the American Planning Association, Corning, NY. September 2012. Presenter. Use of Visualization Techniques andand Computer Graphics to Address the Visibility and Appearance of Off-shore-shore Wind Projects.Projects. 2011 AWEA Offshore Wind Conference, Baltimore, MD. October 2011. Heaton, Patrick J., J. Sanderson Stevens, L.E. BranchBranch-Raymer,-Raymer, & J. Wettstaed. 2010. Archaeological InvestigationsInvestigations of an Early Farmstead Site in Shelby County, Indiana.Indiana. Indiana Archaeology 5(2):745(2):74-95.-95. Heaton, Patrick J. 2003. The Rural Settlement History of the Hector Backbone.Backbone. Northeast Historical Archaeology 32:1932:19-28.–28. Heaton, Patrick J. 2003. Farmsteads and Finances in the Finger Lakes: Using Archival Sources in a GIS Database.Database. Northeast Historical Archaeology 32:2932:29-44.–44. Six, Janet, Patrick J. Heaton, Susan Malin-Boyce,-Boyce, & James A. Delle. 2003. The Artifact Assemblage from the Finger Lakes National Forest Archaeology Project. Northeast Historical Archaeology 32:79-94.32:79–94. Delle, James A., & Patrick J. Heaton. 2003. The Hector Backbone: A Quiescent Landscape of ConflictConflict.. Historical Archaeology 37(3):93-110.37(3):93-110. Heaton, Patrick J. 2000. Book review of Nineteenth-Nineteenth- and Early Twentieth-Century-Century Domestic Site Archaeology in New York StateState,, edited by John P. Hart and Charles L. Fisher, New York State Museum Bulletin No. 495, Albany, NY, 2000. Published in Northeast Anthropology 60:93-94.60:93-94.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 8 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

SAMANTHA HOLCOMB

SSENIORENIOR ENVIRONMEENVIRONMENTALNTAL ANALYST

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Samantha(Samantha Holcomb)Holcomb)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Samantha Holcomb, Holcomb, Environmental Design & Research, Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Senior Environmental Analyst.Analyst.

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I have been employed with EDR since 2017.2017.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Environmental Biology from the State

12 University of New York College of Environmental Science & Forestry inin

13 2010.2010. I also received a Master of Environmental Law & Policy from

14 Vermont Law School in 2012. 2012. I have over 7 years of experience in

15 environmental law and policy, environmental permitting, flfloodplainoodplain

16 management and federal grant compliance and administration.administration. My current

17 curriculum vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant

18 professional experience.

19 Q. What are your current responsibilities at EDREDR??

20 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for interfacing directly with

21 clients, project legal legal counsel, team partners, sub --consultants,consultants, and

1 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Samantha(Samantha Holcomb)Holcomb)

1 regulatory personnel in support of environmental permitting efforts with a

2 specific focus on Article 10 of the New York Public Service Law for the

3 siting of renewable energy projects.projects.

4 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

5 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

6 A. No.

7 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

8 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

9 offer testimonytestimony on in this proceeding?

10 A. No.

11 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

12 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

13 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

14 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

15 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

16 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

17 sponsoring?sponsoring?

18 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: ExhibExhibitit 3, Location of

19 Facilities;Facilities; Exhibit 10, Consistency with Energy Planning Objectives;

20 Exhibit 13, Real Property;Property; Exhibit 15, Public Health and Safety; Exhibit

21 17, Air Emissions; Exhibit 21, Geology, Seismology and Soils; Exhibit

2 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Samantha(Samantha Holcomb)Holcomb)

1 23, Water Resources and Aquatic Aquatic Ecology; and Exhibit 33, Other

2 Applications and Filings.

3 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

4 your direction and/or supervision?

5 A. Yes.

6 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

7 A. Yes.

3 of 3

Samantha Holcomb Senior Environmental Analyst

Samantha is a Senior Environmental Analyst at EDR with over 7 years of professional experience. Samantha previously worked in Vermont and New York City managing climate change and flfloodood resiliency projects. She has a strong background in environmental law and policy, environmental permitting, flfloooodplaindplain management and federal grant oompliancecompliance and administation. Samantha graduated with a Masters of Environmental Law & Policy from Vermont Law School and a Bachelor of Science from the State University of New York College of Environmental Science & Forestry.Forestry. As a Senior Environmental Analyst with EDR, Samantha interfaces directly with clients, project legal cocounsel,unsel, team partners, sub-consultants,-consultants, and regulatory personnel in support of environmental permitting efforts, with a specific emphasis on ArticleArticle 10 of the New York Public Service Law. Samantha is also responsible for conducting environmental review, impact analysis, and permitting; coordinating internal project staff and external team members to prepare deliverables and meet project deadlines; qualityquality assurance/quality control of regulatory permitting studies and exhibits; and, supporting public outreach efforts for both renewable energy and flfloodood resiliency projectsprojects.. educationeducation employment history Master of Environmental Law & Policy, Vermont Law School, 2012.2012. Senior Environmental Analyst, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, DPC, Bachelor of Science, Environmental Biology, State University of New York Bachelor of Science, Environmental Biology, State University of New York Syracuse,Syracuse, NY, 2017-present.-present. College of EnvironmentalEnvironmental Science & Forestry, 2010.2010. Senior ProjedProject Manager, New York City Department of Housing registration / certifications Preservation & Development, 2016-2017.2016-2017. Certified Floodplain Manager (CFM) Project Manager, NewNew YorkYork CityCity DepartmentDepartment of Housing Preservation & Development, 2015-2016.2015-2016. professional affiliations Planner, Two Rivers-OttauquecheeRivers-Ottauquechee Regional Commission: Woodstock, Member, Association of State Floodplain Managers (ASFPM) VT, 2012-2015.2012-2015. Former Member, Vermont Law School Alumni AssodationAssociation Board of Legal Intern, Conservation Law Foundation,Foundation, Montpelier, VT, 2012. Directors Former Commissioner & Secretary of the Executive Committee, Connecticut River Joint Commissions project experience

Mohawk Solar Project,Project, Montgomery County, NY-NY- Responsible for coordinating environmental permitting studies for a proposed 90 MW solar energy fadlity,facility, the fifirstrst solar project to pursupursuee a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law. Project responsibilities included preparation, coordination,coordination, and quality control review of permitting support studies and Article 10 Application exhibits, including coordination with client/consultant team, internal staff, and subconsultants.

Baron Wind Project, Steuben County, NY-NY- Responsible for the preparation and coordination of an Article 10 Application, Application Supplements, and an Application Update for a wind energy project. In coordination with project legal counsel, developed and submitted responses toto Interrogatory Requests (IRs), and participated in meetings and conferences. Bluestone Wind Project, Broome County, NY-NY- Responsible for the preparation and coordination of permitting support studies,studies, Article 10 Application exhibits,exhibits, and Application SupplementSupplement for an approximately 40-turbine-turbine commercial wind power project. Heritage Wind Project,Project, Orleans County, NY—NY – Responsible for the preparation,preparation, coordination and quality control review of a Preliminary Scoping Statement in support of Article 10 permitting.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.cort.www.edrdpc.com

Samantha Holcomb Senior Environmental Analyst

Riverhead Solar 2-2- Responsible for the preparationpreparation,, coordination, and quality control review of a Public Involvement Program Plan and Preliminary Scoping Statement in support of ArtideArticle 10 permitting for a 36MW solar energy generating project. Currently negotiating stipulations. Ogdensburg Shoreline Erosion Management Study, Ogdensburg, NY—NY— Technical expert for flfloodood resiliency planning project, funded by a Sea Grant fromfrom the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) on behalf of the City of Ogdensburg. AssessedAssessed riverine flfloodingooding risk of select public assets and developed targeted resiliency and mitigation strategies while taking into consideration local impactsimpacts of climate change and river geomorphology.geomorphology. experience prior to joining EDR Senior Project Manager, NewNew York City DepartmentDepartment of Housing Preservation & Development—Managed—Managed and coordinated with the subconsultant preparing the NEPA Tier II environmentaenvironmentall review for projects in the Build-it-it-Back-Back Multifamily Program'sProgram’s pipeline. This Program was developed to assist the owners of multifamily buildings affected by Hurricane Sandy within the five boroughs of New York City and was funded by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban DevelopmentsDevelopment’s (HUD) Community Development Block Grant-Grant- Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR)(CDBG-DR) grants.grants. Planner, Two Rivers-OttauquecheeRivers-Ottauquechee Regional Commission —– Project managemanagedd and conductedconducted the environmental review for public infrastructure projects damaged by Tropical Storm Irene.Irene. These projects were funded by HUD CDBG-DRCDBG-DR grants.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

JOHN WOJCIKIEWICZ

ENVIRONMENTAL PPROJECTROJECT MANAGER

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (John(John Wojcikiewicz)Wojcikiewicz)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. John Wojcikiewicz, Wojcikiewicz, Environmental Design & Research, Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Environmental Project Manager.Manager.

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I havehave been employed with EDR since 2015.2015.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Biology with a minor in

12 Environmental Science from Clarkson University in 2011.2011. I also received

13 a MasterMaster of Science in Biology from Virginia Commonwealth University

14 in 2014. I have more than 5 years of experience in wildlife biology, avian

15 ecology, and environmental impact analysis.analysis. My current curriculum vitae

16 is attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

17 experience.

18 Q. What are your current responsibilities at EDREDR??

19 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for conducting environmental

20 review, impact analysis, and permitting for projects under Article 10 and

21 SEQRSEQR..

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (John(John Wojcikiewicz)Wojcikiewicz)

1 Q. Have you previously previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

3 A. No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

6 offeroffer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

11 with the proposedproposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 22,22, Terrestrial

16 Ecology and Wetlands; Wetlands; and Exhibit 23,23, Water Resources and Aquatic

17 EcologyEcology..

18 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

19 your direction and/or supervision?

20 A. Yes.

21

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (John(John Wojcikiewicz)Wojcikiewicz)

1 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

2 A. Yes.Yes.

3 of 3

e John WojcikiewiczWojcikiewicz Environmental Project Manager

John WojcikiewiczWojcikiewicz is an Environmental Project Manager at EDR with more than 5 years of professional experience.experience. He has completed the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Training Program,Program, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYDEC) Erosion and Sediment Control Training and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Threatened and Endangered Species Training.Training. John'sJohn’s expertise includes wildlife biologybiology,, avian ecology,ecology, and environmental impact analysis and associated document preparation . He earned a Master of Science in Biology from Virginia Commonwealth University, and a Bachelor of Science in Biology from Clarkson University.

As a Project Manager with EDR, John is responsible conducting environmental review, impact analysis, and permitting; proficiency in multiple permitting regulations and requirements, such as the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act, Article VII and Article 10 of the New York Public Service Law, and state and federal wetland regulations; analyzing and quantifying potential environmental impacts using GIS and/or AutoCAD; and consulting with regulatory personnel. educationeducation employment history Master of Science, Biology, Virginia Commonwealth University, Environmental Project Manager,Manager, Environmental Design and Research, 2014.2014. Landscape Architecture, Engineering, and Environmental Services, BachebrBachelor of Science, Biology,Biology, MinorMinor in Environmental Science, D.P.C., Syracuse, NY, 2019-2019- present.present. Clarkson University, 2011. Senior Environmental Analyst, Environmental Design and Research, Costa Rica Semester: Tropical Biology Semester, Duke University Landscape Architecture, Engineering, and Environmental Services, Study Abroad, Organization for Tropical Studies, 2010. D.P.C., Syracuse, NY, 2017-2017- 2019. Environmental Analyst, Environmental Design and Research, Landscape professional affiliation'affiliations Architecture, Engineering, and Environmental Services, D.P.C., Syracuse, Member, New York State Wetlands Forum NY,NY, 2015-2017.2015-2017. Member, American Wind Energy Association Avian Field Crew Leader, Wildlife ConservationConservation Society, 2014. Member, National Audubon Society Avian Field Technician, Wildlife Conservation Society, 2012. Natural Resources Analyst, CALIBRE Systems, Fort Drum Military Installation, NY,NY, 2011. proprojectject experience Mohawk Solar, Montgomery County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared sections and fifiguresgures for a Public Involvement Plan (PIP), coordinatedcoordinated preparation of a Preliminary Scoping Statement (PSS),(PSS), drafteddrafted stipulations, and preparedprepared exhibits as part of an Article 10 application for a 90-MW-MW utility-scale-scale power project,project, the fifirstrst solar project to pursue a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need under Article 10 of the New York State PublicPublic Service Law.Law. Designed and conducted avian surveys and managed preparation of a Net Conservation Benefit Plan for Threatened andand Endangered avian species. ConductedConcluded wetland delineations, managed preparation of a wetland delineation report.report. Flint Mine Solar Project, Greene County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared sections and fifiguresgures for a PIP,PIP, coordinatedcoordinated preparation of a PSS,PSS, and drafteddrafted stipulationsstipulations for a 100-MW-MW utility-scale-scale power projedproject subjedsubject to review and approval under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Designed and conducted avian surveys and prepared environmental resources summaries.summaries. Conducted wetland delineations, managed preparation of a wetland delineation report.report. Coxsackie Correction Facility, Greene County, NY-NY- Managed preparation of a Net Conservation Benefit Plan for Threatened and Endangered avian species, and preparation of a Joint Permit Application for state and federal-jurisdictional-jurisdictional wetland resources.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.cort.www.edrdpc.com

John WojcikiewiczWojcikiewicz Environmental Project Manager

Bear Ridge Solar Project, Niagara County, NY-NY- Designed Breeding Bird Surveys in consultation with New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC)(NYSDEC) for a utility-scale-scale power project subject to review and approval under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Arkwright Summit Wind Farm,Farm, Chautauqua County, NY-NY- AuthoredAuthored a Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement,Statement, under the auspices of The State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA),(SEQRA), for a proposed 3636-turbine-turbine wind power facility. Prepared chapters concerning soils and geological resources, biological/ecologicalbiological/ecological resoresources,urces, water resources, noise, air quality and climate, land use, socioeconomics, communications, transportation, public safety,safety, and an alternatives analysis. Also conducted extensive GIS mapping and analysis of environmental data. Prepared various support documents and analyses for the project such as a noxious/invasive species control plan, EPA Air Quality Analysis, and a complaint resolution plan. Prepared sections of the Joint Permit Application to the NYSDEC and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE).(USACE). Assisted in developing wetland mitigation strategies. Cassadaga Wind Power Project,Project, Chautauqua County, NY-NY- Photographically documented views of the project site in support of a visual impact assessment, conducted wetland delineations, compiled environmental data, and prepared draft exhibitsexhibits of an Article 10 PSS and Article 10 Application for a proposed 62- turbine wind power facility. Exhibits prepared addressed soils and geological resources, biological/ecological resources, and water resources. North Ridge Wind Farm, St. Lawrence County, NY-NY- Prepared draft sections of anan Article 10 PSS,PSS, a well as comment response documents for a proposed 40-turbine-turbine wind power facility. Jericho Rise Wind Farm,Farm, Franklin County, NYNY-- Conducted wetland delineations for a proposed 37--turbineturbine commercial wind power project. Conducted GIS analysis of environmental data and generated map sets. Prepared sections of the Joint Permit Application to the NYSDEC and USACE. Copenhagen Wind Farm,Farm, Jefferson & Lewis Counties, NY-NY- Conducted wetland delineations along proposed road improvimprovementsements for a proposed 47-turbine-turbine wind power facility. Conducted GIS analysis of environmental data and generated map sets. Prepared sections of the Joint Permit Application to the NYSDEC and USACE. Great Bay Solar Project,Project, Somerset County, MD-MD- Conducted wewetlandtland delineations and ecological field surveys, prepared draft sections, figures, and amendments of an Environmental Review Document for a proposed 150 MW solar facility. Prepared sections of the Joint Permit Application to the Maryland Department of EnvironmentEnvironment (MDE) and USACE. Binghamton-Johnson-Johnson City Joint Sewage Treatment Plant Improvements,Improvements, Broome County, NY-NY- Prepared PartsParts I, II, and III of an Environmental Assessment Form for proposed improvements to a damaged sewage treatment facility.facility. Baron Wind Project,Project, Steuben County, NY-NY- Photographically documented views of the project site in support of a visual impact assessmentassessment,, conducted wetland delineations, compiled environmental data, and prepared draft exhibitsexhibits of an Article 10 Scoping Statement for a proposed 62-turbine-turbine wind power facility. Exhibits prepared addressed soils and geological resources, biological/ecological resources, and water resources. Pocomoke Solar Project,Project, Worcester County, MD-MD- Prepared a Critical Issues Analysis summarizing the project site conditions and any readily identifiable concerns and/or critical issues associated with the proposed Project, as well as anticipated permitting requirements for a proposed solar energy project that will be sited on an approximately 900-acres-acres of farmland.farmland. Conducted wetland delineations for the project and prepared wetland delineation report. Prepared sections and fifiguresgures for an Environmental Review Document. Rising Warrior Stream Restoration,Restoration, Fort Drum Military Installation, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Prepared stream mitigation banking instrument that established guidelines and responsibilities for the implementation, operation, and maintenance of a stream mitigation bank.bank.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

MATTHEW ROBINSON

VISUALIZATION PRPROJECTOJECT MANAGER

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Matthew(Matthew Robinson)Robinson)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Matthew Robinson, Robinson, Environmental Design & Research, Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Visualization Project Manager.Manager.

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I havehave been employed with EDR since 2016.2016.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science with a minor in History

12 from the University of Vermont in 2005.2005. I also received a Master of

13 Landscape Architecture with a Concentration in Land Planning, Aesthetics

14 and Real Estate from Cornell University in 2010.2010. I have more than 1010

15 years of experience in visual impact assessment. assessment. My current curriculum

16 vitae is attached and provides a full history history of my relevant professional

17 experience.

18 Q. What are your current responsibilities at EDREDR??

19 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for conducting visual impact

20 assessments, including coordination of visual outreach efforts and public

21 open houses, identificationidentification of visually sensitive resources, field evaluation

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Matthew(Matthew Robinson)Robinson)

1 and documentation of project visibility, development of detailed and

2 accurate computer renderings, 3D computer modeling, and visual

3 simulations.simulations.

4 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to to the New York Siting

5 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

6 A. No.

7 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

8 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

9 offer testimony on in this proproceeding?ceeding?

10 A. Yes.Yes. I providedprovided testimonytestimony regardingregarding visualvisual iimpactsmpacts ofof a proposedproposed 5500kW00kW

11 photovoltaicphotovoltaic netnet-metered-metered eelectriclectric generatinggenerating facility,facility, asas anan eexpertxpert witnesswitness

12 forfor thethe SStatetate ofof VermontVermont DepartmentDepartment ofof PublicPublic SServiceervice (Docket(Docket No.No. 16-16-

13 0037-NMP)0037-NMP) inin CaledoniaCaledonia County.County. IInn addition, I havehave providedprovided writtenwritten andand

14 sponsored testimonytestimony toto thethe OhioOhio PowerPower SSitingiting Board,Board, regardingregarding visualvisual

15 impactsimpacts ofof thethe 150150 megawatt,megawatt, Willowbrook Solar ProjectProject (Case(Case No. 18- 18-

16 1024-EL-BGN)1024-EL-BGN) inin BrownBrown andand HighlandHighland Counties,Counties, andand thethe 100100 megawatt,megawatt,

17 AngelinaAngelina SSolarolar ProjectProject (Case(Case No. 18-1579-EL-BGN)18-1579-EL-BGN) iinn PreblePreble County.County.

18 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

19 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

20 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connecconnectiontion

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Matthew(Matthew Robinson)Robinson)

1 with the proposed construction of a 9090.5.5 MW solar generating facility in

2 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

3 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

4 sponsoring?sponsoring?

5 A. I will be sponsoring the followingfollowing ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 24,24, Visual ImpactImpacts.s.

6 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

7 your direction and/or supervision?

8 A. Yes.

9 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

10 A. Yes.

3 of 3

Matthew Robinson visualizationVisualization Project Manager

MatthewMatthew is a Visualization Project Manager at EDR. AsaAs a Visualization Project Manager, Matthew is responsible for overseeing and managing all aspects of various visual impact assessment projects. His role on these projects includes, coordination of visual outreach efforts and public open houses, identification of visually sensitive resources, field evaluation and documentation of project visibility, development of detailed and accurate computer renderings, 3D computer modeling, visual simulations and testimony.

Prior to working at EDR, Matthew worked as an Environmental Planner, Associate Landscape Architect, and Project Manager at Landworks in Middlebury, VT. While at Landworks, Matthew worked on diverse projects that included visual impact and environmental impact assessments, visual simulations, public outreach and communication graphics, land use planning, environmental graphics including signage and wayfinding, streetscape design aesthetic and safety improvements, and site rehabilitationrehabilitation design for utility corridors.

educationeducation employment history

Master of Landscape Architecture, Concentration in Land Planning, VisualizationVisualization Project Manager,Manager, Environmental Design & Research, Aesthetics & Real Estate, Cornell University, 2010.2010. Landscape Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C.,D.P.C., Syracuse,Syracuse, NY, 2016-present.-present. Bachelor of Arts, Political Science, Minor in History, University of Vermont, 2005.2005. Project Manager, Associate Landscape Architect,Architect, LandWorks, Landscape Architecture, Planning and Design, Middlebury, VT, volunteer work 2004-2007,2004-2007, 2009, 2010-2016.2010-2016.

Deputy Tree Warden,Warden, Town of Middlebury, Middlebury, VT,VT, 2014-2016.2014-2016. Associate,Associate, Wagner Hodgson —– Landscape Architecture,Architecture, Burlington, VT,VT, 2008. Foster Owner, Long Trial Canine Rescue, Wilder, VT,VT, 2014-20162014-2016 Manager,Manager, Ann RotheRoche Casual Furniture,Furniture, Shelburne, VT, 1998-2008.1998-2008. project experience

Mohawk Solar, Montgomery County, NY-NY- Responsible for development of a VIA and conceptual mitigation plans, in accordance with New York State Article 10 law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography and preparation of visual simulationssimulations for a proposed 90 MW solar energy facility,facility, the fifirstrst solar project to pursuepursue a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Baron Winds Farm, Steuben County, NY-NY - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with New York State Article 10 law, including, identification of visual sensitivesensitive resources, community outreach, fifieldeld photography and preparation of visual simulations brafor a proposed up-to-to 69-turbine-turbine wind power facility.facility. Canisteo Wind Farm, Steuben County, NY - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with New York StateState Article 10 law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, fifieldeld photography and preparation of visual simulations for a proposed up-to-to 120-turbine-turbine wind power facilityfacility.. Bluestone Wind Farm, Broome County, NY - ResponsibleResponsible for development of a VIA in accordance with New York State Article 10 law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, fifieldeld photography and preparation of visual simulations forafor a proposed up-to-to 40-turbine-turbine wind power facility.facility.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.co.www.edrdpc.com

Matthew Robinson Visualization Project Manager

Alle-CaftAlle-Catt Wind Farm, Allegany, Cattaraugus & Wyoming Counties, NY - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with New York State Article 10 law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photogphotographyraphy and preparation of visual simulations for a proposed up-to-to 117-turbine-turbine wind power facility.facility. Timber Road IV Wind Farm, Paulding County, OH - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including, identificationidentification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography and preparation of visual simulations forafor a proposed up-to-to 54-turbine-turbine wind power facility.facility. Republic Wind Farm, Seneca & Sandusky Counties, OH - Responsible for development of a VIA inin accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography, preparation of visual simulationssimulations and testimony forafor a proposed up-to-to 80-turbine-turbine wind power facility.facility. Emerson CreekCreek Wind Farm, Erie & Huron Counties, OH - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography and preparation of visual simulationssimulations for a proposed up-to-to 87- turbine wind power facility.facility. Hillcrest Solar Farm, Brown County, OH - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach,outreach, field photography and preparation of visual simulations for a proposed 200 MW solar power facility.facility. Willowbrook Solar Farm, Brown & Highland Counties, OH - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including,including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography, preparation of visual simulations aandnd testimony for a proposed 150 MW solar power facility.facility. Alamo Solar Farm, Preble County, OH - Responsible for development of a VIAVIA in accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography and preparation of visual simulations for a proposed 69.9 MW solar power facility.facility. Angelina Solar Farm, PreblePreble County, OH - Responsible for development of a VIA in accordance with Ohio Power Siting Board law, including, identification of visual sensitive resources, community outreach, field photography and preparation of visual simulations forafor a proposed 80 MW solarsolar power facility.facility. Otter Creek I & II Solar Projects, Town of Rutland, Rutland County, VT —– As an expert representing the State of Vermont, provided a peer review of developer’sdevelopers visual assessment of the 4.9 and 2.2 MW projects. Ryegate GLC Solar, Town of Ryegate, Caledonia County, VT —– As an expert representing the State of Vermont, provided a peer review of developersdeveloper’s visual assessment of the 500 kW solar array,array, including testimony. Battle Creek 1 Solar Project,Project, Town of Bennington,Bennington, VTVT - As an expert representing the State of Vermont, provided a peer review of developer’sdevelopers visual assessment of the 2.2 MW project. InterstateInterstate Route 81 Viaduct Project, City of Syracuse, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Responsible for the development of visual simulationssimulations for the replacement of approximately 5 miles of elevated interstate highway. Galloo Island Wind Project, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Responsible for field photography and preparation of visual simulations for a proposed 62-turbine-turbine wind power facility on an island in Lake OntarioOntario.. Emerging Technology and Entrepreneurship Complex (ETEC),(ETEC), SUNY Albany, Albany, NY-NY- Responsible for preparation of a Visual Impact Assessment for a proposed academic buildingbuilding sited on the New York State Office of GeneralGeneral Services (OGS) Harriman Campus. ConnectNY, Oneida & Dutchess County, NY-NY- Responsible for field photography and preparation of a Visual Impact AssessmentAssessment for converters stations associated with a proposed DC transmission line that will be installed within the New York State Thruway right-of-wayright-of-way (ROW). Knapps Corner Substation, Town of Poughkeepsie, NY-NY- Responsible for field photographyphotography,, visual simulations and preparation of a Visual Impact AssessmentAssessment of a proposed electric substation.substation. West River Greenway Trail, Grand Island, NY-NY- Responsible for providing visualvisual simulations in support of landscape architecturalarchitectural design of a proposed 8- mile multi-use/pedestrianmulti-use/pedestrian trail.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Matthew Robinson Visualization Project Manager

Rochester Main Street Streetscape Improvement Projects,Projects, City of Rochester, NY-NY- Responsible for providing visual simulations in support of a streetscape improvement project on East Main Street between the Genesee River and Franklin Street in the City of Rochester. Antrim Wind Project, Antrim, NH-NH- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysis, field photography and resource evaluations in support of a proposed 28.8 MW, nine-turbine-turbine wind facility. Swanton Wind Project, Franklin County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysis, field photography and resourceresource evaluations in support of a proposed 20 MW, seven--turbineturbine wind facility.

Bingham Wind Project,Project, Bingham, ME-ME- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysis, field photography and resource evaluations in support of a proposed 185 MW, 56-turbine-turbine wind facility. Bowers Wind Project,Project, Carroll Plantation & Kossuth, ME-ME- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysis, field photography and resource evaluations in support of a proposed 48 MW, 16-turbine-turbine wind facility. Georgia Mountain Community Wind Project,Project, Chittenden & County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysis, field photography and resource evaluations in support of a proposed 10 MW, four--turbineturbine wind facility. NU-F107-F107 Seacoast Reliability Project, Strafford & Rockingham County, NH-NH- Prior to EDR, ServedServed as lead Landscape Architect for community relations and mitigation measures. Provided field photography, visual simulations, and various exhibits in support of the Visual Impact Statement and pre-filed-filed testimony forafor a proposed new 13-mile-mile 115kV transmission line. Northern Pass Project, Canadian Boarder to Franklin, NH-NH- Prior to EDR, ServedServed as lead field technician,technician, Visual Simulation technician and was expert visual representative in in support of a 192-mile-mile HVDC transmission line.line. Merrimack Valley Reliability Project 345 Transmission Line, Londonderry, NH to Tewksbury, MA-MA- Prior to EDR, ServedServed as community relations/communicationsrelations/communications visual expertexpert andand provided visual simulations, mmitigationitigation plans and mediation services in support of a 24.5-mile-mile long 345kV transmission line. Kidder Wind Project, Orleans County, Irasburg, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysisanalysis,, field photography and resource evaluations in support of a proposed two turbineturbine project. Addison Rutland Natural Gas Project, Phase I & II Chittenden & Addison Counties, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual simulations, visual impact analysis and mitigation planting plans forthefor the VermontAgencyVermont Agency of Natural Resources in their review of a 43-mile-mile natural gas pipeline extension and associated facilities.facilities. VELCO Lamoille Country Reliability Project,Project, Lamoille County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual analysis support during the permitting process and testimony forafor a proposed 10-mile-mile 115kV transmission line and associated relocation of an existing 34.5kV and subsequent substation upgrades.

VELCO NorthwestNorthwest Reliability Project, Rutland & Addison Counties, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visualvisual analysis support during permitting and testimony in support of a 35.5-mile-mile proposed 345kV transmission line that included relocationrelocation of existing 34.5kV and 115kV lineslines and subsequent substation upgrades. BeaverWood Biomass Facility,Facility, Rutland County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual simulations and visual impact analysis through multiple stages of the permitting process in supportsupport of a 30MW biomass facility and an associated 8-mile-mile-long-long transmission tap line. Seneca Mountain Wind,Wind, Orleans County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, WorkedWorked clcloselyosely with developer to provide visual simulations and expert analysis in a community relations/communications role in support of a proposed 20-turbine-turbine project. Sheffield Wind Farm,Farm, Caledonia County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual simulations and VisualVisual Impact Assessment (VIA)(VIA) analysis through multiple stages of the permitting process in support of a proposed 16-turbine-turbine facility. South Village Solar Array, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual simulations and Visual Impact Assessment (VIA)(VIA) in support of a 1-acre-acre solar energy project. Island Line Trail,Trail, Chittenden & Grand Isle Counties,Counties, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of a 14-mile-mile trail as part of the LandWorks team including sign/kiosk/facility structures construction drawings and oversight, in support of a rail trail wayfinding project.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 3 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Matthew Robinson Visualization Project Manager

Burlington Wayfinding Program,Program, ChittendenChittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, DraftedDrafted cconstructiononstruction drawings, assembled bid package and coordinated with potential contactorcontactors,s, provided construction oversight,oversight, RFI support and a final inspection/punch list,list, in support of a downtown wayfinding revitalization.revitalization. Intervale Wayfinding Program,Program, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, DevelopedDeveloped a comprehensive wayfinding plan, conducted field work in support of sign message and placement, on the sign/kiosk/gatewaysign/kiosk/gateway design team,team, drafted locationlocation map, and construction drawings in support of a wayfinding project. Saratoga Springs Wayfinding Program,Program, Saratoga County,County, NY-NY- Prior to EDR, DevelopedDeveloped a comprehensive wayfinding plan, conducted field work in support of sign/kiosksign/kiosk message and placementplacement,, worked with steering committee to provide community outreach, drafted construction drawingsdrawings,, assembled bid package and coordinated with potential contactorcontactors,s, and constructed a scalescale mock-upmock-up of a sign in support of a downtown wayfindingwayfinding project. Falmouth Wayfinding Program,Program, Cumberland County,County, ME - Prior to EDR, DevelopedDeveloped a comprehensive wayfinding plan, conducted field work in support of sign message and placement provided materials and support at community and steering committee meetings, on the Identity Panel/Logo and sign/kiosksign/kiosk design teams, drafted construction drawings, assembled bid package and constructed a scalescale mock-upmock-up of a sign in support of a downtown wayfinding project. Teton Village Wayfinding,Wayfinding, Teton County, WY-WY- Prior to EDR, Participated in the team that developed 3D map of the village and ski mountain to be used by guests and for marketing purposes. Downtown Rutland Gateway Plan, Rutland County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, WorkedWorked as part of a team that provided analyses on a vehicular-focused-focused downtown, identified issues regarding aesthetics streetscape functionality and multimodal safety. South Village,Village, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ConductedConducted field work in support of sign message and placement, designed a regulatory system that incorporated fencing, trail blazes and entrance and exit signs, in support ofof Vermont'sVermont’s first Conservation Community and Agrihood. Middlebury Visitor Services ParkingParking & Interpretive Signage,Signage, Addison County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, DraftedDrafted construction documents, conducted field work in support of sign/kiosksign/kiosk message and placement in support of a downtown wayfinding project. Killington Wayfinding,Wayfinding, Rutland County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a community wayfinding project. South Burlington Wayfinding,Wayfinding, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughoutthroughout different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a community district branding and wayfinding project. Shelburne Wayfinding & Interpretive Panels,Panels, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided design support for signage and kiosks, assisted on different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a community wayfinding project. Maple Tree Place,Place, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, AssistedAssisted in the drafting of designdesign guidelines for a commercial development that fit within the strict rules of the Town, worked with the Town, the developer and potential renters on sign placement questions and requests, produced construction drawings, assisted in the construction managementmanagement and bidding process for a retail/commercial development wwayfindingayfinding pplan.lan. Quechee Lakes Resort Wayfinding,Wayfinding, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a resort branding and wayfinding project. Shawangunk Mountain Scenic Views,Views, Ulster, Sullivan & Orange Counties,Counties, NY-NY- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided report preparation, planning principles and 3D graphic development as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a resort branding and wayfinding project. North Branch Nature Center,Center, Washington County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided project management services, over saw the production of a facilities master plan including, site and circulation plan, demonstration gardens, natural play area, improved lighting and reconfiguredreconfigured parking lot with biofiltration island, as part of a collaborative team for a small school.school. Milton Streetscape,Streetscape, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a community streetscape upgrade project. Danville Transportation Enhancements,Enhancements, Caledonia County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, AssistedAssisted in the drafting of construction documents, produced as built plans, and provided support throughout different phases of the project as part of the LandWorks team,team, for a community transportation and streetscape upgrade proproject.ject.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 4 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Matthew Robinson Visualization Project Manager

Middlebury Riverfront Park,Park, Addison County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, AssistedAssisted in the drafting of construction documents, and construction oversight in support of a community waterfront park and riparian zone remediation project. Jericho Corners Streetscape,Streetscape, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in supportsupport of a community streetscape project. Middlebury Bridges,Bridges, Addison County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided design services, produced visual simulations and created community outreach materials in support of a VTRANS bridge rehabilitation project. Richmond MixedMixed-Use-Use Development,Development, Chittenden County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of the project including 3D visualizations, in support of a unique rehabilitation of a derelict historic cheese factory. Killington Streetscape,Streetscape, Rutland County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided visual graphic and desidesigngn support throughout different aspects of the project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a community streetscape upgrade project. Alburgh Dunes State Park,Park, Grand Isle, County, VT-VT- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided support throughout different aspects of thethe project as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a state park upgrade project. Mohawk Towpath Byway: Scenic Conservation Action Plan,Plan, Schenectady, & Saratoga Counties,Counties, NY-NY- Prior to EDR, ProvidedProvided report preparation, planning principles and 3D graphic development as part of the LandWorks team, in support of a resort branding and wayfinding project.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 5 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

SAMOUEL J. BEGUIN

SENIOR ENVIRONMENVIRONMENTALENTAL ANALYST

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Samouel(Samouel J. Beguin)Beguin)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Samouel J. Beguin, Beguin, Environmental Design & Research, Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Senior Environmental Analyst.Analyst.

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I havehave been employed with EDR since 2017.2017.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Biology and Environmental Studies from

12 Middlebury College in 2013.2013. I also received a Master of Science in

13 Environmental and Forest Biology from the State University of New York

14 College of Environmental Science and Forestry in 2015.2015. I have more than

15 5 years of experience iinn wildlifewildlife biology,biology, scientificscientific research,research, andand

16 environmentalenvironmental cconsulting.onsulting. My current curriculum curriculum vitae is attached and

17 provides a full history of my relevant professional experience.

18 Q. What are your currentcurrent responsibilities at EDREDR??

19 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for conductingconducting environmentalenvironmental

20 review,review, ecological resource investigationinvestigation,, impactimpact analysis,analysis, reportreport

21 preparation,preparation, andand permittingpermitting taskstasks fforor commercial renewablerenewable energy,energy,

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Samouel(Samouel J. Beguin)Beguin)

1 municipalmunicipal infrastructure,infrastructure, andand rresidentialesidential developmentdevelopment projectsprojects inin NewNew

2 YorkYork SStatetate underunder ArticleArticle 1010 ofof thethe PublicPublic SServiceervice LLawaw andand thethe SStatetate

3 EEnvironmentalnvironmental QualityQuality ReviewReview ActAct (SEQR).(SEQR).

4 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

5 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

6 A. No.

7 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

8 court, agency, or other body relative to the subjectsubject matter you plan to

9 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

10 A. No.No.

11 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

12 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

13 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and PublicPublic NeedNeed in connection

14 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

15 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

16 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

17 sponsoring?sponsoring?

18 A. I will be sponsoringsponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 22, 22, Terrestrial

19 Ecology and Wetlands.Wetlands.

20 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

21 your direction and/or supervision?

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Samouel(Samouel J. Beguin)Beguin)

1 A. Yes.

2 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

3 A. Yes.

3 of 3

SamouelSamouel J. Beguin Senior Environmental Analyst

Samouel is a Senior Environmental Analyst with more than 5 years of professional research and consulting experience. Sam is proficient in biological, ecological, and environmental data collection in forest, wetland, montane, aquatic, grassland, and agriculturalagricultural settings. He has considerable experience with scientific data collection, organization, processing, validation (QC), analysis and interpretation, as well as mapping and geographic data management using ESRI ArcGIS software.

He has experience with ththreatened,reatened, endangered and rare species impact assessments and field surveys, wetland and stream delineation and impact assessments, and environmental review and permitting for renewable energy, municipal infrastructure, and private development projects in NewNew York State (SEQRA, Articles 15 and 24 of the Environmental Conservation Law, Article 10 of the Public Service Law, Section 404 of the Clean Water Act).

