Seniors Advisory Council's Comparison
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Seniors Advisory Council's Comparison Study = Sheltered Bus Stops Pinellas Suncoast Transit Comparison Items Sarasota County Area Transit Collier Area Transit Lee County - LeeTran Manatee County Area Transit Volusia County - Votran Info Only Authority What percentage of your riders are older adults (65 and 1. 11% ---- 3.5% 10% 5% 22% over, showing the demographics of ridership)? Federal Transit Administration (FTA), How do you fund your bus local infrastructure surtax 2 funding, and FTA or Box Funds Local, state, and FTA . FTA Grants FTA and Partnership Program FTA shelters? FL Dept. of Transportation Discretionary Service Development 4' x 8', 3' x 12', 4' x 12' and 8' x 12' (aluminum with display schedule boards, some having trash cans, bike racks, or 5’6” x 12’6” or both, and some have nothing 4’6” x 12’6” 2' x 9' (roof is 4' x 10') 5' x 11' 6' (aluminum frame, Plexiglas 4' x 12' and 3' x 9' if right of except the shelter. 85% of What is the definition (style, (aluminum with 3' x 9' (aluminum and (aluminum with bench and walls, 3 walls, interior bench seating, wheel way is constrained. Most include a stops only have a sign. As of 3 size, material, etc.) of your perforated panels plexi-glass; includes trash can with two 22” x 22” chair space end of bench, translucent roof trash can, a map case and bike 5/4/2016 shelters will go to with u shape bike solar powered lighting) map cases. Bike racks to let light in. If Votran places shelter, only typical sheltered bus stop? racks. "real time applications" (allows a rack, trash can and installed in-house). provide shelter). person to be on a mobile device map display) or a desktop computer and locate the departure stop and provides future bus arrivals at stop). How long does it take to 12 months (design, 2 to 3 days (only construct with 12 to 18 months (design, 4 construct/install one of your 18 months permitting, and 6- 12 months 6 - 12 months cooperation of municipalities; not including permitting and construction) shelters? constructions) permitting time). How many total bus stops are 5 2042 557 1710 962 5000 2500 in your system? Do you have shelters at every No - 80 shelters by Votran (Shelters provided by municipalities/developments 6 bus stop location? If not, how No - 232 shelters No - 72 shelters No - 201 shelters No - 188 shelters No - 725 shelters are not included and will not be available many are sheltered? until October 2016) What is the percentage of bus 3% (Votran) 1% (municipalities and 7 11% 13% 11.75% 20% 15% stops that are sheltered? developers) What is the average current 8 cost of constructing/installing $32,000 $15,000 $27,000 $15,000 - 20,000 $14,732.50 $6,000 (Votran Only) a shelter? Updated 06/01/2016 Seniors Advisory Council's Comparison Study = Sheltered Bus Stops Pinellas Suncoast Transit Comparison Items Sarasota County Area Transit Collier Area Transit Lee County - LeeTran Manatee County Area Transit Volusia County - Votran Info Only Authority What is the cost to maintain a County In-house staff or $1,500 (per 9 Maintained in-house Maintained in-house $2,000 (contracted) Maintained by municipality or developer shelter? LAMAR Advertising shelter to repaint) SCAT: Gradually 16 years (through a dedicated capital Over the course of years, what Current shelter contract states program; have installed bus stop is the duration of time it has Gradually over 5 to 6 years approx. 1 year to purchase, shelters since the 1980's. See Gradually over 12 Gradually over last 7 10 taken to construct/install all of (goal to install 50 shelters a receive, construct, and install 34 Gradually over 40 years. graph at bottom of document on years years year in the future) shelters; no information on past your shelters (gradual, phased history of shelters.* shelters. or all at one time)? LAMAR: Gradually 19 years (shelter advertising contract)** Small ads inside the fixed Buses and specific contracted Do you allow advertisement Ad panels (marketable Bus wraps only (none at Votran placed route buses(contracted; advertising shelters on your buses, sheltered or shelters) and ad shelters). Some municipalities have LAMAR Advertising (approx. most ads go on Trolleys; (guaranteed $300 per month/ad 11 transit stops? If so, explain. No backings (certain minimal contract advertising shelters $20,000 annually). receive approx. 