Experimental Evaluation of Commercial-Scale Enhancement of Abalone Haliotisiris Populations in New Zealand
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES Published July 15 Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. l Experimental evaluation of commercial-scale enhancement of abalone Haliotis iris populations in New Zealand David R. Schiel Department of Zoology, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800, Christchurch 1, New Zealand ABSTRACT: The viability of enhancing populations of abalone Haliotis iris by placing hatchery-raised juveniles into natural habitats was evaluated at the Chatham Islands, New Zealand. Eighty thousand abalone, from 3 to 30 mm (shell length) in size, were seeded into 8 sites during 1990 and 1991 and sampled for survival and growth at times ranging from 5 to 23 mo. Annual mortality rates were 27.6 to 98.8 'X and instantaneous mortality ranged from 0.323 to 4.440. Mortality was greatest in sites affected by sand movement, which partially buried juvenile habitat. Desirable characteristics of sites for en- hancement were identified so that the risk of mortality due to habitat shifts can be greatly reduced in the future. Average annual growth increments ranged from 13.5 to 23.8 mm, but the lower value may be conservative because of the varying growth periods that seed were in place at the different sites. Preliminary economic analyses showed that, based on the current price of abalone, 3 individual sites should produce positive financial returns on the future harvest of abalone at the minimum legal size of 125 mm. Although 5 sites will have negative financial returns, the overall return of the 8 sites should exceed the original investment. INTRODUCTION One area where marine restoration may have a chance of success is in invertebrate fisheries, which are There is considerable interest in the methods and susceptible to overfishing (Harrison 1986). This is par- means of restoring marine populations that have been ticularly true of the commercially valuable abalone damaged or depleted in some way (Thayer 1992). To fisheries, which have suffered serial depletion in many be successful, this type of work requires a considerable countries, including New Zealand (Shepherd et al. knowledge about the life history of target organisms 1992b). The possibility of augmenting heavily ex- and an understanding of their ecology. In particular, it ploited abalone populations to help ensure their long- is necessary to know the links between early life stages term sustainability by enhancement with hatchery- and adult stages in terms of habitat requirements, raised seed has been explored in a few countries (Saito growth and survival. These links are far from clear for 1984, Tegner & Butler 1989).The interest in establish- most species. Especially in long-lived species, the rela- ing such a programme in New Zealand is more recent tionship between the numbers of juveniles and adults and has been in response to the perception that natural may break down under the influences of resource recruitment is irregular in many fishing sites limitation, predation, and environmental conditions (Sainsbury 1982a) and that the current high levels of (Underwood & Denley 1984, Connell 1985, Keough fishing effort in the comn~ercialand recreational fish- 1988, Jones 1990).These relationships have consider- ery may not be sustainable (Schiel 1992b). Population able importance in cornmercially-exploited species for enhancement, in conjunction with various manage- which economic value is attached to management ment initiatives, was seen as a means of significantly decisions. Moreover, any attempts at restoration or increasing recruitment to the fishery. enhancement of fished populations must be econorm- Attempts at enhancing abalone populations have cally viable. produced variable results (reviewed in Tegner & Butler Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 97: 167-181,1993 1989). In southern California (USA),it appears that few Paua generally occur in water depths <5 m (Poore seeded juveniles of HaLiotis rufescens survived to har- 1972c, Sainsbury 1982a). Sites where extensive sand vestable size despite many releases (Tegner & Butler and rock movement occur are usually poor habitat for 1985, 1989). Most seeded abalone were never seen juveniles. Rocky reefs that provide good juvenile habi- after release. Significant mortality was due to preda- tat are relatively common around the Chatham Islands, tion by crabs, lobsters and octopus, to the stressed con- New Zealand, where there is a substantial commercial dition of the hatchery-reared juveniles after their paua fishery (Schiel 1992b). This study was designed transport to seeding sites, and to alterations of habitat as a large-scale experiment in which growth and sur- following storms. Trials in Japan with H. discus hannai vival of seeded paua were assessed within a range of have also had variable results but successes have been sites around the island. The objectives were to deter- reported, with some seeded abalone eventually being mine the habitat characteristics suitable