Decision Analysis in Management Science

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Decision Analysis in Management Science MANAGEMENT SCIENCE informs ® Vol. 50, No. 5, May 2004, pp. 561–574 doi 10.1287/mnsc.1040.0243 issn 0025-1909 eissn 1526-5501 04 5005 0561 © 2004 INFORMS Anniversary Article Decision Analysis in Management Science James E. Smith Fuqua School of Business, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina 27708, [email protected] Detlof von Winterfeldt School of Policy, Planning, and Development, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California 90089, [email protected] s part of the 50th anniversary of Management Science, the journal is publishing articles that reflect on the Apast, present, and future of the various subfields the journal represents. In this article, we consider decision analysis research as it has appeared in Management Science. After reviewing the foundations of decision analysis and the history of the journal’s decision analysis department, we review a number of key developments in decision analysis research that have appeared in Management Science and offer some comments on the current state of the field. Key words: decision analysis; probability assessment; utility theory; game theory 1. Introduction for 12% of the papers in Management Science and Management Science (MS) has played a distinguished 17% of the “most-cited” papers (those receiving 50 and distinctive role in the development of decision or more cites). However, given the interdisciplinary analysis. As part of Management Science, the deci- nature of the field, it is difficult to draw sharp bound- sion analysis department has focused on papers that aries and determine precisely what counts as “deci- consider the use of scientific methods to improve sion analysis.” the understanding or practice of managerial decision Following Bell et al. (1988), we can distinguish making. The current departmental statement reads as among three different perspectives in the study of follows: decision making. In the normative perspective, the focus is on rational choice and normative models The decision analysis department publishes articles are built on basic assumptions (or axioms) that peo- that create, extend, or unify scientific knowledge per- ple consider as providing logical guidance for their taining to decision analysis and decision making. We seek papers that describe concepts and techniques for decisions. In the domain of decision making under modeling decisions as well as behaviorally oriented risk or uncertainty, the expected utility model of von papers that explain or evaluate decisions or judgments. Neumann and Morgenstern (1944) and the subjec- Papers may develop new theory or methodology, tive expected utility model of Savage (1954) are the address problems of implementation, present empiri- dominant normative models of rational choice. In the cal studies of choice behavior or decision modeling, domain of judgments and beliefs, probability theory synthesize existing ideas, or describe innovative appli- and Bayesian statistics, in particular, provide the nor- cations. In all cases, the papers must be based on sound mative foundation. decision-theoretic and/or psychological principles The descriptive perspective focuses on how real peo- Decision settings may consist of any combination ple actually think and behave. Descriptive studies of certainty or uncertainty; competitive or noncom- may develop mathematical models of behavior, but petitive situations; individuals, groups, or markets; such models are judged by the extent to which their and applications may include managerial decisions in business or government. predictions correspond to the actual choices people make. One of the most prominent descriptive models According to Hopp’s counts (Hopp 2004MS),1 Man- of decision making under uncertainty is the Prospect agement Science has published 590 decision analysis Theory model of Kahneman and Tversky (1979), later papers in the period from 1954 to 2003, accounting refined in Tversky and Kahneman (1992). This model captures many of the ways in which people deviate 1 We highlight papers that have appeared in Management Science by from the normative ideal of the expected utility model including “MS” after the publication year in the in-text citation. in a reasonably parsimonious form. 561 Smith and von Winterfeldt: Decision Analysis in Management Science 562 Management Science 50(5), pp. 561–574, © 2004 INFORMS The prescriptive perspective focuses on helping peo- and Bayes (1763). Bernoulli was concerned with the ple make better decisions by using normative models, fact that people generally do not follow the expected but with awareness of the limitations and descriptive value model when choosing among gambles, in par- realities of human judgment. For example, we might ticular when buying insurance. He proposed the build a mathematical model to help a firm decide expected utility model with a logarithmic utility func- whether to undertake a particular R&D project. Such tion to explain these deviations from the expected a model may not include all of the uncertainties, value model. Bayes was interested in the revision competitive effects, and sources of value that one of probability based on observations and proposed might expect a fully “rational” individual or firm an updating procedure that is now known as Bayes to consider. It would likely include approximations Theorem. and short cuts that make the model easier to formu- Ramsey (1931) recognized that the notions of prob- late, assess, and solve. Descriptive