Sam is also experienced with technical report writing, preparation of regulatory documents, preparationpreparation of Standard Operating Procedures, Health and Safety Plans, and field data forms, citizen science program planning and management, and soundscape ecology and acoustic monitoring. education employment history

Bachelor of Arts, Biology & Environmental Studies, Middlebury College, Senior Environmental Analyst, Environmental Design & Research, 2013.2013. Landscape Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, DPC, Syracuse, NY, 2019-present-present. Master of Science, Environmental & Forest Biology, SStatetate UniversityUniversity of NewNew YorkYork College of EnvironmentalEnvironmental ScienceScience & Forestry,Forestry, 2015.2015. Environmental Analyst,Analyst, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, DPC, Syracuse, NY, certificationscertifications 2017-2018.2017-2018. Contract Report Writer, Stone Environmental, Inc., Montpelier, VT,VT, 2017.2017. Aquatic Invasive Plant Identification and Surveillance Training (APIPP) (2017) Research Analyst-Analyst- Webb Apprenticeship,Apprenticeship, SUNY Research Foundation, SUNY ESF Adirondack Ecological Center, Newcomb, NY, 2017.2017. CMCITI Program Course Certified in Working with Amphibians in Research Settings (2017), Working with Mice in Research (2017), and Wildlife Staff Scientist I/II,VII, Stone Environmental, Inc., Montpelier, VT, 2015-2017.2015-2017. Research (2017) Research Project Assistant, SUNY Research Foundation, SStatetate UniversityUniversity WICITI Program Course Certified in LaboratoryLaboratory Animal Welfare-Welfare- Stage 1, Lab of NewNew YorkYork College of EnvironmentalEnvironmental SSciencecience & Forestry,Forestry, Adirondack Animal Research (2015) Ecological Center, Newcomb, NY, 2013-20142013-2014 projectproject experience

Mohawk Solar Project, Montgomery County, NY-NY- Designed a winter raptor study, performed winter raptor surveys, and conductedconducted wetland/stream delineations for a 90 MW solar photovoltaic electric generating facility subject to review and approval under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Compiled responses to comments received on the project'sproject’s Article 10 PreliminaryPreliminary Scoping Statement (PSS). Prepared GIS web maps and processed wetland/stream delineation GPS data. Developed a threatened and endangered species mitigation plan for potential impacts to state-listed-listed avian species. AlleAlle-Catt-Catt Wind Farm, Alleghany, Cattaraugus,Cattaraugus, & Wyoming Counties, NY-NY- Conducted wetland and stream delineations for a proposed 290 MW wind power facility subject to review and approval under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Baron Winds Project,Project, Steuben County,County, NY-NY- Assisted with the preparation of a Joint Application for Permit submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) for wetland and stream impacts associated with an up to 242 MW wind power facility subject to review and approval under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Bantam Solar Project,Project, Town of Oppenheim, Fulton County, NY-NY- Coordinated and performed wetland/stream delineations for solar photovoltaic electric generating facility. Prepared GIS web maps and processed wetland/stream delineation GPS data. Binghamton-Johnson-Johnson City Joint SewageSewage Treatment Plan Water Quality Improvement Project, Binghamton, NY-NY- Lead author for a Joint Application for Permit submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) and the U.S. Army Corps of EngineersEngineers (USACE) for a to removeremove project designed to remove accumulated sediment deposits and restore the stream channel for a section of the SusquehannaSusquehanna River in order to

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.com

SamouelSamouel J. Beguin Senior Environmental Analyst

improve water quality, flflow,ow, and aquatic habitat. Performed environmental review (listed species), prepared streamstream impact calculations, and created GIS mapping to support the permit application. Boathouse Permitting Project, Town of Skaneateles, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Prepared a Joint Application for Permit, a Submerged Land License Application, and supporting documents that were submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC),(NYSDEC), the New York State Office of General Services (OGS), and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) for a residential waterfront improvement proprojectject involving installation of a new dock and boathouse. Conducted a site visit with representatives of the NYSDEC. Canisteo Wind Farm, Steuben County, NY-NY- Conducted wetland and stream delineations forafor a proposed 290 MW wind power facility subject to reviewreview and approval under ArtideArticle 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Wastewater System Improvements Project, City of Ogdensburg,Ogdensburg, St. Lawrence County, NY-NY- Conducted an extensive environmental review (rare species, water resources, coastal resources) andand prepared an Environmental Report with associated GIS mapping for a financial assistance application to the USDA Rural Development Rural Utilities Service for a $35.5 million wastewater infrastructure improvement project. Coxsackie Correctional Training FacilityFacility Project, Coxsackie, NY-NY- Lead author for a Joint Application for Permit and a Conceptual Mitigation Plan for a proposed correctional training academy facility in Greene County, New York. Prepared wetland impact calculations, created GIS mapping, and developeddeveloped a mitigation plan for state-listed-listed grassland raptor species. Flint Mine Solar Project, Greene County, NY-NY- DesignedDesigned a winter raptor study, performed winter raptor surveys, performed spring breeding bird surveys, and conducted wetland/stream delindelineationseations for a 100 MW solar photovoltaic facility subject to review and approval under ArtideArticle 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Prepared a winter raptor survey report and supporting GIS mapping. Great Lakes Restoration Initiative Grant Implementation Support, Town of Alexandria, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Performed aquatic vegetation and invasive species surveys in support of integratedintegrated aquatic invasive species management efforts in Goose Bay; prepared summary report submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) in compliance with an issued Article 15, Part 3217 Permit for the Use of Pesticides for thethe Control or Elimination of Aquatic Vegetation.Vegetation. Heritage Wind Project, Orleans County, NY-NY- DesignedDesigned and conducted a vernal pool study for a proposed utility-scale-scale wind power facility subject to review and approval under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law. Prepared a final report and supporting GIS mapping summarizing the findings of the vernal pool study. Provided suggested facility layout changes to the client. Coordinated and performed wetland and stream delineations, managed GIS data, and prepared maps using GIS. Coordinated sensitive receptor survey for the project. Imperial Dam Wetland Restoration Project, Clinton County, NY-NY- Conducted a wetland functions and values assessment and identified potential ecological reference wetlands for a proposed Saranac River restoration project. Stream Restoration and Waterfront Improvement Project, Town of Skaneateles, Onondaga County, NNY-Y- LeadLead author for a Joint Application for Permit submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) for a project designed to improve drainage issues, restore a stream channel, and improveimprove riparian zone conditions on a private parcel. Prepared GIS mapping and assembled aadditionaldditional information to support NYSDEC and USACE review of the permit application. Prepared a Submerged Land License Application, and supporting documents for a proposproposeded dock and boathouse that were submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) and the New York State Office of General Services (OGS). North Ridge Wind Farm, St. Lawrence County, NY-NY- PreparedPrepared Stipulations comment responsesresponses in support of an Article 10 Application for a proposed 100 MW wind power facility. Roaring Brook Wind Power Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Conducted wetland and stream delineations and additional boundary verification for a proposed 20-turbine-turbine wind power facility that has been evolving for 10+ years. Primary author for a Joint Application for Permit submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE).(USACE). Prepared maps using GIS, analyzed project data, and engaged in client and agency correspondence, meetings, and site visits. Pattersonville Solar Project, Town of Princetown, Schenectady County, NNY-Y- Coordinated and performed wetland/stream delineations for solar photovoltaic electrelectricic generating facility. Prepared GIS web maps and processed wetland/stream delineation GPS data. Performed spring avian surveys to determine presence of state-listed-listed species. Pavilion Project, Town of Elbridge, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Lead author for a Joint Application for Permit submitted to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) for a proposed outdoor recreational pavilion building and associated bike path. ConductedConducted an environmental review (listed species, wetlands/streams) andand prepared GIS mapping to accompany the permit application. Transmission Line Rebuild Project, Town of East Greenbush, Rensselaer County, NY-NY- Conducted wetland and stream delineations for a transmission line requiring new structures. Processed delineation data and created maps using GIS.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

JOHN D. HECKLAU

PRINCIPAL, ENVIROENVIRONMENTALNMENTAL SERVICES

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (John(John D. Hecklau)Hecklau)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. John D. Hecklau, Hecklau, Environmental Design & Research, Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Principal, Environmental ServicesServices..

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I have been employed with EDR since 1989.1989.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Biology from Middlebury College in

12 1979.1979. I also received a Master of Science in Environmental & Forest Forest

13 Biology from the State University of New York, College of

14 Environmental Science and Forestry in 1982.1982. I have more than 3030 years of

15 experience in environmental planning and consulting, the majority of

16 which involved energy projects.projects. I also have significantsignificant experience with the

17 environmental review and permitting of commercial renewable energy

18 projects, including with respect to siting, environmental review and

19 analysis, ecological surveys, wetland delineation and permitting, and

20 environmentalenvironmental compliance during during construction. construction. My current curriculum

1 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (John(John D. Hecklau)Hecklau)

1 vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

2 experience.

3 Q. What are your current responsibilities at EDREDR??

4 A. In my current position,position, I am responsible for overseeing all of EDR’sEDR's visual

5 impact assessment projects.projects.

6 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

7 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

8 A. Yes.Yes. I provided testimony related to visual impact assessments for the

9 Cassadaga Wind Project, Galloo Island Wind Project, Project, Bluestone Wind

10 Project, and the Baron Winds Project. I have also submitted testimony in

11 the Athens Generating Case, the Ramapo Energy Limited Partnership

12 Case, the Astoria Energy Case, the Flat Rock Wind Power Case, the St.

13 Lawrence Gas Gas Company Case, and the Central Hudson Gas & Electric

14 Case.

15 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

16 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

17 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

18 A. Yes.Yes. I providedprovided visual testimony to the Rhode Island Energy Facilities

19 Siting Board Board on the 38 Aquidneck Island Reliability Project, the Rhode

20 Island Reliability Project 39, and the Southern Rhode Island Transmission

21 Project. In addition, I have provided visual testimony testimony to the New

2 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (John(John D. Hecklau)Hecklau)

1 Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee on the Merrimack Valley 41

2 Reliability Project and the Groton Wind Power Project. I have also

3 provided visual testimony to the 42 Perquimans and Chowan County

4 Commissions on the Timbermill Wind Farm.Farm.

5 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

6 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

7 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

8 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facilityfacility in

9 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

10 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

11 sponsoring?sponsoring?

12 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 24,24, Visual ImpactsImpacts..

13 Q. Were these portions portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

14 your direction and/or supervision?

15 A. Yes.

16 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

17 A. Yes.

3 of 3

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal Environmental Services

John is a certified Wildlife Biologist with over 30 years of environmental planning and consulting experience, the majority of which has been associated with energy projects. He has been directly involved in the environmental review and permitting of over 4040 commercial wind power projects as well as, hydrohydro relicensing studies, and environmental impact assessments for power plants, transmission lines, and gas franchises. His expertise covers all facets of utility permitting, including siting, environmental review and analysis, ecological surveys, wetland delineationdelineation and permitting, liaison with regulatory agencies, as well as environmental compliance during construction. Since 1993, John has served as principal-in-in-charge-charge or project manager on all of the fifirm’srm's visual impact assessment projects. Along with managing these projects, his role has typically included analyzing the results of the visual impact assessment, and completing the necessary reports and permitting required by federal, state, and local agencies. In addition to his professional experience,experience, John has provided expert witness testimony, made numerous presentations, and published articles on visual impact issues associated with utility-scale-scale wind power projects.

eeducationducation employment history Master of Science in Environmental & Forest Biology, Specializing in Principal,Principal, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Wildlife Biology, State University of New York, College of Environmental Engineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C., Syracuse, NY 2008- Science and Forestry, 1982. present.present. Bachelor of Arts in Biology, Middlebury College, 1979. Project Manager/SeniorManager/Senior Ecologist, Environmental Design & Research, Syracuse, NY,NY, 1995-present.-present. professional affiliations professional affiliations Ecologist,Ecologist, Environmental Design & Research, Syracuse, NY, 1989-1994.1989-1994. Member,Member, The Wildlife Society. Self-Employed-Employed Environmental Consultant, John D. Hecklau, Clinton, NY, Certified Wildlife Biologist, The Wildlife Society. 1988. Planning Board Member/Chairman, Town of Kirkland, NY.NY. Resource Manager, Environmental Programs Division, New York State Power Authority, Marcy, NY, 19841984-1987.-1987. Member,Member, American Wind Energy Association.Association. WildlifeWildlife Biologist, Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection, registration I/ certifications Burlington, CT, 1983-1984.1983-1984. Wildlife Biologist —The– The Wildlife Society.Society. Wildlife Consultant, Central Park Conservancy, New York, NY, 1982-1983.1982-1983. proprojectject experience Icebreaker Wind Project, Erie County, Cleveland, OH-OH- Oversaw federal permitting efforts for a proposedproposed 20-megawatt-megawatt (MW) demonstration wind project off-shore-shore of Cleveland, Ohio in Lake Erie. Permitting efforts indudedincluded Section 404/Section 10 with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Section 401 WaterWater Quality Certification from the Ohio EPA, and approval from the International Joint Commission. Jericho Rise Wind Farm, Towns of Bellmont & Chateauguy, Franklin County, NY-NY- Directed the SEQRA review for this 37-turbine,-turbine, 78 MW project. Oversaw preparationpreparation of a Supplemental EIS, a Final EIS, and multiple support studies including a Visual Impact Assessment, a Shadow Flicker Analysis, Cultural Resources Reports (Archaeology and Historic Resources), a Wetland Delineation Report, and a Rare Plant Survey. AlsoAlso coordinated preparation of local Wind Energy Permit Application and wetland/stream permit applications submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.com

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal I Environmental Services

Sodeman Road Substation,Substation, Saratoga County, NY-NY- DirectedDirected the preparation of an Article VII Application for a new National Grid substation tying into an existing Article VII transmission line.line. Also prepared a Visual Impact Assessment (VIA), wetland delineation, and alternatives analysis for the project. Coordinated preparation of noise study and Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP), and provided expert witness testimony.testimony. Aquidneck Island Reliability Project,Project, Newport, RI-RI- Directed the preparation of the Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) for the proposedproposed upgrade of approximately4.4approximately 4.4 miles of National Grid 69 kV transmission line to 115 kVkV.. The VIA also addressed construction of a new substation and retirement/removal of five substations. Specific tasks included field verification of project visibilityvisibility,, definition of landscape similarity zones and viewer groups, identification of sensitive resources/receptors, development of viewshed maps, preparation of visual simulations, impact evaluation, and preparpreparationation of the VIA report. Wild Meadows & Groton WindWind Farms, Danbury & Groton, NH-NH- Directed the preparation of Visual Impact Assessments (VIAs) and Shadow Flicker Analyses for two commercial wind power projects in New Hampshire. VIAs included viewshed analysis, photo documentation and vvisualisual simulations. Also assisted with public outroutreacheach efforts and state Site Evaluation Committee proceedings, including preparation of pre-filed-filed testimony, response to discovery requests, and participation in a technical session and adjudicatory hearings as an expert witness. Block Island Wind Farm, BlockBlock Island, RI-RI- Directed preparation of Visual Impact Assessments (VIAs) for the proposed Block Island Wind Farm and associated on-shore-shore transmission facilities. The wind farm is a 30 MW facility located in the Atlantic Ocean, 3 miles off the coast. On-shore-shore facilities include electrical lines, switchyards, and substations. The project involved the preparation of daytime and nighttime simulations of the offshore turbines from viewpoints on Block Island and the mainland. Simulations of the above--groundground on-shore-shore components of the project were also prepared, including landscaping and architectural facadefaçade treatments of the switchyards. VIAs also included an inventory of visually sensitive resources, viewshedviewshed analysis, cross section analysis, and evaluation of visualvisual impact. In addition to the VIAs, managed preparation of various presentation graphics for public outreach purposes, including poster boards, animated simulations, an interactive web site, and an animated 'fly“fly-through"-through” video of the wind farm. Eastover RoadRoad New 2301115kV230/115kV Station & Transmission Line Loops,Loops, Rensselaer County, NYNY-- Directed all environmental and civil engineering support to National Grid in their development of the proposed Eastover Road Substation and Tap Lines.Lines. Services provided on this prprojectoject included preparation of a Visual Impact Assessment, on-site-site wetland delineation and permitting, SEQRA documentation, OPRHP coordination, Part 102 report preparation, site grading, and stormwater design, wetland mitigation area design and documentatiodocumentation,n, preparation of Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP), and SWPPP inspections during construction. Environmental Compliance Monitoring during Wind Farm Construction, NY & MA-MA- Directed environmental compliance monitoring during construction of four different wind farms for three different developers in New York and Massachusetts (Hardscrabble, Hoosac, Arkwright Summit and Copenhagen). Assisted with preparation of the Environmental Compliance Manuals and provided compliance training to project contracontractors.ctors. Oversaw and assisted EDR field staff with daily on-site-site monitoring, weekly Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) inspections, preparing reports, coordinating resolution of compliance issues with Construction Site Manager and contractors, and assuring compliance with local, state, and federal permit conditions. CWM Wetland Permitting,Permitting, Model City, NY-NY- Directed multiple wetland delineation and permitting efforts on several potential landfill expansion sites at the CWM Chemical Services facility. Jurisdictional wetlands on site were identified and delineated in accordance with the 1987 CorpsCorps of Engineers Wetland Manual, and delineation reports were prepared and submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Also participated in agencyjurisdictionalagency jurisdictional determinations and development of wetland mitigation area designs, including a 4.5-acre-acre wetland mitigation area incorporatedincorporated into a compensatory flfloodood storage basin. Also provided monitoring of mitigation area success in accordance with wetland permit requirements. Deerfield Wind Power Project, Towns of Searsburg & Readsboro, Bennington County, VT-VT- Directed the prepapreparationration of a National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) compliant Environmental Impact StatementStatement (EIS) for the first wind power project proposed on U.S. Department of Agricultural (USDA) Forest Service land. The project involves the proposed construction of 17 2.0 MW wind turbines on forested ridges in the Green Mountain National Forest. Project activities included preparation of a Public Information Plan, significant public outreach, project scoping, coordination with Forest Service staff, and review of subconsultantsubconsultant resource reports for inclusion in the EIS. A draft supplemental draft, and final EIS were prepared for the project. Responses to over 500 public comments on the draft EIS and 1,000 comments on the supplemental draft were prepared. New England East-WestEast-West Solution Project,Project, MA, RI, CT-CT- Directed preparation of Visual Impact Assessments (VIAs) for multiple National Grid transmission system improvement projects in Rhode Island and Massachusetts. The transmission system improvements involve upgrade of existing transmission lines, construction of new transmission lines, construction of new substations, and existing substation upgrades. Prepared VIAs for each project that included the identification of existing visually sensitive resources, photo documendocumentationtation of existing views, and description of existing landscape character along over 75 miles of proposed transmission line route. Viewshed analyses of existing and proposed facilities were conducted, and over 20 visual simulations were

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal Environmental Services

prepared and rated by a professional panel of landscape architects. VIA reports were included in applications submitted to the State Utility SitingSiting Boards. Also prepared pre-filed-filed visual testimony, responded to discover requests, and provided testimony before the Rhode IslandIsland Energy Facility Siting Board. Blenheim-Gilboa-Gilboa Pumped Storage Project,Project, Schoharie County, NY-NY- Directed the design, construction, and post-construction-construction monitoring of 6+ acres of wetland mitigation areas to compensate for impacts associated with slope stabilizationstabilization activities at the New York Power Authority'sAuthority’s Blenheim-Gilboa-Gilboa Pumped Storage Power Project. Mitigation plans required installation of an impervious bentonite liner, and incorporated a pedestrianpedestrian path and bridge system to provide enhanced recreatirecreationalonal and educational opportunities at the Power Authority'sAuthority’s visitorsvisitor’s center. Performed five years of follow-upfollow-up monitoring to document successful development of wetland characteristics. Southern Rhode Island Transmission Project,Project, RI-RI- Directed the preparatpreparationion of the Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) and Supplemental VIA prepared for the proposed upgrade and extension of approximately 26 miles of an existing National Grid 115 kV transmission line in southernsouthern Rhode Island. The effort consisted of fieldwork, defdefinitioninition of landscape similarity zones and viewer groups, identification of sensitive resources/receptors, development of viewshedviewshed maps and visual simulations, impact evaluation, and preparation of the VIA report. Also provided expert witness testimony to the Rhode Island Energy Facility Siting Board. Cohocton & Marble River Wind Power Projects, Steuben County & Clinton County, NY-NY- Directed State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) compliance for these commercial wind power projects. Work on these proprojectsjects included project layout/environmental field review to assure that impacts on wetlands, agricultural land and ecological resources were minimized. Conducted or oversaw all environmental support studies on these projects and incorporated the results ofof these studies into Draft Environmental Impact Statements. Prepared Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statements to address project changes, and Final Environmental Impact Statements to address all public and agency comments on both of these projecprojects.ts. Also completed state and federal wetland permitting for the Cohocton Project. Commercial Wind Power Project Visual Impact Assessments-Assessments- Directed the preparation of Visual Impact Assessments (VIAs) for 15 commercial wind power projects in Upstate New York. The VIAs for these projects the visual character and significant aesthetic resources withwith a 5 or 10-mile-mile visual study area. Viewshed analysis, lineline-of-of-sight-sight cross sections, field review, and computer-assisted-assisted visual simulations were used to evaluate the potential visibility and visual impact of these projects. Notable projects include the Madison, Fenner, Maple Ridge, Jordanville, Hardscrabble, Cohocton,Cohocton, Dutch Hill, Dairy Hills, Howard, Munnsville, Alabama Ledge and Roaring Brook projects, totaling over 1,400 MW of proposed wind power. Maple Ridge Wind Power Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Directed State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) compliance,compliance, including preparation of Draft and Final Environmental Impact Statements (DEIS/FEIS) for the largest commercial wind power project in the Northeast. Oversaw production of all support studies and directly prepared ecological, wetlands, agricultural, and visual studies for 300 MW wind power project on the Tug Hill Plateau. Incorporate study results into the DEIS and responded to all public and agency comment in the FEIS. Also assisted with state and federal wetland permitting on the project. Maple Ridge 230 kV Transmission Line Project,Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Directed the preparation of Article VII Application to New York State Public Service Commission for a 10.3-mile-mile-long-long 230 kV transmission lineline corridor. Conducted ecological, wetland, and visual fieldwork,fieldwork, prepared Visual Impact Assessment report, and provided expert witness testimony on ecological and visual issues. Hardscrabble Wind Power Project, Herkimer County, NY-NY- Directed environmental compliance monitoring during construction for a 37-turbine,-turbine, 74 MW wind energy project. Assisted with preparation of the Environmental Compliance Manuals and provided compliance training to project contractors. OversawOversaw and assisted EDR field staff with daily on-site-site monitoring, weekly Stormwater Pollution Prevention PlanPlan (SWPPP) inspections, preparing reports, coordinating resolution of compliance issues with Construction Site Manager and contractors, and assuring compliance with local, state, andand federal permit conditions. Munnsville, Fenner, & Madison Wind Power Projects,Projects, Madison County, NY-NY- Directed the expanded Environmental Assessment Forms (EAFs) for these three commercial wind power projects. Work on the projects included project layout/environmental field review to assure that wetland impacts were avoided and impacts to agricultural and ecological resources minimized. Conducted or coordinated support studies addressing potential visual, cultural, noise, ecological, avian and agricultural impacts. Summarized results into expanded EAFs. On each of these projects the Lead AgencyAgency issued a Negative DeclarationDeclaration under SEQRA, indicating that no significant adverse environmental impacts were anticipated. Monitored environmentalenvironmental compliance during construction of the Munnsville and Madison Projects. LIPA Offshore Wind Park, Long Island, NY-NY- Directed the prepreliminaryliminary visual studies associated with a 150 MW offshore wind power project being proposed by the Long Island Power Authority (LIPA). Project included preparation of visual simulations from heavily used beaches and state parks on the South shore. GraphicsGraphics were used for public information and outreach efforts.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 3 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal Environmental Services

Cape Wind Offshore Wind Farm, Nantucket Sound, MA-MA- Directed the production of visual simulations and other graphics/analysis for America'sAmerica’s first proposed offshore wind power facility. Prepared visualvisual methodology write-upwrite-up for the project, responded to agency questions and information requests, and described the methodology and results of EDR'sEDR’s visual studies at a public/agency forum sponsored by the Massachusetts TechnologyTechnology Forum. The project’sproject's visual impact was a sensitive issue, subject to intense scrutiny by various interest groups. E-183E-183 115 kV Transmission Line Relocation Project,Project, CitiesCities of Providence & East Providence, RI-RI- Directed the preparation of a Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) of the propoproposedsed relocation of approximately 1.2 miles of existing overhead transmission line. VIA included viewshed analysis of existing and proposed towers, line-of-of-sight-sight cross sections, field evaluation/photo documentation, preparation of visual simulations, and visualvisual impact evaluation using the ACOE VRAP methodology. Conjunction Empire Connection Transmission Line Corridor-Corridor- Directed the preparation of ecological and visual inventories and impact evaluations undertaken in support of the Article VII Application for a proposed DC transmission line running parallel the New York State Thruway from south of Albany to New York City. The visual study assessed potential impacts of proposed overhead segments as well as converter stations forfor proposed underground transmissiontransmission line segments. Met extremely tight 30-day-day schedule for completion of studies. Reliant Energy Astoria Repowering Project,Project, Queens County,County, NY-NY- Directed Visual Impact Assessment for proposed repowering of the existing Astoria Generating Project. The study involved identification of landscape similarity zones and viewer groups, viewshed mapping, crosscross sections, and visual simulations. Assisted with develdevelopmentopment of visual impact mitigation options, and provided expert witness testimony. TransEnergie Cross-Sound-Sound Cable Project,Project, New Haven, CT & Shoreham, NY-NY- Directed the study and prepared Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) report assessing visual impacts of submarinesubmarine cable crossing of Long Island Sound. VIA focused on the visual impact of above-ground-ground transition stationsstations and associated structures. Neptune Regional Transmission System Project,Project, Sayreville, NJ to Nassau County, Long Island, NY-NY- Directed the study anandd prepared Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) report assessing visual impacts of aboveground components of submarine/underground transmission line in New York City metropolitan area. VIA focused on the visual impact of transition stations in Manhattan and on Long Island. Ramapo Energy Project,Project, Rockland County, NY-NY- Directed the preparation of comprehensive visual impact analysis for a proposed 1,100 MW gas-fired-fired power plant proposed by American National Power. Study involved background data collection, viewshed mapping, line-of-of-sight-sight cross sections, field evaluation, visual simulations, evaluation of visual impacts using the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers methodology, and explorationexploration of various visual mitigation measures. Wrote the Visual Impact Assessment report and assisted with preparation of the visual section of the Article X Application and provided expert witness testimony. Also assisted with ecological investigations, and preparation of Application text and testimony dealing withwith wildlife issues. Athens PowerPower Project,Project, Village of Athens, NY-NY- Evaluated visual resources and visual impacts associated with construction of a 1,080 MW power plant proposed by PG&E National Energy Group. Also delineated state and federal wetlands and documented ecological conditioconditionsns on the project site and along proposed off-site-site utility (gas, water, and electric transmission) corridors associated with the project. Assisted with field data collectcollection,ion, agency liaison, and preparation of a wetland delineation report and functional analysis.analysis. Oversaw preparation of the Ecological Resources and Visual Resources sections of the Article X Application, and provided expert witness testimony on potential ecological impacts.impacts. Project was the first permitted under New York'sYork’s Article X power pplantlant siting regulations. St. Lawrence GasGas,, Lewis County & St. Lawrence County, NY-NY- Directed Environmental Impact Assessment Reports for proposed natural gas distribution systems. Reports included an inventory of environmental resources within the proposed franchise areas, as well as assessment of anticipated impacts and proposed mitigation measures.measures. Lewis County project involved wetland delineation and permitting, and assistance with preparation of construction drawdrawings.ings. Avoca Natural Gas Storage Project,Project, Steuben & Schuyler Counties, NY-NY- Evaluated the environmental impacts of a proposed natural gas storage project. Project included wetland delineation, vegetation, fish and wildlife inventory (including identification of endangered species and critical habitats), viewshed/visibility analysis and preparation of ecological resource reports for the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) license applications. Reports described ecological resources within study area, along with potential impacts to these resources resulting from consconstructiontruction and operation of the project, and proposed means of mitigatingmitigating adverse impacts. A & C Lines Rebuild Project,Project, Central Hudson Gas & Electric Corporation, Dutchess County, NY-NY- Directed preparation of an Article VII application, and associated support studies, for the rebuild of 11 miles of 115 kV transmission lines.lines. Along with the preparation of the application, participated in

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 4 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal Environmental Services

settlement negotiations with state agencies, and oversaw production of the Environmental Management & Construction Plan (EM&CP).(EM&CP). Will also be overseeing environmental compliance monitoring during project construction. Article VII Compliance Monitoring-Monitoring- Directed environmental compliance monitoring on three Article VII projects in Upstate New York. Projects included a 48-mile-mile long natural gas pipeline (St. Lawrence Gas Norfolk to Chateauguay Transmission Line), an 11-mile-mile long 115 kV transmission line (Central Hudson A and C Line Rebuild Project) and a new substation tying into an existing Article VII line (National Grid Five Mile Road Substation).Substation). Directed efforts of on- site Environmental MonitorsMonitors to assure compliance with all conditions of the project Environmental Management and Construction Plan (EM&CPs) and Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plans (SWPPPs).(SWPPPs). Assisted with environmental training of contractors, agency liaison, and reporting. Worked with agency staff and project sponsors to assure compliance with all environmental protection requirements during project construction, includingincluding protection of wetlands and streams, active agricultural land, threatened and endangered species, and archeological resources. Joseph Davis State Park, NYSOPRHP, Village of Lewiston, NY-NY- Inventoried vegetation and wildlife species, and existing natural communities’communities'/wildlife/wildlife habitat and wetland delineation with potential for hydric inclusions. Prepared Environmental Impact Statement for a 180-acre-acre portion of the 300-acre-acre park. Niagara River Gorge Rim Restoration Plan,Plan, The Wild Ones National & City of Niagara Falls,Falls, NYNY-- Directed ecological studies for development of restoration plan for the Niagara River Gorge RIM that included a study to propose closingdosing the Robert Moses Parkway. Ohio Street Launch & Old Bailey Woods, Buffalo Niagara Riverkeepers, City of Buffalo, NYNY-- Directed ecological studies for shoreline and riparian habitat restoration that included monitoring and maintenance plan development. South Buffalo Golf Course, Feasibility Study, City of Buffalo, NY-NY- Directed wetland delineation and ecological assessmentassessment to explore the feasibility of constructing a new, 18-hole,-hole, links style golf course on exiting landfills and adjacent properties in South Buffalo. Riverview Commerce Park, Town of Tonawanda, NY-NY- Directed the preparation of the environmental impact statement,statement, DEIS and FEIS, ecological survey, field delineation of wetlands and Waters of the U.S., wetland mitigation and monitoring plan, Joint Application for Permit, andand SWPPP. Also managed SEQRA process, site remediation and site development activities. BicentennialBicentennial Park/Scenic Woods Master Plan,Plan, Town of Grand Island, NY-NY- Directed the wetland delineation and environmental permitting process as part of the development of a master plan for 229 acres of environmentally sensitive public open space. The Master Plan integrates community input with recreational and ecological design principles to produce a balanced, nature-oriented-oriented park design. Muir Woods, Town of Amherst, NY-NY- Directed wetland mitigation plan, and environmental assessments for proposed 326-acre-acre planned community situated in the natural environment of the Audobon New Community District. The NYS Office of Parks, Recreation & Historic Preservation recognized this project with a Preservation Award. Canal Ponds Business Park, Town of Greece, NY-NY- Directed environmental assessment aspects of master developed by EDR to organize more than 3 million SF of building, parking and drives around a natural open space system. EstablishedEstablished wetlands as a key feature of the site. Obtained all necessary permits by providing a thorough EIS. Army Corps of Engineers recognized this site as a benchmark for developer, design and agencyagency collaboration. Black Creek Park, Monroe County Parks, Towns ooff Chili & Riga, NY-NY- Directed the development of a master plan for a largely undeveloped 1,500-acre-acre County park, one third of which is made up of wetlands. Responsible for comprehensive study of ecological resources includingincluding field inventory of all wildlife,wildlife, wetlands, and natural communities within the park, and an evaluation of the ecological significance/sensitivity of various areas.areas. Oversaw wetland delineation and state and federal wetland permitting. Mendon Ponds Park, Monroe County Parks, Town of Mendon,Mendon, NY-NY- Directed ecological study of this 1,500-acre-acre County park. The park is a designated National Natural Landmark, well known for its variety of rare species and unique natural communities, including fens, bogs, oak openings, and prairie remnants. StudyStudy involved species inventory, analysis of ecological value of various areas of the park, and management recommendations for the protection and enhancement of the park's ecological resources. Town of Grand Island, Bicentennial Park/Scenic Woods Master Plan-Plan- Directed the wetland delineation and environmental permitting process as part of the development of a master plan for 229 acres of environmentally sensitive public open space. The Master Plan integrates cocommunitymmunity input with recreational and ecological design principlesprinciples to produce a balanced, nature-oriented-oriented park design. Albany Pine Bush Preserve,Preserve, Albany County, NY-NY- Developed and updated a comprehensive management plan for a unique inland pine--barrensbarrens community. Project involved extensive data collection, public participation, and doseclose coordination with members of the Albany Pine Bush Preserve

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 5 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal Environmental Services

Commission. Plan indudedincluded resource inventory, management recommendations, an implementation plan, and anan Environmental Impact Statement that addressed the potential impactsimpacts of plan implementation, indudingincluding land acquisition, fire management, and increased public use. Powder Mills Park Master Plan Update, Monroe County Parks, Town of Perinton, NY-NY- Directed ecological assessments as part of the development of a master plan forfor the park. This is a unique park that protects and preserves important natural, historic, and cultural areas and landscapes.landscapes. The park will be preserved and enhanced to provide environmental quality and a diversity of appropriate and sustainable recreatirecreationalonal activities. Irondequoit Bay & Ellison Park Area Master Plan Update, Monroe County, NY-NY- Directed ecological assessments as part of the master plan updates for 6 Monroe County Parks around Irondequoit Bay. The Bay Area Parklands are a system of parks andand trails that protect and preserve important natural, historic, and cultural areas and landscapes. The parks will be preserved and enhanced to provide environmental quality and a diversity of appropriate and sustainable recreational activities. HuckleberryHuckleberry Swamp Preserve, Town of North Rose, NY-NY- Managed ecological assessments of part of the planning, design and engineering improvements to this 80-acre-acre preserve that included constructing new facilities to provide access and education - wetland boardwalk, uplandupland trail, observation areas, bus loop, parking area, gathering spaces, information kiosks, interpretive and directional signage. Flat Rock 230 kV Transmission Line Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Directed the preparation of Article VII Application to New York State Public Service Commission for a 10.3-mile-mile-long-long 230 kV transmission line corridor. Conducted ecological, wetland, and visual fifieldwork,eldwork, prepared Visual Impact AssessmentAssessment report, and provided expert witness testimony on ecological and visual issues. ppublicationsublications / presentations

Presenter, Herkimer-Oneida-Oneida Counties Comprehensive Planning Program / Land Use Training Conference, Marcellus Shale: Local Municipal OptionsOptions,, October 2011. Presenter, Land Use Planning Workshop, The Benefits of Sustainable CommCommunityunity Planning & Design,Design, Jefferson Community College Center for Community Studies, April 2011. Hecklau, J. 2010. Technical Considerations in the Preparation of Visual Simulations of Off-Shore-Shore Wind Power Projects. Presentation at the American Wind Energy AssociationAssociation North American Off-Shore-Shore Wind Conference & Exhibition. October 5-7,5-7, 2010, Atlantic City NJ. Hecklau, J. and J. Gagliano. Local Review of Commercial Wind Power Projects. Presentation at Onondaga County Planning Federation Conference. January 21, 2009, Syracuse, NY. Hecklau, J. and M. Scipioni. Measuring Success of Wetland Mitigation & Monitoring.Monitoring. Presentation at Sustainable Solutions. June 12, 2008, Rochester, NY. American Society of Landscape Architects, New York Upstate Chapter Annual Conference. Hecklau, J. and B. Brazell. State and Environmental Quality Review Act & Public Participation.Participation. Presentation at Wind Energy Conference. April 5, 2008, Herkimer County Community College. Sponsored by Herkimer-Oneida-Oneida Counties Comprehensive PlanningPlanning Program. Hecklau, J. 2006. Evaluating the Visual Impacts of Wind Power Projects.Projects. North American Wind Power. 3 (June): 48-52.48-52. Hecklau, J. Visual Characteristics of Wind TurbinesTurbines.. Presentation at Technical Considerations in Siting Wind DevelopmentsDevelopments Research Meeting. December 1-2,1-2, 2005, Washington, DC. Sponsored by the National Wind Coordinating Committee. Hecklau, J. Evaluating Visual/Aesthetic Impacts of Wind Power Projects.Projects. Presentation at the Second Wind Power Project Siting Workshop, Siting Wind Power Projects in the Eastern U.S. March 8-9,8-9, 2005 Boston, MA. Sponsored by the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA). Lamanna, B. and J. Hecklau. 2002. The Windmills of Madison CountyCounty.. New York State Conservationist. 56(5): 8-11.8-11. Hecklau, J. OOverviewverview of Wind Permitting Frameworks in Different SettingsSettings.. Case Study 1: Madison, NY.NY. Presentation at New England Wind Power Siting Workshop, October 24, 2001, Boston, MA. Sponsored by the National Wind Coordinating Committee. Hecklau, J.D., C. Palmero, E.T. Liverman and J. deWall Malefyt. 1987. Reducing the environmental impacts of stream crossings on a 345kV transmission line in New YorkYork.. In W.R. Byrnes and HA.H.A. Holt, eds. Fourth Symp. on Environmental Concerns in Rights-of-of-Way-Way Manage. Purdue Univ.,Univ., West Lafayette, IN.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 6 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

John D. Hecklau,Hecklau, Principal Environmental Services

Liverman, E.T., J.D. Hecklau and C. Palmero. 1987. Minimization of soil erosion and siltation during construction of the Marcy-South-South 345kV transmission facilitiesfacilities.. pp. 241-253.241-253. In Erosion Control: You're Gambling Without It. Proc. of Conf. XVII. International Erosion Control Assoc., Pinole, CA. 335 pp.pp.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 7 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

BENJAMIN R. BRAZELL

PRINCIPAL, ENVIRONMENTALENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Benjamin(Benjamin R. Brazell)Brazell)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Benjamin R. Brazell, Brazell, Environmental Design Design & Research, Landscape

3 Architecture, Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”),

4 217 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Principal, DirectorDirector ofof Environmental ServicesServices..

7 Q. How long have you been ememployedployed with EDREDR??

8 A. I have been employed with EDR since 2004.2004.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Natural Resources from North

12 Carolina State University in 2001.2001. I have over 2525 years of experienceexperience in

13 the environmental review and permitting of commercial renewable energy

14 projects, including in the areas of environmental impact analysis, Article

15 10 and SEQRA compliance, state and federal wetland permitting, and

16 managing largelarge-scale,-scale, complex projects.projects. My current curriculum vitae is

17 attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

18 experience.

19 Q. What are your current responsibilities at EDREDR??

20 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for overseeing EDR’sEDR's

21 environmentalenvironmental permittingpermitting services and environmental consulting services

1 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Benjamin(Benjamin R. Brazell)Brazell)

1 for utility-scale-scale renewable energy projects.projects.

2 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

3 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

4 A. Yes.Yes. I provided testimonytestimony for the CassadagaCassadaga Wind Project, Galloo Island

5 Wind Project, Bluestone Wind Project, and the Baron Winds Project.

6 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

7 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

8 offer testimonytestimony on in this proceeding?

9 A. Yes.Yes. I sponsored testimony in the Matter of National Grid's Grid’s petition to

10 Amend the Article VII 26 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and

11 Public Need for the 115 kV Fenner to Cortland #3 27 Transmission LineLine.. I

12 also servedserved as an expert witness before the Ohio Power Siting Board in the

13 Matter of the Application of Paulding Wind Farm III 31 LLC for a

14 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need, for the

15 Timber Road III 32 Transmission LineLine..

16 Q. WhatWhat is the purposepurpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

17 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

18 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

19 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facilityfacility in

20 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

2 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Benjamin(Benjamin R. Brazell)Brazell)

1 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

2 sponsoring?sponsoring?

3 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 22,22, Terrestrial

4 Ecology and Wetlands; Wetlands; andand Exhibit 23,23, Water Resources and Aquatic

5 EcologyEcology..

6 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

7 your direction and/or supervision?