to enhance- captured in the commercial fishery (Saito 1984).Where ment on a commercial scale and to provide information recapture rates of seeded abalone were high, the size on whether seeding is an economically viable form of of seed at release was generally 230 mm (Saito 1984, paua population enhancement. Tegner & Butler 1989). New Zealand native abalone (or paua) Haliotis ins are relatively slow-growing, with average increments MATERIALS AND METHODS in shell length of 20 to 25 mm yr-' as juveniles (Poore 1972~).In a hatchery, the cost of raislng smaii abaiorie Study sites. The Chatham Islands are situated is considerably less than raising larger juveniles 700 km from mainland New Zealand at 44'S, 176'W because of the feed, attention, and time required to on the eastern edge of the Chatham Rise (Fig. l),a sub- maintain cultures of larger animals. Therefore, much marine ridge 250 to 500 m deep. The Chathams consist greater numbers oi smaiier individuals can be cultured of 2 main islands and several rocky outcrops. They for a given cost. Because it is necessary for seeding comprise a major fishery management area for Haliotis projects to be financially viable, the trade-offs between iris, with about 292 t caught annually (Schiel 1992b). costs of seed production, the size at release, and the Paua of all sizes are very abundant around the islands survival to harvestable size must be considered (Schiel on virtually all rocky inshore reefs (Schiel unpubl. 1989). In New Zealand, there is only one small hatch- data). This study was done on the main island, ery capable of raising juvenile paua. Growing them to Chatham Island. larger sizes is hampered by the lack of a cheap and I searched extensively for good juvenile habitat, abundant food. Because of the limitations on space and seeking sites of at least several hundred m2 with small food, any programme seeking to use large numbers of boulders on rocky reefs. This type of large-scale juve- hatchery-raised paua for enhancement of populations nile habitat is patchy in occurrence around Chatham is constrained to using small juveniles (<20 mm), which can be raised in the available facility (Tong & Moss 1992). Using seed paua of 8 to 15 mm in size pro- vides a reasonable balance between costs and returns (Schiel 1992a). In small-scale experiments, the recov- ery of 20 mm paua was slightly greater than 12 mm CHATHAM ISLAND paua (Schiel unpubl. data) but the cost of producing the smaller paua was considerably less. -50 S As for many abalone species, Haliotis iris juveniles (<?0 mm) are associated with under-boulder habitat (Poore 1972c, Sainsbury 1982a, Shepherd & Turner 1985). The selection of appropriate habitats, there- fore, was considered likely to be one of the most criti- cal factors affecting the survival of seeded paua. Pre- vious small-scale experiments on H. ins showed that mortality due to predation by fish and large inverte- brates was not great, or at least was not detectable against the background of other factors (Schiel 1992a, unpubl, data). However, habitat-related factors such as shifts in sand and movement of rocks accounted for most mortality, a result also reported by Sainsbury Fig. 1. Map of Chatham Island showing location of sites (1982a). seeded with Haliotis Ins Sch~el.Enhancement of abalone populations 169 Table l. Descnpt~onsand characteristics of enhancement Port Hutt and Whangamoe sites are more protected by sites at Chatham Island. Wind direction is that of greatest headlands. However, during southerly storms the full exposure at each site force of waves several meters in height can strike these sites. Kaingaroa and Owenga are affected by winds Site Exposure Characteristics from north through southeast. Hatchery methods. Eighty thousand juvenile paua Port Hutt (Alabama) S-SW Extensive boulder and small rock (10000 per site) were required for the project, with Owenga N-E Some reef, smaller the intention of seeding them over a 6 mo period. rock, large sand patches However, the production schedule of seed paua was Port Hutt (2) S-SW Extensive reef, some not met and seeding was therefore extended over small rock 1990-1991 (Table 2). Several batches of paua juveniles Whangamoe S-SW Some reef, large were grown during this period at the Ministry of boulders and rock Agriculture & Fisheries hatchery in Wellington. Waikaripi NW-SW Steep reef, some smaller rock Because of the geographic isolation of the Chatham Karen Wreck NW-SW Some reef, boulders and Islands and the possibdity of a separate genetic stock smaller rock there, adult paua from the Chathams were used for Pumphouse NW-SW Some reef, boulders and spawning in the hatchery. At least 8 males and 8 smaller rock females were used in each spawning to minimise the Kaingaroa W, N-E Reef, some smaller rocks, risks of loss of genetic variation (Smith & Conroy 1992). extensive sand patches The techniques used to spawn adults, rear and settle larvae, and raise juvenile paua have been described elsewhere (Tong & Moss 1992). It took 4 to 6 mo to Island and many areas were excluded from the seed- raise paua to an average size of ca 10 mm.