research on deci- ability and utility are intrinsically intertwined and sion making would help the analysts understand, showed that subjective probabilities and utilities for example, which model inputs (e.g., probabilities can be inferred from preferences among gambles. or utilities) can be reliably assessed and how these Ramsey’s essays did not have much influence when inputs might be biased. Prescriptive models are evalu- they were published but they are now much appre- ated pragmatically: Do the decision makers find them ciated: INFORMS’s Decision Analysis Society awards helpful? Or, what is more difficult to ascertain, do the Ramsey Medal to recognize and honor lifetime they help people make better decisions? contributions to the field. DeFinetti (1937) followed a Decision analysis is primarily a prescriptive disci- similar path by developing a system of assumptions pline, built on normative and descriptive foundations. about preferences among gambles that allowed him to In our review of decision analysis in Management derive subjective probabilities for events. His interest Science, we emphasize its prescriptive role, but we was primarily in the representations of beliefs as sub- also discuss normative and descriptive developments jective probabilities, not in the derivation of utilities. that have advanced prescriptive methodologies and The publication of the Theory of Games and Economic applications. We begin in §2 with the early history of Behavior by von Neumann and Morgenstern (1944) decision analysis into the late 1960s when the deci- attracted a great deal of attention and was a major sion analysis department at Management Science was milestone in the history of decision analysis and eco- created. In §3, we discuss the history of the decision nomics. While the primary purpose of von Neumann analysis department at Management Science, describ- and Morgenstern’s book was to lay the foundation ing the editorial structure from 1970 to the present for the study of games, it also established the founda- and reviewing the number of decision analysis arti- tion for decision analysis in the process. Specifically, cles published. In §4, we discuss some of the decision in an appendix to the second edition of the book (pub- analysis research that has been published in Manage- lished in 1947) von Neumann and Morgenstern pro- ment Science, focusing on developments in probabil- vided an axiomatization of the expected utility model, ity assessment (§4.1), utility assessment (§4.2), and in showing that a cardinal utility function could be cre- game theory (§4.3). In our discussion of the devel- ated from preferences among gambles. Their analy- opments of the field, we highlight specific develop- sis took the probabilities in the decision problem as ments that have appeared in Management Science but given and their axioms led to the conclusion that deci- do not strive to discuss all of the decision analysis sion makers should make decisions to maximize their research that has appeared in the journal or decision expected utility. The decision-making framework of analysis research published elsewhere. Our goal is to von Neumann and Morgenstern is now referred to as give a flavor of the decision analysis research that has the expected utility (EU) model. appeared in Management Science in its first 50 years In The Foundations of Statistics (Savage 1954), Savage and some of the debates that have influenced the extended von Neumann and Morgenstern’s expected field. In §5, we conclude and look ahead. utility model to consider cases in which the prob- abilities are not given. While Savage was greatly 2. The Early History of Decision influenced by the work of von Neumann and Analysis2 Morgenstern, his background was in statistics rather The normative foundations of decision analysis can than economics, and his goal was to provide a foun- be traced back at least as far as Bernoulli (1738) dation for a “a theory of probability based on the per- sonalistic view of probability derived mainly from the work of DeFinetti (1937)” (Savage 1954, p. 5). Savage 2 More complete discussions
Recommended publications
  • Project Management © Adrienne Watt
    Project Management © Adrienne Watt This work is licensed under a Creative Commons-ShareAlike 4.0 International License Original source: The Saylor Foundation http://open.bccampus.ca/find-open-textbooks/?uuid=8678fbae-6724-454c-a796-3c666 7d826be&contributor=&keyword=&subject= Contents Introduction ...................................................................................................................1 Preface ............................................................................................................................2 About the Book ..............................................................................................................3 Chapter 1 Project Management: Past and Present ....................................................5 1.1 Careers Using Project Management Skills ......................................................................5 1.2 Business Owners ...............................................................................................................5 Example: Restaurant Owner/Manager ..........................................................................6 1.2.1 Outsourcing Services ..............................................................................................7 Example: Construction Managers ..........................................................................8 1.3 Creative Services ................................................................................................................9 Example: Graphic Artists ...............................................................................................10