8 A. Yes.

9 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

10 A. Yes.

3 of 3

Benjamin R. Brazell,Brazell, Principal Environmental Services

Ben is currently a principal and Director of Environmental Services for Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture & Engineering, D.P.C. With approximately 15 years of environmental consulting experience, Mr. Braze!lBrazell has been directly involved in thethe environmental review and permitting of over 25 commercial wind power projects (primarily located in New York and Ohio). Mr. BrazeBrazell’s specialized expertise includes environmental impact analysis, Article 10 and SEQRA compliance, state and federal wetland permitting, and managing largelarge-scale,-scale, complex projects. He is currently serving as the Project Manager for the Cassadaga Wind Project, the fifirstrst project to submit an Article 10 Application to the New York State Public Service Commission. He has significantsignificant regulatory expertise with Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law, New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) and Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB) compliance, and state/federalstate/federal wetland permitting.permitting. As a Director of Environmental ServicesServices with EDR, Ben oversees the firm'sfirm’s environmental permitting services.services. He has extensive experience providing environmental consulting services for utility-scale-scale renewable energy projects.

educationeducation employment history Bachelor Natural Resources,Resources, North Carolina State University,University, 2001. Principal, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, EngileeringEngineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C.,D.P.C., Syracuse, NY,NY, 2011 - professional affiliations PresentPresent. Member,Member, New York State Wetlands Forum Associate, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, EngileeringEngineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C.,D.P.C., Syracuse, NY,NY, 2010-2010- Member,Member, American Wind Energy Association 20112011. Member, Town of Dewitt Parks & Recreation Commission Division Manager, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Member, American Wind Energy Association Siting & Environmental Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C.,D.P.C., Syracuse, Compliance Committee NY,NY, 2009-2010.2009-2010. Project Manager,Manager, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C.,D.P.C., Syracuse, NY,NY, 2004-2008.2004-2008. Project Scientist, EcoScianceEcoScience Corporation, Raleigh, NC,NC, 2001-2003.2001-2003. Dendrology Tutor, NorthNorth Carolina State University, 2001. proprojectject experience Cassadaga Wind Project —– Managing EDR responsibilities for project review of a proposed 126 MW wind power project. under Article 10 of the Public Service Law in the Towns of Cherry Creek, Charlotte, Arkwright, and Stockton, Chautauqua County, NY. First Article 10 Application submitted and approved inin the State of New YorkYork.. Managed preparation of the Public Involvement Program Plan, the PreliminaryPreliminary Scoping Statement, Stipulations document, multiple supportstudies,support studies, the Article 10 Application. Baron Winds Project —– Managing EDR'sEDR’s responsibilities associated with this 242 MW project located in the Towns of Avoca, Cohocton, Dansville, Fremont, Howard,Howard, and Wayland, Steuben County, New York. The Article 10 Application was submitted in November of 2017 and is being reviewed under the Public Service Law.Law. EDR prepared the Public Involvement Program Plan and the Preliminary Scoping StatementStatement. Galloo Island Wind Project —– Overseeing EDR'sEDR’s responsibilities associated with this 32 turbine, 110 MW project located in the Town of Hounsfield, Jefferson County, New York. This project is being reviewed under Article 10 of the Public Service Law and to date,date, EDR has prepared the Public Involvement Program Plan, the Preliminary Scoping Statement, and the draft Stipulations document. Bear Ridge Solar Project-Project- This project involves proposed photovoltaic (TV)(“PV”) solar energy generating located within the Towns of Cambria and Pendleton, Niagara County, New York. The Facility will generate up to 100 megawatts ("MW')(“MW”) of renewable electricity and will represent one of the largest utility- scale solar power plant in New York State. EDR is currently preparing the PreliminaryPreliminary Scoping StatementStatement. Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.com

Benjamin R. Brazell,Brazell, Principal I Environmental Services

Mohawk Solar Project-Project- This project proposed a 90 megawatt ("MW")(“MW”) photovoltaic ("PV")(“PV”) solar energy generating project located within the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County, New York. The Facility will representrepresent the largest utility--scalescale solar power plant in New York State. EDR completed both the Public Involvement Program Plan the Preliminary Scoping Statement and is currently working on the Article 10 Application. Riverhead Solar 2-2- This project included a prproposedoposed 36 megawatt alternating current photovoltaic solar energy generation facility in the Town of Riverhead, Suffolk County, New York. Jericho Rise Wind Farm-Farm- Provided the SEQRA review for this 37-turbine,-turbine, 78 MW project, located in the Towns of Bellmont and Chateauguy, Franklin County, New York. EDR prepared a Supplemental EIS, a Final EIS, and multiple support studies including a Visual Impact Assessment,Assessment, Shadow Flicker Analysis, Cultural Resources Reports (Archaeology and Historic Resources), a Wetland Delineation Report, and a Rare Plant Survey. EDR also obtained wetland/stream permits from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation. Arkwright Summit Wind Farm-Farm- Prepared the SEQRA review for this 36-turbine,-turbine, 78 MW project, located in the Town of Arkwright, Chautauqua County, New York. EDR prepared a Supplemental EIS, a Final EIS, and multiple support studies including a Visual Impact Assessment and Shadow Flicker Analysis. EDREDR is also responsible for obtaining wetland/stream permits from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the NYS Department of EnvironmentalEnvironmental Conservation. Scioto Ridge Wind Farm-Farm- Managed the preparation of a Certificate Application submitted to the Ohio Power Siting Board for this 176-turbine,-turbine, 300 MW project located in Hardin and Logan Counties, Ohio. EDR's responsibilities included attending work sessions with OPSB staff, directing other subconsultants, coordinating internal staff resources, and assuring a comcompleteplete application was prepared/submitted in accordance with the Ohio Administrative Code. Also managed the preparation of a separate Certificate Application for the associated 4.8-mile-mile 345 kilovolt transmission line, which was submitted subsequent to the wwindind farm application and also accepted as complete following its first submittal. Copenhagen Wind Project-Project- DirectedDirected EDR'sEDR’s responsibilities as a third-party-party consultant to the USFWS. As a result of potential impacts to federally-federally- listed species, the developer is applying for an Incidental Take PermitPermit. EDR is responsible for preparing all NEPA documentation associated withwith this action. Crown City Wind Energy Project-Project- Directed EDR'sEDR’s SEQRA review for this 44-turbine,-turbine, 71 MW project, located in the Towns of Cortlandville, Homer, Solon, and Truxton, Cortland County, New York. EDR prepared a Draft EIS, and throughout this process worked closely with the Lead Agency'sAgency’s consultant. In support of the Draft EIS, EDR also prepared a Visual Impact Assessment, Shadow Flicker Analysis, Addendum Cultural Resources Report, and a Socioeconomic Report. Buckeye II Wind Power Project-Project- ManagedManaged the preparation of a comprehensive Application forafor a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need submitted to the Ohio Power Siting Board forthisfor this 56-turbine,-turbine, 140 MW project located in Champaign County, Ohio. EDR's responsibilities included conducting initial site reconnaissance to define the project layout, attending various workworksessions sessions with OPSB review staff, directing otherother subconsultants, coordinating internal staff resources, and assuring a complete applicationapplication was prepared/submitted in accordance with the Ohio Administrative Code. Allegany Wind Power Project-Project- Directed EDR'sEDR’s SEQRA review for this 29-turbine,-turbine, 72.5 MW project, located in the Town of Allegany, Cattaraugus County, New York. EDR prepared a Draft and a Final EIS, which resulted in successful issuance of SEQRA findings statement and local discretionary approvals in July 2011. Through these efforts, EDR has worked closely with the Lead Agency Special Counsel and consultant throughout the SEQRA review process, coordinated with interested state and federal regulatoryagencies,regulatory agencies, and managed numeroussubconsultants.numerous subconsultants. EDR was also responsible for preparation of the SWPPP in accordance with the SPDES General Permit, which was approved by the NYSDEC in September 2011. Hardscrabble Wind Power Project (Compliance Monitoring)-Monitoring)- Initially managed EDR'sEDR’s role as Environmental Monitor for the construction and restoration of this 37-turbine-turbine project located in the Towns of Fairfield, Norway, and Little Falls, Herkimer County, New York. In addition to preparpreparinging an Environmental ComplianceCompliance Manual and providing compliance training to the project contractors, EDR's responsibilities included overseeing constructionconstruction activities, monitoring the environmental, agricultural, and archeological conditions on the construction site, reporting on ccomplianceompliance with environmental permits and conditions (including federal, state, and local permits and approvals), conducting bi-weeklybi-weekly SWPPP inspections in accordance with the SPDES General Permit, and serving as a liaison between agency representatives and thethe project contractor/developer. Timber Road II Wind Farm-Farm- Managed the preparation of a comprehensive Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need submitted to the Ohio Power Siting Board for this 109-turbine,-turbine, 150 MW project located in Paulding County, Ohio. EDR's responsibilities included attending various work sessions with OPSB review staff, directing other subconsultants, coordinating internal staff resources, and assuring a complete application was prepared/submitted in accordance with the Ohio Administrative Code. Irrespective of the project’sproject's aggressive schedule, EDR plplayedayed a critical role in meeting the permitting deadline.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.com

Benjamin R. Brazell,Brazell, Principal I Environmental Services

Timber Road I Wind Farm-Farm- Managed the preparation of a comprehensive ApplicationApplication for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need submitted to the Ohio Power Siting Board for this 35-turbine,-turbine, 49 MW project located in Paulding County, Ohio. EDR's responsibilities included attending various work sessions with OPSB reviewreview staff, directing other subconsultants, coordinating internal staff resources, and assuring a complete application was prepared/submitted in accordance with the Ohio Administrative Code (the application was accepted as complete following itsits first submittal).submittal). Buckeye Wind Power Project-Project- Managed the preparation of the first ever Application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need submitted to the Ohio Power Siting Board for a wind power project in Ohio. This 70-turbine,-turbine, approximately 130 MW project is located in Champaign County, Ohio, EDR's experience in the wind industry proved invaluable when working OPSB staff, interpreting the State of Ohio'sOhio’s new wind law, directing the efforts of local consulting firms, and coordinating with the project sponsor and legal counsel. The Application was accepted as complete after the first submission. Howard Wind Power Project-Project- Led EDR'sEDR’s SEQRA review for this 25--turbine,turbine, 62 MW project, located in the Town of Howard, Steuben County,County, New York. EDR prepared a Draft and Final EIS, and worked closely with the Lead Agency (SCIDA) Special Counsel and consultant throughout the SEQRA review process. EDR also assisted the Town of Howard (SEQRA Involved Agency) in their issuance of a Findings Statement, and obtained a local Special Use Permit. In addition, EDR obtained NYSDEC authorization under Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, and Corps authorization underunder Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. This project is currently under construcconstruction,tion, and EDR'sEDR’s continued involvement includes obtaining authorization for various project modifications, preparing a Draft and Final EIS forafor a two-turbine-turbine project expansion, which is expected to be approved in August 2011, and assisting the project contracontractor/developerctor/developer with regulatory compliance during construction. Lakeview Amphitheatre Project, Onondaga County, Syracuse, NY-NY- Managed preparation of the projectsproject's Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS), Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS), Findings Statement andand worked closely with the project team to assure compliance with the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA). This effort included preparing an Environmental Assessment Form (EAF), assisting withwith designating Onondaga County as the SEQRA Lead Agency, issuing a Determination of Significance, and preparing a Draft and Final Scoping Document. In support of the DEIS, conducted multiple resource-specific-specific analyses including visual impact assessment, ecological and cultural resource evaluations, and final dodocumentcument formatting and organization. Responded to over 400 substantive comments in preparation of the FEIS. Student Life Center, SUNY Cortland,Cortland, City of Cortland, Cortland County, NY-NY- Directed SEQRA review process on behalf of the State University ConstructionConstruction Fund, including preparation of a EAF and DEIS, numerous DEIS support studies (Visual Assessment, Archaeological SensitivityAssessment,Sensitivity Assessment, and Historic Resources Impact Assessment), Phase I ESA, and FEIS. Prepared Draft and Final Scoping Document; and coocoordinatedrdinated the public hearing on Scoping and the public hearing on the DEIS. Participated in numerous project-specific-specific meetings with local representatives, and on behalf of the State University Construction Fund, and acted as the sole representative during importantimportant meetings with local officials and stakeholders. Buffalo School of Medical & Biological Sciences, SUNY Buffalo, City of Buffalo, Erie County, NY-NY- Directed SEQRA review process on behalf of the State University Construction Fund, including preparation of DEIS and support studies (Visual Assessment, Archaeological Sensitivity Assessment, and Historic Resources Impact Assessment), conducted SEQRA public hearing, preparation of FEIS and SEQRA Findings Statement for a proposed 600,000 GSF new medical/educationalmedical/educational complex (under construction) sited on the University at Buffalo Downtown Campus.

Emerging Technology & Entrepreneurship Complex (ETEC),(ETEC), SUNY Albany, Albany, NYNY-- Directed SEQRA review process on behalf of the State University Construction Fund, including preparation of a Scoping Document, Supplement Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS, Phase 1B Archaeological Survey, Visual Assessment, and coordination of traffic study (by sub-consultant)-consultant) on behalf of the State University Construction Fund (SUCF) for a 12-acre-acre site proposed for new academic building (under construction) sited on the New York State Office of General Services (OGS)(OGS) Harriman Campus. School of Pharmacy,Pharmacy, SUNY Binghamton,Binghamton, Binghamton, NY-NY- Managed SEQRA process on behalf of the SUCF, including preparation of DEIS and support studies (including, Visual Assessment, Archeological Sensitivity Assessment, and Historic Resources Impact Assessment),Assessment), conducted SEQRA public hearing, preparation of EAF,EAF, FEIS, and SEQRA Findings Statement for a proposed new 110,000 SF science/educational building in the City of Binghamton.Binghamton. SEQRA Documentation, Rochester Central Schools District,District, Rochester, NY-NY- DirectedDirected the completion of Part I of the SEQRA Long EnvironmentalEnvironmental Assessment Form (EAF) for several proposed school improvement projects at various school buildings within the District. (2016(2016-Ongoing).-Ongoing). Great Bay Solar, Somerset County, MD-MD- Directed environmental permitting studies in support of Maryland Public ServiceService Commission review for a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN), including preparation of an Environmental Review Document (ERD), wetlwetlandand delineations, Visual Assessment, Phase 1 Archaeological Survey, Historic Resources Assessment, rarerare plant survey, wetland permitting, and local permitting for a proposed 100 MW solarsolar energy project located on 800-acres.-acres. Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 3 www.edrdpc.com

Benjamin R. Brazell,Brazell, Principal I Environmental Services

St. Regis Mohawk Reservation Wetland Analysis,Analysis, St. Regis Mohawk Indian Reservation,Reservation, Franklin County, NY-NY- Directed EDR'sEDR’s wetland reconnaissance investigation, delineation, and reporting efforts associated with a proposed expansion of the Akwesasne Casino.Casino. Digital design files were also provided to EDR in order to make a determination regarding potential impact to identifieidentifiedd wetlands. Murfreesboro Solar Project,Project, Hertford County, NC-NC- Prepared a jurisdictional analysis and permit screening evaluation for this 5 MW solar power project. EDR's responsibilities included review of various resource databases, agency consultation, coordinationcoordination with a local consulting firm, and preparing written response to specific agency comments. Snooks Pond Permitting,Permitting, Town of Manlius, Onondaga County, NY-NY- ManagedManaged the complex permittipermittingng of a single-familysingle-family residence,residence, which required discretionary approvalapproval from federal, state, and local agencies. EDR obtained Corps of Engineers authorization under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act, NYSDEC authorization under the Freshwater Wetlands Act (Article 24 of the Environmental Conservation Law), the ProtectionProtection of Waters Program (Article 15 of the Environmental Conservation Law), and Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, and Town of Manlius Planning Board authorizationauthorization under the local Grading and Excavation provisions. Hardscrabble Wind Power Project (Permitting),(Permitting), Towns of Fairfield, Norway, & Little Falls, Herkimer County, NY-NY- Managed EDR'sEDR’s SEQRA review for this 37-turbine,-turbine, 74 MW project. EDR prepared a Draft, Supplemental, and Final EIS, and worked closely with the Lead Agency'sAgency’s Special Counsel and consultant through the preparation of SEQRA Findings and local Special Use Permits. EDR also obtained regulatory authorization from the Corps of Engineers and NYSDEC, designed the compensatory wetland mitigation area, obtained permit amendments necessitated by constructconstructionion-driven-driven project changes, and we are currently responsible for monitoring/reporting on the success of the wetland mitigation in aaccordanceccordance with Corp of Engineers/NYSDEC permit conditions. WindFamiWindFarm Prattsburgh,Prattsburgh, Towns of Prattsburgh & Italy, Steuben & Yates Counties, NY-NY- Managed the preparation of a Draft and Final EIS for a 44- turbine, 75 MW project. By working closely with the Lead Agency (Steuben County Industrial Development Agency [SCIDA]) and the Lead Agency'sAgency’s Special Counsel and consultant, EDR successfully navigated WindFarm Prattsburgh through the SEQRA review process. Jordanville Wind Power Project,Project, Towns of Warren & Stark, Herkimer County, NY-NY- Managed EDR'sEDR’s preparation of a Draft, Supplemental, and Final EIS for a 67-turbine,-turbine, 136 MW projectproject.. In support of this project, EDR prepared the local special use permit applications, which initiated the SEQRA review of the subject action, assisted in Lead Agency determination, and prepared three EIS'sEIS’s to guide the SEQRA review. EDR worked closely with the Lead Agency (Town of Warren) Special Counsel and consultant during the SEQRA review process. Subsequently,Subsequently, EDR prepared a fourth EIS, which addressed the reduced 40-turbine,-turbine, 80 MW project. Citizens Airtricity Wind Power Project,Project, Towns of Stockbridge, Eaton, Madison, & Augusta, Madison & Oneida Counties, NY-NY- Directed EDR'sEDR’s SEQRA review for the 40 MW Citizens Airtricity Wind Power Project. The Town of Stockbridge Planning Board assumed the role ofof Lead Agency for this project, which became operational in 2007. Green Power Energy Wind Power Project,Project, Madison County, NYNY-- ManagedManaged the SEQRA review forfor this 5-turbine-turbine (9 MW) project, including the preparation of a Full EAF, presenting the SEQRA document at local town board meetings, and continuous client and agency correspondence andand sub-consultant-consultant coordination. Conducted on-site-site ecologicalecological surveys and wetland/stream delineations.

Article VII Application,Application, Maple Ridge 230 kV Transmission Line Project,Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Managed the preparation of Volume II (Plan and Profile Drawings) of the EM&CP document for the 10.310.3-mile4ong-mile-long 230 kilovolt kV transmission line corridor. Conducted on-site-site ecological surveys and wetland/stream delineations and worked closelyclosely with NYS PublicPublic Service Commission staff throughout the project review process. Maple Ridge Wind Power Project,Project, Lewis County, NY-NY- Managed the preparation of various project permits, including state and federal wetland permitting, for the 330-megawatt-megawatt (MW) Maple Ridge Wind Power Project on the Tug Hill Plateau. Conducted on-site-site ecological surveys and wetland/stream delineations. Athens Generating Project Wetland Monitoring,Monitoring, Green County, NY-NY- Directed field surveys/collected data and prepared monitoring reports, which detailed the success of project-specific-specific wetland mitigation sites in accordance with federally issued permitspermits.. Wallkill Loop Upgrade,Upgrade, Orange County, NY-NY- Managed the Pre-Construction-Construction Notification document for in-kind-kind replacement of wood pole structures withinwithin a 4.6-mile-mile long transmission line right-of-way.right-of-way. The Crossings Residential Subdivision,Subdivision, Onondaga County, NYNY-- Managed a Wetland Delineation Report, obtained Corps and NYSDEC wetland permits, and prepared a Detailed Wetland Mitigation Plan forafor a 146--lotlot residential subdivision. At TheThe Mill Residential Subdivision,Subdivision, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Obtained NYSDEC wetland permits for a 224ot22-lot residential subdivision.subdivision. Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 4 www.edrdpc.com

Benjamin R. Brazell,Brazell, Principal I Environmental Services

Sanctuary at the Pastures II Residential Subdivision,Subdivision, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Obtained NYSDEC wetland permits for a 9-lot-lot residential subdivision.subdivision. Cincinnatus Central School District Expansion,Expansion, Cortland County, NY-NY- Managed SEQRASEQRA documentation, conducted field investigations, and corresponded with regulatory personnel for the prproposedoposed school expansion project. A--EE Term Services Contracts (2016-2017),(2016-2017), Monroe County, NY-NY- Managed three local Prime Consultants, EDR is providing Landscape Architecture, Site/Civil Engineering, Community Planning, Ecological and Cultural Resource Management, Visualization, and Regulatory ComplianceCompliance services on an as--neededneeded basis. Genesee Transportation Council, Irondequoit Seneca Trail, MonroeMonroe County,County, Town of Irondequoit, NY-NY- Directed ecological consulting services as part of development of site analysis, feasibility assessment, and production of concept-level-level planning and design for a 10-plus-plus mile urban multi-use-use trail along the Genesee RiverRiver from the northern end of the El Camino Trail through Seneca Park (Olmstead-designed)-designed) to the Irondequoit Lakeside Trail near the O’RourkeO'Rourke Bridge in the Town of Irondequoit. Main Street Streetscape Improvement Project, City of Rochester,Rochester, NY-NY- Directed thethe project which included a rehabilitate pedestrian and bicycle facilities along East Main Street, including increased signage and enhancements to an urban plaza. Coordinating completion of the environmentalenvironmental review section of the Department of TransportationTransportation (DOT) Design Approval Document, including relevant screenings, assessments, and required DOT/FHWA checklists including the FEAW (Federal Environmental Affects Worksheet). Specific items being addressed are threatened & endangered species,species, cultural resources,resources, and parks and recreational resources. Term Contract for Bridge Rehabilitation,Rehabilitation, NYS Thruway Authority,Authority, Western New York-York- Directed Ecological and Cultural Resource Management, and Regulatory Compliance services on an as--neededneeded basis as sub-consultant-consultant to Stantec.Stantec. Costello Parkway Highway Rehabilitation & Bridge Replacement Project, NYSDOT,NYSDOT, Onondaga County,County, Town of Minoa, NY-NY- Directed environmental compliance and regulatory documentation for highway rehabilitation and proposed bridge rehabrehabilitationilitation project. Prepared SEQRA and NEPA checklist documents, an environmental assessment report for all ecological, cultural and aesthetic resources within the project area. Prepared preliminary environmental investigations in compliance with the critercriteriaia contained in the NYSDOT Environmental Procedures Manual. Prepared Phase 1 ESA and Phase 1A Cultural Resource Assessment. Pompey Center Road Highway Rehabilitation & Bridge Replacement Project, NYSDONYSDOT,T, Onondaga County,County, Town of Pompey, NY-NY- Directed environmentalenvironmental compliance and regulatory documentation for highway rehabilitation and proposed bridge replacement project. Prepared SEQRA and NEPA checklist documents, an environmental assessment report for all ecological, cultural and aesthetic resources within the project area. Prepared preliminary environmental investigations in compliance with the criteria contained in the NYSDOT Environmental Procedures ManManual.ual. Highway Rehabilitation & Bridge Replacements, NYSDOT,NYSDOT, Madison, Oneida & Herkimer Counties,Counties, NY-NY- DirectedDirected environmental compliance and regulatory documents for several highway rehabilitation and six (6) proposed bridge replacement projects. Phase 2 services includeinclude SEQRA and NEPA checklist documents, an environmental assessment report for all ecological,ecological, cultural and aesthetic resources within the project area. Prepared preliminary environmental investigations in compliance with the criteria contained in the NYSDOT Environmental Procedures Manual. PreparedPrepared Phase 1 ESA and Phase 1A Cultural Resource Assessment.Assessment. Onondaga Lake Parkway (NY Route 370) from Old Liverpool Road to 1-81I-81 Access & Final Design Project, NYSDOTNYSDOT,, Onondaga County, NY- Managed environmental regulatory compliance, ecological and cultural resource management for proposed highway and bridgebridge rehabilitation/replacement; and parkway corridor enhancements. The scope of work for this project includes preparation of SEQRASEQRA and NEPA documents, an environmental assessment report for all ecological, cultural and aesthetic resources (including wetlandwetlands)s) within the project area, Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment and Phase 1A Cultural Resource Assessment. Term Contract for Engineering Services,Services, NYS Office of Parks, Recreation & Historic Preservation,Preservation, Western, Central & Capital Regions,Regions, NY- Directed Ecological and Cultural Resource Management, and Regulatory Compliance services on an as-needed-needed basis as sub-consultant-consultant to D&B Engineering, Beardsley and C&S Engineers.Engineers. CNYRTA A-E-E Services Term Agreement (2015-2024)-(2015-2024)- Directed Landscape Architecture,Architecture, Site/Civil Engineering, Regulatory Compliance, Community Planning, Ecological and Cultural Resources Management, and Visualization services on an as-needed-needed basis as sub--consultantconsultant to C&S Engineers.Engineers.

Dick'sDick’s Sporting Goods Distribution Center, Broome County Industrial Development Agency TownTown of Conklin, NY-NY- Oversaw EDR team responsible for SEQRA and wetland permitting efforts for a proposed new 900,000 SFSF distribution facility. EDR also prepared state and federal wetlandwetland

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 5 www.edrdpc.com

Benjamin R. Brazell,Brazell, Principal I Environmental Services

delineation and permitting, wetland mitigation design, threatened and endangered species investigation, a Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP), and local Town Board and Planning Board approval.

Rome Ultraviolet Facility, Oneida County, NY-NY- Oversaw the EDR team responsible for environmental permitting and SEQRA review process for the City of Rome to support development of a proposed Ultraviolet Treatment Facility in the City of Rome. EDR was also responsible for a Joint Application for PermitPermit and report in support of a NYS DEC Article 15 permit, preparation of an alternatives analysis, a SWPPP and civil design for the on--sitesite facilities, roads and stream ccrossings.rossings.

Binghamton-Johnson-Johnson City Joint Sewage Treatment Plant Improvements, Broome County,County, NY-NY- Oversaw EDR team responsible for environmental permitting and State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) review process for the rehabilitation and upgrades of the Joint Sewage Treatment Plant. Responsible for preparation of a Joint Application for Permit and report to be submitted to the NYSDEC and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers iin support of an Article 15 permit and Nationwide Permit No. 12 (respectively); preparation of a SWPPP and landscape design.

Consolidation of Facilities, OnondagaOnondaga County Department of Transportation, Syracuse, NY-NY- Coordinated environmental consulting services to support development of a new 70,000 SF, 21-acre-acre highway maintenance facility to serve as a consolidation of two DOT facilities. Also responsible for managingmanaging all ecological resource assessments, including extensive wetland delineation and recommendations for proposed mitigationmitigation efforts. Project deferred.defend. ppresentations/volunteerresentations/volunteer experience

Local Control vs. State Siting. Does it even Matter? 2016 AWEA Siting Conference,Charleston, SC. March, 2016. Presenter. Wind Development Non-Wildlife-Wildlife Siting Issues—Issues – Sounds, Planes, and Views...OhViews…Oh my! 2015 AWEA Siting Conference, Austin, TX. March, 2015. Presenter. Wetlands: Mapped vs. Actual,Actual, WhatWhat You Don't Know About Wetlands Could Hurt Your Project.Project. Environmental Breakfast Club of Central New York, Syracuse, NY. March, 2014. Presenter. Successful Siting and Community Acceptance.Acceptance. 2013 AWEA Ohio Wind Energy Summit, Columbus, OH. September, 2013. Poster Presentation. An Overview of the Relationship Between Permit Commitments and Construction Realities.Realities. 2013 AWEA Wind Power Conference, Chicago, IL. May, 2013. Presenter. Typical Impacts & BenefiBenefitsts of Wind Power Development in New York State.State. 2012 Annual Conference,Conference, NY Upstate Chapter ASLA, Binghamton, NY. June, 2012. Poster Presentation. New York's ArticleArticle 10 Regulations, Potential Implications on New York StateState Wind Power Development and a ComparisonComparison to the Ohio SitingSiting Process.Process. 2012 AWEA Wind Power Conference, Atlanta, GA. May, 2012. Presenter. The Relationship BetweenBetween Permit Commitments and Construction Realities.Realities. 2012 NYS Wetlands Forum Annual Conference, Utica, NY. March, 2012. Presenter. SUNY College of EnvironmentalEnvironmental Science and Forestry (ESF), Renewable Energy Course. March 2010. Presenter. Herkimer-Oneida-Oneida County Land Use Training Conference. October 2009. Presenter. Herkimer-Oneida-Oneida CountyCounty Wind Energy Conference. April 2008. Volunteer. USFWS, Indiana Bat Telemetry Study, Glen Park Hibernaculum, Jefferson County. 2004.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 6 www.edrdpc.com

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

ERICA TAUZER

SENIOR PLANNER

ENVIENVIRONMENTALRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Erica(Erica Tauzer)Tauzer)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Erica TauzerTauzer,, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture,Architecture,

3 Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”), 217

4 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. Senior Planner.Planner.

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I have been employed with EDR since 2015.2015.

9 Q.Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Biology and Spanish from Albion College

12 in 2010.2010. I also received a Master of Science in Environmental Studies

13 from the State University of New YorkYork College of Environmental Science

14 and Forestry in 2014.2014. I have more than 4 years of experience in land use

15 and community planning. planning. My current curriculum vitae is attached and

16 provides a full history of my relevant professional experience.

17 Q. What are youryour current responsibilities at EDREDR??

18 A. In my current position,position, I am responsible for conducting and coordinating

19 projects in the areas of land use and community planning, including for

20 large-scalelarge-scale renewable eneenergyrgy permitting inin New York and Ohio.Ohio.

1 of 2

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Erica(Erica Tauzer)Tauzer)

1 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

3 A. No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you planplan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

11 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring the following EExhibits:xhibits: Exhibit 4,4, Land Use; and

16 Exhibit 27, Socioeconomic Effects.Effects.

17 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

18 your direction and/or supervision?

19 A. Yes.

20 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

21 A. Yes.

2 of 2

Erica Tauzer,Tauzer, AICP 0 II Senior Planner

Erica is a SeniorSenior Planner at EDR with more than 6 years ofof professional experience in land use and community planning.planning. She has worked with communities across the state to plan for change,change, understand existing data, and develop solutions for local and regional needs and lolongtermngterm goals. In her time at EDR, Erica has worked on a variety of projects, including waterfront revitalization plans, socioeconomic analyses, farmland protection plans, public outreach initiatives, environmentalenvironmental resource inventories, grant writingwriting,, and many more. She has worked with a wide range of communities —– from metropolitan areas to rural towns and villages—villages— to suit the needs of her client and their funding entities. As a Community Planner with EDR, Erica'sErica’s responsibilities include project coordination, technical research, writing and report layout for planning reports,reports, grant writing, and land use analysis for large scale renewable energy permitting in New York and OhioOhio,, etc..etc.. She has coordinatedcoordinated and leledd project-related-related communitycommunity outreach meetings/events and has managed the development of outreach materials.materials. She has participatedparticipated actively in project related meetings and has managed the research required for municipal land use regulations,regulations, as well as New York State specific planning programs, such as the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program,Program, Downtown Revitalization Initiative, Hazard Mitigation Plans,Plans, and BrownfieldBrownfield Opportunity Area program. eeducationducation emnInvmentemployment histerhistory Master of Science,Science, Environmental Studies, SStatetate UniversityUniversity of NewNew YorkYork Senior Planner, EnvironmentalEnvironmental Design & Research, Landscape College of Environmental Science & Forestry, 2014. Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C, Syracuse, NY, 20192019-present.-present. Bachelor of ArtsArts,, Biology & Spanish, Albion College, 2010. Planner, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Advanced Studies, Universidad Autrinoma de Yucatan, Departrnent of Advanced Studies, Universidad Autónoma de Yucatán, Department of Architecture, Engineering & Environmental Services, D.P.C, Anthropology, 2009. Anthropology, 2009. Syracuse, NY, 2015-2019.2015-2019. registration / certifications Forestry Educator, Onondaga County Cornell Cooperative Extension, Syracuse, NY,W, 2015-2015.2015-2015. American Institute of CertifiedCertified Planners, American Planning Association Research Coordinator, SStatetate UniversityUniversity of NewNew YorkYork Upstate MedialMedical Certification of Advanced Study in Conflict Resolution, Program for & Ecuador Secretary of Risk Management, Syracuse, NY, 2014-2014- the Advancement of Research on Conflict and Collaboration, 2015. Syracuse University. Research Fellow & Teaching Assistant, SStatetate UniversityUniversity of NewNew YorkYork Community-Based-Based Research Ethics, Northeast Ethics Education College of Environmental Science & Forestry, Courses: Partnership, Brown University. Environmental Dedsion-Making,Decision-Making, Policy & History,History, SyraSyracuse,cuse, NY,W, 2011-2014 professional afiliations 2011-2014 ProjedProject Coordinator, East Side Neighborhood Services & Public Member, American Planning Association Allies, Minneapolis, MN, 2010-2011.2010-2011. Member, Board of Directors, New York State APA —– CNY Section language skills

Fluent in Spanish proprojectject experience

Renewable Energy Permitting in New YorkYork-- Prepared sections analyzing socioeconomic impacts, land use impads,impacts, and conducted public information meetings for submittal to New York State Board on EledricElectric Generation Siting and the Environment under the auspices of ArticleArticle 10 of the Public Service Law, including the fifirstrst such application submitted statewide. Projects indude:include: Mohawk Solar Project, Montgomery County, NY-NY- Conducted socioeconomic and land use analysis and preparedprepared the Exhibit 4, ExhibitExhibit 27 and subsequent socioeconomic report as part of an Article 10 applicationapplication for the fifirstrst solar project to pursue a certificate of environmental compatibility and public need under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law.Law.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.com

Erica Tauzer,Tauzer, AICP Senior Planner

Baron Wind Project, Steuben County, NY-NY- Conducted socioeconomic analysis and ppreparedrepared the Exhibit 27 andand subsequent socioeconomic report as part of an Article 10 application.application. Bluestone Wind Project, Broome County, NY-NY- Conducted socioeconomic analysis and ppreparedrepared socioeconomic report and Exhibit 27 for a proposed 3333 turbine commercial wind power facility and associated offshore transmission line as part of an Article 10 application.application. Galloo Island Wind Project, Jefferson County, NYNY-- Conducted socioeconomic analysis and ppreparedrepared socioeconomic report and Exhibit 27 for a proposed 30 turbine commercial wind power facility and associated offshore transmission line as part of an Article 10 application.application. Cassadaga Wind Project Environmental Review and Permitting, Chautauqua County, NYNY-- - Conducted socioeconomic analysis and ppreparedrepared the socioeconomic report and Exhibit 27 for a proposed 62-turbine-turbine commercial wind power project as part of an Article 10 application.application. Renewable Energy Permitting in OhioOhio-- Prepared socioeconomic reports for applications to the Ohio Power Siting Board for commercial scale wind and solar power projects. In accordance with the Ohio Administrative Code, the certification applications addressed potential prprojectoject--relatedrelated impactsimpacts to ecological resources, soils and geology, groundwater, air quality, aesthetics, agricultural land use, cultural resources, and socioeconomics.socioeconomics. All applications have been accepted as complete after initial submittal. Projects include: Republic Wind Farm,Farm, Seneca and Sandusky Counties, OH-OH- Conducted socioeconomic analysis and prepared the subsequent report for the Certificate Application to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB) for a proposed 20 megawatt (MW) offshore wind project.

Emerson Creek Wind FarmFarm and Transmission Line, Erie and Huron Counties, OH-OH- - Conducted socioeconomic analysis and prepared the subsequent report for the Certificate Application to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).(OPSB).

Timber Road IV Wind Farm and Transmission Line, Paulding County, OH-OH- - Conducted socioeconomic analysis and prepared the subsequent report for the Certificate Application to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).(OPSB). Hillcrest Solar Project, Brown County, OHOH-- - Conducted socioeconomic analysis and prepared thethe subsequent report for the Certificate Application to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).(OPSB). Project Icebreaker, Erie County, Cleveland, OH-OH- - Conducted socioeconomic analysis and prepared the subsequent report for the Certificate Application to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB).(OPSB). Local Waterfront Revitalization Plan,Plan, Town & Village of Cape Vincent, NY,NY, (in progress)progress)-- Completed researchresearch and reporeportrt writing for local planning initiative examining land use and development considerations along land resources adjacent to the St. Lawrence River and Lake Ontario in this northern Jefferson County community. Interfaced with intermunicipal project leadershipleadership to advance priority waterfront ecological, recreational and economic development initiatives within the project area, consistent with the requirements of the NYSDOS Local Waterfront RevitalizationRevitalization Program. Great Lakes Restoration InitiativeInitiative Eurasian Milfoil Control,Control, Town of Alexandria, NY,NY, (in progress)progress)-- Project coordination and management for the Alexandria Milfoil Task Force, a group composed of municipal employees and local volunteers. The GLRI grant was awarded to thethe Town through the US Environmental Protection Agency. Local Waterfront Revitalization Plan,Plan, Town of DeWitt, NY (in progress)-progress)- Completed researchresearch and report writing for local planning initiative examining land use and development considerations along land resources adjacent to the Erie Canal and Butternut Creek in this first-ring-ring suburban community. Interfaced with intermunicipal project leadership to advance priority waterfront ecological, recreational and economic develodevelopmentpment initiatives within the project area, consistent wiwithth the requirements of the NYSDOS Local Waterfront Revitalization Program. 1-81I-81 Viaduct Project,Project, New York State Department of Transportation,Transportation, Syracuse, NY,NY, (in progress)-progress)- Supported community outreach efforteffortss pursuant to federal National Environmental PolicyPolicy Act (NEPA) and New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA). Assisted with planning and execution of meetings ranging from small group discussions to large public open house meetings. Coordinated mailings and email communications and outreachoutreach to individual stakeholders,stakeholders, and researched local issusesissuses.. Represented project at various community events, including a weekly informationinformationalal visitor center. ReZone Syracuse,Syracuse, City of Syracuse, NY-NY- Supported City of Syracuse'sSyracuse’s effort to draft a substantial revision to the municipal zoning code through the NYS Brownfield Opportunity Areas program. Assisted in parcel and district mapping. Update of County Agricultural Economic Development Plan,Plan, BroomeBroome County, Binghamton, NY-NY- Assisted with the development of the County Agricultural Economic Development Plan update in order to provide the Broome County with a strategic and focused guide to promotepromote the sustainable

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Erica Tauzer,Tauzer, AICP Senior Planner

preservation of agriculture lands throughthrough the analysis of lands vulnerable to development and resilient to natural disasters. Funding was provided by a New York State Agriculture and Farmland Protection Program Grant. Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan Update, Broome County, NY-NY- Served asas communitycommunity planner for the Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan that identified key issues facing agriculture in the community, conducted agricultural suitability analysis for parcels which guided the development of recommended strategies for capitalizingcapitalizing on advantages and overcoming barriers, and advanced the viability of farming as an enterprise and a way of life on behalf of Broome County. The purpose of the planning for agriculture is to maintain the quality and accessibility of the sectorssector’s primaprimaryry natural and economic resources. Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan Update, Montgomery County, NY-NY- Served as communitycommunity planner for the Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan that identified key issues facing agriculture in the community, conducted agricultural suitability analysis for parcels which guided the development of recommended strategies for capitalizing on advantagesadvantages and overcoming barriers, and advanced the viability of farming as an enterprise and a way of life on behalf of Montgomery County. Managed weighted geospatial analysis for the identification of priority lands for protection and other implementation efforts. The purpose of the planning for agriculture is to maintain the quality and accessibility of the sectorssector’s primary natural and economic resources. Smart Growth Update and Implementation Project,Project, Town of Marcy, NY-NY- Analyzed land use change and devdevelopmentelopment within this first-ring-ring suburb since the adoption of its existing Master Plan, funded through a grant from the NYSERDA Cleaner Greener Communities program. AssessedAssessed development potential of land throughout residential and commercial areas using ArcGIS,ArcGIS, and recommended methods for protection of rural character in outlying areas. Downtown Revitalization Initiative (DRI), City of Cortland, NY-NY- Assisted with the public presentation of sections of DRI Priority Projects in coordination with the City'sCity’s Local Planning Committee for submittal to New York State as part of $10 million downtown revitalization grant awarded to the City. Downtown Revitalization Initiative (DRI), City of Elmira, NY-NY- Assisted with the preparation of sections of DRI Final Report on Priority Projects in coordination with the City'sCity’s Local Planning Committee for submittal to New York State as part of $10 million downtown revitalizationrevitalization grant awarded to the City. Downtown Revitalization Initiative (DRI), City of Saranac Lake, NY-NY- Assisted with the public presentation of sections of DRI Final Report on Priority Projects in coordination with the City'sCity’s Local Planning Committee for submittal to New York State as part of $10 mmillionillion downtown revitalization grant awarded to the City. Agricultural Enhancement Project, Ontario County, NY-NY- Conducted research the county’scounty's agricultural development and farmland protection plan, funded through a Farmland Protection Planning grant from NYS Department of Agriculture & Markets. Drafted and implemented a public involvement initiative including focus group discussions, community events, public meetings, and social media campaign. Inventoried existing conditconditionsions of the agricultural sector throughout Ontario County, including production statistics, labor and economic indicators, identification of essential supportsupport businesses, and a summary of local environmental management programs. Managed weighted geospatial analysis for the identification of priority lands for protection and other implementation efforts. Multiple Dwellings Study, Town of Henrietta, NY-NY- Provided expertise related to geographic analysis of existing zoning districts and regulations and possible zoning amendments related to smart growth and mixed-use-use dwellings within the Town of Henrietta. Grant writingwriting-- Supported communities in seeking grants for public funds through New York State and federal sources. Specific grant experience with the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative (USEPA), Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (NYSDOS), NYSDEC Invasive Species Control and Response grants. Watershed ManagementManagement Plan,Plan, (2015),(2015), Owasco Lake, Cayuga County, NY-NY- Designed and implemented a survey on visitor goals, concerns and activities regarding Owasco Lake, while conducting outreach and education about the Owasco Lake Watershed Management Planning process. EDREDR is designing and facilitating a community outreach plan with the goal of engaging local residents, agricultural producers and educators around shared visions, goals and concerns relating to the future of the Owasco Lake Watershed, as part of the Owasco Lake Watershed Management Plan. Transit Study Phase 1 (on behalf of the Central New York Regional Transportation Authority), Syracuse Metropolitan Regional Transportation Authority, Syracuse, NY-NY- AssistedAssisted the EDR team responsible for providing locally-based-based community planning and community outreach/ engagementengagement services, with a team of national consultant, to advance recommendations identified in the Syracuse Transit Study Analysis to pursue a higher-intensity-intensity transit services along the DestinyUSA/Regional Transportation Center to Syracuse University and James Street/South Avenue corridors. Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP),(LWRP), NYS Department of StateState (NYSDOS), Town of Alexandria & Village of Alexandria Bay,Bay, NY- Conducted background research and grant writing needed for the continuation of tasks outlinedoutlined by the LWRP process, specifically sidewalk renovations, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 3 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Erica Tauzer,Tauzer, AICP Senior Planner

dock improvements and streetscaping enhancements. Through the waterfront revitalization program the village and town, with assistanceassistance from EDR, has identified a dearclear vision with supporting strategiesstrategies to revitalize the waterfront by rehabilitating historic structures, improving waterfront resources. Cornell Cooperative Extension-Extension- Prior to EDR-EDR- Served as a Forestry Educator and mmanagedanaged tree planting database and site selection for urban tree plantings for the City of Syracuse as part of the Save the Rain program. Coordinated neighborhood volunteer tree planting and special events with the Onondaga Earth Corps. Promoted urban forestryforestry maintenance through educational trainings with CommuniTree Stewards. SUNY Upstate Medical University & Ecuador Secretary of Risk Management-Management- Prior to EDR,EDR, Developed and implemented research on flfloodingooding response vulnerability and capacity. Coordinated project in collaboration with local, national and international stakeholders related to flfloodood response. Supervised team of students, professors and local authorities to implement research methods. SUNY Upstate Medical University & U.S. Department of Defense-Defense- Prior to EDR,EDR, Led local capacity training efforts related to geographic information systems in epidemiological studies. Coordinated two 50-person-person GIS workshops and learning networks for public health practitioners in Machala and Guayaquil, Ecuador. Provided field and logistical support for cholera global surveillance project. SUNY ESF-ESF- Prior to EDR,EDR, Served as a Research Fellow in partnership with the NYS Department of Conservation.Conservation. Utilized qualitative and quantitative analysis with questionnaires and interview data to inform the Natural Resources Damages Assessment and Restoration process for Ononaga Lake and its Watershed.Watershed. TopicsTopics included: integrative policy analysis, procedural justice, place attachment, and ecological restoration. Program for Advanced of Research on Conflict & Collaboration-Collaboration- Prior to EDR,EDR, Co-facilitated-facilitated Onondaga Lake Watershed Community Forums on decisions related to future restoration visions. Mid-Atlantic-Atlantic Regional Ocean Council (MARCO)-(MARCO)- Prior to EDR,EDR, Consultant-Consultant- Designed adaptive management and stakeholder outreach plan for coastal climateclimate change adaptation (that included off-shore-shore wind development). East Side Neighborhood Services & Public Allies, Minneapolis, MN-MN- Prior to EDR,EDR, Initiated and implemented two intergenerational environmental programs and community vegetable gardens. DevelopedDeveloped website, co-planned-planned three fundraiser events, prepared outreach materials, supervised intern. Co- developed an asset-based-based community development afterschool program in collaboration with Boys & Girls Club. NYS Department of Environmental Conservation-Conservation- PriorPrior to EDR,EDR, Implemented face to face surveys of recreational boating and fishing use at Onondaga Lake. Supervised team of four graduate and four undergraduate students.

