Early Australian Optical and Radio Observations of A

Peter Robertson A Bruce Slee A, B and Wayne Orchiston A

A Centre for , James Cook University, Townsville, Qld 4811,

B Australia Telescope National Facility, CSIRO, Epping, NSW 2121, Australia

The Many Faces of , Sydney, 28 June – 3 July 2009 Early Australian observations of Cen A

Contents

Paramatta Observatory and the discovery of NGC 5128

Dover Heights and the discovery of Cen A

New Zealand expedition and the first optical identification

Further observations of Cen A in the 1950s

Back to the future

Acknowledgments

Marie­Louise Ayres (National Library of Australia) Rob Birtles (CSIRO ) Margy Burn (National Library of Australia) Glen Cozens (James Cook University) Ron Ekers (Australia Telescope National Facility) Rod Home (University of Melbourne) Barnaby Norris (Australia Telescope National Facility) Harry Wendt (James Cook University)

Early Australian observations of Cen A

Paramatta Observatory and the discovery of NGC 5128

Thomas Makdougall (1773 – 1860) Governor of

[courtesy State Library of NSW] Paramatta Observatory constructed in 1820­21

Recovery of Encke’s comet in June 182

Transit telescope used for Catalogue of 7385 stars

Dunlop’s cottage at Paramatta

9 inch reflecting telescope erected in backyard

James Dunlop (1793 – 1848) [courtesy State Library of NSW] Dunlop’s solo work on the catalogue of 621 nebulae and star clusters completed in 1826

Published in the Royal Society’s Philosophical Transactions in 1828

Thomas Brisbane and awarded Gold Medal of the Royal Astronomical Society in the same year 1828

First observed on 4 August 1826. His description of ‘Dunlop 482’ (NGC 5128): ‘A very singular double … a little unequal. … These two nebula are completely distinct from each other, and no connection of the nebulous matters between them … Fig. 20 is a good representation.’

Dover Heights and the Discovery of Centaurus A

Early Australian observations of Cen A Dover Heights Site in 1943

Shore defense radar antenna on the blockhouse

Antenna removed in 1946 and the blockhouse used for discrete radio source observations from 1947 to 1953

Pioneers of radio astronomy

Karl Jansky Grote Reber James S. Hey (Bell Labs, New Jersey) (Wheaton, Illinois) (TRE, Malvern, UK) 1932­33 1940­42 1946

John Bolton, Gordon Stanley and Joe Pawsey

The sea interferometer and signals from the Cygnus A source

The first three papers

Nature Australian Journal of Nature Scientific ResearchH February 1948 July 1948 March 1948i ,

S e e

t h e

a t t a c h e d .

I

w a s

g o i n g

t o

i n c l u d e

t h i s

p h o t o ,

b u t

n o w

I ' m

h a v i n g

s e c o n d

t h o u g h t s .

C o u l d

y o u

a s k

H u g h

h o w

h e

k n o w s

i t s

W o o m e r a ?

2 p m

F r i d a y

i s

f i n e .

P e t e r Probably Cygnus­type variable

‘… overlapping of the Centaurus and 5.47 sources has so far prevented their accurate location’

New Zealand Expedition and the First Optical Identifications

Early Australian Observations of Cen A Further cliff­top observations near Auckland in 1948

Identification of Source

‘The limits in the position of the source … enclose NGC 5128. This object is classed as an extragalactic nebula. It is a seventh magnitude object with a peculiar spectrum. Baade calls it a freak and it is referred to by Shapley as a ‘pathological specimen’ though no details are known at present as to the exact nature of its peculiarity.’

Three­page report December 1948

John Bolton, Gordon Stanley and Bruce Slee. Nature paper in July 1949:

‘It is found that all three sources correspond within limits of experimental error to positions of certain nebulous objects.’

Centaurus A (NGC 5128)

Taurus A (the Crab Nebula) Virgo A (M87) First Radio Spectrum of Cen A

• Flux densities from three Yagi­ pairs operating at three frequencies, circa 1949

• Typical non­thermal spectrum of the unresolved central components

• The flux density at 100 MHz is about 2000 Jy

First Measurement of Angular Size

• Phase switched 100 MHz compound interferometer in early 1952

• Two 4­Yagi antennas with variable spacing up to 21 wavelengths along the cliff top

• Slow fringes in top row are mainly due to the extended Cen A source. Total flux density about five times that in the central sources

• Fast fringes at the end of second row are due to the compact inner Cen A components

Hole­in­the­ground telescope at Dover Heights 1952­54

Cen A contours at 400 MHz with the 80 ft dish

• Cen A is clearly resolved 400 MHz with extensions out to 6 deg

• Central sources are not completely resolved, but their orientation is correct

• Flux density of the central sources is about 600 Jy

Further Observations of Cen A in the 1950s

Early Australian observations of Cen A Bernie Mills’ Interferometer at Badgery’s Creek 1952

• One of three 101 MHz broadside arrays

• Base lines to 300 metres

• Confirmed the intensity and position of Cen A

• Confirmed the optical identification of Cen A

The 18.3 MHz Array at Hornsby Valley 1952

• Array consisted of six rows of dipoles arranged in a North­South direction with a beamwidth of 17 deg

• Used as a transit telescope with declination shifted by varying the phasing along the array

• Operation was only possible at night when interference dropped to a low level

18.3 MHz Scans in RA at Five Declinations

• Excess emission between declinations ­42 and ­52 deg at RA of 13­14 h is mostly due to Cen A

• Peaks at the 22/32 deg scans are from Sgr A at the Galactic centre

• 18.3 MHz flux density of CenA was measured by interpolating a feasible baseline; its value of 5300 Jy includes the extended component

The 85.5 MHz Mills Cross at Fleurs 1955

• The North­South arm with the receiver hut on the left

• Each arm was 1500 ft long and beamwidth was 49 arcmin

• Weakest detectable source had a flux density of ~5 Jy

• Beamwidth was 49 arcmin

Mills Cross Map of Cen A

• Kevin Sheridan’s 85.5 MHz map from 1956

• Extended source is 6 deg in the North­South orientation, but the central components are barely resolved by the 49 arcmin beam

• Total 85.5 MHz flux density is 8700 Jy

The 36 ft transit dish at Potts Hill

• The dish was primarily used for HI surveys

• In 1955 Piddington and Trent made a 600 MHz all­sky continuum survey (beamwidth 3.3 deg)

• In 1958 Hindman and Wade made a 1400 MHz continuum survey of several strong sources (beamwidth 1.4 deg)

600 MHz contours from the 36 ft dish (1955)

• Map is constructed from transit scans taken at many elevations

• Extended contours are clearly larger than the beam (inset), but the inner two lobes are unresolved

• Strong sources Taurus A (inset), Sgr A and Cygnus A are clearly visible

1400 MHz contours from the 36 ft dish (1958)

• Hindman & Wade’s map of Cen A (beamwidth 1.4 deg)

• Source extends over 6 deg. in Declination

• The two central lobes are being resolved

Back to the Future

[courtesy ‘Life’ magazine 1951]

Early Australian observations of Cen A Paramatta Observatory

‘The Greenwich of the Southern Hemisphere’

Stone pier for transit telescope

Government House at

[courtesy Glen Cozens]

back to Dover Heights 1989

Bruce Slee and John Bolton

Bruce Slee Sixty years of radio astronomy 1949 ­ 2009