DOCSLIB.ORG

MEETING TRANSCRIPTS 256Th Session of the Pacific Fishery Management Council September 8-11 & 14-18, 2020 Online Meeting Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
MEETING TRANSCRIPTS 256Th Session of the Pacific Fishery Management Council September 8-11 & 14-18, 2020 Online Meeting Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic DRAFT COUNCIL MEETING TRANSCRIPTS 256th Session of the Pacific Fishery Management Council September 8-11 & 14-18, 2020 Online Meeting due to the COVID-19 Pandemic Verbatim transcripts of the Pacific Fishery Management Council are prepared for reference and are limited to Council discussions during the Council Action portion of each agenda item. These transcripts are not reviewed and approved by the Council and are not intended to be part of the formal Council Meeting Record. Contents A. Call to Order .................................................................................................................................................. 4 5. Agenda .......................................................................................................................................................... 4 B. Open Comment Period .................................................................................................................................. 8 1. Comments on Non-Agenda Items ............................................................................................................. 8 C. Administrative Matters ................................................................................................................................ 12 1. National Marine Fisheries Service Report ............................................................................................... 12 2. Executive Order 13921: Promoting American Seafood Competitiveness and Economic Growth – Final Recommendations ............................................................................................................................................ 15 3. Legislative Matters ................................................................................................................................... 33 4. Fiscal Matters .......................................................................................................................................... 34 5. Approval of Council Meeting Record ..................................................................................................... 39 6. Membership Appointments and Council Operating Procedures ............................................................. 40 7. Future Council Meeting Agenda and Workload Planning....................................................................... 48 D. Groundfish Management ............................................................................................................................. 70 1. Gear Switching and Sablefish Area Management Scoping ..................................................................... 70 2. Workload and New Management Measure Priorities – Including the Scoping of Mothership Utilization Issues ............................................................................................................................................................... 83 3. Impact Analyses Methodology Review ................................................................................................. 106 4. Assessment Methodology Review – Final Action ................................................................................. 107 5. Inseason Adjustments – Final Action .................................................................................................... 109 6. Update on Humpback Whale Endangered Species Act Consultation ................................................... 114 7. Emergency Action To Consider A Season Extension For The 2020 Limited Entry Fixed Gear Primary Sablefish Fishery ........................................................................................................................................... 121 E. Highly Migratory Species Management .................................................................................................... 131 1. Recommend International Management Activities ............................................................................... 131 2. Exempted Fishing Permits ..................................................................................................................... 133 3. Biennial Harvest Specifications and Management Measures – Preliminary ......................................... 139 4. Essential Fish Habitat Review ............................................................................................................... 141 F. Ecosystem Management ............................................................................................................................ 143 1. Climate and Communities Initiative Update ......................................................................................... 143 2. Fishery Ecosystem Plan Five–Year Review .......................................................................................... 145 DRAFT Council Meeting Transcript Page 1 of 199 September 2020 (256th Meeting) G. Coastal Pelagic Species Management ....................................................................................................... 148 1. Pacific Sardine Rebuilding Plan – Final Action .................................................................................... 148 H. Salmon Management ................................................................................................................................. 156 1. Reintroduction of Salmon Above Grand Coulee Dam .......................................................................... 156 2. Amendment 20: Management Schedule and Klamath Management Zone Boundary Change – Final Action ............................................................................................................................................................ 160 3. Southern Resident Killer Whale Endangered Species Act Consultation ............................................... 167 I. Pacific Halibut Management ..................................................................................................................... 172 1. 2021 Catch Sharing Plan and Annual Regulations ................................................................................ 172 2. Transition of Area 2A Fishery Management ......................................................................................... 181 3. Commercial-Directed Fishery Regulations for 2021 ............................................................................. 