U.S. Institute of Environmental Conflict Resolution-Resolution- Prior to EDR,EDR, Served as a Udall ScholarScholar Intern.Intern. Supported in the development and implementation of trainings on Government-to-to-Government-Government consultation. Assisted with environmental mediator hiring processes, wrote case briefings on collaborative planning processes for public lands and fulfilled administradministrativeative duties related to stakeholder collaborative processes and conference planning. Michigan Student Sustainability Coalition-Coalition- Prior to EDR,EDR, Served as the Albion College Representative and ororganizedganized three statewide press events to promote awareness on clclimateimate change and energy policy in Michigan.

National Wildlife Federation,Federation, Albion, Ml-MI- Prior to EDR,EDR, Prepared and presented greenhouse gas inventory calculating the carbon emissions at Albion College. Co-foundedCo-founded and facilitated City-wideCity-wide Albion Sustainability Council devoted to promoting sustainable practices. Presented results at two student research symposiums at Albion College. Paso Pacifico,Pacífico, Southwestern Nicaragua-Nicaragua- Prior to EDR,EDR, Assisted with work relating to community-based-based agriculture, cooperativelycooperatively-structured-structured business development and sea turtle conservation in Southwestern Nicaragua. Provided translation services to United Nations EnvironmentalEnvironmental Programme and USAID representatives Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies,Studies, National Science Foundation,Foundation, Baltimore, MD-MD- Prior to EDR,EDR, Conducted and designed independent research on the urban ecology of vacant lots in Baltimore to determine the role of vacant lots in habitat creation and ecological resiliency. Presented information at the annual conference for the Baltimore Ecosystem Study, a collaboration between academic researchers, nonprofits and the City of Baltimore Parks Department. ppublicationsublications

Tauzer, E.C. (2014) An Integrative Analysis of Place and Participation: Onondaga Lake, NY. Summary Report for NY Department of Environmental Conservation and all research participantsparticipants and interestedinterested stakeholders. Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 4 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Erica Tauzer,Tauzer, AICP Senior Planner

Johnson, A. L., TauzerTauzer,, E. C., Swan, C. M. (2014), Human legacieslegacies differentially organize functional and phylogenetic diversity of urban herbaceous plant communities at multiple spatial scales. Applied Vegetation Science.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 5 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

JANE E. RICE

DIRECTOR OF PLANNING

ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN & RESEARCH, LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, D.P.C.

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Jane(Jane E. Rice)Rice)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Jane E. Rice,Rice, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture,Architecture,

3 Engineering and Environmental Services, D.P.C. ("EDR"), (“EDR”), 217

4 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York 13202.13202.

5 Q. What is your current position?

6 A. PPrincipal,rincipal, Director of Planning.Planning.

7 Q. How long have you been employed with EDREDR??

8 A. I have been employed with EDR sincesince 2005.2005.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science from Creighton

12 University in 1981 and a Juris Doctor from Albany Law School in 1986.1986. I

13 also receivereceivedd a Master of LLandscapeandscape Architecture from the State

14 University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry

15 in 1995.1995. I have over 25 years of experience in project management,

16 community and land use planning, smart growth management and

17 analysis,analysis, zoning, zoning, commcommunityunity engagement and outreach, economic

18 development, and redevelopment/revitalization planning. My current

19 curriculum vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant

20 professional experience.

21

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Jane(Jane E. Rice)Rice)

1 Q. What are your current responsiresponsibilitiesbilities at EDREDR??

2 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for managing EDR’sEDR's planning

3 professionals who coordinate with in-house in-house cultural resources

4 management and historic preservation specialists, graphic artists,

5 geographic information systems analysts, analysts, regulregulatoryatory complcomplianceiance

6 specialists, and landscape architects to develop comprehensive planning

7 initiatives.initiatives. I oversee EDR’sEDR's planning practice, which consists of various

8 community--centeredcentered planning initiatives that include comprehensive

9 plans, waterfront revitalizationrevitalization planning and design, brownfield

10 redevelopmentredevelopment planning, developing downtown and neighborhood

11 revitalization strategies, zoning and land use regulations, and agriculture

12 and farmland protection plans. A small portion of our planning work alsoalso

13 includesincludes coordinating or conducting socioeconomicsocioeconomic analyses.

14 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

15 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

16 A. Yes.Yes. I provided testimony for the CassadagaCassadaga Wind Project, Galloo IslaIslandnd

17 Wind Project, Bluestone Wind Project, and the Baron Winds Project.

18 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

19 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

20 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Jane(Jane E. Rice)Rice)

1 A. Yes.Yes. I servedserved as an expert witness before the Ohio Power Siting Board for

2 the Icebreaker Offshore Wind Facility regarding the use of the JEDI

3 model as a tool to assess the economic impacts of utility --scalescale wind

4 energy facilities.

5 Q. What is the purpose of your testimonytestimony in this proceeding?

6 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

7 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

8 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generatinggenerating facility in

9 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

10 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

11 sponsoring?sponsoring?

12 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 4,4, Land Use; Use; and

13 Exhibit 27,27, SociSocioeconomicoeconomic EffectsEffects..

14 Q. Were these these portions portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

15 your direction and/or supervision?

16 A. Yes.

17 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

18 A. Yes.

3 of 3

Jane E. Rice, JD, Principal Director of Planning

Jane is a Principal and Director of Planning services at EDR. She is also a certified planner and licensed attorney with more than 25 years of professional experience in project management, community and land use planning, smart growth management and analysis, zoning, community engagement and outreach, economic development, and redevelopment/redevelopment / revitalization planning. She leads an in-housein-house team of planning professionals who coordinate with in-housein-house cultural resources management and historic preservation specialists,specialists, graphic artists, geographic information systems analysts, regulatory compliance specialists, and landscape architects to develop comprehensive planning initiatives. Jane earned a Master of Landscape Architecture degree from the State University ColleCollegege of Environmental Science & Forestry, a Juris Doctor from Albany Law School, and a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science degree from Creighton University. Jane is also a sought-sought- after lecturer in topics related to Sustainable Land Use Planning & Design, Environmental Integrity, Form-Based-Based Zoning Code, Community Character, and Community Engagement. She is currently a member of the American Planning Association (APA), New York State Chapter of the APA Board of Directors, New York Planning Federation, and NewNew York State Bar Association; and has also served as Chair of the Village of Fayetteville Planning Board for more than two decades. educationeducation registration I/ certifications

Master of Landscape Architecture,Architecture, State UnUniversity iversity of New York College of American Planning AssociationAssociation member (APA)(APA) Environmental Sciences and Forestry, Syracuse, NY, 1996. Juris Doctor Juris Dolor,Doctor, Creighton University School of Law,Law, Omaha, NE,NE, 1982-1983,1982-1983, employment history Albany Law School, Albany, NY, 19841984-1985.-1985. Principal, Director of Planning, Senior Planner, Environmental Design & Bachelor of Arts nin Political Science, CreigCreightonhton University, Omaha, NE, Research, Landscape Architecture and Engineering and Environmental 1981. 1981. Resources, D.P.C, Syracuse, NY, 20142014-present.-present. professional affiliations SenbrSenior Planner, Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture and Engineering and Environmental Resources, D.P.C, Vice President, Onondaga County Planning Federation Board Syracuse & Rochester, New York, 2005-2014.2005-2014. Chairperson, Village of Fayetteville Planning Board Land Use Planner, Independent Consultant, Fayetteville, NY,NY, 2004-2004- 2005. Member, American Planning Association Land Use Planner, Clough Harbour & Associates LLP, Syracuse, NY, Member, Board of Directors, New York State APA—APA – CNY Section 1997-2004.1997-2004. Attorney at Law, Independent Consultant,Consultant Fayetteville,Fayetteville, NY,NY, 19911991-1994.-1994.

Attorney at Law, Scolaro Law Firm, Syracuse, NY, 19871987-1991.-1991.

proprojectject experience

Lakeshore Enhancement Project,Project, Onondaga Lake, Town of Geddes, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Directed team that created site plans and designs, and conducted extensive community outreach and engagement activities, for adaptive reuse and ecological restoration of the 4,000 acres of the former Allied Corporation property (now owned by Honeywell Corporation).Corporation). The purpose of this project is to remediate and reuse the Super Fund site in a more environmentally sensitive manner.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 1 www.edrdpc.com

Jane E. Rice, JD, Principal Director of Planning

Transit Study Phase 1 (SMART 1) on behalf of the CNY Regional Transportation Authority,Authority, Syracuse Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed team providing community planning services, that include outreach and engagement activities to a team of national consultant to advance recommendations identified in the Syracuse Transit Analysis to pursue a higher-intensity-intensity transit services along the Destiny/Regional Transportation Center to Syracuse University and James Street/South Avenue corridors. Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP),(LWRP), NYSDOS,NYSDOS, Town & Village of Clayton Jefferson County, NY-NY- Directed team that developed the LWRP, conducted extensive community outreach and engagement activities, evaluated site and designed segments of the new RiverWalkRiverWalk waterfront connection and access to the St. Lawrence River. The Riverwalk,Riverwalk, (Phase 2-2- NYSDOS 1/ Phase 33-- NYSDOT I/ LAFA Region 3),3), NYSDOTNYSDOT,, Village of Clayton, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Directed site planning and design services, that include community outreach and engagement activities in support of Phase 2 of the Riverwalk Project.Project. Currently reresponsiblesponsible for coordinating design of best options to support Phase 3 implementation. Hiawatha Boulevard-Lodi-Lodi Street Brownfield Opportunity Area Program (BOA),(BOA), NYSDOS, City of Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed team (with Sasaki Associates) that developed a Nomination Study that incorporates a 136-acre-acre area with 11 potential brownfield properties. This is a main artery to a vital, heavily traveled section of Syracuse. It is also an area that is suffering from depdepressedressed commercial properties and deteriorating housing stock, both of which are intermixed with active businesses. Managed team that developed the BOA, conducted extensive community outreach and engagementengagement activities, evaluated site and designed visionary outcomes for this a low-incomelow-income neighborhood. Hiawatha Boulevard-Lodi-Lodi Street Brownfield Opportunity Area Program, City of Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed the team that served as the Lead Consultant in association with Sasaki Associates to create a Nomination Study for the Hiawatha Boulevard/Lodi Street Brownfield Opportunity Area within the City of Syracuse. This BOA incorporates a 136-acre-acre area with approximately 11 potential brownfield properties. The area is a main artery to a vital, heavily traveled section of Syracuse. It is also an area that is suffering from depressed commercial properties and deteriorating housing stock, both of which are intermixed with active businesses. This BOA presents strategic opportunities to stimulate economic development and communcommunityity revitalization. It is in close proximity to the Carousel Center, a regional retail mall which has recently expanded, and that attracts millions of visitors each year, providing a critical mass of people and vehicles passing through the Hiawatha BoulevardBoulevard corridor. The project area also serves as a major transportation route to access the Alliance Bank Stadium, the home field of the Chiefs, which averages half a million ticket sales per year. It is also situated adjacent to thethe Central New York Regional Market, which houses hundreds of stands and attracts more than a million visitors annually, as well as the Regional TransportationTransportation Center. As a result, this BOA provides a significant opportunity for the successful redevelopment of vacant, underutilized and blighted properties located in an area with very high visibility. (2011-2013)(2011-2013) Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP),(LWRP), NYSDONYSDOS,S, City of Ogdensburg,Ogdensburg, St. Lawrence County, NY-NY- Directed team that developed an amendment to the LWRP, conducted extensive community outreach and engagement activities, designed conceptual land use patternpatterns,s, and assisted the City in identifying policies and procedures that will implement the LWRP through a seriesseries of priority projects for improving waterfront connections and economic development opportunities. Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP),(LWRP), NYSDOS,NYSDOS, Town of Alexandra & Village of Alexandria Bay,Bay, Jefferson County, NYNY-- Directed team that identified and designed visionary outcomes for revitalization of the St. Lawrence River waterfront. Assisted in identifying opportunitieopportunitiess for waterfront use and development, and to adopt appropriate policies and implementation strategies. Ongoing development projectsprojects include improvement to the existing Scenic View Park and creation of a new river walk along the River. Conducted extensive community outreach and engagement actiactivities.vities. 1-81I-81 Viaduct-Viaduct- Step 2 Scoping & Preliminary Design Project,Project, NYSDOT,NYSDOT, City of Syracuse, NY-NY- CoordinatedCoordinated extensive community outreach and engagement activities as a member of the Parsons Team to determine design of best options for redevelopment of this major transportationtransportation hub project located close to DowntownDowntown and University Hill area. LocalLocal Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP),(LWRP), NYSDOS, Village of Sackets Harbor, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Directed team that developed the LWRP, conducted extensive community outreach and engagement activities, evaluated site and designed visionary outcomes. This effort included analyzing opportunities and constraints in the Village, establishing a framework of policipolicieses to protect and enhance the resources of the Village and connections to the St. Lawrence River, and by developing proposals to capitalize on the opportunities of the waterfront within the contextcontext of established policies. East Main Street Marketing DistrictDistrict Plan, Rochester, NY (LAFA Region 4),4), NYSDOT, City of Rochester, NY-NY- Directed site planning services, that include community outreach and engagement services, to a team of national and locallocal consultants to identify multi-modal-modal circulation, access and parkingparking improvements along with recommendations for land use development, streetscape enhancements, and community branding, as well asas strategies to promote housing opportunities in the area. Niagara Gorge RIM Ecological Restoration Plan (Robert Moses ParkwayParkway Removal Study),Study), City of Niagara Falls, NY-NY- Directed team that quantified economic, environmental, and social costs and benefits of roadway removal and natural resource restoration proposal, and that analyzed various potential impacts including traffic distribution, active transportation, buffering, naturalnaturalization,ization, environmental quality, and local economic development opportunities. American Society of Landscape Architects Merit Award for Planning

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 2 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Jane E. Rice, JD, Principal Director of Planning

Agricultural Enhancement Plans, Tioga,Tioga, Broome and Ontario County, NY-NY- Directed public participation and outreachoutreach activities, researching countywide agricultural land uses, and agricultural economic concerns, advising county on analysis of priority lands to be protected, andand drafting recommendations to drive sustainable growth consistent with industry and environmentalenvironmental best practices, and NYSDAM guidelines. Niagara Falls Robert Moses Parkway Removal-Removal- Step 2 Scoping & Preliminary Design Project,Project, NYSDOTINYSOPRHP,NYSDOT/NYSOPRHP, Niagara Falls, NY-NY- Directed extensive community outreach and engagement activities, and landscape design to determine and depict best options, for redevelopmentredevelopment of the northern section of this major transportation corridor project. Robert Moses Parkway North Segment Step 2 Scoping & Preliminary Design Project,Project, Niagara Falls, NY-NY- Directed the restoration of the Niagara Gorge Rim along the upper Niagara River will be transformative for thethe City of Niagara Falls. A one-mile-mile stretch of the 50-year-year old, four-lane-lane Robert Moses Parkway fromfrom Main Street in the City of Niagara Falls to its intersection with Findlay Drive will be removed to allow for a re-greening-greening of the park with multi-use-use trails, improved scenic overlooks, and other park amenities. Whirlpool Street will be improved as a comcompleteplete street reconnecting the neighborhoods to the park. As one of the subconsultants on the consulting team EDR worked on developing three alternative concepts from which the preferredpreferred concept was selected, as well as simulations to illustrate the proposeproposedd gateways, streetscape improvements, and other scenic overlooks. We participated in community outreach, engaging the community throughout the process, and provided an assessment of potential impacts on ecological resources, incluincludingding threatened and endangeredendangered species. Girl Scouts Feasibility Study & Master Plan, Tomkins County, Ithaca, NY-NY- Directed a campus and facilities master plan as developed for all 65 acres of Camp Comstock. This master planning process included, site visits, stakeholder meetings, research on local development regulations, and historic and cultural resources relevant to the camp. The effort included improvements to existing facilities as well as new facilities andand uses intended to generate new and sustainable revenues for the Girl Scouts. While developing the master plan we continuously discussed operational and programming issues / needs / preferences so that all aspects are aligned with the recommendations for future improvements and new development. The final Master Plan Report includes the initial feasibility study for all four Girl Scout Camps, the recommendation to initially invest in Camp Comstock for facilityfacility improvements as well program development, and the Master Plan with planning and design details on connectivityconnectivity throughout the main camp, facility improvements, new development and minor but critically important amenities. Plan for Reconnecting the Erie Canal Gateway,Gateway, Town of DeWitt,DeWitt, Onondaga County, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team that was collaborating with the town ofof DeWittDeWitt to prepare a plan for the revitalization of the waterfront along the NYS Canal System. The plan is proposed to include: visioningvisioning for the historic canal corridor, assessment of development patterns, identification of land and water use controls, and development of revitalization policies and implementation strategies. Work will include planning for a segment of the canal way trail that would closedose the gap between thethe Town of Dewitt and the Town of Camillus. Agricultural & Farmland ProtectionProtection Plan,Plan, Ontario County,County, NY-NY- DirectedDirected the EDR team that was collaborating with Ontario County in the development of their Enhancement Plan. EDR is designing and facilitating a community outreach plan with the goal of engaging local farmers, agricultural producers, and stakeholders in the local agricultural business, and facilitated several focus group meetings. With the community’scommunity's direct input,input, and through targeted analysis, we will make recommendations that touch upon local land use regulations, regionalregional policies in support of agricultural producers and businesses, marketing, economic development, and implementation procedures for the Agricultural Enhancement Plan. Agricultural & Farmland Protection Plan,Plan, Tioga County,County, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team that collaboratedcollaborated with Tioga County in the development of their Agriculture and Farmland Protection Plan. We designed and facilitated a community outreach plan with the goal of engaging locallocal farmers, agricultural producers, and stakeholders in the local agriculturalagricultural business. EDR developed, facilitated, and analyzed a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats) exercise with farmers throughout the county, focusing on alternative energy opportunities, commerce and marketing,marketing, and public policy. With the community’scommunity's direct input, and through targeted analysis, our findings and recommendations touched upon local land use regulatregulations,ions, regional policies in support of agricultural producers and businesses, marketing, economic development, and implementation proceduresprocedures for the Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan. Skunk City Neighborhood Master Plan,Plan, Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team that worked inin collaboration with staff from the Department of Neighborhood and Business Development and neighborhood advocates, which drafted the Skunk City Neighborhood Master Plan for the City of Syracuse in 2012. Located on the city’scity's west side, between Strathmore,Strathmore, Tipp Hill, and the Near Westside, Skunk City is a neighborhood where relatively modest public investments could have an outsized impact on residents'residents’ quality of life. Our work within the neighborhood sought to increaseincrease neighborhood safety, stabilize propropertyperty values, encourage new investment, reutilize abandoned properties, and improve pedestrian connectivity within and around the neighborhood. The principal intent of the Skunk City Neighborhood Master Plan is to make strategic and incremental improvemenimprovementsts where such actions could have a positive influence on the environmental, economic, and social fabric of the community. Sackets Harbor Zoning,Zoning, Sackets Harbor, Jefferson County, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team that was retained along with Joel Russell, Esq. toto assist the Village of Sackets Harbor in rewriting their zoning regulations to foster the village'svillage’s growth with a sensitivity towards its cultural resources and its traditional village core and rural edge. EDR completed a community buildout visualization to assist villagers envision its future growth under the then-existing-existing zoning regulations. The potential loss of natural and cultural resources prompted the village to undertake the development of a new hybrid zoning code that applies

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 3 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Jane E. Rice, JD, Principal Director of Planning

a form-based-based structure.structure. The new zoning law provides development regulations that address site layout, architectural treatments, and landscape standardsstandards that preserve the natural resources within the community. The new zoning law utilizes graphics and tables to provide clarityclarity and improve readability. Carrier Dome Rainwater Harvesting,Harvesting, Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team that designed and developed interpretive materials. In the spirit of the Onondaga County Save the Rain program and with the goal of increasing its sustainable practices, Syracuse University embraced the concept of capturing and using the rainwater that falls on the roof of the Carrier Dome. With the RainwaterRainwater Harvesting System enough water is captured to flflushush half the Dome'sDome’s toilets and urinals during major Dome events. The Rain Water Harvesting System consists of two exterior 25,000-gallon-gallon storage tanks, and two interior 4,500 gallon tanks that will hold rainwaterrainwater captured from approximately one third of the Carrier Dome'sDome’s roof. Teamed with a local engineering firm, and two Syracuse University graphic design students, EDR facilitated several design workshops with students and faculty to design, select,select, and develop a logo for the Carrier Dome Rain Harvesting System as well as wall murals and a 3D model/video. EDR facilitated the design of interior interpretiveinterpretive wall murals, exterior signage, and an interpretive video about the rainwater harvesting process as wellwell benefits derived from using such a system. Oswego Brownfield Opportunity Area Program,Program, Oswego County, NY-NY- Directed the team that provided planning and design services to identify what is needed to achieve a coherent and integrated urban development proprogramgram that preserves and protects the best of what exists and incorporates new development in a compatible manner. The design will build on existing infrastructure, incorporate existing historic fabric wherewhere appropriate, and identify appropriate patterns andand forms for new development. EDR has also been charged with identifying what is necessary to create a memorable place through development of an urban design concept that incorporates a clear organization of sites, streets and open space. (2010-2012)(2010-2012) FingerFinger Lakes Sustainability Plan-Plan- Directed the team charged with development of indicators of sustainability in the agricultural and forestry sectors of a 9- county region in Western New York. Facilitated outreach initiatives and analyzed strategies and targets for sustainable development. Comprehensive Plan Update,Update, Town of Canandaigua, NY-NY- Directed the team that researched existing conditions, and analyzed economic and demographic changes over time. Worked with local advisory committee to craft goals and recommended actions for plan implemenimplementation.tation. Managed team that development of Natural Resources InventoryInventory for examination of development proposals by local Environmental Conservation Board. Zoning Amendments-Amendments- Directed the team thatthat researched local land use patterns and development trends, and identification of options for land protection and development strategies. Worked with Town staff and board members to shape improve existing conservation subdivision ordinanceordinance Underground RailroadRailroad Heritage Area Management Plan (HAMP),(HAMP), City of Niagara Falls, NY-NY- Directed the team that researched existing economic and demographic conditions within Niagara County. Managed team that researched history of Underground Railroad that helped shape management strategies. The HAMP was authorized under Section 35.05 of the New York StateState Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation Law to identify and encourage heritage tourism opportunities related to Underground Railroad in the vicinity of Niagara Falls District. Three Rivers Point Waterfront Access Study,Study, Syracuse Metropolitan TransportationTransportation Council,Council, Town of Clay, NY-NY- Directed the team that provided planning and design services to determine best use for 75 acres of prime waterfront land located at the intersection of the Oswego,Oswego, Seneca and Oneida Rivers. The property is an abandoned oil transfer station. In Phase 1, a conceptual master plan was developed to depict a mixed--useuse development. The plan also recommended public space and access to the water, along with a sensitive approach to the historic and cultural valuesvalues of the Town and the site. As a result, the Town received funding to mitigate the Brownfield and demolish deteriorated buildings to make the site more attractiveattractive to investment. Local Waterfront Revitalization Plan (LWRP), Town of DeWitt, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team that was collaborating with the town of DeWitt to prepare a plan for the revitalization of the waterfront along the NYS Canal System. The plan is proposed to include: visioning for the historic canal corridor, assessment of development patterns, identification of land and water use controls, and development of revitalization policies and implementation strategies. Work will include planning for a segment of the canal way trail that would close the gap between the Town of Dewitt and the Town of Camillus.Camillus. ReZone Syracuse,Syracuse, City of Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed EDR team assigned to support a nationally-recognized-recognized land use consulting firm to draft a new zoning code for the City of Syracuse. Project objectives include: (1) ensure the new ordinance and map implement the recommendationrecommendationss of the Comprehensive Plan 2040, including the Syracuse Land Use & Development Plan 2040; (2) transition from the current use-focused,-focused, Euclidian zoning ordinance to an updated ordinance that incorporates principles of Form Based Codes, and Smart Growth; (3) develop and/or imprimprovingoving standards regulating urban design, urban agriculture, lighting, signage, landscaping, parking, site design, infill development, and vacant land management; (4) promote and facilitate historic preservation; (5) develop sustainable development provisioprovisionsns regarding: climate adaptation, renewable energy infrastructure, green building standards, and green infrastructure; (6) increase protection of natural resources; (7) streamline the development review process by creating more predictable zoning regulations;regulations; (8) update the format and structure of the zoning ordinance to be user-friendlyuser-friendly and include graphics and illustrations; (9) remove inconsistencies, outdated language, and reducing the complexity of the zoning ordinance; (10) facilitate increased public awareness of, and participation in zoning reviewsreviews and processes; and (11) increase ways to use technology to provide and receive information from the public. EDR is leading thethe update of the zoning map, participating in public engagement and education, imimplementingplementing character area recommendations noted in the municipal land use plan, and drafting the landscape standards section of the new ordinance. Syracuse Metropolitan Transportation Authority,Authority, Transit Study Phase I1 (SMART 1) (on behalf of the Central RegionalRegional Transportation Authority), Syracuse, NY-NY- Directed EDR team assigned to provide community planning services, that include outreach and engagement activities to a team of national

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 4 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Jane E. Rice, JD, Principal Director of Planning

consultant to advance recommendations identified in the Syracuse TransitTransit Analysis to pursue a higher--intensityintensity transit services along the Destiny/Regional Transportation Center to Syracuse University and James Street/South Avenue corridors. Lakefront Regulating Plan & Zoning Code Revisions, City of Syracuse, NY-NY- Managed and wworkedorked alongside the EDR team assigned to ensure that improvements to the 1,200‐-acreacre Onondaga Lakefront would be developed using the principles of New Urbanism. EDR applied Form‐-BasedBased Code techniques to revise the zoning for this area. The new code emphasizedemphasized the character of the streets and other public spaces, and a mixture of land uses including retail, office, technology, light industry, waterfront recreation, and residential. EDR provided extensive community outreach. Hybrid code was adopted and integratedintegrated into the existing zoning code Multiple Dwellings Study, Town of Henrietta, NY-NY- DirectedDirected EDR team assigned to provide planning expertise related to an in-depthin-depth review and analysis of existing land use plans and regulations, and to develop proposed zoning amendments related to multiple dwellings and other land uses within the Town of Henrietta.Henrietta. Empire State Development, Downtown Revitalization Plans,Plans, Round 1-1- Oversaw EDR team that assisted with design (focusing on waterfront improvements) for City of Jamestown, and with zoning for the City of Oswego and Elmira. Round 2 —– Oversaw EDR team thatthat assisted with design (focusing on waterfront improvements) for City of Hudson, and with zoning and permitting for the City of Cortland. New York Rising Community Reconstruction Plan,Plan, Herkimer,Herkimer, Madison, & Oneida County,County, NY-NY- Directed thethe New York Rising CommunityCommunity Reconstruction Program that was established bytheby the New York State Department of State in the wake of several severe weather events including Hurricanes Sandy and Irene, Tropical Storm Lee, and the devastating flfloodsoods of 2013. The program leverages state investments to assist with reconstruction projects directed toward damaged infrastructure, as well as other projects that are intendintendeded to mitigate against future risks and increase their resiliency in the face of future storm events. As a member of the consulting team EDR assisted with community outreach throughout Madison, Oneida, and Herkimer Counties, where back-to-backback-to-back storms flfloodedooded entire communities twice within three days —– washing out roads, bridges, utilities, and other infrastructure.infrastructure. The New York Rising Countywide Resiliency Plan (for each county) represents the first steps that the county and state will take towardtoward implementing priority projects, and ultimately creating a more resilient Madison, Oneida, and Herkimer County. Governor'sGovernor’s Office of Storm Recovery, Village of Waterfront Resiliency Program, NY-NY- Directed EDR to provide community engagement services to focus stakeholders in moving community planning and capacity building, economic development, health and social services,services, housing, infrastructure, natural and cultural resource recovery projects, programs, and actions forward under the NYRCR Planning Program. Onondaga County Multi-Jurisdictional-Jurisdictional Hazard Mitigation Plan Update-Update- Oversaw EDREDR team providing community outreach and engagement services. The purpose of this project is to provide consultant services to update the Plan for Onondaga County and 35 participating municipalitiesmunicipalities and jurisdictions.jurisdictions. The final plan must also meet Federal and State requirements and be approveapprovedd by the Federal Emergency Management Agency and the NYS Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Services. Genesee Transportation Council, Ontario Lake Parkway Transportation Alternatives Feasibility Study, Towns of Kendall & Carlton, Orleans County, NY-NY- ManagedManaged land use planning and design, needs assessment, and community engagement services to support the determination of the feasibilityfeasibility of re-purposing,-purposing, in whole or part, the eastbound and/or westbound lanes of approximately 12.7-miles-miles of Lake Ontario State Parkway. The deteriorating condition of the westernmost portion of the Parkway, has raised legitimate concerns about the long-termlong-term viability of its continued operation as a divided, four-lane-lane highway. The proposed project will investigate whether it is financially feasible to re-purpose-purpose or decommission the eastbound and westbound lanes or portions thereof, while still providing an appropriate facility for vehicle demand. Old Erie Canal Corridor Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP), NYSDOS, Madison County, NY-NY- Directed the EDR team collaborating with Madison County to prepare a plan for reimaging the Old Erie Canal Corridor. The plan is proposed to include: visioning for thethe historic canal corridor, assessment of development patterns,patterns, identification of land and water use controls, and development of revitalization policies and implementation strategies. Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Update, NYSDOS, City of Binghamton, Broome County, NYNY-- Directed the EDR team collaborating with the City of Binghamton to update the LWRP to reflect current local conditions including significant new developmedevelopment,nt, and to include recommendations and projects that build greater community resilience to natural hazards and resurrect housing and businesses damaged by recentrecent flfloodingooding events. An approved LWRP will guide sustainable development, increase utilization of the waterfront, and promote economic development to improve the overall quality of life for residents and visitors. This project also includes preparation of National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) CommuniCommunityty Rating System for the City, a program that recogrecognizesnizes community flfloodplainoodplain management activities that exceed the minimum NFIP requirements and is necessary to occur as part of any waterfront management plan. publications / presentationspreqpnthtinng Presenter, Onondaga County Planning Federation, McIntyre Commons: A Case Study in Brownfield Redevelopment, Community Character, and EnvironmentalEnvironmental Integrity, March 5, 2015 Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 5 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

Jane E. Rice, JD, Principal Director of Planning

Presenter, Onondaga County Planning Federation, Form-Based-Based Zoning: A CreativeCreative Approach, March 13, 2014 Presenter, Onondaga County Planning Federation,Federation, Sustainable Land Use Planning & Resource ConservationConservation Strategies, March 14, 2013 Panelist, GreeningUSA Green Bag Lunch Series, Sustainable Land Use Planning & Resource Conservation Strategies, 2013. Presenter, Sustainable Community Planning, APA/ASLAAPA/ASLA Upstate NY Chapters Joint-Conference,-Conference, Utica NY, September 2011. Presenter, Land Use Planning Workshop, The Benefits of Sustainable Community Planning & Design, Jefferson Community College CenterCenter for Community Studies, 2011. Land Use Training Workshop for Herkimer-Oneida-Oneida Counties, Herkimer--OneidaOneida Counties ComprehensiveComprehensive Planning Program, 2010. Land Use Planning Workshop for Jefferson County, 2009. Annual Planning Symposium for the Onondaga County Planning Federation, Syracuse, NY, 2008 and 2009.

Environmental Design & Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, & Environmental Services, D.P.C. 6 www.edrdpc.comwww.eutupu.uu.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

SCOTT L. MCDONALD

LEAD/SENIOR BUSBUSINESSINESS DEVELOPER

AVANGRID RENEWABLES,RENEWABLES, LLC

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Scott(Scott L. McDonald)McDonald)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Scott L. McDonald, Avangrid Renewables,Renewables, LLCLLC,, 7650 North State Street,

3 Suite 1, Lowville, New York 13367.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Lead/Senior Business Developer.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Avangrid Renewables?Renewables?

7 A. I have been employed with Avangrid Renewables, Renewables, or a predecessor, predecessor, fforor

8 overover 7 years.years.

9 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

10 experience.experience.

11 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Environmental Science from Marist

12 College in 1976. I also received a Bachelor of Science in Mechanical

13 Engineering from the State University of New York at Buffalo in 1989. I

14 have more than 25 years of experience in renewable development. My

15 current curriculum vitae is attached and provides a full history of my

16 relevant professional experience.

17 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Avangrid Renewables?Renewables?

18 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for leading and managing the

19 developmentdevelopment of several proposed largelarge-scale-scale renewable solar and wind

20 projectsprojects in New York.

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Scott(Scott L. McDonald)McDonald)

1 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

3 A. No.

4 Q. Have you previously previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain ExhiExhibitsbits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

11 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 1, General

16 Requirements; Exhibit 2, Overview and Public Involvement; Exhibit 3,

17 Location of Facilities; Facilities; Exhibit 9, Alternatives;Alternatives; and Exhibit 13, Real

18 Property.Property.

19 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

20 your direction and/or supervision?

21 A. Yes.

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Scott(Scott L. McDonald)McDonald)

1 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

2 A. Yes.

3 of 3

SCOTT L. MCDONALD

Avangrid Renewables Cell: 518.518.703.0180703.0180 7650 North State Street, Suite 1 Lowville, New York 13367 Email: [email protected]@avangrid.com

SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS

.■ More than 2255 years of renewable energy experience with fourteen in development of 4 GW of wind energy project pipeline in New York, New England, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Ohio, and Kansas;Kansas; one in development of 90 MW of solar in New York; aandnd technical lead responsible for 800+ MW of Avangrid Renewables'Renewables’ operating wind energy assetsassets.. .■ Technical lead and key development team member in Atlantic Renewable Energy Corporation's Corporation’s greenfield efforts and 500500++ MW pipeline subsequently acquired by PPM Energy, Inc. .■ Meteorology manager closely aalignedligned with Avangrid Renewables' Renewables’ developmentdevelopment,, engineering, construction, permittingpermitting,, origination, and procurement teamsteams to assess and meet business development goals, deliver competitive projects, maintain staff technical quality and state-of-the-artstate-of-the-art proficiencyproficiency,, while work transparentlytransparently and effectively in a fast paced work environment. .■ Support of projects through all stages of developmentdevelopment,, iincludingncluding landowner and stakeholder engagement, strategic direction, and energy sales and PPA support. .■ Responsible for all aspects of wind resource,resource, project design, and energy assessment activitiesactivities for Avangrid Renewables' Renewables’ eastern and Mid -Continent-Continent regions across multiple projects simultaneously, simultaneously, which includes greenfield prospecting, site selection, measurement campaign design and oversightoversight,, wind plant design, and turbine site suitability.suitability. .■ Extensive knowledge and understanding of environmental and community acceptance challenges that must be addressed at the onset to drive projectprojectss towards successsuccess.. .■ Excellent communication, presentation and negotiation skills; highly motivated self-starterself-starter and thrivesthrives in a highhigh-pressure,-pressure, competitive environment.

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

Lead/Senior Business Developer,Developer, Avangrid Renewables, Clifton Park,Park, New York Sep 20201616-Present-Present

.■ Development lead of Avangrid Renewables'Renewables’ proposed 90.5 MW Mohawk Solar project located in the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, NNY,Y, and the 100 MW North Ridge Wind Project located in Hopkinton NY, both subject to siting reviewreview by the Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment under Article 10 of the New York State Public Service Law. .■ Closely aalignedligned with Avangrid Renewables'Renewables’ development, engineering, and permitting teams to assess and meet business development goals.goals. .■ Key presenter in project development related outreach activities to include town,town, county IDA and school board meetings, as well as community, landowner, and local and state-level-level permit meetings. .■ Manage all greenfield prospecting and project development activities in New York and New England.England. .■ Supported the NNYSERDAYSERDA Tier-1-1 Renewable Energy Certificate solicitation efforts under RFP RESRFP18-RESRFP18- 1 and ongoing post award reporting requirements for the Mohawk Solar project.

Scott L. McDonald PageP a g e 2

Manager, Scott L McDonald Consulting,Consulting, LLC, Clifton Park,Park, New York Feb 20201515-Sep-Sep 2016

.■ Provide wind energy consultancy and technical advisory services in all aspects of client-based-based needs including initial project scoping, project development, financial closing, and permit support, meteorological monitoring campaign design, wind resource and energy assessments, array design, wind flow and wake modeling, site IEC classifications, project loss and uncertainty assessments, technical due diligence, and independent review of third-party-party energy assessments. .■ ProvidedProvided asset divestdivestitureiture and financial closing support for client with holdings in Palm Springs and the Altamont Pass, CA. Additional rresponsibilitiesesponsibilities include advising and assisting development staff with internal project approvals, CUP applicationapplications,s, site constraints assessmentsassessments,, hearing and pepermitrmit support, management and technical oversight of third-party-party consultants and due diligence activities,activities, measurement campaign design and installation management, data analysis and reporting, reporting, array designdesign,, and site suitability assessmentsassessments.. .■ Provided project development support and led all wind resource assessment, meteorological monitoring ccampaign,ampaign, and array design actactivitiesivities for the proposed GallooGalloo Island Wind Project near Watertown, NY. Represented client at an open-house-house meeting to promote communicommunityty acceptance. .■ Conducted “top"top-down"-down” evaluations of third-party-party wind resource and energy reports for wind farms located in IL and UT totaling 300 MW of installed capacity.

Head of Energy Assessments, North America,America, Natural Power ConsultantsConsultants,, Saratoga,Saratoga, NY May 2014-Feb-Feb 2015

.■ Principal US interface with Natural Power'sPower’s international technical management team.team. .■ Directed all aspects of client-based-based needs including initial project scoping, energy assessments, wind flow and wake modeling, array design, site IEC classifications, project loss and uncertainty assessments, and technical due diligence for banks and financialfinancial institutions. .■ Lead responsible for managing the energy assessments and reporting for projects located in California, New York and Puerto Rico. .■ Managed the due diligence activities to support Natural Power'sPower’s first US-based-based project financing. .■ ProvidedProvided technical advisory services for clients to include “top"top-down"-down” wind resource, energy yield, uncertainty, array design, wake, and site suitability evaluations of third party reports for wind farms located in TX and OK totaling 800+ MW of installed capacicapacity.ty. .■ Lead US effort to update Natural Power'sPower’s methodology validation study.

Senior Manager,Manager, Wind Resources, New Dimension Energy Company,Company, Inc.,Inc., Waltham,Waltham, MA Dec 20201212-Apr-Apr 20201414

.■ Directed all aspects of wind project development, including site prospecting, wind resource assessment, permit support, wind flow modeling, energy assessment, array design, due diligence, and turbine site suitability forfor NDEC, Ogin Inc.'sInc.’s wholly-owned-owned project development company. .■ Advised business development staff on project acquisition and repower opportunities within the North American renewable energy market, as well as supporting all project economic assessments and PPA solicitations.solicitations. .■ Assisted development team with presenting project acquisition opporopportunitiestunities for internal approvals. .■ Technical liaison to Ogin’sOgin's engineering team on mission critical turbine performance issues (power curve, wake, and noise) related to the development and deployment of a shrouded 150 kW wind turbine. .■ ResponsibleResponsible for scheduling, budgets, staffing, and managing a team of industry experts to design and execute a comprehensive wake measurement campaign, key to turbine commercialization. Scott L. McDonald PageP a g e 3

.■ Manager of an IEC 6140061400-1-1 Ed3 compliant noise study conducted on a commercial turbine prototypeprototype.. Responsibilities includincludeded budget, staffing, RFP development and consultant selection, and test execution. .■ Directed the installation and configuration of IEC 61400-0161400-01 Ed.2 1995 compliant meteorological masts for power curve certification at Ogin’sOgin's prototype and wake campaign test sites. .■ Lead all wind plant design, energy assessment, and site suitability activities for proposed wind projects located in California, New York, and Maryland.Maryland. .■ Key contributor in cross-departmental-departmental knowledge transfer to align product design, construction, installation, and cost with industry expectations and needs. .■ Provide technical support to Ogin’sOgin's international development team and sales department, as well as customer and customer’scustomer's consultants.

