Culture and Contempt: the Limitations of Expressive Criminal Law
Culture and Contempt: The Limitations of Expressive Criminal Law Ted Sampsell-Jones* The law is the master teacher and guides each generation as to what is acceptable conduct. - Asa Hutchinson' The law of the land in America is full of shit. - Chuck D' I. INTRODUCTION Over the past decade, legal scholars have paid increasing attention to ways that criminal law affects social norms and socialization. While these ideas are not entirely original,1 the renewed focus on criminal law's role in social construction has been illuminating nonetheless. The recent scholarship has reminded us that criminal laws prevent crime not only by applying legal sanctions ' The author received an A.B. from Dartmouth, a J.D. from Yale Law School, and is currently clerking for Judge William Fletcher on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Thanks to Michelle Drake, Bob Ellickson, Elizabeth Emens, Owen Fiss, David Fontana, Bernard Harcourt, Neal Katyal, Heather Lewis, Richard McAdams, Brian Nelson, and Sara Sampsell-Jones for their suggestions and comments. Asa Hutchinson, Administrator, U.S. Drug Enforcement Admin., Debate with Gov. Gary Johnson (N.M.) at the Yale Law School (Nov. 15, 2001), available at http://www.usdoj.gov/dea/speeches/sl 11501.html. 'CHUCK D, FIGHT THE POWER: RAP, RACE, AND REALITY 14 (1997). 1. See Mark Tushnet, Everything Old Is New Again, 1998 WISC. L. REV. 579. By tracing the ideological development of the "new" school of criminal law scholarship, Bernard Harcourt has questioned its originality. BERNARD E. HARCOURT, ILLUSION OF ORDER: THE FALSE PROMISE OF BROKEN WINDOWS POLICING 1-16, 24-56 (2001).
[Show full text]