185 J. Habitat Issues ............................................................................................................................................. 195 1. Current Habitat Issues ........................................................................................................................... 195 DRAFT Council Meeting Transcript Page 2 of 199 September 2020 (256th Meeting) Meeting Transcript Summary Verbatim transcripts of Council Actions are available on the Council website. The transcripts may be accessed at https://www.pcouncil.org/council-meetings/previous-meetings/. DRAFT Council Meeting Transcript Page 3 of 199 September 2020 (256th Meeting) A. Call to Order 5. Agenda Marc Gorelnik [00:00:00] That concludes the ED report and will take us to our next agenda item, which is approval of the agenda. We have, Chuck had mentioned we have no proposals to review under Agenda Item D.3 so I guess I'll open the floor for discussion on the agenda and see if there is a motion to approve the agenda or to amend the agenda before approval. Corey Niles. Corey Niles [00:00:41] Thanks Mr. Chair and first to get some discussion going here. I do think we have, we are interested in having a discussion here about modifying the agenda. The issue that's been brought to our attention and I know it's been brought to the GMT and NMFS's attention and others as well as that the market and economic conditions of the pandemic have affected all of us, but it is affecting sablefish, the fishery up in Alaska and the timing of when they finish up there and are able to come down here and prosecute their tier fishery, so this issue came up just a day or two ago after the written public comment deadline had closed, but we expect that Bob Alverson will be coming up under B.1 to ask us to consider this change to the, to extend the season length from October 31st to the end of the year, so I'm going on too long here, but I believe one idea that would allow the Council to consider the merits, that idea, we would have to modify the agenda to even take that up, the question of whether we should do a change and we could do that most naturally under the D.2, I believe, if I have my agenda right here where we talk about workload implications in general. So I'll stop here quickly and see if staff had a reaction, if we have an interest in take, in considering this request in looking for the, if others are supportive of where and how to do best. Marc Gorelnik [00:02:42] Thank you Corey. Well, I'll look to staff for some guidance here. Chuck Tracy [00:02:47] Thanks Mr. Chair. Thanks Mr. Niles. So if there is a request that the Council wants to consider for picking emergency action on something like that they could take that up similar to how we did back in April on the whiting mothership catcher processor issue, so that would involve the Council considering the need for and modifying the agenda to set up a new agenda item and so there'd have to be sufficient justification for that but that could be done. I think it would be good to if that, if there is consideration of that to include some discussion about the workload
Load more

Recommended publications
  • HUK+Adult+FW1920+Catalogue+-+
    Saving You By (author) Charlotte Nash Sep 17, 2019 | Paperback $24.99 | Three escaped pensioners. One single mother. A road trip to rescue her son. The new emotionally compelling page-turner by Australia's Charlotte Nash In their tiny pale green cottage under the trees, Mallory Cook and her five-year- old son, Harry, are a little family unit who weather the storms of life together. Money is tight after Harry's father, Duncan, abandoned them to expand his business in New York. So when Duncan fails to return Harry after a visit, Mallory boards a plane to bring her son home any way she can. During the journey, a chance encounter with three retirees on the run from their care home leads Mallory on an unlikely group road trip across the United States. 9780733636479 Zadie, Ernie and Jock each have their own reasons for making the journey and English along the way the four of them will learn the lengths they will travel to save each other - and themselves. 384 pages Saving You is the beautiful, emotionally compelling page-turner by Charlotte Nash, bestselling Australian author of The Horseman and The Paris Wedding. Subject If you love the stories of Jojo Moyes and Fiona McCallum you will devour this FICTION / Family Life / General book. 'I was enthralled... Nash's skilled storytelling will keep you turning pages until Distributor the very end.' FLEUR McDONALD Hachette Book Group Contributor Bio Charlotte Nash is the bestselling author of six novels, including four set in country Australia, and The Paris Wedding, which has been sold in eight countries and translated into multiple languages.
    [Show full text]
  • British Film and TV Since 1960 COM FT 316 (Core Course)
    British Film and TV Since 1960 COM FT 316 (Core Course) Instructor Information Names Ms Kate Domaille; Dr Christine Fanthome Course Day and Meeting Time [Weekdays], [time] Course Location [Name] Room, 43 Harrington Gardens, SW7 4JU BU Telephone 020 7244 6255 Email Addresses [email protected]; [email protected] Office Hours By appointment Course Description In this course you will learn how British film and television has evolved from the 1960s to the present day You will undertake a series of case studies of British film and television genres and examine how the aesthetics, audience expectations and production conventions have changed over time You will develop a deep set of analytic skills for appreciating the evolution of British film and television The course provides opportunities to appreciate the specific evolution of film and television in the British context from the 1960s to the present day through the study of production conventions, representation and audiences. A close focus is placed on the development of film and television through an examination of industry movement and changing audience expectations over time. The course offers opportunities to analyse and evaluate social change through the medium of film and television. Subjects covered in individual sessions include comedy, crime, fantasy, art film and TV, youth culture, heritage drama, the ethics and logistics of filming in public spaces, documentary and social realism, and new documentary which will encompass reality TV and citizen journalism. Course Objectives On completion of the course, the successful student will show evidence of being able to: interpret film or television texts in terms of their understanding of the cultural contexts in which those works were created.