Manager,Manager, Meteorology, Iberdrola Renewables,Renewables, Inc.,Inc., Radnor,Radnor, Pennsylvania Jun 20200909-Nov-Nov 20201212

.■ Manager of the meteorology staff directing all greenfield prospecting, wind resource and energy assessment efforts, wind flow modeling, uncertainty analyses, wind plant design, site suitability, and due diligence activities covering the Eastern, New England, England, and Mid -Atlantic-Atlantic regions, as well as numerous Mid-Continent-Continent projects. .■ Closely aalignedligned with Iberdrola development, engineering, and permitting teams to assess and meet business development goals.goals. .■ Key presenter in project development related outreach activities, including town board, community, landowner, and local and state-level-level permit meetings. .■ Appointed and active member of the Sound Task Force Team and lead staff member responsible for internal sound modeling activities to improve modeling accuracaccuracy,y, project design efficiency, and project risk reduction. .■ Technical lead forfor the 2010-build-build 78 MW Hardscrabble Wind Project in NY, the 2011-build-build 304 MW Blue Creek Wind Project in OH, and the 2012-build-build 28.5 MW Hoosac Wind Project in MA. .■ Demonstrated analanalyticalytical skills in the most complex terrain and forested regions of the Iberdrola pipeline, namely projects in MA, ME, NH, NY, PA, VT, and WV. .■ Assisted the staff Director in managing the due diligence effort for those eastern projects selected for post-construction-construction assessment by Iberdrola Spain under the worldwide Project Eagle initiative. .■ Demonstrated OEM site suitability (IEC 61400-0161400-01 Ed.2 1995, IEC 6140061400-01-01 Ed.3 2005) and project due diligence issue resolution skills. .■ Lead in acquiring and incorporating lilidardar remote sensing (Leosphere) and CFD (Meteodyn) wind flow modeling capabilities into the analytical toolkit.

Lead Senior Meteorologist,Meteorologist, Iberdrola Renewables,Renewables, Inc.,Inc., Portland, Oregon May 20020088-May-May 2009

Senior Meteorologist,Meteorologist, PPM Energy, Inc.,Inc., Portland, Oregon (Acquired(Acquired by Iberdrola) Jan 2005-Apr-Apr 20020088

.■ Lead for all wind resource assessment, wind plant design, and due diligence activities covering the New England, New York and Mid -Atlantic-Atlantic regions. Activities included aallll aspects of site layout and resource assessment with a focus on strategic meteorological mast and remote sensing siting (sodar), mast configuration and installation; data collection and validation; long-term long-term resource and energy assessments; and IEC 61400-12-161400-12-1 reference mast siting and configuration. .■ Aligned with project developers to achieve optimal wind plant design with consideration of all design constraints, which includes environmental impacts (noise, shadow flicker, wetland), and land owner and construction issues. .■ Technical lead for the 2007-build-build 34.5 MW Casselman Wind Project and the 2010-build-build 50.4 MW South Chestnut Wind Project, both in PA. Scott L. McDonald PageP a g e 4

.■ Provided key technical support for the Maple Ridge I/II and Casselman Wind Project poportionsrtions of the PPM Aeolus financing portfolios. Primary reviewer of the independent engineer’sengineer's due diligence reports and directly responsible for the successful resolution of all energy assessment or array design issues. .■ Active participant in industry standards standards and state-of-the-art state-of-the-art technology assessments, including coco-- authoring and presenting a sodar technology paper at AWEA 2007, and an invited presenter at the 2005 and 2006 AWEA Fall Symposiums. .■ Demonstrated experience in the design and implementation of state-of-the-artstate-of-the-art mast and sodar-basedsodar-based resource assessment programs, especially in complex topography, with focus on reducing energy estimate uncertainty and project risk, and successful due diligediligencence review.

Project Manager/Engineer,Manager/Engineer, Atlantic Renewable Energy Corporation (A(Acquiredcquired by PPM Energy)Energy) JulJul 20020011-Dec-Dec 20200404

.■ Responsible for all wind resource assessment, wind plant design, and due diligence activities,activities, as well as assisting in key development activities, in support of Atlantic Renewable'sRenewable’s 500+MW Northeast and Mid-Atlantic-Atlantic development pipeline. .■ Assisted development team on site prospecting, greenfield development, proposal development, as well as projecprojectt planning, permitting, land control, and public outreach activities. .■ Commissioned projects include the 322 MW Maple Ridge Wind Farm (2005) and the 30 MW Fenner Wind Project (2001) in NY, the 66 MW Mountaineer Wind Energy Center Project (2002) in WV, and thethe 30 MW Meyersdale Wind Energy Project (2003) in PA. .■ Demonstrated expertise in the use of WAsP and WindFarmer, industry recognized wind resource characterization and wind plant development software. .■ Worked with AWS Truewind on its first commercial applicationapplication of MesoMap, their proprietary mesoscale wind flow model. In conjunction with an extensive met monitoring program and validation regiment, MesoMap was employed as the basis for the wind resource characterization at Maple Ridge. .■ Conducted a preliminarpreliminaryy offshore wind energy assessment for a successful New Jersey BPU grant.

Project Engineer,Engineer, AWS Scientific, Inc., Albany, NY ((KNAKNA AWS Truepower)Truepower) Nov 1992-Jun-Jun 20200101

.■ Project engineer responsible for wind resourceresource,, energy assessment and due diligence activities, as well as designing, installing, and managing client-based-based resource assessment programs located nationwide, including international assignments. .■ Managed all wind resource, energy assessment, wind plant design, rereportingporting activities, including client relationships, for the 322 MW Maple Ride Wind Project in NY. .■ Managed two nationally recognized DOE/NREL sponsored wind resource assessment programs, the Utility Wind Resource Assessment Program (UWRAP) and CONFRRM (Cooperative Networks for Renewable Energy Measurements), as well as the Pennsylvania Wind Resource Assessment Program (PAWRAP), and an extensive New York monitoring network for ESEERCO and Niagara Mohawk (KNA National Grid). .■ Principle coco-author-author of the WindWind Resource Assessment Handbook (published by NREL); presented wind resource assessment papers at three AWEA national conferences; and a key contributor and presenter at two DOE/NREL-sponsoredDOE/NREL-sponsored pre-conference-conference seminars. .■ Team engineer for the Niagara Mohawk'sMohawk’s Advanced Wind Turbine Technology Project whose main goal was the optimization of U.S. Windpower’sWindpower's 33MVS wind turbine for extreme cold weather operation. Responsibilities included wind plant operation and maintenance, mechanical system performance monitoringmonitoring and evaluations, and system component testing. Received “windsmith”"windsmith" training at U.S. WindPower'sWindPower’s California manufacturing facility.

Scott L. McDonald PageP a g e 5

Manager,Manager, McDonald Consulting, Newburgh, NY Aug 1991-Oct-Oct 1992

.■ Provided accident reconstruction technical consulting services for the insurance industry.

Project Engineer,Engineer, Verna Engineering, Carnegie, PA Sep 1989-Jul-Jul 1991

.■ Provided multi-disciplinary-disciplinary forensic engineering services to a wide ranging client base.

Laboratory Coordinator,Coordinator, Lawler, Matusky & Skelly Engineers, Pearl River, New York Jun 1978-Aug-Aug 1986

.■ Lab coordinator for environmental engineering firm tasked with evaluating power plant intake anandd discharge cooling water impacts on Hudson River fish populations.

EDUCATION

Bachelor of Science, Mechanical Engineering State University of New York at Buffalo,Buffalo, Buffalo,Buffalo, NY May 1989

Bachelor of Arts, Environmental Science Marist College, Poughkeepsie, NYNY May 1976

PUBLICATIONS/PRESENTATIONS

.■ Invited AWEA panel member, “Industry"Industry Standards Survey",Survey”, AWEA Wind Resource & Project Energy Assessment Seminar, 2012, Pittsburgh, PA. .■ Invited AWEA panel member, “Minimizing"Minimizing Measurement Uncertainty",Uncertainty”, AWEA Wind Resource & Project Energy Assessment Workshop, 2011, Seattle, WA. .■ McDonald, S. L. and Crescenti, G. H., “Sodar"Sodar Use to Elucidate Tower-Based-Based Wind Shear and Hub Height Speed Estimates",Estimates”, AWEA WindPowerWindPower 2007 paper & presentation, Los Angeles, CA. .■ McDonald, S. L., “Measurement"Measurement Part 2: How To Collect It",It”, AWEA & CanWEA Wind Resource Assessment Workshop 2006 presentation, Syracuse, NY. .■ McDonald, S. L., “Addressing"Addressing Wind Measurement Uncertainties: A PerspectivePerspective From a Wind Developer",Developer”, AWEA Wind Energy Fall Symposium 2005 presentation, La Quinta, CA. .■ McDonald, S. L and Bailey, B. H., “Advancements"Advancements in Wind Monitoring and Data Quality Assurance: Lessons Learned from the Utility Wind Resource Assessment Program",Program”, AWEA WindPower 1998 paper & presentation, Bakersfield, CA. .■ Bailey, B. H. and McDonald, S. L, “The"The Utility Wind Resource Assessment Program",Program”, AWEA WindPower 2005 paper, Bakersfield, CA. .■ NREL (Bailey, B. H., McDonald, S. L, et al.), “Wind"Wind Resource AssessmentAssessment Handbook: Fundamentals for Conducting a Successful Wind Monitoring Program",Program”, and pre-conference-conference seminars at AWEA WindPower 1997 and 1998. .■ McDonald, S. L and Bailey, B. H., “A"A Field Comparison of Popular Wind Monitoring Systems",Systems”, AWEA WindPower 19951995 paper and presentation, Washington, D.C.

PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS

Board MemberMember-- Vice President, Friends of Shenendehowa Rowing

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

NORMAN C. PHILLIPS

DIRECTOR, SITE CONSTRUCTION

AVANGRID RENEWABLES,RENEWABLES, LLC

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed TestimonyTestimony (Norman(Norman C. Phillips)Phillips)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Norman C. Phillips,Phillips, Avangrid Renewables,Renewables, LLCLLC,, 1125 NW Couch Street,

3 Portland, Oregon 97209.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Director, Site Construction.Construction.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Avangrid Renewables?Renewables?

7 A. I have been employed with Avangrid Renewables since March 2007.2007.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I have over 35 years of experience in developing, constructing, operating,

11 and maintaining renewable energy projects.projects. My current curriculum vitae is

12 attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

13 experience.

14 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Avangrid Renewables?Renewables?

15 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for the overall construction

16 management of all Avangrid RenewablesRenewables projects, including oversight of

17 all on --sitesite staffing, quality control, and safety during each phase of

18 construction.construction.

19 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

20 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

21 A. No.

1 of 2

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed TestimonyTestimony (Norman(Norman C. Phillips)Phillips)

1 Q. HaveHave you previously served as an expert witness before any other

2 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

3 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

4 A. Yes.Yes. I previouslypreviously providedprovided testimonytestimony andand servedserved as an expertexpert witnesswitness for

5 the TTuleule WindWind projectproject in California.California.

6 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

7 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

8 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

9 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

10 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

11 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

12 sponsoring?sponsoring?

13 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 12,12, Construction;Construction; and

14 Exhibit 15,15, Public Health and SafetySafety..

15 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared prepared by you, or under

16 your direction and/or supervision?

17 A. Yes.

18 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

19 A. Yes.

2 of 2

4124341243 Maple Street Palmdale, CA 93551 Norman C. Phillips Cell: 661-361-8754661-361-8754

Summary

Director of Site Construction withwith over 35 years of experience in developing, constructing,constructing, operatingoperating and maintainingmaintaining projects in the renewable energy industry. Specializing in Construction Management of wind and solar projectsprojects throughout United States and CanadaCanada,, actively involved in thethe construction and completion of 104 projects,projects, introducingintroducing nearly 9 gigawatts of clean renewable energy intointo the electrical grid.grid.

Professional Experience

March 2007 to Present ResponsibleResponsible for overall construction management of all projects nationally, resource Avangrid Renewables, LLC management of all on-site-site staffing,staffing, quality control and safety during all phases of (Formerly lberdrolaIberdrola Renewables & PPM construction to ensure that project milestones are met safely,safely, on schedule and within Energy) Energy) budget. Management of the Construction Safety and Quality teams, provide pre and budget. Management of the Construction Safety and Quality teams, provide pre and post project construction support to the Development, Permitting, Engineering, Director, Site Construction post project construction support to the Development, Permitting, Engineering, Estimating, Project Management and Operations & Maintenance teams.

Nov. 1983 to March 2007 In charge of managing project contracts, schedules, milestones, budgets, customer GE Energy requests and change orders form project initiation or singing through completion and (Formerly(Formerly Enron Wind & Zond) handoverhandover to the Service team for operations, including procurement of materials resources, sub-contracts. Project Manager resources, sub-contracts.

Managed the construction interface with the Project Origination Group and potential Customers during contract negotiation processprocess and assist in project turnover to the Construction Manager Project Managers. Perform site walks on potential projects and assist Project Controls Group through estimating phase of all projects. Review and approve sub-sub- contracts, procedures, schedules and estimates.

Provided supervision of site construction staff, review and approval of site procedures relating to safety, quality budgeting and scheduling, material management and administration. Monitor sub contractor performance, schedule andand Construction Site Manager quality. Approve all project expenditures, contracts and change orders. Review and approve construction methods including rigging, concrete placement, underground electrical cabling, wind turbine installation, etc.

Assistant Construction Site Assist Construction Site Manger in supervision and management of sub contractor: Manager contracts, schedules, change-orders,-orders, progress and safety.

Responsible for design review and approval of access roads, pads and foundations. AssureAssure that contractor has adequate personnel and equipment to meet performance Civil Superintendent schedules while providing quality work according to contract. Review and approve all change-orders-orders and invoices.

Equipment Operator "A",“A”, Operate heavyheavy equipment as required for construction and maintenance of access roads, pads, trenching and backfill for underground electrical systems for wind turbine installation and maintenance. Provide re-vegetation-vegetation and Equipment Operator "A"“A” erosion control as required to meet State andand County requirements. Operate cranes as required to load, unload, install and maintain wind turbines. Responsible for training and certification of new equipment operators. Equipment Operator "B",“B”, Operate heavy equipment as requiredrequired to construct and Equipment Operator "B"“B” maintain access roads, pads, electrical trenching, back fill and erosion control.

Education • Cerro Coso Community College: OSHA Construction’sConstruction's Standards Course • Power Systems University: Elements of Leadership Effectiveness • Primavera:Primavera: SureTrak Project Manager 3.0 • RS Means: Unit Price Estimating • Six Sigma: Green Belt Certified • LEAN: ManufacturingManufacturing and CConstructiononstruction training • OSHA: 10hr • OSHA: 40hr Licenses Commercial Drivers License: Class A, B, C & M-1,M-1, including all associated endorsements;endorsements; (Tanker, DoublesDoubles / TriplesTriples & Passenger)Passenger)

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

PAUL J. SKURDAHL

DIRECTOR, ENGINEENGINEERINGERING AND CAPITAL ESTIMATING

AVANGRID RENEWABLES,RENEWABLES, LLC

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Paul(Paul J. SkurdahlSkurdahl))

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Paul J. SkurdahlSkurdahl,, Avangrid Renewables, Renewables, LLCLLC,, 1125 NW Couch StreetStreet,,

3 Portland,Portland, Oregon 9720997209..

4 Q. What is your currentcurrent position?

5 A. Director, Engineering and Capital EstimatingEstimating..

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Avangrid Renewables?Renewables?

7 A. I have been employed with Avangrid Renewables since 2005.2005.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering from Oregon

11 State University in 1981.1981. I have over 35 years of experience in the

12 engineering and development of energy projects. projects. My current curriculum

13 vitae is attached and provides provides a full history of my relevant professional

14 experience.

15 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Avangrid Renewables?Renewables?

16 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for the overall design,

17 procurement, and budgeting of all Avangrid Renewables projects in the

18 United StatesStates,, including creation of the design standard and specifications

19 for each project.project.

20 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

21 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

1 of 2

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Paul(Paul J. SkurdahlSkurdahl))

1 A. No.

2 Q. Have you previously served served as an expert witness before any other

3 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

4 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

5 A. Yes.Yes. I havehave providedprovided testimonytestimony foforr severalseveral projectsprojects iinn the StStateate of Illinois,Illinois,

6 includingincluding CayugaCayuga Ridge,Ridge, OtterOtter Creek,Creek, and DeerDeer Run.Run.

7 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

8 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

9 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

10 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

11 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

12 Q. What Exhibits, Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

13 sponsoring?sponsoring?

14 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 14,14, Cost of Facilities;Facilities;

15 Exhibit 26,26, Effect on Communications; Exhibit 27, Socioeconomic

16 Effects; and Exhibit 40, TelecommunicationsTelecommunications InterconnectionInterconnection..

17 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

18 your direction and/or supervision?

19 A. Yes.

20 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

21 A. Yes.

2 of 2

PAUL J. SKURDAHL 20685 WillametteWillamette Drive,Drive, West Linn,Linn, OR 97068 (971)(971) 235-1497235-1497

PROFESSIONAL PROFILE Experienced energy professional with a broad background in renewable energy including all phases of the development and construction of wind and solar projects. In depth knowledge of project construction including design, permitting, estimating, agreements,agreements, procurement,procurement, and project management. management. Significant experience with power purchase agreements, interconnect agreements, energy trading, partner agreements, acquisitions, deal structuring and project finance.

Demonstrated ability to set strategic plans, manage budgets and meet operational targets.targets. Effective leader with the ability to hire and lead teamsteams to achieve targeted goals while managing change and the competing priorities of safety, cost and scheduleschedule.. Bottom-line-line profit and loss responsibility.

Existing, broad relationships within AvangridAvangrid and Iberdrola of key influencers and decision makers.

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Avangrid Renewables,Renewables, PPORTLAND,ORTLAND, OREGONOREGON 20052005 - Present

Director, Engineering and Capital Estimating 2015 - Present Directing team of engineeringengineering and estimating professionals providing engineering support for design,design, procurementprocurement and capital budgeting of all US wind, solar and storage projects. projects. Commercial lead from E & C for all turbine supply agreements, agreements, engineering design agreements,agreements, PPA reviews, and Dossier reviewsreviews.. Supporting all civil and electrical construction contracts. Responsible for creating design standards and specifications. AnnualAnnual capital/construction budget of over $2B. • Leading Engineering Team responsible for EPC packagespackages including scope of work, specificationsspecifications,, design requirements and contractor evaluation,evaluation, contractor design reviews through to 1FC,IFC, managing construction design issues (RFI's),(RFI’s), project commissioning and closeout. o Supported the successful design and startup of four 2017 wind projects and one 2018 solar project.project. o Managed procurement (created specs, evaluated bids and managed deliveries) of more than 20 procurement items for each of the four 2017 projects.projects. o Created the EPC procurement package (civil and electrical) for all 2019 COD projects in 4 months, leadingleading to the successful engagement of four EPC contractorscontractors.. o Creating the EPC package for six 2019/20 COD projects (wind, solar and storage) including lessons learned from 2018 process.process. • Leading Estimating Team responsible for project cost estimates (wind, solar,solar, storage and repowerrepower)) fforor all AR US projects. Provide budgets, reviews project and construction risks, develop preliminary construction schedules, identify optimization/cost savings opportunities whilewhile tracking permitting, landland,, IA, and PPA'sPPA’s for CapEx impactsimpacts.. o Provided CapEx analysisanalysis and project design input to Dossiers for all approved greenfield and repower projects (wind, solar and storage). o Provided timely cost estimates for all RFP and bidding, averaging less than one-week-week response time.time. o Supporting CapEx analysis for turbine procurement for five 2020 COD projects, projects, including new technology reviewreview.. • E&C lead for turbine supply agreements including: o FourFour 2019 COD and fivefive 2016/2017 COD projects.projects. o TTwowo 2018, two 2017 and three 2016 safe harbor equipment supply agreements.agreements. o TTwowo safe harbor repower agreements including EPC scope of supplysupply.. o FrameworkFramework TSA’sTSA's for SGRESGRE,, GE and Vestas.Vestas. • E&C lead for negotiating multiple repower supply and installation agreements. • Supporting the development and due diligence of multiple potential tax financingfinancing and acquisition projects.

Director, Capital Project Estimating 2010 - 2014 Responsible for capital budgets for wind, solar and biomass in the US. Provide input to support strategic and business planning, investment and procurement decisions.

PPAULAUL J. SSKURDAHLKURDAHL PPAGEAGE 2

Regional Director, Midwest Region,Region, Technical Services 2005 - 2010 Responsible for engineering support (engineering(engineering design, cost analysis,analysis, and permitting) of more than 1,500MW of Midwest development projects. Managed engineering support to all aspects of the wind development process including land, meteorology, permitting and design, as well as conconstructionstruction and operational issues for multiple turbine types (Gamesa,(Gamesa, MHI,MHI, Suzlon, GE and Vestas).Vestas). ProvidedProvided engineering support forfor new biomass initiative.initiative. • CompletedCompleted/operational/operational projects include:include: Maple Ridge Phase IA and II, Cayuga Ridge, Casselman, MoraineMoraine II, Penascal I & II, Buffalo Ridge I and II, Elm Creek I and II, Farmers City, City, and New Harvest.Harvest. Provided significant development support to Hoosac, Tule, Hardscrabble, Blue Creek, Baffin and others.

Project Manager —– Construction ((FarmersFarmers City and Mapleridge Phase IA and II)II) Managed all items for project construction including civil and electrical design, permitting, equipment procurement, contracting, contract management and accounting during the construction and start-up.start-up. Met or exceeded all scheduleschedule and cost targets.

Da Vinci Merchants,Merchants, HOUSTON,HOUSTON, TTEXASEXAS 2004 - 2005 StartStart-up-up company focusing on the development of greenfield and brownfield pipeline and oil and natural gas exploration and production (E&P) assets along the Gulf Coast.

ViceVice President, Marketing Responsible for implementing business strategy, financialfinancial analysis and partnering relationships. • Negotiated strategic partnership arrangement with two new technology firms that provided significant cost reductions and increased success rate of newnew prospect drilling.

TTECHNICOLORECHNICOLOR (THOMSON(THOMSON MULTIMEDIA),MULTIMEDIA), Paris, France 2002 —– 2003 Electronics company with more than $10B in revenues and 64,000 employees. TTechnicolorechnicolor distributes its products and services under the Thomson, RCA, Technicolor and Grass Valley brand names.

Global Commodity Manager —– Energy, Houston, TTXX 2003 Director, Energy Procurement —– Americas, Houston, TX 2002 Sourced electricelectricity,ity, natural gas and other fuels, water and industrial gases at all Thomson facilities in the Americas, Europe and Asia. Structured contracts and managedmanaged risk for more than $130M in annual purchases. Led energy efficiency analysis and upgrade projects at multiplemultiple manufacturing facilities. Managed contract structuring and risk management. Developed world-wideworld-wide energy purchase strategy and budgets.budgets. • Purchased natural gas for all North American facilities for 2003-2004 2003–2004 saving more than $2M $2M compared to the procurementprocurement process previously in place. Reduced price volatility by implementing a forward hedging strategy. • Reconfigured previously cancelled cogen/efficiency project saving $2M$2M per year with a 3-year-year payback. • Led RFP and contracting process for electricity and natural gas consuming facilities in the UK, France, Italy and Poland saving more than $5 million annually. • Identified, arranged and negotiated energy efficiency upgrade at film production facility, reducing energy and water costs by $1$1MM per year. • Negotiated compressed air outsourcing agreement,agreement, reducing operating costs by more than $450,000 per year.year.

BP,BP, Houston, TX 2000 —– 2002 Oil super-major-major with $129 B in revenues and 110,000 employees.

Director, Business Development, North America, BP GGLOBALLOBAL POWER,POWER, Houston, TX Responsible for project development in North America covering more than 2,500MW of 1PP IPP projects. Responsibilities included power sales, fuel supply, transmission, project management,management, structuring and risk management. Developed regional strategic plans and budgets.budgets. Lead team of professionals supporting development projects. • AnalyzedAnalyzed gas and power markets versus trading strategy to reconfigure and optimize previously cancelled opportunities at BP owned chemical, refinery and NGL facilities, resulting in re-approval-approval of more than 1,000MW of projects for further development. • Led acquisition team for 500MW 1PPIPP and 325MW expansion opportunity located adjacent to a BP refinery, resulting in revised tolling agreementagreement which enhanced investment returns (IRR) by more than 5%. • Led development of 85MW cogeneration project in California. Results: completed financialfinancial approvals, design, and construction agreements (including major equipment purchases),purchases), and permit preparationpreparation in less than six months.

PPAULAUL J. SSKURDAHLKURDAHL PPAGEAGE 3

EENGAGENGAGE ENERGY,ENERGY, Houston, TX 1998 - 1999 Top-10-10 energy marketer owned jointly by The Coastal Corporation and Westcoast Energy with more than $6B$6B in revenues. North American operations covering electricity, natural gas and coal.

Director, Structured Power Led team responsible for the origination of electric and gas contracts, trading and marketing joint ventures, acquisitions, merchant plant contracts (tolling agreements, fuel supply and electric sales), reverse tolling and the conception and execution of new business and products. Responsible for negotiations, financialfinancial analysis, credit and risk analysis, hedging, and integration into daily trading operations (front and back office). office). ResponsibleResponsible for competitor analysis and industry trend reporting to Senior Management. • Negotiated and closed trading joint venture with 800MW electric coop in Wisconsin (Dairyland)(Dairyland) that produced firstfirst year profit of $1.2M (double pro-forma-forma projections) with no additional capital commitment (VAR = $0). • Negotiated long-termlong-term full requirements service agreement with retail aggregator, resulting in doubling of cash flowflow and profit from major customer. • Led due-diligence-diligence team in for the acquisition of a major trading company'scompany’s operations. • Negotiated cross commodity trade (gas for electricity) resulting in profit of $2$2M.M. • Negotiated world-wideworld-wide energy outsourcing/guaranteed savings agreement with major international glglassass supplier for 23 world-wideworld-wide locations. • Led negotiations for more than 1,000MW of tolling agreements while developing company'scompany’s base tolling agreement and tolling insurance product.

PPOWERLINKOWERLINK CCORPORATION,ORPORATION, Portland, OR 1989 - 1997 Independent power producer with projects in U.S., Canada, Indonesia, The Philippines and Central America. Projects ranged from 60MW to 660MW. Fueled by natural gas, biomass, coal and fuel oil. Board member from 1996 to 1998.

ViceVice President, Business Development 1994 - 1997 Director, P.T. Puncakjaya Power (Indonesian Affiliate) 19951995-- 1997 Developed electric power projects up to $500$500M.M. Managed the conception and implementation of projects, structuring structuring and finance,finance, partnering,partnering, cash flowflow and tax analysis, engineering scope and design, risk assessment, financingfinancing and due diligence. Contracted for power sales, fuel supply, EPC, O&M, permitting, etc. Managed PowerLink'sPowerLink’s 30% interest in P.T. Puncakjaya Power, a 380MW utility system in Indonesia with annual operating budget of $38$38M.M. • Led acquisition and financingfinancing of private Indonesian electric utility system whose operating earnings exceeded pro-forma-forma projections by 55-10%-10% per year. • Expanded existing Indonesian project, which more than doubled assets ($215M to $530M),$530M), operating revenues ($50 M to $120$120M)M) and book income ($10M($10M to $25M).$25M). • Reduced capital and operating costs through design optimization of $200$200MM power project resulting in 20% reduction in customer price.

Director of Finance 1989 - 1993 Accountable for all financial forecasting, risk analysis and due diligence for new investments. Created fivefive-year-year business plan, analyzed power sales contracts, operating budgets and acquisitions for financial effecteffects.s. Results included formulating a unique interest rate hedge, reducing construction interest costs by over $2 million and over $500,000 per year thereafter, and recommended engineering design modification which increased net cash flowflow by more than 2%, and net present value by 12%.

PPORTLANDORTLAND GENERALGENERAL ELECTRICELECTRIC COMPANY,COMPANY, Portland, OR 1981 - 1989 Various positions in Engineering, Operations and Corporate Planning. Responsibilities included managing industrial customer contracts and Least Cost Planning, energy efficiency programs and implementation strategies.

EDUCATION Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering,Engineering, Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon. M.B.A. Executive Program, University of Oregon, Beaverton, Oregon. Completed 1st year of two-year two-year program prior to relocation to Houston in 19981998..

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

JOHN C. ALLEN

SENIOR DIRECTOR, PHYSICALPHYSICAL SECURITY & NERC COMPLIANCE

AVANGRID MANAGEMENT COMPANY

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (John(John C. Allen)Allen)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. John C. Allen, Allen, Avangrid Management Company,Company, 89 East Avenue,

3 Rochester,Rochester, New York.York.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Senior Director, Physical Security & NERC Compliance.Compliance.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Avangrid Management

7 CompanyCompany??

8 A. I have been employed with Avangrid Management Company since

9 OctoberOctober 2001.2001.

10 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

11 experience.experience.

12 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Chemical EnEngineeringgineering from Bucknell

13 University in 1989.1989. I also have a Master's Master’s of Science in Environmental

14 Management from the State University University of New York College of

15 Environmental Science and Forestry in 1994.1994. I have over 20 years of

16 experience managing security and regulatory compliance programs—

17 including NERC compliance —physical—physical security operations, security

18 technical services and fire protection. protection. My current curriculum vitae is

19 attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

20 experience.

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (John(John C. Allen)Allen)

1 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Avangrid Management

2 CompanyCompany??

3 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for all physical physical security

4 operations, security technical services, firefire protection, and NERC

5 reliability standards for all Avangrid projects and holdings.holdings.

6 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

7 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the EnvEnvironment?ironment?

8 A. No.

9 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

10 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

11 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

12 A. No.

13 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?proceeding?

14 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

15 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

16 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

17 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie,Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

18 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

19 sponsoring?sponsoring?

20 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 18, 18, Safety and

21 SecuritySecurity..

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (John(John C. Allen)Allen)

1 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

2 your direction and/or supervision?

3 A. Yes.

4 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

5 A. Yes.

3 of 3

JohnJohn C. Allen 89 East Avenue Rochester,Rochester, New York 14649 5585-771-419685-771-4196 [email protected]@avangrid.com

SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS Senior manager with over 20 years of experience of managing complex, multi-facetted-facetted programs.programs. Successful in directing enterprise level security and regulatory compliance programs, physical security operations, security technical services and firefire protection. Responsible for multi--millionmillion dollar capital and operating budgets.

Expertise includes: • Communication and reporting at all levels of the company up through the board of directors.directors. • Coordination with global security governance on security and compliance activities.activities. • Program management within a matrixmatrix management organization.organization. • Strategic planning and oversight.oversight. • Risk communication and management.management.

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

Avangrid Management CompanyCompany,, Rochester, NY Senior Director, Physical Security & NERC ComplianceCompliance,, 2019 to present Responsible for Physical Security Operations, Security Technical ServicesServices,, Fire Protection and the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) reliability standards compliance program at all Avangrid, Inc. U.S. holdings. • ManageManage department with staff of 26 security,security, fire protection and compliance professionals and over 100 security guard and security system contractors. • Responsible for annual capital and operating budgetsbudgets of over $70$70 million. • Successful in achieving corporate goals for physical security,security, fire protection and compliance activities, including budget efficiencies to meet corporate targets. • Responsible for management and oversight of NERC compliance auditsaudits and regulatoryregulatory filingsfilings for five operating companies. • Responsible for identifying physical security risks and mitigation strategies. • Coordinated internal NERC Compliance Committee made up of executives and senior management impacted by the NERC Standards.

Director, SecuritySecurity,, 2014 to 2019 Responsible for PhysicalPhysical Security Operations, Security Technical Services and Fire Protection at all Avangrid, Inc. U.S. holdings. • Manage department with staff of 13 security and fire protection professionals and over 100 security guguardard and security system contractors. • Responsible for annual capital and operating budgetsbudgets of over $70$70 million. • Obtained approval of a dossierdossier and framework agreements for a three-yearthree-year physical security program of $200$200 million. John C. Allen Page 2 585585-771-4196-771-4196

• Responsible for identifying physical security risks and mitigation strategies. • Responsible for developing strategic direction for physical security,security, including creation of a 3--yearyear road map for technology deployment.

Iberdrola USA Management CompanyCompany,, Rochester, NY Director, NERC CoCompliance,mpliance, 2012 to 2014 Responsible for compliance oversight for CMP, NYSEG and RG&E with over 100 NERC reliability standards,standards, including cyber and physical security under the NERC CIP StandardsStandards.. • Managed staff of 6 compliance professionals and coordinated efforts of approximately 50 subject matter experts. • Responsible for management and oversight of NERC compliance auditsaudits and regulatory filingsfilings for three operating companies. • Responsible for negotiating finesfines and penalties with NERC Standards enforcement groupgroup for violations of the standards. • Coordinated internal NERC Compliance Program Steering Committee made up of executives and senior management impacted by the NERC Standards. • Responsible for compliance effort to include approximately 200 additional substations into the NERC Compliance ProgramProgram under the 100 kV Bright Line definition change.

Rochester Gas and Electric CorporationCorporation,, Rochester, NY Manager, NERC ComplianceCompliance,, 2010 to 2012 ResponsibleResponsible for compliance oversight for RG&E and NYSEG with all NERC ReliabilityReliability SStandards,tandards, including the cyber and physical security ClPCIP StandardsStandards..

Manager, Programs/ProjectsPrograms/Projects,, 2008 to 2010 ResponsibleResponsible for managing special programs and projects for the RG&E and NYSEG executive team,team, including creation of the NERC ComplianceCompliance Program.

Director, Generation Environmental Services,Services, 2003 to 2008 Responsible for compliance with environmental regulatoryregulatory programs applicable to electricity generation facilitiesfacilities..

Senior Environmental Analyst, Environmental Affairs,Affairs, 2001 to 2003 Responsible for Air Quality Program regulatory compliance for all RG&E facilities.facilities.

EENSRNSR CorporationCorporation,, Syracuse, NY Project ManagerManager/Engineer,/Engineer, 19931993 to 2001 Managed and executed environmental projects for industrial and institutional clients.

EDUCATION

M.S., Environmental Management,Management, SUNY College of EnviEnvironmentalronmental Science and Forestry B.S., Chemical EEngineering,ngineering, Bucknell University John C. Allen Page 2 585585-771-4196-771-4196

LICENSES

Professional Engineer - New York State

INDUSTRY GROUPS

New York State Utility Security Working Group Northeast Power Coordinating CouncilCouncil Task Force on Infrastructure Security & Technology Edison Electric Institute Security Committee American Gas Association Natural Gas Security Committee

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

MICHELE A. FIORILLO, P.E.

GEOTECHGEOTECHNICALNICAL DEPARTMENT MANAGER

TERRACON CONSULTANTS-NY,-NY, INC.

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Michele(Michele A. Fiorillo)Fiorillo)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Michele A. Fiorillo, Fiorillo, Terracon Consultants -NY,-NY, Inc.Inc.,, 15 Marway Circle,

3 Suite 2B, Rochester, New York 14624.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Geotechnical Department Manager.Manager.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Terracon?Terracon?

7 A. I have been employed with Terracon since 2016.2016.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received received a Bachelor and Master of Science in Geotechnical Sciences

11 from the University of Rome, Italy, "La “La Sapienza.”Sapienza." I also received a

12 Master of Engineering in Geotechnical Engineering from the State

13 University of New York at Buffalo. Buffalo. I have more than 20 years of

14 experience in the geotechnical engineering and construction materials

15 fields.fields. In addition, I have overseen subsurface drilling investigations and

16 geotechnical evaluations for the design and construction of new

17 substations and improvements at existing substations substations for solar and wind

18 projects in New York and Pennsylvania. My current curriculum vitae is

19 attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

20 experience.

21

1 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Michele(Michele A. Fiorillo)Fiorillo)

1 Q. What are your current responsibilities at TerraconTerracon??

2 A. In my current position,position, I am responsible for overseeing geotechnical

3 engineering services related to site characterization and exploration, soils

4 laboratory services, geotechnical engineering design, transportation

5 design-build,-build, geotechnical consulting and other specialty services.services.

6 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

7 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

8 A. No.No.

9 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

10 court, agency, or other body relative to the subjectsubject matter you plan to

11 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

12 A. No.No.

13 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

14 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

15 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need iinn connection

16 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

17 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

18 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

19 sponsoring?sponsoring?

20 A. I will be sponsoring sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 21, Geology,

21 Seismology and SoilsSoils..

2 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Michele(Michele A. Fiorillo)Fiorillo)

1 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

2 your direction and/or supervision?

3 A. Yes.

4 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

5 A. Yes.

3 of 3

Michele A. Fiorillo, P.E. GEOTEGEOTECHNICALCHNICAL DEPARTMENT MANAGER

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCEEXPERIENCE EDUCATION Mr. Fiorillo brings over 20 years of experience in the geotechnical engineering and B.S., Geological Sciences, University of Rome, Italy, "La“La Sapienza",Sapienza”, 1994 construction materials testing services fields. HisHis projects have included investigations into slope failures and recommendations recommendations regarding corrective action; retaining wall design; M.S., Geological Sciences, University pavement evaluation and redesigns; foundation recommendations for various projects; and of Rome, Italy, "La“La Sapienza",Sapienza”, 1994 slope stability recommendations. Some of the projects Mr. Fiorillo has worked on are M.E. (Master of Engineering), presented below. Geotechnical Engineering, SUNY at Buffalo, 2000

PROJECT EXPERIENCE —– BRIDGES REGISTRATIONS Professional Engineer: NYSDOT 1-690I-690 over Teall Avenue & Beech Street Design-Build-Build —– Syracuse, NY Contract No. D900035 New York —– Lic #085888 Connecticut—Connecticut– Lic # PEN.0029949 Mr. Fiorillo is the Lead Geotechnical Engineer for this $61M Design-Build-Build project. The project Pennsylvania—Pennsylvania– Lic # PE080766 consistedconsisted of reconstructing a 3 ¾/4 mile mile section of 1-690 I-690 in the City of Syracuse, Onondaga OhioOhio—– Lic #77791 County, New York. The existing bridges carrying 1-690 I-690 over Beech Street and Teal! Teall Avenue were replaced with new structures that would provide a minimum 75 -year-year life service. The were replaced with new structures that would provide a AFFILIATIONS existing viaduct, including including the spans over Beech Street, was replaced with a single -span-span Association of Bridge Design and bridge over Beech Street and conventional roadway embankment for the bridge approaches. Construction Due to the poor geological conditions (peat, soft clay and marl) the proposed embankment and American Society of Civil Engineers - Rochester Chapter - member associated Mechanically Stabilized Earth (MSE) walls will be supported by a ground American Society of Civil Engineers - improvement system consisting of Controlled Modulus Columns (also designated as "rigid “rigid member inclusion elements")elements”) and an engineered geosyntheticgeosynthetic-reinforced-reinforced Load Transfer Platform (LTP). American Council of Engineering Companies The existing viaduct superstructure was removed in two stages to allow for ground improvement while providing lanes for traffic. Temporary Geosynthetic Reinforced Soil WORK HISTORY Systems (GRSS) were constructed between the two phases. Temporary shoring consisting of Terracon Consultants-NY,-NY, Inc., sheetsheet piles with tieback anchors were also proposed to support the excavation for the Teal!Teall GeotechnicalGeotechnical Department Manager,Manager, 2016-Present-Present Avenue bridge. The project, as it relates to the Design Builder'sBuilder’s geotechnical scope of work, consisted of the following: ROC GeotechnicalGeotechnical ConsultingConsulting Engineers,Engineers, PLLC: Owner / Senior Geotechnical • Replacement of Beech Street viaduct (BIN 11051139).051139). Engineer, 2011-20162011-2016 • Reconstruction of 1-690I-690 between Lodi Street and Peat Street. • Replacement of Teall Avenue Bridge (BIN 1051149). Tierney Geotechnical Engineering, • Reconstruction of the existing interchange intersections with Teall Avenue. P.C.: Geotechnical Engineer 20042004-2011-2011 • Reconstruction of the existing ramp configurations at Teall Avenue to maintain direct Geotechnical

access from the Teall Avenue area to the interstate. EmpireEmpire Geo-Services,Geo-Services, Inc.Inc. • Reconstruction of the Teall Avenue intersection with Canal Street and Post Office Geotechnical Engineer 2002-20042002-2004 driveways. • Minimizing public impacts to area businesses and the public in this very heavily VanVan DerDer Horst,Horst, GeotechnicalGeotechnical traveledtraveled corridor. Engineering, P.C. Geotechnical Engineer,1999-2002Engineer,1999-2002

NYSDOT 1-390I-390 Interchange Improvements CME Associates,Associates, Inc. Design-Build-Build Contract No. D900018 - Rochester, NY Engineering Technician,Technician, 1998-19991998-1999 Mr. Fiorillo is the Lead Geotechnical Engineer for this $30.7M Design-Build-Build project. Mr. Fiorillo RochesterRochester Asphalt Materials (RAM); performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for QC/QA Technician,Technician, 1997-19981997-1998 design of the proposed constructionconstruction of a new rigid frame bridge replacement over the Erie Canal (BIN 4443310); construction of a grade separated crossingcrossing for the new Ramp NFE over CMECME Associates,Associates, Inc. relocated Ramp DH (BIN 1079660);construction of four new interchanges at Route 15A (on/off Engineering Technician1995-1997Technician1995-1997 ramps) to improve traffic flow, safety, and roadway capacity; installation of a new, energy - efficient high -mast-mast lighting system; constrconstructionuction of a temporary pedestrian bridge over the canal; protection of one of the City'sCity’s 24"24” water distribution mains located adjacent to the new bridge abutment; pedestrian access to the Erie Canal Trail system.system.