    [Show full text]
  • 1947–1967 a Conversation with Howard Raiffa
    Statistical Science 2008, Vol. 23, No. 1, 136–149 DOI: 10.1214/088342307000000104 c Institute of Mathematical Statistics, 2008 The Early Statistical Years: 1947–1967 A Conversation with Howard Raiffa Stephen E. Fienberg Abstract. Howard Raiffa earned his bachelor’s degree in mathematics, his master’s degree in statistics and his Ph.D. in mathematics at the University of Michigan. Since 1957, Raiffa has been a member of the faculty at Harvard University, where he is now the Frank P. Ramsey Chair in Managerial Economics (Emeritus) in the Graduate School of Business Administration and the Kennedy School of Government. A pioneer in the creation of the field known as decision analysis, his re- search interests span statistical decision theory, game theory, behavioral decision theory, risk analysis and negotiation analysis. Raiffa has su- pervised more than 90 doctoral dissertations and written 11 books. His new book is Negotiation Analysis: The Science and Art of Collaborative Decision Making. Another book, Smart Choices, co-authored with his former doctoral students John Hammond and Ralph Keeney, was the CPR (formerly known as the Center for Public Resources) Institute for Dispute Resolution Book of the Year in 1998. Raiffa helped to create the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis and he later became its first Director, serving in that capacity from 1972 to 1975. His many honors and awards include the Distinguished Contribution Award from the Society of Risk Analysis; the Frank P. Ramsey Medal for outstanding contributions to the field of decision analysis from the Operations Research Society of America; and the Melamed Prize from the University of Chicago Business School for The Art and Science of Negotiation.
    [Show full text]
  • Management Science
    MANAGEMENT SCIENCE CSE DEPARTMENT 1 JAWAHARLAL NEHRU TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY HYDERABAD Iv Year B.Tech. CSE- II Sem MANAGEMENT SCIENCE Objectives: This course is intended to familiarise the students with the framework for the managers and leaders availbale for understanding and making decisions realting to issues related organiational structure, production operations, marketing, Human resource Management, product management and strategy. UNIT - I: Introduction to Management and Organisation: Concepts of Management and organization- nature, importance and Functions of Management, Systems Approach to Management - Taylor's Scientific Management Theory- Fayal's Principles of Management- Maslow's theory of Hierarchy of Human Needs- Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y - Hertzberg Two Factor Theory of Motivation - Leadership Styles, Social responsibilities of Management, Designing Organisational Structures: Basic concepts related to Organisation - Departmentation and Decentralisation, Types and Evaluation of mechanistic and organic structures of organisation and suitability. UNIT - II: Operations and Marketing Management: Principles and Types of Plant Layout-Methods of Production(Job, batch and Mass Production), Work Study - Basic procedure involved in Method Study and Work Measurement - Business Process Reengineering(BPR) - Statistical Quality Control: control charts for Variables and Attributes (simple Problems) and Acceptance Sampling, TQM, Six Sigma, Deming's contribution to quality, Objectives of Inventory control, EOQ, ABC Analysis,
    [Show full text]
  • Abstract and Background Project Management Has Been Practiced Since Early Civili- Zation
    Business Theory Project Management: Science or a Craft? Abdulrazak Abyad Correspondence: A. Abyad, MD, MPH, MBA, DBA, AGSF , AFCHSE CEO, Abyad Medical Center, Lebanon. Chairman, Middle-East Academy for Medicine of Aging http://www.meama.com, President, Middle East Association on Age & Alzheimer’s http://www.me-jaa.com/meaaa.htm Coordinator, Middle-East Primary Care Research Network http://www.mejfm.com/mepcrn.htm Coordinator, Middle-East Network on Aging http://www.me-jaa.com/menar-index.htm Email: [email protected] Development of Project Management thinking Abstract and background Project management has been practiced since early civili- zation. Until 1900 civil engineering projects were generally managed by creative architects, engineers, and master build- Projects in one form or another have been undertaken for ers themselves. It was in the 1950s that organizations started millennia, but it was only in the latter part of the 20th cen- to systematically apply project management tools and tech- tury people started talking about ‘project management’. niques to complex engineering projects (Kwak, 2005). How- Project Management (PM) is becoming increasingly im- ever, project management is a relatively new and dynamic portant in almost any kind of organization today (Kloppen- research area. The literature on this field is growing fast and borg & Opfer, 2002). Once thought applicable only to large receiving wider contribution of other research fields, such as scale projects in construction, R&D or the defence field, psychology, pedagogy, management, engineering, simulation, PM has branched out to almost all industries and is used sociology, politics, linguistics. These developments make the as an essential strategic element for managing and affect- field multi-faced and contradictory in many aspects.