    [Show full text]
  • Archery for All the Real Benefits of Inclusivity Berkshire Archery Association Hidden History Brought to Light
    Official Magazine of Archery GB SUMMER 2021 | £4.95 BRITISH 3D Championships Rovers return to Pentref Archery for all The real benefits of inclusivity Berkshire Archery Association Hidden history brought to light SPECIAL Preparing for REPORT The Game Fair Discounted entry offer for AGB members Ragley Hall, 23-25 July TOKYOINTERNATIONAL JUDGES TALK THROUGH THEIR ROLES INSIDE: Compound • Getting archery-fit • Kit care • Griffin vane giveaway 2021 new MXT-10 www.wiawis.com l www.win-archery.com 2021 new META DX 2021 new ACS EL -- TRUETRUE- - SMOOTHNESS! SMOOTHNESS! MOSTMOST STABILITYSTABILITY &ACCURACY!&ACCURACY! -- BESTBEST SHOOTINGSHOOTING FEELING!FEELING! SUMMER 46 2021 NEWS/FEATURES News 06 A joyful return to the range, Big Reopening report, Big Weekend RIGHT: plans, new AGB strategy details, Day in the club round-up and more life of our RDO Mailbag 76 34 Have your say 58 Club Spotlight 36 Bowbrook Archers on their latest achievements History 38 The way we wore – clothing changes on the field Judge and jury ARCHERY GB Three international judges talk 40 through their roles ahead of the Day in the life Tokyo Games 58 Meet Toby Andrews, Regional Archery for all PRACTICAL Development Officer 46 A look at the sport’s accessibility Rule changes as told by the archers who know Latest updates How to 33 British 3D 62 Run a beginners’ course Directory Championships How to get in touch 52 Return to sport 80 Wet weekend in Wales went Chartered physiotherapist down a storm 66 Nicky Hunt on how to Berkshire Archery safely rebuild your form 40 55 Association
    [Show full text]
  • English Folk Traditions and Changing Perceptions About Black People in England
    Trish Bater 080207052 ‘Blacking Up’: English Folk Traditions and Changing Perceptions about Black People in England Submitted for the degree of Master of Philosophy by Patricia Bater National Centre for English Cultural Tradition March 2013 This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution- NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 444 Castro Street, Suite 900, Mountain View, California, 94041, USA. Trish Bater 080207052 2 Abstract This thesis investigates the custom of white people blacking their faces and its continuation at a time when society is increasingly aware of accusations of racism. To provide a context, an overview of the long history of black people in England is offered, and issues about black stereotypes, including how ‘blackness’ has been perceived and represented, are considered. The historical use of blackface in England in various situations, including entertainment, social disorder, and tradition, is described in some detail. It is found that nowadays the practice has largely been rejected, but continues in folk activities, notably in some dance styles and in the performance of traditional (folk) drama. Research conducted through participant observation, interview, case study, and examination of web-based resources, drawing on my long familiarity with the folk world, found that participants overwhelmingly believe that blackface is a part of the tradition they are following and is connected to its past use as a disguise. However, although all are aware of the sensitivity of the subject, some performers are fiercely defensive of blackface, while others now question its application and amend their ‘disguise’ in different ways.