State Route 427 Bridge over ChemungChemung River BIN 1061330 / PIN 6039.116039.11 —– Design-Build-Build Contract D900019 - Chemung, NY

Michele A. Fiorillo, P.E. PageP a g e 11| 1

Mr. Fiorillo is the Lead Geotechnical Engineer for this $20M Design-Build-Build project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluationevaluation for design of the proposed replacement of the existing seven span, 802-foot-foot long, steel, multi-girder-girder SR 427 bridge over Chemung River, including new foundations; removal of existing substructure and superstructure; approach roadway reconstruction necessarynecessary to connect existing roadwaysroadways to the new bridge.

Kendrick Road Bridge (BIN 4443840) —– Rochester, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the Lead GeotechnicalGeotechnical EngineerEngineer for this $15M Design Build project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the proposed EH Ramp structure, the widening of the existing Kendrick Road abutments and pier, and the MSE wall proposed for the new accelerationacceleration lane from the 1-390I-390 Northbound on-ramp-ramp structure, in accordance with the methodologies presented in the AASHTOAASHTO LFRD Bridge Design Specifications. Driven steel H-piles-piles were proposed as a foundation system for the new structures.

1-81I-81 Bridges over RouteRoute 80 (BIN 1030661 and BIN 1030662) —– Contract No. D900023 Mr. Fiorillo is the Lead GGeotechnicaleotechnical EngineerEngineer for this $8M Design Build project. The project consisted of replacement replacement of the two existing bridges (BIN 1030661 1-81I-81 SB and BIN 1030662 1-81I-81 NB) including new foundations;foundations; approachapproach roadway reconstruction and resurfacing;resurfacing; reconstruction/wideningreconstruction/widening along Route 80 under 1-81.I-81. Mr. Fiorillo was responsible for the preparationpreparation of Geotechnical Work Plan and Geotechnical Interpretative and Foundation Design Report. As part of the preparation of these reports, soil and rock profiles were completed for the purpose of geotechnical analysis, design, and construction. Geotechnical design recommendations (in accordance with AASTHO LRFD Bridge Design Manual) for shallowshallow foundations for the new bridges. The design included both static and dynamic loads, and downdrag and liquefaction potential of the on-site-site soils. Global stability analyses for the new structures. Review of design of temporary support structures.

HulbertonHulberton Road Bridge (BIN 3319220) - Murray, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical engineer of record for this project. The project consisted of replacement of an existing bridge with a 3- sided buried pre-cast-cast bridge structure supported on cast in -place-place concrete shallow foundations bearing directly upon bedrock. The design was completed in accordance with the methodologies presented in the AASHTOAASHTO LFRD Bridge Design Specifications. Mr. FiorilloFiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation and recommendations for foundation types.types.

Harrison Road Bridge (BIN No. 2217130) —– Town of Homby,Hornby, New York Mr. Fiorillo worked as staff engineer for this project. The project included replacement of an existing bridge with a new bridge along the aalignmentaalignment of Harrison Road over Dry Run Creek. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and and geotechnical evaluation and recommendations for foundation types.

PROJECT EXPERIENCE —– UNIVERSITY OF ROCHESTERROCHESTER Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of numerous structures located within the University of Rochester Campus. Some of projects included:

Science Quad Elevated Walkway —– University of Rochester River Campus,Campus, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical engineer of record for this project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drillingdrilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the proposed elevated walkway. GeotechnicalGeotechnical recommendations for foundationsfoundations were provided.

Institute of Data Science - University of Rochester River Campus,Campus, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical engineer of record for this project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the proposed multistory building and associated underground utilities. utilities. GeotechnicalGeotechnical recommendations for deep foundations and flflooroor slabs werweree provided.provided.

Schlegel Hall Addition - University of Rochester River Campus,Campus, New York Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the proposed multistory building and associated underground utilities. GGeotechnicaleotechnical recommendations for a structural mat foundation was provided.provided.

Fauver Stadium Residence Hall - University of Rochester River Campus,Campus, New York Mr. Fiorillo provided geotechnical recommendations for design of the proposed multistory building. Geotechnical recommendations for shallow foundations and flflooroor slabs were provided. GeotechnicaGeotechnicall recommendations were also provided for design of a relief reinforcedreinforced earth structure,structure, which was recommendedrecommended in order to reduce the earth pressure on the below grade wall along column line A/B.

Michele A. Fiorillo, P.E. PageP a g e 12| 2

PROJECT EXPERIENCE —– OTHERS

Warsaw Central School District —– Warsaw, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical engineer of record for this project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the proposed campuscampus building additions, parking lot expansions and parkingparking lot rehabilitation. EvaluationEvaluation of existing pavement, and geotechnicalgeotechnical recommendations for foundations and floor slabs were provided.provided.

Rochester Institute of Technology Gene Polisseni Hockey Arena —– Rochester, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the special inspector of record for this project. Mr. Fiorillo performed special inspection oversight on this project, as well as the pile driving inspection.

Promenade at Erie Harbor —– Rochester, New York Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical engineer of record for this project. The Promenade at Erie Harbor project consists of a public promenade constructed along the east side of the Johnson-Seymour-Seymour Mill Race, within the area referred to as Erie Harbor Park. Our scope of work consists of providing geotechnicalgeotechnical recommendations for the following proposed structures:

• PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE: Construction of a new twin -plate-plate girder pedestrian bridge to connect the northern end of the promenade with the south sidewalk of the existing Court Street Bridge. The pedestrianpedestrian bridge consisted of a 3-span-span structure that is approximately 200 feet long and 12 feet wide. Span 1 of the bridge will extend from a new concrete abutment (designated as "Begin “Begin Abutment") Abutment”) constructed with the elevated promenade over to the existing stone stone pier that is partially supporting the former Lehigh Valley Terminal Building. Span 2 will extend from this stone pier (designated as Pier #1) to a new single, circular column concrete pier installed in the Genesee River just south of the Court Street Bridge.Bridge. The foundation for this pier (designated as Pier #2) was drilled and socketed into the Genesee River bedrock. Span 3 wwasas cantileveredcantilevered from the new river pier over to the south fascia of Court Street Bridge. • RETAINING WALL: Construction of an approximately 95 -foot-foot long, new retaining wall at the southern end of the proposed Promenade. The proposed retaining was supported on a cast-in-in-place-place concrete footing. • RACEWAY WALL: Reconstruction and preservation of the Johnson-Seymour-Seymour Raceway Wall. The existinh wall was fully removed down to rock and replaced. A new 360-foot-foot-long-long raceway was constructedconstructed.. As part of the construction, new grouted anchor dowels were installed for the proposed Raceway Wall.Wall.

Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the proposed bridges, retaining and raceway walls. Mr. Fiorillo performed special inspection oversight on this project, as well as the drilldrilleded shaft inspection.

New Pasteurizer Building at Genesee Brewing Company —– Rochester, NY Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical engineer of record for this project. Mr. Fiorillo oversaw the geotechnical investigation for a 1-story-story slab- on-grade-grade structure. This project was located within close proximity to the existing bank of the Genesee River. Geotechnical recommendations for foundations and flflooroor slabs were provided.provided.

Wal-Mart:Wal-Mart: Various Sites in NY Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnical geotechnical engineer of record for these projectprojects.s. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the Walmart stores and associated pavement and stormwater stormwater management areas. Some of services generally performed included: • Subsurface exploration and geotechnical recommendations for proposed buildings, pavement, stormwater management structures, slopes, retaining walls.walls. • Shallow and deep foundation design recommendations; settlement analyses • Design of mechanically stabilized earth walls and reinforced slopes;slopes; global stability of slopesHydraulicslopesHydraulic conductivity (i.e. slug testing; double ring-infiltrometerring-infiltrometer testing) • InfiltrationInfiltration testing in accordance with NYSDEC Stormwater Management Design Manual, Appendix D. Infiltration Testing Requirements). • On-site-site inspections during construction.

ALDI Stores: Various Sites in NY

Michele A. Fiorillo, P.E. PageP a g e 13| 3

Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechngeotechnicalical engineer of record for these project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the Aldi stores and associated pavement and stormwater management areas. Mr. Fiorillo performed specialspecial inspection oversight on these projecprojects.ts.

Electric Substations: Various Sites in NY Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechngeotechnicalical engineer of record for these project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the improvements proposed at existing substations, and development of new substations.

Communications Towers: Various Sites in NY and PA Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechngeotechnicalical engineer of record for these project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of proposed monopole and self-supporting self-supporting communications towers. Recommendations for both shallow foundationsd and drilled shafts were generally presented.

Wind Turbines: Various Sites in NY and PA Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechngeotechnicalical engineer of record for these project. Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of proposed wind turbines. Recommendations for both shallow foundationsd and drilled shafts were generally presented.

Photo Voltaic Power Plants (Solar Array): Various Sites in NY and PA Mr. Fiorillo is the geotechnicalgeotechnical engineer of record for several solar projects. Some of the sites are: Pattersonville Solar Project,Project, Pattersonville, Schenectady,Schenectady, NY Brickchurch Solar (NY),(NY), Sodus,Sodus, Wayne,Wayne, NY Salt Point Solar,Solar, Hyde Park,Park, Dutchess County, NY Dubois Solar,Solar, Crawford,Crawford, Orange County, NY Reisender Solar,Solar, Ellenville,Ellenville, Ulster County, NY Livingston 4 Solar,Solar , Caledonia,Caledonia, Livingstone County, NY Costanza Solar,Solar, Westerlo,Westerlo, Albany County, NY Entersolar Amphenol Solar,Solar , Sidney,Sidney, DelawareDelaware County, NY AEGIS Solar, LLC,LLC, Canandaigua,Canandaigua, Ontario County, NY Cowburn Solar,Solar, Newfield,Newfield, PA Java Solar Power Facility,Facility, JJava,ava, Wyoming County, NY Harford Solar Array, Harford, Cortland County, NY

Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation,investigation, laboratory testing, and geotechnical evaluation for design of the foundations for the rack -supported-supported solar panels and associated ancillary structures. Recommendations for ground-screw-screw piles (i.e. Krinner ground screw), driven steel piles, pre-cast-cast ballasted foundations, drilled shafts, and shallow foundations were gegenerallynerally presented.presented.

SPECIALTY FOUNDATIONS Texas Roadhouse Restaurant —– Greece, New York Mr. Fiorillo performed oversight of the subsurface drilling investigation and geotechnical evaluation for design of the foundations for the new building. Recommendations for Rammed Aggregate Piers (RAPs) for support of shallow foundations were presentedpresented.. Mr. Fiorillo is the special inspector of record for this project. The type of RAPs used for this project consisted of VibroPier installed by Hayward- Baker. Mr. Fiorillo performed special inspection oversight on this project, as well as during the VibroPier installation. For this project a total of 167 VibroPiers were installed by Hayward-Baker.-Baker.

Michele A. Fiorillo, P.E. PageP a g e 14| 4

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

DAVID M. HESSLER,HESSLER, PP.E..E.

PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT, VICE-PRESIDENTVICE-PRESIDENT

HESSLER ASSOCIATES, INC.

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (David(David M. Hessler)Hessler)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. David M. Hessler,Hessler, Hessler Associates, Inc.Inc.,, 38329 Old Mill Way, Unit 8,

3 Ocean View, DE 19970.19970.

4 Q. What is your currentcurrent position?

5 A. Principal Consultant and Vice President.President.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Hessler Associates?Associates?

7 A. I have been employed with Hessler Associates for 28 years.years.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering from the

11 University of Maryland and a Bachelor of Arts from the University of

12 Hartford.Hartford. I have more than 25 years of experience in the prediction,

13 assessment, and mitigation of environmentaenvironmentall noise from new and existing

14 power generation and industrial facilitiesfacilities.. My current curriculum vitae is

15 attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

16 experience.

17 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Hessler Associates?Associates?

18 A. In my current position,position, I am responsible for anticipating potential noise

19 impacts at sensitive receptors near project sites and recommend practical

20 noise abatement measures to avoid any impacts.impacts.

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (David(David M. Hessler)Hessler)

1 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

3 A. No.No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. Yes.Yes. I havehave testified in various matters and proceedings before the Office

8 of the New York State Attorney General, the Washington State Energy

9 Facilities Siting Board, the Public Service Commission of West Virginia,

10 the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, Protection, the New

11 Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee, the Public Utilities Commission of

12 Ohio, the Wisconsin Public Service Commission, the South Dakota Public

13 Utilities Commission, the Maine State Government Energy, Utilities and

14 Technology Committee, and the the Rhode Island Energy Facility Siting

15 Board.Board.

16 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

17 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

18 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

19 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

20 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (David(David M. Hessler)Hessler)

1 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

2 sponsoring?sponsoring?

3 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibiExhibits:ts: Exhibit 19,19, Noise and

4 Vibration.Vibration.

5 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

6 your direction and/or supervision?

7 A. Yes.

8 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

9 A. Yes.

3 of 3

CURRICULUMCURRICULUM VITAE

DAVIDDAVID M. HHESSLERESSLER

Title: Principal Consultant,Consultant, Vice-President-President Hessler Associates, Inc.

Professional Affiliations: Professional Engineer (P.E.), Commonwealth of Virginia Member Institute of Noise Control Engineering (INCE)(INCE) National Council of Acoustical Consultants (NCAC)

Education: Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering (B.S.), 1997 Summa ccumum Laude A. James Clark School of Engineering University of Maryland, College Park, MD

Bachelor ofof Arts (B.A.), 1982 University of Hartford, Hartford, CT

Employer: Hessler Associates, Inc. 38329 Old Mill Way, Unit 8 Ocean View, DE 19970

Office Location: St. George, UT

Years in present position: 2828

Current Job Description: Acoustical engineer specializing in the prediction, assessment and mitigation of environmental noise from new and existing power generation and industrial facilities. Typical tasks include:

• Field measurement studies of existing ambient sound levels in the the vicinity of proposed project sites • Computer noise modeling of new facilities prior to construction • Environmental impact assessments for new projects • Noise mitigation design studies of new facilities • Verification measurements of completed facilities • DiagnosticDiagnostic studies of facilities with existing noise problems • Design and specification of noise mitigation measures • Educational lectures on noise issues for private corporations • Expert witness testimony

General Experience: As an outside consultant to nearly all all the major power industry EPC contractors,contractors, developers and OEM’s,OEM's, have been the principal acoustical designer of over 400400 power plants and industrial facilities worldwide ranging from a 3900 3900 MW power station in Saudi Arabia to numerous combustion turbine combined cycle plants,plants, data centers, diesel generator installations, refineries and wind turbine projects. Typically, the focus of the work on these projects was to anticipate potential noise impacts at sensitive receptors near the project and recommend practical practical noise abatement measures to avoid them. In addition, extensive verification measurements in and around the completed power plants, plants, industrial facilities and wind farms have been performed to confirm that the design recommendations have been successfullysuccessfully executed.

RepresentativeRepresentative Papers and Publications: 'Wind“Wind Turbine NoiseNoise",”, Chapter 7 Measuring and Analyzing WindWind TurbineTurbine Sound Levels,Levels, Multi-Science-Science Publishing Co., Brentwood, Essex, UK, JanJan.. 2012. Comprehensive book on all aspects of wind turbineturbine noise.noise. Each chapter written by a recognized expert in that subject.

Teleseminar 'Wind “Wind Turbine Siting and Best Practices", Practices”, National Regulatory Research Institute (NRRI), Invited speaker, Jan. 2012.

"Best“Best Practices Guidelines for Assessing Sound Emissions Emissions from Proposed Wind Farms and Measuring the Performance of Completed Projects",Projects”, Prepared for the Minnesota Public Utilities CommissionCommission under the auspices of the National Association of Regulatory Utility CommissionersCommissioners (NARUC), Oct. 2011.

"Accounting“Accounting for Background Noise when Measuring Operational Noise from Wind TurbinesTurbines",”, Fourth International Meeting on Wind Turbine Noise, Rome, Italy, Apr. 2011.

"Recommended“Recommended noise level design goals and limits at residential receptors for wind turbine developments developments in the United States", States”, Noise Control Engineering JournalJournal,, J.59 (1), January-February-February 2011.

'Wind“Wind tunnel testing of microphone windscreen performance applied to field measurements of wind turbines", turbines”, Third International Meeting on Wind Turbine Noise,Noise, Aalborg, Denmark, June 2009.

"Experimental“Experimental study to determine wind-induced-induced noise and windscreen attenuation effects on microphone response for environmental wind turbine and other applications",applications”, Noise Control Engineering JournalJournal,, J.56, July-August-August 2008.

Expert Witness Cases: Before the Washington State Energy Facilities Siting Board (EFSEC) on behalf of Bechtel and the Cherry Point Cogeneration Project, Bellingham, WA, 2003. 2003. Permitting support for a proposed combined cycle power plant facility.

BeforeBefore the Public Service Commission of West Virginia on behalf of the Longview Power Project near Morgantown, WV, WV, 2006. Permitting support for a proposed coal-firedcoal-fired power plant facility.

Before the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection on behalfbehalf of Waste Management and the Alliance Sanitary Landfill in Taylor, PA, 2006. Support in defending against a Class Action Lawsuit brought by neighbors of the landfill.landfill.

Before the Office of the Attorney General of New York on behalf of the Hudson Valley CommunityCommunity College Cogeneration (Diesel) Plant. Support in defending against a Class Action Lawsuit brought by neighbors.

2

Before the Hanover County (VA) Board of Supervisors Supervisors on behalf of Martin Marietta Marietta Materials and the Doswell Quarry, Quarry, 2008. Permitting support for a proposed quarry expansion.

Before the New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee on behalf of Granite Reliable Power, LLC, 2008. Permitting support for a proposed wind turbine project in Northern New Hampshire.Hampshire.

Before the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Ohio Power Siting Board on behalf of EverPower Renewables and the Buckeye Wind Project, 2008. Permitting support for a proposed wind turbine project in OhioOhio..

Before the Wisconsin Public Service Commission on behalf of Clean WisconsinWisconsin with regard to the proposed Highland Wind Farm in Forest, WI. Docket No. 2535 -CE-CE-100.-100. Engaged as an independent expert to evaluate the Applicant's Applicant’s sound studies and the testimony of opposition groups.

Before the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, Ohio Power Siting Board on behalf of EverPower Renewables and the Buckeye II Wind Project, 2012. Permitting support for a proposed wind turbine project in Ohio.

Before the Maine State Government Energy, Utilities and Technology Committee on behalf of Patriot Renewables and the Beaver Ridge Wind Project, 2014.2014. Peer review of operational sound testing by others.

Before the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission on behalf of the Commission Staff to review the noise aspects of the application for the Crocker Wind Farm Project. Docket EL17-055.EL17-055. April 2018.

Before the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission on behalf of the Commission Staff to review the noise aspects of the application for the Dakota Range Wind Project. Docket EL18-003.EL18-003. April 2012018.8.

BeforeBefore the Rhode Island Energy Facility Siting Siting Board, Board, servingserving as an an outside expertexpert to the Town of Burrillville, RI reviewingreviewing the noise aspects of the Clear River Energy Center permit application, Docket SB-2015-06,SB-2015-06, December 2018.

BeforeBefore the the South Dakota Public Utilities Utilities Commission, serving as an an outside expertexpert to the PUC Staff reviewingreviewing the noise aspects of the Deuel HarvestHarvest Wind Project permit application, Docket EL18-053,EL18-053, April 2019.

3

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

GIRISH BEHAL, PMP

DIRECTOR-STRATEGIC-STRATEGIC INITIATIVES AND DEVELOPMENT

SNC-LAVALINSNC-LAVALIN

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Girish(Girish Behal)Behal)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Girish Behal,Behal, SNCSNC-Lavalin,-Lavalin, 150150 State Street, Suite 120, Rochester,Rochester, New

3 York 14614.14614.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Director-Strategic-Strategic Initiatives and Development.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with SNC-Lavalin?SNC-Lavalin?

7 A. I have been employed with SNCSNC-Lavalin-Lavalin since 2011.2011.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Civil Engineering from Maharaja

11 Sayajirao University, India and a Master of Science in Electrical and

12 Computer Engineering from Worchester Polytechnic InstituteInstitute.. I also

13 received a Master of Business Administration from the University of

14 Rochester.Rochester. I have more than 14 years of experience in onshore and

15 offshore renewables, transmission, and distribution projects for voltage

16 levels from 11kV to 345 kV, involving substation, overhead, and

17 underground transmission lines. lines. My current curriculum vitaevitae is attached

18 and provides a full history of my relevant professional experience.

19 Q. What are your current responsibilities at SNC-Lavalin?SNC-Lavalin?

20 A. In my current position,position, I am responsible for leading and managing project

21 development in the area of onshore and offshore renewables, portfolio

1 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Girish(Girish Behal)Behal)

1 management of key projects in the area of FERC 1000, interregional

2 transmission planning, and strategic due diligencediligence.. I also provide project-

3 specific oversight to the engineering teams that perform interconnection

4 analysis, congestion analysis, and additional studies and engineering to

5 support projects in the power sector.

6 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

7 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

8 A. No.No.

9 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

10 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

11 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

12 A. Yes.Yes. I have testified in various local and state proceedings related to the

13 following: Station 251251 and Station 124 Expansion Projects in New York;

14 several new 115 -kV-kV substations before the Connecticut Siting Council;

15 and a 115 -kV-kV circuit separation project before the Massachusetts

16 Department of Public Utilities.

17 Q. What is the purpose of your testimonytestimony in this proceeding?

18 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

19 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

20 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

21 the Towns of Minden andand Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

2 of 3

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Girish(Girish Behal)Behal)

1 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

2 sponsoring?sponsoring?

3 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 88,, Electric System

4 Production Modeling.Modeling.

5 Q. Were these portions of the Application Application prepared by you, or under

6 your direction and/or supervision?

7 A. Yes.

8 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

9 A. Yes.

3 of 3

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

Mr. Girish Behal, PMP, has more than 18 years of experience in a variety of onshore and offshore renewables, Transmission and Distribution projects for voltage levels from 11 kV to 345 kV, involving substation, overheadove►head and underground transmission lines, Statcom, Static Var Compensator and Phase shifting transformers. His responsibilities have included Project Development, Project Management, Contract Management and Negotiation, Engineering Management, planning, coordination of various disciplines, constructionconstruction supervision and outage management. Mr. Behal'sBehal’s current focus is to provide valuevalue-added-added development solutions for HVAC and HVDC transmission, onshore and offshore renewables, energy storage and FERC 1000 project development in the United States utilizing utilizing his engineering and business experience. Prior to that, he has managed several transmission and distribution projects from project scope definition, includingincluding initial system planning studies, to commissioning and closeout, including managing a group of Project Managers and teams to supportsuppo►t client needs. Mr. Behal has experience with siting and pe►mittingpermitting of Transmission and Distribution facilities including representing the client in front of regulatory and public agencies. Mr. Behal is a creative problemproblem solver with a keen ability to resolve project issues

SECTORS OF EXPERTISE Years of Experience Power )› Power Transmission and Distribution; Wind, Solar and Tidal )› 18 years Power; Interconnections Oil & Gas )› Petroleum Refining; Petrochemicals Years with SNC-LavalinSNC-Lavalin Complementary sectors )› Professional / Consulting Services )› 8 years Additional Expertise )› Due diligence ; Building & Leading Multi-disciplined-disciplined Teams; Contract Negotiation and Management; Energy Storage Systems

Key Positions EDUCATION )› Director 2017 Master of Business Administration, Simon Business School , University of Rochester, )› Project Manager Rochester, New York, United States )› Senior Project Manager 2011 Master of Science in Electrical and Computer Engineering (Power Systems),

Worchester Polytechnic Institute, Worchester, Massachusetts, United States Languages Graduate Certificate in Power Systems, Worchester PolytechnicPolytechnic Institute, Worchester, 2009 )› English Massachusetts, United States )› Hindi 1999 Bachelor of Civil Engineering, Maharaja Sayajirao University, Baroda, Gujarat, India

1995 Diploma in Civil Engineering, Maharaja Sayajirao University, Baroda, Gujarat, India

EXPERIENCE

SINCE 2011 SNC-LAVALIN,SNC-LAVALIN, ROCHESTER, NEW YORK, UNITED STATES Clean Power Since 2017 Director - Strategic Initiatives and Development

)› Lead and Manage Client and Project Development in the area of onshore and offshore Renewables )› Portfolio management of key projects in the area of transmission interconnection planning, strategic due diligences )› Lead multi disciplinary teams to deliver energy system solutions combining energy

2019/03 Page 1 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

storage, renewables and grid design Site Experience )› Lead, Mentor and Manage multi-location-location and multi-cultural-cultural project teams for Project Site Experience Execution )› India )› Lead Consulting assignments for strategic clients )› United States )› Grow, maintain and manage client relationships

Project Manager, SouthFork Offshore Wind Farm Project ,, Conceptual engineering, Deepwater wind, New York, United States (09/2017 - present) Computer Applications

SNC-LSNC-L supported the client during the interconnection process and delivered )› Primavera preliminary engineering for the client for the 120 MW offshore wind project in the US. )› Microsoft Project

)› Microsoft office suite Power Transmission & Distribution - Montreal Microsoft office suite 2015-20172015 - 2017 Senior Project Manager —– Strategic Initiatives )› Lotus Notes › SAP Lead and Manage Project Development in the area of onshore and offshore ,› Autocad Renewables, portfolio management of key projects in the area of FERC 1000, Inter-Inter- regional transmission planning mandates and strategic due diligences Lead, Mentor and Manage multi-location-location and multi-cultural-cultural project teams for Project Execution Grow, maintain and manage client relationships Create cross functional teams to address client needs Support Organization'sOrganization’s key strategic growth initiatives

Galloo IslandIsland Wind Project ,, Planning, Apex, New York, United States (11/2016 - 02/2017)

SNC-LavalinSNC-Lavalin performed production cost analysis utilizing Promod for the New York State Department of State Article X filing to support the project.

Project Manager, South Fork Offshore WindWind Farm ,, Preliminary engineering, Deep Water WindViand South Fork LLC, New York, United States (07/2017)

South Fork Wind Farm (SFWF) is a 90 MW offshore wind farm connecting to Long Island. It is a unique project that entails a very long undersea cable for the interconnection to the project point of interconnection.

Project Manager, SPPSPP-MISO-MISO Interregional Model Development ,, Strategic Planning, Confidential, United States (06/2016 - 02/2017)

The Client Mandated SNC-LavalinSNC-Lavalin to create an inter-regional-regional system model and perform production cost analysis utilizing PROMOD to evaluate interregional transmission project opportunities for SPP and MISO.

Power Transmission & Distribution - Calgary 2012-20152012 - 2015 Senior Project Manager

)› Lead, mentor and manage a group of project managers and project teams in the planning, execution and management of a portfolio of mid to large size brown field and green field substation and transmission line capital projects. )› Managed team to deliver CAPEX portfolio value of $58.9M, $51.3M and $67.4M for the years 2012, 2013 and 2014 to the client. )› Recruit and retain project team members including Project Managers, Construction and Commissioning Managers,Managers, Engineers and Project Support staff. )› Direct project leadership on specific projects.

2019/03 Page 2 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

)› Maintain and manage client relationships for a portfolio of projects currently managed by SNC-Lavalin.SNC-Lavalin. )› Support marketing and business development efforts as needed.

Project Manager, Station 124 Phase Shifting Transformer, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Penfield, New York, United States, CA $34 000 000 (03/2012 - 08/2014)

The project involved engineering, procurement and construction of two (2) 115 kV, + 20% Phase Shifting Transformers, 138/184/230 MVA at station 124 in RG&E territory to comply with FERC ruling. The project was required to support 20% increase in the power output from the interconnected NuclearNuclear station facilities. This project involved major expansion of existing facilities. The substation (Station 124) also required significant Federal State and Local environmental permitting.

)› Completed Project ahead of schedule and under budget. )› Completed complex outage during the nuclear unit outage and avoiding future outages that would require down powering of the unit.

Rochester Gas and Electric Program Portfolio, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, New York, United States (03/2012 - 12/2014)

Managed a group of Project Managers to deliver a portfolio of projects to the Client at various voltages and various stages of project lifecycle. The team delivered variety of projects from substation upgrades to major expansions ofof the transmission and distribution system.

Delivered CAPEX portfolio value of $58.9M, $51.3M and $67.4M for the years 2012, 2013 and 2014 to the client.

Station 124 Static Var Compensator ,, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Penfield, New York, United States, CA $30 500 000 (04/2012 - 08/2013)

Engineer, procure and construct a -100/+200-100/+200 MVAR Static Var Compensator (SVC) at Station 124 to provide reliability support in the area. The SVC is installed at 14kV and connected to the 115 kV system through two (2) 200 MVA transformers. This project involved significant expansion of existing Station 124 resulting in needs for Federal, State and local environmental permitting.

)› Completed the project on schedule and on budget )› Negotiated savings to the tune of US$ 140K for the client on change orders for the contractors )› Resolved significant technical design issues to ensure the functionality of the system being installed.

2011 - 2012 1 Project Manager

)› Developed project scope, budget and schedule for electrical transmission capital improvement projects. )› Managed and delivered technically complex key projects to the client on schedule )› Built rapport with client'sclient’s management and staff gaining their trust and confidence. )› Represented the client organization in public and regulatory forums. )› Collaborated with cross functional teams in developing, evaluating and recommending contracts and procurement of equipment and services. )› Assembled and directed a distributed project execution team in a Multi-Office-Office Execution arrangement.

Project Manager, Substation Automation Project ,, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Rochester, New York, United States, CA $36 000 000, Multiple (08/2011 - 04/2012)

The project mandate was to create the project scope of work documents, project estimates and project schedule for the client for various automation upgrades for 12 substations. The mandate included pre-conceptual-conceptual engineering for the project.

2019/03 Page 3 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

)› Project estimates and scopes delivered to the client on schedule and on budget. )› Exceeded client CAPEX goals for the project.

University of Rochester Substation Project ,, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Rochester, New York, United States, CA $28 000000 000, 115 kV/12 kV, 3000 Amp rated substation (08/2011 - 12/2012)

The University of Rochester (U of R) has requested additional supply to be provided by RG&E to serve its projected growth load and resolve reliability issues. The substation will be a new 115 kV/11.5 kV breaker and a half substation with two (2) 115 kV/11.5 kV 70 MVA transformers. Remote work is planned at stations 33, 82, and Mortimer/National Grid for line protection. Fiber optics will be installed from station 251 to stations 33, 82,82, and Mortimer for communications.

)› Project Option Evaluations completed on schedule and under budget. )› Lead the project team through successful project siting process.

Station 124 Phase Shifting Transformer, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Penfield, New York,Yo►k, United States, CA $34 000 000 (12/2011 - 12/2012)

The project involved engineering, procurement and construction of two (2) 115 kV, + 20% Phase Shifting Transformers, 138/184/230 MVA at station 124 in RG&E territory to comply with FERC ruling. The project was required to support 20% increase in the power output from the interconnected Nuclear station facilities. This project involved major expansion of existing facilities. The substation (Station 124) also required significant FederalFederal State and Local environmental permitting.

Completed Project ahead of schedule and under budget. Completed complex outage during the nuclear unit outage and avoiding future outages that would require down powering of the unit.

Station 124 Static Var Compensator Project, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Penfield, New York, United States, CA $30 500 000, -100/+200-100/+200 MVAR SVC (12/2011 - 12/2012)

Engineer, procure and construct a -100/+200-100/+200 MVAR Static Var Compensator (SVC) at Station 124 to provide reliability support in the area. The SVC is installed at 14kV and connected to the 115 kV system through two (2) 200 MVA transformers. This project involved significant expansion of existing Station 124 resulting in needs for Federal, State and local environmental permitting.

)› Completed the project on schedule and on budget )› Negotiated savings to the tune of US$ 140K for the client on change orders for the contractors )› Resolved significant technical design issues to ensure the functionality of the system being installed.

Project Manager, Station 124124-42-204-42-204 Fiber ,, Project Management, lberdrolaIberdrola USA, Rochester Area, New York, United States, CA $1 750 000 (12/2011 - 12/2012)

Design, permit, procure and install 24.2 miles of fiber for system protection communication between station 124, 42 and station 204.

Project completed under budget

2004-20112004 - 2011 NORTHEAST UTILITIES SERVICE COMPANY,COMPANY, BERLIN, CONNECTICUT, UNITED STATES Transmission Business Projects 2006-20112006 - 2011 Project Lead

)› Responsible for development of project scope, budget, schedule performance for assigned electrical transmission capital improvement projects.

2019/03 Page 4 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

)› Responsible for representing the organization in public and regulatory forums. )› Responsible for assembling and leading a diverse, multifunctional project team consisting of internal company employees, contractors, consultants to effectively and efficiently deliver projects on time. )› Responsible for establishing outage dates and coordinating outages with system operators and the outage teams. )› Responsible for creating detailed project schedules, including identification of major milestones, for overseeing, controlling, communicating and managing all activities required to complete assigned transmission system capital improvement projects. )› Responsible for monitoring and controlling project costs through preparation of monthly cash flows, verification of actual or committed costs to estimated costs and identification of cost variances that require further action to ensure completion within budget. )› Responsible for working with cross functional teams in developing, evaluating and recommending construction contracts and procurement of high value project specific equipment and services.

Project Manager, Hollow Core and Obsolete Equipment Replacement Program, Project Management, Northeast Utilities (CL&P and WMECO), Multiple, Connecticut, United States, CA $170 000 000, 115 kV/345-kVkV/345-kV (10/2010 - 05/2011)

This program was a five year system wide equipment replacement program which involved replacement of obsolete equipment in both 115-kV-kV and 345-kV-kV systems across 80 plus substations in two operating companies owned by Northeast Utilities.

)› Created an extensive program execution plan )› Managed and negotiated long term outage plan for multiple stations )› Managed and negotiated work agreements with union workforce

Project Manager, SherwoodShe►wood Substation, Project Management, Northeast Utilities (CL&P), Westport,Westpo►t, Connecticut, United States, CA $23 860 000 (03/2010 - 05/2011)

Build a new greenfield substation 115-13.8115-13.8 kV to support local load growth. The project involved tapping into the existing 115-kV-kV lines and adding two 115-13.8115-13.8 kV auto-transformers-transformers and fourfour switchgear units.

)› Successfully lead the permitting of the new Substation )› Managed critical relationships with neighboring property owners

Project Manager, IEC 61850 Simulator Laboratory Program, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Berlin, Connecticut, United States, CA $2 500 000 (04/2009 - 08/2010)

Design and implement a prototype IEC 61850 technology laboratory to create standards and implementation across the Northeast Utilities organization. This project involved a new technologytechnology for the organization, significant organization change and learning implementation in addition to establishment of the laboratory.

)› Successfully tested and implemented a new technology

Project Manager, WaterfordWate►ford Substation, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Waterford,Wate►ford, Connecticut, United States, CA $25 000 000 (08/2007 - 05/2010)

Build a new greenfield substation 115-27.6115-27.6 kV to support local load growth. The project involves tapping into the existing 115-kV-kV lines and adding two 115-27.6115-27.6 kV auto-transformers.-transformers.

)› Successfully led the project team through permitting process. )› Complex remote end work completed within the tight project schedule.

Project Manager, Critical Infrastructure Protection program, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Connecticut, United States, CA $24 000 000 (02/2008 - 05/2009)

2019/03 Page 5519 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

This project involves creating separate communication networks, modifications to existing systems and enhancing physical security for critical cyber assets across three states (Service Territories).

)› Completed project under budget and on schedule )› Ensured compliance with regulatory requirements )› Managed multi-locationalmulti-locational teams

Project Manager, Ludlow Auto Transformer Replacement ,, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Ludlow, Massachusetts, United States, CA $10 250 000, 345 kV (09/2007 - 12/2009)

Design, procure and install three-single-single phase 200 MVA units at Ludlow in spare position for connections at a later date.

)› Project Completed on schedule and budget.

Project Manager, Wilton Substation, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Wilton, Connecticut, United States, CA $11 500 000 (11/2006 - 05/2008)

Build a new greenfield 115-27.6115-27.6 kV Substation for local load growth. The project involves tapping into the existing 115-kV-kV lines and adding two 115-27.6115-27.6 kV auto-transformers.-transformers. The most unique part of the project is extremely small construction site bordered by wetlands with species of special concern.

)› Complex construction due to limited space.

Project Manager, Devon Substation Upgrade Project ,, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Milford, Connecticut, United States, CA $8 520 000, 115-kV-kV (04/2006 - 10/2008)

The project involves replacement of existing equipment and addition of new equipment for increase in thermal ratings and reliability of the station. The most unique part of the project is to enable reliable supplysupply to the distribution system downstream with multiple concurrent and overlapping equipment outages.

)› Completed complex outage schedule (72+ outages) with Zero incidents )› Negotiated and awarded lumpsum construction contract for construction resulting in change orders less than 3% of the contract value.

Assistant Project Manager, Bethel to Norwalk Project ,, Project Management, Northeast Utilties ,, Connecticut, United States, CA $397 000 000 (01/2006 - 08/2006)

Build a new 345-kV-kV overhead and underground Transmission line between Danbury, CT and Norwalk CT with two transition stations. Reconductor and upgrade existing 115 kV lines. Build new 115 kV line. Install two 400MVA shunt reactors to the system. Build extensive upgrades and expansions for Substations in Norwalk CT and Danbury CT including two new 345-kV-kV GIS substations.

Transmission Business Projects 2005-20062005 - 2006 Associate Engineer/Project Lead

)› Responsible for development of project scope, budget, schedule performance for assigned electrical transmission capital improvement projects. )› Responsible for representing the organization in public and regulatory forums. )› Responsible for assembling and leading a diverse, multifunctional project team consiconsistingsting of internal company employees, contractors, consultants to effectively and efficiently deliver projects on time. )› Responsible for establishing outage dates and coordinating outages with system operators and the outage teams. )› Responsible for creating detailed project schedules, including identification of major milestones, for overseeing,

2019/03 Page 6 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

controlling, communicating and managing all activities required to complete assigned transmission system capital improvement projects. )› Responsible for monitoring and controlling project costs through preparation of monthly cash flflows,ows, verification of actual or committed costs to estimated costs and identification of cost variances that require further action to ensure completion within budget. )› Responsible for working withwith cross functional teams in developing, evaluating and recommending construction contracts and procurement of high value project specific equipment and services.

Assistant Project Manager, Bethel to Norwalk Project ,, Project Management, NortheastNortheast Utilities, Connecticut, United States, CA $397 000 000, 115-kV,-kV, 345-kV-kV (09/2005 - 08/2006)

Build a new 345-kV-kV overhead and underground Transmission line between Danbury, CT and Norwalk CT with two transition stations. Reconductor and upgrade existing 115 kV lines. Build new 115 kV line. Install two 400MVA shunt reactors to the system. Build extensive upgrades and expansions for Substations in Norwalk CT and Danbury CT including two new 345-kV-kV GIS substations.

Transmission Business Projects 2004-20052004 - 2005 Assistant Engineer

)› Complete responsibilities for assigned portions of project management responsibilities. )› Assist Project Manager in developing and evaluating construction contracts and procurement of high value items like Shunt Reactors. )› Assist Project Managers in managing overall scope, budget and schedule of high profile electrical transmission projects including schedule adherence, project communications and projects engineering, design and construction services. )› Coordinate project team efforts with maintenance for project turnover to maintenance. )› Perform technical and commercial review and provide recommendation to the management for project changes. )› Performed first line technical and commercial approval of contracontractorctor invoices. )› Performed technical and commercial review of bids.

Assistant Project Manager, Bethel to Norwalk Project ,, Project Management, Northeast Utilities, Connecticut, United States, CA $397 000 000 (2004 - 09/2005)

Build a new 345-kV-kV overhead and underground Transmission line between Danbury, CT and Norwalk CT with two transition stations. Reconductor and upgrade existing 115 kV lines. Build new 115 kV line. Install two 400MVA shunt reactors to the system. Build extensive upgradupgradeses and expansions for Substations in Norwalk CT and Danbury CT including two new 345-kV-kV GIS substations.

2003-20042003 - 2004 CURTIS PARTITION CORP,CORP, NEW YORK, NEW YORK, UNITED STATES Project Engineer

)› Assist project managers in daily field operations including manpower allocations, create and track RFI'sRFI’s submitted to GC, attend project meetings, prepare project catch-upcatch-up plans. )› Evaluate general contractor schedule, prepare resource-loaded-loaded schedule for the company to assist in manpower optimization. )› Evaluate new project management softwares and recommend project management software for organization wide implementation.

1999-20011999 - 2001 LARSEN & TOUBRO LTD,LTD, BARODA, GUJARAT, INDIA Project Engineer

)› Assisted project manager in preparation of project progress reports, scheduling, schedule updating, vendor follow up and contractor invoice processing. )› Assisted project manager in consolidating change order documentation.