10%. from shelter = approx. $216,000 benches); receive (receive approx. $350,000 per year plus a bus ads-$5,000 annually). annually; received approx. approx. ____ annually. 60/40 split with the adverising firm). None at bus stops. $433,291.82 in FY 2015). Newer shelters manufactured by different fabricators (Daytech, Brasco, Tolar); similar styles include the LAMAR advertising shelters, City of Sarasota and 4 sizes: 4' x 8', 3' x 12', 4' x 12' Same with aluminum frame, dark brown Are all shelters constructed North Port. (forest green with a and 8' x 12' aluminum with a 2' x 9' (roof is 4' x 10'), finish with clear Plexiglas panels and the the same? If not, what are the dome roof and bench). Some 3' x 9' (aluminum and minimum bus shelter pad -10' x 5’6” x 12’6” or 4’6” x aluminum with a color roof is a translucent beige Plexiglas to allow 12 different sizes/types of older models are a different being plexi-glass; includes 15' and maximum 10' x 30' 12’6” scheme andh mesh sides and light in.; 3-wall construction (variations replaced. Venice shelters are solar powered lighting). (depending on site location, shelters that are installed at back. depending if the cities or a developer gets black. Some shelters ROW, etc.). 4 older styles as your bus stops? involved). constructed/installed by well. public/private entities (ex. Sarasota Memorial Hospital-match the architectural style of their building). What is the area covered in miles of your bus routes 13 measured in directional miles 152 327 538 743 (square miles) 893 599 reported to National Transit Database? Updated 06/01/2016 Seniors Advisory Council's Comparison Study = Sheltered Bus Stops Pinellas Suncoast Transit Comparison Items Sarasota County Area Transit Collier Area Transit Lee County - LeeTran Manatee County Area Transit Volusia County - Votran Info Only Authority 800 ft. to 1200 ft. (currently reviewing spacing in the Comprehensive Operations Analysis (COA) to be completed What is the average distance Summer 2016 and anticipate 1320ft. (longer routes ); 2640 ft. (less urban areas); 14 800 ft. 250 ft. 500 to 1,000 ft. between bus stops? recommending increase in the 700 ft. (urban settings) 700 ft. (downtown) spacing between stops to every quarter mile or more, based on the density of adjacent land uses). Developers, the municipalities, Shelter Match Program for Have you partnered with any neighborhoods, non-profits custom shelters (PSTA pays community organizations to (Senior Friendship Centers) for site development up to Municipalities - Orange City, DeBary, 15 Developers Developers None construct/install sheltered and scouts. (ex. Pinecraft $7,300 and split cost of current DeLand, Ormond Beach, and Volusia County stops and if so, who and how? neighborhood and Englewood standard shelters; simple Adventure Scout Troop). 50%/50% split of total cost). Public Transit and Who is the decision-maker on Neighborhood SCAT Transit Planning staff Votran management and municipalities placement of shelters within Enhancement 16 collaborate with municipalities Planning Department MCAT Logistics Manager PSTA (Chris Cochran) (drien by request for need not social or Division (construct low-income or expensive staff economic factors of a neighborhood. neighborhoods? on ridership not neighborhoods) What is your estimated FY 2016: installed 30; Averaging 30 - 35 sites 65 over the next two years; The per year placement would be fractional; 17 number of new shelters per FY 2017: estimate a minimum 10 50 per year thereafter approx. 20 per year. only place as requested. year? of 12. * SCAT History of Sheltered Benches ** LAMAR advertising shelters update and status – SCAT is currently working with Sarasota County Real Estate staff on the potential purchase of shelters from LAMAR advertising. LAMAR’s contract expires in May 2017. Concurrently, SCAT is preparing an advertising content policy, which will be presented to the Board in the near future. Updated 06/01/2016.