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. V. Mccarthy & Hough, Transcript of Hearing on Validity of MDMA
    EXHIBIT 1 1 0C64MCC1 1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 1 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK 2 ------------------------------x 2 3 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 3 4 v. 09CR1136(WHP) 4 5 SEAN McCARTHY, 5 LARRY WARREN HOUGH, 6 Defendants. 6 7 ------------------------------x 7 8 New York, NY 8 December 6, 2010 9 10:10 a.m. 9 10 Before: 10 11 HON. WILLIAM H. PAULEY III 11 12 District Judge 12 13 APPEARANCES 13 14 PREET BHARARA 14 United States Attorney for the 15 Southern District of New York 15 DANIEL CHUNG 16 ELISHA KOBRE 16 Assistant United States Attorneys 17 17 MICHAEL SPORN 18 SCOTT MICHELMAN 18 JAY RORTY 19 Attorneys for Defendant McCarthy 19 20 JOHN C. MERINGOLO 20 Attorney for Defendant Hough 21 21 22 23 24 25 SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. (212) 805-0300 2 0C64MCC1 1 (Case called) 2 THE COURT: Good morning, I note the presence of the 3 defendant Mr. McCarthy at counsel table and I note the presence 4 of Mr. Hough as well. This matter is on for a hearing. Are 5 the parties ready to proceed. 6 MR. CHUNG: The government is ready. 7 MR. RORTY: We are, your Honor. There are two 8 preliminary matters I would like to discuss. 9 THE COURT: Go ahead. 10 MR. RORTY: The government filed a letter with this 11 court Friday afternoon, that is December 3. I wanted to make 12 sure the court has received that letter. 13 THE COURT: I have. 14 MR. RORTY: On Mr. McCarthy's behalf, we filed a 15 pleading, a motion to exclude extrinsic evidence of the defense 16 expert's conduct yesterday afternoon, a motion electronically 17 filed with two affidavits, I wanted to make sure the court 18 received that document.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Appearance of the Comedy LP, 1957–1973
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works All Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects 9-2016 On the Appearance of the Comedy LP, 1957–1973 David Michael McCarthy The Graduate Center, City University of New York How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_etds/1515 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] ON THE APPEARANCE OF THE COMEDY LP, 1957–1973 by DAVID MICHAEL McCARTHY A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty in Music in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, The City University of New York 2016 ii © 2016 DAVID MICHAEL McCARTHY All rights reserved. iii On the Appearance of the Comedy LP, 1957–1973 by David Michael McCarthy This manuscript has been read and accepted for the Graduate Faculty in Music in satisfaction of the dissertation requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. ___________________ __________________________________________ Date Amy Herzog Chair of Examining Committee ___________________ __________________________________________ Date Norman Carey Executive Officer Supervisory Committee: Jane Sugarman, Advisor Anne Stone, First Reader Sumanth Gopinath Amy Herzog THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK iv ABSTRACT On the Appearance of the Comedy LP, 1957–1973 by David Michael McCarthy Advisor: Dr. Jane Sugarman Many observers of contemporary comedy in the United States during the 1960s referred to musical aspects of extra-musical performances. Comedy LP records furnish important artifacts for the study of the musical appearances these observers produced for themselves.
    [Show full text]
  • Born Standing Up: a Comic\'S Life
    Also by Steve Martin NOVELS The Pleasure of My Company Shopgirl PLAYS Picasso at the Lapin Agile WASP NONFICTION Pure Drivel Cruel Shoes SCREENPLAYS Shopgirl Bowfinger L.A. Story Roxanne The Jerk (coauthor) Scribner A Division of Simon & Schuster, Inc. 1230 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10020 Copyright © 2007 by 40 Share Productions, Inc. All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book or portions thereof in any form whatsoever. For information address Scribner Subsidiary Rights Department, 1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020. Scribner and design are trademarks of Macmillan Library Reference USA, Inc., used under license by Simon & Schuster, the publisher of this work. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Martin, Steve, 1945– Born standing up: a comic’s life/by Steve Martin. p.cm. 1. Martin, Steve, 1945–2. Entertainers—United States—Biography. I. Title. PN2287.M522A3 2007 792.7'028092—dc22 [B] 2007027143 ISBN-13: 978-1-4165-6974-9 ISBN-10: 1-4165-6974-X Photograph credits appear on last page. Visit us on the World Wide Web: http://www.SimonSays.com To my father, mother, and sister, Melinda Contents Beforehand Coffee and Confusion Comedy Through the Airwaves Disneyland The Bird Cage Theatre Television The Road Breakthrough Standing Down Acknowledgments Born Standing Up Beforehand I DID STAND-UP COMEDY for eighteen years. Ten of those years were spent learning, four years were spent refining, and four were spent in wild success. My most persistent memory of stand-up is of my mouth being in the present and my mind being in the future: the mouth speaking the line, the body delivering the gesture, while the mind looks back, observing, analyzing, judging, worrying, and then deciding when and what to say next.