2019/03 Page 7197 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

)› Coordinated with client/owner'sclient/owner’s engineers, detail engineering contractorcontractor,, site engineering for design review and drawing submittal etc. at design/build refinery project site. )› Reviewed and processed site and contract related drawings and documentation (RFI's).(RFI’s). )› Construction observation, inspection and issuance of rectification "punch lists". )› Assisted engineering manager in project engineering issues, including discussions and clarifications of contractual and technical issues with detail engineering subcontractor for shop drawings review. )› Provided field support for preparation of "As-Built"-Built" drawings. )› Technical discussions and clarifications with engineering and vendor as required.

Assistant Project Manager, Milk Powder Plant and Liquid Milk Plant expansion Project, Project Management, National DailyDairy Development Board (NDDB), Banaskantha, Gujarat, India, CA $29 540 000 (08/2000 - 07/2001)

This project was an Engineering Procurement and Construction contract for design, supply and construction Liquid Milk Plant (35MMTPA) and Milk Powder plant (20MMTPA). This was expansion project.

Assistant Project Manager, Hydrogen plant, De-HydrogenisationDe-Hydrogenisation De-sulphurisationDe-sulphurisation plant, Offsite and Utilities Package, Project Management, Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited, Vishakhapatnam, Odisha, India, CA $261 000 000 (07/1999 - 09/2000)

: This project was an Engineering Procurement and Construction contract for design, supply and construction of Hydrogen plant, De-HydrogenisationDe-Hydrogenisation De-sulphurisationDe-sulphurisation plant including all related offsite and Utilities as needed for Plant operation.

PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS

SINCE 2015 Institute of Electrical & Electronic Engineers, Membership no. 93512798

SINCE 2007 Project Management Institute (PM(PMI),I), Membership no. 1021284

PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT

2007 Certificate in Project Management, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts, United States

2007 Project Management Professional, Project Management Institute, Newtown Square, Pennsylvania, United States

ADDITIONAL TRAINING

2013 1 Leadership Training, Knightsbridge, Toronto, Ontario, Canada

PUBLICATIONS AND PRESENTATIONS

HVDC - Powering the Future, Rochester, United States, 2017 Eroding Values and Emerging Ethical Issues in contemporary Indian Management, Baroda, Gujarat, India, 2000 Environmental Impact Assessment Methodologies: Critical Review, Jhansi, Uttar Pradesh, India, 1998

COMMITTEES

SINCE 2015 WG 15.05.08 HVDC and FACTS Economics and Operating Strategies, United States

2019/03 Page 8 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

.)) GIRISH BEHAL, PMP SNC • LAVALIN

SINCE 2015 WG 15.05.18 Studies for Planning of HVDC

SINCE 2015 WG 15.05.19 Practical Technologies for VSC HVDC Systems

DIRECTORSHIPS

SINCE 2017 I Co-Co- Vice Chair

AWARDS AND SCHOLARSHIPS

2015 The Simon School of Business Scholarship (25% tuition fees), University of Rochester, Rochester, New York, United States

2001 University Fellow, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States

2000 First place in Young Managers Competition, Baroda Management Association, Baroda, Gujarat, India

1999 Express Group Gold Medal, The Maharaja Sayajirao University, Baroda, Gujarat, India

1999 Shri K H Patel Gold Medal , The Maharaja Sayajirao University, Baroda, India

1999 Late Friend (Dr.) Piyush Parikh Gold Medal Fund, The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda, Baroda, India

ACADEMIC POSTS

2002 - 2003 1 Graduate Research Assistant , The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States

PUBLIC HEARINGS

2018 Pre-filed-filed Testimony for Article 10, Exhibit 8 for Case 16-F-055916-F-0559 for Bluestone Wind Energy Facility, New York State Department of Public Services, United States

2018 Pre-filed-filed Testimony for Article 10, Exhibit 8 for Case 16-F-026716-F-0267 for Deer River Wind Energy Facility, New York State Department of Public Services, UnitedUnited States

2017 Pre-filed-filed Testimony for Article 10, Exhibit 8 for Case 15-F-032715-F-0327 for Galloo Island Wind Energy Facility, New York State Department of Public Services, United States

2013 Station 251 Project, Town of Brighton Planning Board, Brighton, New York, United States

2011 Station 124 Expansion Project, Town of Penfield, Planning and Zoning Commission, Penfield, New York, United States

2010 New 115-kV-kV substation in Westport,CT, Connecticut Siting Council, Westport, Connecticut, United States

2010 115-kV-kV Circuit Separation Project, Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities, Boston, Massachusetts, United States

2008 New 115-IN-KV Substation in Waterford, CT, Connecticut Siting Council, Waterford, Connecticut, United States

2006 New 115 kV/11.5 INKV substation, Connecticut Siting Council, New Britain, Connecticut, United States

2019/03 Page 9 / 9 CURRICULUM VITAE

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

KENNETH L. AYERS

MANAGING ATTORNEYATTORNEY

THE AYERS LAW FIRMFIRM,, PLLC

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Kenneth(Kenneth L. Ayers)Ayers)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Kenneth L. Ayers,Ayers, The Ayers Law Firm,Firm, PLLC,PLLC, 50 Grand Street, Palatine

3 Bridge, New York 13428.13428.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Managing Attorney.Attorney.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with The Ayers Law FirmFirm,, PPLLC?LLC?

7 A. I have been employedemployed with The Ayers Law Firm,Firm, PLLCPLLC since 2004.2004.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts from Syracuse University in 1969 and a

11 Master of Arts from Dartmouth College in 1973. 1973. I also received a Juris

12 Doctor from Albany Law School of Union University in 1982. I have

13 more than 35 years of experience in the practice of law, including the

14 areas of real estate development, land use, municipal law, environmental law,

15 construction lawlaw,, and litigation in both federal and state courts. courts. My current

16 curriculum vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant

17 professional experienceexperience..

18 Q. What are your current responsibilresponsibilitiesities at The Ayers Law Firm, Firm,

19 PLLCPLLC??

20 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for overseeing and leading the

21 firm'sfirm’s general civil law practice.practice.

1 of 2

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Kenneth(Kenneth L. Ayers)Ayers)

1 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the EnviroEnvironment?nment?

3 A. No.No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

11 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, MontgomeryMontgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 331,1, Local Laws and

16 Ordinances.Ordinances.

17 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

18 your direction and/or supervision?

19 A. Yes.

20 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

21 A. Yes.

2 of 2

RESUME KENNETH LL. AYERS 50 West Grand Street Palatine Bridge, New York 13428 (518) 673-8100673-8100

LEGAL EXPERIENCE

PRIVATE LAW PRACTICE - 1983 to Present General Civil Practice including: • Real Estate - real estate fifinancingnancing and development, contracts, closings, residential and commercial leases, zoning and land use matters, tax assessments; • Commercial - partnerships, LLCs, business and agricultural contracts, leases, financing, collections and secured transactions; • Corporate - financing,financing, employment contracts, inincorporation,corporation, dissolution, equipment leasing • Environmental - SEQRA, Mined Land Reclamation Act, Historic Preservation, commercial and agricultural regulatory compliance; • Surveying - litigation, consulting, seminars and conferences; • Personal Injury;Injury; • LitigationLitigation - Real Estate, Land Use, Commercial, InsuranceInsurance;; and • Municipal —– Zoning, Land Use, SEQRA, Eminent Domain.

ASSISTANT COUNSEL - Dormitory Authority of the State of New York-5/82-5/82 to 12/88 Primary responsibility for providing and supervising legal services to the eighth largestbest public construction agency in the United States including the following areas: • Architectural, Engineering, Purchasing and Construction Contracts - negotiating, drafting, interpreting and public bidding; • Real Estate - zoning and land use matters, negotiation and drafting mortgages and commercial leases and eminent domain proceedings; • Environmental Law - SEQRA, Superfund, Asbestos Abatement and Cost- Recovery, Toxic Torts, Historic Preservation; • Litigation - complex architectural malpractice and construction cases, civil rights and personal injury; • Affirmation Action - M/WBE and EEO; and • Legislation - drafted departmental bills, coordinated with other agencies, and assisted Governor's counsel's office in researching, drafting and reviewing various departmental and program bills.

LEGAL INTERN - New York State Energy Research and Development Authority - 2/81 to 5/82 Researched and drafted pleadings, memorandum of law and proposed settlement agreements in complexcomplex nuclear litigation.litigation. Research and drafted legislative bills and memoranda in support. Reviewed and summarized proposed and newly enacted state and federal laws and regulations on a variety of environmental and energy related topics.

STUDENT INTERN - GoGovernmentvernment Law Center of Albany Law School - 6/80 to 12/82 Researched and wrote a manual on selected legal issues in highway law and successfully developed and planned a state-widestate-wide seminar for its presentation to attorneys and land surveyors.

EDUCATION

Albany Law School of Union University - Juris Doctor - 1982 Dartmouth College - Master of Arts and Liberal Studies -1973-1973 Syracuse University - Bachelor of Arts - 1969

OTHER EXPERIENCE

High School Social Studies Teacher, 19691969-1979-1979

COMMUNITY SERVICE

Member, Fort Plain School Board,Board, 1997-20061997-2006

PUBLICATIONS

"Surveyor's“Surveyor’s Handbook New York State Highway Law",Law”, 2008, Palatine Press

"Land Titles in New York StateState-- Selected Legal Issues", 1998, New York State Association of Professional Land Surveyors, Inc.

"Adjoining"Adjoining Landowner Boundary Law and Dispute Resolution in New York", 1995 New York State Association of Professional Land Surveyors, Inc.

"New York Riparian Law: Selected Legal Issues", 1993 New York State Association of Professional Land Surveyors, Inc.

"Vermo'Vermontnt Highway Law: A Summary of Selected Vermont Statutes and Common Law", 1989 Vermont Society of Land Surveyors

"Highway Law and the Land Surveyor", 1981; Supplement, 1988. New York State Association of Professional Land Surveyors, Inc.

ADMITTED TO PRACTICPRACTICEE All New York State Courts, United States District Court for the Northern District of New York Supreme Court of the United States

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

JOSEPH B. GREEN

DEVELOPMENT DIRECTORDIRECTOR

COMMUNITY ENERGY SOLAR,SOLAR, LLC

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Joseph(Joseph B. Green)Green)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Joseph B. Green, Green, Community Energy Solar, LLCLLC,, Three Radnor Corp

3 Center, Suite 300, Radnor, PA 19087.19087.

4 Q. What is your current position?position?

5 A. Development Director.Director.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Community EnergyEnergy??

7 A. I have been employed with Community Energy since 2017.2017.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of SciencSciencee in Polymer Chemistry from Carnegie

11 Mellon University.University. I have more than 1010 years of experience in developing

12 and constructing renewable energy products in New York, Pennsylvania,

13 Ohio, and Virginia.Virginia. My current curriculum vitae is attached and provides a

14 fullfull history of my relevant professional experience.

15 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Community EnergyEnergy??

16 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for overseeing and leading the

17 development of renewable energy projects, including project design, design,

18 landowner selection/contracting, initiation of permitting submissions,

19 coordination with municipal officials and permitting departments,

20 completion of tax negotiations,negotiations, and fieldfield reconnaissance for

1 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Joseph(Joseph B. Green)Green)

1 archaeological resources, wetlands, and threatened and eendangeredndangered

2 species.species.

3 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

4 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

5 A. No.No.

6 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

7 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

8 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

9 A. Yes.Yes. I have served as an expert witness in several zoning hearings for

10 projects in Pennsylvania.

11 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

12 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

13 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

14 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

15 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

16 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

17 sponsoring?sponsoring?

18 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 331,1, Local Laws and

19 Ordinances.Ordinances.

20 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

21 your direction and/orand/or supervision?

2 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Joseph(Joseph B. Green)Green)

1 A. Yes.

2 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

3 A. Yes.

3 of 3

JOSEPH B. GREEN

Community Energy Solar, LLC Cell: 610.662.4121 Three Radnor Corp Center, Suite 300, Radnor, PA 19087 Email: [email protected]

SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS

.■ More than 10 years'years’ experience developing and constructing renewable energy projects in PA, NY,NY, OH and VA.VA. .■ Development expert tasked with site selection, project design, landowner contracting, environmental and interconnection evaluation, permitting, offtake, tax and finance. .■ Construction manager of wind farms tasked with safety, schedule, permit compliance, QA/QC and budget responsibility. .■ Expert witness for multiple zoning hearinghearingss in PA. .■ Lead presenter in multiple public meetings for renewable projects in PA and NY.

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

Development Director, Community Energy Solar, LLC,LLC, Radnor, PA May 2017-Present-Present

.■ Initial lead developer of the 90.5MW Mohawk Solar project in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County, NY. .■ Responsible for Mohawk Solar project design, landowner selection/contracting, initiation of Article 10 submissions, coordination with Towns'Towns’ Supervisors and permittipermittingng departments, completion of PILOT negotiations and field reconnaissance for archaeological resources, wetlands, T&E species. .■ Key presenter in Mohawk Solar public meetings. .■ Leading development effort for other solar projects in NY and PA.

Stay-at-at-home-home-dad-dad 2012-May-May 2017

Mid-Atlantic-Atlantic Development Manager, lberdrolaIberdrola Renewables, Radnor, PA 20102010-2012-2012

.■ Responsible for wind project site selection and development in PA, OH, VA. .■ Managed a team of developers, environmental, interconnection, permitting and engineering experts. .■ Coordinated development of hundreds of MWs of wind projects with varying permitting requirements from local permits to statewide processes.

Project and Construction Manager, lberdrolaIberdrola Renewables, Radnor, PA 20062006-2010-2010

.■ Managed development and construction of the 26MW Locust Ridge Wind Farm and 102MW Locust Ridge II wind projects in PA. .■ Responsible for proprojectject design including environmental, wind resource, interconnection and geotechnical studies. .■ Responsible for schedule, budget, safety, quality, tax -equity-equity financing and third -party-party engineering reviews. .■ Coordinated zoning expert testimony for both projects and sat as an expert witness during zoning proceedings. Joseph B. Green PageP a g e 2

Project Developer, Community Energy Inc.,Inc., Radnor,Radnor, PAPA 20052005-- 2006

.■ Lead developer of the 26MW Locust Ridge Wind Farm in PA. .■ Responsible for all permitting, scheduling, design, and interconnection activities. .■ Expert witness during zoning hearings for meteorological towers and the wind farm as a whole. .■ Community Energy, Inc. was acquired by Iberdrola Renewables in 2006.

District Sales Manager, Photocircuits Corporation, Glen Cove, NY 1997-20051997-2005

.■ Responsible for customer development and satisfaction, order quality, pricing and deliverdelivery.y. .■ Required frequent frequent travel to multiple customers in Mid -Atlantic-Atlantic region, which led me into wind development.

Lieutenant, US Navy 1993-19971993-1997

.■ Weapons Officer, USS Conolly (DD-979).-979). .■ Responsible for readiness, safetysafety and effective employment of all ship'sship’s weapons systems. .■ Command Duty Officer qualified. .■ Officer of the Deck (inport and underway) qualified.

EDUCATION

Bachelor of Science, Polymer Chemistry Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 1993

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

THERESA A. ALBANESE

SENIOR PROJECPROJECTT MANAGER, ENVIRONMENTAL

MOTT MACDONALD

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled TestimTestimonyony (Theresa(Theresa A. Albanese)Albanese)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Theresa A. Albanese,Albanese, Mott MacDonald,MacDonald, 111 Wood Avenue SouthSouth,, Iselin,Iselin,

3 New Jersey 08830.08830.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. SSeniorenior Project Manager, EnvironmentalEnvironmental..

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

7 A. I have been employed with Mott MacDonald since 2015.2015.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Natural Resource Management and

11 Applied Ecology, and Wildlife Management from Rutgers State

12 University of New JerseyJersey.. I have more than 30 years of experience in the

13 environmental management, consulting, and permitting. permitting. My current

14 curriculum vitaevitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant

15 professional experience.

16 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

17 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for conducting environmental

18 studies involving wetland and waterway identifications,identifications, delineations, and

19 analyses, environmental assessments, and wetland and stream mitigation,

20 enhancement, and restoration.restoration.

1 of 2

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled TestimTestimonyony (Theresa(Theresa A. Albanese)Albanese)

1 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the EnvironmeEnvironment?nt?

3 A. No.No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

11 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, MontgomeryMontgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 29,29, Site Restoration

16 and Decommissioning.Decommissioning.

17 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

18 your direction and/or supervision?

19 A. Yes.

20 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

21 A. Yes.

2 of 2

M

MOTT MACDONALD

Theresa A. Albanese, Ms. Albanese is a Professional Wetland Scientist with 30 years of extensive PWS environmental management, consulting and permitting experience. Theresa has Senior Project Manager, managed technical and administrative components of various projects and Environmental conducted various environmental studies involving wetland and waterway Personal summary identifications, delineations, and analyses; environmental assessments; wetland and stream mitigation, enhancement/enhancement/ restoration and mitigation. Ms. Albanese Education: has significant permitting experience with Federal regulatory agencies, including BS, Natural Resource the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC),(FERC), NEPA.NEPA. Her role as an Management and Applied Ecology, and Wildlife Environmental Manager includes coordination of various local, state and federal Management, Rutgers State permitting for civil, utility, energy, power and transportation projects within the University of New Jersey, various regions of the US. She has performed alternative routing analyses and 1986 feasibility studies natural gas pipelinespipelines,, transportation and variousvarious utility corridor Registrations:Registrations: projects, water/wastewater, industrial and commercial projects. Additionally, Professional Wetland Theresa is well versed in various States'States’ environmental review process and Scientist, #000153 NEPA. Ms. Albanese has also served as the resident engineer wetland specialist and has inspected and monitored utility, rail and transportation wetland mitigation construction projects. Professional memberships:

● BS, Natural Resource Employment'mployment historyhistory Management and Applied Ecology and Wildlife 2015 —– Present Mott MacDonald Management, Rutgers 2002 —– 2014 Gannett Fleming, Inc. State University of New 2000 —– 2002 ENSR International Jersey 1996 —– 2001 Natural ResourcesResources Group, Inc. ● Professional Wetland ScientistScientist (PWS) - Society 1986 —1996– 1996 Lynch, Giuliano and Associates of Wetland Scientists (SWS) —– Chapter member Selected projects ● Connecticut Association of Connecticut Association of TenesseeTenessee Gas Pipeline (TGP) Company, Vegetation Maintenance Plan Projects, MA, RI, Wetland Scientists Wetland Scientists NH, NY, and PA: Environmental Project Manager responsible for consultations and (CAWS) (CAWS) notifications with state rare species agencies, USFWS, and Conservation Commissions, as ● Association of applicable on rare species and wetland and waterbody impacts. The Project involved the Massachusetts Wetland mechanical vegetation maintenance of existing gas pipeline ROWs as needed. Scientists (AMWS) Scientists ● Women's Transportation Transportation Equinor,Equinor, Empire Wind Grid Connection Study and Landfall Assessment and Land Seminar (WTS) Routing Study,Study, Brooklyn, Kings County and various communiteis in Nassau and Suffolk ● New York State Wetlands Counties, NY:NY: Conducted analysis of the NYISO'sNYISO’s 345 kV and 138 kV transmission system in Forum New York City and Long IslandIsland to accept a significant amount of offshore wind power from ● Town of Southington, CT Statoil'sStatoil’s offshore lease area. The goal of the project was to determine the most suitable Inland Wetland and locations to serve as a point of interconnection and develop a strategy for filing interconnection Watercourses Commission requestsrequests with the NYISO. ● Environmental Review & Compliance for Natural Kinder Morgan; Northeast Energy Direct Project, PA, NY, MA, CT, NH: Environmental Gas Facilities (2015)(2015) Team lead responsible for the oversight and management of environmental and permitting ● NYS DEC endorsed subcontractor for a new 420-mile,-mile, 20 to 36-inch-inch diameter interstateinterstate natural gas pipeline supply Stormwater Trained natural gas to markets throughout the northeast United States, and nine new compressor units Contractor in Pennsylvania, New York, and Massachusetts. The project included Federal, state and local SWT#16-T-32917-2SWT#16-T-32917-2 permitting authorities, including the FERC,FERC, USFS, NPS, USACE, USFWS, and multiple state agencies, including counties and municipalities.

Years in practice: Iroquois Gas Transmission System;System; ConfidentialConfidential feasibility-routing-routing natural gas projects Westchester and Nassau Counties, NY: Environmental manager developed feasibilityfeasibility of 32 new pipeline transmission lines lines on Westchester and Long Island, New York. Performed detdetailedailed ArcGIS mapping and desk-top-top route reconnaissance to evaluate environmental constraints along multiple potential routes. The reconnaissance involved a constructability analysis to determine likely construction risks and methods to mitigate those risks.risks. Constructability concerns sensitive resource impacts (e.g.; wetlands/waterbodies,

KT |1 08108 | 2016 Theresa A. Albanese, PWS M Page 2

MOTT MACDONALD

endangered species, historic locations), and zoning and development impacts.impacts. The evaluation resulted in a recommended route that would be feasible and constructible, while minimizing cost, schedule, safety, safety, environmental and public relations risks. The final product of both projects was a conceptual design of the recommendedrecommended pipeline routes, including both onshore and offshore pipeline alignments, along with a comprehensive summary of permitting requirements, design considerations, CAPEX costs, construction schedules and Monte Carlo risk assessments.

Columbia of Ohio Gas; NineNine Proposed Points of Delivery (PODs),(PODs), Fairfield and Fairwood Counties, OH:OH: Environmental permit lead responsible for research and compilation of environmental permitting for various existing and proposed gas metering stations, PODs, and point of receipt (PORs) and associated pipelines.pipelines. Performed a Geospatial Information Systems (GIS)-based(GIS)-based desktop study to identify resources and permitting authorities.authorities. Local authorizations include zoning, buildingbuilding,, excavation, demolition and road-access-access permits. Reviewed historical databases and registers. Performed federal and state consultations and reviews for rare, threatened and endangered (RTE) species habitats. PreparedPrepared National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES)(NPDES) notice of intent and separate project StormwaterStormwater PollutionPollution Prevention PlansPlans (SWPPP) (2017 —– 2018)2018) PennEast Pipeline Company, LLC; PennEast Project, PA, NJ:NJ: Environmental Manager providing permitting and engineering support for FERC resource reports and state permitting effort for 114 miles of 36-inch-inch diameter interstate natural gas pipeline, one compressor station, and associated above-ground-ground facilities. The proposed pipeline will supply natural gas to markets in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. NiSource/Columbia Pipeline Group, KY, LA, MD, OH, PA, VA,VA, WV: Environmental Manager responsible for identifying environmental and regulatory aspects of decision support packages on numerous pipeline/facility replacement and modernization projects. The projects include abandonment, replacement, looping, and coating of hundreds of miles of bare steel natural gas pipeline with new steel and plastic pipe, ranging from 4-inches-inches to 20-inches-inches in diameter. American Midstream, LLC; High Point Gas Transmission, Venice to Toca Pipeline Abandonment Project, LA: EnvironmentalEnvironmental Manager responsible for developing FERC Resource Reports and state and federal permit applications for the abandonment and sale of approximately 61.3 miles of natural gas pipeline to be converted for the transportation of Y- grade natural gas liquids. Rice Olympus Midstream, LLC; Odin Phase III Pipeline Project, OH: Environmental project manager responsible for environmental permitting and biological survey activities supporting the design and construction of approximately eight miles of 24-inch-inch diameterdiameter steel gathering line to supply natural gas markets in Ohio, West Virginia and Pennsylvania. Surveys included wetland and waterbody surveys, oversight of cultural resources literature review, a habitat assessment, and consultation with USAGE,USACE, USFWS, Ohio Environmental Protection Agency and OH Department of Natural Resources. Consolidated Edison of NY, Croton River Horizontal Directional Drill Project, Croton on the Hudson, NY: Assistant Project Manager /Project Wetland Scientist/Permit Specialist for instinstallationallation of seven HDPE 13kV submerged cables, management of project and schedule, facilitated and performed various environmental services, consultations and reports in support of the project design and construction. Secured local, state and federal permitspermits for project. Managed technical, budgetary and administrative items along with schedule. Massachusetts Department of Transportation, 1-91I-91 Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Design-Build,-Build, Longmeadow to Bernardston, MA: Senior Project Wetland Scientist responsible for identifying environmentally sensitive areas and performing wetland delineations in the vicinity of three proposed variable message signs and three closedclosed-circuit-circuit television (CCTV) systems locations. Work included identifying and preparing local wetland permits and coordinating with federal, state, and local environmental agencies. Tasks included preparing Notice of Intent (NOI) for a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) general construction permit; and filing NOI via the U.S. EPA website; preparation of stormwater pollution prevention plan (SWPPP) for six additional sites. Massachusetts Department of Transportation, Route 128/1-95128/I-95 Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Design-Build,-Build, Burlington to Lynnfield MA: Senior WetlandWetland Scientist performed wetland and water delineations utilizing GPS along 10-mile-mile corridor for fiber-opticfiber-optic route to support three closedclosed-circuit-circuit television (CCTV) systems. Preparation of local wetland permits and coordination with federal, state, and locallocal environmental agencies. Theresa A. Albanese, PWS M Page 3

MOTT MACDONALD

Venice to Toca Pipeline Abandonment Project, American Midstream, High Point Gas Transmission, LA: Environmental Manager responsible for developing FERC Resource Reports for Filing Certificate authorization; obtained state and federalfederal permit/authorizations for the abandonment and sale of approximately 61.3 miles of natural gas pipeline to be converted for the transportation of Y-grade-grade natural gas liquids. Conectiv Energy, Biological Assessment, Burlington County NJ: Environmental LeadLead for feasibility analysis for proposed construction of 550 MW power plant. Developed and implemented 10-month-month monitoring study of nesting bald eagle pair) nesting on Newbold Island in the Delaware River. Prepared Biological Assessment —– Section 7 ESA andand evaluated impact assessments to US Fish and Wildlife Service and NJDEP Division of Fish and Wildlife. Consultation and coordination with resource agencies and stakeholders. Besicorp-EmpireBesicorp-Empire Development Company, LLC, Newsprint Recycling Plant and 500 MW GasGas-Fired-Fired Generation Plant Facility (Proposed Nine-Mile-Mile Transmission Line), East Greenbush, NY: Land Use Task Manager responsible for performing environmental studies, including wetland delineations, environmental assessments, corridor feasibility studies, threatened and endangered habitat assessments, and flfloraora and fauna surveys, along an existing right-of-wayright-of-way for a proposed transmission line. Responsibilities included assisting with the development of a report and application per Article VII of the New YorkYork State Public Service Law for siting of major utility transmission facilities. Conectiv Power Delivery, Upgrades for Electrical Transmission Lines/Installation of 1.7 Miles of New Submerged Cable, Stafford to Ship Bottom, NJ: Project Manager responsible for environmental and biological surveys including wetlands and habitat assessments for rare, threatened and endangered species; prepared and managed the production of various environmental reports, including an environmental impact statement, NMFS essentialessential fish habitat study, a barred owl habitat study, swamp pink habitat assessment, and submerged aquatic vegetation report and mapping. Prepared/submitted various Federal and State permit applications, for proposed upgrades of two existing, 6-mile-mile-long,-long, electricalelectrical transmission lines and the installation of new 1.7 miles of submerged cable. New York City Department of Environmental Protection, Environmental Support Services for Gilboa Dam Reconstruction, Schoharie County, NY: Senior Environmental Biologist responsibleresponsible for permitting and managing technical studies at the Gilboa Dam and Schoharie Reservoir associated with proposed dredge and disposal of sediments from within the reservoir. Performed natural resource studies and applied for and obtained a NYSDEC scientific collection permit. Additional studies along with permitting were performed for assessment of construction access routes, temporary waterway crossings, geotechnical borings, and sampling for various locations. Coordinated and developed various ppermitermit applications to the NYSDEC Dam Safety Unit and to the USACE for nationwide permit authorizations. New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP), Filtration Avoidance Determination, Stormwater Control, Westchester and Putnam Counties, NY: Project Wetland Scientist/ Permit Lead responsible for conducting biological studies and permitting and environmental review services for miscellaneous civil and transportation task-order-order contracts and design work at facilities throughout the NYCDEP watershedwatershed region. Projects included stormwater conveyance and stormwater treatment work related to the city's filtration avoidance determination and the construction of improvements to control stormwater erosion. Conducted research and prepared SEQR environmentalenvironmental assessment and management of permits and authorizations. Prepared local, state and Federal permits including an NYSDEC/USACE Joint Application for Permit; NYSDEC Article 24 Freshwater Wetland permits; New Jersey Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permits; a Section 401 Water Quality Certification; an MS4 Notice of Intent and stormwater pollution prevention plan approval; local land disturbance, soil erosion, flfloodplainoodplain disturbance, wetland and tree-cutting-cutting permits; and municipal site plan approvals.approvals. Permitting entities included NYSDEC, USACE, the County of Putnam, the Town of Bedford, and the Town of Carmel. New York City Department of Environmental Protection, Ashokan Field Campus, Ashokan, NY: Senior Scientist responsible for the preparation of an assessment of regulations, approvals, and permits required to rehabilitate an existing berm at the Ashokan Field Campus. Environmental studies included wetland studies, environmental assessment, flfloodplainoodplain forest transects, bat mist-net-net surveys and monitoring;monitoring; conducting research, and preparing permitting document write-ups.write-ups. Theresa A. Albanese, PWS M Page 4

MOTT MACDONALD

NJ Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP), NJDEP Environmental Assessment and Field Contractor for CDBG Program; Nine NJ Coastal Counties: NEPA-NEPA- HUD Program Director/Project Manager served as main contact for NJDEP responsible for team performing NEPA-HUDNEPA-HUD Environmental reviews and planning for various Superstorm Sandy Relief funding programs. Williams E&P, Unconventional Gas Well Permitting Services, Broome County NY: EnvironmentalEnvironmental Permit Coordinator/ Senior Wetland Scientist responsible for coordinating and preparing submittals to facilitate the development of a well pad site for vertical well explorations. Stakeholder coordination town and county, NYSDEC Bureau of Oil and Gas,Gas, and the Susquehanna River Basin Commission. Various submittals for roadway bonding forms, land development plan, erosion and sediment control plan, post-construction-construction stormwater management plans, resource agency consultation and sign-off,-off, pollution/prepapollution/preparedness/contingencyredness/contingency plan, drilling permits, approval by rule registration, water source registration, and water metering plan. Performed biological studies including site reconnaissance and wetland delineation, and coordinated land survey. Coordinated pre- application meeting with the NYSDEC field inspector for project intent and stakeholder input. Critical path method scheduling was applied and tasks were identified to meet client schedule. Conectiv/Atlantic City Electric, Maintenance Dredging for a Coal-Fired-Fired Power Plant, Great Egg Harbor River, Cape May County, NJ: Project Manager responsible for acquiring state (NJDEP) permits and licenses and modification to a USACE Individual Permit for maintenance dredging for the water intake location and the outfalloutfall channel area in a portion of a navigable river, also designated as a federal wild and scenic ririver.ver. Consultation with federal, state and local agencies. National Railroad Passenger Corporation (Amtrak), Culvert Modifications Various locations CT: Project Scientist responsible for facilitating and performing various environmental services for culvert replacements, including coordinating and providing various permitting needs relative to four culvert locations and determined applicability of local, CT State (Water Quality Certificate, Coastal Area Management), and federal (USACE Programmatic Permit) regulations as they applied to the proposed culvert replacements. Performed biological wetland and waterbody investigations. Preparation of initial permits as requiredrequired and consulting with state and federal regulatory agencies. Additional tasks included performing a review of hydraulic and hydrologic design analyses; consultation requests for rare species database reviews to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, NationalNational Marine Fisheries Service, and the Connecticut Natural Diversity office. Assisted with development of construction plans, specifications, cost estimates, and construction schedules for each of the four sites. Connecticut Department of Transportation, DanburyDanbury Branch Signalization, Danbury to Norwalk, CT: Environmental Task Manager/Senior Wetland Scientist responsible for environmental permitting for a major capital improvement known as the Danbury Signalization and Pole Project, to construct various improvementsimprovements along an approximate 24-mile-mile section of the Metro-North-North Railroad Danbury Branch. The overall project included the installation of approximately 808 concrete caisson foundations to support steel wide-flange-flange bolted base poles and 106 guy anchor foundations,foundations, to be constructed within the existing railroad right-of-way.right-of-way. A corridor wetland delineation and assessment was completed to address regulatory jurisdiction and to evaluate and identify environmentally sensitive areas along the corridor. Prepared catecategoricalgorical exclusion document for Federal Transit Administration for the entire project corridor. Preparation of USACE Programmatic General Permit - Category 2. State permits and authorizations included the preparation and submittal of a 401 State Water QualityQuality Certificate, CTDEP Certificate of Permission and Coastal Area Management consistency review. Evaluated and developed the required specifications, notes, and details for the construction drawings as a result of the delineations of the various environmentallyenvironmentally sensitive areas. Coordination of permitting plan set and construction plans, specification and documents including delineation limits and environmental considerations. Coordination with federal, state, and local resource agencies including Connecticut Department of Transportation, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the National Marine Fisheries Service regarding threatened and endangered species and species of special concern. Atlantic City Municipal Utilities Authority, Design, Environmental Permitting,Permitting, and Construction Management of 48-Inch-Inch Water Main Bypass, Atlantic City, NJ: Task Manager/Senior Environmental Scientist responsible for the environmental permitting for a two-two- phase project, involving the installation of a 24-inch-inch-diameter,-diameter, high-density-density polyethylene (HDPE) emergency bypass line installed by HDD to supplement a 48-inch-inch-diameter-diameter water Theresa A. Albanese, PWS M Page 5

MOTT MACDONALD

main, and the slip-lining-lining of an existing 48-inch-inch water main. Secured initial emergency environmental permits from federal and state agencies. Secured and obtainedobtained a soil erosion and sediment control certification. Consulted and corresponded with the U.S. Coast Guard regarding navigation for placement of a barge in the waterway and considerations of a federal channel. Rare species consultation and coordination with NMFS, FWS and state agencies and time of year seasonal restrictions. Prepared and implemented a coastal wetland restoration/mitigation design plan and design for mitigation and coordinated construction and monitoring with the agencies. Awards  2011 SouthingtonSouthington-Cheshire-Cheshire YMCA Volunteer Service Award  2010 President'sPresident’s Project Team Award: NJDOT Reconstruction of New Jersey Route 18 Project (Gannett Fleming)

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

JONATHAN SOWINSKI

TRANSPORTATION PLANNER

MOTT MACDONALD

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Jonathan(Jonathan SowinskiSowinski))

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Jonathan SowinskiSowinski,, Mott MacDonald, MacDonald, 111 Wood Avenue SouthSouth,, Iselin,Iselin,

3 New Jersey 08830.08830.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Transportation Planner.Planner.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

7 A. I have been employed with Mott MacDonald since 2007.2007.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Arts in Environmental Design from the

11 University of New York at Buffalo. Buffalo. I have more than 1313 years of

12 experience in the evaluation and development of land use, traffic,

13 transportation, and community development strategies. strategies. My current

14 curriculum vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant

15 professional experience.

16 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

17 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for evaluating and developing

18 land use, traffic, transportation, and community development strategies for

19 variousvarious projects.projects.

20

1 of 2

17-F-F-0182-0182—Pre—Pre--FiledFiled Testimony (Jonathan(Jonathan SowinskiSowinski))

1 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

3 A. No.No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to thethe subject matter you plan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and PublicPublic Need in connection

11 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 25, Effect on

16 TransportationTransportation..

17 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

18 your direction and/or supervision?

19 A. Yes.

20 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

21 A. Yes.

2 of 2

M

MOTT MACDONALD

Jonathan Sowinski Mr. Sowinski'sSowinski’s career as a transportation planner has been focused on the Personal summary evaluation and development of land use, traffic, transportation, and community Education: development strategies. Mr. Sowinski has applied his skills to a variety of transportation projects, including modeling high-speedhigh-speed tollingtolling on the New York BA, Environmental Design, University of New York at State Thruway, evaluating baggage claim operations at one of the world'sworld’s largest Buffalo, School of airports, and large event (NFL games and stadium events) traffic control and Architecture and Planning, optimization. Mr. Sowinski has been involved in several planning efforts such as 2010 the Niagara Falls State Park Operations Plan,Plan, which included evaluating land Professional memberships: uses,uses, visitor and staff circulation and interaction,interaction, and developing improvements American Planning for park efficacy and enhanced operation. He has also been fortunate to carry Association (APA) many award-winning-winning designs from initial planning phases through construction completion, including the North Union Street Complete Streets Improvements and Niagara Falls State Park'sPark’s new Olmsted/VauxOlmstedNaux inspired "Riverway".“Riverway”. Employment historyhistory 2007 - Present Mott MacDonaldMacDonald 2006 - 2007 Gypsum Systems, Inc. 2004 - Present Pines Homes & Pools, LLC 1999 - 2003 United States Army Selectedelected projects John F. Kennedy International Airport Access Portal Study, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Queens, NY: Planner for study of proposed entry portals to improve efficiency of revenue collection and security. Responsible for assessingassessing revenue and security technologies, site needs, traffic impacts, security operations,operations, and capital costs. Bank Street One-wayOne-way Conversion, City of Cape May, Cape May, NJ:NJ: Responsible for evaluating the impacts of converting a City street from two-waytwo-way traffic to one-wayone-way traffic. Provided a traffic impact report to the City detailing the various effects that the conversionconversion would have on the surrounding network traffic. Robert Moses Parkway, South Segment, Parkway Renovations and Historical Interpretation, New York State Office of Parks, Niagara Falls, NY: As the Prime Consultant Planning Specialist, worked withwith a diverse team of historical planners, landscape architects, and public involvement specialists to redesign a parkway along the Niagara River into an interpretive recreation of Fredrick Law Olmsted'sOlmsted’s 19th Century Riverway. Provided current and historical land use mapping and collected current traffic volume counts. This Project is currently under construction. Buffalo Light Rail Rapid Transit State of Good Repair Assessment Report, Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority, Buffalo, NY: InspectorInspector for the State of Good Repair Assessment Report. Project included development of an asset database, performance of a field condition assessment, and preparation of a report of conditions and capital improvement needs.needs. The project included assessment of all of the systems within the tunnel section of the Buffalo Metro Rail System. Tunnel systems consisted of the tunnel structure, track, train control, traction power, overhead contact system, and mechanical, electrical, and plumbing components. Pennsylvania Avenue Traffic Calming, City of Cape May, Cape May, NJ: Responsible for evaluating existing traffic conditions along a 1.5-mile-mile corridor and providing various alternatives for traffic calming. SPOT Prioritization Evaluations, NCDOT, Statewide,Statewide, NC:NC: Responsible for using Transmodeler software to analyzeanalyze multiple locations throughout North Carolina slated for future Statewide Transportation Improvement Program (STIP)(STIP) projects. This analysis consisted of comparing travel times both before andand after the proposed improvement projectsprojects.. Route 3535,, Bridge Over Ashley Avenue, New Jersey Department of Transportation (NJDOT), Borough of Brielle, Monmouth County, NJ: Provided design services on this project for the replacement of the existing bridge deck to meet current standards. ResponsibleResponsible development of traffic impact reports evaluation construction and detours.

SM I| 0099 I| 20182018

M Jonathan SowinsleSowinski Page 2 MOTT MACDONALD

Route 71,71, Main Avenue to Cedar Avenue , Pavement, New Jersey Department of TransportationTransportation (NJDOT), Neptune Township, Asbury Park, Loch Arbour, and Allenhurst Borough, Monmouth County, NJ: Provided design support on this pproject,roject, which included full depth pavement reconstruction and resurfacing of 2.1 miles of Route 71 through Asbury Park throughthrough Loch Arbour and Allenhurst. Responsible for evaluating traffic volumes and developing traffic signal timings for 17 signalized intersections to meet current NJDOT standards as well as pedestrian safety improvements. Parkside Ave. at Florence Avenue Intersection Improvement, City of Buffalo, Buffalo, NY: As Project Planner and Transportation Specialist,Specialist, designed intersection improvements to increase safety and lower speeds along Parkside Ave. in the City of Buffalo.Buffalo. Mr.Mr. Sowinski began this project by leading public input sessions garnering support and consensus, continued by drafting the design approval documents and overseeing detailed design, and completed the project as the Engineer in Charge during construction. Niagara Gorge Trail, Town of Lewiston, NY: Project Planner, responsible for the preparation of design alternatives for a bicycle/pedestrian trail along the top of the Niagara Gorge. This trail would join two existing multi-use-use trails connecting a 3.25-mile-mile void in the existing Seaway Trail system. The project addresses security concerns where alternatives cross New York State Power Authority facilities and an international bridge crossing. The completed trail will provide residents and visitors withwith access, amenities, and one-of-of-a-a-kind-kind views of a world class natural wonder. Pearl Street Conversion, City of Buffalo, Buffalo, NY: Project Planner and Transportation Specialist charged with converting the existing street from one-wayone-way traffic to two-waytwo-way traffic within the existing curb lines. This project complements the Cars on Main Street project and will improve the downtown CBD circulation. Satisfying the City'sCity’s Complete Street implementation efforts, the final design includes dedicated bikbikee lanes, pedestrian improvements, and on street parking along the entire corridor. North Union Street Streetscape Design, City of Olean, Olean, NY: As Lead Planner, coco-- authored a successful TIGER application for the City of Olean that provided $7 Million for further planning, design, and construction to transform the City'sCity’s "Main“Main Street"Street” within the Central Business District. The project consisted of developing alternatives for reimagining the four-lane-lane main street into a more pedestrian oriented Complete Street. Final design included bicycle and pedestrian amenities, traffic calming design elements, and green stormwater infrastructure to help to revitalize the downtown. Mr. Sowinski was also critical in the preparation and planning of the robust public engagement effort. Ralph Wilson Stadium Traffic Study, Buffalo Bills and Erie County, Orchard Park, NY: As Project Planner and Transportation Specialist, headedheaded the robust data collection effort that included developing a library of video footage of the transportation operations on game day to evaluate the game day access and egress. Mr. Sowinski also led the analysis and development of improvement alternatives, managed game day staff, prepared project reports, scheduled meetings,meetings, and debriefed the client throughout the project. The final design alternative realized a reduction in travel time by 40%. Demolition and Relocation of the Williamsville Toll Barrier, New York State Thruway Authority, Williamsville, NY: As Junior Designer/Technician,Designer/Technician, performed on-site-site traffic counts, raw data collection, and peak hour summarization. Developed demand modeling used for the design of a highhigh-speed-speed EZ-passEZ-pass with an adjacent traditional toll plaza to replace the existing Williamsville toll barrier. Designed maintenance and protection of traffic plans for the four-stage-stage demolition plan. Parkside Neighborhood Traffic Study, City of Buffalo, Buffalo, NY: As Project Planner, tasked to holistically evaluate the Parkside Neighborhood traffictraffic operations in an effort to identify feasible opportunities to improve safety, access, and reinforce the sense of community place. Tested alternatives using a variety of microsimulation tools and developed a menu of individual improvement strategies that have been presented to the community and stakeholders in order to develop a consensus regarding priority of capital improvements that the City should implement. Hong Kong Airport Baggage Hall Microsimulation, Mott MacDonald, Hong Kong, China:China: As Modeling Lead, developed a simulation model using VISSIM software for the estimated peak capacity operation period for post construction operations related to the 3rd runway at Honk Kong International Airport. The model evaluated various terminal coconfigurationsnfigurations regarding the baggage hall and routing options of service vehicles and baggage tugs and dollies.