    [Show full text]
  • Topic 6: Projected Dynamical Systems
    Topic 6: Projected Dynamical Systems Professor Anna Nagurney John F. Smith Memorial Professor and Director – Virtual Center for Supernetworks Isenberg School of Management University of Massachusetts Amherst, Massachusetts 01003 SCH-MGMT 825 Management Science Seminar Variational Inequalities, Networks, and Game Theory Spring 2014 c Anna Nagurney 2014 Professor Anna Nagurney SCH-MGMT 825 Management Science Seminar Projected Dynamical Systems A plethora of equilibrium problems, including network equilibrium problems, can be uniformly formulated and studied as finite-dimensional variational inequality problems, as we have seen in the preceding lectures. Indeed, it was precisely the traffic network equilibrium problem, as stated by Smith (1979), and identified by Dafermos (1980) to be a variational inequality problem, that gave birth to the ensuing research activity in variational inequality theory and applications in transportation science, regional science, operations research/management science, and, more recently, in economics. Professor Anna Nagurney SCH-MGMT 825 Management Science Seminar Projected Dynamical Systems Usually, using this methodology, one first formulates the governing equilibrium conditions as a variational inequality problem. Qualitative properties of existence and uniqueness of solutions to a variational inequality problem can then be studied using the standard theory or by exploiting problem structure. Finally, a variety of algorithms for the computation of solutions to finite-dimensional variational inequality problems are now available (see, e.g., Nagurney (1999, 2006)). Professor Anna Nagurney SCH-MGMT 825 Management Science Seminar Projected Dynamical Systems Finite-dimensional variational inequality theory by itself, however, provides no framework for the study of the dynamics of competitive systems. Rather, it captures the system at its equilibrium state and, hence, the focus of this tool is static in nature.
    [Show full text]
  • Management Science (MSC) 1
    Management Science (MSC) 1 Management Science (MSC) MSC 287 - BUSINESS STATISTICS I Semester Hours: 3 Introduction to probability & business statistics. Covers: tabular, graphical, and numerical methods for descriptive statistics; measures of central tendency, dispersion, and association; probability distributions; sampling and sampling distributions; and confidence intervals. Uses spreadsheets to solve problems. Prerequisite: Any 100 level MA course. MSC 288 - BUSINESS STATISTICS II Semester Hours: 3 Inferential statistics for business decisions. Topics include: review of sampling distributions and estimation; inferences about means, proportions, and variances with one and two populations; good of fit tests; analysis of variance and experimental design; simple linear regression; multiple linear regression; non parametric methods. Prerequisite: MSC 287. MSC 385 - OPERATIONS ANALYSIS Semester Hours: 3 Survey of the firm's production function and quantitative tools for solving production problems, quality management, learning curves, assembly and waiting lines, linear programming, inventory, and other selected topics (e.g., scheduling, location, supply chain management). Uses the SAP software. Prerequisite: MSC 288. MSC 410 - TRANSPORTATION & LOGISTICS Semester Hours: 3 An analysis of transportation and logistical services to include customer service, distribution operations, purchasing, order processing, facility design and operations, carrier selection, transportation costing, and negotiation. Prerequisite: MKT 301. MSC 411 - SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT Semester Hours: 3 Supply chain management focuses on networks of companies that deliver value to customers. The course focuses on understanding integrated supply chains and examines how product development and design, demand, marketing, globalization, customer locations, distribution networks, suppliers and ERP systems impact a company's supply chain design. Prerequisite: MSC 287. MSC 412 - ARMY SENIOR LOGISTICIAN-ADV Semester Hours: 3 The Senior Logistician Advanced Course (SLAC) is part of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Howard Raiffa, 92 a Leader in the Study of How Decisions Are Made