    [Show full text]
  • Midweek Family Safe VOL
    PAGE 5 Holly police chief offers helpful tips to keep our motorcycle driving friends and Midweek family safe VOL. 27 NO. XXX WEDNESDAY, JULY 29, 2020 $1.00 Argentine Township man drowns in McKane Lake Pandemic prom By Sharon Stone Ralph Roberts, 63, of Argentine Township, drowned in McKane Lake in Argentine Township on Sunday, July 26. Argentine Township Police Chief Dan Allen Ralph Roberts said police were alerted to the situation at approximately 5:20 p.m. Argentine Township police and the Genesee County Sheriff’s Argentine Township police and Office dive team stage near the south end of McKane Lake in the Genesee County Sheriff’s Argentine Township for a water rescue at 5:20 p.m., Sunday, July Office Dive Team responded to 26. Ralph Roberts of Argentine Township drowned after diving in the south end of McKane Lake. from a pontoon. Photo: Erick Ward See MCKANE LAKE on 6 Fenton area hit Fenton Township man with power outage is write-in candidate nConsumers Energy reports underground nWill be Democratic choice for Genesee electric line failure Sunday, July 26 County Board of Commissioners for 6th District By Sharon Stone By Sharon Stone Nearly 1,250 local Consumers Energy Tim Draeger, 56, of Fenton Township is a customers lost power Sunday, July 26. write-in candidate in the Democratic Primary for the 6th District County Commission seat Consumers Energy reported that an Three attendees at The Senior Pandemic Prom 2020: ‘20s in Genesee County. Draeger is a 21-year underground electric line failure initially Gatsby Gala pose for photos at the Ponemah Lakeside resident of Fenton Township.
    [Show full text]
  • Winter 2021 Schedule | January 25-March 5 WINTER 2021 SCHEDULE
    Winter 2021 Schedule | January 25-March 5 WINTER 2021 SCHEDULE Vision: Extending and improving the quality of life Mission: Provide lifelong learning and social connections Membership Fee Options + Annual Deluxe Membership for $165 includes 4 free learning groups per session, and unlimited free workshops. + Annual Basic Membership for $65 includes unlimited free workshops, learning groups are $30 each. + Holiday Membership Special for $25, includes a 6-week membership, one 6-week class, and unlimited workshops and Munch A New Year, New Hope and Learns. 2020 has been a challenging year. It has been nine months since we’ve Sedona/Verde Valley been able to get together on campus and it will be awhile longer, but I am OLLI Class Exchange! optimistic about 2021. The news about vaccines for Covid-19 and the The Prescott and Sedona/Verde treatments for those who get Covid-19 shine some light to the tunnel’s end. Valley OLLI have collaborated to This Winter OLLI session catalog will offer an Epidemiology course by offer each respective group access a new OLLI facilitator, John Acquavella PhD. John has spent his career to the other’s online classes. Registration for Sedona OLLI in Epidemiology, which is the study of the distribution and determinants classes and workshops will open of disease in human populations. He will not only talk about our current up on December 14 to Prescott pandemic but provide insight into help us understand vaccines and if and OLLI members. All Prescott OLLI why we should consider getting vaccinated when we can. members will pay alacart for the Your support during these times has been critical to our survival as your Sedona classes ($30 for classes, $15 for workshops.) Prescott OLLI local source for lifelong learning.
    [Show full text]
  • Read Book the Big Midweek : Life Inside the Fall Ebook
    THE BIG MIDWEEK : LIFE INSIDE THE FALL Author: Steve Hanley Number of Pages: 448 pages Published Date: 15 Jul 2016 Publisher: Route Publishing Publication Country: Glasshoughton, Yorks, United Kingdom Language: English ISBN: 9781901927658 DOWNLOAD: THE BIG MIDWEEK : LIFE INSIDE THE FALL The Big Midweek : Life Inside the Fall PDF Book Birds and Climate ChangeFrom the cells of aquatic algae to the majestic redwoods towering 100 metres above the California coast, the history of plant evolution has been one of increasing complexity. And as the author says, 'You don't have to become a monk, or a vegetarian, or spend hours contemplating your navel'; you simply need to notice your mind's busyness and not get all tangled up in it. Even in the less developed nations of the world, people are starting to believe that everyone ought to be able to live into old age and be protected from the major causes of premature death. and why?) -- Easiest (yet most neglected) multihull maintenance issue -- Why fiberglass production boats and wooden boats can both suffer from mildew and rot -- What to change put in the hulls each and every time you go sailing -- Active (and passive) pieces of equipment to help keep your boat fresh for years to come -- Must-have pieces of equipment to include in the engine area -- Avoiding chainplate errors (that cause corrosion structural damage -- 1 way small multihulls suffer from damage" SR-71: The Complete Illustrated History of the Blackbird, The World's Highest, Fastest PlaneFlying to a coffee table near you comes the new paperback edition of this authoritative and illustrated history of the most mind-bending military aircraft ever flown.
