The Politics of Abstraction: Race, Gender, and Slavery in the Poetry of William Blake
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Tennessee, Knoxville TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange Masters Theses Graduate School 8-2006 The Politics of Abstraction: Race, Gender, and Slavery in the Poetry of William Blake Edgar Cuthbert Gentle University of Tennessee, Knoxville Follow this and additional works at: https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_gradthes Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Recommended Citation Gentle, Edgar Cuthbert, "The Politics of Abstraction: Race, Gender, and Slavery in the Poetry of William Blake. " Master's Thesis, University of Tennessee, 2006. https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_gradthes/4508 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters Theses by an authorized administrator of TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. For more information, please contact [email protected]. To the Graduate Council: I am submitting herewith a thesis written by Edgar Cuthbert Gentle entitled "The Politics of Abstraction: Race, Gender, and Slavery in the Poetry of William Blake." I have examined the final electronic copy of this thesis for form and content and recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree of Master of Arts, with a major in English. Nancy Goslee, Major Professor We have read this thesis and recommend its acceptance: ARRAY(0x7f6ff8e21fa0) Accepted for the Council: Carolyn R. Hodges Vice Provost and Dean of the Graduate School (Original signatures are on file with official studentecor r ds.) To the Graduate Council: I amsubmitting herewith a thesis written by EdgarCuthbert Gentle entitled"The Politics of Abstraction: Race,Gender, and Slavery in the Poetryof WilliamBlake." I have examinedthe finalpaper copy of this thesis forform and content and recommend that it be acceptedin partialfulfillm ent of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts, with a major in English. Nancy oslee, Major Professor Acceptance forthe Council: an of THEPOLITICS OF ABSTRACTION: RACE, GENDER, AND SLAVERY IN THE POETRY OF WILLIAM BLAKE A Thesis Presented forthe Master of Arts Degree The University of Tennessee, Knoxville Edgar CuthbertGentle August 2006 11 Acknowledgments I would firstlike to thankmy formerteachers at Rhodes College, who helped to develop and inspire my thinking during those pivotalyears. Thankyou to Tina Barr, Gordon Bigelow, MarshallBoswe ll, JenniferBrady, Rob Canfield,Thomas F. Cohen, RalphHanna, Michael Leslie, CynthiaMarshall, Stephen Schottenfeld, and BrianW. Shaffer. Myteachers andadvisers at the University of Tennessee have also given me a great deal of advice and support during each stage of this process. For this, I would like to thankMatthew Abraham, Misty Anderson, Janet Atwill, Jenn Fishman, NancyM. Goslee, David Ikard, Michael L. Keene, and John P. Zomchick. I would also like to thankthe University of Tennessee forproviding me with fundingfrom the fallof 2004 until the spring of 2006. Finally, thankyou to my parents,Edgar and JannGentle, fortheir constant love and encouragement throughout my life. I owe everythingto their example of compassion and virtue. lll Abstract This study examinesthe relationshipbetween the poetry of WilliamBlake and the abolitionist movement gainingforce in Englandfrom 1789-1793. The poems The Visionsof the Daughters ofAlbion (1793) and"The Little Black Boy" (1789) express sympathywith this movement, depicting racialprejudice andoppression in unsparing ways. However, other aspects of the poems threaten to undercutthis message, such as the equation of corruptionwith black imagery and puritywith white imagery. This is a sign of Blake's limited scientificand theologicalunderstanding of race, which leads to an inadequate portrayalof enslaved Africans. Because his interests lie primarily in universal andChristian definitions offreedom, the poetfails fullyto engage theproblem of slavery. This paper will describe these limitations in Blake's poetry and in the critical response by Blake scholars, which oftenfails specifically to mention issues of enslavement. Chapter One will outline these problems and describe the poet's connection to the abolitionist project. ChapterTwo will explain the relationship between The Visionsof the Daughters ofAlbion andthe writings ofJohn Gabriel Stedman, analyzing studies by Anne Rubenstein, Camilla Townsend, Eugenie R. Freed, and David V. Erdman. In Chapter Three, the utopian readings of Visionsoffered by Erdman and Steven Vine will be countered using the arguments of Anne Mellor andNancy Goslee. Finally, Chapter Four will attempt to explain Blake's specificstance with regard to racial difference andintegration, primarily citing David Bindman, Ngugi Wa Thiong' o, andthe text of"The Little Black Boy." These readings will reveal the perspective of a gifted artistwhq was nevertheless limited by the biases ofhis ownculture andtime period. IV Table of Contents Chapter Page I. William Blake and the Limits of Racial Knowledge . