Report on the State of the Art of the Iraqi Higher Education System And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
D1.4 Update needs analysis report State of the Art of the Higher Education system and its governance in Iraq Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq Authors Martina Zipoli, Silvia Marchionne, Marco Di Donato, Federica De Giorgi UNIMED, Mediterranean Universities Union Contributors Sudad Ahmed, Osamah Abdullatif, Sudad Amer Dayl (University of Baghdad) About INsPIRE The overarching goal of INsPIRE is to support, through the cooperation of European institutions, the rebuilding, modernization, and internationalization of the governance system of higher education institutions (HEIs) in Iraq with a specific focus on planning and programming systems. Due to the recent crisis and political economic situation, the current higher education system requires a strong intervention to face the weakness of the existing governance system. To institutionalize good governance practices in Iraqi HEIs, which also means enforcing institutional values such as autonomy, accountability, participation, and internationalization, as well as implementing well-structured management systems, will contribute to the development of Iraqi HIEs helping them to meet the international standards. The aim of the project is to support HEIs in Iraq in order to make them capable of establishing a modern governance framework through the adoption of innovative practices. The specific objectives of INsPIRE are the following: . Enhancing good governance, management and accountability practices in the HEIs . Establishing a clear governance framework, including well-defined and clear mission and goals through the definition and implementation of action plans . Strengthening the international relations management within the HEIs . Improving participation in strategic planning and development activities for non-university actors and non-state actors More at www.projectinspire.eu Project Partners . University of Siena, Italy (coordinator) . Bologna University, Italy . Evora University, Portugal . Aydin Istanbul University, Turkey . UNIMED- Mediterranean Universities Union, Italy . University of Mosul . University of Baghdad . University of Basrah . Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University . University of Sumer . Al-Qasim Green University . University of Basrah Oil and Gas 2 Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq . Al Karkh University for Science . Southern Technical University . Wasit University . Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research in Iraq Document Information Project Title Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq Project n. 598790-EPP-1-2018-1-IT-EPPKA2-CBHE-SP Deliverable D1.4 Update needs analysis report “State of the Art of the Higher education system and its governance in Iraq” Work package WP1 Update of needs analysis Date of Delivery 30/04/2021 Confidentiality Status Not public Author (Partner Institution) UNIMED, Mediterranean Universities Responsible Author(s) Martina Zipoli Silvia Marchionne Marco Di Donato Federica De Giorgi Contributor(s) Sudad Ahmed, Osamah Abdullatif. Sudad Amer Dayl (University of Baghdad) Abstract (for dissemination) The D1.4 Update needs analysis Report aims to provide an up-to-date state of the art of the Higher Education System in Iraq in relation to the governance of HEIs, and identifies gaps and priorities in governance practices that have to be addressed. The INsPIRE project has been funded with support from the European Union. This document reflects the view only of the author, and the Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License 3 Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq Table of Contents Acknowledgments Introduction 1.Methodological Note . Focus groups at the KOM in Siena . Online Survey . Desk research . Virtual Focus Groups . Diagnostic Tool . Structure of the Report 2.Governance Terminology and Models . University Governance key concepts . Higher Education systems governance models . Conclusions on the literature review 3.The Iraqi Higher Education System . Historical Background . Key information on the Higher Education sector in Iraq . National legal framework Key findings of the research process . Results of the Focus Groups held at the KOM . Survey responses . Virtual Focus Groups main outcomes Self-evaluation results Stakeholders Mapping Needs of the Iraqi Higher Education System Bibliography Annex I – Topics and questions Focus Groups KOM Annex II - Survey Annex III - Self-evaluation questionnaire 4 Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq Acknowledgements This research has been conducted by UNIMED, Mediterranean Universities Union, as part of the work under the Work Package 1 of the INsPIRE project, to perform an updated needs analysis of the Iraqi Higher Education System, with the collaboration of the University of Baghdad. A special thank goes to all the colleagues directly and indirectly involved that greatly assisted the research. We thank all the Iraqi Universities partners of the project and the Iraqi Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research for having provided us with sources, assistance and contributions, and for the comments and inputs that greatly improved the research process and the research outcomes. Any error in data and statistics reported in this Report is the sole responsibility of the UNIMED research team and represent only UNIMED views. 5 Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq Introduction The first step of the project is to conduct an up-to-date needs analysis of the Iraqi Higher Education governace system, which requires, besides the realisation of a comprehensive literature review aimed at identifying the existing governance frameworks, the development of a tailored analysis of key dimensions with the support and collaboration of one Iraqi university. The study aims at identifying the current situation of the universities involved in the project and enables the identification of specific needs to address. Covering a number of dimensions related to the improvement of a governance framework, the study aims also to delineate both gaps and priorities in governance practices to address, setting a number of objectives for Universities to achieve. The analysis is based on a combination of a desk research, a self-evaluation and a diagnostic tool elaborated by European experts. The study has been carried out starting from a desk research, consisting in reviewing relevant literature and collecting previous expertise in order to develop a baseline knowledge, and standardize the understanding of concepts and terminologies related to HE governance among the consortium institutions. Upon the desk research findings, the report has been informed by the data from a survey and the results of a self-assessment conducted through a governance diagnostic tool. Results have been elaborated through a close collaboration between the WP1 Leader, UNIMED, and the WP1 co-leader, the University of Baghdad. All the other partners have contributed to the analysis providing key information to the researchers, and supporting UNIMED in fully understanding the key features of the Iraqi HE governance system. The current Report sums up all the activities performed, representing on the one side the first achievement of the project, on the other side the knowledge base upon which the subsequent activities are designed (from the capacity building action, to the outlining of the actions plans and the governance reform process itself). 1. Methodological Note The overall objective of the study is to provide Partners with a picture of Higher Education governance in Iraq, which serves as a reference for the future developments of Higher Education Institutions in the country with the aim of meeting international quality standards. Researchers relied on a qualitative methodology to conduct data collection and the Report has been written by directly involving Iraqi partners, both the Universities of the Consortium and the Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research. This study, as part of the work under the Work Package 1 of the INsPIRE project, is the result of more than 6 months of research, reflections, conversations, exchanges and writing conducted by the UNIMED team (in alphabetical order: Federica De Giorgi, Marco Di Donato, Silvia Marchionne, Martina Zipoli) in strong collaboration with the WP co-leader the University of Baghdad, in the person of Sudad Amer Dayl, the Iraqi Minister of Higher Education and Scientific Research represented by Hussain Al-Rubaiey and Huda Abdullah, and the contribution by all the Iraqi Universities of the Consortium: Wasit University, Southern Technical 6 Innovative Governance Practices in the Higher Education Institutions in Iraq University, Al Karkh University for Science, University of Basrah Oil and Gas, Al-Qasim Green University, University of Sumer, Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University, University of Basrah, University of Baghdad, University of Mosul. The research has been structured in several steps, conducted contemporary and subsequently, all framed into a comprehensive methodology. As a preliminary activity, Focus Groups during the kick-off meeting were held in Siena, in February 2019, to collect expectations, experiences and perceptions by the participants and to discuss inputs related to “Improving