    [Show full text]
  • Labor Day Weekend Crashes in County Leave 1 Dead, 10 Hurt
    <* 0 I llth Year No. 20 ST. JOHNS, MICHIGAN THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 8, 1966 2 SECTIONS-26 PAGES 10 CENTS CLINTON COUNTY Traffic deaths Labor Day weekend Since Jan. 1- 12 crashes in county This time last year: 7 leave 1 dead, 10 hurt High speed was blamed for an Meridian Road south of Alward Bloodmobile at early-Sunday accident which Road and hit a sign and fence. claimed the life of a St. Johns man, William E. Ike, 24, of 501 LATER SATURDAY morning, Ovid Sept. 15 Lambert Drive. Morris F. Noonan, 20, of R-3, The Red Cross Bloodmobile There were several other St. Johns lost control of his car will visit Ovid next Thursday, Labor Day weekend accidents on West High Street east of Hol- Sept. 15, to serve blood donors around the county which result­ lister Road in Ovid and the car from both the Ovid and Elsie ed in injuries. went Into a ditch. He'and two areas. Tentative arrangements Mr Ike died at 3 a.m. Monday passengers were unhurt. are for the bloodmobile, to beset in Sparrow Hospital in Lansing. Robert R. Begley Sr., 34, of up at the Memorial Hall in Ovid He was Clinton County's 12th Northridgeville, Ohio, and Wil­ from, noon to 6 p.m. traffic fatality of 1966. liam E.'Cummings, 54, of Jack­ Mrs Earl Slagh of Elsie and son were drivers of two autos Mrs Ada Wittenberg of Ovid are THE ACCIDENT occurred which collided Monday evening chairmen from their respective about 5:30 a.m. Sunday on Price in the homebound rush on US-27.
    [Show full text]
  • Camino Foods, Inc., Lawrence Foods, Inc
    BEFORE THE OFFICE OF TAX APPEALS STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN THE MATTER OF THE APPEAL OF, ) ) CAMINO FOOD, INC., ) OTA NO. 18124037 LAWRENCE FOODS, INC., ) OTA NO. 18124039 ) APPELLANT. ) ) _________________________________ ) TRANSCRIPT OF VIRTUAL PROCEEDINGS State of California Wednesday, March 24, 2021 Reported by: ERNALYN M. ALONZO HEARING REPORTER STATE OF CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF TAX APPEALS 1 BEFORE THE OFFICE OF TAX APPEALS 2 STATE OF CALIFORNIA 3 4 5 IN THE MATTER OF THE APPEAL OF, ) 6 ) CAMINO FOODS, INC., ) OTA NO. 18124037 7 LAWRENCE FOODS, INC., ) OTA NO. 18124039 ) 8 APPELLANT. ) ) 9 _________________________________ ) 10 11 12 13 14 Transcript of Virtual Proceedings, taken 15 in the State of California, commencing at 16 1:08 p.m. and concluding at 3:58 p.m. on 17 Wednesday, March 24, 2021, reported by 18 Ernalyn M. Alonzo, Hearing Reporter, in and 19 for the State of California. 20 21 22 23 24 25 STATE OF CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF TAX APPEALS 1 APPEARANCES: 2 3 Panel Lead: ALJ SUZANNE BROWN 4 Panel Members: ALJ JOSHUA ALDRICH 5 ALJ ELLIOT SCOTT EWING 6 For the Appellant: SAMUEL BROTMAN SAMUEL LEMON 7 8 For the Respondent: STATE OF CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF TAX AND 9 FEE ADMINISTRATION 10 CHAD BACCHUS JASON PARKER 11 RAVINDER SHARMA 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 STATE OF CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF TAX APPEALS 1 I N D E X 2 3 E X H I B I T S 4 5 (Appellant's Exhibits 1-8 were received at page 10.) 6 (Department's Exhibits A-K were received at page 11.) 7 8 PRESENTATION 9 PAGE 10 By Mr.
    [Show full text]