[May X6, 1874. Fairly Do the Same with the Girls
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
654 THE BRITISH MEDICAL _OURNAL. [May x6, 1874. fairly do the same with the girls. There are good advisers-Maudsleys WE publish in another column an alleged cure for hydrophobia, sent to and Clarkes-who will not allow the element of sex in education to be us by Mr. Prince, from whom we have already published several com- overlooked. The University of London has enough of its own work to munications on the subject. It is impossible not to attach some im- do, without aiming at supplementing the decrees of Providence by pro portance to the cases recited; but the formula appears to us to resemble hibition legislation intended to enforce a disability which it is feared many which have already been tried and found practically useless. that the alleged natural incapacity of women might be powerless to maintain. THE TICHBORNE CLAIMANT. The same excess of benevolence of intention, accompanied with ab- WE understand that the result of imprisonment has been materially to solute cruelty in action, marks the rest of the argument. A woman lessen the enormous bulk .of Arthur Orton-the Tichborne Claimant. must not be granted a degree in medicine because she could not practise He gets the ordinary prison diet, and has not suffered in health. He efficiently when entceintte, and because she ought not to take home scarla- is employed in tailoring. He is reduced in weight from 22 stone to less tina to her children. Caveat emozplor. The first is a matter which con- than I8. cerns those who propose to engage alud pay for her services very much -the University of Londoni not at all. As to the second, it may be KING'S COLLEGE IIOSPITAL. said that a man ought not to carry scarlatina to his own children or to WVE understanid that the Secretary of King's College Hospital, and the anybody else's children any more than a woman: it is presumable that members of the Council who had publicly declined to accept the report he takes precautions, which are not the exclusive privilege of any sex. of the arbitrators in respect to the nursing of the hospital, have re- The argument is two-edged ; for it might, in practical life, easily be signed; so that it may noNw be expected that concord will be restored. turned in another direction, as accoucheurs are aware. It is, in fact, It is, in our opinion, much less important that this hospital should be worthless for either use. nursed under any particular system, than that a good understanding Did the world undertake to provide hiandsomely for ulmarried should prevail among all who are responsible for the efficiency of the women, the benevolence of the argument which would, against their hospital. We hear that there is likely to be some opposition to that will, deprive them of the higher and more remunerative kinds of know- clause of the arbitrators' report which adopted the suggestion contained ledge and mental training, might be more cogent. But as it does not, in our report on the nursing-that a senior resident medical officer and as it raises no objection to their following the laborious callings of should be appointed. That oppositioln is, however, apparently based schoolmistress, governess, nurse, and midwife, on the condition that upon a misconception, which is likely to be corrected by furtlher in- they shall be only half educated and poorly paid, the benevolence of quiry. The appointment of such an officer would involve a small the proceeding seems to be on a par with its logic. expenditure only; and if, as at St. MIary's Hospital, he were constituted registrar and cliloroformist, the expense could be nearly met by an junior appointments would THE SOHO HOSPITAL FOR WOMEN. existing endowment, and no sacrifice of the be necessary. \WE have received from Lord Cholmondeley a copy of the reply of the Council to the statement of the medical officers, in respect to the alleged DARWINISMAl TESTED 1VY RECENT RESEARCIIES IN LA?NGUAGE. dlisregard of their complaints as to the nursing and general managemenit ON Monday, Mlay i ith, Dr. Bateman of Norwich delivered a very of the hospital. Hadc we received it earlier we would have felt it a interesting lecture on this subject in Paris to a large Anglo-American duty to publish it, notwithstanding its length. As, however, the dis- and French audience. Sir John Cormack, who was in the chair, in it pute to which it relates may, we hope, be considered as in a great mea- few remarks at the close of the lecture, amid the assenting applause of sure settled by satisfactory concessions on the part of the Councilj we the meeting, said that he thought the lecturer had made good his anti- trust we do sufficient justice to the Council in this matter by intimating Darwinian position. Dr. Bateman chiefly insisted on the three follow- all that this document expresses a general defence of their proceedings, and ing points. i. Articulate speech is an nnive,-sal attribute of man; of acquiring it. In support of this gives an account of their efforts to improve the nursing. WVe hope that the races have language and the capacity were cited the writings of Tylor, Lubbock, and Moffat the Council, having established a better systemii of government, will make the proposition African traveller. 