    The Washington Post July 24, 2016 Howard Raiffa, 92 A leader in the study of how decisions are made Dr. Raiffa in a Harvard classroom in 1975. (Richard A. Chase/Harvard Business School) by Emily Langer Howard Raiffa, a professor of economics who was credited with leading an intellectual revolution in business and other arenas by teaching decision-making not as an art, but as a science grounded in mathematics and statistics, died July 8 at his home in Oro Valley, Ariz. He was 92. His death was announced by the Harvard Business School, where Dr. Raiffa joined the faculty in 1957, and by the Harvard Kennedy School of government and public affairs, which cited him as one of the founding fathers of its modern incarnation. The cause was Parkinson’s disease, said his daughter Judith Raiffa. During a nearly four-decade career at Harvard, Dr. Raiffa became known as one of the most creative thinkers in his field: the study of how people make decisions — good, bad, wise or unwise — in situations of uncertainty. He was the quintessential interdisciplinary academician. Trained in mathematics and statistics, he was a joint chair at Harvard’s business and government schools and did work that was applied to commerce, law, foreign affairs, public policy, medicine and sports. In an interview, Max H. Bazerman, a professor of business administration at the Harvard Business School and co-director of the Center for Public Leadership at the Harvard Kennedy School, said Dr. Raiffa was someone who “wanted to use his brilliance in applied contexts to make the world better.” In the early years of his career, Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Management Science 1
    Management Science 1 MANAGEMENT SCIENCE Department Code: MAS Introduction Management Science uses the ideas and methods of science, mathematics, statistics, and computing, which collectively are often referred to as Business Analytics, to help managers make better business decisions. Management science techniques have been applied in a wide variety of areas including financial modeling, marketing research, organizational theory, transportation and logistics, health care, environmental protection, and manufacturing. Almost any decision can benefit from the methods of management science/analytics. Educational Objectives The Department of Management Science offers a major area of specialization in Business Analytics as well as a minor in Business Analytics. The Business Analytics curriculum is designed to give Miami Herbert Business School students the necessary educational background and experience to allow them to work as successful business analytics professionals. Students pursuing the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) degree with a major area of specialization in Business Analytics are trained to combine quantitative, statistical, and computational tools and techniques to help companies understand, predict, and act on large amounts of data, improving decision-making in increasingly complex and interconnected business environments. For students pursuing the Bachelor of Science in Business Administration (BSBA) degree program, the major in Business Analytics requires a solid background in the sciences and mathematics. Additionally, students are required to take sequences of courses in optimization, decision science, and data analytics. A number of the courses in the Business Analytics curriculum require projects, in which the student evaluates a real-world system or process. As the system is studied and modeled, the student applies management science methods to find ways to improve the process.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art and Science of Negotiation
    tl t ,I The Art and Science of Negotiation HOWARD RAIFFA The BelknapPress of Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts and London, England I I i i I I I Acknowledgments Ideas are incestuous. They commingle and refuse to sort thenr- selves out so that one can say, "These ideas are his or hers arrd those mine." I know, however, that many of the ideas in the chap- ters that follow are the ideas of others, and some of these others can be identified. To no one am I more indebted than to John Ham- mond. This book would not have been written if I had not chosen to teach a course in competitive decision making at the Harvard Busi- Copyright O f 982 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College All rights reserved ness School, a course that evolved over more than a decade. In the Printed in the United States of America mid-1960s I taught a doctoral seminar in individual, group, and irr- teractive decisions, and in the early seventies John Hammond irr- corporated some of the material from that seminar in a pioneering 'he "Competitive Art of Negotiating" is a registered trademark of Gerard I. Nierenberg. This M.B.A. course entitled Decision Nlaking." I later in- :,The Art and Science of Negotiation, is not connected with Mr. Nierenberg's herited that course from John and built on his materials. Although i or programs. my course evolved into one that was substantially different frorn John's, he had set the tone; and even when I departed from his 87 6543 work, I had a very comfortable launching pad.