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 1 II. · The Influenceof John Gabriel Stedman .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 10 III. The Visions of the Daughters of Albion and the Politics of Abstraction ....· 29 IV. LiberatoryChristianit y and the Perception of Race in "The Little Black Boy".......................................................... 54 List of References . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 67 Vita ............................................................ 72 1 Chapter One William Blake and the Limits of Racial Knowledge As demonstrated in his "The LittleBlack Boy"1 (1789) and The Visions of the Daughters ofAlbion 2 (1793), themesrelated to slavery andrace are animportant characteristic in the poetry of WilliamBlake. In both pieces, theauthor expresses his sympathieswith the abolitionistcause gaining forcein England from1789-1 793. Written at the opening and the temporaryconc lusion of the debates, respectively, these poems depict steadily growing conflicts that could no longer be suppressed by white authority. There are also, however, aspects of thesepoems that threaten to undercut Blake's message of liberation, such as theexpre ssion of corruptionthrough black imagery and purity with white imagery. This is a signof the author's limited understandingof race, which leads to an inadequate portrayal of enslaved Africans. In Visions, the consideration of femalesexual freedomin the West takes precedence over a more specific discussion of race and slavery. For Oothoon, Theotormon, and Bromion, human captivity is primarilya state of hellish abstraction, "eternalfire" (Vi sions of the Daughters ofAlbion, plate 7, line 23) and"eternal chains" (Visions, plate 7, line 23) representing the inescapable fate of the unredeemed. In "The Little Black Boy," the narrator's dream of a raciallyequitable heaven places him in a position of subservience, "shad[ing] [the English child] from the heat" (Songs of Innocence and ofExperience, plate 10, line 25) in order to win his affection. Both poems display the biases of the 1 Readings of "The Little Black Boy" will referto copy Z of Songs ofInnocence and of Experience. 2 Readings of The Visionsof the Daughters ofAlbion will referto copy J. 2 poet's culture and time period, revealing insularassum ptions about theorigins of racial sufferingand the predetermined nature of enslavement. Theauthor defines restriction andliberty for his charactersthrough Christian notions of humanfallibility and salvation, which come beforea direct indictmentof the slave trade. Each narrativeattempts to criticize literaland metaphoric forms of slavery, but these critiques place universal concepts of freedomabove specific solutions. This paper will attempt to address these inadequacies as theyexist in the very formof the poetry andin the critical response by Blakescholars, which often failsto mention these issues. Chapter Onewill brieflyoutline these limitations and describe Blake'simpression of andinvolvem ent with the abolitionist project. Chapter Two will explain the complex relationship between The Visionsof the Daughters ofAlbion and the writings of JohnGabriel Stedman, analyzingstudies by Anne Rubenstein, Camilla Townsend, Eugenie R. Freed, andDavid V. Erdman. In Chapter Three, the utopian readings of Visions offeredby Erdmanand Steven Vine will be countered using the arguments of Anne Mellor andNancy Goslee. Finally, Chapter Four will attemptto explain Blake'sspecific stance with regardto racialdifference andintegration, primarily citing David Bindman,Ngugi Wa Thiong'o, andthe text of"The Little Black Boy." This poem precedes Visions chronologically but also offers the clearestinsights into theissues raised by Mellor andGoslee, describing racial conflictin a more concise, lyric form. In these ways, the paper will present the views and artistry of a giftedindividual and the politicalforces that inspired and shapedhis work. WilliamBlake's personal concern with the British slave trade can be traced back to his involvement in the New JerusalemChurch, a Swedenborgiansect of heretical 3 Protestants. In 1789, he and his wife officiallyembraced the teachings ofthis sect, which advocated establishing coloniesin Africafor the conversion of newly freedslaves (Rubenstein andTownsend 279-280). ThoughBlake's affiliation with thissect soon dissolved aftera more conservative leader came into power (Rubensteinand Townsend 279-280), the abolitionist ideas ofthe New Church would continue to inform his thinking. In 1791, free-thinkingbook publisher Joseph Johnson presented Blake with John