Microbial Community Diversity Associated with Carbon and Nitrogen Cycling in Permeable Marine Sediments Evan M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2006 Microbial Community Diversity Associated with Carbon and Nitrogen Cycling in Permeable Marine Sediments Evan M. Hunter Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES MICROBIAL COMMUNITY DIVERSITY ASSOCIATED WITH CARBON AND NITROGEN CYCLING IN PERMEABLE MARINE SEDIMENTS By EVAN M. HUNTER A Thesis submitted to the Department of Oceanography in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science Degree Awarded: Spring Semester, 2006 The members of the Committee approve the thesis of Evan Hunter on March 20th, 2006. _________________________ Joel Kostka Professor Directing Thesis _________________________ Heath Mills Committee Member _________________________ Markus Huettel Committee Member _________________________ Lee Kerkhof Committee Member Approved: _____________________________________________ William K. Dewar, Chair, Department of Oceanography The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables iv List of Figures v Abstract vii INTRODUCTION 1 1. CHARACTERIZATION OF MICROBIAL DIVERSITY IN PERMEABLE MARINE SEDIMENTS OF THE SOUTH ATLANTIC BIGHT 8 2. PROFILING OF THE OVERALL, NITRIFYING, AND DENITRIFYING MICROBIAL COMMUNITY DIVERSITY IN PERMEABLE MARINE SEDIMENTS OF THE NORTHEASTERN GULF OF MEXICO 46 CONCLUSIONS 86 REFERENCES 89 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH 101 iii LIST OF TABLES 1.1 Summary of dissolved gases and nutrient concentrations in column experiments. 16 1.2 Statistical analyses of SSU rRNA, nosZ, and amoA gene clone libraries using standard ecological and molecular estimates of sequence diversity. 18 1.3 Summary of SSU rRNA gene sequences from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB clone libraries. 22 1.4 Summary of nosZ gene sequences from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB clone libraries. 33 1.5 Summary of amoA gene sequences from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB clone libraries. 37 2.1 Summary of amoA gene sequences from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, 3G1820, and Total clone libraries. 55 2.2 Statistical analyses of SSU rRNA and nosZ gene clone libraries using standard ecological and molecular estimates of sequence diversity. 58 2.3 Summary of SSU rRNA gene sequences from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, 3G1820, and Total clone libraries. 59 2.4 Summary of nosZ gene sequences from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, 3G1820, and Total clone libraries. 78 iv LIST OF FIGURES 1.1 The South Atlantic Bight sampling site (W27) located at 31o29’N, 80o26’W (Google Earth, 2006). 11 1.2 Experimental design of column incubations. 12 1.3 Rarefaction curves determined for the different RFLP patterns of SSU rRNA (A), nosZ (B), and amoA (C) gene clones from total, SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB samples. 20 1.4 Frequencies of bacterial phylogenetic lineages detected in SSU rRNA gene clone libraries derived from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB samples. 25 1.5 Phylum Proteobacteria neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes-Cantor distance correction, of SSU rRNA gene from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB samples. 27 1.6 Non-Proteobacteria neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes-Cantor distance correction, of SSU rRNA gene from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB samples. 30 1.7 Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes- Cantor distance correction, of nosZ gene from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB samples. 36 1.8 Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes- Cantor distance correction, of amoA gene from SC#1, SC#3, LC#1, LC#3 and SAB samples 39 2.1 The St. George Island sampling sites located at 29o 44.885 N, 84o 42.594 W (Gulf site) and 29o 45.034 N, 84o 42.719 W (Bay site) (Google Earth, 2006). 49 v 2.2 Rarefaction curves determined for the different RFLP patterns of SSU rRNA (A), nosZ (B), and amoA (C) gene clones from total, 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, and 3G1820 samples. 57 2.3 Frequencies of bacterial phylogenetic lineages detected in SSU rRNA gene clone libraries derived from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, 3G1820, and Total samples. 62 2.4 Phylum Proteobacteria neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes-Cantor distance correction, of SSU rRNA gene from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, and 3G1820 samples. 65 2.5 Non-Proteobacteria neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes-Cantor distance correction, of SSU rRNA gene from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, and 3G1820 samples. 67 2.6 T-RFLP fingerprints of March Bay 0-2 cm, Bay 2-4 cm, and Gulf 0-2 cm samples. 