M Jonathan SowinskSowinski Page 3 MOTT MACDONALD

St. John'sJohn’s VISUM Model Update, City of St. John's,John’s, St. John's,John’s, NL: As a Junior Technician, assisted with development of a new travel demand model for the City of St. John’s,John's, NL. Duties included transferring data from existing Quick Response System II (QRSII) model and updating a database of jobs and population per zone in order to create a base model. Traffic Counting Program, GreaterGreater Buffalo Niagara Regional Transportation Council, Buffalo, NY: As Project Leader, oversaw the installation of over 300 locations throughout Erie and Niagara counties, scheduling a minimum of 72 hours of data collection at each location. Used GIS mappingmapping to ensure the most efficient use of time and resources. Coordinated two teams of field staff and kept detailed records of staff, equipment, and expenses. Mr. Sowinski provided the client with weekly progress reporting and developed an interactive databasedatabase of collected count information used by the GBNRTC. Southlands Traffic Impact Study, City of St. John's,John’s, St. John's,John’s, NL: As Project Planner, developed travel demand models for the City of St. John’s,John's, NL reflecting the proposed phased SouthlandsSouthlands development. Future forecast VISUM models were created in order to reflect baseline growth as well as future capital improvement projects. New land use zones were created to simulate the proposed phased development in line with the future year models incincludingluding various access alternatives. Windsor-Essex-Essex Parkway Detailed Design Studies,Studies, Windsor, ON: Project Planner to provide technical input for the development of traffic control plans and traffic management plan for the staged construction of an approximate 11-km-km extension of Highway 401 from North Talbot Road in the Town of Tecumseh to the proposed inspection plaza in the Brighton Beach area of the City of Windsor. Work included travel demand forecasting and the development of VISSIM models for numerous staging plan alternatives and detour routes for the Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure Ontario. Angus L. MacDonald Bridge Corridor Traffic Assessment, Halifax Harbour Bridges, Halifax, NS: Analyst for traffic assessment to determine the benefits to traffic and transit operations from an additional lane on Angus L. MacDonald Bridge.Bridge. Developed and analyzed VISSIM network models for existing and future peak hour conditions for 18 individual alternatives including HOV/HOT lanes and transit specific options. US Route 219 Planning Study, Southern Tier West Regional Planning Development Board, NY: Planner and Analyst for an Economic Impact Study assessing the social, economic, and environmental benefits of constructing a four-lane-lane expressway for US 219 from Springville to Salamanca, NY. Mr Sowinski generated forecasting models and reports based on potential and existing land uses and developments supported by the construction of the four- lane expressway. Idylwyld Drive & Circle Drive Interchange ImprovementImprovement Functional Study, City of Saskatoon, SK: Project Planner for a sstudytudy to provide mitigated measures to the interchange and along Circle Drive corridor for traffic operational improvements for the short-termshort-term and long-long- term horizon periods due to construction of South River Bridge. Responsible for travel demand forecast analysisanalysis using VISUM model outputs, traffic operation analysis using VISSIM and evaluation of alternatives. Long Harbour Traffic Impact Study, Vale Newfoundland & Labrador Ltd., Long Harbour, NF: Project Planner for the assessment of a proposed developmentdevelopment consisting of 30 housing units, a training center and a community center in the town of Long Harbour, NF. Responsible for travel demand forecast for the new development and evaluation of critical intersections affected by new traffic volumes and patternspatterns using Synchro/Sim Traffic. Other responsibilities included preparation of final report and presentation materials. Niagara Falls State Park Operations Plan, New York State Office of Parks Recreation and Historic Preservation, Niagara Falls, NY: Served as a Project Planner. Evaluated current park operations, land uses, and circulation to provide NYOPRHP a comprehensive Operations Plan. Mr. Sowinski was responsible for data collection and the development of elemental improvement strategies for the park'spark’s traffic and parking, motorized and non-motorized-motorized circulation, public transportation, and trolley operations. Cross Sound Link Tunnel, Polimeni International, Garden City, NY: As Project Planner, developed design year traffic forecasts forfor proposed tunnel across the Long Island Sound. Using population and employment data from United States Census and New York Metropolitan Transportation Council, TransCAD models were produced to estimate future travel demand in order to evaluate the projecprojectt feasibility.

M Jonathan SowinskSowinski Page 4 MOTT MACDONALD

New Hartford, New York Growth Plan,Plan, New Hartford, NY: As Project Planner, reviewed land use plans for multiple regional growth plan options. Produced specific maps in order to show impacts of particular regional growth plans prespresentedented by the town. Calculated future travel demands based on new development patterns and determined individual mitigation recommendations for any possible areas of concern where roadway improvements may have been needed. Generated specific regional macro and micro transportation examinations through VISSIM and TransCAD modeling. Assisted in developing strategies for funding, implementing needed improvements and generating recommendations for optimizing desired outcomes, and future traffic control design. Youngs Road and Aero Drive Intersection Design, Erie County Department of Public Works, Buffalo, NY: As Transportation Planner, reviewed all traffic analyses related to the intersection of Youngs Road and Aero Drive. Responsibilities included review of data collection methods and analysis of existing conditions, evaluation of design alternatives, and producing VISSIM traffic models to evaluate all alternatives. New Facility Development, SUNY Canton, Canton, NY: As Junior Designer/Technician, assistedassisted in creating DEIS for the planned addition to the SUNY Canton Campus. Researched aerial maps and state registries in order to determine the project site condition and identify any potential development restrictions. Women and Children'sChildren’s Hospital Traffic Analysis, Frauenshuh Inc., Buffalo, NY: As Transportation Planner,Planner, conducted analysis of future traffic patterns and demands as a result of redevelopment of Women and Children'sChildren’s Hospital of Buffalo, NY. Produced EnvironmentalEnvironmental Impact Statement Scoping document and Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the proposed renovation. Conducted building site research and investigated potential negative impacts and the proposed development. Assisted in identifying additional traffic and parking demands for the intended renovation. Traffic forecasting included the use of Synchro in order to evaluate affected transportation elements and determine potential areas of concern.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

RAMESH HARIHARAN

MAMANAGERNAGER —– ELECTRICAL SYSTEM STUDIES

MOTT MACDONALD

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Ramesh(Ramesh Hariharan)Hariharan)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Ramesh Hariharan, Hariharan, Mott MacDonald, MacDonald, 101101 StStationation Drive,Drive, SSuiteuite 130,130,

3 Westwood,Westwood, MAMA 02090.02090.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. Manager —– EElectricallectrical SSystemystem SStudies.tudies.

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

7 A. I have been employed with Mott MacDonald since 2019.2019.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Technology in Electrical Engineering fromfrom the

11 Malaviya National Institute of Technology in 2004. 2004. I also received a

12 Master of Science in Electrical Engineering from the University of Texas

13 at Arlington in 2008. I have more than 1414 years of experience in

14 transmission planning and power systems studies.studies. My current curriculum

15 vitae is attached and provides a full history of my relevant professional

16 experience.

17 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

18 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for managing the design of

19 transmissiontransmission and power systems for various energy projects.projects.

20 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

21 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

1 of 2

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Ramesh(Ramesh Hariharan)Hariharan)

1 A. No.No.

2 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

3 court,court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

4 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

5 A. No.No.

6 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

7 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

8 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

9 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

10 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

11 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will will you be

12 sponsoring?sponsoring?

13 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 55,, Electric System

14 EffectsEffects..

15 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

16 your direction and/or supervision?

17 A. Yes.

18 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

19 A. Yes.

2 of 2

M

MOTT MACDONALD

Ramesh Hariharan Mr. Hariharan is an experienced power systems professional with demonstrated Personal summary success in power system studiesstudies.. He has over 15 years of progressive experience in transmission planning, utility, FACTS/SVC and HVDC, and 4 yearsyears Education: of management experience. He has played an integral role in engineering and MS Electrical Engineering, business development, proposal, planning and bid management. Mr. Hariharan University of Texas at Arlington, 2008 is well-versed-versed in designing systems for U.S., Canada and Australia. He is skilled BTech Electrical Engineering, in transmission planning,planning, power system studies, SVC design, interconnection Malaviya National Institute of and planning studies tools (PSS/E, PSCAD, PSLF, MATLAB/Simulink, Technology,Technology, 2004 MathCAD, SAP-Material-Material Master Module, Adobe, MODWEB, CYME, RSCAD/RTDS, TARA, ASPEN). He is also experienced in MS Office, VBA and Professional memberships: experienced in MS Office, VBA and Excel.Excel. IEEE

CIGRE Employmentc.mployment historyhistory Languages: 20120199 - Present Mott MacDonald Hindi 2016 - 2019 PSC Consulting Tamil 2014 - 2016 GE Grid Solutions English 2011 - 2014 ALSTOM Grid Power Electronics 20200808 - 20112011 PacifiCorp Key skills: 20200404 - 20062006 ABB Inc. Transmission Planning, Power System Studies, SVC Selected projects Design, Interconnection and PSC Consulting:Consulting: Manager, Specialist Studies. Developed, implementedimplemented and started Specialist Planning Studies Tools: Studies (including Electromagnetic Transients) team for PSC North America working on global PSS/E, PSCAD, PSLF, projectsprojects.. Subject matter expert within the sector. Provided guidance to utilities/ISOs forfor system MATLAB/Simulink, MathCAD, implementation given their goal and system configurations. Advised ISOs on the additional CYME, RSCAD/RTDS, study needs, established scope of work and executed projects. Working with ISOs on their TARA, ASPEN study needs and performing the study. Developed EMT studies for solarsolar interconnection in Years in practice: weak system. Developed HVDC Interconnection Study for Canadian Utility. Established scope of work and methodology for performing EMT studies for PSC Australia. Supported PSC 1515 Australia in BD for EMT studies. Expert Review on limitation on adding solar generation at Distribution level.level. Project Management and experience with EVM.EVM. GE Grid Solutions:Solutions: Electrical Design Manager.Manager. Static Var Compensators (FACTS) developmentdevelopment.. Alignment of scope, processes, skills set and KPI with market expectations.expectations. Specific focus on recruitment and coaching of the engineers in the team. ToT of Engineering processes to improve the design competitiveness. New tool Introduction & knowledge transfer to the team. Responsible for the development of the equipment specificationspecification template used across GE SVC Business. New Product development to improve the efficiency of Harmonic study. DesignedDesigned & developdevelopeded equipment specification for the new tenders and projects. EstimatedEstimated the hours required for completing different studies for the competitive Tender bidding. DevelopedDeveloped technical document describing the studies & scope. ALSTOM Grid Power Electronics:Electronics: Senior Power Systems Engineer. Managed the Power Systems Studies team and lead the execution of the projects pipeline on-time-time within the allocated budgets. Defined the technical approach; dependency relation between tasks, resources required, and risks involvedinvolved in project execution. Coordinated and supervised the support to Commercial and Business Development Departments to anticipate future market needs. Strategies priorities and manage workload for the team. Expertise in FACTS Control Interaction Study, Surge Arrester Sizing Study, Harmonic Studies, RTDS Testing, SVC on-site-site energization tests, RAM and Loss study for FSC and SVC. Performed Capacitor, Transformer and Reactor sizing. Lead in Transfer of Technology of Fixed Series Capacitor Bank. Performance validation of installed SVC in PSS/E and PSCAD. Insulation Coordination, TOV and TRV studies. Dynamic Performance study and gain optimization of SVC. PacifiCorp:PacifiCorp: Transmission Planner. Energy Gateway Studies —– involvedinvolved in the development of base case used for Energy Gateway phase 2 studiesstudies,, Path Rating studies,studies, Power Flow Studies,Studies, Dynamic Stability studies,studies, Reactive Margin studies,studies, Series Capacitor location studystudy,, Reactor Sizing study.study. Lead for the Windstar Study Group and was responsible for getting approvalapproval for TOT 4A path rating (WECC phase 2 approval). Reviewing other studies including Single Pole Switching studies done by third party consultants. Development of Remedial Action

RH |1 03 |1 2019 Ramesh Hariharan M Page 2

MOTT MACDONALD

Scheme. Operation Transfer Capability study for TOT 4A/TOT 4B nomogram (approved(approved by WECC OTCPC) for 2010 winter, 2011 spring and 2011 Summer. Responsible for developing local generation tripping scheme. SVC location and sizing studies in South Eastern Wyoming. Team member in the development and submission of base case to WECC (Western(Western Electricity Coordinating Council). Involved in the NERC TPL studies. System Impact Studies for large generator interconnection and transmission service requests. Team member for identifying and mitigating issues related to PacifiCorp migrating to PSS/EPSS/E version 32 (Power Flow software used by PacifiCorp). Team Member for implementing MOD at PacifiCorp. Member of Archer Study Group (TOT 3 upgrade) and MSTI study group. Involved in reviewing the base case and study results of other utilities as an affectedaffected system. Involved in 10-year-year Load and Resource forecast. ABB Inc.:Inc.: Design Engineer. Worked in Instrument Transformer and Transformer Bushings divisions of ABB at Vadodara (India) heading Design and process Quality functions for Transformer Bushings. Team leader and member in the development of 72.5kV, 145kV and 245kV bushing and improvement of its first pass yield. Involved in failure analysis of Current Transformer, Capacitor Voltage Transformer and Bushings. Involved in Type Test for 400kV Current TransformerTransformer and Bushings. Responsible for costing for Current Transformer and Capacitor Voltage Transformer. Team member for 245kV Bushing Vendor development. Have handled logistics for bushings for 6 months. Publications'•iblications and Presentations B. Mehraban, American Electric Power, Columbus OH, USA, D. Reed; R. Gutman; B. Depommier; R. Hariharan; S. R. Mendis; S. Shah, SVC refurbishment for smart grid power quality enhancement and life extension, 2014 IEEE PES T&D Conference and Exposition, 14-1714-17 April 2014, Pages 1 —– 8. Keynote Speaker on HVDC and FACTS at Southwest Power Pool Technology Fair.

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

KRYSTIAN SOKOLOWSKI

SENIOR TRANSMISSIONTRANSMISSION LINE ENGINEER

MOTT MACDONALD

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Krystian(Krystian SokolowskiSokolowski))

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Krystian SokolowskiSokolowski,, Mott MacDonald, MacDonald, 101101 StStationation Drive,Drive, SuiSuitete 130,130,

3 Westwood,Westwood, MA 02090.02090.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A. SenioSeniorr Transmission Line EngineerEngineer..

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

7 A. I have been employed with Mott MacDonald since 2016.2016.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Computer Engineering from the

11 Wentworth Institute of TechnologyTechnology.. I also received a Master of Science in

12 Electrical Engineering from the Worcester Polytechnic Institute. I have

13 more than 1414 years of experience in the engineering and design of

14 switchyards,switchyards, substations, overhead and underground transmission and

15 distribution.distribution. In addition, I have significant experience in interconnection

16 for renewable energy projects.projects. My current curriculum vitae is attached and

17 provides a full history of my relevant professionalprofessional experience.

18 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

19 A. In my current position, position, I am responsible for engineering and designing

20 switchyards, substations, and overhead and underground transmission for

21 various energy projects.projects.

1 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Krystian(Krystian SokolowskiSokolowski))

1 Q. HaveHave you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

2 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

3 A. No.No.

4 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

5 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you planplan to

6 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

7 A. No.No.

8 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

9 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

10 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

11 withwith the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

12 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

13 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

14 sponsoring?sponsoring?

15 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 11,11, Preliminary

16 Design Drawings; Exhibit 34, Electric Interconnection; and Exhibit 35,

17 Electric and Magnetic Fields.Fields.

18 Q. Were these portions of the Application prepared by you, or under

19 your direction and/or supervision?

20 A. Yes.

21 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

2 of 3

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Krystian(Krystian SokolowskiSokolowski))

1 A. Yes.

3 of 3

M Summary Resume

MOTT M MACDONALD

Mr. Sokolowski is a Senior Transmission Line Engineer whose primary area of i lk expertise is in engineering and design associated with the field of Power Delivery. Proficient with the design of overhead power lines from 13.2kV through 500kV500kV in the U.S. and Europe,Europe, he has conductedconducted field inspections, participateparticipatedd in the selection and evaluation of structures and structure spotting, preparepreparedd scope documents, drawings and associated bills of materials.materials. He preparesprepares drawings and documents for new construction, refurbishment of existing assets, and Krystian Sokolowski,Sokolowski, PE reconductoring of power lines. Involved with the development of structure Senior Transmission Line standards using 3-D3-D technology, and the development of new software ideas to Engineer interactivelyinteractively generate detailed drawings and associated bills of material, complete with a fit check of parts and clearance to neighboring parts, and to Personal summary complete with a fit check of parts and clearance to neighboring parts, and to improve to the quality and clarity of the drawings. Education:Education: Mr. Sokolowski is experienced with the engineering and design of wind energy projects, BS in Computer Engineering, is experienced with the engineering and design of wind energy projects, especially in the design of the transmission interconnection and collector system (overhead and Wentworth Institute of Tech especially in the design of the transmission interconnection and collector system (overhead and underground). He has managed and executed multiple transmission lines for National Grid in Power Systems Management, Massachusetts, RhodeRhode Island, andand New York. Worcester Polytechnic Institute Selected projects M.S. Electrical Engineering, Mount Signal 3 Solar, CA - Mortenson: Detailed design of 230/34.5W230/34.5KV collector substation, Worcester Polytechnic provided construction support, evaluated bid documents. Prepared the physical design of the Institute electrical equipment. PerformedPerformed ground grid,grid, bus calculation, lightning, and lighting studies and prepared reports. Registrations:Registrations: Stillwater 2, CA - Mortenson: Detailed design of 63/34.5KV collector substation, 63kV Professional Engineer metering station, provided construction support, evaluated bid documents. Prepared the MA #49226,#49226, 2011 physicalphysical design of the electrical equipment. PerformedPerformed ground grid, bus calculation, lightning, NH #13893,#13893, 2012 and lighting studies and prepared reports. NY #93589,#93589, 2014 Kibby Wind Park,Park, ME - TransCanada:TransCanada: Detailed design of 35KV collector system, provided RI #PE0011049,#PE0011049, 2013 construction support, evaluated bid documents. Collector pole structure analysis per NESC, ME #PE 15265, 2017 Sag-Tension-Tension design and overhead cables as required, collector grounding, collector pole VT #PE 018.0134182, 2018 spotting, collector designdesign and construction drawings. Languages: Longview 500kV Transmission/Substation Design,Design, WV - GenPower:GenPower: Owners Engineer work for 500kV designdesign. Responsible for checking all transmission associated design and Polish drawings for the EPC contractor. English Bliss Wind Park, NY - Noble Environmental Power:Power: Detailed design of 35KV collector Years in practice: system, provided construction support, evaluated bid documents. Collector pole structure 14 analysis per NESC, Sag-Tension-Tension design and chart development for spacer cable, Cable de- rating for underground and overhead cables as required, collector grounding, collector pole spotting, collector design and construction drawings. Clinton Wind Park, NY - Noble Environmental Power:Power: Detailed design of 35KV collector system, provided construction support, evaluated bid documents. Collector pole structure analysis per NESC, Sag-Tension-Tension design and chart development for spacer cable, Cable de- rating for underground and overhead cables as required, collector grounding, collector pole spotting, collector design and consconstructiontruction drawings. Altona Wind Park, NY-NY- Noble Environmental Power:Power: Detailed design of 35KV collector system, provided construction support, evaluated bid documents. Collector pole structure analysis per NESC, Sag-Tension-Tension design and chart development for spacer cable, Cable de- rating for underground and overhead cables as required, collector grounding, collector pole spotting, collector design and construction drawings. Allegany Transmission Line, NY-NY- Noble Environmental Power:Power: Provided eengineeringngineering and supportsupport for licensing this new 5-mile-mile 115kV transmission line. Engineered and designed a 115 kV transmission line using PLS-CADD.PLS-CADD. MATEP, MA - Advanced Energy:Energy: Provided engineeringengineering in support of licensing. Preliminary engineering and design for the interconnectionsinterconnections of a power plant output to multiple 115 kV and 345 kV transmission lines using 33-D-D graphical representation of the entire interconnection, substation and lines for presentation to regulating agencies.

KS |1 06 |1 16 |1 47939.0

Duley & Ryan Substations, NY - Noble EnvironmentalEnvironmental Power:Power: Designed 230kV interconnecting taps for both substations. Provided engineeringengineering support during construction. Assisted with engineering and design of the substation yard. 115kV and 230kV Transmission Lines, NY: Supported the preliminary reviewreview of reconductoring of 10 115kV lines, a total of approximately 130 circuit miles, evaluated each line using ACSS, ACCR, and ACCC conductors, and analyzedanalyzed approximately 31 steel lattice tower types. Additional scope included installing a new 230kV transmissiontransmission line approximately 32 circuit miles, and rebuilding three 115kV transmission lines approximately 27 circuit miles. All lines require an EMF study and detailed scope of work. Tasks include managing a team of 11 employees and the duration of the projeprojectct was approximately 4 monthsmonths of engineering. WP1 230kV Transmission Tap, NY - NYPA:NYPA: Preparation of constructionconstruction ddocuments.ocuments. Responsible for engineeringengineering the complete layout and design of the looped tap into the Ryan Switchyard. Designed taptap structures in accordance with client, regional, and NESC standards. Analysis of various aspects of the transmission line using PLS CADD. WP2 230kV Transmission Tap, NY - NYPA:NYPA: Preparation of Construction Documents. Responsible for engineeringengineering the complete layout and design of the looped tap into the Duley Switchyard. Designed taptap structures in accordance with client, regional, and NESC standards. Analysis for various aspects of the transmission line using PLS CADD. 015SO15S 69kV Transmission Line, MA:MA: Detailed design of a 69 kV transmissiontransmission line,line, approximately 3.5 miles, using spacer cable construction supported on steel structures. SupportedSupported permitting, an environmental study, and alternative option studies. The design included non-standardnon-standard structure design, steel pole specification, and foundation design. Cabot Tap Separation 115 kV Transmission Line, MA:MA: Provided preliminary and detailed engineering design services to separate existing double circuit 115 kV transmission lines sharing double-circuit-circuit lattice towers onto new independent single circuit steel structures. SupportedSupported permitting, an environmentalenvironmental study, and alternative option studies. The design included non-standardnon-standard structure design, steel pole specification, and foundation design. Transmission Line North America Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) Compliance Project, MA:MA: Prepared weeklyweekly update reports, managed project schedule and budget, completed assessment of existing PLS-CADDTMPLS-CADD™ models, and prepared report including solutions to resolve clearance violations. Mr. Sokolowski performed field inspections of transmission lines to confirm all sub-standard-standard spans pre determined in the early phases in PLS-PLS- CADDTMCADD™ as well as line analysis to determine the maximum conductor temperature in which the conductor can run to eliminate sub-standard-standard vertical clearances. He prepared and reviewed material andand design packages for construction, provided construction support, and prepared as- built packages and project closeouts. Y177 115 kV Refurbishment, MA:MA: Provided preliminary engineering and detailed design for the refurbishment of 25.8 mile 115 kV transmission line. The design included structure outline drawings, hardware assembly drawings, bills of material, and steel pole specification based on client, regional, and NESC requirements. Q143S and R144 115 kV Refurbishment, RI:RI: Provided preliminary engineering and detailed design for the refurbishment of two 115 kV transmission lines, each 11.5 miles in length. The design included structure outline drawings, hardware assembly drawings, bills of material, and steel pole specification based on client and NESC requirements. L164 Reconductoring Project, MA:MA: Prepared construction documents associated with the reconductoring of a 3.5-mile-mile transmission line. EngineeredEngineered structure modifications and replacement structures in accordance with client, regional, and NESC standards using PLS-PLS- GADDCADD™. TM National Grid, Syracuse, NY:NY: Reconductoring, relocating, and replacing existing 13.8 kV, 23kV, 34.5 kV, 69kV and 115kV lines and associated wood-pole-pole and steel structures. Participated in the field inspection of the line, evaluated replacement structures, prepared scope document, and prepared document and drawings for construction issue. Prepared plan and profile drawings using PLS-CADD.PLS-CADD. Prepared STORMSSTORMS Work Request. National Grid, Westborough, MA:MA: Reconductoring, relocating, and replacing existing 13.8 kV, 23kV, 34.5 kV, 69kV and 115kV lines and associated wood-pole-pole structures. Participated in the field inspection of the line, evaluated replacement structures,structures, prepared scope document, and prepared document and drawings for construction issue. Prepared plan and profile drawings using PLS-CADD.PLS-CADD. Prepared PeopleSOFT Work Request.

KS |1 06 |1 16 |1 47939.0 National Grid, Westborough, MA:MA: Developed andand supported interactive 33-D-D models and a relational database (transmission structures and parts). Transmission Structure Standards 69 through 345kV: Modelled and investigated legacy parts and new policy parts to be used in new engineering and construction standards. Participated in the development of new standard structures and concepts based on client, regional, and NESC standards. Assembled dimensioned structures, checked clearances, part compatibility, and fit. Generated bbillill of materialsmaterials and dimensiondimensioneded drawings ready for construction. Relay Protection and Control - National Grid: Work involved 13.8kV through 230kV relay protection and control projects for substations and transmission lines. Provided preliminary engineering and prepared scope documents for cost and estimation purposes. Developed protection and control relay design brief documents along with protective relaying descriptions, relay input/output schedules, relay lists and protective one lines. Performed power system fault analyses using ASPENASPEN one-line-line program and generated relay coordination curves. Sentinel Power Plant Project, CA —– Competitive Power Ventures:Ventures: Detailed design of 800MW power plant. Work included specifying, reviewing and recommending electrical distribution equipment for purchase.purchase. DetailedDetailed design of ground grid followingfollowing receipt of vendor documents. Analyzed cable de-rating-rating and voltage drop for direct buried cable. Fair Haven Power Plant, VT: Provided engineering in support of permitting. Preliminary engineering and design for the interconnections of a power plant output to 115 kV transmission lines. This design was presented to regulating agencies using 33-D-D graphical representation of the entire interconnection, substation and existing lines.lines. Ansonia Power Plant, CT: Provided Engineering in support of LGIA. Preliminary engineering and design for the interconnections of a power plant to the United Illuminating Company 115 kV Substation. Ivanpah Solar Project,Project, CA - Klondyke Construction:Construction: Detailed design of overhead and underground 33KV & 115KV transmission line. Transmission line structure analysis per NESC, Sag-Tension-Tension design, underground layout design, overhead layout design, structure grounding and construction drawings. Analyzed cable de-rating-rating and voltage drop for direct buried cable.

KS |1 06 |1 16 |1 47939.0

NEW YORK STATE BOARD ON ELECTRIC GENERATION SITING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

______

Application of Mohawk Solar LLC for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need Pursuant to Article 10 of the Public SServiceervice Law for Construction Case 17-F-018217-F-0182 of a Solar Electric Generating Facility in the Towns of Canajoharie and Minden, Montgomery County. ______

PRE-FILED-FILED TESTIMONY OF

NATHAN MATTHYSSE

ELECTRICAL, INSTRUMENTATIONINSTRUMENTATION & CONTROL ENGINEER

MOTT MACDONALD

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Nathan(Nathan Matthysse)Matthysse)

1 Q. PPleaselease state your full name, employeremployer(s),(s), and business address(es).address(es).

2 A. Nathan Matthysse, Matthysse, Mott MacDonald, MacDonald, 111 Wood Avenue SouthSouth,, Iselin,Iselin,

3 New Jersey 08830.08830.

4 Q. What is your current position?

5 A.A. Electrical, Instrumentation, & Control EngineerEngineer..

6 Q. How long have you been employed with Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

7 A. I have been employed with Mott MacDonald since 2018.2018.

8 Q. Please describe your educational background and professional

9 experience.experience.

10 A. I received a Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering Technology

11 from Michigan Technological University in 2006. 2006. I have more than 1313

12 years of experience in electrical design, system consulting, construction

13 and commissioning in numerous forms of power generation throughout

14 the Americas and internationally.internationally. My current curriculum vitae is attached

15 and provides a full history of my relevant professional experience.

16 Q. What are your current responsibilities at Mott MacDonald?MacDonald?

17 A. In my current position,position, I am responsiblresponsiblee for engineering and consulting on

18 electrical design, system consulting, construction, and commissioning for

19 various energy generation projects.

20 Q. Have you previously provided testimony to the New York Siting

21 Board on Electric Generation Siting and the Environment?

1 of 2

17--FF--01820182—Pre—Pre-Filed-Filed Testimony (Nathan(Nathan Matthysse)Matthysse)

1 A. No.No.

2 Q. Have you previously served as an expert witness before any other

3 court, agency, or other body relative to the subject matter you plan to

4 offer testimony on in this proceeding?

5 A. No.No.

6 Q. What is the purpose of your testimony in this proceeding?

7 A. To sponsor certain Exhibits in Mohawk Solar’sSolar's Application for a

8 Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need in connection

9 with the proposed construction of a 90.5 MW solar generating facility in

10 the Towns of Minden and Canajoharie,Canajoharie, Montgomery County, New York.York.

11 Q. What Exhibits, and/or other aspects of the Application will you be

12 sponsoring?sponsoring?

13 A. I will be sponsoring the following ExhibitsExhibits:: Exhibit 29,29, Site Restoration

14 and Decommissioning.Decommissioning.

15 Q. Were these portions of the Application Application prepared by you, or under

16 your direction and/or supervision?

17 A. Yes.

18 Q. Does this conclude your testimony?

19 A. Yes.

2 of 2

M

MOTT MACDONALD

Nathan Matthysse Over 1313 years of experience as an Electrical/18,CElectrical/I&C engineer in the power Personal summary generation industry. Mr. Matthysse has extensive experience in electrical design, system consulting, construction and commissioning in numerous forms of power Education: generation throughout the AmericasAmericas and internationally.internationally. Technologies he hashas BS, Electrical Engineering BS, experience with include: Solar PV,PV, Combined Cycle, Simple Cycle, Coal, Technology, Michigan Technological University, Nuclear, AQCS

2006 Employmentemployment historyhistory Key skills: 2018 - Present Mott MacDonald Electrical Design; Electrical 2016 - 2018 RINA Consulting Design Review; Construction; 2006 - 2016 Black & Veatch Commissioning; Independent Engineering; Owners Rep 2005 Classic Engineering Engineering; and Selected projects Construction Monitoring. City of Cincinnati,Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH: Owner'sOwner’s Engineer and Project Manager for supporting the Years in practice: City of Cincinnati in their effort to execute the City Green Plan. Review of potential facilities, 13 potential PPA structures, development and execution of RFPRFP process for thethe engagement of solar PV developer with the goal of designing and installing 25MW of solar PV at/on City owned facilities at zero cost to the city while providing market pricing for generation. Apex Renewables,Renewables, U.S.:U.S.: As Owner'sOwner’s Engineer establishedestablished a relationship to provide specific project support as well as general Staff Augmentation for the clientclient throughout the US. Support included the permitting and design packages for numerous solar PV projects ranging from 10MW to >1GW.>1GW. Karadoc SolarSolar Project, BEON, Victoria, AS:AS: Solar PV Engineering. Responsible for full design of 100MW solar park. Design included One Lines, Three Lines, Site Arrangement, blocking diagrams, Project Installation Details, Circuit lists, Grounding, Trenching Plans, cablcablee sizing, and Underground calculations. Confidential Clients, International: Owners engineer for numerous Solar PV plants located in the following countries; Australia, Brazil, Canada, Guam, Honduras, Jamaica, Mexico, Namibia, South Africa, United States andand Uruguay. Responsibilities included 30% design packages, creation of EPC Technical Specifications, EPC bid tabs, review of proposed designs, identification of design flflaws,aws, code compliance concerns, concurrence with design requirements in EPC contract, equipmentequipment review, schedule review, spec review, identification of items limiting lifetime of plant, Commissioning and completion paperwork review, as-built-built review, etc. Confidential Clients, International: Independent engineer for Solar PV technology review/comparisons.review/comparisons. Analysis included design and cost benefit comparisons for string vs. central inverter technologies and 1000V vs. 1500V inverter technologies. Evaluation included full design with associated BOM, as well as CAPEX/OPEX comparison for designs utilizingutilizing the associated technologies. Gauss Energia,Energia, Mexico:Mexico: Owner'sOwner’s Engineer and Project Manager for multiple PV and Energy Storage projects in Mexico.Mexico. Facilities included:included: Aura I rebuild —– 30MW Mexico, Aura III —– 20MW Mexico, Aura III Battery Storage —– 10MW10MW 27MWh Mexico, Aura I Expansion —– 2MW expansion to existing facility. Responsibilities included review of proposed designs, identification of design flflaws,aws, code compliance concerns, concurrence with design requirements in EPC contract, equipment review, schedule review, spec review, identification of items limiting lifetime of plant, 30% design package, creation of EPC Technical Specifications, EPC Bid Tabs etc. LNG Feasibility Study, Panama:Panama: Sole Electrical Engineer on feasibility study for LNG project inin Panama. Study included evaluating conversion of existing power generating facilities from HFO to natural gas, evaluation of market conditions, available technologies, prelim design and site selection for LNG Storage and new natural gas generating facilities.facilities. Trenton Channel, Belle River, St. Clair, River Rouge, DTE, MI: Lead Electrical Commissioning Engineer supporting commissioning of Dry Sorbent Injection and Activated Carbon Injection systems on the Flue gas side of 10 Fossil Generating Units. InjectionInjection systems were operating and meeting EPA required levels for emissions by the government mandated date allowing the 5.4GW of generating capacity to continue to operate. Managed team of over 10 professionals in commissioning and electrical checkout for all devices on injection islands.

NM |1 02 12019| 2019 Nathan Matthysse M Page 2

MOTT MACDONALD

Supported Commissioning for two Fly Ash System Upgrades including new Fly ash conveying system, Pin Paddles (wet ash unloading) and T/R Sets. Renaissance Power Plant, DTE, Carson City, MI: Lead Electrical Commissioning EngineerEngineer supporting replacement and commissioning of GSU at a simple cycle plant consisting of (4) Siemens 501 FD2 Combustion Turbines. Oversaw installation, testing and specifications for the new GSU in addition to creating As-BuiltsAs-Builts for GSU and integrated systesystems.ms. Shepard Energy Centre,Centre, ENMAX, Clagary, AB, Canada:Canada: As Electrical/Lead Schematic Engineer, primary responsibilities for this award winning Canadian 2 on 1 Mitsubishi G Class Combined cycle plant included, creating project Load List, specifying and managingmanaging contracts for the generator stepstep-up-up transformers, Diesel Generator, Medium Voltage SWGR, Low Voltage SWGR, MCC's and pre-fabricated-fabricated enclosures, Protective Relay Panel and batteries. Additional responsibilities included equipment bid evaluations, contractcontract management, Electrical design including creation of Three-lines,-lines, One Lines, Riser Diagrams, and Specification Drawings, Electrical Calculations such as Battery and UPS Calculations. Other Responsibilities included creating and maintaining the electrical load list, equipment list, setting up project circuit list, and managing the schematic efforts totalling over 1200 design drawings. Continued project support as Electrical Field Engineer as engineering was Issued for construction and directed and oversaw construction efforts. Primary responsibilities included inspection of equipment upon arrival, management of craft labour, organization of work packages to allow commissioning to commence and resolution of all electrical and I&Cl&C related design issues. Also ensured proper installation of the electrical aspects of the project. Upon Mechanical Completion of systems, responsibilities transitioned to Electrical Commissioning Engineer and starting up the 800MW combined cycle to meet guaranteed power commitment. ManagedManaged team of over 20 electric and l&CI&C technicians for commissioning of all loads and devices within schedule. Energized hundreds of pieces of equipment safely without any damage to equipment or personnel, equipment included MV and LV SWGR, Diesel Generators,Generators, GSU's,GSU’s, MV Motors, LV Motors, Battery Systems, UPS's,UPS’s, DCS, VFD'sVFD’s and fire systems. Upon Substantial completion, support was continued through warranty. JK Smith Units 9 & 10,10, EKPC,EKPC, Winchester, KY:KY: Lead Schematic Engineer responsible for this two-unit-unit Combustion Turbine project consisting of two GE LMS 100's100’s Schematic and Wiring Design. In addition to the creation and management of I/O list with additional responsibility of maintaining circuit lists,lists, instrument lists and updating all project one-lines,-lines, three lines, metering and relaying diagrams. Clifty Creek, AEP, Madison, IN: Project Electrical Engineer responsible for managing the projects load list, motor list, electrical equipment list, and powerpower circuit list for a Chiyoda Scrubber Jet Bubbling Reactor Project. Utilized learned skills from previous projects to complete duct bank studies, cable sizing calc's and breaker and bucket sizing calc'scalc’s for 13.8kV, 4.16kV SWGR, 480V SUS & MCC's.MCC’s. Completed a Lightning Risk Assessment, Lighting & Receptacle Power Distribution Design, and LAN/Communication One lines. Stardale Solar Park, Confidential Client, ON, Canada: Solar PV Engineering. Responsible for full design of solar park Design included One Lines, Three Lines, Project Installation Details, Circuit lists, Grounding, Trenching Plans, Specifications and created the project E-Tap-Tap model, cable sizing, Load Flow, Short Circuit, and Underground calculations. Confidential Clients, NorthNorth America:America: Solar PV Owners Engineer for numerous projects throughout N. America, responsible for review of proposed designs, identification of design flflaws,aws, on-site-site construction monitoring including code compliance, equipment review, schedule review, spec review, identificationidentification of items limiting lifetime of plant, etc. Confidential Clients, NorthNorth America:America: Solar PV Independent Engineer for numerous projects throughout N. America, responsible for review of proposed designs, identification of design flflaws,aws, missed design, code compliance,compliance, equipment review, vendor production abilities, schedule review, spec review, etc. T.B. Simon Power Plant,Plant, Michigan State University, Lansing, MI: Project Discipline Engineer. Responsible for the design of a 1700 tph coal handling system. Included in the scope of design is modification of existing gallery and 200 tph unloading and conveyor system, new 1500 tph unloading and conveyor system, fuel / biofuel blending system, improvements to comply with current NFPA classification for coal handling facilities. City Water, Power & Light, Dallman Unit 4 Coal Plant, Springfield, IL: Engineering technician. Electrical Designer providing checking support for all facility schematics from Nathan Matthysse M Page 3

MOTT MACDONALD

Generator through low voltage DC systems. Developed project testing and commissioning documentation and supported testing plan development. Gateway Combined Cycle, Pacific Gas & Electric, Antioch, CA: Electrical Designer provprovidingiding checking support for facility schematics and coordinated Electrical As-Built-Built effort for this 580MW Combined Cycle project. Plum Point Power Plant, Plum Point Energy Associates, Osceola, AR: Schematic Designer responsible for managing the production ofof Electrical Schematic and wiring diagrams for all major systems associated with this 665MW pulverized coalcoal-fired-fired power plant. Designs included creation of Aux. power system schematics, trip logics, and all BOP system designs. Lungmen Nuclear Power Plant, Taipower,Taipower, Taipei, Taiwan:Taiwan: Lead Schematic Designer responsible for managing the production of Electrical Schematic and wiring diagrams for all major systems including creation of Aux. power system schematics and BOP systems for this 2.7GW Nuclear Power Plant.Plant.