    [Show full text]
  • Management Science (MS)
    Management Science (MS) MS 5363. Pricing and Revenue Management. (3-0) 3 Credit Hours. MANAGEMENT SCIENCE (MS) Revenue Management is about “providing the right product to the right customers at the right time at the right price.” The main goal of Management Science (MS) Courses this course is to apply revenue management practices to appropriate MS 5003. Quantitative Methods for Business Analysis. (3-0) 3 Credit industries successfully. Specifically, the course will provide tools to Hours. forecast customer demand successfully, identify pricing and revenue Prerequisites: MAT 1033 and MS 1023, their equivalents, or consent opportunities, understand the impact of constrained capacity, opportunity of instructor. Introduction to managerial decision analysis using costs, customer response, demand uncertainty and market segmentation quantitative and statistical tools. Course includes a general framework on pricing decisions, and accordingly formulate and solve pricing for structuring and analyzing decision problems. Some of the topics optimization problems for revenue maximization. The material covered in include decision theory, statistical techniques (such as analysis of the course assumes a basic understanding of probability and probability variance, regression, nonparametric tests), introduction to linear distributions, some knowledge of spreadsheet modeling, and using Excel programming, and introduction to time series. Uses applicable decision Solver or similar optimization tools to get a solution. Differential Tuition: support software. Differential Tuition: $387. $387. MS 5023. Decision Analysis and Production Management. (3-0) 3 Credit MS 5383. Supply Chain Analytics. (3-0) 3 Credit Hours. Hours. The main goal of this course is to integrate data analytics with supply Prerequisite: MS 5003 or an equivalent. Study of applications of chain management.
    [Show full text]
  • Optimization Methods in Management Science and Operations Research
    15.053/8 February 5, 2013 Optimization Methods in Management Science and Operations Research Handout: Lecture Notes 1 Class website + more Class website – please log on as soon as possible – Problem Set 1 will be due next Tuesday Lots of class information on website Piazza.com used for Q&A and discussions No laptops permitted in class, except by permission laptops 2 We will use clickers from Turning Technologies. If you own one, please bring it to class with you, starting Thursday. If you don’t own one, we will lend you one for the semester. 3 Videotapes of classes Current plan: start videotaping lectures starting Today (I think). In addition, PowerPoint presentations will all be available. 4 Excel and Excel Solver During this semester, we will be using Excel Solver for solving optimization problems. We assume some familiarity with Excel, but no familiarity with Excel Solver. Homework exercises involve Excel. – Versions A and B (experiment starting this year). – Excel Solver tutorial this Friday 5 An optimization problem Given a collection of numbers, partition them into two groups such that the difference in the sums is as small as possible. Example: 7, 10, 13, 17, 20, 22 These numbers sum to 89 I can split them into {7, 10, 13, 17} sum is 47 {20, 22} sum is 42 Difference = 5. Can we do better? Excel Example 6 What is Operations Research? What is Management Science? World War II : British military leaders asked scientists and engineers to analyze several military problems – Deployment of radar – Management of convoy, bombing, antisubmarine, and mining operations.
    [Show full text]
  • Howard Raiffa Jeffrey Keisler
    University of Massachusetts Boston From the SelectedWorks of Jeffrey Keisler September, 2016 In Memoriam: Howard Raiffa Jeffrey Keisler Available at: https://works.bepress.com/jeffrey_keisler/72/ In Memoriam: Howard Raiffa Decision Analysis Today 35(2):4-7, September 2016 Howard Raiffa died peacefully on Friday, July 8, 2016 at the age of 92. Raiffa was the Frank Plumpton Ramsey Professor of Managerial Economics Emeritus at the Business School and the Kennedy School at Harvard University. He was both a towering intellect and a kind and good man, who inspired colleagues across many disciplines and organizations with his keen mind, ecumenical approach to academic research, and his generous spirit. Raiffa’s intellectual and personal qualities persist in the many PhD students (I was fortunate to be one) he advised over his 40 years as a professor. Without him there would be no field of decision analysis as we know it. His work spanning over six decades continues to shape the field, through his mentorship of many leading researchers, and his own seminal publications. Along with his many honors in other fields, Raiffa was the first recipient of the Decision Analysis Society’s Ramsey Medal, and was recently honored along with Ronald Howard at the celebration of the 50th Anniversary of the field of Decision Analysis, with the creation of the annual Raiffa-Howard Award. Much has been written about his life and career. A list of tributes, biographical essays and Raiffa’s own writings is provided at the end of this essay. Within decision analysis, his impact is incalculable. Raiffa had the mind of the mathematician and the heart of a coach.
    [Show full text]