72 2.7 Sorensen’s based index dendrograms of SSU rRNA gene (A) and nosZ gene (B). 75 2.8 Neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree, incorporating a Jukes- Cantor distance correction, of nosZ gene from 3B02, 3B1820, 3G02, and 3G1820 samples. 77 vi ABSTRACT Though a large fraction of primary production and organic matter cycling in the oceans occurs on continental shelves dominated by sandy deposits, the microbial communities associated with permeable shelf sediments remain poorly characterized. Therefore, the primary objective of this study was to provide the first detailed characterization of microbial diversity in representative marine sands of the South Atlantic Bight (SAB) and the northeastern Gulf of Mexico (NEGOM) through analyses of SSU rRNA gene (Bacteria), nosZ (denitrifying bacteria), and amoA (ammonia- oxidizing bacteria) sequences. Communities were analyzed by DNA extraction, clone library construction, and terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) community fingerprinting. Sediment characteristics, geochemical parameters, and rate measurements were obtained in parallel with microbial community analysis. Microbiological and biogeochemical approaches were coupled, allowing the structure- function relationships of key microbial groups involved in carbon and nitrogen cycling in continental shelf sediments to be examined. In the SAB study (Ch. 1), clone libraries were constructed from both sediment core material and manipulated sediment within column experiments. Rapid organic matter degradation and coupled nitrification-denitrification were observed in column experiments at flow rates and oxygen concentrations resembling in situ conditions. Numerous SSU rRNA gene phylotypes were affiliated with the phyla Proteobacteria (classes α-, δ-, and γ-Proteobacteria), Planctomycetes, Cyanobacteria, Chloroflexi and Bacteroidetes. Detectable sequence diversity of nosZ and SSU rRNA genes increased in stratified redox-stabilized columns compared to in situ sediments, with the α- Proteobacteria comprising the most frequently detected group. Alternatively, nitrifier communities showed a relatively low and stable diversity that did not co-vary with the other gene targets. In the NEGOM study (Ch. 2), high throughput techniques were developed and applied to extensively profile overall and denitrifying microbial communities in a large vii number of sediment samples over various sediment depth intervals, contrasting sites, and sampling periods. Cloning/sequencing and community fingerprinting (T-RFLP) approaches were applied in parallel to characterize microbial diversity and phylogenetic composition. Statistical estimators including species richness, Shannon-Weiner and 1/D indices, nucleotide diversity, gene diversity, evenness, and θ (π) indicated little difference between four clone libraries constructed from selected depth intervals (0-2 cm, 18-20 cm) at each site in March. In contrast, T-RFLP profiles and robust phylogenetic analysis showed distinct trends in diversity according to site, depth, and time period sampled. The results elucidate predominant phylotypes that are likely to catalyze carbon and nitrogen cycling in marine sands. Several microbial groups (δ-Proteobacteria, γ- Proteobacteria, Planctomycetes) were confirmed as significant contributors to the microbial communities of permeable marine sediments in agreement with previous work. However, the robust sequence database of this study expanded current knowledge to reveal a large overall community diversity including additional groups (α- Proteobacteria, Bacteriodetes/Chlorobi, and Cyanobacteria) that had not been previously recognized using cultivation-independent methods with inherently lower resolution. The α-Proteobacteria, in particular, were shown to be relatively abundant in the overall and denitrifying communities at both SAB and NEGOM sites. Although overall diversity increased in response to redox stabilization and stratification in column experiments, the major phylotypes remained the same, indicating that the columns sufficiently mimic in situ conditions. While SSU rRNA gene phylotypes detected by clonal analysis were similar at the phylum level at all sites, the NEGOM site showed much higher species richness in comparison to SAB. At NEGOM, T-RFLP showed distinct differences in community diversity according to site, depth, and time. The sequence database from this thesis will facilitate the development of improved probes and primer sets to be used in quantifying the metabolically active members of permeable sand communities. Rapid community fingerprinting methods developed here should allow for more extensive comparisons across environmental gradients in order to better understand the factors controlling microbial diversity in permeable sediments viii INTRODUCTION THE PERMEABLE CONTINENTAL SHELF ENVIRONMENT AND IT’S SIGNIFICANCE TO ORGANIC MATTER CYCLING Approximately one-third of oceanic primary