2. Language is a distinctive attribute of man; it coii- anzende hono-rable to those who had to tender their resignation in order to the difference of kind between man and the lower that Dr. sequently establishes secure it. It ought to be mentioned here, Heywood Smith animals, whiclh Mr, Darwin is in search of. 3. Although physiologists has, as we learn, been in no small degree instrumental in influencing the -Gall, Broca, and others-have been for a long period trying to con- adoption of the improved constitution, to which we last week referred. nect speech with some definite portion of the brain, they have hitlherto failed; and, as science has failed to trace speech to a material centre- DR. JAMES PALFREY has beeln appointed co-lecturer oni Midwifery has failed to connect mind with matter-speech contstitttes a difetncs) at and Diseases of Wiomen at the London Hospital Medical College. kintd bet-ween ;nan andI thze lozuer- aninmals. THREE distinict laboratories for Physics, Physiology, and Pharmaco- DEAT}I FROM CHLOROFOR'M. logy, are being constructed at Potsdam, under the superintendence of A LAMIENTABLE accident, with a fatal result, occurred on Wednesday, Herr Spieker. May 6tlh, to MIrs. Walker, wife of Dr. Robert Walker, Lowther Street, ON Monday eveninig, Mlay 25th, Dr. J. 11. Axeling will read a paper Carlisle. The lady was troubled wvith toothache, and had occasionally at a nmeeting of the Health Departmnent of the Social Science Associa- taken chloroform to allay the pain. On the afternoon in question, she "' complained of toothache to Dr. Walker, as lie was leaving home to tion, to be held at their rooms in Adam Street, Adelphi, on The which Almielioration of the Present Position of Midwives". proceed to Longtown. Afterwards she lay down on the sofa, shie \vas accustolmied to do after dinner, and was observ-ed by a servant THE biennial festival of the Royal National Hospital for Consunmp- to have a handkerchief pressed to her face. Dr. Walker returned at tion at Ventnor was held on April 29th at Willis's Rooms, under the half-past four o'clock, when, to hiis great grief and astonishment, he presidency of the Bishop of WVinchester. Ladies as well as gentlemiieln found his wife lying quite dead on the sofa. He tried artificial respira- were present at this dinner, and the contributions during the evening tion, and galvanism, but in vain. An inquiry into the cause of deatlh amounted to £°5oo. The last block of two houses, completing the was held, when the evidencc of Lr. Sulliv,an showed that the immediate original design for the hospital, as intended by the founder, Dr. A. cause of death was suffocation, brought about by the fillinig of the Hassall, is to be erected at the cost of the Baroniess Meyer de Roths- mouth, and the falling back of the root ofthe tongue inlto the throat during child, in memory of her late husband. unconsciousness produced by bceathing chloroform; so that suffoca- May i6,1874.1 THE BRITISH MEDICAL _70URNAL. 655 May 16,1874.] THE BRITISH MEDICAL 7OURNAL. 655~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ tion was the immediate cause of death, but that suffocation owed its advancing its realisation. Notwithstanding the favour it finds in many presence and its action to the influence produced by chloroform breathed places, there must be people of greater weight to take it in hand before immediately before. The jury held a brief consultation, and returned it can succeed. The little way the movement has made in spite of much talk and discussion, appears best from the fact that it has not met with a verdict that death was accidental tlhrough the inadvertent use of opposition from the clerical side." chloroformn. INTERNATIONAL MIEDICAL CONGRESS. TIHE BRITISHI CHIARITABLE FUND IN PARIS. IN consequence of the decision arrived at in September last at the OUR Paris correspondent writes : The annual ball on behalf of the Medical Congress held in Vienna, appointing the city of Brussels as the British Charitable Fund in Paris, and under the patronage of the seat of the next meeting in I875 for the International Congress of British Ambassador, took place, for the first time since the war, on Aledical Science, a Committee has been formed to make arrangements. Tuesday, the 28th ultimo, at the Grand Hotel, and a most brilliant The Committee is composed of the following members: M.